This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
lg
(puvxaala XQlvtxai naxa xovg rj naxaXrptxtnr) Zxcaixovg, oxi KaxaXrjnxix^q iaxt x& 0^6 {mocQxovxog ytvia&at luil xar' aixb x6 'hnaqxov ivanoiitfiay^ivoag tial ivansaq>Qaytafiiv(og' x6 &^ vnocQxov 8oiuxov nuxuXrinxfKriv xivtiv (puvxaaCav. cf. Pyrrh. fuc^txat^ oxt vnuQxov iaxlv, i%
183.
ibid.
Hypot.
m
71^65 xovxoig
242.
10
ex mathem. scientia 1 Vol. XIX p. 529 K. vnuQXxrjv tlvat xrjv (ia&rjfiuxtKr}v intaxrifitr\v riQ%tt xai xCbv ZxaiivcSiv (ptXoaocpcov , uvSq&v xai Xoyovg Sttnntnovrjfiivav nal xbv
98
Ps. Galeni Prognostica
IltQl ftiv xov ij
§lov bnoiog iaxt naQuaxrjadvxoiv So^a. 99 Philo de congressu erud. gratia § 146 Vol. III p. 102, 15 Wendl. Kalxoty ovSt tovto xtg ayvoti, oxi niiaatg xatg xaxct fiiQog (scil. intaxi^fiatg) nai xa aniQfiuxu, i^ «v ccvu^Xuaxtiv ^So^t xu &toiQ'qfiuxu , (ptXoxug
15
ccQxag
^laonXtvQu yuQ kuI oxaAijva, xvxXovg xt »ut noXvy(6via St x«t yQUfififig nai ay^iqfiuxu ytoifitxQlu nQOGt^tVQf arjfitlov
ao(plu StScoQrjxut.
xa uXXu
xal
»0 inttpavtlag xat CxtQtov (pvatv^ a Sr\ Ql^ut tucI &tfiiXtot x&v Xtx&ivxcov tiaiv, ovxiTt ytoifjLtXQiu. n6^tv yuQ avx^ Xiytiv 6(nfoj«iv?j, oTt arjfittov fUv iaxtv^ ov fiiQog ovSiv, yQUfifir} St fiijxog unXuxig, inttpuvttu St fi^xog kuI nXd-
T05 fi6vov
Tuvxu
i'xtt^
Xoaocp^p.
axtQtbv St
avuycttxai
—
yccQ
T6 ys
xug xQtig txtt StuGxuattg, ft-^xo?, ;tA.aT05, pdd^og; nai rj ntQi OQOiv nQuyfiaxtiu nuGa xSt (pixal ttvuytyv(oG%tiv yQUfifiaxtK^g xfjg ocxtyQU(pttv
(piXoGotpia^
firiv
25
^v nuQuxQinovxsg xivtg yQUfifiuxtaxixr}v xuXovGtv' x^g EnttSuv St xtXttoxiQug avunxv^tg x&v nuQu notrjxuig xt Kui avyyQucptvatv. ovv ntQi x&v xov Xoyov Stt^tQxcovxat fitQ&v, xoxt ov xu cptXoGocpiag tvQr]-
XtaxiQug
inuyytXfiu,
xi fiaxu nuQuGn&vxui xt wxi nuQtQyoXuPovGt; xuvxrjg yuQ tStov i^txd^ttv., GvvStafiog, xi ovofia, xi Qrjfuc, xi Kotvbv ovofia., xi iStov, xi iXXtntg iv XSyto, ao xi xi uno(pavx6v, xi iQcoxrjfiu, xi nvafuc, xi TCtQiSKxtxov, xi fuxTtxov, nXilQtg,
xi
o^oTtxov.
nQuyficcTtiug
xug yuQ rjS^
iaxiv
TitQi "j^
uvxoxtX&v Cvv&ttau'
xui
d^toficcxoiv
rjfiicpoivov
St
rj
Kui
»axrjyoQr}fidxoiv
g?(ov^ev
^ nuvxtXa>g
ucpavov axotxttov iSsiv Kai n&g sKuaxov xovxov ttui&t Xiyta&ut^ wxi n&aa xoct Gxotxtioiv xui x&v xov Xoyov fUQWv iSiu^ o^ (ptXoao(pia 7} ntQi (poivfjg ntnovrixai xai iiaxi^vvaxat; (1. 31 expecto: nQoaxuKxt%6v pro iro^tfXTtxov)
100 Plutarchus quomodo
adol. poet. aud. debeat p.
34 b.
Ti^v d'
nkiov t&v Isyo^ivaiv
^up^tftv vniSei^sv dQd^&g 6 XQv^innog, o ts det xui dLa^L^d^SLV ini xd d^iosLSrj to xQ^^i^C^ov. fisrdysLV otl] D. et sinav 348) yocQ 'H(fL6dog (Op.
inl
'ovd'
av ^ovg dn6koLT\
sl
firj
ysLTcav xocxbg
xal nsQl xvvbg ravro xal nsgl '6vov XiysL xal nsgl xStv
36
dnoXie^uL davafiivoiv.
Kal ndXLv
Toi5
sCr}*
ndvrav
bfioLag
EifQLnCSov XiyovTog
21 aiytr] Xiyti dQi^Oftivri Tum. 18 noXvyava H'GF. &Qaxix6v Wendl., sixxix6v M, dQaxix6v A, ti ti xax(iv 5pa GF.
(inc.
32 tixxixdv, xl
40
DE COGNITIONE DOCTRINA.
82 fab.
fr.
950 N) *T4S d'
ietl dovXog tov d-avetv atpQovtis «v'; tcsqI jc6vov xal v6(Sov tavtbv sIqyjxsv.
v7taxov6teov ort xal
5
101 Plutarchus quomodo adol. poet. aud. debeat p. 31 E. dst dh t&v 6vo(idtG)v a^eXag dxovsiv^ dXXd ffjv fiiv KXsdvd^ovg iiTjdh naididv naQaitsteQ^aL' xatSLQavsvstai ydq idttv (its TtQoGnoiovfisvog i^tjyste&at tb
'Zsv 7cdtSQ"Idri&sv ^sdioiv' (F 320) xal t6 '
10
Zsv dva /JaSoavats
'
{TI 233)
xsksxxov dvaytyvco^xsLV vcp' sv, wg tbv ix ffjg y^g dvad^(iLd)(isvov xal XQv6Ljt7tog dh dsQa dtd trjv dvd8o6Lv dvadadcovatov ovta. TtokXaxov yXL^XQog i^tCv^ ov jtaC^av dlX' svQr]6LXoy&v djtLd^dvcjg, xal '
'
svQv6na KQovtdrjv slvat tbv dstvbv iv xal Sta^s^rjx6ta t^ dvvd^st tov X6yov. 7caQa^tai,6(LSvog
16
5.
§
tc5
dtaXiyso&at
IIeqI gijTijJfcos.
Scripsit Chrysippus jceQi ^rjxrjaecag
duo volumina
cf.
n.
13
v.
102 Clemens
Al. Strom. VI 14 p. 801 Pott. eaxiv de ri (lev tn^^ridig xb KaxaXa^etv Sid xivav Crjfieicov dvevQisxovGa x6 vnoKelfievov' ri 20 e^Qeaig de neQag Kal dvdnavaig ^rix^qGemg iv Kaxaliqtpei yevofievrig. 103 Cicero Acad. Pr. 11 26. (i. e. Antiochus contra dKaxakriil^lav disiTcl
^Qliri
Quid quod, si ista vera simt, ratio omnis tollitur, quasi quaeputans). dam lux lumenque vitae! nam quaerendi initium ratio attulit, quae quaestio perfecit virtutem, cum esset ipsa ratio confirmata quaerendo.
—
25
autem est adpetitio cognitionis, quaestionisque finis inventio. at nemo invenit falsa, nec ea quae incerta permanent, inventa esse possimt, sed cum ea, quae quasi involuta fuerunt, aperta sunt, tum inventa dicuntur. sic et initium quaerendi et exitus percipiendi et comprendendi tenetur.
30
104
Plutarchus apud Olympiodorum in Plat. Phaedon.
p. 125, 7 ed. olovxe ^r^xeiv kuI evQtaKeiv, ojg iv Mevavi (p. 80 E) nQO^e^Xrixai' o^e yuQ a lafiev' (idxaiov yaQ' ovxe a (v^f ia(iev' Kuv yaQ neQtniaco^iev avxotg, dyvoov(iev, ag xotg xv/pvaiv. 01 Se dnb xrjg Sxoag xdg (pvaiKag ivvotag atxicavxai' et (lev S^q Svvd(iei, x6 avTo iQov(iev' el Se iveQyeia, Sid xi ^rjxov^iev d ta(iev; el Se ttn6 xovxoov dkXa dyvoov(ieva. n&g aneQ ovk ia(iev.
Finckh.
"Oxi dnoQov ovxcag el
——
S5
3 TavTcc libri, corr. Herch. Hoc et quod sequitur fragmentum Chrysippi hic coUocavi, quia ad artem poStas explicandi i. e. grammaticam pertinent, eiusque artis cum philosophia necessitudinem. Referenda sunt ad libros: ns^l tov Jt&g 23 dux 5 Cf. I n. 535 (Cleanthes) H n. 1062. &ei x&v Tcoiriiidrav cckovsiv §' 31 &itoQOv 29 facultate addidi. tenetur Bentley, tenet lihri. Bentley. .
||
Wyttenbachius, &7t6Qov bvrog eadem sunt quae nQoXi^ipsts.
Svrcos
pum
libri.
34 q^vaixal ^vvoiai apud Chrysip-
DE COQNITIONE DOCTRINA.
§ Qualis
Esse
norraa iudicii.
sit
106 Diogenes
G.
Laert.
88
IlBQi XQirriQCov,
normam
VII 54.
iudicii contra Scepticos defenditur.
di
xQirrJQiov
XQv6ticnog
xad^aq^rjOt
iv
r&v Ov6tXG>v
rfj /3'
aXrjd-eiag
tfig
xvy%(xvtLV Ti^v xarakrjicrixiiv tpavraaiav, rovri6ri ri^v
xal 'AvrinarQog xal
6 ^ilv yccQ Borjd^og xQir^Qia nXsiova anoXsinei,
^AnoXX68o3Qog. xal at6&rj6LV xal ^qe^lv xal inL^rrjfit^v fisvog nQbg avrbv iv
tc5 nQcbra)
6 8}
q>tto\
anb vnaQxovrog^
XQv6Lnnog
s
vovv
dLatpSQd-
XQLrrjQtd (pr)6LV elvat
nsQl kdyov
tt[69r}6LV xttl nQ6Xi^xl>LV.
106 Augustinus in
sensibus
corporis
de
civ. dei
eorumque
VIII
—
7.
regulis
qui posuerunt iudicium veritatis omnia quae discimtur me-
—
tienda esse censuerimt, ut Epicurei et quicumque
alii
tales,
lo
ut etiam ipsi
qui cum vehementer amaverint sollertiam disputandi, quam dialecticam nominant, a corporis sensibus eam ducendam putarunt, hinc asseverantes animum concipere notiones, quas appellant ivvolag, earum rerum scilicet quas definiendo explicant; hinc propagari atque conecti totam discendi docendique rationem. 107 Sextus adv. math. VII 35. ndQEGti (livxoi nai t6 koyiKov rovxo Stoici,
(scil. KQixriQiov) VTtoSiaiQSiad^ai, Xiyovxccg 01;,
xb Sh
^Qcanog,
wg
ov
Si'
ov, xb Ss
Si
Ss
37. %ai
xuolag.
a>g
x6 fiiv xt elvai KQixiqQiov
nQOO^okr) nai
G-jiiGig.
ag v navxl XQova yiyovev dnaQaXXaKxov. 113 Cicero Acad. Pr. II 85. Stoicum est quidem nec admodum cre3 eixi dvevges Turnebus, xi dvsvqes vel xivd vevqa libri. Lambin. 19 addissolvit lihri, corr. Davisius.
lihri, corr.
in
conclusione
est libri.
Arcesilai.
31
dicemus
lihri
optitni.
15 Silibonem 22 primum: scil. 40 Stoicum sed
DE OOQNITIONE DOCTRINA.
35
„nullum esse pilum omnibus rebus talem, qualis sit pilus nullum granum'^ 114 Cicero Acad. Pr. II 54. cur id potius contenditis, quod renmi na-
dibile
alius,
tura non patitur, ut non g 6 XQvainn6e qpTjffi om. F. fittivovxa). 23 oi add. Wil. 1
yfiMxa
(=
—
DIALECTICA. TOUTiu
TtapaiveT
cuvriYopiac,
fitovjci
drroxi^iv
euXaPeiac, ujcnep iv toTc
lacT'
biaXuovTac
dXXct
89
t6
auTtuv
biKacTTipioic,
7Ti6av6v
nepl TTdvToiv, dTripdXXci,
„ToTc
qptici,
)if|
^CTd •xap
)iev
toOto
TTOieTv,
Kai cuv€pt6v icTi TTp6c 5 pouXovTar toTc h' ^TTiCTrmr|v dvepTaZo^^voic, KaG' Tiv 6)ioXoTOun€vujc Piiuco^eSa, Td ^vavTia, CTOixeioOv Ko\ KaTacT0ixi2^€iv touc eicaTO|ievouc dTr' dpx»\c
s
H^XP> tAouc" icp' J)V Kaip6c ^cti iiivncGnvai Kai tujv dvavTiujv X6tujv, biaXuovTttc auTuJv t6 TTi6av6v, Ka6dTT€p Kai dv toTc biKacTTipioic." TauTi Tdp auTaTc XdEeciv eipr|Kev. 128 Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1037 b. *Ev ^ev TaTc OuciKaTc G^ceci ToOTa T^Tpatpev .."Ectoi be koi KOTaXaiipdvov-
lo
Ti, TTp6c Td ^vavTia ^TTixeipeTv, Tfjv evoOcav cuvriTopiav TTOiouji^vouc' TTOT^ b' oub^Tepov KaTaXa)i pd vovTttC eic ^KdTe-
Tdc
pov Td 6vTa XeT€iv." 129 Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1037 b. 'Ev be tuj Trepi thc toO A6tou Xpr|ceujc eiTTiuv, tbc ou beT Trj toO X6tou buvd)iei TTp6c Td
\ir\
^TTipdXXovTa xpTlc6ai, Ka6dTT€p oube ottXoic, toOt'
Tdp Tfjv tiuv dXnOuiv eupeciv beT xPTlc6ai Kai toutujv thv cuTTtveiav, eic TdvavTia b'ou, ttoXauTfj, TTp6c Xa»v TTOiouvTUJV toOto." ttoXXouc [b^] XeTujv Tcujc touc ^TrexovTac. „rrp6c
^TTeipriKe"
is
)iev
«o
130 Diogenes Laert. VII 46. avrtiv 6s xr}v diaXsxTiiir}v avayimlav elvai xal aQsrrjv iv tiSsi iteQii^ovOav ccQexdg' t^v te ajtQontcoaiav iiciatiqfiriv toH note 6ei avyxatatld^ea&ai nal fiij' tijv te aveinaiotrita laxvQOv koyov nQOg t6 slnog, &ate ^r\ ivStdovai avt&' t-qv te aveXey^iav layyv iu XoycOj &ate (ir} anayea^ai vn avxov eig to avtiKeifievov' f^v te afiataiotrjta e^iv dvatpiQOvaav tdg tpavtaaiag inl tbv oQ&bv Xoyov. avti^v te t^i/ iniati^firjv
(paaiv
xaT«A*ji/;tv
rj
da^pakii
rj
e^iv iv
cpavtaai&v nQoadi^ei
26
dfie-
tdntatov vnb Xoyov. ovk uvev de x^^^g diaXentiiifjg d-ecoQiag tbv aocpbv anTWTOv iaea&ai iv Xoyco' to te yuQ dXrj&ig nal tb t^evSog Siayivcoanea&ai vn' avtfjg xal t6 TCt^O^av^v t6 te dficpi^oXcog Xeyofievov dievKQiveia9ai' xcoQig te avtf}g ovk elvat bSm iQcotav nat dnoKQivea&at. Stateivetv Se trjv iv taig
30
dnocpuvaeai nQonetetav kui ini td ytvofuva, coate eig dnoafiiav y.ai eiKatoovx uXXcog te tQinea&ut tovg dyvfivdatovg ejipvtag tdg cpavtaaiug. 6i,vv Ktti dyxivow Kui tb oXov Seivbv iv Xoyotg cpuvi^aea&ttt tbv aocpov'
trita
tov yuQ uvrov elvut OQ^&g StuXiyea&ui Kui StaXoyi^ea9ut Kui tov uvtov nQog te ru nQOKeifUVtt StttXex^T^vui Kui n^bg t6 iQCotcofievov dnoKQivaa^ttt.,
uneQ ifineiQOV Cf. fittXtattt
6tttXeKttKfjg
Vn
83.
KQtttvvcoat
Kui
dv6Qbg
elvui.
totovtot
fuv
iv
totg
01
XoytKoig
6ittXeKtiKbv fiovov elvttt tbv aocpov.
Stco'tKoi^
tvu
ndvru yuQ
tu
—
5 ivccvtia libri, Soyftaxa Re. &vay%aia. Wy. vix necessarium. Ad libi-um 20 Ss del. Wil. 23 24 xsql Xoyov XQTiaecas videtur hoc fragmentum pcrtinere. 25 xt scripsi ter, 8s libri. 27 ^x tpavxaaicbv nQOS li^iv F. 32 dnocfdvatei Bcripsi,
36 nQoaxtifieva B Xtyontva F. Staitx^^fivai B. 37 ifintiQOv xal F. 88 ra pro iva B. 39 XQaxvvcov B. rd om. P. (tovov ante dtl suppl. B* tlvat dtl (om. fiovov) F.
dnocpdatai
libri.
||
||
dnoKQivta&at B. I'
(invov dtl
P
||
35
DIALECTICA.
40 6ia
nQayfiara
iv
T^g
yaq xo Xoyi%ov xl det
ftev
(cig
ki-
ovofidxcov dQ&oxrjxog oncag Stixa^av oi vofioi inl xotg eQyoig ovK av e'xeiv etnelv' dvoiv 8e ovGaiv Gvvrjd^eiatv xatv vnoninrovOatv xij aQexi eKa6xov eGxi x&v ovxtov Gxonet, tj Se xi xaXeixai. rrj, '^ fiev
XXV
131 Papyrus 1020 (Hercul. Vol. Coll. alt. X 112—177. Hermes OxNd] o(T)t t^v (&)7tQontG)6L{av) [Col. IVn p. 473 sq.).
=
\
rifiafi{s)v xal tijv
rdd-stog
taGia
nQO
XQog ds
(avsi.) xaL6t(rj)ta, \
i(5
6Q&&{g).
^Xrjfisd^a 10
ri%iy,ov
xe
neQi
y£tv;)
5
bqa6%ai, oGa xe xov ^vtftxov xonov
koyoig d^ecoQiag
xvy^avH na\ av naXiv oQa xov
S^
\tl
tag ivaytiag dt(a)/3£
\
fi(s)v a7tQ07Ctc3 6ia
ri
6vvxatad'Sti\xr}v xata vsq lCivovGa t iv (pavtaaiatg
xata(X)ri\ntGii,
7CaQSXo(fi)sv(r})
\
Zlsl
xatalr}\ntixalg.
fiij
yccQ
tpav-
\
xal
avBi\xtov tbv dxQOXte).
\
talg
\
at
xataXij^tl^scog,
|
a6vvxa
8ia%s(evdfi
I
raikrjv
,
7ia{Qa) d{ix)B6{^tti) \
=
I
yccQ
xsxvSty ovx s^ov6lv
.
.
o
.
.
.
.
ovg
. I
i6)\xiv d{6)^a
Tfcxat
{xal
at
.
.
i^) .
.
8id xb
\
\
iXei
xavxag'
|
txa
\
«okkag (x&v)
naqoQav
6
d{l)
.
.
.
.
.
6
.
.
.
vt
.
.
|
|
yaQ
^{etajtxcoxixij
adv{vatov) ovdi
|
.
.
.
\
lo
'
.
.
.
.
V'
3caQanX{rj6)ia
ayvqelv tbv
ii.ri\8\v
e6taf
fie\xd 8h
x{av xbv (pQ{6)-
JteQi
i6
fiij
\
xd naQa{nX^6)ta (pav {X)d i6xt{v,
xal
d' {dxex)vta if) 7iaQ6{Qa)6ig xal 7ta\QaQt&{}irj)6L{g xg>v) dva\(ii6ov ... a .... t e t £ta 7caQaQetd-fi{r})6at Tcat ... at x ex \
\
.
.
•
.
.
•
Ta
.
.
.
.
. I
a
I
In
.
0)69^
.
.
at
.
xov ^ev {8ovg)
.
.
.
.
a
.
8td (toi»)|to xal Xe ov otg ...
= Ox Ma] va'
.
.
7ia
.
.
.
6t
xotg
.
av
|
.
.
.
jo
xa{l
|
\
«av^TOg q){av)Xov TaTotg
.
.
|
\
I
d..
.
.
yCve{6)^at Tai>|Ta iv xolg Xoyi^ev ydQ vn6v{o)tcc xal ij ay{v)qt{a) xa(l)
i^
\
.
xa(l)
a)xokq{v^e)l \
o
.
ovra q)av\Xa ovx e{6t)a{t)
(jtt^v)
dfiaQrrjfjtcctav.
I
.
|
T(a) 8h dvaui6ov.f
d{nt6)xta
rj
.
.
xug el\Q{rjiii)vag, ot tas x va o a)kXa
totus versus deest
I
.
(^)|,uii/
deest in nj 8e
XQo{etQ)r]fi{e)\v(ov xd
xotg a vev
sig
elg
.
.
x
slciv
.
.\.
.
av
.
6o\q>bv' d{(p' a))v xal {totav)ta
vtjLiov,
ovx
.
iv
.
.
I
og .....
[Ox Ld,
.
I
V
I
.V
.
ov{8b)v desunt duo versus
I
XQ00v6t
.
.
ov {^)r)xiov X
\
exei ....
X
. \
a
c
.
xal sl6ax^il6ovxai
\
ttv\xovg ^ {a)xixvovg elvai .
.
avxotg xaxcc xa nXc
I
—
\
cv
&)vB %a7itxtrix{ov) ovdevbg Ox Lc) Ta(5)tv Frgm. Illn
.
.
41
xqtovx{ot)g
\
8ta(poQa
.
. \
dxoX{o)vd-ei xal [Col. C3{g €p)a{6tv) xb xovg {6)o(po{vg) dve^a{7c)axri\xovg elvat xal dvafiaQ^x^^xovg xax' eif dto xal 7ceQl {xdg 6)vv\'j4Qt{6x)oxiXrjv {x)aL 7cdvxa 7CQd{x)xeLv
xovxotg 8e
\
I
»5
\
{xa)xad-i6eLg ojcog ytvov\xaL
yiyovev
\
dXkd
aXlcyg,
(ie\xd xaxaXrjil>eag ^rAftjo)
yaQ i6^XLV
fiev
X6yov 6Q{96)\trit{og
i{7Ct)\tri8ev{6t)g
neQl X6yov
fiij
7Cqg)Xov
i{7c)L{6x)Qo\g)7].
i^ct^xrjfi^r]).,
{el'x')
n{Qayfi)atsLaL' x{al yuQ)
|
etxe
{r])(ptXo6q(pta., r]
\
tav
iv{tb)g '6vteg
{avf^ t^)
{tov)
X6-
\
'
yov fioQCcjv xal
tr]g
Xoytxotg vnaQxovta' I
I
\
av)ta)v xq{v) {6)6fi{e)9a ifin{e)L-
{Xi)ya tbv
e{l 8')
r]
\
xa{td
q>v6)LV
i6(ttv)
8t(icXext{txi])
\
{tolg)
7c{a6)t
= Ox Mb]
{d)nox{Q)t6et {nt)9av{b)v
{x)al tbv iv i{Q)at{r])6et
n^eQt^yCve^d^at
\
tov
ini6t{i])}i{r])
\
8vvatbv elvat
\
(ir]te
\
tovtov 8etvbv
{x)al dnox{Q)C6et 8etvbv 8ia(pev{y)etv, tbv 8' oiov \
fi{iq)re
ovxa
\
\
—
el-
12 dtvaiaiasiv pap. 16 aftaoTTjlfjjTcov pap. vroi.iv pap. Tjxa fi 25 xar' !4gi(aT)otfXr]v testatur ... ovta pap. 19« xai pap. pap. CrSnert Herm. 36, 550. 27 oite n. 28 triSov g pap. o, o tov n. | oqt 32 AIM6ICT 29 Ta TtSQiXoysia n. o, svrog evtsg n, sv g svtsg o. M€NT n. 36 Ssiov o, is lov n. {|
17
.
aiffrt
.
.
.
.
.
||
II
||
.
so
^t^akiye^^d^^at xad^ r]{fiag?
[Col. Iln
vat'
{6v)v{tdi,e(ag
X6{y)ov 8e
{Qag au)|TM"
6{Q)d-a{g
\
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ss
DULECTICA.
42 i^aitatcc69-ai
k£y£6%-ai
ov(t)s h
I
xal
\
li£v det avTov
\
3t£QLysvE09'a(i slvjui
inax{tiov si)vai xa(X)
tovt(o(v) i6o[iiv(x)v
I
xal diatpBvyetv tc Cxa\vbv d' txavov iv ta 8{C)a-
|
nvai iv t&L diaks\y£6d-aL, tbv
\
\
\
svsQcatijtLxbv xat (sv)\a7C0XQLtLx6v^
xata tbv
e(lajt)a(tG))\fi(s)vov ov(t'
av
avtov) tl;svds6i xal 3eQo(7Csti\6L XdyoLg dQd^&s ajtoxQL)\vouivoVy st tiva tQL\firjv fi£v iv kdyaL d' £G}g t&v nQ06Yix£v avtbv (£X£lv\ I
— — \
\
'fj
iXaxl6\tC3V d-ECOQrjtL^X^.^V Ox Mc] xatoc tbv i^a7c(a) t(Ofi£vov, ovte (aX)!iov [Col. Illn iv t&L 8LaX(i)y£69(i(L av\t)L Xiyovtog, dvvatov av, p(fov $£ Lxavbv ovt£ t(r])Qfi6aL a(vt)bv bvtog n£QLy£(vi6)9aL dxEQLyivqtov
=
\
[
\
10
.
\
I
xal
yuQ
I
aXrjd^sg Xiycav
\
avt&v dvtSQsi xal
\
ipsvdsg Xi(y)ov6LV av dvs^i(X)sxtOL ovt sg ot
\
\
inL7toQsv6ovta(L)' (t)vy%dvov6L 8s xal d^y^a^OL xal xataX(rj)\7ttLXol bvteg d(^L)G)\(idtG)v avtd(Qx)(og £Xiy%oy(t£g t£ t)bv d(paLQov^£VOv X6\yov xal i6xvov(t£g) tolg
ib
\
SeI i)v(avtL)ovg' xal i\Xiyx()(v) 6vvx(a)t(a)
tov(g
\
— —
tovg i(vavtC)ovg
132
\
\
7IQ06(7tQ)bg
yaQ avtoi)g xal d^xLvrftovg eIvul (-6)«' 6vvxatatL9£69aL n£(pQay^ivG)g TtQog \
Sextus adv. matli. VII 38.
hcra 01 ditb
20
\
\
xriv 8t
\
aiijOftav OLOvxal xivtg xal
(td.-
xara XQEig XQonovg^ oveia xe xat 6v6xd6ei xai dvvdfiei' ov6ia fiev nuQo^ov r] fiev dXi^d^eia 6&fid i6xi, xb 8e dXrjd-eg deoofiaxov vnfJQxev. nal eiKoxoagy (pa6tv, xovxl fiev yuQ dvdnaXiv 8e i6xi' xb 8e Xenxbv d^cofiaxov. xb Se XeKxov' d^loafid d^icofia Tijg
2xoag
SiucpiQZiv xdXr]9ovg
dXri^eia eCofid i6xi naQo^ov ini6xrift.ri ndvxcav dXrj&wv dnocpavSonet xvy%dveiv, na6a 8e ini6xi^firj nag e%ov ioxlv rjYefiovtxov^ &6neQ Kal 17 n&g e%ov6a leiQ nvyfir] voelxai' xb 8e rjyefiovixbv 6G>fia naxd xovtovg 'i)nriQxev' xoivvv xal r) dXi^&eia Kaxd yivog eexat ffoftartxif. 6v6xd6ei 8e na&o^ov xb fiev dXrj&eg ag fiovoeiSeg xi nal dnXovv xr)v (pv6iv 8e dXi^9eia wg dv ini6xrifiri 7ia^e6trjxvia xovvavxiov 6vvevorjxai rj 7]
xixr}
25
—
——
xe Kul nXeiovav a&Q0i6fia xvyxdveiv vneiXrjnxai. vdfiei 8e xuvxa dXXi^Xcav KeicoQi6xai, inel xb fiev dXrj&eg ov firjg eifexo (xal yuQ (pavXog kuI 6 viqniog kuI 6 fiefirjvcag XI dXri^eg, ovk e^ei 8e int6xrifir\v dXrjd^ovg) rj 8e dXrj&eta o9ev kuI 6 e%cav xavxrjv 6o(p6g ioxtv (ini6rrifiriv 9ea)Qetxui. 6xrjfiaxiKT^
30
35
&&v) Kui ovnoxe dnb doxeiag uvxb
kuv tpevSog
ipevSexat,
—
Xeyrj,
Stu xb
—— xar'
8v-
intOx^qfirjv
yuQ el^ev dXr}dnb xax^g, dXX'
fir}
44. (oSe kuI
6o(p6g, xovxi6 xrjv xov dXrj&ovg intox^^firjv excov, iQei fiev noxe tpevSog, ipev6exat Se ovSenoxe Std xb firj eyetv xr]v yv(6firjv ipevSet 6vyKaxaxi&efievr]v. 45. rb tl>evSog Xeyetv xov 'iljevSe69at Kaxd noXv Sieviqvoxev, rj xb fiev dnb d6xeiag Siad^e^eoag nQ0(piQe6^ui.
6XIV
40
42.
ndvxoag imexriXeyet fiev noxe
—
yivexut yvtofirjg, xb Se ipev8e6&ut dnb novr]Qag. 133 Alexander in Aristot. Metaphys. p. 258,4 Bon.
301,17 Hayd.
tb
5 ipBv4 i^aitaTmfievov rest. idem. 7 Q^eto6 itQoefixsv pap. cf. Croneii Herm. 36, 649. T]98cog pap. ixavov n, inav8 ovrs rtov pap. 9 ocov scripsi, yov pap. prjTixmv n. ^at o. 15 isituQ 0. 11 ipsvSst pap. 12 (ifinsa aovrai n STCirs6ir\«ovrat o. 3 ina%xhov restituit Brinckmann.
ioci pap.
;
||
||
.
.
16 casdem syllabas scriba per errorem bis exaravit.
38 exspectamus:
(^iiaiy &7tb.
DULECTICA. 'fiytia&ai
fi^
6ij
(lalkov &'Alo akXov
43 o
dux^tvdia^ai.,
SomI xoig &nb
xljf
£xo&Sy ^eHdog xe xccl nuQa xa <paiv6(uva. 134 Cicero Orator 32, 115. Ergo eum censeo, qui eloquentiae laude ducatur, non esse earum rerum (scil. logicae) omnino rudem, sed vel illa
antiqua vel hac Chrysippi disciplina institutus, noverit
primum
6
deinde
et
et
copulatorum: simplicium vim, naturam, genera verborum, sit iudicetur: quot modis quidque dicatur: qua ratione verum falsumne quid efficiatur e quoque, quid cuique consequens sit, quidque contrarium:
quumque ambigue mtdta dicantur, quomodo quidque eorum
dividi ex-
planarique oporteat. 135 Galenus in Hippocr. de med. officina Vol. XVIII B p. 649 K. r&v aiG^attov andaatg tijv yvafiTjv itps^ijg IVa^cv, onsQ iaxl rr}v duivoiav, rjv inei St XI Koi vovv xat (pqiva nal Xoyov noiv&g ot av&Qoanoi xuXovaiv. *al x&v xara ywv^v iari rtg Xoyog^ acpOQL^ovng ovv rovxov xov ngoeiQrjfiivov loyov ol tpiXoaotpoi KaXovaiv ivSia&exovy w Xoyat xa (iax6(i£va yiyvcoano(uv^ olg i(i7t£Qiixexai xal dialQeaig xal avv^eaig xal avdXvatg nal anidei^ig. Sextus adv. math. VIII 275. (paalv oxi av9Q(onog ovjrl rw nQOtpoxal x&v ^totov (xal yuQ xoQaxeg nai i|;iTTaxot uX6y(ov X6yo) Siaq)iQei Qtxm xlxxai ivccQ&QOvg nQOcpiQOvxat (pcovdg) dXXa x& ivdta&ixo), ovSe x^ dnX^ «ilAa xri (lexa^axiK^ nai avv&exixy. St6neQ dxoXovftdvov (pavxaaia 9lag evvoiav exiid i6ttv Jtoist dh ^ (pcav^ 7iQo6iov<Sa dxov6v6iv dxb t&v (pcavovvtov.
yivrjg xal ^AvtinaTQos
xav. tolg
141 5
xccl
Gellius Noct. Att.
V
Sed vocem Stoici corpus
15.
dunt eamque esse dicunt ictum aera. 142 Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. II 488. sophos physicos, qui dicunt,
143 Varro de lingua lat. VI 56. qui primo dicitur iam fari, vocabula et 10 sux)
imago Jiominis non
bus, pueris primitus
incipientihus fari,
secundum
philo-
esse.
Loqui db
loco
dictum,
quod
reliqua verha dicit, ante
quam
Hunc Chrysippus
quisque loco ea dicere potest.
ut loqui: quare ut
Ferit clamor:
vocem corpus
esse conten-
negat loqui, sed
homo, sic in corvis, corniciverha non esse verha, quod non
sit
loquantur.
144 Galenus 15
xavxhv di iexi
in Hippocr. de v,ca
cpiovrj
humoribus
Vol.
lib. I,
dtdXenxog xal avdi^, dXX'
•^
XVI
fxsv
p.
204 K. ov
(pcovrj
tqyov iaxl
OQydviov, ri didXenxog de x&v diaXeKXiK&v, cov xb (lev itQGixov iaxiv r) yX&xxa, eneixa Se r} Qlg nal xd xeiXr} xal ol odovxeg. cpatvrixixd de OQyavd icxi XdQvy^ xal oi xtvovvxeg avxbv (iveg xal vevQa, o6a
x&v
20
q}G)vr}xiii&v
xr)v i^ iyxecpdXov naQaxofii^et xovxotg Svvafiiv. avdrjv Se ovxs itav xb xijg dxoi]g iStov ata&rjxbv ot jiaXaiol ixdXovv, ovxe ixetvo fiovov, o Sid 6x6[iaxog ixnefmexat, iv « neQtexsxat xal xb xXdetv xat xb avQixxetv xai oifKoteiv
xat
jSijTtftv
xat o6a xotavta, ftovrjv Ss xrjv dv&Qcojtov cpcovqv, xad-' ^v Sia-
Xeyofie&a JtQog dXXrjXovg, avSr}v mvofia^ov. Idem in Hippocr. Epidem. III Comment. III Vol. 25
dem
verbis utitur inde ab avSr^v Se ovxe
xal 6
Jtoirjx^qg,
xrjvtxavxd
rivixa
inoii^Ge
xoTg
iSiotg
—
XVEI
1 p.
757 K.
iis-
Pergit: ovxat yovv tnnotg StaXeyofievov xbv 'AitXXea, wvofia^ov.
xbv exeQOv avx&v dfieitpa^d^at Xoyotg xQV^dfieyov dv&Qanivri
(pr}6t
AvSr^evxa, ydQ (pr)6tv, e^&rixe d^ed XevxcoXevog "HQr} (T 407). ov^ dcpcovov ovra nQOxeQOv ovS' &g ovx e^ovxa xr^v xotvriv x&v Tnncav cpcoo^xag ovv xal ,,&ebv avV1JV, dXX' wg ovx ovofia^ofievqv avSrjv ixeivrjv. StaXexxG).
ag 30
Srie66av^^ etQrixe xrjv dv&Qcanivrj noetSr)
cpaatv elvat,
yovv r)Xtog xat x&v dv&Qconcav
145
35
fir)
6eXr)vri
StaXexxa
j^^ojjiuvijv,
iSeag.
Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin
tellectum,
oxi xai avxr)v dvd^QO)-
^e&v xotovxcov 'bnaQiovxcav. ivaQy&g xai xd Xotnd x&v doxQcov dnoxeinGiQrixe ndfinoXv xijg ndvxcav x&v
sensus,
corpus
IV 117
(p.
336 Aucher).
(in-
comparat cum vocalibus, semivocalibus, conso-
nantibus).
146
I, 24 (p. 341 Delarue) Vol. I p. 74, 10 Ko. xb ifininxet eig nQOxeifievov Xoyog ^a&vg xai dnoQQr^xog, 6 neQt (pv6ecag ovo40 fidxcav, noxeQOv, ag oiexat 'AQt6xoxeXr)g, %e6et ioxi xd ovofiaxa ^, ag vofii-
Origenes contra Celsum
^ovetv oi dnb
xr)g
nQdyfiaxa, xa&'
cov
2xoag, cpv6et, fitfiovfievcav x&v nQcoxoav cpcov&v xd xd dvofiaxa, xa&b xai ^xotyetd xiva xi^g itvfioXoyiag
eiedyovotv.
147 Diocles Magnes apud Diog. 1 fi
449.
yiocl
Xqvo. — (fvcfKcbv
40 iatl
$
om. F.
Del., sial A.
Laert.
2 jtQoeovacc
VII 57. BFP,
tov
corr. P'.
8\
Xoyov
31 CalypBO
DULECnCA. i6xl
(liQtj
xivxB, S)S
XQo6r]yoQLa^
P^ftQov 6xoLXilov ikEyev slvaC XLg
s
xaxa 8\ xbv
k6yov xal xa xrjg q)(ovijg 6xoLX£ici ysvvav XQaxov nhv titg 6vXXa^dg, slxa i^ a-bx&v ysvva6%-ai x6 xe '6vo(ia xul xb ot jcdXLv 6 ^^(ttt xal x^v nQ6^s6LV &q%^qov xe xal 6vvds6(iov, ttvxbv
XQv6LJtxog 6vo(i>d^SL xov X6yov 6xoLxela. 149 Galenus de differentia pulsuum III 4 Vol. VIII
aXXa xul
662.
p.
lo
tl XrjQiLg, t6 pXlxvQi, g)aai, xal xb amvSai^bg aarjiia TtavzsX&g iati. ti Sr]Xoi nai tb amvdatl^bg ovx av&^coTCC, ix(ov; xal yuQ tb ^Xltvqi HQOVficc 15 olnitov jttdvov, aXXa xo:t OQyuvov tivog iativ bvofia. Cf.
Diog. Laert. VII 57 (Diogenes Babylonius). Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 8 Z. ed. Bas.
160
OixftOTc^xog
6i
6
ta avv t& ovofiati nai tbv 6(»ttf/tt6v l'jrovTa ^A^iatotiXrig avviovvfia nixXrixe Tov avT6v rimQ ol Et(i3'C%oi ta noXXa a(ia eiovta ovofiata, wg Ilaqig xal ^AXii,avSqog 6 avtog^ xai anX&g Ta 7CoXv(ovrj(ia Xsyofieva.
161 Varro de lingua
lat.
IX
1
... nesciunt docere
so
discere
quam
quae ignorant, in quo fuit Crates, nohilis grammaticus, qui fretus
Chry-
sippo, homine acutissimo, qui reliquit ^eQl dva^iaXCag III libros, contra analogiam atque Aristarchum est nixus, sed ita, ut scripta individeatur pervidisse
Chrysippus, de inaequabilitate cum scribit sermonis, propositum habet ostendere similes res dissimilibus verbis et dissimiles
cant eius,
ut neutrius
similibus esse vocabulis notatas, id quod
162
Gellius N. A.
XI
12.
Chrysippus
est
verum
ait,
et
ts
etc.
omne verbum am-
higuum natura esse, quoniam ex eodem du^ vel plura Diodorus autem, cui Crono cognomentum fuit „nullum", est
quod
voluntatem,
accipi possunt, inquit,
so
„verbum
ambiguum, nec quisquam ambiguum dicit aut sentit, nec aliud dici quam quod se dicere sentit is, qui dicit etc." 163 Galenus de sophismatis ex elocutione 4. Vol. XIV p. 595K.
videri debet,
EHQrjxaL de XLva xal xotg UxcaVxolg neQl xovtav, xttLov ineXd^ov6LV Idetv, et XLg i^a nCnxeL xQ6nog
yuQ (avy iaayayvG)g ol
tttvttt Qrjtiov.
xvvovteg, neiQa(ievoi 6e ofiag Xvetv xu toig ovv ol
doxovvxu uxonu.
— —
35
tov-
dnb r^g £toug ixQrj^uvto nu6iv xul (Jv^ tolg uXXoLg xav ivuvxCav 'AQL6xotiXeL xuxu n66ttg rixoXov-
so
6LOQL6[iolg totg nsQL
^r}6av, ixeCvov xug d(poQ(iug uvxotg 6e6ax6xog iv
xa ne^l xav
dvxL-
xeLiiivav 6vyyQU(itittXL ccg i^eLQyu6uvxo iv xotg uvxav ^L^XCoLg. 173 Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 98 E. ed. Bas. xal yuQ xal
xdg e^eLg
ii/uvxCttg vniXafiov,
ag
ixelvog
(scil.
Aristoteles),
otov qppd-
vrj6LV dOQdv xal tovg xatd 6v^vyCav dvttttd'ia6t."' oQovg 176 Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 102 Z. ed. Bas. Kal ot dnb tfig 2Jtoag Ss StV^xvQC^ovtat, oti ovSsv tav xatd dn6(pa6tv Xsyo(iislvaC q)rj6tv ^^in^
ovx dQSt^^ r^v ydQ dv tfj dQSt'^ ivavtCa rj xat T^ xaxCa ivavtCa ij ov xaxCa^ vnb (ihv tijv ovx aQStijv xal trig xaxCag ntntov6rjg xat dXXav noXXav (xat ydQ XCd^ov xal tnnov xal
SQvav ovSsvC i6ttv ivavtCov
ndvtav twv na^d tijv aQStt^v) vnb Sh tijv ov xaxCav xal Tijg dQStrig i6tat ovv svl ndvta ivavtCa, xal td avtd xat tav dXXav ndvtav. 35 TjJ
aQSt^ xal
tri
xaxCa ivavtCa, sC
(lij
r]
aQstij tf] xaxCa ivavtCa,
dXX
(yd xaxCa' 6v^^fi6stat xal 6novSaCotg (ii6a ivavtCa slvat xaX (pavXotg, dtonov Sh tovto, xat (idXt6ta sl xaX td avtd xal ij
11 «payftara hic quoque 3 &XX' &ii,iea}g scripsi, &XXa fisctog ed. Bas. 23 7tQ0(piQ0(isv ad19 xai ru addidi. ivuvticc addidi. XsKzd dicuntur. didi hic locus probat cetera quoque, quae Ttsql ivavxLav Stoica Simplicius profert, ||
;
Chrysippi esse.
DIALECnCA.
61
Kul to dvotv ivavtCav rxp' 6 fiiv icAvxu tii imoTclnxovxa noi6o dl xal xoi6xrjxag elvaiy d)g imh x^v aqsxi^ xaX xtjv xaxiav, vtp' (iij.
xrjxag xal noia^
Sg
'6jr6
xijv
ovx &q£X'^ xal
xi)v
o^ xaxiav (vnb xav-
xag yuQ xal xoi6xr]X£g xal noia xal iviQyeiai xal nav bxiovv i6xi) xal xovx6 i6xLV &n£ii^aivov. oiixag ^ihv ovv xal naQu xolg 2^rcolxal xa &no<paxixag avxiX£C(i£va. xotg di6Qi6xai xd xb ivavxCa
176 Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 102/^ ed. Bas. ot yoHv avxiiuia&ai vofil^ovGiv. (i6vu xu «TtoqpoTtxa xoig xazaipaxixoig Bekkeri Anecd. naQaXelncofUv fiaxo(iivov
naq
,
xal
Staixol
x&v XxmyiSiv Xsyofuvov xaxa ri^Vy '^QL6roriX£L dh ov rovro jcqovx£Lto etc. Cf. 16
£6rLv
102 B.
f.
£X
dXXd rbv
fihv
Tt£Qi
TtXriQr]
rov '^QLdroreXLXOv xai rov
r£
rav
Xoyov
6r£Qr}6£(ov
XQv6L7t7t£Lov
^l^Xlov
Xa(i^dv£Lv.
178 Simplicius
in
Aristot.
categ.
f.
101 E.
ed. Bas.
f^fog
dh
xai 6r£QrJ6£Gig ov Svvarbv £ig dXXrjXa (lEra^oXijv yLV£6d-aL. rv(pX6rrig ovxin xai dvaTtaXLV. bd^EV xai 6 i^ 6ip£(og fihv ydQ yLV£raL^ (livroL 20
i^-^rrj^EV, £t rv(pXovg Qr^riov rovg v7toxv^ivrag., dvvaix dh fiivovg 7taQax£vrr]6£(og dva^Xi^aL^ xai i^p' cov rd ^Xi(paQa xixX£i-
XQv6L7t7tog 6rai.
rrjg
(lovg
rj
ra
ydQ dvvdfiEag ov6i]g ioLxivaL ra xara(i£fivx6rL rovg 6(pd-aXx(oXvo(iivc} bQav dLa Tt 7taQa7tira6(ia^ ov d^paLQed^ivtog
ovdhv xcoXv£taL bQdv. 26
ovdh djcb
dio
6t£Qrj6£(og
e^LV
sig
yCvetaL
ij
tOLavtrj (i£ta^oXr]. Xa(i^dv£L dh vvv 6riQr]6LV rrjv xard 7trjQG)6iv. 179 Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 100 B. ed. Bas. (Jamblichum
xai ydQ xai rbv Xqv6l7C7Cov 'Aql-
se exscribere significat ipse S.).
6roriX£L £7c6(jl£vov 6r£QrjrLxd Xiy£LV ravra^ 66a dvaLQ£L 7caQ£(i(faCvovra
80
f^v rov ix^LV (pv6LV^ ovx d^cXag^ dXX' orav i(i(paCvri rb 7C£(pvxbg xai 0T£ 7ci(pvx£v xtti dvtCx£LtaL tfj dxb tov ix^Lv X£yo(iivri £\£l rj 6ti-
—
Qr]6Lg^ d>g
r]
xai ov
(jl6vov
tv(pX6tr]g
trjg
7COLOtr]t(ov
tov
bQdv
aC 6t£Qr]6£ig, iv£Qy£Cag xai
dXXd xai iv£Qy£LCOv, tov r] ^jjajAdrijg tfjg
^aSC^£Lv.
180 Papyrus Letronnii 36
7C£Qi
d7C0(patLxcbv
(ed.
Brunet Notices
et extraits de manuscrits de la bibliotheque imperiale.
Tome XVIII
Paris 1865, Th. Bergk Opusc. II p. 114). I. (av tL)g' „Ovx old' OTCcag XQ^ (i6t)LV 07C£Q ovtc) XiyoL (tf]g 'H)QaxX£Lag (pQovtC-\(dog x)atr]yoQ£tv.^'' 6)a(pcbg xat£Ld6ta I
I
(^ov
Nai
\
37
oiy. del.
adesp. 77 Nauck.
Bergk, propter suam supplendi rationera, quae incerta
est.
fr.
DIALECTICA.
I
(ov ttX)rj»h 8v Usyev 6
|
53 „OtJx old* onas
(«oti7ir)ijff'
(XQ^ tbv)
—
\
'
x)%
6afpS)s xaxBt,86\{xtt.
t^vdcbg
ovxs)
ovdh
ov
I
\
(ddailfio)vtt
i}ie\{x9-rj
(ovr' dkr]9'S)g)
Mov\{6av
Movd&v
{inaC8sv6)ttv xXvxal
\
ocv
ovxa
„(o{}rot
\
i\{naCSev6)ttv xXvxai
ovxa kiyoL
in:ttCdev)6ttv
ojceQ) Xex^eCri
|
\
\
oxbq kex)^eCri
Mov6av
'^fi^ovtt I
oij
(El ((pQovx)idog xaxrjyoQstv.^ (xig av „xol ^ie^^ivov (xs oiXrj^&g) ovreo XeyoL HQttxXEitts
ccv
\
{xig
xkvxttl
av
{&rl^ai}^
ovxag' „o^TOt
II.
(le
^ie
^evov ov\{dh dda-
fie)
0^/3at."
„toi)
(0^/3at" ovx dX)t]^hg
\
|
{vaC' o^)x£ ilfeviiag
^ivov
val
\
o)xf
^ivov ovdh
\
jiiOfc
ftoi
i\{kix^r}
ddttrjnova Mov6ttv lo \
HttQdttvditttXXog dQi6xei xr^v dLavoiav^^
dvxCxBLXttL a^CaiLtt xttXtttpttXLxbv
„0v
{ovdh ddailii)ovtt dkrjd^hg
inaC\8ev6av xXvxal 0ij/3at." 3. El dXrjd-ag xLg xav noLr]\xav ovxag dnetpttCvexo
„0v
—
xa'
dtavotav"
val ov dvxCxsLxai d^Cafia XttXtttpaxLxbv xa'
4.
— xav —
„0{; jttot vai ov dXrjd-&g XLg
SLttvoLttv.^^
„0u
dLavoLttv}''
fiot
TtOLrjxav
ovxag
16
djtetpaCvexo'
dnetp-qvaxo xig- (trag. fr. adesp. 83 Nauck) „Ovx ^v ttQ ovd-hv ytfjfi iXevd-iQav Sdxvov
Ei
i
Wvx^fiv bfioCag
to
dvSQbg ag dxL^Ctt}^ xa'
dvxCxeLXttL d^Cafitt xaxttfpaxLxbv
„Ovx ^v vai ov
dxLfiCa.^^
dxe(pT/ivttx6 XLg'
—
„0VX ^V 5.
85
dxLflCtt.^^
ovxag dni<pa6xev EvQLnCdrjg' (Iphig. Aul. 28) „0^x ayafiaL xavx dvdQog dQL6xiag}^
{El dXrjd-ag)
dvxCxBLXttL a|tOfia xaTaqpartxov xa'
„Ovx vtti
—
d^CaiLtt xaxtttpttXLxbv
30
x^
dQL6xiag.^^
ov dni(ptt6xev ovrog EtfQLnCdrjg'
„Ovx 6.
aptffrccDg."
ov dvxCxBLXttL
„0^x vtti
—
—
dQL6xiag.^^
El ^AvdQo^ttxri E\)QLnCdov nQbg
'EQfiLbvrjv
xovxov dneq)rlvaxo xbv
m
xQ6nov' (Androm. 205)
„Ovx
«1 ifiav 6s (paQ(idxav 6xvysL n66Lg^^
dvxCxsLXttL d\Ca\itt xttxaqittXLxbv x^'
„Ovx 1
ov cod.,
Letronue.
i^
male
—
n66Lg^
Letr.
6 Pind.
fr.
198 Bergk.
26 Ei
«iArjfl-ds
add.
DIALECTICA.
54
180
oi avxiiceitai
vccl
„Ovx
i^
a^icoiia
—
xata(patixbv ta'
jrdtfts"
val ov ^AvdQOfidxf] EvQLTiCdov tcqoq 'EQ^i6vr}v aTtetp^vato tovtov tbv tQoitov
„0^
5
7.
Et
£|
—
;rdtfig"
av (Eur. Stheneb. e&tiv o6tL£ navt dv^Q £vdai(iovet.^^
iativ, ojteQ ovtco Xex^d^etrj
ocXrjQ-ig
„Ovx
fr.
662 N.)
dvtLxeitaL a|tcj^a xatacpatLxbv rc3* „Ovx e6tLv evdaL^ovet.^^
—
vai ov dvtCxeLtaL
10
di,C(Ofia
„0v}« «^rtv
V. val ov
xatacpatLxbv
tct*
evdaifiovet.^''
dkrjd^ig iettv oiteQ ovtco Xex^eCrj
eativ
„Ovx 8.
—
—
^t dkr}»eg bv Ueyev
&v
evdaL^ovet.'^ EvQLTtCdrjg- (inc. fab.
fr.
896 N.)
„Oi)x iv yvvaL^l tovg veavCag XQ^fov, aAA' iv dg."
'
ttTtecpttGxev ^^ttv
15
yevoito
—
jraT^dg."
16. El '^ -^evdos ri ttkrjd-es i6tiv, o iXe%^ri vtc EvQiTtCdov tov tQ6nov tovtov (Eur. Hel. 1261) „ov;f ade vavttts dXo^evovs tv^^evoiiev}'
X. ttvtf\xeiTtti
„ov;( (bde vtti
ov
— —
ttvtCxeittti
vtti
tt^iCca^a xtttttcptttixbv
ouT£ i^evdos ovte
tQonov tovtov ,,ovx ^Se
Tt;|u./3£V0ft«v."
— —
-liOvx code
£0
xttttttpatixbv tm*
tt^Ccofitt
tv^fievo^ev}' e6tiv (o eXe'x^r])
ttlrjd-es
——
„ov3c e0Ti (tov
ttvtCxeittti
814 N.)
fr.
ta'
—— xatatpatixbv — — neSov}' EvQinCSrjs eXeyev e6ti — —
„ovx e6ti ov
Phoenix
ridiov neSov.^^
^Q^i^avtos
ttvtCxeittti tt^Ccj^a xatttcpatixbv
vtti
vn EvQinCdov tbv
TVfi/3£vo|u.«v."
17. {Ei) dXrj&as EvQinCdrjs {eX)eyev' (Eur. 25
ta'
neSov}''
tt^Caiitt
ta'
„ovx e6ti vtti
30
ov ttkri^as
„ovx 18.
neSov.^^
El EvQinCSrjs ovtas „ovx
avtCxeittti tt^Cca(ia 35
vttl
„ovx 'e0tiv ov avtCxeittti „ovx
ccnecpttCveto'
(Eur. Suppl. 270)
'e6tiv ovd^lv Sitt
'e6tLV
teXovs evStti^ovetv.^' ixbv ta' xarag^at
— —
evSttLfiovetv."
oc^Cco^itt
xatacptttLxbv ta'
evStti^iovetv.''
6 quae uncis inclusi, non sunt in codice; snpplevi 24 El deest in cod. 21 o iXix^r] add. Bergk. Bergkium. 25 iari 30 val in marg. add. librarius. sipKvrog cod.
Eurip.
partim .
||
.
secutus
iyiv cod.
33 sv&cci(iovovv
DIALECTICA. vccl
180
ov EvQiTivdris oikas ccn€(paCv£to'
—
„ovx ieriv
El ovras
19.
57
evdaifiovelv}'
ajcetpaiverd tis ta>v Jtotrjt&v (trag.
„ovx d^ta
fr.
ovx
(iix(q)&v 6e' (isydXa d'
adesp. 79 N.)
'i%ai!*
B6tiv ti$ og ovtas dnofpaCvoit &v'
—
hix(q)cI)v
^yd^iG)
val ov e6tiv Ttj
—
El
i';u«."
ov dnB(paCvEt6 tis t&v Jtoii^t&v ovt&s'
„OVX 20.
dl^LG)
10
«XCO."
„ovx
ixndyXaSt
insLdii (idXa (iol tpCXos ^i?v."
——
„[x] i(pd(ir}v 'AxiXrii
val ovx
13 K.)
xoka6ELv aXxLfiov ^rop
i(pdfiYjv 'AxLXrji
i6tLV
d%CGi(id
«
'^i^v,"
di,CG)(id i6tLV'
—— ovtas dni(pa6xev — — —
„[x] i(pd(irjv 'AxLXfiL
val ov 'Aya^iifivav
^ovx
El
fr.
'jiyafisfivav ovtcas dni(pa6xev (Cypriorum
(ade (idX'
21.
av
ovtas dxotpaivoLt
off
„[x] d^ici hix(q)g)v vtti
b
^X®"
'j4X)C(ittv
„ovx
icpd^irjv
f^^tyv."
^ijv."
6 noLrjtijq ovtas dne^paCveto' (Alcm.
fr.
25)
so
ifis
dvrjQ dyQOLXos ovdh tfxatdg."
xatag)d6X0L dv tLS' „[x] ^s dvriQ
—
tfxatdff."
val ov Xttta(pd6xoL av tLS' „[x] ^s dvriQ
—
t6
tfxaidg."
val ovx 'AXx(tdv 6 noLr^t^s ovtcos dne(paCveto'
„ovx 22.
rjs
——
tfxatdg."
El ovtcas dno(paCvoLt av
tts'
n[ov]dr}vt a(ineS6s (ydd'
(Anacr.
fr.
15)
el(iL,
d6toL6L nQo^rjvrjs,
«o
o^ AvttXQicav ovtojs dnecprivato' ov dr)vt' nQ06r)vrjs'
—
vttl
ov ovtcos dno(pttCvoLt av
—— ovtas ——
„di^r' val ov 'AvttXQicDV
„ov 23.
EC
nQ06rjvrls-^''
oW
15
dnetpi/jvttto'
nQ06r]vrls.^
Uttng)G) ovTCjg dno(paLvo(iivr}'
„o^x
corr.
drjvt'
rtg"
ZttL d^ico'
dvo
(Sappho
(loi
td
fr.
36)
voT^(iata.^^
4 /itxmv cod. eemper. 8 Ka^ico cod., corr. Bergk.* 15. 17 25 xtjs cod., corr. idem. 29 ov del. idem. Bergk.
xfqpafiTjv cod.,
DIALECTICA.
58
180
ani(pa6xBV' otti
^^old^
Bi6lv
——
voilfiatay val ov
didXextoi.
aficpi^oXoL
ei6lv
a^tpi^oXot
didXexroi.
val ov UajccpGj ovtag djcotpaivofievt]' oid' ottt
„ovx
5
dnecpadxtv' „oid' bttt
—
—
——
voijfiata.^^
vorjfiata.''
Ei Ztantpa ovtag dneq^adxev
— —
„ovx ot(J' voTjvata." e6tiv tt xatacpattxbv d^ios^a dvttxeifievov
10
— —
vttt
„o^x old' voijfiata.^'^ ov e6ttv rt xata<pattxov d^lca^a dvttxeifievov ta' oi)
vo^fiata.^'
UantpG) oiitag dne(pa6xev'
——
otd'
„ovx
15
— —
oid'
„ovx val
rcu'
i/oi^ftara."
24. Ei notrjt7]g ttg ovtcog dnetpaiveto' (lyr.
fr.
adesp. 106 Bgk.)
„ovx eldov dveficaxea xd(»av." e6ttv rt xata(pattxbv d^icofia dvttxeifievov t&' „ovx eldov xdQttv.''
—
val ov e6ttv tt xata(pattxbv d^icofia dvtixeifievov
jo
„ov
tei'
II
tredecim versus desiderantur I
a x6{Qav
|
xettat
8e%etat
I
86
.... |x eldov tcav
ov etd
.
xata(pat{txG)
dve(iG)xea .
.
dvo
a|i(o) ^Lata |
|
6tv xdxelva
dn{o(patLxd dv) tidnocpaiv .... \
|
x6\Qav dno(p
|
veficaxea
x6Qav
.
.
.
. |
. |
§
181 elvai t6 30
Diocles
2.
Aexta
iXXinfl.
Laert. VII 63. (paal de [toJ A,cxt6v xS>v 8s Xiv,x&v xa fiiv XevcpiGxdfievov. ot 2!xa)i}ioi, rd de iXXtitii' iXXiTtij (lev ovv iexi rd
Magnes apud. Diog.
xata cpccvraolav
yovGiv elvai avxoxeXrj
Xoyiiir}v
eTtt^rjxovfiev ydq ^Ttg;" dvandQxiaxov eyipvxa xijv incpOQUv, olov ,^yqd(pet^^. avroreXri d' iarl rd d7tr]Qxia(ievr]v e%ovxa xr]v iKcpOQuv, oloV ,,yQd(pet
85
^wx^aTijg". 182 Philo de agricultura § 139. Vol. II p. 122, 18 Wendl. oxi r&v 6'vT(av rd fiev iart acofiara, rd 6' dacofiara' nai Q6v
*
nQog d^idofiaxog yiveaiv. x6
olov
3^a, a
toTeXu}v.
3.
Scripsit Chrysippus de rebus hac
85
icp'
Ss
noXXr]
kuI naQu SaaKaXia Kul rd nXsiara r&v avyyQa(i(idr(ov intXsXotnsv. rotg
nsQt nQoaray(idr(ov
tractatis:
paragrapho
/3
nsQt iQcor^^asag ^' nsQi nsvascog S' intro(ir}
a nsQt e^wTijffewg Kat nsvasag
.
Magnes apud Diog. Laert. VII 66. StacpsQSt Ss d^ico^ia xat nva(ia (Kaiy nQoaraKrtKov Kai OQKtKov Kot dQariKov Kal iQwrr}(ia 'hno^srtKOV Kat nQoaayoQSvrtKov Koi nQay(ia o(iotov d'^t(0(iart. dS,i(0(ia (isv
186
Diocles
Kai
n.
20 Scripsit Chrysippus hsqI dQ&cbv 41 xal addidi. oqikov B.
13 V.
||
xal
vntitav
ngbs ^iXccQxov a.
Vide
DIALECJTICA.
61
iaxiv ^ HnHSoq. Igtaliyovxss &no<paiv6(ie&a, fiiu(f ^ aXrj^ig xai xb a^ltofui, aixrjxixbv di &noiaxi di wg avxoxiXlq ^Uv, UQayyM Tijfia di o-Cw iiXri^iq iaxiv o^tc lifevdog' xfflamgy ohv „i^a ys rKiiQa iaxl-^*' xoHxo &axs x6 iih ^rifiiQa iaxlv''^ a|/(api iaxi, x6 di „i^a ys rjfiiQa iaxlv^'' i(f(oxr}fuc. o avfipokin&g ovx taxiv anoxQlvea&at^ ebg inl 6i iaxt
y^
iaxiv
nvafia
TOt)
nQayfia 7iQ6g ,jVar',
^^coT^jitaTOs,
TaxTtx6v 144 iV)
akXa (jSsi) eineiv „oUei iv x&6e tw tottw". o kiyovxeg nQaaxdaaoftev,
6i iaxi nQayfia^
oloV
(fr.
6
rcQoa-
trag. adesp.
„av fUv ^dSi^e xag in'^Ivd%ov §odg^^. o el kiyoi Ttj, 6qhix6v **** v 'Ayaftiftvov^. ofLOiov 6i iaxiv d^Kafiaxiy o xijv ixcpOQav e^ov a^tW|itaTtXT)v naQa xivog nlnxei xov yivovg x&v d^ciafidxojv, olov fiOQiov iikeovaafi6v t/ jra^^og f^w 16 ,,xa>l6g y' 6 TTa^^&evwv". eaxi 6h nQutfii6r]aiv ificpeQrig 6 /SovxoAoff" (frg. trag. adesp. 109) xai inanoQrjxiicov xi nQayfia 6ievr]vo%6g d^icofiaxog, o ei kiyoi xig^ dnoQoir} jjobff
av o^e Totg
(Menandri
fr.
281, 9 Kock)
xi kvni] xat §iog'^' ,,&^' eaxi avyyeveg 6e dkr]&fi iaxiv oijre tpevdf] xd iQGixr]fiaxa xal rd nvOfuxxa iuxl xd xov-
nuQank-qaia, xwv
187 KOiv&g
d^itofidroav
^
dkr^d^&v
Sextus adv. math. VIII 70.
iv
kenrcb
t6
elvai
dkr]&eg
r]
avxina yuQ
nal x6
—
ijjev^og.
i^^iovv oi Zrcoinoi keKx6v 6e vndQieiv
cpaal x6 Kaxd koymr^v cpavxaoiav vcpiaxdfievoV koyiY,r]v 6e elvai cpavx&v 6e keKX&v xd xaaiav ymQ'' ^v t6 qpavTaO^O^fv eari, koyco naQaax^aai. wv Ta fiev ikkcnf] naQeia^co vvv, r&v fiev ikkinf] xakovat xd 6e avTOTcA^. 6e avxorek&v nkeiovg
elvai cpaat svSog t6 sItcsiv ori sCrai.
^ ovk sGxai, i]XOi uQa icXrjd^sg 1) tpsvSog ^dxsQOv. 199 Sextus adv. raath. VIII 79. Ta vvv Ss ixsivo ^xiov xorsXsg a^itofia 6vv&srov slvat &iXov6iv, olov t6 ^rifiiga KSirai SK rs rov „'qfiiQa^'' nal xov „l'()Ttv". sGxai
5 r^roi
200 10
Proclus in Euclid. p. 193 Priedlein.
anavxa Xoyov anXovv anocpavxiKov dtaXsKxtnag
'^fitv
xo av-
itfT/"
avy-
anb x^g2xo&g
nat 01 ys
nQoaayoQSvsiv siatd^aatv, nai tixav yQacpcoat xi^vag „7C£^( altwftaTov", tovto 8ta x&v iniyQafjt-
fiarav SrfXovv i&iXovatv. 201 Diocles Magnes 15
oxi
a^ia)fia
apud Diog. Laert. VII
nt&avov
75.
di iaxtv
a^icofia xb ayov sig avynaxd&satVy oiov „£? xig xt sxsksv, ixsivr} iKsivov fiijsxt xd fiiv ipsvdog 8s xovxo' ov yccQ ri oQvtg aov iaxi fii^rrjQ. rrjQ iaxi'^. iaxt Svvaxd^ xd 8s dSvvaxa^ Kai xd fisv dvayKata, xd 6' ovk dvay-
Svvaxbv fisv xb iniSsKXtKbv xov dXrjd^sg slvat, x&v iKxbg firj ivavdS^vvaxov Ss 6 (u.ij xtovfiivcav nQbg xb dXrj&sg slvat, olov ,,^'^ /iiOKXrig^''. iaxtv intSsKXtKbv ro^v dXrj&sg slvat, olov j,-^ y^ mraTat". dvayKaiov Si
Kaia.
onsQ dXrfOig Sv o^vk sartv intSsKriKbv rov tlJSvSog slvat, 1) intSsKrtKbv rd d' ixT6g a-uTco ii/avTtoiJTat n^bg xb tps^vSog slvat, olov ^-^ a^tT'^ Kai dXrjd^ig iaxtv xai 'ipsvSog otov xs o^vK dvayKaiov Si iaxtv dttpsXsi^^.
20 iartv,
fiiv
iart,
x&v iKxbg firjSsv ivavxtovfiivcav, oiov xb ,,nsQtnaxsi Jicov^'. s^Xoyov Si iaxtv d^itofia xb nXsiovag dcpoQfidg sypv sig xb dXr^Q^sg slvat, olov ,,^t(oxai aXXat Si siat StacpOQai d^tcofidxcov Kai fisxanxcoastg aofiat avQtov^^.
slvat,
25
dXrj&mv sig tl^s^vSrj xaJ. «vTtGT^Joqoa/, jtf^i cov iv x& nXdxst Xiyofisv. Stoici vero possibile quidem Boethius ad Aristot. de interpr. p. 374. esset verae praedicationis, nihil his prohibenposuerunt, quod susceptibile a^vxcav i^
quae cum extra sint cum ipso tamen fieri contiagunt; impossibile autem, quod nullam unquam suscipiat veritatem, aliis extra eventum ipsius prohibentibus ; necessarium, quod cum verum sit falsam praedicationem
tibus, 30
nulla ratione suscipiat.
Idem salius 35
p.
429.
illud
videatur esse
autem ignorandum non
possibile
a
necessario;
est,
dividunt
quod Stoicis univerenim enuntiationes
hoc modo: „enuntiationum, inquiunt, aliae sunt possibiles, aliae impossibiles; possibilium aliae sunt necessariae, aliae non necessariae; rursus non necessariarum aliae possibiles etc." stulte atque improvide idem possibile
et
genus non necessarii et speciem constituentes. 202 Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. c. 46 p. 1055
d.
'O
Ss
t&v
M dvvarS)V Xdfog
nQbg tbv r^g sifiaQiievrjg Xoyov ccvto) n&g oi) ftajjdsi ovx ieti dvvatbv ojtSQ ^ ictiv dXri^^hg r) E6tai, fL£v6g i6tLv; 'yccQ xatd Ji68(OQOv, ,,&kXd Jt&v tb iTCLdsxtixbv tov ysvie^^ai, xav ietiv'^ s6taL Svvatd jcokld t&v firj fiiXXiri 'y£V'^6£6d'aL 8vvat6v ,ai)
xa^' 16
sCiiaQiiivrjv.
«bff
pro xal F.
BF. 44 ^ aga
slatv (hoc ord.)
Chrjsippo.
libri.
Cf.
slfiaQfiivTiv libri.
14 re add. Wal.
firj
om. BP.
u.
[r]
i^
959 sq.
.S7
xal coni.
n
DIALECTICA.
66
ovx anXa 6i
OLOV to „^ft£()a itfrtV".
di,i,(o(iccTcov\
i^ d^icSfiatog dLafpoQOVfiivov
i6XL xa Svveoxaxcc
i^ d^icofiaxog (ihv SLa-
i^ d^LCOfidxcjv^
rj
g)OQOVfiivov, OLOv „£i i)(iiQa ioxCv^ {^(leQa ioxCvy^.
oiov „£? rifiiQa iotC, (pag 5
204
Magnes apud Diog. Laert. VII 69.
Diocles
i^ dl^LOfidxav dc,
ioxC^'.
h
Ss roig dnXoig dnoipaxiKbv xat t6 dQvqxLTibv xal tb axsQrjXLiibv nal xb a«^rtx($v bis
9 dnotpavxLnbv P; rovro vnhQ xb ¬pavxty.bv F. oix om. BPF, suppl. Galesius.
¬pavriiiov FP, sed v bis expunxit P*.
||
17 xal 16 avvsaxmg (vel &g) BPF. 14 ovrop (pro Jioov) BPF. 20 dedicaxatriYOQi^liatog addidi, i^ &OQiaxov ftop/ov tj i^ &OQiaxtov fiOQioav F. tivae 36 tl del. Bek. xaraqpartxat, abdicativae >= liTro^artxai. 10. 12. 18. 16.
=
DIALECTICA.
rt xv(fievti (ioqiov^ olov „t1; xa^zai^^ ^&v&Qmnog xadi^tat" ^ „£a>K(fuxrjg ici(fimxxei:^. ovv „Tlg neQinaxet'^ aoffiaxov iaxtv^ iml ovx aq)toQixi xiva x&v iiti neQinaxovvx(av' yioiv&g yaQ itp inaaxov avx&v ixtpiQea&ai Svvaxai'
avTovg iv olq aoQiaxov
6i iaxi xot' 6h
niaa
67
x6 fiiv fiiffovg
o^ag
xu
^xovxa
xa^Tat" aqiafiLivov iaxlv, inelneg aq^toQixe x6 Semvvfievov x6 6e ^^^(oxQaxrjg xaOijrat" ftiaov vn^qxev., ineine^ o^xe uoqiaxov iaxiv, atptaqine yaq x6 el6ogj o^xe oiQiafiivovy ov yuQ fiexa 6ei^ea)g i%aAA' Ibtxf ftiaov &.fiff)oxiq(ov vnaqxj^f^v^ tov xe aoQiaxov xai xoH oaQiax6
6h
„ovxog
i
n(f6a(onov.
(pi^exai^
fUvoV yivea&ai 6i (puai x6 aoQiaxov aXrj&ig
——
—
OTav x6
WQi.aft.ivov
aXri^eg evQiaxrjxui. 100 xui 6ij x6 a)Qiafiivov xovxo a^icafiu^ x6 „ovxog xu&rixui^^ ^ „o^T05 neQinuxet'^, xoxe (pualv akrj&lg vnuQxeiv oxuv xu> vn6 xrjv 6et|tv ninxovxi avfi^e^i^Kri x6 nuxrjyoQrjfiu, olov x6 iiu9iia9ui ^ t6
lo
neQinuxeiv.
206 Alexander Aphrod. apud 36
Siraplicium in Aristot. phys. p. 1299, in d^ xovxtov x&v koytov, cprjaiv 6 ^Aki^uvSQog^ 6wax6v oQfjuo6eixvvvui xu nuQu xoig 2x(o'iiiorg ci^KOfxuxu, a fiexaninxovxu
i5
Diels.
fievov
eaxi 61 xuvxu xoiuvxu' „£^ nul ukrj&ig iaxi vOv, a^jr6|u.fvov ajro eig ukrj&eg x6 „f^(rtTat", ukk^ eaxai
m
xov „t^ ij//(Bv" ovx liffTat akr}&eg x6 ,,xui fij0£Tat", ov fii} ovxog ukr)&ovg x6 okov avvrififiivov yivoixo uv '^ev6og fiexuninxov' ov yuQ uei^ oxe x6 „f§" ov fir}v uv ei'r} 6 Ji(ov. ttkrj&ig^ xai x6 „f^v 6vvdi6(icjv 6v(i7cijcXsxxaL, olov ,^xal 8Lst,svy(iivov 8i i6XLV^ 6 vnb xov rKiiQa i6xl xal q)&g i6xL''''.
„^TOt" 8Lat,svxxLxov 6vv8i6(iov ^ii^svxxai^ oiov, „^Tot ri(iiQa i6XLv r) vv^ i6XLv'^. inayyiXXsxaL 8\ 6 6vv8s6(iog ovxog xb sxsqov xav a|t(o(idxLov
25
alxLCo^sg 8i i6xLV
sivaL.
^sv8og
di,CGi(ia
xb 6vvxa666(isvov
olovsl yaQ atdta Toi> „dK)Ti", olov „dtdTt r](i,iQa i6xC, (pCog i^xCv'^. 8e xb (laXXov xl6v S6XL xb TCQ&xov xov 8svxiQov. 8La6a(povv rov t6 vnb iaxL t6 (laXXov 6vv8La6a(povvrog 6vvrarr6(isvov d^Co^id
8i6(iov xaX rov s 6
Xq.
BPF.
||
(prialv iv rfj
sl
||
|(
DIALECTICA. veveraL.
dib tcaTtudav &3io(p<x6xa}HBv avrd^ rov kdyov ixetvov ijroi yt
dxotparix^^v dvfiitkox^^v 6oiiev'
09
oi)dlv
ydg
dnotparixbv dvat ^vfinenXey^isvov
i\
TCgbg rb
nagbv
diatpBQEt
— —
gvfixsjtXBy^idvov
(pij-
XiyBiv
«AA' ol nsgl XQvatnnov^ xdvrav&a rfj kiisi ^aXXov r} rotg nQayfia^i nQo6i%ovrBg rbv vovv, anavrai rd 6id r&v 6v(inXBxrix&v xaXovfiivav 6vvdi6n(ov 6vvi6rd(iBva xdv ix (laxofiivav ^ dxoXovd-(ov^ ^viinsnXByfiiva xadno(pari,xbv ^ OviinXoxriv.
Xov6i,v^ iv olg fihv iyxBirai rig dxQl^Bta 8t8a6xaXCag^ d^iBX&g XQ*^(iBvot rotg 6v6(ia6iv^ iv olg dh
ovdsv 8ta(piQov al q^aval
avrot vo(io&BrovvrBg tdta 6i^(iatv6(iBva
209 Dexippus
in
6rj(jtaCvov6Lv,
etc.
lo
18 Busse.
Aristot. categ. p. 22,
fiovqv avfinkoiirjv rrjv (lexd avfinXeyitixov
yovxeg xoig £x(oiKOig iTtaKolov&ovaiVj
gxxijuv
dr}
oi
ozi
avvSiOfiov TtQocpOQccv Xi(ov
aQiaioxsQog
'AQiaxoxikrjg
x&v nQea^vxiQCOv avvrj^ela xQf^f^vog, otxivsg xrjv x&v nXei6v(ov (UxoH koyov avvoSov avfinkoxrjv mvofia^ov. Q&v 210 Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 29 p. 1047 c. 'AXXd (irjv xal
xrj
avrbg q>rj6lv
15
Chrysippus) rdg dtd dixa d^i(0(idr(ov 6v(inXoxdg nXrjd^et vnsQ^dXXBtv ixarbv (ivQtddag.f ovrs dt avrov ^rjrrjeag int^isXag
(sc.
ovrs dtd zav i(inBtQ(ov rb dXrjd-eg l6roQr]6ag etc. XQv6tnnov de av xal ot xdvrsg iXiyxov6tv "InnaQx^g i6rtv, dnodetxvvav dQt^(ir)ttxot. rov t6 dtdnr(0(ia Xoyt6(iov na(i(iiyBd-Bg avnp yeyov6g' eiye rb (lev
20
notst 6v(inBnXBy(iivc3v d^t(0(idt(ov (ivQtddag dixa, xal tavtatg tQt6xCXta te66aQdxovta iwia., tb d' dnocpattxbv ivvanQog x66ia nsvt^xovta dvo n^bg tQtdxovta xal (ita (ivQtd6t.
xata(partxbv
Cf. Plut. Quaest. Conviv.
VIII
9,
ubi eadem fere verba recurrunt.
dnb rovxav nal ini xd 211 xe ini xd Xoind etdrj x&v xd nat inl xoiv&g 6i£^£vy(jtivcc avfinenkeyfiiva orav dnk&v kiycoatv vytig tXvai av(ined^i(0(idxcov 8ia§aiv£tv. ovx nksyfiivov xb ndvx' £XOv iv avx& dkrjd^fj, olov xb ^-^juipa iaxC nai cp&g Haec impugnat Sextus, deinde periaxiv^^^ '^£vSog di xb 1'xov tl)£vdog. xb xaxd fihv xd nketaxa fUQrf vyikg x& iv dkk' 128. cpaai, |3/w, &an£Q git nax' akiyov Sh Si^^Qcoybg ovn dnb x&v nkeiaxcov xai iyi&v fi£Q&v [fjtdxtov., dkk* dnb ToiJ dkiyov xai Si£^QCoy6xog St£Q^coy6g^ oCtm {fyitg £lvat kiyofuv^ xra t6 avfimnhyfiivov ^ ndv *iv fiovov ^jri^ ri)£vSog, nk^iova Si dkr}9rj, Acjr^a£xat xb okov dnb xov ivbg t^£vSog. Sextus adv. math. VIII 124.
js
iviaxai Sh
—
212 Gaienus de vno^Brtxriv nQ6ra6iv,
simplic. 7)v
(livov 6vo(id^ov6tv. 213 Gellius Noct. Att. d^lcofjta dicunt „si dies est, sol
id
—
medicam.
oC nsQl
XVI
II 16.
rbv
8, 9.
Vol.
XI
XQv6tnnov
Sed
quod
p.
499 K.
rijv
Graeci
avvrjfifiivov movetur",
super terras est." 9
;i;pco|Li.e'i'0(s
'*
d^Cafia 6vvr}(i-
tale est: „si Plato ambulat, Plato
5 itgoaixovTBe Kalbfl., nQoaixovai cod. 10 vofio&fxovvTBS Kalbfl., ^iovoi alTovvTcct cod.
^^
cod., corr. Kalbfl.
27 tf inlBk. in adn., ini tb
libri.
*«
DULECTICA.
70 Item quod
avixitenkcyfiivov, nos vel „coniunctum" vel „copuest eiusdemmodi: „P. Scipio, Pauli filius, et bis consul fuit et triumpliavit et censura functus est et collega in censura In omni autem coniuncto si unum est mendaL. Mummi fuit". cium, etiamsi cetera vera sunt, totum esse mendacium dicitur. 214 Sextus adv. math, VIII 88. ov ndvv di ys dvvuvxai TiaQaCtiiGai xb ccvxiKslfievov Tjfiiv ot Zxminol. q)a6l yaq' ,,ccvtiii£l(ievd iaxiv &v x6 Etegov xov exeQOV ccitocpdaei TtXeovd^ei, olov' rjfiiQa iaxiv ov% illi
latuin" dicimus,
5
quod
—
—
^
'
xov yciQ rifiiQa iaxiv^ d^icofiaxog xb ov^ TjfjUQa iativ' dnodkk' g>daei nXeovd^ei xy ^ovp', nal did xovx dvxtKeifievov iaxiv iKeivto^^. ei xovx iaxi xb dvxtKei(i£vov, eaxai nal xd xotavxa dvxitieifieva to xe ^rjfxeQa 'qfUQa iaxiv.
10
iaxiv ^xal cp&q iaxiv' Kai xb ^rjfiiQa iaxivy Koi ovyt cp&g iattv.' ^^'^fiiQa S)q itfrtv". fucxoiv xb iiixu xhv „e^' rj xov ^^iittQ^^ avvdea{iov xBxayfiivov i^yovjiievov ioxlv^^.
nQ&xov wtkeixaiy x6 dh Xomov kijyov xe nal devxeQOV, xal iuv avaaxQOtpoig ixq>iQf}xai x6 okov avvr}(ifiivoVy olov ovxotg „<pa)g iaxiVy etiUQ rj(UQu iv xovxa Xf^yov (uv xakeixai x6 „<pa>g iaxiv^^ nalneQ nQ&iaxiv^*" xai xs nai
5
yuQ
xov i^evex&iv, riyovfuvov de x6 ^rnniQu iaxiv^^^ xaineQ devxeQOv keyoiuvov^ ditt x6 nexu x6v „£t7i;£^" avvdeaiiov xexayQ^ai. i) {uv ovv avaxaaig xov avvrjniiivov^ mg iv avvxoiim eineiv^ iaxl xoiavxr\^ inayyikkea&ai 6e donet
x6 xoioHxov cc^icJiia axokov&etv x& iv avx& nQtoxai x6 iv uvxa> 6evTC^ov, xal ovxog xov i]yoviiivov eaea&ai xo^kfjyov. o&ev atp^onivrjg ftiv xa> riyoviiivoi xov xrjg xoiavxrjg inayyekiag xal uKokov^ovvxog nai x6 avvrniiiivov^ iirj owfojnivTjg 6e k^qyovxog ukr]9eg yivexai
lO
tlfev6og.
217 Galenus dtdw
ju.^
I'(rw
introductio elvui.
Tode,
x66e
dialectica
vo&iiev^
inei6uv cp. 3 p. 8, 11 Kalbfl. olov (^0x1} vvi, ovn lcTrtv, rniiQuv
is
6ie^evynivov a^twju-a Tttfi twv vfwTf^xav cpikoaotpoiv (scil. Stoicis) ovofia^eTat, xu&uneQ ye Kui avvr}(xiiivov x6 exeQov el6og x&v nQoxaaeoiv x&v vno9exi.x&v ug xaxa avviieiuv ikiyoiiev yiyvead^ai (cf. supra: inet6av vnuQelvtti
ntaxevrjxut 61 exeQOv vnuQyetv ri y.uxu avvi%etuv\ oixetoxiQu 6e iaxt fo t6 [Ta] „dt£f£i;y|iif'vov" TOtg a|t(U|U.aatv (ug 6rjkov6xt 6tutQext%ag nQOxuaetg eg}uiiev ovoiJtd^ea&ut)
