Życie wirtualnych dzikich

Wielu osobom trudno wyobrazić sobie pracę bez Wikipedii. Choć nie zawsze stanowi pełne, wystarczające i bezbłędne źródł...

Author: Dariusz Jemielniak

15 downloads 646 Views 4MB Size Report

This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form

DOWNLOAD PDF

Wielu osobom trudno wyobrazić sobie pracę bez Wikipedii. Choć nie zawsze stanowi pełne, wystarczające i bezbłędne źródło wiedzy, to właśnie od niej studenci, naukowcy, czy inni użytkownicy Internetu zaczynają poszukiwania informacji na interesujący ich temat. Książka Dariusza Jemielniaka stanowi przewodnik po świecie Wikipedii, nie jest to jednak „instrukcja obsługi”, wprowadzenie w techniczne niuanse, czy też prezentacja dziejów popularnej encyklopedii. Autor przedstawia Wikipedię i ruch Wikimedia jako organizację czy nawet zjawisko społeczne, zaś jego książka jest etnograficzną podróżą po świecie tytułowych „wirtualnych dzikich”, świecie opartym na otwartej współpracy i samoorganizacji. Czytelnik ma dzięki temu okazję poznać nowe, interesujące oblicze świata organizacji zaprezentowane przez doskonale znającego realia pracy ruchu Wikimedia Autora. dr hab. Beata Glinka, prof. UW, Wydział Zarządzania Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego

Ta książka otwiera oczy. Umożliwia wyjątkowy wgląd w zamknięty świat aktywistów Wikipedii. Profesor Jemielniak jest mocno zaangażowanym Wikipedystą i jednocześnie międzynarodowym naukowcem z dziedziny zarządzania. To podwójne umocowanie pozwala mu na dotarcie do słabo znanych materiałów, które przedstawia w złożonej, pogłębionej analizie. Rezultaty jego badań są przedstawione w niniejszej książce. Otwiera ona oczy czytelnika na gry o władzę i mechanizmy zarządzania stojące za pozornie chaotyczną, anarchistyczną społecznością otwartej współpracy (...). Książka Jemielniaka jest lekturą obowiązkową dla wszystkich, którzy chcą zrozumieć przyszłość współczesnych organizacji. prof. dr hab. Andrzej K. Koźmiński, członek korespondent PAN, profesor Akademii Leona Koźmińskiego

5HFHQ]HQFL GUKDE%HDWD*OLQNDSURI8:8QLZHUV\WHW:DUV]DZVNL :\G]LDâ=DU]ĆG]DQLD SURIGUKDE$QGU]HM..RĩPLĕVNLF]âRQHNNRUHVSRQGHQW3$1 SURIHVRU$NDGHPLL/HRQD.RĩPLĕVNLHJR

5HGDNFMD $QQD*RU\ĕVND 3URMHNWRNâDGNL 6WXGLR.$5$1'$6=%HDWD.XOHV]D'DPD]LDN 6NâDGLâDPDQLH -2/$.6²-RODQWD6]DQLDZVND 7âXPDF]HQLH]Mċ]\NDDQJLHOVNLHJR²:RMFLHFK3ċG]LFK

&RS\ULJKWE\3ROWH[WVS]RR &RS\ULJKWE\$NDGHPLD/HRQD.RĩPLĕVNLHJR :DUV]DZD

:\GDQLHSXEOLNDFML]RVWDâRGRÀQDQVRZDQH SU]H]$NDGHPLċ/HRQD.RĩPLĕVNLHJR

3ROWH[WVS]RR :DUV]DZDXO2NV\ZVND WHO HPDLOZ\GDZQLFWZR#SROWH[WSO LQWHUQHWZZZSROWH[WSO

,6%1

SPIS TREŚCI

PODZIĘKOWANIA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 WPROWADZENIE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Dlaczego warto badać społeczności otwartej współpracy? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Świadomość zbiorowa, głąby, przegrani i inne błędne założenia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Zawartość książki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY

...............

27

Wikipedia: podstawowe fakty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Podstawowe zasady i normy zachowania . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Życie społeczności, status i reprezentacja samego siebie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA

...........................................................................

55

Role społeczne . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59 Głosowania nad przyznawaniem uprawnień administratora . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Choroba licznikowa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 Ścieżka zdrowia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 Czy system upadł? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 Czy admiństwo to wielka rzecz? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 78 Dymisjonowanie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80 Klika . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83 Egalitarny system władzy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89

6

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK?

.............................................................

93

Rozwiązywanie wirtualnych konfliktów . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93 Zapraszamy na Danzig . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Wieczna wojna . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 Pokój z pominięciem konsensusu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 Trajektorie konfliktów . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Współpraca, konflikt, a może i to, i to? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY

....................................................................................................

131

Kontrola przez śledzenie zmian . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134 Kontrola przez strukturę wypowiedzi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 140 Kontrola przez procedury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 Przyczyny biurokratyzacji . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 150

NIE UFAJ NIKOMU: PRAWDA JEST... GDZIEŚ TAM

.....................................................

157

Zaufanie a społeczności open source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158 Sprawa Essjaya . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161 Na czym polegał występek Essjaya? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166 Późniejsze debaty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 168 Zaufanie i kontrola referencji . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171 Zaufanie do procedur . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 174

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT?

...............................................................................................

183

Odejście założyciela? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 184 Ojciec Założyciel czy Ojcowie Założyciele? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 185 Zmieniająca się rola Walesa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 191 Przełomowe eksperymenty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 201 Dziecięca pornografia? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205 Tryby przywództwa w społecznościach otwartej współpracy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 214 Przekroczony Rubikon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 219

SPIS TREŚCI MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 223 Wewnętrzni interesariusze ruchu Wikimedia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 226 Relacje między WMF a organizacjami lokalnymi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 230 Relacje między WMF a społecznościami . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 238 Forking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 250 Niekompletna z definicji? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 256

UWAGI KOŃCOWE

..........................................................................................................

261

Nowe wolności i altruizm, czy wyzysk na nowo? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263 Wikipedia jako zagrożenie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 266 Zakończenie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 270

DODATEK 1: METODYKA BADAŃ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 273 Etnografia a przeniknięcie do badanej społeczności . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 273 Narracja w pierwszej osobie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 276 Metody badawcze . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 278 Pytania badawcze . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281 Etnografia wirtualna . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 282 Nazewnictwo i powody, dla których badanie oparto na dwóch Wikipediach . . . . . . 284

DODATEK 2: PIĘĆ FILARÓW WIKIPEDII

.......................................................................

289

Wprowadzenie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 289 Pięć filarów . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 291 Czym Wikipedia nie jest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 293 Podstawowe pojęcie neutralności . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 307 Wikipedia: Prawa autorskie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 323 Wikipedia: Wikietykieta . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327 Podstawowe zasady etykiety Wikipedii . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327 Wikipedia: Ignoruj wszystkie zasady . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 329

BIBLIOGRAFIA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 331

7

PODZIĘKOWANIA

3RZVWDQLHQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīNLE\âRE\QLHPRīOLZHEH]SRPRF\]HVWURQ\ SURJUDPX/DERU :RUNOLIH3URJUDPQD8QLZHUV\WHFLH+DUYDUGD D]ZâDV]F]DEH]SRPRF\(ODLQH%HUQDUG5LFKDUGD%)UHHPDQD L-RKQD7UXPSERXUD XUORSXQDXNRZHJRRG$NDGHPLL/HRQD.RĩPLĕ VNLHJRLZVSDUFLDÀQDQVRZHJR0LQLVWHUVWZD1DXNLL6]NROQLFWZD :\īV]HJR -HVWHPUyZQLHīZG]LċF]Q\]DNRPHQWDU]HSRP\Vâ\LUHDNFMHXF]HVW QLNyZVHPLQDULXPSRğZLċFRQHJRRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\Z%HUNPDQ &HQWHUV]F]HJyOQLHSRFKRG]ĆFHRG6KXQ/LQJ&KHQ%0DNR+LOOD L%ULDQD.HHJDQDNWyU\FKXZDJLGRW\F]ĆFHSLHUZV]HMZHUVMLNVLĆīNLE\â\ EDUG]RFHQQH-RVHSK-5HDJOHWDNīHVNRPHQWRZDâF]ċğýWHJRRSUDFR ZDQLD0RīOLZRğýSU]HG\VNXWRZDQLDSURMHNWX]>HQ:36L]HBFRPSDULVRQV@@ -DNSRGDMĆ QLHNWyUHEDGDQLD:LNLSHGLDXWU]\PXMHUyZQLHīZ\VRNLSR]LRPF]\ WHOQRğFL]DZDUW\FKZQLHMWUHğFL>HQ:36L]HBFRPSDULVRQV@@RGQRVLVLċGRGR NXPHQWX]DZDUWHJRSRGDGUHVHPKWWSVHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:36L]HBFRPSD ULVRQVOXEKWWSVHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD6L]HBFRPSDULVRQVJG\ī:3 VWDQRZLVNUyWRG:LNLSHGLD 3RGZyMQHQDZLDV\NZDGUDWRZHVĆFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\P HOHPHQWHPW]ZZLNLNRGXZNVLĆīFH]DğVâXīĆGRâDWZHJRRGG]LHOHQLDZHZQċWU] QHJRDGUHVXGRNXPHQWX6NâDGQLDâĆF]GRLQQ\FKGRNXPHQWyZZ:LNLSHGLLMHVW F]\WHOQDLV]HURNRVWRVRZDQDZVSRâHF]QRğFLZLNLSHG\VWyZ-DNRīHNVLĆīNDVNLHUR ZDQDMHVWGRSROVNRMċ]\F]QHJRF]\WHOQLNDOLQNLZ]Z\Nâ\FKQDZLDVDFKNZDGUD WRZ\FKRGQRV]ĆVLċGRSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLGRNXPHQW\ZZHUVMLDQJLHOVNLHMSRSU]H G]RQHVĆNRGHPMċ]\NDHQ]DRWZLHUDMĆFĆSDUĆQDZLDVyZ1LHNWyUHGRNXPHQW\ GRVWċSQHZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLQLH]QDMGXMĆVZRMHJRRG]ZLHUFLHGOHQLDZZHUVML SROVNLHMOHF]WDNVLĆīNDEċG]LHSU]\ZRâ\ZDýGODZ\JRG\&]\WHOQLNDSROVNLHVWURQ\ :LNLSHGLLRLOHEċG]LHWRPRīOLZH

WPROWADZENIE SURIHVMRQDOLVWDPRJĆF\VWZRU]\ýÅSRUWIROLRµLDXWRU\WHWZğUyGF]âRQNyZ VSRâHF]QRğFLPRīHRF]HNLZDýGâXJRIDORZ\FKNRU]\ğFLZNZHVWLDFK ]ZLĆ]DQ\FK]UR]ZRMHP]DZRGRZ\P%XGRZDQLHUHSXWDFMLMHVWV]HURNR SRVWU]HJDQHMDNRMHGHQ]JâyZQ\FKPRW\ZDWRUyZXF]HVWQLFWZDZUXFKX )/266:HEHU 6\WXDFMDSU]HGVWDZLDVLċMHGQDN]JRâDRGPLHQQLHZSU]\SDGNX :LNLSHGLL,QDF]HMQLīPDWRPLHMVFHZSURMHNWDFK)/266OHF]SRGRE QLHGRJLHURQOLQHMDNQDSU]\NâDG7KH:RUOGRI:DUFUDIWF]\7LELD F]\GRDJUHJDWRUyZWUHğFLLVLHFLVSRâHF]QRğFLRZ\FKW\SX3LQWHUHVW L)DFHERRN X]QDQLHLÅNDULHUDµEXGRZDQHVĆJâyZQLHZHZQĆWU]VSR âHF]QRğFLLGODQLHMVDPHMQLH]DğGODğZLDWD]HZQċWU]QHJR1DSLVDQLH GOD:LNLSHGLLZLHOXDUW\NXâyZRZ\MĆWNRZHMMDNRğFLU]DGNRSU]\ZR â\ZDQHMHVWZ&9&RPRīHMHV]F]HZDīQLHMV]HDUW\NXâ\Z:LNLSHGLL WZRU]RQHVĆZSU]HZDīDMĆFHMF]ċğFLSU]H]QLHHNVSHUWyZ]DğZLHOX SURIHVMRQDOLVWyZHG\WXMĆF\FK:LNLSHGLċSRGHMPXMHWHPDW\]QDF]QLH RGELHJDMĆFHRGLFK]DLQWHUHVRZDĕ]DZRGRZ\FK.LHUXMĆFHQLPLPRW\Z\ VĆZRF]\ZLVW\VSRVyERGPLHQQHRGLGHLNWyUHSU]\ğZLHFDMĆF]âRQNRP VSRâHF]QRğFL)/266&LIIROLOOLE>HQ:LNLSHGLD$VVXPHJRRG IDLWK@@>>:3=':@@ RGZV]\VWNLFKZ\PDJDVLċE\QLH]DNâDGDOL]â\FK LQWHQFMLSR]RVWDâ\FKHG\WRUyZMDNWHīE\UHDJRZDOLWDNMDNE\ZV]\ VF\LQQLG]LDâDOLZGREUHMZLHU]HQDZHWJG\E\QDSLHUZV]\U]XWRND Z\JOĆGDâRWRRGZURWQLH=DVDGDWDMHVW]RF]\ZLVW\FKZ]JOċGyZSR VWU]HJDQDGRğýHODVW\F]QLH]DğMHMU]DGNLHâDPDQLHQLHSRFLĆJD]DVREĆ NRQVHNZHQFML:DīQHMHVWMHGQDNE\QLHSU]\SLV\ZDýLQQ\P]â\FK LQWHQFMLQDZHWZRGQLHVLHQLXGRXī\WNRZQLNyZRPURF]QHMSU]HV]âRğFL HG\F\MQHM=DVDGDWDMHVWQLHMDNRSRZLĆ]DQD]RF]HNLZDQLHPE\QLH JU\ĩýQRZLFMXV]\>>HQ:LNLSHGLD3OHDVHGRQRWELWHWKHQHZFRPHUV@@ >>:31*1@@ 1RZLXī\WNRZQLF\F]ċVWRSRSHâQLDMĆJâXSLHEâċG\EĆGĩ QLHSRWUDÀĆSLVDýDUW\NXâyZ]JRGQLH]SU]\MċW\PLVWDQGDUGDPLJG\ī QLHVĆQDZHWğZLDGRPLLVWQLHQLDMDNLFKNROZLHNVWDQGDUGyZ&]ċVWR WHīEH]ZLHGQLHâDPLĆLQQH]DVDG\SURMHNWX5HJXâDWDSRGNUHğODīH ZURJLHQDVWDZLHQLHGRQRZRSU]\E\â\FKHG\WRUyZMHVWV]F]HJyOQLHQLH ]GURZHGODSURMHNWX 7RZâDğQLHQRZLFMXV]HVĆV]F]HJyOQLHSRGDWQLQDHG\WRZDQLHZRE OLF]XNRQÁLNWXLQWHUHVyZ>>HQ:3&2,@@>>:3.,@@ 2GUDG]DVLċ

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY HG\WRZDQLHDUW\NXâyZZNWyU\FK]DFKRZDQLHQHXWUDOQRğFLPRīH HG\WRURZLSU]\Mğý]WUXGHP6]F]HJyOQLHRVWURīQLHQDOHī\SRFKRG]Lý GRDXWRELRJUDÀL2SLV\ZDQLHRUJDQL]DFMLOXE]MDZLVN]NWyU\PLSLV]ĆF\ MHVWV]F]HJyOQLH]ZLĆ]DQ\UyZQLHīQLHMHVW]DOHFDQH]DğRGHG\WRUyZ RF]HNXMHVLċXMDZQLHQLDSRWHQFMDOQ\FK]DJDGQLHĕZNWyU\FKPRīH GRMğýGRNRQÁLNWXLQWHUHVyZ$GPLQLVWUDWRURPRGUDG]DVLċZ\NRU]\ VW\ZDQLHSU]HND]DQ\FKLPQDU]ċG]LZV\WXDFMDFKZNWyU\FKZ\VWċ SXMĆMDNR]Z\NOLHG\WRU]\²QDSU]\NâDG]DEORNRZDQLHXī\WNRZQLND ]NWyU\PZHV]âRVLċZVSyUPRīHE\ýSRGVWDZĆGRG]LDâDĕG\VF\SOL QDUQ\FKZREHFQDNâDGDMĆFHJREORNDGċDGPLQLVWUDWRUDFK\EDīHVSyU Z\QLND]SUyEWâXPDF]HQLDEâċGQ\FKG]LDâDĕSUREOHPDW\F]QHPX Xī\WNRZQLNRZL-HV]F]HGZLH]DVDG\PyZLĆRW\PīHZV]\VWNLHUHJXâ\ SLVDQHVĆSRWRE\XâDWZLýUR]ZLMDQLH:LNLSHGLLQLH]DğGODVDPHJR LFKLVWQLHQLD-HGQD]DEUDQLDSU]HV]NDG]DQLDZSUDF\:LNLSHGLLSRWR E\FRğXGRZRGQLý>>HQ:332,17@@>>:332,17@@ FRZSUDNW\FH R]QDF]DīHXī\WNRZQLF\QLHSRZLQQLSRGHMPRZDýSUyE]G\VNUHG\WR ZDQLD]DVDGSU]H]SRV]XNLZDQLHQLHNRQVHNZHQFMLZLFK]DVWRVRZDQLX OXESU]H]SUyE\HJ]HNZRZDQLDUHJXâZDEVXUGDOQ\OXEQLH]Z\Nâ\ VSRVyE'UXJD]DEUDQLDSRJU\ZDQLD]V\VWHPHP>>HQ:3*$0(@@ F]\OLZVSRVyESU]HP\ğODQ\Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQLD]DVDG:LNLSHGLLZ]âHM ZROLZ\V]XNLZDQLDÅKDF]\NyZµREHMğýPRīOLZRğFLQLHHW\F]QHJR SRVWċSRZDQLD]GUREQRVWNDPLF]\EORNRZDQLDNRQVHQVXVXSU]H] Z\FRI\ZDQLHQLHZLHONLFK]PLDQ]DPLDVWGRNRQDQLDSRSUDZHNVDPR G]LHOQLH ,VWQLHMHZLHOHQRUPHG\WRZDQLD]ZLĆ]DQ\FK]PHU\WRU\F]QĆVWURQĆ SUDF\Z:LNLSHGLLNWyUHZZLHOXSU]\SDGNDFKVĆV]F]HJyâRZHOHF]QLH ]ZLĆ]DQH]RUJDQL]DFMĆSUDF\LZVSyâSUDF\FRVWDQRZLREV]DU]DLQWHUH VRZDQLDQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīNL:DUWRWXMHGQDNZVSRPQLHýRNRQLHF]QRğFL HG\WRZDQLD]SRV]DQRZDQLHPQHXWUDOQHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD>>HQ :31329@@>>:31329@@ &KRý]DâRīHQLHWREU]PLMDNSR]\W\ZL VW\F]Q\LGHDOL]PZSUDNW\FHVSURZDG]DVLċGRV\WXDFMLZNWyUHMDUW\ NXâ\QLHPRJĆE\ýVWURQQLF]H]DWRPXV]ĆGRNâDGQLHSU]HGVWDZLDý ZV]\VWNLHRSLVDQHZZLDU\JRGQ\FKĩUyGâDFKDVSHNW\]DJDGQLHQLDSUR SRUFMRQDOQLHGRLFKLVWRWQRğFL1DZHWMHğOLSUDNW\F]QH]DVWRVRZDQLH WHM]DVDG\QLHMHVW]DZV]HEOLVNLHLGHDâRZL2EROHULLQ VWDQRZL RQDMHGQĆ]QDMğFLğOHMSU]HVWU]HJDQ\FKUHJXâUR]ZLMDQLDKDVHâLMHGQĆ ]WU]HFKUG]HQQ\FK]DVDG:LNLSHGLL'ZLHSR]RVWDâHğFLğOH]HVREĆSR ZLĆ]DQHWR]DVDGDZHU\ÀNRZDOQRğFL>>HQ:39HULÀDELOLW\@@>>:3:(5@@ L]DND]XSU]HGVWDZLDQLDWZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHM>>HQ:3125@@>>:325@@

41

42

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... :\PyJZHU\ÀNRZDOQRğFLR]QDF]DīHZV]HONLHLQIRUPDFMHNWyUH PRīQD]DNZHVWLRQRZDýQDOHī\SRSU]HýZLDU\JRGQ\PLĩUyGâDPL-HğOL EUDNXMHWDNLFKĩUyGHâRF]HNXMHVLċīHXī\WNRZQLF\SU]HGHZV]\VWNLP RGV]XNDMĆSRWU]HEQHPDWHULDâ\UHIHUHQF\MQH0RJĆUyZQLHīR]QDF]\ý F]ċğýWHNVWX]QDF]QLNLHPÅSRWU]HEQHĩUyGâRµV\JQDOL]XMĆFLQQ\PHG\ WRURPLF]\WHOQLNyZīHGDQDLQIRUPDFMDQLHPDRSDUFLDZPDWHULDâDFK ]HZQċWU]Q\FK =DVDGDQLHSU]HGVWDZLDQLDWZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHM]DEUDQLDSXEOLNRZD QLDLQIRUPDFMLEH]RGQRV]HQLDLFKGR]HZQċWU]Q\FKSXEOLNDFMLJG\ī :LNLSHGLDQLHPDVâXī\ýMDNRSLHUZRWQHĩUyGâRZLHG]\-HVWWRV]F]H JyOQLHZLGRF]QHZKDVâDFKRSLVXMĆF\FKQLHGDZQHZ\GDU]HQLDNLHG\ WRĩUyGHâLQIRUPDFMLMHVWQLHZLHOHDSRGDZDQHGDQHV]\ENRVLċ]PLH QLDMĆ]DğXī\WNRZQLF\F]ċVWRVWDUDMĆVLċ]DZLHUDýZKDVâDFKLQIRUPDFMH NWyUHQLHVĆXĩUyGâRZLRQH.HHJDQLLQ :WDNLHMV\WXDFML XWU]\PDQLHZ\VRNLHMGRNâDGQRğFLLQIRUPDFML]DZDUW\FKZDUW\NXOH Z\PDJDGREUHMNRRUG\QDFMLG]LDâDĕ.HHJDQLLQ =DNUHVZNWyU\PXĩUyGâDZLDQLHLQIRUPDFMLMHVWZ\PDJDQH]DOHī\ RF]\ZLğFLHRGV\WXDFML7HPDW\QDXNRZHQDOHī\RSLHUDýQDSXEOLNDFMDFK QDXNRZ\FK]DğZLDGRPRğFL]HğZLDWDSRSNXOWXU\PRīQDRSDWU\ZDý SU]\SLVDPL]SUDV\F]DVDPLQDZHW]WDEORLGyZ=DVDGDWDMHVWUyZQLHī RGPLHQQLHLQWHUSUHWRZDQDZ]DOHīQRğFLRGSURMHNWX&]DVDPLQDZHW SURVWHZ\OLF]HQLDRSDUWHQDGDQ\FKĩUyGâRZ\FKMDNQSSRG]LHOHQLH3.% SU]H]OLF]EċPLHV]NDĕFyZNUDMXZFHOXX]\VNDQLD3.%SHUFDSLWDPRīH ]RVWDý]DNZDOLÀNRZDQHGRNDWHJRULLÅWZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHMµJG\īWDNLHM NDONXODFMLQLHGDVLċRGQDOHĩýZPDWHULDâDFKĩUyGâRZ\FKF]DVDPLGR ]ZRORQHVĆ]DWRGDOHNRLGĆFHZQLRVNLZ\VQXZDQHQDSRGVWDZLHĩUyGHâ -HGHQZ\PyJMHVWQLH]PLHQQ\Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQHĩUyGâDPXV]ĆE\ý ZLDU\JRGQH>>HQ:356@@ QLHGRSXV]F]DOQHMHVWF\WRZDQLHĩUyGHâ RQLVNLHMUHSXWDFML6DPRSXEOLNRZDQHĩUyGâDLQIRUPDFMLLĩUyGâDRGD MĆFHMVLċNZHVWLRQRZDýMDNRğFLPRJĆVâXī\ýW\ONRGRRSLV\ZDQLDVD P\FKVLHELHMDNWHīVWRVRZDQHZSU]\SDGNDFKJG\QLHVĆZ\MĆWNRZH >>HQ:35(')/$*@@ =DVDG\:LNLSHGLLGRW\F]ĆFHZHU\ÀNRZDOQRğFLLQLHSXEOLNRZDQLD WZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHMVĆGRğýRVWUH=DNUHVZNWyU\PVĆRQHHJ]HNZRZDQH ]DOHī\RGWHPDWXHG\WRUyZLWHQGHQFML]DFKRG]ĆF\FKZVSRâHF]QRğFL 'REUĆLOXVWUDFMĆWHJR]MDZLVNDSR]ZDODMĆFĆ]UR]XPLHý]DVDGċG]LD âDQLDZZQRUPMHVWOHNWXUDKDVHâQDWHPDWKRPHRSDWLLF]\XIRORJLL ZSU]\SDGNXNWyU\FKF\WRZDQHVĆZ]DMHPQLHVSU]HF]QHĩUyGâDDWDNīH SRMDZLDMĆVLċĩUyGâDZFDâHMUR]FLĆJâRğFLZHU\ÀNRZDOQRğFLLU]HWHOQRğFL

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY 0LPRWHJRDUW\NXâ\WDNLHFDâNLHPGREU]HZSDVRZXMĆVLċZRF]HNLZDQLD VWDZLDQHKDVâRPHQF\NORSHG\F]Q\P 3U]H]ODWD]DUyZQRDQJLHOVNDMDNLSROVND:LNLSHGLDZ\ND]Dâ\WHQ GHQFMċGROHSV]HJRXĩUyGâDZLDQLDLQIRUPDFML:QLHNWyU\FKSU]\SDGNDFK X]\VNDQHZ\QLNLVĆDEVXUGDOQHLNRPLF]QH'ODSU]\NâDGXZHZU]Hğ QLXDPHU\NDĕVNLSLVDU]3KLOLS5RWKZ\VWRVRZDâOLVWRWZDUW\GR :LNLSHGLLRSXEOLNRZDQ\ZF]DVRSLğPLHÅ7KH1HZHQ:3&9@@ >>:313$@@ 'RZROQ\IUDJPHQWWHNVWXVNRSLRZDQHJRGR:LNLSHGLL MDNRSODJLDWMHVWQDW\FKPLDVWSR]DXZDīHQLXXVXZDQ\:DOF]\VLċWHī ]QDUXV]HQLHPSUDZDDXWRUVNLHJRSRGSRVWDFLĆZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQLD PDWHULDâyZSU]H]RVRE\QLHSRVLDGDMĆFHGRQLFKSUDZ²ZG]LHG]LQLH PDWHULDâyZ]HZQċWU]Q\FKDNFHSWRZDOQHVĆW\ONRQLHNWyUHZROQHOLFHQ FMH&R]DEDZQH:LNLSHGLDNWyUĆF]ċVWRZLQLVLċ]DSU]\F]\QċHSL GHPLLSODJLDWyZMHVWPRGHORZ\PZUċF]SU]\NâDGHPSUDZRU]ĆGQHJR SRGFKRG]HQLDGRSUDZDDXWRUVNLHJR-HV]F]HEDUG]LHMğPLHV]QHMHVW MHGQDNWRīHSURIHVMRQDOQHPHGLDF]ċVWRZ\NRU]\VWXMĆPDWHULDâ\ IRWRJUDÀHLIUDJPHQW\KDVHâ ]:LNLSHGLLEH]SRGDQLDĩUyGâDF]HJR Z\PDJDVWRVRZDQDZ:LNLSHGLLOLFHQFMD²]DNâDGDMĆīHMHğOLPDWHULDâ MHVWGDUPRZ\WRX]QDQLHDXWRUVWZDRUD]SRGDQLHĩUyGâDVĆQLHLVWRWQH *G\E\:LNLSHGLDSU]\MċâD]DVDGċZ]DMHPQRğFLZVWRVXQNXGRLQVW\ WXFMLNRSLXMĆF\FKMHM]DZDUWRğýE\âDE\RZLHOHERJDWV]DZWUHğFLOHF] VSRâHF]QRğýRFKRWQLNyZDPDWRUyZSRGFKRG]LGRSUDZDDXWRUVNLHJR RZLHOHEDUG]LHMVXPLHQQLHQLīNRUSRUDF\MQLG]LHQQLNDU]HLDXWRU]\ 7HQ]DG]LZLDMĆF\IHQRPHQGDVLċ]DVWRVRZDýQLHW\ONRGR:LNLSHGLL VSRâHF]QRğFL)/266LğURGRZLVNDRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\VĆ]Z\NOH GREU]H]D]QDMRPLRQH]SUDZHP]XZDJLQDLGHRORJLF]QHZVSyâ]DDQ JDīRZDQLHZUXFKZROQRğFLVâRZDLLQIRUPDFML&ROHPDQ FKRý QDOHī\QDGPLHQLýīHSU]HQLHVLHQLHLGHDâyZ)/266]ZLĆ]DQ\FK ]NRGHPRSURJUDPRZDQLDGRğZLDWDLQQ\FKG]LHâWZyUF]\FKQLHMHVW PRīOLZHZSURVW\VSRVyEEH]RNUHğORQ\FK]DVWU]HīHĕPLPRG]LDâDĕ SRGHMPRZDQ\FKSU]H]&UHDWLYH&RPPRQV+LOO&ROHPDQ

:ROQHG]LHâDNXOWXU\LRGSRZLHGQLHOLFHQFMHRSLVDQHVĆV]HU]HMSRGDGUHVHP KWWSIUHHGRPGHILQHGRUJ'HILQLWLRQ

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY

ŻYCIE SPOŁECZNOŚCI, STATUS I REPREZENTACJA SAMEGO SIEBIE 1DZHWMHğOLZJURQLHQDMDNW\ZQLHMV]\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZZHZV]\VWNLFK SURMHNWDFK]QDF]QDF]ċğýZ\ELHUDQDMHVWGRSHâQLHQLDIRUPDOQ\FK IXQNFMLNWyUHRSLVDQHEċGĆSyĩQLHM VWDQRZLĆRQLPQLHMV]Rğý5ROH ZVSRâHF]QRğFLSU]\]QDZDQHVĆZZ\QLNXJâRVRZDĕLZLHOXOXG]LZâDğ QLH]WHJRSRZRGXQLHGHF\GXMHVLċQD]JâDV]DQLHVZRLFKNDQG\GDWXU 1DWXUDOQHMHVWīHVNRURZV\VWHPDFKHJDOLWDUQ\FKLZ]DU]ĆG]DQLX XF]HVWQLF]ĆF\PQLHVĆWâXPLRQHVWUXNWXU\QLHIRUPDOQH*UXEHUL7ULF NHWW LEXGRZDQLHVWDWXVXXī\WNRZQLF\XFLHNDMĆVLċGRUyīQ\FK ğURGNyZUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDVLHELHLU\ZDOL]RZDQLDRVWDWXVZJUXSLH ZVSyâHG\WRUyZ/RNDOQHEXGRZDQLHVWDWXVX]DOHīQHMHVWRGGRVWRVR ZDQLDVLċGRG\VNXUVXRUJDQL]DFMLLWZRU]HQLDRGSRZLHGQHMQDUUDFML QDRNRâRVLHELH:VSRVyEW\SRZ\GODVSRâHF]QRğFLRRWZDUW\PPRGHOX ZVSyâSUDF\Xī\WNRZQLF\NRU]\VWDMĆ]PHWRGEXGRZDQLDLV\JQDOL]DFML VWDWXVXZVSRâHF]QRğFL]DSRPRFĆğURGNyZUR]SR]QDZDOQ\FKW\ONRGOD LQQ\FKHG\WRUyZ%LDQFKLLLQ 3RV]XNLZDQLHZ\īV]HMSR]\FML ZğUyGXī\WNRZQLNyZMHVWVLOQ\PPRW\ZDWRUHPZUR]ZLMDQLXVSRâHF] QRğFLZLUWXDOQ\FK/DPSHOL%KDOOD :DUWRUyZQLHīZVSRPQLHý īHZLNLSHG\ğFLSRGREQLHGRKDNHUyZDOHRGPLHQQLHQLīVWHUHRW\SRZL NRPSXWHURZLV]DOHĕF\²VĆQLH]Z\NOHWRZDU]\VF\&ROHPDQE :LNLSHG\ğFLRUJDQL]XMĆVLċZJUXS\IRUPDOQHLQLHIRUPDOQH2SUyF] JUXSZ\ZRG]ĆF\FKVLċ]ī\FLDSR]DSURMHNWHPGHÀQLRZDQ\FKVW\OHP ī\FLD]DSDWU\ZDQLDPLSROLW\F]Q\PLF]\KREE\LVWQLHMĆJUXS\]ZLĆ]DQH Z\âĆF]QLH]:LNLSHGLĆ1DMF]ċğFLHMVSRW\NDQ\PSRG]LDâHPLGHRORJLF] Q\PZğUyGZLNLSHG\VWyZMHVWSRG]LDâQDÅLQNOX]MRQLVWyZµW\FK NWyU]\ZLHU]ĆīH:LNLSHGLDMDNR]DVyEF\IURZ\QLHSRZLQQDE\ýRJUD QLF]DQDEDULHUDPLZâDğFLZ\PLGODW\SRZ\FKHQF\NORSHGLLLSRZLQQD RSLV\ZDýMDNQDMV]HUV]\]DNUHVWHPDWyZ LÅGHOHFMRQLVWyZµHG\WRUyZ NWyU]\XZDīDMĆīHGHF\]MHRHQF\NORSHG\F]QRğFLSRZLQQ\E\ýSRGHMPR ZDQH]WDNĆVDPĆVHOHNFMĆMDNZSU]\SDGNXWUDG\F\MQ\FKHQF\NORSHGLL LīHVHQVRZQ\SUyJZ\NOXF]DQLD]EċGQ\FKWUHğFLZSâ\ZDSR]\W\ZQLH QDMDNRğýSURMHNWX 2E\GZDSRGHMğFLDVĆZHZ]JOċGQHMUyZQRZDG]H LW\ONRMHGQR]QDF]QH]DGHNODURZDQLHV\PSDW\]RZDQLD]MHGQĆ]W\FK ÀOR]RÀLPRīHVNXWHF]QLH]DSU]HSDğFLýV]DQVHRVRE\GHNODUXMĆFHMLQ NOX]MRQL]POXEGHOHFMRQL]PQDVXNFHVZJâRVRZDQLX]DğGHNODUDFMH XPLDUNRZDQHQLHVWDQRZLĆSRGVWDZGRNU\W\NL²MDQSRVRELğFLHGH NODUXMċīHMHVWHPXPLDUNRZDQ\PLQNOX]MRQLVWĆ

45

46

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... *UXS\W\SRZHGOD:LNLSHGLLIRUPXMĆVLċQDRNRâRW\SRZ\FK]DGDĕ 'ODSU]\NâDGXF]ċğýZLNLSHG\VWyZGHNODUXMHMDNRVZRMHW\SRZH]DMċFLH Å]ZDOF]DQLHZDQGDOL]PXµOXEÅSDWURORZDQLHRVWDWQLFK]PLDQµVSHFMD OL]XMHVLċZVSUDZG]DQLXHG\FMLLQQ\FKSLV]ĆF\FKF]ċVWRNRQFHQWUXMĆF VLċQDHG\FMDFKXī\WNRZQLNyZDQRQLPRZ\FK'ODWHJRZâDğQLHZLHOX GRZFLSQLVLyZZLG]LMDNLFKZDQGDOL]P\VĆXVXZDQHZSU]HFLĆJXPLQXW F]\QDZHWVHNXQGRGZVWDZLHQLDGR:LNLSHGLLZLHOXZLNLSHG\VWyZ SU]HJOĆGDZV]\VWNLHRVWDWQLRGRNRQDQHZSURMHNFLH]PLDQ\LNRQFHQ WUXMHVLċV]F]HJyOQLHQDG]LDâDQLDFKQLH]DUHMHVWURZDQ\FKOXEğZLHīR ]DUHMHVWURZDQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZ=DSRPRFĆRSURJUDPRZDQLDZVSLH UDMĆFHJR]ZDOF]DQLHZDQGDOL]PyZF]\QQRğýWDQDELHUD]QDF]HQLDVSR âHF]QRğFLRZHJR*HLJHUL5LEHV ]DUyZQRMDNRHOHPHQWVSDMDMĆF\ JUXSċJG\īJċVWHVLHFLZ\QDJUDG]DMĆVSRâHF]QLHW\FKNWyU]\NDU]ĆRVRE\ QDUXV]DMĆFHQRUP\3LVNRUVNLL*RUEDWDL MDNLSRND]]UċF]QRğFL :LNLSHGLLZHOLPLQRZDQLXEâċGyZ ,VWQLHMĆRVRE\RSLHNXMĆFHVLċQRZ\PLHG\WRUDPLZLWDMĆFHLFKZSUR MHNFLHLZSURZDG]DMĆFHZğZLDW]DVDG:LNLSHGLL&]ċğýXī\WNRZQLNyZ VSHFMDOL]XMHVLċZRNUHğORQ\FKG]LHG]LQDFKZLHG]\LWZRU]\ZLNLSURMHNW\ RUD]SRUWDOHVNXSLDMĆFHJUXS\OXG]L]DLQWHUHVRZDQ\FKRNUHğORQ\P]D JDGQLHQLHPSU]\F]\P]DJDGQLHQLDFHFKXMĆVLċGXīĆUyīQRURGQRğFLĆ ²PRīHWRE\ýSLâNDQRīQDVRFMRORJLDJU\53*F]\NROHMQLFWZR :LNL SURMHNW\RGJU\ZDMĆ]QDF]ĆFĆUROċZJUXSRZDQLXXī\WNRZQLNyZRRNUHğ ORQHMVSHFMDOL]DFMLSR]ZDODMĆFQDXVWUXNWXUDOL]RZDQLHLNRRUG\QDFMċ SUDFUHGDNWRUVNLFK)RUWHLLQ 6SHFMDOL]DFMDZLNLSURMHNWyZ PRīHSU]\EUDýUyZQLHīIRUPċSLOQRZDQLDQLHNWyU\FKDVSHNWyZWHFK QLF]Q\FK:LNLSHGLLWDNLFKMDNWZRU]HQLHLQIRERNVyZSLVDQLHERWyZ GRRNUHğORQ\FK]DGDĕF]\SLOQRZDQLHNDWHJRU\]DFMLKDVHâ 2F]\ZLğFLHSRMDZLDMĆVLċWHīLQQHPQLHMRÀFMDOQHIRUP\VSHFMDOL ]DFML'ODSU]\NâDGXSHZQDOLF]EDXī\WNRZQLNyZUHJXODUQLHG\VNXWXMH QDG]DVDGDPLSURMHNWXZÅ.DZLDUHQFHµVZRLVW\PIRUXPG\VNXV\MQ\P SRğZLċFRQ\PSRV]F]HJyOQ\PDVSHNWRPUR]ZRMX:LNLSHGLL,QQLXF]HVW QLF]ĆZG\VNXVMDFKQDGHQF\NORSHG\F]QRğFLĆDUW\NXâyZ0LPRīHGOD ZLHOXWHPDWyZLVWQLHMĆNU\WHULDHQF\NORSHG\F]QRğFL]DZV]HVĆSU]\ SDGNLJUDQLF]QHJG]LHDUJXPHQWDFMD]DSR]RVWDZLHQLHPXVXQLċFLHP DOERQDSUDZĆDUW\NXâXEĆGĩWHīSRâĆF]HQLDJR]LQQ\PKDVâHPPXVLE\ý SU]HP\ğODQD'HF\GRZDQLHRW\PNWyUHDUW\NXâ\PDMĆE\ýZ\HNVSRQR ZDQHQDJâyZQHMVWURQLH:LNLSHGLLXDNWXDOQLDQHMFRG]LHQQLHUyZQLHī Z\PDJD]DDQJDīRZDQLDF]ċğFLVSRâHF]QRğFLVNâDGDMĆFHMVLċ]ZLHOX UHJXODUQLHHG\WXMĆF\FKOXG]L3U]\]QDQLHKDVâXVWDWXVXÅPHGDORZHJRµ

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY MHVWU]DGNLPZ\UyīQLHQLHP²DNWXDOQLHZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLMHVW PQLHMQLīWU]\W\VLĆFHKDVHâRW\PVWDWXVLHFRR]QDF]DīHGRZ\Uyī QLHQLDNZDOLÀNXMHVLċPQLHMQLīMHGQDW\VLċF]QDZSLVyZ 3RGREQLH SU]\]QDQLHVWDWXVXÅGREUHJRDUW\NXâXµRGE\ZDVLċSRDSUREDFLHVSR âHF]QRğFLJG]LHZG\VNXVMLUyZQLHīF]ċVWRVSHFMDOL]XMĆVLċRNUHğORQH RVRE\:DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLMHVWQLHFDâHW\VLċF\ÅGREU\FKDUW\NXâyZµ SU]\F]\PDUW\NXâ\ÅPHGDORZHµQLHVĆMXī]DOLF]DQHGRJURQDÅGR EU\FKµ 1DGDQLHWDNLHJRVWDWXVXKDVâXQLHMHVWQLHRGZRâDOQH²SUDZLH W\VLĆFKDVHâVWUDFLâRVWDWXVÅPHGDORZ\FKµ]XZDJLQDQLHVSHâQLDQLH DNWXDOQ\FKNU\WHULyZSU]\MċW\FKZSURMHNFLH 5yīQRURGQRğýG]LDâDĕLREV]DUyZZNWyU\FKGRFKRG]LGRLQWHUDNFML PLċG]\ZLNLSHG\VWDPLMHVWZ\VRND']LċNLWHPXNDīGHPXXī\WNRZQL NRZLWZRU]\VLċPRīOLZRğýSUDF\ZG]LHG]LQLHZNWyUHMPRīQDZ\NRU]\ VWDýMHJRXPLHMċWQRğFLDOHWHīGRFKRG]LGRUR]SUDV]DQLDNRQFHQWUDFML ZâDG]\RUJDQL]DF\MQHM,VWQLHMĆHG\WRU]\NWyU\FKJâyZQ\PVHQVHP E\FLDZLNLSHG\VWĆMHVWHG\WRZDQLHKDVHâOHF]SRZDīDQLHZSURMHNFLH EXGRZDQHMHVWQDLQWHUDNFMDFK]LQQ\PLLXF]HVWQLFWZLHZHZVSyOQ\FK G\VNXVMDFK)RUWHL%UXFNPDQ DSRGREQLHGRSR]\FMLZLQQ\FK VSRâHF]QRğFLDFKXī\WNRZQLF\PXV]ĆZ\ND]DýQLHW\ONRīHSRWUDÀĆ HG\WRZDýDOHWHīīHQDRGSRZLHGQLPSR]LRPLHZFKRG]ĆZLQWHUDNFMċ ]LQQ\PL:VSyâHG\WRZDQLH:LNLSHGLLSROHJDSU]HFLHīQDSURFHVLH QHJRFMRZDQLDLNRQVWUXRZDQLDZSLVyZXMDZQLDMĆF\FKZV]\VWNLH]QD F]ĆFHSXQNW\ZLG]HQLD.DQHLLQ ZâĆF]\ZV]\ZWRGRSXV]F]DO QRğýRNUHğORQ\FKĩUyGHâMDNWHīUyZQRZDīHQLHWHJRFRVWDQRZLGDQH QHXWUDOQHDFRQLHZLċFQDZHW]DGDQLDZ\GDMĆFHVLċPLHýFKDUDNWHU LQG\ZLGXDOQ\FKDUDNWHU\]XMĆVLċSHZQ\PLDVSHNWDPLZVSyâSUDF\ 3RQRZQLHQDOHī\GRGDýīHZLNLSHG\ğFLVĆWRZDU]\VF\1DZHWPLPR ]DSLVyZZSRGVWDZRZ\FK]DVDGDFKRW\PīH:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWVLHFLĆ VSRâHF]QRğFLRZĆ]DğZLċNV]RğýZ\PLDQ]GDĕMHVW]ZLĆ]DQD]HQF\NOR SHGLĆLMHMUHGDJRZDQLHPLVWQLHMHV]HURNLZDFKODU]SURGXNFMLNXOWX URZHMSU]H]QDF]RQHMZ\âĆF]QLHGODLQQ\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZ0RīQDWHī RGQDOHĩýZLHOHKXPRU\VW\F]Q\FKHVHMyZLīDUWyZUR]XPLDQ\FKW\ONR SU]H]ZWDMHPQLF]RQ\FKZ\PLHQLDQ\FKZğUyGF]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFL F]\WHOQLF\FKFĆF\SR]QDýWċF]ċğýZLNLSHG\MQHJRIRONORUXSRZLQQL

:DUWRQDGPLHQLýīHZJURQLHZ\UyīQLRQ\FKKDVHâVĆRSLV\SRZRMHQQHMKLVWRULL 3ROVNL>>HQ+LVWRU\RI3RODQG² @@ RUD]SROVNLHMNXOWXU\]RNUHVX,,ZRMQ\ ğZLDWRZHM>>HQ3ROLVKFXOWXUHGXULQJ:RUOG:DU,,@@

47

48

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]DSR]QDýVLċ]]DZDUWRğFLĆNDWHJRULL>>HQ&DWHJRU\:LNLSHGLDKXPRU@@ >>.DWHJRULD+XPRUZLNLSHG\VWyZ@@ :LċNV]RğýZLNLSHG\VWyZQLHGâXJRSR]GRE\FLXSLHUZV]\FKV]OLIyZ ZSURMHNFLHWZRU]\VZRMĆVWURQċXī\WNRZQLNDVâXīĆFĆDXWRSUH]HQWDFML 3RVLDGDQLHWDNLHMVWURQ\PDLVWRWQHLPSOLNDFMHSUDNW\F]QH]XZDJLQD WRīHOLQNLGRQLHLVWQLHMĆF\FKVWURQNRORURZDQHVĆQDF]HUZRQRDRVRE\ ZVSyâRGSRZLHG]LDOQH]DSRZVWDQLHNDīGHMVWURQ\Z\PLHQLRQHVĆZMHM KLVWRULLLQDOLğFLHRVWDWQLFK]PLDQHG\FMH]DUHMHVWURZDQ\FKXī\WNRZ QLNyZQLHGRNRĕFDREH]QDQ\FK]HVSRâHF]QRğFLĆQDW\FKPLDVWVLċZ\ UyīQLDMĆLF]ċVWRXZDīDVLċMH]DZ\PDJDMĆFHXZDJL1LHSRVLDGDQLHVWURQ\ Xī\WNRZQLNDVNXWNXMHQDW\FKPLDVWRZ\PE\FLHPSRVWU]HJDQ\PZUROL QRZLFMXV]DOXEHNVWUDZDJDQFNLHJRUHGDNWRUD-HGQĆ]SLHUZV]\FKOHNFML NWyU\FKXG]LHOD:LNLSHGLDMHVWZLċFNRQLHF]QRğýVWZRU]HQLDRVRELVWHM VWURQ\MDNWHīVWURQ\G\VNXVMLRVRELVWHMVWURQ\NRQWDNWRZHM ,VWQLHMHZLHOH]DVDGRUJDQL]DFMLVWURQ\Xī\WNRZQLND1DMF]ċğFLHM Xī\WNRZQLF\RSLVXMĆVLHELHLVZRMH]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDF]DVDPLZVSRPLQD MĆFWHīDVSHNW\]DZRGRZH&]ċVWRNRU]\VWDMĆ]W]ZXVHUERNVyZSU]HG VWDZLDMĆF\FKJUDÀF]QLHQLHNWyUHZâDğFLZRğFLXī\WNRZQLND3RODWHVĆ ]UyīQLFRZDQHLPRJĆRGQRVLýVLċGRUyOSHâQLRQ\FKZ:LNLSHGLLMċ]\NyZ ]DLQWHUHVRZDĕF]\SRJOĆGyZSROLW\F]Q\FKLUHOLJLMQ\FKNRSLDPRMH JR]HVWDZXXVHUERNVyZ]QDMGXMHVLċSRSUDZHMVWURQLH &]ċğý]QLFK MHVWQDZHWīDUWREOLZD/LF]EDXVHUERNVyZZ\ğZLHWODQ\FKQDVWURQLHMHVW UyīQRURGQD²QLHNWyU]\ZLNLSHG\ğFLZRJyOHLFKQLHVWRVXMĆLQQL]Dğ PDMĆLFKSRQDGVHWNċZâĆF]\ZV]\ZWRLQIRUPDFMHRÅSDWURQXVDFKµ ]HğZLDWD+DUU\·HJR3RWWHUD XOXELRQ\FKVHULDODFKWHOHZL]\MQ\FKF]\ QDZ\NDFKī\ZLHQLRZ\FK*G\E\SUyERZDýWXZ\]QDF]\ýMDNĆNROZLHN SUDZLGâRZRğýWRXī\WNRZQLF\GHNODUXMĆF\UDG\NDOQHSRJOĆG\OXE V\PSDW\]XMĆF\]HVNUDMQ\PLSUDNW\NDPLPDMĆPQLHMV]HV]DQVHQD SRSDUFLHZMDNLPNROZLHNJâRVRZDQLX=GDU]DâRVLċīHGHNODUDFMHSROL W\F]QHOXEZ\]QDQLRZHZ\VWDUF]Dâ\E\VNXWHF]QLHXğPLHUFLýZQLRVHN RQDGDQLHXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDF\MQ\FKJG\īSU]HFLZQLF\XZDīDOL īHQDZHWJG\E\NDQG\GDWE\âZVWDQLHRGâRī\ýVZRMHV\PSDWLHQDERN SU]\FRG]LHQQHMSUDF\LQQLXī\WNRZQLF\PRJOLE\EâċGQLH]DNâDGDýīH ]RVWDOLQLHZâDğFLZLHSRWUDNWRZDQL]XZDJLQDSU]HNRQDQLDRZHM

3HâQDOLVWDXVHUERNVyZGRVWċSQ\FKGODUHGDNWRUyZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLGR VWċSQDMHVWSRGDGUHVHPKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD8VHUER[HV*DOOHU\ ZSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]Dğ²KWWSSOZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD8VHUERNV\

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY RVRE\'RGDWNRZRNRU]\VWD QLH]SU]HVDGQLHGXīHMOLF]E\ XVHUERNVyZQDVWURQLHXī\WNRZ QLND MHVW PQLHM SRSXODUQH ZğUyGGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKZLNLSH G\VWyZ 1LHLVWQLHMHVWDQGDUGRZ\ ]HVWDZXVHUERNVyZOHF]ZLHOX ZLNLSHG\VWyZRJâDV]DZWHQ VSRVyESRVLDGDQLHZGDQ\PSUR MHNFLHOXESR]DQLPRNUHğOR Q\FKXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUD WRUELXURNUDWDLWGZV]\VWNLH RSLVDQHZNROHMQ\PUR]G]LDOH 1LHNWyU]\RWZDUFLHGHNODUXMĆ WHīIDNWQLHE\FLDDGPLQLVWUD WRUHPFKRýF]DVHPMHVWWRUyZ QR]QDF]QH]QDU]HNDQLHPQD DNWXDOQ\REUD]VSRâHF]QRğFL -HGQ\P]QDMF]ċğFLHMVWRVRZD Q\FKERNVyZMHVWW]ZZLHīD %DEHO3R]ZDODRQDXī\WNRZ QLNRPQDSRZLDGRPLHQLHLQ Q\FKRVZRLFKXPLHMċWQRğFLDFK Mċ]\NRZ\FKZZLċNV]RğFLSUR MHNWyZZVNDOLRGEUDNPRī OLZRğFL NRPXQLNRZDQLD VLċ ZGDQ\PMċ]\NX GRSR]LRP EOLVNLURGRZLWHPXXī\WNRZQL NRZL L1Mċ]\NRMF]\VW\ :LHīD %DEHORUD]GHNODUDFMHSHâQLR Q\FKZSURMHNFLHIXQNFMLLQDGD Q\FKXSUDZQLHĕVĆW\SRZHGOD ZLċNV]RğFLSURMHNWyZ:LNLPH GLD3RGREQLHQLHPDOXQLZHU VDOQDMHVWPRīOLZRğýSRGDQLD SâFL²ZXVHUERNVLHDOERRVWDW QLRZXVWDZLHQLDFKNRQWDXī\W NRZQLNDFRGRGDWNRZRXPRī

49

50

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... OLZLDRGPLHQQHZ\V\âDQLHDXWRPDW\F]Q\FKZLDGRPRğFLGRNRELHW LPċīF]\]Q:LċNV]RğýXī\WNRZQLNyZQLHNRU]\VWDMHGQDN]WHMRSFML 3R]RVWDâHXVHUERNV\WZRU]RQH VĆVSRQWDQLF]QLHZSRV]F]HJyO Q\FKSURMHNWDFKMHğOLQDGHMG]LH WDNDSRWU]HEDDZ]DVLċJXUċ NLQLHPDQLNRJRNWRSRPyJâE\ ZW\P]DGDQLX1LHMHVWWRFLċī NLHZ\]ZDQLHOHF]Z\PDJDSR QDGSRGVWDZRZHJR]UR]XPLHQLD NRGXXī\ZDQHJRZ:LNLSHGLL LNRQVWUXNFMLVWURQSURMHNWX² QDZHWZQDMSURVWV]HMZHUVMLXVHU ERNVXSRZLQQDSRMDZLýVLċRGSR ZLHGQLRSU]HVNDORZDQDJUDÀND DMHJRZVWDZLHQLHQDVWURQċSR ZLQQRDXWRPDW\F]QLHJHQHUR ZDýZSLVZRGSRZLHGQLHMNDWHJRULLJUXSXMĆFHMXī\WNRZQLNyZRW\FK VDP\FK]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDFKF]\SRJOĆGDFK:SROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLVWZRU]\ âHPNLONDQDğFLHXVHUERNVyZDJG\GRâĆF]\âHPGRJURQDHG\WRUyZZHUVML DQJLHOVNLHM]DXZDī\âHPīHEUDNRZDâRWDPLQIRUPDFMLRXī\WNRZQLNDFK ýZLF]ĆF\FKNDUDWHLWDHNZRQGRZLċFSU]\JRWRZDâHPRE\GZDXVHUERNV\ :LċNV]RğýXī\WNRZQLNyZUR]ZLMDVZRMHVWURQ\RVRELVWHVWRSQLRZR REVHUZXMĆFEDUG]LHMGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKHG\WRUyZ.RSLRZDQLHIUDJPHQ WyZNRGXLXF]HQLHVLċWHFKQLF]Q\FKV]WXF]HNSU]H]LPLWDFMċWRV]HURNR SU]\MċWDQRUPDRGJU\ZDMĆFD]QDF]ĆFĆUROċZHQNXOWXUDFMLG]LDâDMĆFD SRGREQLHGRSRGJOĆGDQLDHG\FMLLQQ\FKRVyEZDUW\NXâDFK :LHOXEDUG]LHM]DDZDQVRZDQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZEXGXMHVZRMH VWURQ\RVRELVWHRSLHUDMĆFVLċQD]DDZDQVRZDQHMVNâDGQLQSGRGDMĆF RSâ\ZDMĆFHHOHPHQW\DQLPDFMH]DJQLHīGīDMĆFQDVWURQLHHOHPHQW\ ]LQQ\FKGRNXPHQWyZDXWRPDW\]XMĆFDUFKLZL]RZDQLHZLDGRPRğFL &KZDOHQLHVLċVZRLPLXPLHMċWQRğFLDPL]GHF\GRZDQLHRGJU\ZDZDīQĆ UROċLVâXī\SU]HGVWDZLDQLXZâDğFLFLHODWDNLHMVWURQ\MDNRRVRE\GRğZLDG F]RQHMEXGRZDQLXMHMUHSXWDFML.LONDUD]\QDZHWE\âHP]DS\WDQ\ RSURVWĆV]WXF]NċWHFKQLF]QĆNWyUĆZ\NRU]\VWDâHPQDVZRMHMVWURQLH Xī\WNRZQLNDDNWyUDSROHJDâDQDZVWDZLHQLXOLF]QLNDZ\ğZLHWODMĆFHJR OLF]EċVHNXQGRGPRMHJRQDURG]HQLDDNWXDOL]RZDQHJRSU]\NDīG\P ZF]\WDQLXVWURQ\%\âHPRWRS\WDQ\PLċG]\LQQ\PLGODWHJRīHNRG

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY RGSRZLHG]LDOQ\]DOLF]QLNWUXGQRMHVWVNRSLRZDýEH]SRSUDZHNLNRQ VXOWDFML²MHVWZQLPXNU\WDPRMDGDWDXURG]HQLD 6WURQDXī\WNRZQLNDWRUyZQLHīPLHMVFHSUH]HQWRZDQLDRVLĆJQLċý LZ\UyīQLHĕ]DSUDFċGOD:LNLSHGLL2SUyF]]QDF]QHJRZNâDGXZSRZVWD QLHOXEUR]EXGRZċPHGDORZ\FKLGREU\FKDUW\NXâyZLVWQLHMHFDâ\V]HUHJ RVLĆJQLċýNWyU\PLPRīQDVLċSRFKZDOLý6ĆRQHUDF]HM]GH]RUJDQL]R ZDQHQLīSRXNâDGDQHLZNDīG\PSURMHNFLHZ\JOĆGDMĆLQDF]HM(G\WR U]\DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLF]ċVWRNRU]\VWDMĆ]ÅQDJUyG]D]DVâXJLµ >>HQ:36HUYLFHDZDUGV@@ NWyUHQDOHīQHVĆXī\WNRZQLNRPZ]DOHī QRğFLRGLORğFLGRNRQDQ\FKHG\FMLLVWDīXZSURMHNFLH1DJURGDZ\VWċSXMH ZRGVâRQDFK]NWyU\FKQDMZ\īV]D9DQJXDUG(GLWRU(G\WRU6WUDī\ 3U]HGQLHM Z\PDJDRGSU]\V]â\FKMHM]GRE\ZFyZGRNRQDQLDW\VLċF\ HG\FMLLVSċG]HQLDODWQDHG\WRZDQLX:LNLSHGLL

Odznaka Vanguard Editor ĨUyGâRKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL)LOH(GLWRUBBODSLVBPDWWHUBLLLMSJ

.ROHMQHQDJURG\PDMĆGRğýSRPSDW\F]QHQD]Z\6ĆWRQS>HQ:LNLSHGLD%DUQVWDUV@@>>:LNLSHGLD 2G]QDF]HQLD:LNLSHGLL@@3U]\]QDZDQHVĆ]DRNUHğORQHRVLĆJQLċFLD ]Z\NOHQDOHīĆFHGRNDWHJRULLGâXJRIDORZHMZ\ELWQHMVâXīE\GOD:LNL SHGLL1LHPDīDGQ\FK]DVDGLFKWZRU]HQLDJG\īNWRNROZLHNF]XMĆF īHMDNLHğRG]QDF]HQLHQLHLVWQLHMHMHVWZVWDQLHMHVWZRU]\ýOHF]F]ċğý MHVWEDUG]LHMSRSXODUQDRGSR]RVWDâ\FK3U]\NâDGHPMHVW:RUNLQJ :LNLSHGLDQ·V%DUQVWDU2G]QDF]HQLHGOD3U]RGRZQLNDSUDF\ NWyUH ÅPRīQDSU]\]QDýRVRERPQLH]âRPQLHLZLHF]QLHSUDFXMĆF\PQDGEDU G]LHMSUDFRFKâRQQ\PLLSRZWDU]DOQ\PL]DGDQLDPLµF]\:LQH%DUQVWDU 2G]QDF]HQLH(QRORJD NWyUHSRZVWDâRGODXKRQRURZDQLDRVyERZ\ELW Q\FK]DVâXJDFKGODKDVHâGRW\F]ĆF\FKZLQ2G]QDF]HQLDPRīQDSU]\]QD ZDýLQQ\PHG\WRURPF]HJRQLHUHJXOXMĆīDGQHQRUP\SR]DRF]\ZLVWĆ QRUPĆVSRâHF]QĆNWyUDPyZLE\QLHSU]\]QDZDýRG]QDF]HĕVRELHVD P\P1DZHWMHGQDNWDNLH]DFKRZDQLHQLHMHVWEH]SRğUHGQLR]DND]DQH 1DJURG\LQQHJRW\SXWRRVRELVWHRG]QDF]HQLDVWZRU]RQHSU]H]Xī\W NRZQLNyZ²>>HQ:33HUVRQDOXVHUDZDUGV@@NWyUHPRīQDSU]\]QDý ]DGRZROQHRVLĆJQLċFLHSRGDQHSU]H]VSRQWDQLF]QHJRWZyUFċRG]QDF]H QLD3U]\NâDG\WDNLFKQDJUyGWRRG]QDF]HQLDERīRQDURG]HQLRZH7KH 0RXOG\6DQGZLFK$ZDUGQDJURGDVSOHğQLDâHMNDQDSNL ]DQLH]âRPQĆ SUDFċQDU]HF]SRSUDZLDQLD:LNLSHGLL36,DZDUG1DJURGD3VL GOD XSU]HMP\FKLSRPRFQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZMDNREâRJRVâDZLHĕVWZR]GURZLD SV\FKLF]QHJRF]\7KHGLVFREDOORINQRZOHGJHDZDUG'\VNRWHNRZD NXODPĆGURğFL PDMĆFD]DğZLDGF]DýīHMHMSRVLDGDF]VWDQRZLğPLH WDQNċZVSyâWZyUFyZ:LNLSHGLLLSRPDJDMHMQLJG\VLċQLH]DWU]\P\ ZDýSRGREQLHGRU]HF]RQHMNUċFĆFHMVLċNXOL,VWQLHMĆLQQHQDJURG\ ²>>HQ:32WKHUDZDUGV@@SU]\]QDZDQH]DRNUHğORQHSRMHG\QF]H G]LDâDQLD:ğUyGQLFK]QDMGXMHVLċ7KH=HQ*DUGHQ$ZDUGIRU,QÀQLWH 3DWLHQFH1DJURGDRJURGX=HQ]DQLHVNRĕF]RQĆFLHUSOLZRğý PRīH MĆRWU]\PDýÅHG\WRUNWyU\Z]QRMXLZU]DZLHZ\ND]DâQLHE\ZDâĆ FLHUSOLZRğýµ 3U]\ZRâXMĆFSRQRZQLHSXEOLNDFMċ(GLWRU6XUYH\5HSRUW]NZLHWQLD ZLG]LP\īHX]QDQLHZJUXSLHZVSyâHG\WRUyZMHVWGODZLHOXZLNL SHG\VWyZEDUG]RLVWRWQHÅ2G]QDF]HQLDLQDJURG\SU]\]QDZDQHSU]H] Xī\WNRZQLNyZVĆEDUG]RZDīQ\PHOHPHQWHPIXQNFMRQRZDQLDVSR âHF]QRğFL2WU]\P\ZDQLHNRPSOHPHQWyZVWDQRZLNROHMQ\PRW\ZDWRU GRG]LDâDQLD(G\WRU]\FHQLĆVRELHX]QDQLHZRF]DFKLQQ\FKUHGDNWRUyZ RZLHOHZ\īHMQLīLQQHRVLĆJQLċFLDWDNLHMDNQDSU]\NâDGZ\UyīQLHQLH

WIKIPEDIA W TELEGRAFICZNYM SKRÓCIE: LICZBY, ZASADY, EDYTORZY QDSLVDQ\FKSU]H]VLHELHDUW\NXâyZVWDWXVHPPHGDORZ\FKF]\XPLHV] F]DQLHDUW\NXâyZLFKDXWRUVWZDQDJâyZQHMVWURQLHµ:LNLPHGLD)RXQ GDWLRQ %DGDQLDHNVSHU\PHQWDOQHSRND]XMĆWHīīHRWU]\ PDQLHRG]QDF]HQLDZ\ZRâXMH]Z\īNċSURGXNW\ZQRğFL5HVWLYRLYDQ GH5LMW SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPMHğOLGRVWDâRVLċMHZORVRZ\VSRVyE +LOOLLQ :]DMHPQRğýZRG]QDF]DQLXUHGDNWRUyZQLHMHVWQRUPĆMDN]GDU]D VLċZLQQ\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXZVSyâSUDF\6WHZDUW OHF]QLHMHVWWHīQLF]\PQLH]Z\Nâ\P3RGREQLHMDNPDWRPLHMVFH ZSU]\SDGNXLQQ\FKQDJUyGLVWQLHMĆXī\WNRZQLF\EDUG]LHMMHFHQLĆF\ WZRU]ĆF\QLHIRUPDOQHNOLNLZ\PLHQLDMĆFZJUXSLHXF]HVWQLNyZRG]QD F]HQLDLSRSUDZLDMĆFVZyMZL]HUXQHN7DNLSURFHVFKRýQLHMHVWU]DG NRğFLĆQLHMHVWWHīMHGQDN]DFKRZDQLHPW\SRZ\PLRSUyF]V\WXDFML ZNWyU\FKXī\WNRZQLF\RRF]\ZLVW\FKPRW\ZDFKG]LDâDQLD]GHF\GR ZDQHSRVWDZ\SROLW\F]QHF]\Z\]QDQLRZH Z]PDFQLDMĆZ]DMHPQLH VZRMHZL]HUXQNLE\XFKRG]Lý]DOHSV]\FKZRF]DFKJURQDUHGDNWRUyZ² PDUDF]HMSR]\W\ZQ\Z\GĩZLċNQDZHWMHğOLQDJURG\VĆSU]\]QDZDQH RVRERPRQLH]DELHJDMĆF\PDQLHW\PNWyU\PIDNW\F]QLHVLċQDOHīĆ 3U]\]QDZDQLHRG]QDF]HĕWRZDīQ\U\WXDâJG\īRVRE\MHSU]\]QD MĆFHWHī]RVWDMĆ]DXZDīRQH0DXVV 0RīHZâDğQLHGODWHJR ZHZU]HğQLX-LPER:DOHVPLDâSRQDGRG]QDF]HĕLLQQ\FKQD JUyG3U]\]QDZDQLHRG]QDF]HĕMHVWXZDīDQH]DG]LDâDQLHEH]VSU]HF] QLHSR]\W\ZQHQLHPD]GHÀQLRZDQ\FKRJUDQLF]HĕLSR]EDZLRQHMHVW NRV]WyZMHVWZLċFVSRâHF]QLHDNFHSWRZDQ\PPHFKDQL]PHPX]QDQLD SUDF\LQQHJRZLNLSHG\VW\2GJU\ZDRQRGRGDWNRZR]QDF]ĆFĆUROċ ZSUDF\QDGLGHQW\ÀNRZDQLHPVLċ]JUXSĆ$VKWRQ 'RGDWNRZR MDVQHMHVWīHZSURMHNFLHWDNUR]OHJâ\PMDNDQJLHOVND:LNLSHGLDQLH GDVLċ]QDýZV]\VWNLFK6\JQDOL]RZDQLHVSRâHF]QHLEXGRZDQLHZL]H UXQNXSU]H]VWURQċXī\WNRZQLNDRGJU\ZDMĆ]QDF]ĆFĆUROċZXVWDQDZLD QLXSR]\FMLVSRâHF]QHMZSURMHNFLHRRWZDUW\PXF]HVWQLFWZLH6WHZDUW SRGREQLHMDNSU]\]QDZDQLHRG]QDF]HĕRUD]LFKRWU]\P\ZDQLH %\ýPRīHZâDğQLHGODWHJRRWU]\PDQLHRG]QDF]HQLD]ZLċNV]DV]DQVċ QDSU]\]QDQLHGDQHPXXī\WNRZQLNRZLNROHMQHJRZSU]\V]âRğFL5HVWLYR LYDQGH5LMW JG\īZZ\QLNXSU]\]QDQLDRG]QDF]HQLDGRFKRG]L GR]PQLHMV]HQLDU\]\NDQDJURG]HQLDNRJRğNWRPRīHVLċRND]DýQLHJR G]LHQZ\UyīQLHQLD1DâDPDFK:LNLSHGLLQLHW\ONRZNâDGZHQF\NORSHGLċ

=REKWWSVHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL8VHU-LPERB:DOHV%DUQVWDUV

53

54

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... OHF]UyZQLHīQDJURG\LRG]QDF]HQLDZ\ZRâXMĆSR]\W\ZQHHIHNW\VSR âHF]QRğFLRZHNWyUHZLQQ\FKJUXSDFKRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXZVSyâSUDF\ PRJâ\QLH]RVWDýGRFHQLRQHZWDNV]HURNLP]DNUHVLH.ULSOHDQLLQ 3ROLW\NDSRVWU]HJDQDMDNRV]WXNDEXGRZDQLDUHSXWDFMLRGJU\ZD ZDīQĆUROċZ:LNLSHGLLSRGREQLHGRVSRâHF]QRğFLZVSyâNRQVXPSFML %RWVPDQL5RJHUV 0LPRLVWQLHQLDWDNLHJRQLHIRUPDOQHJRV\VWHPXEXGRZDQLDLRGQDM G\ZDQLDVWDWXVXZVSRâHF]QRğFLMDNWHīSUDFQDGZâDVQ\PZL]HUXQNLHP :LNLSHGLDPDZDFKODU]IRUPDOQ\FKUyO]RUJDQL]RZDQ\FKZV\VWHP SDUDKLHUDUFKLF]Q\RUD]DQW\KLHUDUFKLF]Q\6ĆRQHWHPDWHPNROHMQHJR UR]G]LDâX


$QGUHZ.HHQNU\W\NXMĆFQLHHNVSHUFNLFKDUDNWHU:LNLSHGLLSRGNUHğOD īHNXOWDPDWRUDSURZDG]LGRÅPQLHMV]HMLORğFLNXOWXU\PQLHMU]HWHO Q\FKZLDGRPRğFLLFKDRVXQLHSRWU]HEQHMLQIRUPDFMLµ 1LH MHVWPRīOLZHSRGMċFLHG\VNXVMLQDGWDNPJOLVW\PLLQLHXJUXQWRZDQ\PL DF]DVDPLVSU]HF]Q\PL]HVWDQHPIDNW\F]Q\P VWZLHUG]HQLDPLOHF] MHGQRMHVWSHZQHQLHHNVSHUFNLDF]DVDPLWHīQLH]DZRGRZ\ZVHQVLH IRUPDOQLHFHUW\ÀNRZDQHMZLHG]\ FKDUDNWHU:LNLSHGLLMHVWMHM]QDNLHP UR]SR]QDZF]\P0RīOLZRğýVWZRU]HQLDPHU\WRNUDW\F]QHJRVWDWXVX LSR]\FMLZRUJDQL]DFMLZVSRâHF]QRğFLJHQHUXMĆFHMZLHG]ċSU]H]HG\FMH SRFKRG]ĆFHRGQLHHNVSHUWyZMHVWFHQWUDOQDGODPRGHOXG]LDâDQLD:LNL SHGLLPRīHWHīE\ýJâyZQ\PPDJQHVHPSU]\FLĆJDMĆF\PDXWRUyZMDN WRVLċG]LHMHZLQQ\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKZLUWXDOQ\FK.HOW\/DPSHO L%KDOOD 2SUyF]LVWQLHQLDQLHIRUPDOQ\FKSR]\FMLZVSRâHF]QRğFL VSRVRE\SU]\]QDZDQLDZ:LNLSHGLLUyORUJDQL]DF\MQ\FK]ZLĆ]DQ\FK ]RNUHğORQ\PLXSUDZQLHQLDPL UyīQLĆVLċRGPRGHOLSU]\MċW\FKZWUDG\ F\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMDFKZâĆF]QLH]W\PLNWyUHG]LDâDMĆ]JRGQLH]]DVDGDPL ]DU]ĆG]DQLDSDUW\F\SDF\MQHJR*UHHQZRRGLLQ.LP 6SRâHF]QRğFLSURMHNWyZRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\F]ċVWREXGRZDQHVĆ QDSâDVNLFKVWUXNWXUDFKSR]LRP\FKLUR]SURV]RQHMNRRUG\QDFML%HQ NOHU SRGREQLHGRNXOWXU]ELHUDFNRâRZLHFNLFK'RGDWNRZRVĆ ]Z\NOHRZLHOHPQLHM]KLHUDUFKL]RZDQHQLīRUJDQL]DFMHWUDG\F\MQH LZRZLHOHPQLHMV]\PVWRSQLX]DOHīQHRGVIRUPDOL]RZDQHMZâDG]\

56

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 3RZHOO%DUOH\L.XQGD6NROLN 0RīQDQDZHWWZLHU G]LýīHWZRU]ĆRQHQRZH]MDZLVNDLIRUP\]DU]ĆG]DQLDED]XMĆFQD PRGHOXFKDRW\F]QHJRLZLHF]QLH]PLHQLDMĆFHJRVLċED]DUX5D\PRQG 'HPLOL/HFRFT6NROLNL7RPF]\N SR]EDZLRQHJR Z\UDĩQHJRFHQWUXPNRRUG\QDFML2GQRV]ĆFHVXNFHV\SURMHNW\LQWHU QHWRZHED]XMĆFHQDZVSyâSUDF\PXV]ĆSROHJDýQLHW\ONRQDWHFKQLFH OHF]WDNīHQDXNU\W\FKRUD]ZLGRF]Q\FK]DVDGDFKLURODFKNXOWXURZ\FK 2UOLNRZVNL+HPHWVEHUJHUL5HLQKDUGW &KRýF]ċğýSURMHNWyZRSHQVRXUFHPRīHVNRU]\VWDý]MDVQR]GHÀQLR ZDQHMKLHUDUFKLL&URZVWRQL+RZLVRQ :LNLSHGLDRSDUWDMHVWQD VSRQWDQLF]Q\PSURZDG]RQ\PZWU\ELHDGKRFÅSRG]LDOHSUDF\ZNWy U\POXG]LSU]\FLĆJDWDSUDFDNWyUDLPVSUDZLDSU]\MHPQRğýOHF]SU]\ QLHZLHONLPW\ONRXG]LDOHKLHUDUFKLLµ$\HUVLLQ LQDMF]ċğFLHM RSLVXMHVLċMĆMDNRDKLHUDUFKLF]QĆ%UXQV 2GPLHQQLHMHGQDN QLīZSU]\SDGNXSURMHNWyZ)/266NWyUHSR]ZDODMĆXī\WNRZQLNRP QDEXGRZDQLHX]QDQLDZ]QDF]HQLXSURIHVMRQDOQ\PLHNVSHUFNLP /DNKDQLL:ROI9RQ+LSSHOL9RQ.URJK īDGQH]G]LDâDĕ LUyOZ:LNLSHGLLQLHRIHUXMHZLċNV]RğFLHG\WXMĆF\FKSU]HZDJLNWyUĆ GDâRE\VLċZ\NRU]\VWDýZNDULHU]H]DZRGRZHM3URJUDPLğFLZğURGR ZLVNDFKRSHQVRXUFHF]ċVWRGRğZLDGF]DMĆ]HVWURQ\NROHJyZSRIDFKX SU]\QDMPQLHMQLHZLHONLHJRX]QDQLD]DZRGRZHJROXEPRJĆ]JURPD G]RQHGRğZLDGF]HQLHZSLVDýGRFXUULFXOXPYLWDHSUDZLHQLJG\QLH MHVWWRMHGQDNZ\NRQDOQHGODHG\WRUyZLIXQNFMRQDULXV]\:LNLSHGLL :W\PSURMHNFLHRGPLHQQLHQLīZSU]\SDGNXSURMHNWyZRSURJUDPRZD QLDRSHQVRXUFHOHF]SRGREQLHGRJLHURQOLQHW\SX7KH:RUOGRI:DUFUDIW F]\7LELL X]QDQLHLÅNDULHUċµEXGXMHVLċJâyZQLHZHZQĆWU]VSRâHF] QRğFLLGODQLHMQLH]DğGODğZLDWD]HZQċWU]QHJR ,VWQLHMĆMHGQDNSHZQHSRGRELHĕVWZDPLċG]\:LNLSHGLĆDSURMHNWDPL RRWZDUW\PNRG]LH6KLUN\ 'ODSU]\NâDGX:LNLSHGLDUR]ZLQċâD VLċSRGZSâ\ZHPNXOWXU\KDNHUyZZSURZDG]DMĆFSRVWDZ\DQW\HOLW\ VW\F]QHLX]QDQLHVWDWXVXQDSRGVWDZLHRSLQLLLQQ\FKF]âRQNyZVSR âHF]QRğFLSU]\Z\âĆF]QLHV\PEROLF]Q\FKNRU]\ğFLDFKXF]HVWQLFWZD 2·1HLOE =JRGQLH]W\PHWRVHP5D\PRQG² ğZLDGRPLHZ\ND]XMHQLHXIQRğýZREHFHJRW\]PXLPRW\ZDWRUyZ QDSċG]DQ\FKSU]H]HJRRUD]RGU]XFDMHDXWRSURPRFMDQDMF]ċğFLHMMHVW EH]OLWRğQLHNU\W\NRZDQDQDZHWMHğOLVSRâHF]QRğýPRJâDE\SRWHQFMDOQLH QDQLHM]\VNDý'RWHJRVWRSQLDīHQDMJUXEV]HU\E\LSU]\ZyGF\SOH PLHQQL]PXV]HQLVĆGRRVWURīQHJRZ\UDīDQLDVLHELHLKXPRU\VW\F]QHJR

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA XPQLHMV]DQLDVZRLFKFHFKSU]\NDīGHMVSRVREQRğFLE\XWU]\PDýVWDWXV :\VWċSXMHWXEDUG]RVLOQDPHU\WRNUDFMDZNWyUHMZ\JU\ZDQDM OHSV]\IDFKRZLHF LHWRVWHJRīHMDNRğýSRZLQQDDZUċF]PXVL EURQLý VLċVDPD1DMOHSV]ĆSU]HFKZDâNĆMHVWRSUDFRZDQLHNRGXNWyU\ÅSR SURVWXG]LDâDµLZNWyU\PNDīG\NRPSHWHQWQ\SURJUDPLVWDUR]SR]QD IDNW\F]QĆMDNRğý 7DEXQDSċG]DQHJRSU]H]HJRSR]HUVWZD]ZLċNV]D ZLċFSURGXNW\ZQRğý

1DZHWMHğOLSRZ\īV]\F\WDWRGQRVLVLċGRSURJUDPLVWyZLKDNHUyZ UXFKXZROQHJRRSURJUDPRZDQLDMHVWUyZQLHSUDZG]LZ\GOD:LNLSHGLL QDMEDUG]LHMSURPLQHQWQLHG\WRU]\PDMĆRÀFMDOQLHZ\ND]\ZDýSRNRUċ LVNURPQRğýQLHZ\UDīDMĆFSU]\W\PGĆīHĕGRSHâQLHQLDIXQNFMLZVSR âHF]QRğFL3U]\MċFLHUROLZVSRâHF]QRğFLMHVWQLHUR]HUZDOQLH]ZLĆ]DQH ]HWRVHPVâXīE\QLHSU]\ZyG]WZDSU]\QDMPQLHMZRÀFMDOQLHZ\UDīDQ\FK RSLQLDFK(JRXī\WNRZQLNDQLHPRīHE\ý]E\WQLRZ\EXMDâHDPLPR WHJRīH]QDF]Q\ZNâDGZKDVâDMHVWFHQLRQ\Xī\WNRZQLF\VĆZDQJLHO VNLHMZHUVMLGRNXPHQWX>>HQ:LNLSHGLD2ZQHUVLSRIDUWLFOHV@@>>:LNL SHGLD&]\MĆZâDVQRğFLĆVĆDUW\NXâ\@@XSRPLQDQLīH 1LNWQLH]DOHīQLHRGSRVLDGDQ\FKXPLHMċWQRğFLQLH]DOHīQLHRGSR]\FML ZVSRâHF]QRğFLQLHPDSUDZDG]LDâDýWDNMDNE\E\âZâDğFLFLHOHPRNUHğ ORQHJRKDVâD

:WDNLPğURGRZLVNXJG]LH]DUyZQRNXOWXUDRUJDQL]DF\MQDMDNLIRU PDOQ\SURMHNWFDâRğFL]DNâDGDMĆDQW\KLHUDUFKLF]QRğýJG]LHNRPSOHWQLH EUDNXMHPRW\ZDWRUyZHNRQRPLF]Q\FKLJG]LHFDâRğýLQWHUDNFMLSU]H ELHJDZ,QWHUQHFLHUR]NâDGUyO]DXIDQLDVSRâHF]QHJRLZâDG]\PRīHE\ý ]XSHâQLHLQQ\QLīMHVWWRZâDğFLZHGODWUDG\F\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFML7HPDW WHQE\âMHGQDNZZLċNV]RğFL]DQLHGE\ZDQ\SU]H]QDXNRZFyZG]LH G]LQ\RUJDQL]DFMLV]F]HJyOQLHMHğOLFKRG]LREDGDQLDMDNRğFLRZH&]ċğý DXWRUyZZ\UDīDWHRULHPyZLĆFHīHZ:LNLSHGLLÅIXQGDPHQWDOQ\ HJDOLWDU\]PVSRâHF]QRğFLSU]HNUDF]DJUDQLFHUyOLDXWRU\WHWyZQLHNWy U\FKMHMF]âRQNyZµGH9XJW OHF]ZPRLPRGF]XFLXWDNLH WHRULHZ\ZRG]ĆVLċ]EUDNXGRğZLDGF]HQLDQDXNRZFyZZUHGDJRZDQLX :LNLSHGLL6SRâHF]QRğýSURMHNWXU]HF]\ZLğFLHFHFKXMHVLċZâDğFLZRğ FLDPLHJDOLWDUQ\PLOHF]Z\VWċSXMHZQLHMUyZQLHīVWDELOQDVWUDW\À NDFMDLFLĆJRWNLGRUR]ZLĆ]DĕVLâRZ\FKÅ3UyEDSRZRâDQLDJUXS\©EH] VWUXNWXU\ªMHVWWDNXī\WHF]QDL]âXGQDMDNSUyEDXVWDQRZLHQLD©RELHN W\ZQHMªZLDGRPRğFLSUDVRZHMQDXNLVSRâHF]QHM©EH]ZDUWRğFLªF]\

57

58

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ©ZROQHMªJRVSRGDUNLµ)UHHPDQ JG\īVWUXNWXU\LKLHUDU FKLHSRMDZLDMĆVLċZHZV]\VWNLFKVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKQLH]DOHīQLHRG IRUPDOQHJRQLPL]DU]ĆG]DQLD-DNWZLHUG]LF]ċğýQDXNRZFyZRUJD QL]DFMHVĆZUċF]Å]QDWXU\KLHUDUFKLF]QHµ.HUU ]DğDNWRU]\ RUJDQL]DF\MQLF]ċVWRQLHFKċWQLHXF]HVWQLF]ĆZV\VWHPDFKGHPRNUDW\F] Q\FKQDZHWMHğOLPDMĆNXWHPXRND]Mċ(ZLGHQWQLHZNZHVWLLGHPRNUD FMLRUJDQL]DF\MQHMSDQXMHVLOQ\VFHSW\F\]PPLPRWHJRīHXGRZRGQLâD RQDMXīVZRMĆVNXWHF]QRğý9LJJLDQL %DGDQLDSRND]XMĆMHGQDN īHRUJDQL]DFMDG]LDâDĕQDED]LHZVSyâSUDF\F]ċVWRQLHSURZDG]LGR Z\WZRU]HQLDSHâQHMGHPRNUDFMLOHF]UDF]HMGRPLHV]DQNLWHMīH]ROLJDU FKLĆ+HUQDQGH] 1LHPXVLWRR]QDF]DýīHLGHDâ\HJDOLWDU\]PX VĆVND]DQHQD]DJâDGċ3RSURVWXGHPRNUDW\F]Q\XNâDGQLH]DSRELHJD SRZVWDZDQLXKLHUDUFKLL9LJJLDQL FKRý]QDF]QLHMHâDJRG]L -HGQRF]HğQLHLSDUDGRNVDOQLHWDNLHKLHUDUFKLHSRVWU]HJDVLċZRUJD QL]DFMDFK]DU]ĆG]DQ\FKSDUW\F\SDF\MQLHMDNREDUG]LHMQLHVSUDZLHGOLZH QLīZRUJDQL]DFMDFKWUDG\F\MQ\FK]XZDJLQDRERZLĆ]XMĆF\HJDOLWDUQ\ G\VNXUVPRīHZQLFKWHīZ\VWĆSLýDOLHQDFMDÅP\NRQWUDRQLµ9LJ JLDQL 6SRâHF]QRğFLZLUWXDOQHRSDUWHVĆQDZLHOXURODFKIRUPDOQ\FKLQLH IRUPDOQ\FKZOLF]DMĆFZWRUROHEâD]QyZZDQGDOLLSLHQLDF]\E\XWU]\ PDý]UyZQRZDīHQLH2UWRQ-RKQVRQ ZF]\P:LNLSHGLDQLH RGELHJDRGUHV]W\:SURMHNWDFKRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXZVSyâSUDF\ ]DJQLHĩG]LâRVLċUyZQLHīZLHOHQLHUyZQRğFLPLPRJâRV]RQ\FKSU]H] QLHQD]HZQĆWU]HJDOLWDUQ\FK]DVDG2UWHJDLLQ -DN]DXZDīDMĆ 6KHL]DI5DIDHOLL>HQ:LNLSHGLD -XVWLQ.QDSS'D\@@

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA F]ċğFLZNâDGXZSURMHNWRGPQLHMV]RğFLQLHMHVWQLH]Z\Nâ\ZğZLHFLH )/2660RFNXVLLQ/HUQHUL7LUROH 6NRURZLċFSRQDGMHGQDWU]HFLDHG\FMLZ:LNLSHGLLGRNRQ\ZDQDMHVW SU]H]SâRGQ\FKHG\WRUyZNWyU]\VĆGRWHJRQDMDNW\ZQLHMV]\PLF]âRQ NDPLVSRâHF]QRğFLMHVWGRV\ý]UR]XPLDâHWDNīHīHFLVDPLXī\WNRZQLF\ ]GRPLQXMĆJâRVRZDQLDLEċGĆZ\ELHUDýVRELHSRGREQ\FK:LċNV]Rğý Xī\WNRZQLNyZ]GDMHVRELHMHGQDNVSUDZċ]IDNWXīHVDPDOLF]EDHG\FML QLHMHVWZâDğFLZĆPLDUĆZDUWRğFLZHMğFLRZHMXī\WNRZQLNDMDNMXīZVSRP QLDQRZğUyGHG\FMLGDQHJRXī\WNRZQLND]QDOHĩýPRīQDUyZQLHīVSRUĆ OLF]EċPDâR]QDF]ĆF\FKGUREQ\FKSRSUDZHNSU]\F]\PMHGQRF]HğQLH SRZDīQHUR]EXGRZ\DUW\NXâyZPRJĆGRNRQ\ZDýVLċZ²HG\FMDFK .RU]\VWDQLH]OLF]E\HG\FMLMDNRPLHUQLNDVâXī\ZLċFW\ONRRNUHğORQHM JUXSLHHG\WRUyZSRGREQLHMDNNRQFHQWUDFMDQDÅMDNRğFLµLÅZHU\ÀNR ZDOQRğFLµZğZLHFLHDNDGHPLFNLPVâXī\DGPLQLVWUDWRURPXQLZHUV\ WHFNLP6KRUHL:ULJKW 3RGREQLHZ:LNLSHGLLÅOLF]QLNHG\FML VWDQRZLORNDOQĆZDOXWċµ5HDJOHE 3UREOHPHPMHVWZ\VRNLVWRSLHĕVNRPSOLNRZDQLDRSUDFRZDQLDGR ZROQHMLORğFLRZHMPLDU\MDNRğFLZNâDGXHG\WRUD,VWQLHMĆZSUDZG]LH SRP\Vâ\LPHFKDQL]P\SRGĆīDMĆFHZW\PNLHUXQNXOHF]ZV]\VWNLHPDMĆ ZDG\1DSU]\NâDGRG]ZLHUFLHGODMĆFIDNWīHSURVWHSRSUDZNLRUWRJUD ÀF]QHOXELQWHUSXQNF\MQHQLHSRZLQQ\OLF]\ýVLċWDNVDPRMDNVWZR U]HQLHGXīHJRKDVâDRG]HUDSURVWHE\âRE\]OLF]DQLHLORğFLGRGDZDQHJR GR:LNLSHGLLWHNVWX1LHPyZLWRMHGQDNQLFRZDUWRğFLZVWDZLDQHJR PDWHULDâX:U]HF]\ZLVWRğFLEDUG]RZDUWRğFLRZLHG\WRU]\SRWUDÀĆXV]F]X SODýKDVâDDQLHW\ONRMHUR]EXGRZ\ZDý:RSURJUDPRZDQLXMHGQĆ ]R]QDNMDNRğFLIUDJPHQWXNRGXMHVWWRF]\GDVLċJRVNUyFLýEH]VWUDW 5D\PRQG =WHJRZ]JOċGXNXV]ĆFHZ\GDMHVLċPLHU]HQLH LORğFLLVWDELOQRğFLGâXJRğFLWUZDQLD GRGDQHJRWHNVWX1LHVWHW\ZSUR ZDG]HQLHWDNLHMPHWRG\SRPLDUyZZF]DVLHU]HF]\ZLVW\PZ\GDMHVLċ Z\PDJDýZLHOX]DVREyZLE\ýSURFHVHPVNRPSOLNRZDQ\PZLċFQLH GRV]âRMDNGRWĆGGRVNXWNX 6NXWNLHPSRZ\īV]HJRMHGQĆ]QLHZLHOXVNZDQW\ÀNRZDQ\FKFHFK ZNâDGXXī\WNRZQLNDMHVWOLF]EDGRNRQDQ\FKSU]H]HĕHG\FML:V]\VF\ ZLNLSHG\ğFLZLHG]ĆīHFHFKDWDMHVWQLHGRVNRQDâDZīDUJRQLHSURMHNWX REVHVMDZ\VRNLHMOLF]E\HG\FMLQRVLQD]ZċÅFKRURE\OLF]QLNRZHMµF]\ HGLWFRXQWLWLV]RE>>HQ:LNLSHGLD(GLWFRXQWLWLV@@>>:LNLSHGLD1DEL MDF]OLF]QLND@@ OHF]ZREOLF]XEUDNXLQQ\FKZVNDĩQLNyZLORğFLRZ\FK MHVWZDNW\ZQ\PXī\FLX:LHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZF]ċVWRVSUDZG]DVWDQ OLF]QLNDHG\FMLLQWHUORNXWRUyZ2·1HLO

69

70

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 6\WXDFMDWDSU]\SRPLQDZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQLHF]DVXVSċG]RQHJRZSUDF\ MDNRZVNDĩQLNDHIHNW\ZQRğFLSURJUDPLVWyZLLQQ\FKSUDFRZQLNyZ NWyU\FKG]LDâDQLDED]XMĆQDZLHG]\QDZHWPLPR]JRGQ\FKRSLQLLFR GRWHJRīHPLDUDWDQLHPyZLSUDNW\F]QLHQLFZLHOXNLHURZQLNyZZÀU PDFKLQIRUPDW\F]Q\FKVWRVXMHMĆ]EUDNXLQQ\FKğURGNyZ-HPLHOQLDN 3RGREQLHPLDUDWDSURZDG]LGRVSDF]RQ\FK]DFKRZDĕZV\WXD FMDFKJG\SUDFRZQLF\UR]SR]QDMĆPHFKDQL]PV\VWHPXLG]LDâDMĆE\ JRRGSRZLHGQLRZ\NRU]\VWDýQSSUDFXMĆFGRSyĩQ\FKJRG]LQSU]H] FRWZRU]ĆLOX]MċSUDFRFKâRQQRğFLVZRLFKG]LDâDĕ 'RGDWNRZRFKRý:LNLSHGLDMHVWVSRâHF]QRğFLĆRFKRWQLF]ĆLQDSċG]D MĆZVSyâSUDFDQLH]DğUR]JU\ZNLZNWyU\FKZV]\VF\PDMĆÅZ\MğýQD F]\VWRµSUREOHPOLF]QLNRPDQLLMHVWGRGDWNRZR]DRVWU]DQ\SU]H]UyīQH IRUP\SU]\MDFLHOVNLHMNRQNXUHQFML1DZHWZLNLSHG\ğFLNWyU\FKVWDWXV VSRâHF]Q\QLHPRīHVLċ]PLHQLý]XZDJLQDOLF]EċGRNRQDQ\FKSU]H] QLFKHG\FMLSU]H]WRīHVĆXVWDELOL]RZDQ\PLF]âRQNDPLVSRâHF]QRğFL OXEMXīSHâQLĆIXQNFMċDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ F]ċVWRZVSRVyEV\PEROLF]Q\ U\ZDOL]XMĆZNRQNXUHQFMDFKZNWyU\FKWU]HED]URELýFRğV]\EFLHM'OD SU]\NâDGXDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\QLHU]DGNRÅU\ZDOL]XMĆµZXVXZDQLXKDVHâ QRPLQRZDQ\FKGRV]\ENLHJRVNDVRZDQLDSU]H]UHJXODUQLHHG\WXMĆF\FK Xī\WNRZQLNyZDELXURNUDFLPRJĆÅNRQNXURZDýµRWRNWRV]\EFLHM SU]\]QDXSUDZQLHQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSRSRP\ğOQ\PGODNDQG\GDWD JâRVRZDQLX1DZHWVWHZDUG]LVSLHV]ĆVLċGRXVWDQDZLDQLDJOREDOQ\FK EORNDGNRQWLDGUHVyZ,3RUD]RGELHUDQLDXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRURP 5yīQHUROHVSRâHF]QHNUHXMĆUyīQHZ]RUFH]DFKRZDQLDRUD]VWUDWHJLH VDQNFMRQRZDQLDG]LDâDĕXī\WNRZQLNyZ :RGQLHVLHQLXGRELXURNUDWyZSROVNLHMLDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLRUD] GRVWHZDUGyZZ\GDMHVLċīHZ\VWċSXMHQDGPLDUIXQNFMRQDULXV]\1DG Z\īNLLZ]DMHPQHQDNâDGDQLHVLċUHMRQyZG]LDâDĕSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKXī\W NRZQLNyZVĆSUDZGRSRGREQLHSRīĆGDQHL]UR]XPLDâH]HZ]JOċGyZRUJD QL]DF\MQ\FKJG\īRFKRWQLF\PRJĆRSXV]F]DýV]HUHJLXF]HVWQLNyZSURMHNWX EH]RVWU]HīHQLDMDNWHī]XZDJLQDVH]RQRZH]Z\īNLDNW\ZQRğFL=XZDJL QDWRīHELXURNUDFLPRJĆWUDFLýVZRMHXSUDZQLHQLDSRGâXīV]\PRNUH VLHQLHDNW\ZQRğFL]DğVWHZDUG]LPXV]ĆSRWZLHUG]DýVZRMĆSU]\GDW QRğýGODVSRâHF]QRğFLSHZQDDWPRVIHUDU\ZDOL]DFMLMHVWFRG]LHQQRğFLĆ FKRýSU]HELHJDRQDZOHNNLHML]GHF\GRZDQLHSU]\MD]QHMDWPRVIHU]H .RQNXURZDQLHRHG\FMHG]LDâDQLDDGPLQLVWUDF\MQHF]\LQQHZ\UyīQLNL VSUDZLDMHGQDNīHLFKOLF]EDVWDMHVLċW\PEDUG]LHMZDUWRğFLRZD 'OD]QDF]ĆFHMF]ċğFLVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLLOLF]EDGRNRQDQ\FK SU]H]GDQHJRXī\WNRZQLNDHG\FMLMHVWEDUG]RLVWRWQ\PZ\]QDF]QLNLHP

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA MHJRSU]\GDWQRğFLZDīQLHMV]\PQDZHWQLīWRF]\Xī\WNRZQLNWHQ SRP\ğOQLHSU]HV]HGâJâRVRZDQLHQDGSU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕDGPL QLVWUDWRUD/LF]EDHG\FMLV]F]HJyOQLHÅZSU]HVWU]HQLJâyZQHMµF]\OL ZDUW\NXâDFKQLH]DğZG\VNXVMDFKVSRâHF]QRğFLRZ\FK X]QDZDQDMHVW ]DX]DVDGQLHQLHVDPHJRXF]HVWQLFWZDZSURMHNFLH]GDU]DVLċF]ċVWR īHXī\WNRZQLNRPF]\QLĆF\PVXJHVWLHLXF]HVWQLF]ĆF\PZG\VNXVMDFK RJyOQ\FKSU]\SRPLQDVLċLīRVWDWQLRLFKZNâDGZDUW\NXâ\Z:LNLSHGLL MHVWQLHWċJLLīHSRZLQQLSRSUDZLDýVZyMZL]HUXQHNZRF]DFKLQQ\FK HG\WXMĆFKDVâDQLH]DğNRPHQWXMĆF

ŚCIEŻKA ZDROWIA 2JyOQLHMV]HVSRMU]HQLHSU]\QRVLZLGRNMHV]F]HEDUG]LHMQLHSRNRMĆF\ 2EVHVMDQDSXQNFLHOLF]QLNDHG\FMLXMDZQLDMĆFDVLċZJâRVRZDQLDFK QDGSU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDDQJLHOVNLHMOXESROVNLHM :LNLSHGLLWRW\ONRF]ċğýSUREOHPX:\ERU\DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSRVWU]HJD VLċFRUD]F]ċğFLHMMDNRSURFHVSU]HUDīDMĆF\LQLHSU]\MHPQ\DZLHOXXī\W NRZQLNyZQLHFKFHEUDýZQLFKXG]LDâXJG\īZLHG]ĆFRLFKF]HND=QD PLHQQHMHVWīHZREXZHUVMDFKMċ]\NRZ\FK²SROVNLHMLDQJLHOVNLHM² SURFHVWHQ]ZDQ\MHVWÅğFLHīNĆ]GURZLDµEĆGĩWHīÅNUZDZĆâDĩQLĆµ F]DVDPLU]HF]\ZLğFLHSU]\MPXMĆFIRUPċHJ]DPLQXVSUDZG]DMĆFHJR XPLHMċWQRğFLNDQG\GDWDF]ċVWRSU]H]]DGDZDQLHWUXGQ\FKS\WDĕ RUD] RVRELVW\FKSU]\W\NyZLRğPLHV]DMĆF\FKNRPHQWDU]\F]\QLRQ\FK]]D PLDUHP Z\HNVSRQRZDQLD ZDG NDQG\GDWD &\WXMĆF 6XH 5DQJHOO >>HQ5HTXHVWVBIRUBDGPLQVKLS'DUNZLQG@@ZQLHGDZQ\PJâRVRZDQLX JUXGQLD 1LHī\F]ċMXīVRELHQLJG\NROHMQHJRSURFHVX38$-HVWWRQLHOXG]NLH F]HSLDOVWZRF]ċVWRQLHVSUDZLHGOLZHDZZLċNV]RğFLSU]\SDGNyZPDMĆFH NRQIURQWDF\MQĆQDWXUċ:LHPīHZZ\QLNXOXVWUDFMLSRGF]DV38$:LNL SHGLċRSXV]F]DOLMXīGREU]\HG\WRU]\

:LHOHJâRVRZDĕMHVWSU]HJUDQ\FKSRZ\ZOHF]HQLXSU]H]MHGQHJRXī\W NRZQLNDZ]JOċGQLHPDâR]QDF]ĆFHJRXFK\ELHQLDOXEZDG\NDQG\GDWD

38$WRVNUyWRGSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUD

71

72

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SRF]\PQDVWċSXMHV]HUHJQDZLĆ]DĕGRZ\HNVSRQRZDQHMVâDERğFL-DN QDSLVDâMHGHQ]GRğZLDGF]RQ\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ>>HQ8VHU.XGSXQJ 5I$FULWHULD@@ :\QLNLJâRVRZDQLDQDGSU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕWRF]DVDPLORWHULD RSUyF]JDUğFLUHJXODUQ\FKXF]HVWQLNyZNWyU]\QDMF]ċğFLHMFKRýQLH ]DZV]H ZLHG]ĆFRURELĆJâRVRZDQLHMHVWZUċNDFKSRWRNXMHGQRUD]R Z\FKNRPHQWDWRUyZIDQyZNU\W\NyZLQRZRSU]\E\â\FK=GDU]DVLċ īHOREERZDQLH]DJâRVHPSU]HELHJD]DNXOLVRZRVĆWDF\NWyU]\NRPHQ WXMĆJâRVRZDQLHRVWHQWDF\MQLH]DSXQNWZ\MğFLDSU]\MPXMĆFNRPHQWDU]H LQQ\FK]DğF]ċğýJâRVXMĆF\FKZRJyOHQLHSRMPXMHWHJRSURFHVX,QQL ]DğXF]HVWQLF\]URELĆZLHOHE\XPRW\ZRZDýVZRMHJâRV\F]ċVWRZ\FLĆ JDMĆFVWDUHQLHPDMĆFHMXī]QDF]HQLDGLII\]DUFKLZXP

,QQ\DGPLQLVWUDWRUXMĆâFDâRğýRVWU]HM>>HQ8VHU$QLPXP5)$@@ 8ī\WNRZQLF\UR]GPXFKXMĆF\GRQLHERW\F]Q\FKUR]PLDUyZQDMPQLHMV]H QDZHWQLHGRFLĆJQLċFLDNDQG\GDWDQDNUċFDMĆGUDPDWXUJLċZ\GDU]HQLD ²FRPRīHGRSURZDG]LýGRV\WXDFMLZNWyUHMJâRVRZDQLHQDGNDQG\GD WHPNWyU\]DVâXJXMHQDIXQNFMċDGPLQLVWUDWRUDZSDGDZNRUNRFLĆJ SRUDīNL%DUG]RV]NRGDīHELXURNUDFLF]ċVWRSRPLMDMĆWRFRIDNW\F]QLH PyZLVLċSRGF]DVJâRVRZDQLDLGHF\GXMĆRMHJRZ\QLNXMHG\QLHQDSRG VWDZLHVWRVXQNXJâRVyZ

*âRV\VSU]HFLZX]QDOD]â\MXīQDZHWVZRMHVWDâHPLHMVFHZIRONORU]H :LNLSHGLL]REQS>>HQ:LNLSHGLD:LNL6SHDN'HFRGLQJ5I$@@ 'RGDW NRZR]XZDJLQDWRīHQLHPXV]ĆRQHE\ýPRW\ZRZDQHF]ċVW\PX]D VDGQLHQLHPMHVWÅEUDN]DXIDQLDµ JâRVRZDQLDQDGSU]\]QDQLHPVWDWXVX DGPLQLVWUDWRUDSU]\FLĆJDMĆNU\W\NyZ:LNLSHGLLNWyU]\PRJĆQLHPLHý QLF]HJRNRQNUHWQHJRSU]HFLZNRGDQHPXNDQG\GDWRZLOHF]NRU]\VWDMĆ ]QDGDU]DMĆFHMVLċRND]MLE\Z\UD]LýVZRMĆNU\W\NċZREHFRUJDQL]DFML VSRâHF]QRğFLMDNRWDNLHM $GPLQLVWUDWRU.XGSXQJSU]HDQDOL]RZDâSUyENċS\WDĕ]DGDQ\FK SRGF]DVJâRVRZDĕQDGSU]\]QDQLHPÁDJLDGPLQLVWUDWRUDDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLZURNX-DNSRND]XMHMHJRDQDOL]D>>HQ8VHU.XGSXQJ 5I$BFULWHULD@@ QDZHWS\WDĕPRīQDVNODV\ÀNRZDýMDNRÅQLHLVWRWQH

:īDUJRQLHZLNLSHG\VWyZGLIIWRSRUyZQDQLH]PLDQQDVWURQLHPLċG]\GZRPD HG\FMDPL

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA OXEGUĆīĆFHSU\ZDWQHRSLQLHNDQG\GDWDµMDNRÅSRSURVWXJâXSLHµ MDNRÅPDUQRWUDZVWZRF]DVXV]XNDQLHSRUDG\µ,QQHPQLHMSR SXODUQHOHF]LWDNSRZWDU]DOQHNDWHJRULHS\WDĕWRWDNLHNWyUHPDMĆ ÅRV]XNDýµNDQG\GDWDOXEWDNLHNWyUHVĆÅğZLDGRPLH]ZRGQLF]Hµ,QQL EDGDF]HZ\ND]DOLMXīWHīīHJâRVRZDQLH]DNDQG\GDWXU]HOXESU]HFLZ QLHMMHVWğFLğOH]ZLĆ]DQH]]DOHīQRğFLĆPLċG]\FKDUDNWHUHPNDQG\GDWD LJâRVXMĆFHJR/HVNRYHFLLQ %LRUĆFSRGXZDJċWDNPDâRRSW\PLVW\F]QHV]DQVHQLHG]LZLIDNW īHZ:LNLSHGLLMHVWVSRURUR]F]DURZDQ\FKNDQG\GDWyZQDDGPLQLVWUD WRUD6NXWNLHPWHJRE\âRSRMDZLHQLHVLċZLHOXRSRZLHğFL]SU]HVWUR JDPLQDSU]\NâDGWDNLHMMDNĆRSLVDâXī\WNRZQLN'D\HZDONHUNWyU\ ZVSRVyEQDVWċSXMĆF\]UHIHURZDâVZRMHGRğZLDGF]HQLD]GRSLHUR]DNRĕ F]RQHJRQLHXGDQHJRJâRVRZDQLDQDGSU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕ]DPNQLċ WHJROLVWRSDGD>>HQ8VHU'D\HZDONHU@@ 2ERMċWQLHFRPyZLĆLQQLRERMċWQLHMDNQLHXJUXQWRZDQHPRJĆE\ýLFK RVNDUīHQLDPXVLV]VLHG]LHýFLFKR1DZHWMHğOLNU\W\NXMHFLċNWRğNWR MHVWRF]\ZLVW\PSRP\OHĕFHPQLHSRZLQLHQHğRGSRZLDGDý1LHZROQR FLSRND]DýīHMHVWHğXUDīRQ\QDZHWMHğOLRGSLHUDV]RF]\ZLVWHNâDPVWZD ']LHOQLHPXVLV]]QRVLýVWU]Dâ\ORVXQDZHWMHğOLSDGDMĆ]HVWURQ\OXG]L NLHSVNRPyZLĆF\FKWZRLPMċ]\NLHP=RVWDWQLFKHG\FMLQDPRLP 38$F]WHUG]LHğFLSRFKRG]LâRRGMHGQHJRXī\WNRZQLNDNWyU\RGGDâJâRV VSU]HFLZX&]WHUG]LHğFL1LNWQDZHWQLHPUXJQĆâRNLHPQLNWQLHSR SURVLâE\WHQF]âRZLHN]ZROQLâ7RWDNMDNE\ZâDğQLHRGE\ZDâDVLċSU]\ VLċJDZNOXELHXF]QLRZVNLPJG]LHLGLRFLPDMĆV]DQVċZOHSLDýFLNODSV\ SRWRE\XGRZRGQLýīHMHVWHğZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRZLHONLPLGLRWĆE\QDOHīHý GRLFKNOXEX 3LHUZV]HG]LHVLċýJâRVyZVSU]HFLZXSRFKRG]LâRRGXī\WNRZQLNyZ NWyU]\âĆF]QLH]DURELOLEORNDG2F]\ZLğFLHNWyīOHSLHMZLHMDNLH FHFK\SRZLQLHQPLHýDGPLQLVWUDWRURGğZLHīR]DEORNRZDQHJR]JRU]N QLDâHJRHG\WRUD]EDJDīHPSUREOHPyZ"7RWDNMDNE\SR]ZROLýVND]D Q\P]DVLDGDýMDNRâDZQLF\ERWRRQLQDMOHSLHMZLHG]ĆMDNZ\JOĆGD SU]HVWċSFD -HGHQ]DU]XFLâPLEUDNXSU]HMPRğFLLRSDQRZDQLD.ROHMQ\Xī\WNRZ QLNF]ċVWREORNRZDQ\PDMĆF\RJUDQLF]HQLDQDHG\WRZDQLHSRZLHG]LDâ īHâDīċ]DQLPLUDSRUWXMċMHJRG]LDâDQLD3R]RVWDOLSRSURVLOLRGLII\ 'RZRG\"1LHQLHQDVWĆSLâ\MXīNRPHQWDU]HQLHE\âRGLIIyZSRSURVWX RVWU]Dâ]HVWURQ\SU]\SDGNRZHJRSDODQWD'RFKRG]LâRGRV\WXDFML ZNWyU\FK]DSHâQLDQRVWURQ\G\VNXVMLOXG]LNWyU]\E\PQLHQLHSRSDUOL

73

74

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SRWRE\]QLV]F]\ýPQLHMDNRNDQG\GDWD.WRğSU]HVDG]LâL]DF]Ćâ]ELHUDý JâRV\SRSDUFLDQDVZRMH38$1DW\FKVWURQDFKG]LDâ\VLċV]DORQH U]HF]\ZV]\VWNLHZUDPDFKGR]ZRORQ\FKG]LDâDĕ 3HZLHQXī\WNRZQLN]DEORNRZDQ\MXīV]HğýUD]\ZVWDZLâJâRVVSU]HFLZX LRVNDUī\âPQLHRF]âRQNRVWZRZMDNLHMğPJOLVWHMNRQVSLUDFMLJG\īZMHJR PQLHPDQLX]E\WV]\ENRSR]QDâHPīDUJRQSURMHNWXLPRMDÅNU]\ZD XF]HQLDVLċµURVâD]E\WRVWURRGNLHG\]DF]ĆâHPHG\WRZDýF]\OLRGPDMD

7DNLHUHÁHNVMHLZ\UD]\UR]F]DURZDQLDQLHVĆZ:LNLSHGLLQLF]\P QLH]Z\Nâ\P

CZY SYSTEM UPADŁ? PDUFDURNX-XPER:DOHVSRFLHV]DMĆFXī\WNRZQLND0\6WUDW SRMHJRQLHXGDQ\P38$QDSLVDâÅ38$WRSURFHVRNURSQ\L]HSVXW\µ VLHUSQLD]DXZDī\âWHīQDZâDVQHMVWURQLHG\VNXVMLZWRNX UR]ZDīDĕQDGSRSUDZĆSURFHVXSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕÅVDPIDNW LVWQLHQLDWHJRSURFHVXRGVWUDV]DFDâNLHPSRNDĩQDOLF]EċGREU\FK NDQG\GDWyZµDVDPMHVWÅ]DWURVNDQ\RGREU\FKNDQG\GDWyZQLHSUy EXMĆF\FKQDZHWXELHJDýVLċRGRGDWNRZHXSUDZQLHQLDJG\īSURFHV WHQVWDQRZLNRV]PDUQLHZDUW]DFKRGXµ,QQLXī\WNRZQLF\RGQRV]ĆVLċ GR38$SRGREQLHPyZLĆFRQLPMDNRRÅZ\VRFHVWUHVXMĆF\PLF]ċVWR SRQLīDMĆF\PGRğZLDGF]HQLXSRUyZQ\ZDOQ\P],QNZL]\FMĆµNZLHW QLD>>HQ8VHU.XGSXQJ5I$FULWHULD@@ 5R]SRF]ċWRZLHOHG\VNXVMLLSURSR]\FMLWHJRMDNPRīQDQDSUDZLý SURFHVSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUD7HPDWWHQMHVWU]H F]\ZLğFLHSRSXODUQ\ZğUyGF]ċğFLXī\WNRZQLNyZ3U]HDQDOL]RZDQH SU]H]HPQLHG\VNXVMHLRSLQLHQDWHPDWPRīOLZHJRNLHUXQNXZNWyU\P PyJâE\SRGĆī\ýSURFHV38$ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLSU]HNUDF]DMĆ W\VLċF\VâyZSU]\F]\PPRīOLZHMHVWīHSU]HRF]\âHPF]ċğýPQLHM SRSXODUQ\FKG\VNXVMLLHVHMyZ:LHOHGRNXPHQWyZMHVWQDGDOUR]ZL MDQ\FKDG\VNXVMHZQLFKFLĆJQĆVLċSRG]LğG]LHĕ3RGREQHG\VNXVMH RSRUyZQ\ZDOQHMZLHONRğFLSU]HSURZDG]DQRZSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLL² ZHGâXJPRMHMZLHG]\²ZZLHOXLQQ\FKSURMHNWDFK1DMF]ċğFLHMZ\UD īDQHSRP\Vâ\WRQRPLQRZDQLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ]DPLDVWJâRVRZDQLD QDGQLPLV]NROHQLHRFKRWQLNyZLSR]ZDODQLHLPQD]DSR]QDQLHVLċ

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA ]]DNUHVHPRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğFLDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSU]H]IRUPDOQ\SURFHV SRGREQ\GRNXUVXXF]HOQLDQHJRF]HODGQLFWZDLPHQWRUVWZDF]\UR] ELFLHXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDQDNLONDSRPQLHMV]\FKUyONWyUH PRīQDE\âRE\SU]\MPRZDýQDVLHELHSRNROHL%DUG]LHMUDG\NDOQHLGHH ]DNâDGDâ\QDSU]\NâDGDXWRPDW\F]QHSU]\]QDZDQLHXSUDZQLHĕXī\WNRZ QLNRPVSHâQLDMĆF\PRNUHğORQHNU\WHULD5R]ZDīDQRVNRPSOLNRZDQH DOJRU\WP\LZ]RU\SU]\]QDMĆFHSXQNW\]DZ\SHâQLDQLHRNUHğORQ\FK ]DGDĕLÅRGEORNRZXMĆFHµNROHMQHHWDS\VWDWXVXDGPLQLVWUDWRUD6XJH URZDQRSU]HP\ğOHQLHZ\PDJDĕNWyUHPXVLVSHâQLDýNDQG\GDW5R]ZD īDQRWHī]DRVWU]HQLHZ\PDJDĕZVWRVXQNXGRXF]HVWQLNyZJâRVRZDQLD 3RZUDFDMĆF\PSRP\VâHPE\âDWHī]PLDQDIRUPDWXG\VNXVMLQS ]PQLHMV]HQLHOLF]E\GR]ZRORQ\FKZJâRVRZDQLXS\WDĕ 3RGUR]ZDJċ SRGGDZDQRQDZHWJâRVRZDQLHZV\VWHPLHWDMQ\PGRVWċSQHGODXī\W NRZQLNyZVSHâQLDMĆF\FKRNUHğORQHNU\WHULDSRGREQLHMDNFDâĆSOHMDGċ SRP\VâyZRUyīQ\PVWRSQLXHJ]RW\F]QRğFL6WRMĆFZREOLF]XPRīOLZHJR SDUDOLīX]DVXJHURZDQRWHīXWU]\PDQLHZPRF\DNWXDOQLHRERZLĆ]X MĆFHMSURFHGXU\SU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕZUD]]UyZQROHJâ\PZSURZD G]HQLHPQRZ\FKXVWDOHĕ:VW\F]QLXURNXQDGDOQLHRVLĆJQLċWR NRQVHQVXVXFRGRWHJRMDNLH]PLDQ\QDOHīDâRE\ZSURZDG]LýGRSURFHVX 38$LMDNQDOHīDâRE\WR]URELý]SUDZGRSRGRELHĕVWZHPJUDQLF]ĆF\P ]SHZQRğFLĆG\VNXVMHEċGĆWUZDýQDGDO 1LHNWyU]\QLHXZDīDMĆE\SURFHVSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕE\â ]HSVXW\1DSU]\NâDGXī\WNRZQLN(UUDQWVNRPHQWRZDâFDâRğýQDVWċ SXMĆFRQDVWURQLH:DOHVD 38$E\âRGODPQLHSU]Hī\FLHPZ\VRFHSR]\W\ZQ\PJG]LH]NLONX JâRVyZVSU]HFLZXZ\FLĆJQĆâHPJDUğýXī\WHF]Q\FKSRUDG2F]\ZLğFLH īHZDKDâHPVLċLNU\JRZDâHPSU]HGZ\VWDZLHQLHPVZRMHMNDQG\GDWXU\ V]F]HJyOQLHīHVDPVLċQRPLQRZDâHPDOHXZDīDPīH]SHZQ\FKZ]JOċGyZ MHVWWRLVWRWQDF]ċğýSRF]XFLDīHMHVWVLċJRWRZ\P0RīH38$]E\WQLR OXG]LVWUDV]\SHZQLHWDNMHVW DOHQLHVĆG]ċE\XVXQLċFLHZV]\VWNLFK ÅVWUDV]DNyZµ]WHJRSURFHVXE\âRSRVXQLċFLHPGREU\P7DNVDPR ZLG]LP\SRGZyMQHVWDQGDUG\NWyUHPQLHGHQHUZXMĆ²DGPLQLVWUDWRURP FDâ\F]DVXFKRG]ĆQDVXFKR]DFKRZDQLDNWyUHGRSURZDG]Lâ\E\GR ÀDVNDZNDīG\P38$DOERSU]\QDMPQLHMPRFQRE\MHSU]\EORNRZDâ\ 1LHZLG]ċQLF]GURīQHJRZUR]ELHUDQLXZNâDGXQDF]ċğFLSLHUZV]H LNU\W\NRZDQLXNDQG\GDWyZSR]DW\PīHG]LHMHVLċWR]E\WRVWURDSR JâRVRZDQLX]DPLHUD²(UUDQWFKDW VLHUSQLD87&

75

76

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 8ī\WNRZQLN9HMYDQÿLFNëSRVXQĆâVLċZVZRLPNRPHQWDU]XMHV]F]H GDOHM :RZ2WDN:LG]ċWRVDPRUD]]DUD]HP1LHZ\REUDīDOQ\NRV]PDU 7\G]LHĕZSLHNOH5\WXDOQHSRQLīHQLH©XVXQLċWRREUDĩOLZ\IUDJPHQWª 6]F]HU]HPyZLĆFWRMHğOLQLHSRWUDÀV]VWDQĆýRNRZRNR]NU\W\NĆ ]LJQRURZDýE]GHW\LRGQLHğýVLċGRLVWRWQ\FKSXQNWyZNU\W\NLZVSR NRMQ\LXSU]HMP\VSRVyEWROHSLHMGRURğQLM7DNG]LHMHVLċZSUDZG]L Z\Pī\FLXLWDNSRZLQQRE\ýWHīWXWDM2SLQLHZ\UDīDQHSU]H]OXG]L QLH]DZV]HSRV\SDQHVĆUyīDQ\PLSâDWNDPLDMHğOLQLHSRWUDÀV]XWU]\ PDýVLċQDIDOLWR38$QLHMHVWGODFLHELH7\ONRWDNDRSLQLD²9HMYDQ ÿLFNëWDON_FRQWULEV ZU]HğQLD87&

1DMZ\UDĩQLHMWUDXPDNWyUĆOXG]LHXWRīVDPLDMĆ]JâRVRZDQLDPL MHVWF]DVHPSU]H]RVRE\SRVWURQQHSRVWU]HJDQDMDNRXī\WHF]QDJG\ī ZWHQVSRVyEVSUDZG]DVLċGRMU]DâRğýNDQG\GDWyZNWyU]\MDNRDGPLQL VWUDWRU]\PXV]ĆE\ýZVWDQLHXG]LHOLýQLHUDFMRQDOQ\PLUR]]âRV]F]RQ\P Xī\WNRZQLNRPVSRNRMQHMRGSRZLHG]L 0LPRWHJRZLċNV]RğýZLNLSHG\VWyZZLG]LZSURFHVLHSU]\]QDZD QLDXSUDZQLHĕFRğ]âHJR$QDOL]XMĆMHJRNRQVHNZHQFMHGRVWU]HJDMĆF QLHFLHNDZHUH]XOWDW\ 3UREOHPMHVWWHJRW\SXīH]Z\NOLFLVLXī\WNRZQLF\QDMSUDZGRSRGREQLHM RSXV]F]ĆSURMHNWDOERZ\MGĆZSRâRZLHNROHMQHMZLNLSHG\MQHMZDONLER RQLWXVĆSRWRE\VLċGREU]HEDZLý=DWRFLNWyU]\VLHG]ĆZNOLNDFK OXESU]HS\FKDMĆQDVLâċVZyMSXQNWZLG]HQLDQLHRGSXV]F]ĆERPDMĆ ZLHONLSODQ²Xī\WNRZQLF\WHJRW\SXPDMĆRZLHOH]DVLOQ\ZSâ\ZQD :LNLSHGLċLWR]XZDJLQDLFKLVWQLHQLHZLNLQLHG]LDâDMDNSRZLQQD 2VWDWQLRZLG]LDâHPVXJHVWLċUR]SLVDQLD5)&ZVSUDZLH38$DOHWDND G\VNXVMDQLFE\QLHGDâD7RQLHSURFHVSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕMHVW SRSVXW\²FDâ\V\VWHPMHVWSRSVXW\LWRZâDğQLHFDâ\V\VWHPQDOHī\ ZZLċNV]RğFLSU]HSLVDýQDQRZR 3XPSNLQ6N\WDONZU]HğQLD>>HQ:LNLSHGLDBWDON 5I$BUHIRUPB5DGLFDOBDOWHUQDWLYHV@@

5HTXHVWIRU&RPPHQWF]\OLSURğEDRNRPHQWDU]

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA 2SUyF]SU]HQLNOLZHMDQDOL]\G]LDâDQLDV\VWHPXWHQNRPHQWDU]SU]\ ZRâXMHPRW\ZNOLNLQDSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLRNUHğODQHMF]DVHPÅ*7:µ F]\OLÅ*UXSĆ7U]\PDMĆFĆ:âDG]ċµ *âyZQ\DUJXPHQWMHVWRVWUR]DU\ VRZDQ\F]ċğýGREU\FKLGRMU]Dâ\FKHG\WRUyZQLHOXELNRQIURQWDF\MQHJR VW\OX38$LPRīH]GHF\GRZDýīHQLHZHĩPLHXG]LDâXZJâRVRZDQLX Z\âĆF]QLH]XZDJLQDVDPMHJRFKDUDNWHUDQDZHWRSXğFL:LNLSHGLċ ]QLHVPDF]RQDERMDPLWRF]ĆF\PLVLċZSURMHNFLH:HGâXJSRZ\īV]HJR HG\WRUDMHVWMDVQHLSRWZLHUG]DMĆWRWHīLQQHRVRE\īHSURFHV38$ DNWXDOQLHQLHVâXī\Z\EUDQLXQDMOHSV]\FKNDQG\GDWyZDZUċF]RGVWUD V]DRGXF]HVWQLF]HQLDZSUDFDFKQDGUR]ZRMHP:LNLSHGLL ,QWHUHVXMĆFHMHVWWRīHSURFHVZ\ELHUDQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZXZDīD VLċ]DVNDīRQ\MXīRGURNX]RE>>HQ8VHU$DURQB6FKXO]1HZB 5I$BPHWKRG@@ &LHNDZHMHVWWHīīHSURFHVZ\âDQLDQLDDGPLQLVWUDWR UyZSRVWU]HJDQ\MHVWMDNR]HSVXW\LNRV]PDUQ\UyZQLHīZSROVNLHM :LNLSHGLLNWyUDQLHGRğZLDGF]\âDDīWDNZLHONLHJRVSDGNXOLF]E\NDQ G\GDWyZF]\SRP\ğOQLH]DNRĕF]RQ\FKJâRVRZDĕMDNZHUVMDDQJLHOVND =DUyZQRZSROVNLHMMDNLDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLSU]\]QDZDQLHXSUDZ QLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDMHVWV]DQVĆZ\UDīHQLDVSU]HFLZyZZREHFG]LDâDĕ VDPHMVSRâHF]QRğFL0RīHWRR]QDF]DýīHRERMċWQLHMDNLH]PLDQ\ ZSURZDG]RQH]RVWDQĆZV\VWHPLHZ\ELHUDQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZ\QLN QLH]PLHQLVLċ]E\WQLRMHğOLXī\WNRZQLNRPSR]ZROLVLċQDZ\UDīDQLH RSLQLL0yZLĆRW\PVDPLZLNLSHG\ğFL'ODSU]\NâDGXNZLHWQLD )HWFKFRPPV]DXZDī\âQDVWURQLH>>HQ:LNLSHGLDBWDON5I$BUH IRUPB@@īHÅSUREOHPHPZSURFHVLH38$QLHMHVWVDPSURFHV W\ONRMHJRXF]HVWQLF\µDUJXPHQWXMĆFīHīDGHQV\VWHPJâRVRZDQLD QLHRGPLHQLQDVWDZLHQLDJâRVXMĆF\FK3URFHVZ\ELHUDQLDDGPLQLVWUD WRUyZMHVWGODZLHOXXF]HVWQLNyZSURMHNWXZVSRVyERF]\ZLVW\ZDīQ\ DMHJR]DSDğýMHVWVNXWNLHPQLHW\ONRVDPHMSURFHGXUDOQHMVWURQ\SUR FHVXMDNSRZLQQLE\ýZ\ELHUDQLDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\DOHWHīJâċEV]HJR QLH]DGRZROHQLDSRFKRG]ĆFHJRRGRJyâXVSRâHF]QRğFL 3UDZGĆMHVWīH]QDF]QĆF]ċğýī\FLDVSRâHF]QRğFLZ\SHâQLDMĆJâRVR ZDQLDXUDVWDMĆFGR]DJRU]Dâ\FKGHEDWF]DVDPLZ\NUDF]DMĆFSR]D JUDQLFHG\VNXVMLQDGDNWXDOQ\PNDQG\GDWHP3RMDZLDMĆFHVLċZWUDN FLH38$SUREOHP\ZVND]XMĆīHXī\WNRZQLF\WUDNWXMĆRZHJâRVRZDQLD Z\MĆWNRZRSRZDīQLHLZLHOX]QLFKPDZUDīHQLHīHXF]HVWQLF]ĆZG\V NXVMLQDGQDGDQLHPZ\MĆWNRZRZDīQ\FKLU]DGNLFKSU]\ZLOHMyZ7DNLH SRGHMğFLHMHVW]DVNDNXMĆFHMHğOLSU]HFLZVWDZLVLċMHRÀFMDOQHMUHWRU\FH :LNLSHGLLZNWyUHMSRGNUHğODVLċīHUROHLIXQNFMHSRZLQQ\E\ýVWR VXQNRZRPDâRZDīQH

77

78

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII...

CZY ADMIŃSTWO TO WIELKA RZECZ? -DNMXīZVSRPQLDQRNXOWXUDRUJDQL]DF\MQD:LNLSHGLLRSLHUDVLċQD VâXīHEQHMUROLNDīGHJRXī\WNRZQLNDPDMĆFHJRGRGDWNRZHXSUDZQLH QLD=XZDJLQDWRīHZLċNV]RğýUyOVSRâHF]QRğFLRZ\FKQDZHWPLPR LVWQLHQLDLFKIRUPDOQHJRRSLVXZSDMDQDMHVWZGURG]HQLHIRUPDOQHJR ]ī\ZDQLDVLċ]HVSRâHF]QRğFLĆ:HOVHULLQ LLFKSUDNW\NRZDQLD IXQNFMRQDULXV]RP:LNLSHGLLF]ċVWRSU]\SRPLQDVLċīHSHâQLĆIXQNFMċ VâXīHEQĆZVWRVXQNXGRLQQ\FK3RZLWDQLHQRZ\FKVWHZDUGyZQD NDQDOH,5&QLHZLHOHUyīQLVLċRGWHJRNWyUHRWU]\PDâHPRGGZyFK EDUG]LHMGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKNROHJyZ²Å:LWDMFLHQLHZROQLF\µ3RGREQLH ]DUyZQRQDDQJLHOVNLHMMDNLQDSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\ F]ċVWRQD]\ZDQLVĆÅFLHFLDPLµ]DğSU]\]QDQLHVWDWXVXDGPLQLVWUDWRUD ZLĆīHVLċ]ÅSU]HND]DQLHPPLRWâ\µEĆGĩPRSD$GPLQLVWUDWRURPF]ċVWR SU]\SRPLQDVLċīHQLHVĆZKLHUDUFKLLXPLHMVFRZLHQLZ\īHMRG]Z\ Nâ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZīHLFKJâRVMHVWWDNVDPRLVWRWQ\LīHQLHZROQR LPZ\NRU]\VW\ZDýSU]HND]DQ\FKLPXSUDZQLHĕ]ZâDV]F]D]DEH]SLH F]DQLDDUW\NXâyZXVXZDQLDLFKLEORNRZDQLDXī\WNRZQLNyZ ZVSR UDFKZNWyU\FKVĆVWURQĆ=DVDG\:LNLSHGLLVWDQRZLĆMHGQR]QDF]QLH īHÅJURQRDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZQLHSRZLQQRZ\HZROXRZDýZNLHUXQNX RGUċEQHMSRGJUXS\3RZLQQLRQLUDF]HMVWDQRZLýF]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFL E\ýUyZQLLQQ\PHG\WRURPQLHPLHýVSHFMDOQ\FKPRF\JG\HG\WXMĆ Z]Z\F]DMQ\VSRVyEµ:LHOXDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ]SHâQĆV]F]HURğFLĆSRG SLVXMHVLċSRGW\PHJDOLWDUQ\PVSRMU]HQLHPQDLFKIXQNFMċ -HGQR]QDMF]ċğFLHMSRZWDU]DQ\FKSRU]HNDGHâQDWHPDWDGPLQLVWUD WRUyZJâRVLīHÅE\FLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUHPWRQLFZLHONLHJRµ]RE>>HQ:LNL SHGLD12%,*'($/@@ &\WDWWHQSRFKRG]L]Z\SRZLHG]L-LPER:DOHVD ]SRF]ĆWNXURNX.ZHVWLDWDSRMDZLâDVLċQDSRF]ĆWNXNU\VWDOL ]RZDQLDVLċVWUXNWXU:LNLSHGLLOHF]XURVâDZUċF]GRUDQJL]DVDG\ RSLVXMĆFÀOR]RÀċSRG]LHODQĆSU]H]ZLHOXZLNLSHG\VWyZ &KFLDâE\PW\ONRSRZLHG]LHýīH]RVWDQLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUHPWR QLF ZLHONLHJR 3RP\ğODâHPīHWDNRGQLHFKFHQLDQDGDPXSUDZQLHQLDV\VRSDNLONX RVRERPNWyUHVLHG]ĆZSURMHNFLHRGMDNLHJRğF]DVX&KFLDâE\PUR]ZLDý DXUċPLVW\F\]PXLÅZâDG]\µRWDF]DMĆFĆWċIXQNFMċ7RīHXSUDZQLHQLD ZâDğFLZHGODDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZQLHVĆSU]\]QDZDQHNDīGHPXMHVWW\ONR NZHVWLĆUR]ZLĆ]DĕWHFKQLF]Q\FK

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA 1LHSRGREDPLVLċīHSRZVWDMHSRF]XFLHMDNRE\SU]\]QDQLHSUDZ DGPLQLVWUDWRUDE\âRF]\PğV]F]HJyOQ\P-LPER:DOHVOXWHJR OLVWDG\VNXV\MQD:LNL(1O

3RZ\īV]\IUDJPHQWF]ċVWRSU]\ZRâ\ZDQHMHVWZG\VNXVMDFKQDGUROĆ DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZSURMHNWDFK:MHGQHM]HVWDUV]\FKZHUVMLVWURQ\ >>HQ:LNLSHGLD$GPLQLVWUDWRUV@@Z\UDīRQHMHVWWRQDVWċSXMĆFR :SRF]ĆWNDFKLVWQLHQLD:LNLSHGLLZV]\VF\MHMXī\WNRZQLF\IXQNFMRQRZDOL MDNDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\²LQDGDOSRZLQQLWDNIXQNFMRQRZDý2GVDPHJR SRF]ĆWNXSRGNUHğODQRīHJURQRDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZQLHSRZLQQRZ\HZR OXRZDýZNLHUXQNXRGUċEQHMSRGJUXS\SRZLQQLRQLUDF]HMVWDQRZLý F]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFLLE\ýUyZQLNDīGHPXLQQHPXHG\WRURZL2JyOQLH DGPLQLVWUDFMDLXWU]\PDQLHGREUHJRVWDQX:LNLSHGLLVĆ]DGDQLDPLGOD NDīGHJRQLHZ\PDJDMĆF\PLQDU]ċG]LWHFKQLF]Q\FKSU]\]QDZDQ\FK DGPLQLVWUDWRURP

0LPRWHJRSU]\FDâ\PG\VNXUVLHRHJDOLWDUQRğFLE\FLHDGPLQLVWUD WRUHPMHVWZRF]DFKZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZZLHONĆVSUDZĆ&RZLċFHM DGPLQLVWUDWRU]\ZUD]]U]HF]\ZLVW\PLOXEZ\LPDJLQRZDQ\PLQDG Xī\FLDPLSU]\]QDQ\FKLPXSUDZQLHĕVĆRELHNWHPSUHWHQVML]DğVDP IDNWLVWQLHQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSRVWU]HJDVLċFRUD]F]ċğFLHMMDNR]QDN QLHUyZQRğFLZğUyGHG\WRUyZ']LHMHVLċWDNQLH]DOHīQLHZSROVNLHM LDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLMDNWHīZNLONXLQQ\FKSURMHNWDFKFRPRīH ZVND]\ZDýQDZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\WDPPRGHORUJDQL]DF\MQ\QLH]DğQD FHFKċFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QĆV\WXDFMLPLHMVFRZHMLZ\VWċSXMĆF\FKZGDQ\P SURMHNFLHRVyE1DZHWXī\WNRZQLF\SUyEXMĆF\Z\UZDýVLċ]SDUDOLīX GHF\]\MQHJRGRW\F]ĆFHJRSURFHVXSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕLVWDUDMĆF\ VLċX]GURZLýV\WXDFMċXZDīDMĆīHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\VWDQRZLĆF]ċğý SUREOHPX3U]\NâDGRZRXī\WNRZQLN'DQNF\WRZDQ\ZGRNXPHQFLH >>HQ:LNLSHGLD5I$BUHIRUPB@@VWZLHUG]Lâ 3RZLQQLğP\RGVHSDURZDýVLċRG]GHQHUZRZDQLDVSRâHF]QRğFLQDQDG Xī\FLD]HVWURQ\DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZMDNWHīVWDUDýVLċQLHUR]MHīGīDý NDQG\GDWyZNWyU]\GHF\GXMĆVLċZ\VWĆSLýRQDGDQLHLPXSUDZQLHĕ

-DNZLGDýRSUyF]ZDGSURFHVXSU]\]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕLVWQLHMH JâċEV]\SUREOHPRV]HUV]\P]DVLċJXGXīDF]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFLZLHU]\ ZSRG]LDâP\²RQLX]QDMĆFSU]\W\PDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ]DZ\VRFH

79

80

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... XSU]\ZLOHMRZDQĆ HOLWċ QLHXVWDQQLH QDGXī\ZDMĆFĆ QDGDQ\FK LP XSUDZQLHĕ 'RGDWNRZRZLHOHRVyEQLHREGDU]RQ\FKVWDWXVHPDGPLQLVWUDWRUD LQLHZLG]ĆF\FKRJUDQLF]HĕFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FKGODXSUDZQLHĕWHM JUXS\HG\WRUyZGRGDWNRZRPLWRORJL]XMHWċLWDNV\PEROLF]QĆUROċ

DYMISJONOWANIE 'XīDF]ċğýSUREOHPX]ZLĆ]DQHJR]SURFHVHP38$Z\ZRG]LVLċVWĆG īHDGPLQLVWUDWRUDQLHPRīQDâDWZRRGZRâDý*G\NDQG\GDWX]\VND Z\VWDUF]DMĆFRVLOQHSRSDUFLHVSRâHF]QRğFLZJâRVRZDQLXQDGQDGDQLHP PXXSUDZQLHĕWRRLOHQLH]âDPLH]DVDGZVWRSQLXX]DVDGQLDMĆF\P MHJR]DEORNRZDQLHOXERVĆG]HQLHSU]H].RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\XWU]\PXMH RQGRGDWNRZHXSUDZQLHQLDPLPRPRīOLZHMXWUDW\]DXIDQLD]HVWURQ\ VSRâHF]QRğFLMDNWHīPLPRPRīOLZHM]QLīNLVWDQGDUGyZG]LDâDQLD SRQLīHMPLQLPXPNWyUHJRRF]HNXMHVLċRGNDQG\GDWyZDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\ PRJĆQDSU]\NâDGZ\FRIDýVLċ]DNW\ZQHJRHG\WRZDQLDF]\QLHXSU]HM PLHVLċ]DFKRZ\ZDýFRPRīQDE\LP]DU]XFLýJG\E\GRSLHURNDQG\ GRZDOLQDRZĆIXQNFMċOHF]FRQLHMHVWQDW\OHZ\UDĩQHE\]DMĆâVLċQLPL .RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\EĆGĩLQQ\DGPLQLVWUDWRU 3XQNWZLG]HQLDZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZGDVLċSRGVXPRZDýNRPHQWD U]HPSR]RVWDZLRQ\PQDVWURQLHG\VNXVML-LPER:DOHVD>>HQ8VHUBWDO N-LPERB:DOHV$UFKLYHB@@ =QDF]QDF]ċğýSUREOHPXOHī\ZW\PīHVWDWXVDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSU]\ ]QDZDQ\MHVWGRī\ZRWQLRZLċFOXG]LHUHDJXMĆRGUD]XQDNDīG\V\JQDâ PyZLĆF\RW\PīHGDQ\Xī\WNRZQLNPRīHVLċGRWHMIXQNFMLQLHQDGD ZDý2F]\ZLVW\PUR]ZLĆ]DQLHPVĆWXNDGHQFMHJG\ī]\VNDOLE\ğP\ ZWHG\]DSHZQLHQLHīHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\NWyU]\SRVWċSXMĆZQLHRGSR ZLHGQLOXEFK\WU\VSRVyEFKRýQLHDīWDNGRNXF]OLZLHE\]DMPRZDâVLċ QLPL.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\ZNRĕFXGRURVQĆ7\ONRīHJURQDDGPLQL VWUDWRUyZQLHGDVLċSU]HNRQDýGRWHJRW\SXSURSR]\FMLīDGQ\PLDUJX PHQWDPLQDMF]ċğFLHMPDP\GRF]\QLHQLD]SRGHMğFLHPW\SXÅRGGDP

-HVWWRVWZLHUG]HQLHRJyOQHJG\īQDSU]\NâDGZV]ZHG]NLHM:LNLSHGLLDGPLQL VWUDWRUyZZ\ELHUDVLċQDQRZRFRURN

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA ÁDJċDGPLQLVWUDWRUDMDNPLMĆ]DELHU]HFLH]PRLFK]LPQ\FKPDUWZ\FK UĆNµ6KRUW%ULJDGH+DUYHVWHU%RULVWDON PDUFD87&

.ZHVWLDRJUDQLF]HQLDGâXJRğFLVSUDZRZDQLDIXQNFMLSU]H]DGPL QLVWUDWRUyZOXERWZDUFLDGURJLGRLFKRGZRâ\ZDQLDMHVWZ:LNLSHGLL WHPDWHPZLHOXJRUĆF\FKGHEDW2JyOQLH]DSDGâNRQVHQVXVFRGRWHJR īHGREU\PSRP\VâHPE\âRE\]PXV]HQLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZNWyU]\ VWUDFLOL]DXIDQLHVSRâHF]QRğFLGRUH]\JQDFML]IXQNFML1LHMHVWMHGQDN MDVQHMDN]RUJDQL]RZDýWRRGVWURQ\SUDNW\F]QHM1DMZLċNV]\PSUREOH PHPMHVWXVWDOHQLHNWRPRīHPLHýSUDZRGRXUXFKRPLHQLDSURFHGXU\ ²SRZLQQRWRE\ýZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRSURVWHOHF]Z\NOXF]DýG]LDâDQLDZDQ GDOLWUROOLLXī\WNRZQLNyZQLH]DGRZRORQ\FK]SUDZLGâRZRSRGMċW\FK SU]H]DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZG]LDâDĕ6DPLDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\SU]\]QDMĆīH FLċīNRVSUDZRZDýWċIXQNFMċGREU]HEH]]DGDUFLD]UyīQ\PLRVREDPL -DVQHMHVWīHZLċNV]Rğý]DEORNRZDQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZī\ZLXUD]ċ² X]QDMĆīH]RVWDOLQLHVSUDZLHGOLZLHSRWUDNWRZDQLDSU]\QDMPQLHMīH Z\PLHU]RQRLPNDUċQLHSURSRUFMRQDOQĆGRSRSHâQLRQ\FKZ\VWċSNyZ 7DNQDSUDZGċLPEDUG]LHMDGPLQLVWUDWRUDQJDīXMHVLċZG]LDâDQLD NWyUHSRZLQLHQZ\NRQ\ZDýW\PZLċNV]DV]DQVDQDWRīHEċG]LHVLOQLH QLHOXELDQ\SU]H]W\FKF]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFLNWyU\FKQLV]F]\FLHOVNLH ]DSċG\]RVWDâ\SRKDPRZDQHOHF]NWyU]\QLHVĆQD]DZV]HZ\NOXF]HQL ]SUDFZ:LNLSHGLL 2ERMċWQLHMDN]RVWDQLHRSUDFRZDQDSURFHGXUD RGELHUDQLDVWDWXVXDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSRZLQQDRQDGRW\F]\ýMHG\QLHW\FK NWyU]\IDNW\F]QLHQLHSUDZLGâRZRRGJU\ZDMĆVZRMĆUROċLQDGXī\ZDMĆ VZRLFKXSUDZQLHĕ 6SRâHF]QRğýQLHE\âDZVWDQLHRSUDFRZDýMDVQ\FK]DVDGRGZRâ\ZDQLD DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZLċFSRZVWDâRVWZRU]RQHQDSUċGFHSyâRÀFMDOQHUR] ZLĆ]DQLHF]ċğýDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZGREURZROQLHJRG]LVLċQDRGZRâDQLH ]SHâQLRQHMIXQNFML]DOHīQLHRGGRğýRJyOQLHVIRUPXâRZDQ\FK]DVDG :DUXQNLNWyUHPXVLVSHâQLýDGPLQLVWUDWRUSRGOHJDMĆF\GHPRNUDW\F] QHPXJâRVRZDQLXQDGRGHEUDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕVĆUyīQH0LċG]\SROVNĆ DDQJLHOVNĆ:LNLSHGLĆVĆZW\PZ]JOċG]LHSHZQHUR]ELHīQRğFLLQQH Z\VWċSXMĆQDZHWZUDPDFKMHGQHJRSURMHNWX²]XZDJLQDGREURZROQ\ FKDUDNWHUSURFHVXRGELHUDQLDXSUDZQLHĕNDīG\DGPLQLVWUDWRUPDSUDZR XVWDOLýZâDVQHZDUXQNL 1DMSRZV]HFKQLHMV]HZ\PRJLSURFHVXRGELHUDQLDXSUDZQLHĕDGPL QLVWUDWRUDZSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLWRSRSDUFLHZQLRVNXSU]H]FRQDMPQLHM WU]HFKUHGDNWRUyZ]FRQDMPQLHMHG\FMDPL²ZPDMXZNDWH JRULLRVyEJRWRZ\FKGRZHU\ÀNDFMLXSUDZQLHĕZSLVDQ\FKE\âR]H

81

82

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ:DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]DGPLQLVWUD WRUyZJRG]LVLċQDRGHEUDQLHXSUDZQLHĕQDSRGREQ\FKZDUXQNDFK FKRý]V]HUV]\PZDFKODU]HP]DVDGZ]DOHīQRğFLRGLQG\ZLGXDOQ\FK Z\ERUyZ1DOHī\MHGQDN]DXZDī\ýīHRNRâRDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ GRNRQDâRSRQLīHMHG\FMLZRNUHVLHGRZROQ\FKPLHVLċF\DLGHDZH U\ÀNDFMLXSUDZQLHĕMHVWEDUG]LHMSRSXODUQDZJURQLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ RZ\VRNLHMDNW\ZQRğFL -HVWHPMHGQ\P]DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZNWyU]\JRG]ĆVLċQDZHU\ÀNDFMċ XSUDZQLHĕ0yMSU]\SDGHNVWZRU]\âKLVWRULċZSROVNLHMZHUVMLMċ]\NRZHM %\âHPSLHUZV]\PLGRPDUFDMHG\Q\P DGPLQLVWUDWRUHPZVWR VXQNXGRNWyUHJRXUXFKRPLRQRSURFHGXUċZHU\ÀNDFMLXSUDZQLHĕFR VWDâRVLċZSDĩG]LHUQLNX'RğZLDGF]HQLDQDSHZQRQLHPRīQD QD]ZDýSU]\MHPQ\PDSRSRWZLHUG]HQLXPRMHMSU]\GDWQRğFLGODSURMHNWX MDNRDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSU]\SURFHQWRZ\PSRSDUFLX]GHF\GRZDâHP VLċQDRJUDQLF]HQLHPRīOLZRğFLZ\VWĆSLHQLDSU]\V]â\FKZHU\ÀNDFML Z\NOXF]DMĆF]JURQDRVyENWyUHPRJĆ]DLQLFMRZDýWHQSURFHVW\FK NWyU]\PDMĆQDNRQFLHEORNDG\OXEE\OL]HPQĆMDNRDGPLQLVWUDWRUHP ZNRQÁLNFLHEċGĆF\PSU]HGPLRWHPG]LDâDĕ.RPLWHWX$UELWUDīRZHJR 0RMDGHF\]MDVSRZRGRZDâDZ\âĆF]HQLHVLċ]JUXS\DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ JRWRZ\FKQDZHU\ÀNDFMċMHV]F]HNLONXRVyE0RīHLDGPLQLVWURZDQLH :LNLSHGLĆQLHMHVWÅZLHONĆVSUDZĆµDOHW\ONRGRSXQNWXZNWyU\PÁDJċ DGPLQLVWUDWRUDPRīQDVWUDFLý ']LċNLWHPXGRğZLDGF]HQLX]UR]XPLDâHPMHV]F]HGRELWQLHMīHE\FLH DGPLQLVWUDWRUHPMHVWGODPQLH]DLVWHGXīĆVSUDZĆ*G\E\PQLHX]\VNDâ SU]\QDMPQLHMSRSDUFLDXSUDZQLHQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUD]RVWDâ\E\PL RGHEUDQH1LHZLHPF]\QLHSU]HQLyVâE\PVLċZWHG\QDâDP\DQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLRJUDQLF]DMĆFVZyMXG]LDâZSROVNLHMZHUVMLMċ]\NRZHM3R GREQLHMDNQDGDQLHVWDWXVXDGPLQLVWUDWRUDMHVWR]QDNĆ]DXIDQLDMHJR RGHEUDQLHMHVWMDVQĆSU]HVâDQNĆEUDNX]DXIDQLD]HVWURQ\VSRâHF]QRğFL 8VWDQRZLHQLHMHGQROLWHMSURFHGXU\ZHU\ÀNDFMLXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQL VWUDWRUyZSRGREQLHMDNVROLGQH]UHIRUPRZDQLHSURFHVXSU]\]QDZDQLD RZ\FKXSUDZQLHĕPRīHE\ýWUXGQHJG\īDGPLQLVWUDFMD:LNLSHGLĆ MHVWZ\QLNLHPJâċERNR]DNRU]HQLRQHJRSRVWU]HJDQLDJâyZQLHSU]H] QLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZQLHUyZQRğFLHG\WRUyZ3URFHGXU\RVLĆJDQLD NRQVHQVXVXNWyU\PSRğZLċFRQ\MHVWF]ċğFLRZRNROHMQ\UR]G]LDâUyZ QLHīQLHVâXīĆWXSRPRFĆ


KLIKA &RFLHNDZHF]ċğýXī\WNRZQLNyZQLHW\ONRXZDīD:LNLSHGLċ]DKLHUDU FKLF]QĆLROLJDUFKLF]QĆOHF]WDNīHVĆG]LīHMHVWRQDVLHGOLVNLHPNOLN LÅJUXSZWDMHPQLF]Hĕµ0HW]E .RQFHSFMDNOLNLF]\VLWZ\MHVW Z:LNLSHGLLSU]HGPLRWHPG\VNXVMLRGVDPHJRSRF]ĆWNXLWRFDâ\F]DV SRZUDFDMĆF\PPDMĆF\PQDZHWVZRMHSRF]HVQHPLHMVFHZZLNLIRON ORU]H]RE>>HQ:LNLSHGLD5RXJHDGPLQ@@>>:LNLSHGLD*UXSDWU]\PD MĆFDZâDG]ċ@@ SHZQHJRURG]DMXVSXğFL]QĆSRNXOWXU]H8VHQHWXLKD NHUyZ3IDIIHQEHUJHU*URVVPDQ :VLHFL8VHQHWSRMDZLâD VLċNDVWDDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZÅEDURQyZµDXWRNUDW\F]QLH]DU]ĆG]DMĆF\FK VHUZHUDPLLXZDīDMĆF\FKVLċ]DRGPLHQQĆNDWHJRULċXī\WNRZQLNyZ 3IDIIHQEHUJHU &KRýDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\:LNLSHGLLPDMĆRZLHOH PQLHMV]HXSUDZQLHQLDQLīZ8VHQHFLHDZSUDNW\FHWHGZLHIXQNFMHâĆF]\ MHG\QLH]ELHīQRğýQD]ZVWUDFKSU]HGJUXSĆX]XUSXMĆFĆVRELHSUDZR NRQWUROLZV]\VWNLFKSR]RVWDâ\FKMHVWZ:LNLSHGLLIDNWHP-DNJâRV]Ć QDMEDUG]LHM]DJRU]DOLNU\W\F\:LNLSHGLLÅRGPLHQQLHRGEâċGQHJR SU]HNRQDQLDīHZV]\VF\Z\VWċSXMĆ]WHJRVDPHJRSR]LRPX:LNLSHGLċ FKDUDNWHU\]XMHVNRPSOLNRZDQDVWUXNWXUDKLHUDUFKLF]QDZNWyUHM SHâQRVLWZRUD]NRQÁLNWyZPLċG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLIUDNFMDPLµ)LQNHO VWHLQ :HJDOLWDUQ\PğURGRZLVNXNDīGHSRGHMU]HQLHQLHUyZQRğFL XSUDZQLHĕLPRīOLZRğFLZ\VWċSRZDQLDQDGXī\ýZâDG]\SRZRGXMH SRMDZLDQLHVLċNROHMQ\FK]QDNyZRVWU]HJDZF]\FKLWRQLH]DOHīQLHRG VWRSQLDSUDZG]LZRğFLSRGHMU]Hĕ.RQLHF]Q\D ,GHċGREU]HRGGDMH QDVWċSXMĆF\F\WDW3HWHUV $MHğOLNZHVWLRQXMHVLċG]LDâDQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUD:LNLSHGLL"Å1LJG]LH QLHGRMG]LHV]DWDNXMĆFDGPLQDµ1DZHWMHğOLU]HF]RQ\DGPLQQLHPD UDFML0URF]Q\VHNUHWDGPLQLVWURZDQLD:LNLSHGLĆPyZLīHMHVWWRNXOW VLHýNXPSOLSHZQHJRURG]DMXPDVRĕVNLH]U]HV]HQLH $GPLQLVWUDWRU]\]DZV]HSRSLHUDMĆLQQ\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZJG\ī OLF]ĆQDWRīHLLQQLVWDQĆZREURQLHÅLFKKDVHâµJG\SU]\MG]LHMDNLğ īyâWRG]LyE]]DPLDUHPLFKQDSUDZ\OXEGRNRQDQLD]PLDQ

,GHDNOLNLF]\ÅDGPLĕVNLHMPDÀLµMHVWī\ZD]DUyZQRZSROVNLHMMDN LDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL-HMFHQWUDOQ\PSXQNWHPMHVWSU]HNRQDQLHīH SHZQDJUXSDXī\WNRZQLNyZV]F]HJyOQLHOXG]LREGDU]RQ\FKGRGDW NRZ\PLXSUDZQLHQLDPL ZVSRVyEQLHZLG]LDOQ\]]HZQĆWU]SUyEXMH

83

84

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... U]ĆG]LýVSRâHF]QRğFLĆVWHUXMHQLĆNXDNFHSWDFMLSRP\VâyZNOLNL]DZV]H VWDZLDQDVZRLPDRGF]DVXGRF]DVX]ELRURZR]HZV]\VWNLFKVWURQ DWDNXMHUHEHOLDQWyZZDOF]ĆF\FKRSUDZG]LZĆZROQRğý2F]\ZLğFLH ZZLHOXSU]\SDGNDFKNRQFHSFMDLVWQLHQLDNOLNLMHVWW\SRZĆWHRULĆVSLV NRZĆZ\QLNDMĆFĆ]RGU]XFDQLDSU]H]Xī\WNRZQLNyZIDNWXīHPRJĆRQL QLHPLHýUDFML7DNLMHVWÅRÀFMDOQ\µREUD]SRSLHUDQ\SU]H]ZLHOXDGPL QLVWUDWRUyZQLHLVWQLHMHīDGQDDGPLQLVWUDWRUVNDNOLNDZG\VNXVMDFK DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLF]ċVWRVWRVXMHVLċVNUyW7,1&RGÅWKHUHLVQRFDEDOµ ]RE>>HQ:LNLSHGLD7,1&@@²WHQDUJXPHQWZ\WDF]DQ\MHVWQD]E\W F]ċVWR DRVRE\RGGDMĆFHVLċZL]MLLVWQLHQLDVHNUHWQHMVNRRUG\QRZDQHM JUXS\PRF\SRSURVWXVQXMĆWHRULHVSLVNRZH3DUDQRLF]QHZL]MHVĆ F]ċVW\PWHPDWHPīDUWyZZ:LNLSHGLLDWDNīHZLHOXSDURGLL²]RE >>HQ:LNLSHGLD/LVWRIFDEDOV@@L>>HQ:LNLSHGLD5RXJHDGPLQ@@ -DNRDGPLQLVWUDWRUSRG]LHODPSRJOĆGīHLVWQLHQLHMDNLHMNROZLHNNOLNL F]\VLWZ\DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZ:LNLSHGLLMHVWDEVXUGHPLğPLHMċVLċZUD] ]ÅNROHJDPLSRIDFKXµJG\WHPDWSRZUDFD-HVWHğP\EDUG]R]UyīQL FRZDQĆJUXSĆF]ċVWRQLHSRWUDÀĆFĆVLċGRJDGDýZVSUDZLHQDMRF]\ ZLVWV]\FKLSURVW\FKGHF\]MLNWRNROZLHNWZLHUG]LīHPRJOLE\ğP\ XWZRU]\ýVNRRUG\QRZDQĆJUXSċG]LDâDQLD]GHF\GRZDQLHSU]HFHQLD PRīOLZRğFLDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ 5yZQROHJOHMHGQDNQLHPRJċQLHZLG]LHýSHZQHJR]LDUQDSUDZG\ ZSRZUDFDMĆF\FKSRP\VâDFK-DNREDGDF]ZLHPīHZâDG]DZRUJDQL ]DFMLF]ċVWRZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQDMHVWSU]H]GRPLQXMĆF\FKJUDF]\ZFHOX XSUDZRPRFQLHQLDZâDVQ\FKīĆGDĕDWDNīHRğPLHV]HQLDīĆGDĕLQQ\FK =GHF\GRZDQLHMHVWPRīOLZHīHZQLHNWyU\FKSU]\SDGNDFKHG\FMH DQRQLPRZ\FKOXEğZLHī\FKVWDīHPXī\WNRZQLNyZFKRýPHU\WRU\F] QLHSRSUDZQHLX]DVDGQLRQHPRJĆ]RVWDýX]QDQH]DVNâDGRZHZRMQ\ HG\F\MQHM L QLHSRGGDQH V]F]HJyâRZHM DQDOL]LH SU]H] SLHUZV]HJR ]EU]HJXDGPLQLVWUDWRUDNWyU\SRSURVWXZ\FRIXMH]PLDQ\,QQLXī\W NRZQLF\ZLG]ĆFīHDGPLQLVWUDWRUZ\FRIXMH]PLDQ\Xī\WNRZQLND QLHEċGĆFHJRDGPLQLVWUDWRUHP]DNâDGDMĆīHQLHGRğZLDGF]RQ\ZLNL SHG\VWDMHVWNROHMQ\PLGHRORJLF]Q\PERMRZQLNLHPRRNUHğORQĆVSUDZċ LQLHZFKRG]ĆZV]F]HJyâ\FRRGZURWQLHQLīSURVWHZ\FRI\ZDQLH HG\FMLZ\PDJDâRE\Z\VLâNXZâRīRQHJRZ]UR]XPLHQLHUDFMLRE\GZX VWURQVHQVXZSURZDG]DQ\FK]PLDQSRF]\PGRSLHURPRJâRE\QDVWĆSLý SRGMċFLHGHF\]ML 3LHUZV]HZ\FRIDQLH]PLDQSU]H]DGPLQLVWUDWRUD PRīHZWDNLFKSU]\SDGNDFKXVWDOLýWUHQGWUDNWRZDQLDNROHMQ\FK HG\FMLSRFKRG]ĆF\FKRGWHMVDPHMRVRE\

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA &]ċVWRZâDğQLHWDNLH]DFKRZDQLDWZRU]ĆZUDīHQLHLVWQLHQLDNOLNL =GDU]DVLċīHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\RSLHUDMĆVZRMHGHF\]MHQDRSLQLLLQQ\FK DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZF]\HG\WRUyZRGXī\P]DXIDQLX2ZLHOHâDWZLHM SU]\MĆý]DSHZQLNīHLQQ\DGPLQLVWUDWRUOXEXī\WNRZQLNRGâXJLHM DNW\ZQRğFLZSURMHNFLHPLDâUDFMċ6]\ENRVSHâQLDVLċZWHQVSRVyE GREU\XF]\QHNL]ZLċNV]DOLF]QLNHG\FMLRMHGHQ7DN]DZV]HSRZLQQR VLċVSUDZG]Dý]PLHQLRQHWUHğFLDSRVWZLHUG]HQLXīHQLHMHVWHğP\ Z\VWDUF]DMĆFRNRPSHWHQWQLGRSRGMċFLDGHF\]MLRZ\FRIDQLXHG\FML SRZLQQRVLċSRZVWU]\PDýRGG]LDâDQLD-HGQDNSU]HZDīDZâDğQLH WDNLH]DFKRZDQLHLF]ċVWRZ\VWDUF]DWRGRVWZRU]HQLDDWPRVIHU\QLH VSUDZLHGOLZRğFLLUR]VLHZDQLDZL]MLVROLGDUQRğFLZğUyGDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ %\E\ýMHGQDNXF]FLZ\PPXV]ċQDGPLHQLýīH]GDU]DQDPVLċ]PD ZLDýSU]HFLZXī\WNRZQLNRPSU]\QDMPQLHMZRJUDQLF]RQ\PWHJRVWZLHU G]HQLD]QDF]HQLX&RRF]\ZLVWHQLHURELĆWHJRZV]\VF\FKRýF]ċğý SURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLDPDOLVW\G\VNXV\MQHGRVWċSQHZ\âĆF]QLHGOD DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZJG]LHF]DVDPLG\VNXWXMHVLċQDGSURSRQRZDQ\PLZVWR VXQNXGRRNUHğORQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZX]QDZDQ\FK]DSUREOHPDW\F]QH SU]\SDGNL G]LDâDQLDPL:LHOXDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZROLSRSURVLýZV\WXD FMLJG\PRīHP\ZHMğýZZRMQċHG\F\MQĆPLċG]\VDP\PLDGPLQLVWUD WRUDPLRSRPRFNRJRğÅSRIDFKXµ=GDU]DVLċQDPWHīNRQVXOWRZDý ZV\WXDFMDFKNLHG\ZQDV]\PPQLHPDQLXSRWU]HEQHMHVWğZLHīHVSRM U]HQLHQDSUREOHP1LHPDZW\PRF]\ZLğFLHQLF]âHJRJG\īRGQRV]ĆF VLċGRRFHQ\V\WXDFMLSU]H]NRJRğLQQHJRSR]ZDODP\QDRFHQċQDV]\FK ZâDVQ\FKG]LDâDĕ6NRURMHGQDNQDMFKċWQLHMSURVLP\RSRPRFW\FK NWyU\FKGREU]H]QDP\LFRGRNWyU\FKPDP\GXīRSHZQRğFLīHSR G]LHOĆQDV]SXQNWZLG]HQLDF]ċVWRSRGHMPXMĆFSRGREQHNURNLSR]D :LNLSHGLĆXī\WNRZQLNEċGĆF\SU]HGPLRWHPWDNLHJRG]LDâDQLDPD SUDZRF]XýVLċRVDF]RQ\0RīHWHJRQLHZHUEDOL]RZDýOHF]F]XMHīH MHVWSU]HGPLRWHPUR]JU\ZHNZâDG]\QDZHWMHğOLQLHMHVWZVWDQLH REURQLýVZRMHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDW\PLVDP\PLğURGNDPLFRLQWHUOR NXWRU]\JG\īDQLQLHPDZ:LNLSHGLLÅZ\VRNRSRVWDZLRQ\FKµNRQWDN WyZDQLVDPQLHMHVWQDRGSRZLHGQLRVWDELOQHMSR]\FML-HVWRF]\ZLVWH īHRUJDQL]DFMHRUR]OXĩQLRQHMKLHUDUFKLLVĆSRGDWQHQDVWUDWHJLHGRPL QDFMLZVSRâHF]QRğFL+DOH\L6LGDQLXV ]DğWRFRDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\ SRVWU]HJDMĆMDNRHOHJDQFNLHRGQLHVLHQLHVLċGRSUREOHPyZXī\WNRZ QLNDZNWyU\PNLONDRVyESRNROHLWâXPDF]\PXUyīQHDVSHNW\PRīH ]RVWDýX]QDQHSU]H]Hĕ]D]PDVRZDQ\DWDNZNWyU\PDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\ PDMĆOHSV]ĆSR]\FMċZVSRâHF]QRğFLQDU]ċG]LDLSURFHGXU\SR]ZDODMĆFH

85

86

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... QD]DīHJQDQLHNRQÁLNWXQDZHWZWHG\JG\G]LDâDMĆZSRMHG\QNċ'Rğý SUDZGRSRGREQHMHVWUyZQLHīīHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\EċGĆXPQLHMV]Dý ZDJċW\FK]DFKRZDĕVZRLFKNROHJyZNWyUHQLHVĆ]JRGQH]RÀFMDOQ\PL UHJXâDPLSURMHNWX*ODVIRUGLLQ FRMHV]F]HXPDFQLDZXī\WNRZ QLNDFKSRF]XFLHQLHZâDğFLZHJRLFKSRWUDNWRZDQLD %\ýPRīH]XZDJLQDRZĆQLHUyZQRğýZNZHVWLDFKNDSLWDâXVSR âHF]QHJRVDPIDNWPRīOLZRğFLNRPXQLNRZDQLDVLċDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ QD]DPNQLċWHMOLğFLHG\VNXV\MQHMGHQHUZXMHZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZ-DN VWZLHUG]LâSHZLHQZ\VRFHNU\W\F]Q\ZVWRVXQNXGR:LNLSHGLLVHUZLV RIHUXMĆF\VZRLPXī\WNRZQLNRPDOWHUQDW\ZQ\PRGHOUR]ZLMDQLD WUHğFLHQF\NORSHG\F]Q\FK :SURZDG]RQRVNRPSOLNRZDQHV\VWHP\NRQWUROLSR]ZDODMĆFHQD]D PURīHQLH]DZDUWRğFL:LNLSHGLLZIRUPLHNWyUDMHVW]JRGQD]ZL]MĆ -LPER:DOHVD3RZLHU]FKRZQLH:LNLSHGLDZ\GDMHVLċSU]HMU]\VWDRG ZLHG]DMĆF\VĆZVWDQLHSU]HğOHG]LýKLVWRULHHG\FMLLG\VNXVMHNDīGHJR Xī\WNRZQLND,VWQLHMĆGXīHREV]DU\:LNLSHGLLSRZLHODMĆFHVFKHPDW\ SRVWċSRZDQLDVĆGRZHJRMDNWHīUyīQHSURFHV\]DVDG\G\VNXVMH -HGQDN]DNXOLVDPL-LPERZUD]]JDUVWNĆDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZNRQ WUROXMHG]LDâDQLHVHUZLVX]DSRPRFĆOLVWG\VNXV\MQ\FK.RPLWHW$UEL WUDīRZ\PDZâDVQĆOLVWċG\VNXV\MQĆVĆWHīOLVW\RQD]ZDFKÅLQWHUQDOOµ LÅSULYDWHOµ

)DNWNRPXQLNRZDQLDVLċDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZVZRLPJURQLHEH]NRQ WUROLVSRâHF]QRğFLE\âWHPDWHPNLONXUR]JRU]Dâ\FKG\VNXVML]DUyZQR ZDQJLHOVNLHMMDNLSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLLNLONDNURWQLHJâyZQLHSR ]QDF]Q\FKEâċGDFKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZVWDZDâVLċRELHNWHPRVWUHMNU\ W\NLÅ6HNUHWQDµOLVWDG\VNXV\MQD]RVWDâDUyZQLHīRSLVDQDZSUDVLH LQIRUPDW\F]QHM0HW] 3RMDZLâ\VLċNRQWURZHUVMH]ZLĆ]DQH]JâyZQ\PLZVSyâUHGDNWRUDPL HQF\NORSHGLLSRW\PMDNMHGHQ]Xī\WNRZQLNyZXMDZQLâīHF]RâRZLDG PLQLVWUDWRU]\SURMHNWXXī\ZDMĆWDMQHMOLVW\G\VNXV\MQHMGRQDNâDGDQLD VDQNFML]D]DXZDīRQH]DJURīHQLDLFKZâDG]\ :LHOXSRGHMU]HZDâRMXīīHWDNDOLVWDE\âDZXī\FLXJG\ÅHOLW\U]ĆG]ĆFHµ :LNLSHGLĆFRUD]F]ċğFLHM]DMPRZDâ\VLċHOLPLQRZDQLHPXī\WNRZQLNyZ

KWWSHQF\FRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLDZHUVMD]VW\F]QLDGRVWċSNZLHWQLD

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA ]MDNNROZLHNQLHZDīNLFKSRZRGyZ3RSRWZLHUG]HQLXLVWQLHQLDOLVW\ G\VNXV\MQHMV]HUHJRZLHG\WRU]\VWRMĆQDVNUDMXUHZROXFML

-HVWMDVQHīHLVWQLHQLHQLHSXEOLF]Q\FKNDQDâyZNRPXQLNDFMLSUR ZRNXMHGRVQXFLDIDQWDVW\F]Q\FKWHRULL-HGQDNSRP\VâMDNRE\DGPL QLVWUDWRU]\DNW\ZQLHEUDOLQDFHORZQLNÅ]DXZDīRQH]DJURīHQLDLFK ZâDG]\µQLHVSUDZG]DVLċZSUDNW\FH*G\E\WDNE\âRRGZDīQLERKD WHURZLHZDOF]ĆF\ZLPLċVSUDZLHGOLZRğFLE\OLE\SU]HğODGRZDQLUyZQLHī SRGF]DVJâRVRZDĕ38$NWyUH²FRFLHNDZH²XSDGDMĆ]Z\NOH]DVSUDZĆ JâRVyZXī\WNRZQLNyZQLHEċGĆF\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUDPL]DğZLNLSHG\ğFL SURSRQXMĆF\UHIRUP\V\VWHPXZW\PVXJHUXMĆF\QRZHVSRVRE\ZH U\ÀNDFMLXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZV]\ENR]RVWDOLE\SREORNRZDQL FRVLċMHGQDNQLHG]LHMH'RGDWNRZRMDNMXīZVSRPQLDQRDGPLQLVWUD WRU]\QLHVWDQRZLĆMHGQRURGQHMJUXS\WDNQDSUDZGċVSRâHF]QRğý DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZMHVWZ\VRFH]UyīQLFRZDQDMHğOLFKRG]LRRSLQLHSU]H NRQDQLDLSXQNW\ZLG]HQLDQDSRV]F]HJyOQHNZHVWLH'\VNXVMDQDG LVWQLHQLHPNOLNSRWZLHUG]DMHGQDNRF]\ZLVWĆNZHVWLċRJUDQLF]DQLH GRVWċSXGRMDNLHMNROZLHNIXQNFMLV]F]HJyOQLHZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKZ\VRNR ZDUWRğFLXMĆF\FKUyZQRğýQDW\FKPLDVWXUDVWDGRUDQJLV\PEROXVWDWXVX GODSRVLDGDF]\GRGDWNRZ\FKXSUDZQLHĕSU]\F]\PXī\WNRZQLF\WDNLFK XSUDZQLHĕSR]EDZLHQL]DF]\QDMĆRZ\FKSRVLDGDF]\QLHQDZLG]Lý 3UREOHPXQLHGDVLċUR]ZLĆ]DýSURVW\PLğURGNDPLJG\īS\WDQLH LQQ\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZRRSLQLċMHVWRJyOQLHU]HF]XMPXMĆFGREUĆ SUDNW\NĆ:\PXV]DQLHE\ZV]\VWNLHWHJRW\SXNRQVXOWDFMHSU]HELH JDâ\]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPSXEOLF]Q\FKNDQDâyZNRPXQLNDFMLQLHPD VHQVXJG\īZSLV\QDDGPLQLVWUDF\MQHMWDEOLF\RJâRV]HĕVSRZRGRZDâ\E\ ]DOHZLQIRUPDFML2F]\ZLğFLHPRīQDZSURZDG]LýSHZQHPHFKDQL]P\ NRQWUROLVSRâHF]QHMXWU]\PXMĆFDUFKLZDSXEOLF]Q\FKRWZDUW\FK OLVW G\VNXV\MQ\FK=MDZLVNRGĆīHQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZGRZ]DMHPQ\FKNRQ WDNWyZL]QDMRPRğFLSR]DSURWRNRâHPMHVWMHGQDN]DUyZQRSR]\W\ZQH MDNLQLHXQLNQLRQH8SXEOLF]QLHQLHOLVWG\VNXV\MQ\FKQDMSUDZGRSR GREQLHMQLHSRFLĆJQċâRE\]HVREĆLFKHOLPLQDFMLW\ONRSU]HQLHVLHQLH QLHRÀFMDOQ\FKNDQDâyZNRPXQLNDFMLJG]LHLQG]LHM1DOHī\]DXZDī\ý īHZW\PSU]\SDGNXPHWRG\RUJDQL]DFML:LNLSHGLLVNXWNXMĆSRMDZLH QLHPVLċ]QDF]QHMUR]ELHīQRğFLPLċG]\HJDOLWDUQĆKLVWRU\MNĆRW\PīH ZV]\VF\Z:LNLSHGLLVĆUyZQLDSUDNW\NĆZNWyUHMGRPLQXMĆHG\WRU]\ RGâXJLHMKLVWRULLG]LDâDOQRğFLZSURMHNFLH =SUDNW\F]QHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDQLHMDZQHNDQDâ\NRPXQLNDFML PRJĆVWDýVLċ]DZRUHPEH]SLHF]HĕVWZDGODNDQDâyZRWZDUW\FKFR

87

88

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... QDELHUDV]F]HJyOQHJR]QDF]HQLDZğZLHWOH]QDF]QHMUR]FLĆJâRğFLNRQ WUROLELXURNUDFMLZ:LNLSHGLLEċGĆFHMSU]HGPLRWHPG\VNXVMLMHGQHJR ]NROHMQ\FKUR]G]LDâyZNVLĆīNL :]DVDG]LHSU]H]FDâ\F]DVZV]\VF\ Xī\WNRZQLF\]QDMGXMĆVLċSRGNRQWUROĆVSRâHF]QRğFLRGF]HJRMHG\Q\P RGVWċSVWZHPMHVWOLVWDG\VNXV\MQD3R]ZDODRQDUyZQLHīQDV]F]HUH Z\UDīDQLHQLHPRGHURZDQ\FKRSLQLLQDWHPDWG]LDâDĕLQQ\FKDGPLQL VWUDWRUyZLXVWDQDZLDQLHNRQVHQVXVXLFKZ\FRI\ZDQLDMHğOLMHVWWR NRQLHF]QH -HGQDNMDNVWZLHUG]Lâ)RXFDXOWÅOXG]LHZLHG]ĆFRURELĆF]ċVWR ZLHG]ĆGODF]HJRURELĆWRFRURELĆQLHZLHG]ĆMHGQDNF]HJRWRFRURELĆ GRNRQXMHµF\WRZDQ\Z'UH\IXVL5DELQRZ -HVWMDVQHīH ]DFKRZDQLDDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZGRNRQ\ZDQHZGREUHMZLHU]HLZâDğFLZH GODQLFKPHWRG\NRPXQLNDFMLPRJĆVWZRU]\ýZL]HUXQHNLVWQLHQLDNOLNL QDZHWZXP\VâDFKZLNLSHG\VWyZNWyU]\VDPLHG\WXMĆ]JRGQLH]]DVD GDPLQLHPyZLĆFMXīRRVREDFK]]HZQĆWU]:RUJDQL]DFMLRGREURZRO Q\PXF]HVWQLFWZLHNWyUDMDNRQDGU]ċGQĆ]DVDGċJâRVLUyZQRğýZV]\VW NLFKXī\WNRZQLNyZQDMVâDEV]HV\JQDâ\ğZLDGF]ĆFHRW\PīH]DVDGD WDQLHMHVWSU]HVWU]HJDQDPRJĆZ\ZRâDýIUXVWUDFMċLJQLHZXF]HVWQL NyZ-HğOLRÀFMDOQLHZ\UDīDQH]DVDG\SURPXMĆDKLHUDUFKLF]QRğýOHF] ZVSRâHF]QRğFLGDMĆVLċ]DXZDī\ýPDQLIHVWDFMHKLHUDUFKLLZW\PQLH MDZQHNDQDâ\NRPXQLNDFMLRVRE\GODNWyU\FKRZHNDQDâ\QLHVĆGR VWċSQHNRQNOXGXMĆīHDKLHUDUFKLF]QRğýMHVWIDâV]HPGRZRG]ĆF\P NRQWUDVWyZZHZQĆWU]VSRâHF]QRğFL&RZLċFHMPRJĆRQLF]XýSRWU]HEċ RGHJUDQLDVLċQDSRVLDGDF]DFKGRGDWNRZ\FKSU]\ZLOHMyZ -HGQ\P]SRZRGyZGODNWyU\FK38$ZZLHOXSURMHNWDFKVWDMHVLċ WDNPċF]ĆF\PGRğZLDGF]HQLHPPRīHE\ýIDNWīHJâRVRZDQLDQDG SU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDVĆMHG\Q\PZ\UD]HPZâDG]\ QDGDGPLQLVWUDFMĆVSUDZRZDQHMSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý1DWXUDOQHMHVW īHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\F]ċVWRSU]HNUDF]DMĆF\VZRMHXSUDZQLHQLDWUDFĆ QDGDQHLPSU]\ZLOHMH'RW\F]\WRMHGQDNMHG\QLHPQLHMV]RğFLDGPLQL VWUDWRUyZ:LċNV]RğýVWRVXMĆFVLċ]JUXEV]DGRZ\W\F]Q\FKMHVW QLHW\NDOQDQDZHWMHğOLMDVQHMHVWīHVSRâHF]QRğýQLHZ\EUDâDE\LFK QDIXQNFMċDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSRQRZQLHWDNLHRVRE\QLHWUDFĆVWDWXVX DGPLQLVWUDWRUDWDNGâXJRMDNQLHSU]HNUDF]DMĆJUDQLF\SR]ZDODMĆFHM QDZHU\ÀNDFMċOXERGHEUDQLHXSUDZQLHĕ38$WRMHG\Q\SURFHVZNWy U\PXī\WNRZQLF\PRJĆSURWHVWRZDýSU]HFLZNR]UyīQLFRZDQLXSU]\ ZLOHMyZ&RFLHNDZHMDNMXīZVSRPQLDQRDQLZSROVNLHMDQLZDQJLHO VNLHM:LNLSHGLLQLHPDMDVQ\FKSURFHGXURGZRâ\ZDQLDLZHU\ÀNRZDQLD

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA XSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğýFRSRQRZQLHSRWZLHUG]D IDNWīHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\VWDQRZLĆXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQĆNDVWċ

EGALITARNY SYSTEM WŁADZY 8F]HVWQLFWZRZG\VNXVMDFKVSRâHF]QRğFLLMHMRUJDQL]DFMDFKMHVW]ZLĆ ]DQHMDNWZLHUG]LWHRULDZ\PLDQ\]RND]MĆGR]\VNDQLDDSUREDW\ V]DFXQNXOXEVWDWXVXZJURQLHLQQ\FKRVyE%ODX %XGRZDQLH UHSXWDFMLLX]QDQLDZVSRâHF]QRğFLZLUWXDOQHMMHVWLVWRWQ\PPRW\ZD WRUHPGRXF]HVWQLFWZDZG]LDâDQLDFKRZHMVSRâHF]QRğFL'RQDWK SRGREQLHMDNPDWRPLHMVFHZWUDG\F\MQ\FKğURGRZLVNDFKSUDF\ +HU]EHUJLLQ :SU]\SDGNX:LNLSHGLLU\WXDâ\EXGRZDQLDVWD WXVXLVSRVRE\DXWRSUH]HQWDFMLZVSRâHF]QRğFLRPyZLRQHZSRSU]HGQLP UR]G]LDOHMDNWHī]\VNDQLHSRSDUFLDZVSyâHG\WRUyZSU]H]SU]\MċFLHQD VLHELHUROLDGPLQLVWUDWRUDLZ\īV]\FKIXQNFML SU]HGVWDZLRQHZQLQLHM V]HMF]ċğFLVĆPRW\ZXMĆFHLZRF]\ZLVW\VSRVyELVWRWQHGODHJ]HNZR ZDQLDZâDG]\LKLHUDUFKLL%\ýPRīHZâDğQLH]XZDJLQDXF]HVWQLF]ĆFĆ LHJDOLWDUQĆVWUXNWXUċSURMHNWXVDPDREHFQRğýXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQ\FK UyOZ\ZRâXMHQLHSURSRUFMRQDOQHGRVZRMHJRFKDUDNWHUXQLHSRNRMHSR GREQLHGRQLHVSRNRMQ\FKUHODFMLPLċG]\VSRâHF]QRğFLĆ:LNLSHGLLD:LNL PHGLD)RXQGDWLRQFRMHVWWHPDWHPMHGQHJR]GDOV]\FKUR]G]LDâyZ 2GVZRMHJRSRZVWDQLD:LNLSHGLDRSLHUDâDVLċQLHQDKLHUDUFKLLRUJD QL]DF\MQHMF]\ĩUyGâDFKQLHIRUPDOQHMZâDG]\DQDNXPXORZDQHMUHSX WDFML&LIIROLOOL %XGRZDQLHVWDWXVXZVSRâHF]QRğFLMHVWSHZQHJR URG]DMXPHFKDQL]PHPX]DOHīQLHQLDXWU]\PXMĆF\PZ\VRNĆPRW\ZDFMċ F]âRQNyZJUXS\QDMDNW\ZQLHMV]\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZ*HRUJH -DNSRND]XMHQLQLHMV]\UR]G]LDâNXOWXUD:LNLSHGLL]DUyZQRMHMZHUVML SROVNLHMMDNLDQJLHOVNLHMSRGĆī\âDZNLHUXQNXGRFHQLDQLDRVWHQWDF\M QLHZLGRF]Q\FKSRğZLċFHĕQSSRğZLċFDQLDF]DVXQDELMDQLXOLF]QLND HG\FML QLH]DğIDNW\F]Q\FK]\VNyZGODHQF\NORSHGLL/LF]EċHG\FMLGR FHQLDVLċ]QDF]QLHVLOQLHMQLīLFKMDNRğýDW\VLĆFGUREQ\FKSRSUDZHN SRPDJDZSRGQLHVLHQLXVWDWXVXZVSRâHF]QRğFLRZLHOHEDUG]LHMQLī VWZRU]HQLHSHUIHNF\MQHJRDUW\NXâXRW\VLĆFXVâyZ3URFHVMHVWSRGREQ\ GRWHJRFR/HVOLH3HUORZQD]ZDâDÅLQG\ZLGXDOQ\PKHURL]PHPµ3HUORZ X]QDQLHRUJDQL]DFMLGODWHDWUDOQ\FKJHVWyZLV\PEROLGRPLQXMH QDGFLFKĆV\VWHPDW\F]QĆSUDFĆ:\VWċSRZDQLHWHJRSURFHVXQLHMHVW

89

90

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]DVNDNXMĆFHZSUDF\RSDUWHMQDZLHG]\-HPLHOQLDND-HPLHO QLDND OHF]IDNWīHOLF]EDHG\FMLGHF\GXMHRZDUWRğFLZVSRVyE QLH]DOHīQ\RGGHPRNUDW\F]QLHREVDG]DQ\FKVWDQRZLVNMHVWQDMSUDZ GRSRGREQLHMMXīQLH]GURZ\GODSURMHNWXZXMċFLXGâXJRIDORZ\PJG\ī RGVWUDV]DRGXF]HVWQLFWZDW\FKNWyU]\ZROHOLE\VSHFMDOL]RZDýVLċ ZSRZDīQLHMV]\FKHG\FMDFKZ\VRNLHMMDNRğFL7DNLSURFHVMHVWMHGQDN FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\GODSRVWċSXMĆFHMELXURNUDW\]DFMLRUJDQL]DFML%ODX L6FRWW FREċG]LHSU]HGPLRWHPG\VNXVMLZMHGQ\P]NROHMQ\FK UR]G]LDâyZ 2EVHVMDQDSXQNFLHOLF]E\HG\FMLPRīHE\ý]ZLĆ]DQD]LQQ\PMHV]F]H ]MDZLVNLHP-DNWZLHUG]L$OI5HKQ VSRâHF]QRğFLZDUH]RZH SLUDFNLHJRRSURJUDPRZDQLD RSLHUDMĆVLċQDNXOWXU]HGDUyZ3U]HVâDQLH GRVLHFLRSURJUDPRZDQLDMHVWV\PEROLF]Q\PJHVWHPSRWZLHUG]DMĆF\P XF]HVWQLFWZRZVSRâHF]QRğFLZ]PDFQLDMĆF\PVWDWXVÅRÀDURGDZF\µ ,QQLQDXNRZF\GRGDMĆīHVSRâHF]QRğFLRWZDUWHJRRSURJUDPRZDQLD VWRVXMĆ]DVDGċRÀDURZ\ZDQLDZFHOX]RUJDQL]RZDQLDUHODFMLZHZQĆWU] VSRâHF]QRğFLRZ\FK5D\PRQG%HUJTXLVWL/MXQJEHUJ .HOW\ 6WDQRZLĆRQHVSHF\ÀF]Q\ÅPDULDīDOWUXL]PX LNRQFHQWUDFMLQDVDP\PVRELHµ5KHLQJROG LWZRU]ĆJRVSR GDUNċSRGDUXQNyZSRVWNDSLWDOLVW\F]QĆIRUPċVSRâHF]HĕVWZD%DU EURRN 3RGREQLHMHVWZSU]\SDGNX:LNLSHGLL²OLF]EDHG\FMLVWDQRZLVLOQĆ ZDUWRğýV\PEROLF]QĆZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQĆZRNUHğODQLXSR]\FMLMHGQRVWNL ZJUXSLH0RīOLZHīHVWRVXMHVLċMĆZREOLF]XEUDNXLQQ\FKğURGNyZ EĆGĩWHī]XZDJLQDSUHIHURZDQLHSRPLDUXSRQLHVLRQ\FKRÀDUQDGZDU WRğFLRZDQLHPZNâDGX3U]\F]\QĆPRīHWXE\ýHIHNWXERF]Q\RJyOQHM ÀOR]RÀLHJDOLWDU\]PXSRğUHGQLRZ\PXV]DMĆF\LVWQLHQLHğURGRZLVND ZNWyU\POXG]LHRQDMZ\īV]\FK]GROQRğFLDFKGR]DRIHURZDQLDLQWHOHN WXDOQHJRZNâDGXQLHSRZLQQLGRPLQRZDýQDGVSRâHF]QRğFLĆ1LH]D OHīQLHRGSRZ\īV]HJROLF]EDGRNRQDQ\FKHG\FMLRGSRZLDGDVWDWXVRZL Xī\WNRZQLNDZVSRâHF]QRğFL&LIIROLOOL5DIDHOLL$ULHO

:DUWRWXQDGPLHQLýīH]MDZLVNDGREURZROQHMLQLHPDWHULDOQHMSUDF\W\SRZH GODVSRâHF]QRğFLRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXZVSyâSUDF\MDNWHīUXFKX)/266]ZLĆ]DQH ]SRGDUXQNRZ\PFKDUDNWHUHPHSRNLSRVWNDSLWDOLVW\F]QHMPRīQDUyZQLHīSR VWU]HJDýZNDWHJRULDFKQRZ\FKVSRVREyZQDVSUDZRZDQLHNRQWUROLQDGSURGXNFMĆ LSHUVZD]MċLGHRORJLF]QĆNXRILDURZDQLXSUDF\]DGDUPR7HUUDQRYD Å]GH NRGRZDQĆµLSU]HNRQVWUXRZDQĆZVFHQDULXV]]\VNRZQRğFL'HOHX]HL*XDWWDUL

FORMALNE ROLE ORAZ HIERARCHIA :P\ğONODV\F]QHMZHEHURZVNLHMGHÀQLFMLZâDG]DWRÅSUDZGRSRGR ELHĕVWZRīHMHGHQ]XF]HVWQLNyZ]ZLĆ]NXVSRâHF]QHJREċG]LHZVWDQLH Z\HJ]HNZRZDýZâDVQ\SRP\VâSRPLPRRSRUXµ:HEHU :W\PXMċFLXRUJDQL]DFMD:LNLSHGLLMHVWVNUDMQLHSR]EDZLRQDHOHPHQWX ZâDG]\]DğMHGQRVWNLQLH]DOHīQLHRGVSUDZRZDQHMUROLQLHPRJĆ QDU]XFDýVZRMHMZROLSR]RVWDâ\P %UDNZâDG]\LQG\ZLGXDOQHMQLHVSUDZLDMHGQDNīH:LNLSHGLDQLH MHVWSRVWU]HJDQDMDNRRUJDQL]DFMDKLHUDUFKLF]QD']LHMHVLċWDNJG\ī ZRGF]XFLXZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZQLHEċGĆF\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUDPLDGPLQL XWZRU]\OLRGUċEQĆXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQĆNDVWċXī\WNRZQLNyZ0LPRīH UyīQLFDZHZSâ\ZLHQDNV]WDâWDUW\NXâyZMDNWHīQDSURFHVSRGHMPR ZDQLDGHF\]MLZUDPDFKRUJDQL]DFMLPLċG]\DGPLQLVWUDWRUDPLDQLH DGPLQLVWUDWRUDPLMHVWPLQLPDOQDV]F]HJyOQLHMHğOLZ]LĆýSRGXZDJċ LVWQLHQLHGXīHMOLF]E\QLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZRZ\VRNLPVWDWXVLHZVSR âHF]QRğFL DNXOWXUD:LNLSHGLL]DNâDGDīHSRVLDGDQLHGRGDWNRZ\FK XSUDZQLHĕQLHSU]HNâDGDVLċQDZ\īV]\VWDWXVOXEZLċNV]ĆZâDG]ċ ZVSRâHF]QRğFLZğUyGQLHNWyU\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZGRPLQXMHSRVWU]HJDQLH QLHUyZQRğFLVSRâHF]QHM-HVWRQRGRGDWNRZRSRGV\FDQHZ]DMHPQ\P SRSLHUDQLHPVLċDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZZUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLXNRQÁLNWyZ]SR V]F]HJyOQ\PLXī\WNRZQLNDPLMDNWHīIDNWHPLVWQLHQLDNDQDâyZNRPX QLNDFMLPLċG]\DGPLQLVWUDWRUDPLNWyUHOHīĆSR]D]DVLċJLHPNRQWUROL SXEOLF]QHM0LPRīHDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\QLHXZDīDMĆZVSyâSUDF\LNRPX QLNDFMLPLċG]\VREĆ]DRSUHV\MQHDWDNīHPLPRLVWQLHQLDRVWU\FKQRUP ]DFKRZDQLDG]LċNLNWyU\PXī\ZDMĆEDUG]LHMVWRQRZDQHJRMċ]\NDQLī QRZRSU]\E\OLLQDF]HMQLīZWUDG\F\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMDFKSRU0RUDQG ZNRĕFXWZRU]ĆRQLV\VWHPGRPLQDFMLFKRýE\SU]H]Z\NRU]\ VW\ZDQLHGRVWċSQ\FKNRQWDNWyZQDFLVNQD]UR]XPLHQLHORNDOQ\FK ]DVDGLLVWQLHQLHRNUHğORQ\FKWHFKQRORJLL)RXFDXOW+HOOHU %DOOL:LOVRQ%M¡UQL1JZHQ\DPD &LNWyU]\ZLVWQLHMĆF\P V\VWHPLHVĆPQLHMXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQLXZDīDMĆJR]DQLHVSUDZLHGOLZ\ V]F]HJyOQLH]HZ]JOċGXQDNRQWUDVWPLċG]\VWDQHPIDNW\F]Q\PDRÀ FMDOQ\PMċ]\NLHP:LNLSHGLLSURPXMĆF\PUyZQRğý 1LHMHVW]DVNDNXMĆFHV]F]HJyOQLHZğUyGSOHPLRQZLUWXDOQ\FKīH UHWRU\NDEUDNXDXWRU\WHWyZPRīHUDF]HMZVND]\ZDýLīDXWRU\WHW\ QLHFKċWQLHSRFKRG]ĆGRREVHUZDFMLLNU\W\NL2·1HLO -HğOLRÀ FMDOQ\G\VNXUVVSRâHF]QRğFLDNFHQWXMHEUDNKLHUDUFKLLDZSUDNW\FH XF]HVWQLF\RGF]XZDMĆQLHUyZQRğýWRHJDOLWDUQDQDUUDFMDPRīHQDZHW QLHğZLDGRPLHXFLV]DýG\V\GHQWyZ&KRýQLHZLHU]ċE\WDNE\âRZW\P SU]\SDGNXMHVWGRğýRF]\ZLVWHīHSRGNUHğODMĆFGHPRNUDFMċLUyZQRğý

91

92

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... VSRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLL]DVSRNDMDZâDVQĆREVHVMċQDSXQNFLHKLHUDUFKLL LDXWRU\WHWyZFRMHVWVNXWNLHPSRGV\FDQLDREDZSU]HGQLPL 1DOHī\WXMHGQDN]D]QDF]\ýīHZÅGHPRNUDW\F]Q\FKKLHUDUFKLDFKµ NZHVWLHRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğFLZâDVQRğFLDXWRU\WHWXLZâDG]\VĆG\VNX WRZDQHZVSRVyERZLHOHEDUG]LHMRWZDUW\QLīZNRQZHQFMRQDOQ\FK RUJDQL]DFMDFK9LJJLDQL FRV]F]HJyOQLHZSU]\SDGNXQRZLFMXV]\ LQLHXF]HVWQLF]ĆF\FKREVHUZDWRUyZPRīHVWZDU]DýZUDīHQLHZLċN V]HJRVNRPSOLNRZDQLDV\WXDFMLQLīPDWRPLHMVFHZU]HF]\ZLVWRğFL 2WZDUWHZ\UDīDQLHQLH]DGRZROHQLDNWyUH]Z\NOHR]QDF]DīHV\WXDFMD MHVWVNUDMQLHQDSLċWDZRUJDQL]DFMDFKHJDOLWDUQ\FKGRGDWNRZRV\JQD OL]XMHīHXF]HVWQLF\PRJĆRWZDUFLHZ\UDīDýVZRMHREDZ\LZ\]QDZDý UyīQLFHSRJOĆGyZEH]VWUDFKX =DNUHVNRQWUROLRUJDQL]DF\MQHMZ:LNLSHGLLMHVWZ\MĆWNRZRUR]OHJâ\ FREċG]LHSU]HGPLRWHPG\VNXVMLZGDOV]\FKF]ċğFLDFKNVLĆīNL5HWR U\ND:LNLSHGLLMHVWVNUDMQLHHJDOLWDUQDZLċFQDZHWQDMPQLHMV]DQLH ]JRGQRğýVWDQXIDNW\F]QHJR]RÀFMDOQLHJâRV]RQ\PMHVWSRVWU]HJDQD MDNRZ\VRFHQLHSRNRMĆFD5R]ELHīQRğýPLċG]\RÀFMDOQ\PG\VNXUVHP DSRVWU]HJDQĆU]HF]\ZLVWRğFLĆRUJDQL]DF\MQĆF]ċVWRVWDQRZLSRZyG QLHSRNRMyZZRUJDQL]DFML5RVHQ)OHPLQJL6SLFHU OHF]ZSU]\SDGNX:LNLSHGLLFDâRğýGRW\F]\SRGVWDZRZ\FKGODRZHMRU JDQL]DFMLZDUWRğFLL²FRQLHMHVW]DVNDNXMĆFH²SRZRGXMHīHF]ċğý Xī\WNRZQLNyZMHVWQLH]DGRZRORQD]VDPHJRLVWQLHQLDLNRQVWUXNFML V\VWHPX)DNWīHZHU\ÀNDFMDXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZMHVWXWUXG QLRQDUyZQLHīMHVWGODQLFKNROHMQĆR]QDNĆQLHUyZQRğFL2E\GZD SURFHV\]ZLċNV]DMĆWUXGQRğýJâRVRZDĕQDGSU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZQLHĕ DGPLQLVWUDWRUDJG\ī]MHGQHMVWURQ\MHVWWRMHGQD]QLHZLHOXRND]MLJG\ V]HUHJRZLZLNLSHG\ğFLPDMĆIDNW\F]Q\ZSâ\ZQDSRGHMPRZDQHGHF\]MH MHGHQJâRVVSU]HFLZXMHVWZDUWW\OHFRF]WHU\JâRV\SRSDUFLD ]GUXJLHM ]Dğ]ZLċNV]DQLHRF]HNLZDĕZVWRVXQNXGRNDQG\GDWyZQDDGPLQLVWUD WRUyZMHVWQDWXUDOQHMHğOLQRPLQDFMDPDE\ýGRī\ZRWQLD 1LHPRīOLZRğýSRUDG]HQLDVRELH]QLHG]LDâDMĆF\PV\VWHPHPSU]\ ]QDZDQLDXSUDZQLHĕSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğFLZLHOXSURMHNWyZMHVWV\PS WRPDW\F]QDGODJâċEV]\FKSUREOHPyZMĆQċNDMĆF\FK%ċGĆRQHSU]HG PLRWHPGDOV]HJRRSLVXSURZDG]RQHJRQDSRGVWDZLHDQDOL]\UHODFML :LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ]HVSRâHF]QRğFLDPLSURMHNWyZDWDNīHEDGDQLHP QDGWUDMHNWRULDPLNRQÁLNWyZNRQWUROĆELXURNUDW\F]QĆHJ]HNZRZD QLHP]DXIDQLDRGU]XFDQLHPSU]\ZyG]WZDLQDSLċFLDPL]ZLĆ]DQ\PL ]]DU]ĆG]DQLHP:LNLSHGLĆ

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK?

ROZWIĄZYWANIE WIRTUALNYCH KONFLIKTÓW :DVNRL)DUDM ]DXZDī\OLīHZV\WXDFMDFKJG\ZLHG]ċX]QDMHVLċ ]DGREURZVSyOQHQLH]Dğ]DFHQQ\]DVyENWyU\QDOHī\FKURQLýSU]HG NUDG]LHīĆOXG]LHFKċWQLHMVLċQLĆZ\PLHQLDMĆNLHUXMĆFVLċGREUHP RJyâXLPRUDOQ\PLSRZLQQRğFLDPLZREHFLQQ\FKQLH]DğSREXGNDPL HJRFHQWU\F]Q\PL.RQFHSFMDWDMHVWVSyMQD]HVW\OHPG]LDâDQLDVSRâHF] QRğFL:LNLSHGLLQLHPDZĆWSOLZRğFLīHZLNLSHG\ğFLDNW\ZQLRGGâXī V]HJRF]DVXGREU]HVLċEDZLĆWZRU]ĆFZVSyOQHGREUD3UyEDÅSRVLD GDQLDµZLHG]\MHVWZ:LNLSHGLLUDF]HMRELHNWHPNU\W\NLPyZLVLċ HG\WRURPīHQLHZROQRLPXZDīDýE\MDNLHNROZLHNWUHğFLE\â\LFK ZâDVQRğFLĆQLHSRZLQQLWHīREUDīDýVLċMHğOLNWRğGRNRQXMHHG\FMLZSL VDQHJRSU]H]QLFKWHNVWXDFKRýZVSyâDXWRUVWZRGDQHJRKDVâDMHVWLP SU]\SLVDQHQDVWURQLHJUXSXMĆFHMKLVWRULċHG\FMLVWURQ\WRSUDFD ZNWyUHMXF]HVWQLF]ĆPDFKDUDNWHU]ELRURZ\3UDNW\NDUyīQLVLċ

7\WXâQLQLHMV]HJRUR]G]LDâXQDZLĆ]XMHGRDUW\NXâXSUDVRZHJRDXWRUVWZDIUDQ FXVNLHJRQDURGRZHJRVRFMDOLVW\0DUFHOD'pDWDRSXEOLNRZDQHJRMDNR0RXULUSRXU 'DQ]LJ"ZURNXQDâDPDFKÅ/·°XYUHµZWHG\NRPHQWRZDQHJRV]HURNRQLH W\ONRZH)UDQFMLOHF]UyZQLHīZSR]RVWDâ\FKNUDMDFK(XURS\:HGâXJ'pDWD)UDQ FMDQLHSRZLQQDE\âDX]QDý]DZDUWHJR]3ROVNĆVRMXV]XQLHSRZLQQDWHīDQJDīRZDý VLċZG]LDâDQLDZRMHQQHSU]HFLZNR1LHPFRPJG\E\]DDWDNRZDâ\RQH3ROVNċ:LċFHM SRGDGUHVHPKWWSSOZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL0DUFHOB'pDW

94

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ZSUDZG]LHRGRÀFMDOQHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDLMHVWZLHOHSU]\NâDGyZHG\ WRUyZZ\ND]XMĆF\FK]DFKRZDQLDZâDVQRğFLRZH+DOIDNHULLQ 7KRP6DQWHOOLLLQ OHF]HG\WRU]\FLSU]H]VZRMHG]LDâDQLDQD UXV]DMĆSRGVWDZRZH]DVDG\SURMHNWX -HGQD]JâyZQ\FK]DOHW:LNLSHGLLMHVW]DZDUWDZMHMFUHGRMHVWWR HQF\NORSHGLDNWyUĆNDīG\PRīHHG\WRZDý-DN]DXZDīD&OD\6KLUN\ ² :V\VWHPLHJG]LHNDīG\PDSUDZRGRUR]SRF]ċFLDMDNLHJRğG]LDâDQLD FKRýE\PL]HUQHJRNUyWNLLQLRVĆF\QLHZLHOHLQIRUPDFMLZSLVPRīHE\ý SRGVWDZĆSU]\V]âHJRGREUHJRKDVâD6DPQLVNLSR]LRPSRF]ĆWNRZHJR ZSLVXPRW\ZXMHGRMHJRSRSUDZ\RZLHOHZLċFHMRVyEZ\UDīDFKċýSR SUDZLHQLD]âHJRZSLVXQLīVWZRU]HQLDGREUHJRRGSRGVWDZ

3URFHVWHQMHVWIDNW\F]QLHW\SRZ\GOD:LNLSHGLLLLQQ\FKVSRâHF] QRğFLZLUWXDOQ\FK²ZLHOH]DFKRZDĕRQOLQHPRW\ZRZDQ\FKMHVWW\P īHÅNWRğVLċP\OLZ,QWHUQHFLHµ 7HQVDPSURFHVVSUDZLDMHGQDNīHHG\WRZDQLH:LNLSHGLLRSLHUDVLċ ZZLċNV]\PVWRSQLXQDQLH]JRG]LHQLīQDZVSyâSUDF\*RUEDWDLL-HPLHO QLDND -HGQR]QDF]QHQD]ZDQLH:LNLSHGLLSURMHNWHPRSDUW\P QDZVSyâSUDF\E\âRE\WDNQDSUDZGċ]ZRGQLF]HIDNW\F]QDğZLDGRPD ZVSyâSUDFDHG\WRUyZLNRRUG\QDFMDZVSyOQLHSURZDG]RQ\FKG]LDâDĕ VĆQLH]Z\NOHU]DGNLH:ZLċNV]RğFLSU]\SDGNyZRGL]RORZDQLXī\WNRZ QLF\GRNRQXMĆHG\FMLLSU]HFKRG]ĆGRNROHMQHJRKDVâDZLċNV]RğýXī\W NRZQLNyZNRQFHQWUXMHVLċQDW\PF]\PIDNW\F]QLHVLċ]DMPXMHLZFKRG]L ZLQWHUDNFMċ]LQQ\PLW\ONRZSU]\SDGNXQLH]JDG]DQLDVLċ]LFK]GD QLHPDOERJG\SRWU]HEXMHSRPRF\ 1LHXQLNQLRQHMHVWīHFRG]LHQQLHZ:LNLSHGLLZ\VWċSXMĆNRQÁLNW\ :LHOH]QLFKHOLPLQXMHVLċSU]\ZRâXMĆF]DVDG\QSW\SRZHGOD,QWHUQHWX WUROORZDQLHZ:LNLSHGLLRJUDQLF]DQHMHVW]QDF]QLHVNXWHF]QLHMQLī ZGRZROQ\PLQQ\PVHUZLVLHLQWHUQHWRZ\P.HQGDOO%UXQWRQ JG\īLVWQLHMĆ]DVDG\NRQVWUXNW\ZQHJR]DFKRZDQLD²QSV]F]H JyâRZDQRUPD>>HQ:LNLSHGLD32,17@@>>:LNLSHGLD1LHSU]HV]NDG]DM ZSUDF\:LNLSHGLLW\ONRSRWRDE\FRğXGRZRGQLý@@ 3RGREQLHGRğýV]\ENRHOLPLQRZDQHVĆHG\FMHGRNRQ\ZDQHZ]âHM ZLHU]H3UDZGĆMHVWīHZLHOHRVyELLQVW\WXFMLSUyEXMHZSâ\QĆýQDNV]WDâW

3RUQSSRSXODUQ\NRPLNVLQWHUQHWRZ\DXWRUVWZD5DQGDOOD0XQURHKWWS [NFGFRP

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? DUW\NXâyZZ:LNLSHGLLRSLVXMĆF\FKMHVDPH3U]\NâDG\WRPLQHG\FMH SU]\SLV\ZDQH&,$3HSVL&R:DO0DUWRZLL([[RQRZL+DIQHU EĆGĩZSURZDG]DQHSU]H]DJHQFMHSXEOLFUHODWLRQVWDNLHMDN%HOO3RW WLQJHUQD]OHFHQLHLFKNOLHQWyZ3HJJL:ULJKW =Z\NOHHG\FMH GRNRQDQHSU]H]DJHQFMH35VĆQLHWUZDâHJG\īQDW\FKPLDVWSR]DXZD īHQLX]RVWDMĆXVXQLċWHSRQLHZDīU]XFDMĆVLċâDWZRZRF]\QDZHWMHğOL LFKJâyZQ\P]DGDQLHPMHVW]DPJOHQLHQLHZ\JRGQ\FKGODRSLV\ZDQHJR SRGPLRWXLQIRUPDFML:FKRG]HQLHZG\VNXVMHQDWHPDWXVXQLċW\FK HG\FMLG]LDâX35MHVWEH]FHORZHJG\ī:LNLSHGLDSU]\ZRâXMHV]F]HJyâRZH ]DVDG\HQF\NORSHG\F]QRğFLRSLVXGRERUXQHXWUDOQ\FKVâyZLHQF\NOR SHG\F]QRğFLZRJyOH 8ī\WNRZQLF\NWyU]\VĆXSDUFLZGRGDZDQLXEâċGQ\FKLQIRUPDFMLOXE ZPDQLSXORZDQLX]DZDUWRğFLĆVĆZNRĕFXDOEREORNRZDQLDOERLQIRU PRZDQLR]DVDGDFKSDQXMĆF\FKZSURMHNFLH:SU]\SDGNDFKVNUDMQ\FK LZ\MĆWNRZ\FKPRīHGRMğýGR]DEORNRZDQLDPRīOLZRğFLHG\WRZDQLD :LNLSHGLL]HVWURQ\FDâHMRUJDQL]DFML3U]\NâDGHPMHVW.RğFLyâ6FMHQ WRORJLF]Q\HG\WXMĆF\RNRâRDUW\NXâyZ]QLP]ZLĆ]DQ\FKSUyEX MĆF\ZWHQVSRVyE]UyZQRZDī\ýNU\W\NċRUJDQL]DFMLLXī\ZDMĆF\ZLHOX NRQWGRZSâ\QLċFLDQDWUHğýKDVHâE\E\âDRQDPXSU]\FK\OQLHMV]D 3RZ\F]HUSDQLX]Z\Nâ\FKğURGNyZVNXWNLHPQDMGâXīHMWUZDMĆFHM SURFHGXU\DUELWUDīRZHMZKLVWRULLDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLPLHVLċF\ PDMDDGUHV\,3QDOHīĆFHGR.RğFLRâD6FMHQWRORJLF]QHJR]RVWDâ\ SR]EDZLRQHPRīOLZRğFLHG\WRZDQLD:LNLSHGLL6LQJHO GRV]âRWHī GR]DEORNRZDQLDSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKNRQWV\PSDW\NyZVFMHQWRORJLL]RE >>HQ:35HTXHVWVBIRUBDUELWUDWLRQ6FLHQWRORJ\@@ 3RVWċSRZDQLH]RVREDPL]]HZQĆWU]ZFKRG]ĆF\PLZJURQRHG\WRUyZ :LNLSHGLL]MDVQ\PL]DPLDUDPLMHVWGRğýSURVWH6\WXDFMDMHVW]JRâD RGPLHQQDMHğOLXī\WNRZQLF\]DPLHU]DMĆF\]DZV]HONĆFHQċXWU]\PDý VWDQGDQHJRDUW\NXâXRGSRZLDGDMĆF\LFKSXQNWRZLZLG]HQLDVĆGRğý

:W\PNRQWHNğFLHZDUWRFK\EDZVSRPQLHýQLHGDZQĆNRQWURZHUVMċ35]XG]LD âHPMHGQHJR]ZLNLSHG\VWyZ:HZU]HğQLXURNX5RJHU%DPNLQSUH]HV LVNDUEQLN:LNLPHGLD8.VLHGHPQDğFLHUD]\GRSURZDG]LâGRSRMDZLHQLDVLċ ZUXEU\FHÅ&]\ZLHV]īHµHNVSRQRZDQHMQDJâyZQHMVWURQLHDQJLHOVNLHM:LNL SHGLLKDVHâR*LEUDOWDU]H²]QLHVSRW\NDQĆGRWĆGF]ċVWRWOLZRğFLĆZ\QRV]ĆFĆSR NLONDGQLSRGF]DVJG\U]ĆG*LEUDOWDUXRSâDFDâJRMDNRNRQVXOWDQWD%OXHD 6NXWNLHPIRUVRZDQLDWUHğFLSU]H]SUDFRZQLNDRUJDQL]DFMLSDUWQHUVNLHM]RVWDâD RQDSRGGDQDDXG\WRZL:0)LGREURZROQLHZ\FRIDâDVLċ]SURFHVXSR]\VNLZDQLD ğURGNyZILQDQVRZ\FK%OXHE %U\W\MVNLSDUWQHUUXFKX:LNLPHGLDSRGMĆâ NURNL]PLHU]DMĆFHGRSU]HSURZDG]HQLDZHZQċWU]QHJRDXG\WXLZSURZDG]HQLD SURFHGXU]DSRELHJDMĆF\FKZSU]\V]âRğFLNRQIOLNWRPLQWHUHVyZSRGREQHJRURG]DMX

95

96

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... GREU]H]DSR]QDQL]]DVDGDPL:LNLSHGLLLPLPRīHVĆXSDUFLSU]HVWU]H JDMĆRERZLĆ]XMĆF\FKQRUP 3UREOHPWHQMHVWGRğýW\SRZ\ZLċFZ:LNLSHGLL]DZDUWHVĆGREU]H QDSLVDQHUDG\LSURFHGXU\UR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZ²]RE>>HQ:LNL SHGLD&RQÁLFWUHVROXWLRQ@@>>:LNLSHGLD5R]ZLĆ]\ZDQLHNRQÁLNWyZ@@ :LċNV]RğýNRQÁLNWyZGDVLċUR]ZLĆ]DýMHğOLZV]\VF\XF]HVWQLF\VWRVXMĆ VLċGRSU]\MċW\FKQRUPF]\OLMHğOL]DFHQWUDOQ\SXQNWSU]\MPXMĆ]DZDU WRğýKDVHâXWU]\PXMĆFKâRGQHQDVWDZLHQLHLVWRVXMĆZ\ZDīRQHDUJX PHQW\.RQÁLNW\QDQLHZLHONĆVNDOċPRīQDZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL UR]ZLĆ]\ZDýUyZQLHīSU]H]VWZRU]HQLHGRNXPHQWXÅ5HTXHVWIRU&RP PHQWµ5)&SURğEDRNRPHQWDU] JG]LHZVSyâHG\WRU]\PDMĆV]DQVċ Z\UD]LýVZRMHRSLQLHLZ\SUDFRZDýVDW\VIDNFMRQXMĆFHUR]ZLĆ]DQLH 3URFHGXUD5)&PLPRīHMHVWRZLHOHVWDUV]DRGVDPHM:LNLSHGLLJG\ī VWRVRZDOLMĆZODWDFK;;ZLHNXDUFKLWHNFLZVSyâF]HVQHJR,QWHUQHWX .HOW\%UXQWRQ QLHMHVWVWRVRZDQDWDNV]HURNRZSROVNLHM :LNLSHGLLJG\īX]QDQRMĆ]D]E\WQLRSRGDWQĆQDG]LDâDQLDWUROOLRUD] ]âRğOLZ\FKHG\WRUyZ:DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLVSRU\Z\PDJDMĆFHXZDJL HG\WRUD]]HZQĆWU]VĆRJâDV]DQHQDÅWDEOLF\UR]ZLD]\ZDQLDNRQÁLN WyZµ²GLVSXWHUHVROXWLRQQRWLFHERDUG>>HQ:3'51@@ :SU]\SDGNXNRQÁLNWyZRVRELVW\FKLVWQLHMĆGRGDWNRZHLQVW\WXFMH XâDWZLDMĆFHRVWXG]HQLHDWPRVIHU\LZSURZDG]HQLHSUDZLGâRZ\FKQRUP ]DFKRZDQLDZJUXSLHFKRýE\SU]H]SRND]\ZDQLHGREU\FKSU]\NâDGyZ :IDNW\F]QHMSUDNW\FHSUDZQHMLÀUPRZHMDUELWUDīLPHGLDFMDVWDQRZLĆ VWDQGDUGRZHPHWRG\UR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZRGQLHGDZQD-HPLHO QLDNL0LNâDV]HZLF]-HPLHOQLDN Z:LNLSHGLLPHFKDQL]P\ WHVĆGREU]HUR]ZLQLċWHLDNW\ZQLHZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQH)RUPDOQDPHGLD FMDMHVWRVWDWHF]Q\PNURNLHPUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZZ\QLNDMĆF\FK ]WUHğFLKDVHâ]DğSRDUELWUDīVLċJDVLċZSU]\SDGNDFKNRQÁLNWyZ ]ZLĆ]DQ\FK]]DFKRZDQLHPXī\WNRZQLNyZLLQQ\FKNZHVWLLOHīĆF\FK SR]D]DZDUWRğFLĆKDVHâ 'HEDW\QDG]DZDUWRğFLĆ:LNLSHGLLVĆV]F]HJyOQLHLVWRWQHJG\īVWD QRZLĆRQHWU]RQZLċNV]RğFLNRQÁLNWyZVĆWHīRZLHOHWUXGQLHMV]HGR UR]ZLĆ]DQLDQLīSRW\F]NLRVRELVWHRZLHOHWUXGQLHMMHVWXVWDOLýNWRPD UDFMċQLīNWR]DFKRZXMHVLċZQLHRGSRZLHGQLVSRVyE 5yīQLFHSRJOĆGyZ QDWHPDW]DZDUWRğFLKDVHâF]ċVWRVNXWNXMĆW]ZZRMQDPLHG\F\MQ\PL SRGF]DVNWyU\FKHG\WRU]\UHSUH]HQWXMĆF\RE\GZLHVWURQ\NRQÁLNWX ]PLHQLDMĆQDSU]HPLDQ]DZDUWRğýKDVâDGRSRVWDFLNWyUDRGSRZLDGD LFK]DSDWU\ZDQLRP3RPQLHMV]HZRMQ\HG\F\MQH]GHF\GRZDQLHQLHVĆ U]DGNRğFLĆ:LHOH]QLFKQLHVNXSLDQDVRELHQDZHWXZDJLHG\WRUyZ

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? LDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSURMHNWX7\ONRZSU]\SDGNDFKJG\VSRU\UR]UD VWDMĆVLċGRSRVWDFLZNWyUHMXF]HVWQLF]\ZQLFKZLċNV]DOLF]EDHG\WR UyZJG\RLQWHUZHQFMċSURV]HQLVĆDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\LWGVWDMĆVLċRQH ZLGRF]QHGODV]HUV]HMVSRâHF]QRğFL0LPRWHJRZLċNV]Rğý]WDNLFKNRQ ÁLNWyZUR]ZLĆ]XMHVLċQDV]F]HEOXORNDOQ\PZJURQLHPDNV\PDOQLH NLONXQDVWXHG\WRUyZ]DDQJDīRZDQ\FKZSUDFHQDGGDQ\PDUW\NXâHP OXE]DLQWHUHVRZDQ\FKRNUHğORQĆG]LHG]LQĆZLHG]\ ']LHMHVLċWDNJâyZQLH]XZDJLQDGREU]HUR]ZLQLċWH]DVDG\:LNLSHGLL ZVND]XMĆFHHG\WRURPSUDZLGâRZHVSRVRE\UR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDVSRUyZ LSRV]XNLZDQLDZVSyOQHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD6ĆRQHZ\MĆWNRZRFLHNDZH ZNRQWHNğFLHEDGDĕQDGRUJDQL]DFMDPLJG\īVĆXQLNDWRZHLVLOQLH VNRQFHQWURZDQHQDEXGRZDQLXNRQVHQVXVX7DNLWU\ESRGHMPRZDQLD GHF\]MLVWDMHVLċFRUD]EDUG]LHMSRSXODUQ\ZG]LHG]LQLH]DU]ĆG]DQLDRG ODW'UXFNHU3XUVXHUL&DEDQD -DN]DXZDī\â-RVHSK5HDJOHE ZLHOH]FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FK GOD:LNLSHGLL]DVDGRVLĆJDQLDDNFHSWRZDOQHJRGODZV]\VWNLFKUR]ZLĆ ]DQLDMHVWSRGREQ\FKGRPHWRGG]LDâDQLDNZDNUyZ5HOLJLMQHJR7RZD U]\VWZD3U]\MDFLyâ 6XH*DUGQHUDNWXDOQLHSLDVWXMĆFDVWDQRZLVNR G\UHNWRUNLZ\NRQDZF]HM:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQUyZQLHīZ\ND]XMH ī\ZH]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHNZDNLHUVNLPLPHWRGDPLGRFKRG]HQLDGRSRUR ]XPLHQLDJG\īX]QDMHīHPHWRG\SU]H]QLFKVWRVRZDQHSU]\SRPLQDMĆ SURFHV\]DFKRG]ĆFHZSURMHNWDFK:LNLPHGLD -DN]DXZDīD0LFKDHO6KHHUDQMH]XLWDD]DUD]HPMHGHQ]SLRQLHUyZ WHMG]LHG]LQ\SRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLNZDNU]\GĆī\OLGRRVLĆJQLċFLDMHG QRP\ğOQRğFLSUHIHUXMĆFNRQVHQVXVDRGU]XFDMĆFJâRVRZDQLD SU]H U\ZDMĆFUR]ZDīDQLDZV\WXDFMDFKZNWyU\FKNRQVHQVXVE\âWUXGQ\GR RVLĆJQLċFLDVâXFKDMĆFSRP\VâyZLQQ\FKOXG]L]RWZDUW\PQDVWDZLHQLHP XQLNDMĆFEH]SRğUHGQLHJRSU]\ZyG]WZDSRGF]DVG\VNXVML]DSUDV]DMĆF ZV]\VWNLFKFKċWQ\FKGRXG]LDâXZGXFKXHJDOLWDU\]PXMDNWHīRGG]LH ODMĆFHPRFMHRGIDNWyZ6KHHUDQ =JURPDG]HQLDNZDNUyZPDMĆ FKDUDNWHUVLOQLHQLHIRUPDOQ\PRīOLZHMHVWGRâĆF]HQLHVLċGRG\VNXVML QDZHWMHğOLQLHMHVWVLċRÀFMDOQLH]DSURV]RQ\PPRīQDWDNīHFDâ\PL PLHVLĆFDPLEUDýXG]LDâZ]HEUDQLDFKEH]RNUHğODQLDVZRMHJRIRUPDO QHJRVWDWXVXMDNRXF]HVWQLND/RXLV

&RSRWZLHUG]DUR]PRZDSU]HSURZDG]RQDSRGF]DVRGE\ZDMĆFHMVLċZ:DV]\QJ WRQLHNRQIHUHQFML:LNLPDQLDOLSFD RUD]OLVWDNVLĆīHN]DPLHV]F]RQD SU]H]6XH*DUGQHUQDMHMRVRELVW\PEORJXSRGDGUHVHPKWWSVXHJDUGQHURUJ ERRNVLOLNHV\WXDFMD]OLSFD²OLVWD]DZLHUDNVLĆīHNRNZDNUDFKRUD] SRğZLċFRQ\FKLQQ\P]DJDGQLHQLRP

97

98

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 7HRJyOQHQRUP\SU]\SRPLQDMĆZLHOH]]DVDG:LNLSHGLL'ODSU]\ NâDGX]JRGQLH]]DVDGDPLSURMHNWXZV]\VWNLHVSRU\R]DZDUWRğý DUW\NXâyZSRZLQQRVLċUR]ZLĆ]\ZDýSU]H]SRV]XNLZDQLHNRQVHQVXVX =DVDG\SURMHNWXRUD]RÀFMDOQDUHWRU\NDVĆZW\PZ]JOċG]LHMDVQH >>HQ:3&RQVHQVXV@@ -HğOLQLHPRīQDRVLĆJQĆýSRUR]XPLHQLDMHG\QLHSU]H]HG\WRZDQLH SURFHVXVWDODQLDNRQVHQVXVXSU]\MPXMHEDUG]LHMVNU\VWDOL]RZDQĆ IRUPċXF]HVWQLF\G\VNXVMLRWZLHUDMĆQRZ\ZĆWHNQDVWURQLHG\VNXVML KDVâDLZWRNXG\VNXVMLGĆīĆGRZ\SUDFRZDQLDZVSyOQHJRVWDQRZLVND 6WDUDMĆVLċGUXJĆVWURQċSU]HNRQDý]DSRPRFĆDUJXPHQWyZRSDUW\FK QD]DVDGDFKSURMHNWXĩUyGâDFKL]GURZ\PUR]VĆGNXPRJĆWHīVXJH URZDýDOWHUQDW\ZQHUR]ZLĆ]DQLDOXENRPSURPLV\NWyUH]DGRZROĆ ZV]\VWNLHVWURQ\VSRUX6NXWNLHPPRīHE\ýSRUR]XPLHQLHNWyUHīDGQHM ]HVWURQQLHXVDW\VIDNFMRQXMHNRPSOHWQLHOHF]NWyUHZV]\VF\X]QDMĆ]D UR]ZLĆ]DQLHVHQVRZQH.RQVHQVXVMHVWZ:LNLSHGLLFLĆJâ\PSURFHVHP F]ċVWROHSLHMMHVW]DDNFHSWRZDýQLHGRNRĕFDLGHDOQHUR]ZLĆ]DQLHUR]X PLHMĆFīHNDīGDVWURQDSRGOHJDFLĆJâHPXXOHSV]DQLXQLīVWDUDýVLċ QDW\FKPLDVWRZRXVWDOLýMHGQĆÅLGHDOQĆµZHUVMċDUW\NXâX-DNRğýDUW\ NXâyZHG\WRZDQ\FKSU]H]VSU]HF]DMĆF\FKVLċUHGDNWRUyZMHVWQDMF]ċğ FLHMRZLHOHQLīV]DRGMDNRğFLDUW\NXâyZNWyU\FKZVSyâHG\WRU]\VWDUDMĆ VLċVSRMU]HýV]HU]HMQDSUREOHP

,VWQLHMĆV]F]HJyâRZHZ\W\F]QHFRGRWHJRMDNZF\ZLOL]RZDQ\VSRVyE VWDUDýVLċRVLĆJQĆýNRQVHQVXV*âRVRZDQLDQDGVSRUQ\PLNZHVWLDPL X]QDMHVLċ]DUR]ZLĆ]DQLH]âH-HGQR]F]ċVWRSRZWDU]DQ\FKZ:LNL SHGLLSRU]HNDGHâPyZLīHÅJâRVRZDQLDWR]âRµ]DğHVHMRSLVXMĆF\ SRGVWDZ\WDNVNUDMQHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDLVWQLHMHZ:LNLSHGLLDRG URNXUyZQLHīZVHUZLVLH0HWD:LNLRGG]LHOQ\PSURMHNFLHW\SX ZLNLVâXīĆF\PNRRUG\QDFMLG]LDâDĕZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLD RGGâXīV]HJRF]DVX²ZG\VNXVMDFKF]ċVWRVWRVRZDQ\MHVWVNUyWRGQD]Z\ HVHMXF]\OLÅ9,(µRGYRWLQJLVHYLO 3RGREQLHZ\W\F]QH]DFKRZDĕ QD:LNLSHGLLSRGNUHğODMĆīHJâRVRZDQLDQLHPRJĆE\ýVWRVRZDQH ZPLHMVFHG\VNXVML>>HQ:33ROOLQJLVQRWDVXEVWLWXWHIRUGLVFXV VLRQ@@ :LNLSHGLDRSLHUDVZRMHG]LDâDQLHQDNRQVHQVXVLH*G\SRMDZLDMĆVLċ NRQÁLNW\UR]ZLĆ]XMHVLċMHZGURG]HG\VNXVMLGHEDW\LZVSyâSUDF\ *âRVRZDQLDQLHVĆZSUDZG]LH]DND]DQHOHF]SRZLQQRVLċMHVWRVRZDý

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? ]RVWURīQRğFLĆ-HğOLMXīVLċMHRUJDQL]XMHWRQDOHī\RQLFKP\ğOHýMDNR RğURGNDFKXVWDOHQLDNRQVHQVXVX]DğQLHRFHOXVDP\PZVRELH

-HGQD]SRGVWDZRZ\FK]DVDG:LNLSHGLLF]\P:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVW >>HQ:3:KDW:LNLSHGLDLVQRW@@RGSRZLHGQLNZSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLL WR>>:LNLSHGLD&]\P:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVW@@ GRGDMH :LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWHNVSHU\PHQWHPZG]LHG]LQLHGHPRNUDFMLF]\LQQHJR V\VWHPXSROLW\F]QHJR*âyZQ\PFKRýQLHMHG\Q\PWU\EHPSRGHMPR ZDQLDZQLHMGHF\]MLLUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZMHVWHG\WRZDQLHLG\V NXWRZDQLHZWDNLVSRVyEDE\GRSURZDG]LýGRNRQVHQVXVX²QLHMHVWQLP MHGQDNJâRVRZDQLHWDPHWRGDSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLMHVWRJUDQLF]RQD GRQLHZLHOXSU]\SDGNyZMDNZ\EyUF]âRQNyZ.RPLWHWX$UELWUDīRZHJR &]DVDPLGRWHVWRZDQLDSRWHQFMDâXNRQVHQVXVXZ\NRU]\VWXMHVLċDQNLHW\ OHF]WHJRW\SXPHFKDQL]P\UDF]HMKDPXMĆQLīUR]ZLMDMĆG\VNXVMċ SRZLQQRVLċZLċF]QLFKNRU]\VWDýUR]ZDīQLH

7ċÀOR]RÀċVWRVXMĆZLċNV]HSURMHNW\:LNLPHGLD:WUDNFLHG\VNXVML QDWHPDW\RJyOQHQDMF]ċğFLHMXZDīDVLċīHNRQVHQVXVRVLĆJQLċWRMHğOL ]GDQĆZHUVMĆ]JDG]DVLċFRQDMPQLHMG\VNXWXMĆF\FKG]LDâDMĆF\FK ZGREUHMZLHU]HOHF]SRGREQLHGRF\WRZDQ\FKSRZ\īHM]DVDGRGUDG]D VLċVWRVRZDQLHPHFKDQLF]Q\FKZ\OLF]HĕQXPHU\F]Q\FK 3RGRELHĕVWZDGRV\VWHPXG]LDâDQLDNZDNUyZVĆXGHU]DMĆFHOHF] LVWQLHMĆLQQHVSRâHF]QRğFLL]DVDG\NWyUHZ\JOĆGDMĆDQDORJLF]QLHGRPH FKDQL]PyZ:LNLSHGLL3U]\NâDGHPVĆUHJXâ\SU]\SRPLQDMĆFHVSRVRE\ G]LDâDQLDW]Z6HDUFK&RQIHUHQFHPHWRG\RGâXJLHMKLVWRULLLWUDG\FMDFK :LOOLDPV7ULVW F]ċVWRZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHMZG]LHG]LQLH DFWLRQUHVHDUFK&URPELH2HOV-HPLHOQLDN%M¡UQ L%RXOXV&KURVWRZVNLL-HPLHOQLDN NRQFHQWUXMĆFHMVLċ QDXF]HVWQLF]ĆFHMDXWRUHÁHNVMLRUJDQL]DF\MQHMSU]\F]\P6FKDIIW L*UHHQZRRG &DâRğýSURFHVXNâDG]LHQDFLVNQDVWUXNWXUċSR]EDZLRQĆKLHUDUFKLLRUD] ÅGHPRNUDW\F]Q\GLDORJµZNWyU\PNDīG\JâRVMHVWV]DQRZDQ\F]DV Z\SRZLHG]LZVSyâG]LHORQ\DGRWHJRUR]ZLMDQHLZVSLHUDQHVĆRWZDUWH WU\E\NRPXQLNDFMLPLċG]\JUXSDPL

6HDUFK&RQIHUHQFHLLQQHPHWRG\SDUW\F\SDF\MQHJRWZRU]HQLDZL]ML VWUDWHJLF]QHMMDNQS)XWXUH6HDUFKSRU%U\VRQL$QGHUVRQ

99

100

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SRGREQLHGR]DVDG:LNLSHGLLGĆī\GRRVLĆJQLċFLDNRQVHQVXVXFKRý DNFHQWXMHUDF]HMSRUR]XPLHQLHQDNLONXQDMLVWRWQLHMV]\FKSâDV]F]\]QDFK RGNâDGDMĆFLQQHNZHVWLHVSRUQHQDERN3RğZLċFDVLċWHīHOLPLQDFML QLHNRQVWUXNW\ZQ\FKNRQÁLNWyZQHXWUDOL]DFMLQDGXī\ýZâDG]\LG]LD âDQLRPQDSRGVWDZLH]JRG\VSRâHF]QRğFL&RZLċFHMZUyīQ\FKRGPLD QDFKGHPRNUDFMLSU]HP\VâRZHMWHJRW\SXPHWRG\RUJDQL]DFMLQLHVĆ QLHVSRW\NDQH%DVVL6KDFNOHWRQ*UHHQZRRGLLQ ]Dğ DNWXDOQLHZ\NRU]\VWXMHVLċMHF]DVDPLQSZ]DU]ĆG]DQLXSURMHNWDPL,7 .RFK0DUNVL/RFN\HU -HG\Q\PSUREOHPHPSU]\SRUyZQ\ZDQLX:LNLSHGLLGRVSRâHF]QRğFL NZDNUyZ6HDUFK&RQIHUHQFHLLQQ\FKSRGREQ\FKV\VWHPyZVSRâHF] Q\FKMHVWWRīH]DVDG\WHQLH]DZV]HG]LDâDMĆZWHQVDPVSRVyEZ:LNL SHGLL2GPLHQQLHQLīZZ\īHMSU]\ZRâDQ\FKV\VWHPDFKZZLHOXSU]\ SDGNDFK]DVDG\:LNLSHGLLSR]RVWDMĆMHG\QLHMDNR]DSLVDQHUHJXâ\ :V]F]HJyOQRğFLZ:LNLSHGLLZLHOHNRQÁLNWyZQLHMHVWUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQ\FK SU]H]GĆīHQLHGRNRQVHQVXVXOHF]SU]H]XSDUWRğýLGRSURZDG]DQLH GUXJLHMVWURQ\NRQÁLNWXGRZ\F]HUSDQLD-HVWWRW\SRZH]ZâDV]F]DGOD NRQÁLNWyZNWyUHSU]HUDVWDMĆVZRMĆVNDOĆ]Z\NOHVSRW\NDQHVSRU\ )HQRPHQWHQQLHE\âMDNGRWĆGSU]HGPLRWHPGRNâDGQLHMV]\FKEDGDĕ FKRýPRJâ\E\RQHU]XFLýZLċFHMğZLDWâDQDWUDMHNWRULHUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLD NRQÁLNWyZZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKLQWHUQHWRZ\FK =W\FKZ]JOċGyZZDUWR]DREVHUZRZDýFRG]LHMHVLċZSU]\SDGNX NRQÁLNWyZZ\UDVWDMĆF\FKSR]DORNDOQ\NRQWHNVWLUR]FLĆJDMĆF\FKVLċ SR]D]Z\F]DMRZHUDP\]DFKRZDĕJG\īSR]ZDODMĆRQHQDOHSV]HSR]QDQLH L]UR]XPLHQLHPHFKDQL]PyZVSRâHF]QRğFLRZ\FKSURZDG]ĆF\FKGRLFK UR]ZLĆ]DQLDL]DKDPRZDQLDHVNDODFML$QDOL]DV\WXDFMLVNUDMQ\FKMHVW ZW\PSU]\SDGNXV]F]HJyOQLHFHQQDJG\īWRZâDğQLHWHJRW\SXV\WX DFMHVLOQLHXZLGDF]QLDMĆSURFHV\RUJDQL]DF\MQH(LVHQKDUGW :\V]XNLZDQLHÅV\WXDFMLVNUDMQ\FKNU\W\F]Q\FKZ\SDGNyZLGUDPD WyZVSRâHF]Q\FKµMHVWZUċF]]DOHFDQHSU]H]QLHNWyU\FKQDXNRZFyZ 3HWWLJUHZ =W\FKZ]JOċGyZZQLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDOHSU]HDQDOL]XMċMHGQĆ]QDM Vâ\QQLHMV]\FKZRMHQHG\F\MQ\FKZKLVWRULL:LNLSHGLLNWyUDUR]HJUDâD VLċZURNXL]DVâXī\âDQDPLDQRÅQDMZLċNV]HJRLQDMGâXīV]HJRVSRUX QDGNV]WDâWHPDUW\NXâXZ:LNLSHGLLµQDGDOEċGĆFOLGHUHPUDQNLQJX

KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD:LNLSHGLDB6LJQSRVW *GDQVNBRUB'DQ]LJ

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? GHEDWQDGWUHğFLĆ:LNLSHGLL²F]ċğFLRZRZâDğQLH]XZDJLQDWRīH ZZ\QLNXWHJR]DPLHV]DQLDRNDOLEU]HHSRSHLZSURZDG]RQRQRZHPH WRG\UR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZ'\VSXWċV]HURNRX]QDQR]DMHGHQ ]QDMZLċNV]\FKSXQNWyZ]DSDOQ\FKG\VNXVMLQDGWUHğFLĆ:LNLSHGLL ZSXEOLNDFMDFKSRğZLċFRQ\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLSURMHNWX$\HUVLLQ /LK$QGHUVRQ .RQÁLNWZ\EXFKâZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL DQJDīXMĆFUyZQLHīSROVNLFKHG\WRUyZFRVSUDZLDīHMHVWMHV]F]HFHQ QLHMV]\GODQLQLHMV]HMSXEOLNDFML7UZDâRGURNXGR]DğMHJR V]F]\WRZDDNW\ZQRğýSU]\SDGDâDQDODWD²*âyZQĆRVLĆ VSRUXE\âRWRF]\DNWXDOQLHSROVNLHPLDVWR*GDĕVNQLHSRZLQQRE\ý ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLZ\PLHQLRQHLRSLVDQHSRGQLHPLHFNĆQD]ZĆ 'DQ]LJV]F]HJyOQLHZNRQWHNğFLHKLVWRU\F]Q\P&DâRğýGHEDWRSLQLL LG\VNXVMLQDGZ]JOċGQLHPDâRZDīQĆNZHVWLĆSRFKâRQċâDSRQDGW\ VLċF\VâyZF]WHURNURWQLHZLċFHMQLī]DZLHUDWDNVLĆīND 3RSU]H]DQDOL]ċWHMHSLFNLHMSRW\F]NLSRNDīċīHZSUDNW\FHV\VWH PRZLUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZZ:LNLSHGLL]GDU]DMĆVLċSRWNQLċFLD MHğOLRE\GZLHVWURQ\GĆīĆGRNRQIURQWDFMLLZWDNLPVDP\PVWRSQLX DQJDīXMĆVLċZGHEDWċ2SLV]ċMDNWDNLHSRFKâDQLDMĆFHF]DVNRQÁLNW\ GDVLċUR]ZLĆ]DýZ\âĆF]QLHSU]H]RGHMğFLHRG]DVDG\NRQVHQVXVXLDQ NLHWRZDQLHMHğOLXF]HVWQLF\G\VNXVMLVĆMXīQLĆGRVWDWHF]QLH]PċF]HQL $QDOL]DGRSURZDG]LGRRJyOQLHMV]HMNODV\ÀNDFMLNRQÁLNWyZZ:LNLSHGLL MDNWHīZVND]DQLDLVWRWQ\FKUyīQLFPLċG]\]DVDGDPL:LNLSHGLLDUH JXâDPLXVWDQRZLRQ\PLSU]H]NZDNUyZRUD]6HDUFK&RQIHUHQFH

-HVWWRUyZQLHīMHGQD]ÅQDMEDUG]LHMīDâRVQ\FKZRMHQHG\F\MQ\FKµMDNSRGDMH VWURQD>>HQ:LNLSHGLD/DPHVWHGLWZDUV@@,QQHSU]\NâDG\EROHğQLHGâXJLFKELWHZ QDâDPDFKDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]SROVNLPVPDF]NLHPWRQSGHEDWDQDGW\PF]\ &KRSLQE\â3RODNLHPSyâ3RODNLHPSyâ)UDQFX]HPSyâ)UDQFX]HPSyâ3RODNLHP F]\PRīHFDâNRZLFLH)UDQFX]HPMDNWHīF]\MHJRQD]ZLVNRQDOHī\]DSLV\ZDýMDNR Å6]RSHQµ]JRGQLH]UHJXâDPLSROV]F]\]Q\SRMDZLâVLċUyZQLHīVSyURWRF]\0L NRâDM.RSHUQLNE\â3RODNLHP1LHPFHPF]\3UXVHP,QQHSU]\NâDG\]DJRU]Dâ\FK GHEDWNWyUHMHGQDNQLH]QDOD]â\VZRMHJRPLHMVFDQDZVSRPQLDQHMOLğFLHOHF] PRJâ\E\VLċGRQLHMNZDOLILNRZDýWRG\OHPDWF]\0DULċ&XULHOXE0DULċ6NâR GRZVNĆ&XULH QDOHī\XZDīDý]D3RONċSyâ3RONċSyâ)UDQFX]NċF]\)UDQFX]Nċ RSROVNLPSRFKRG]HQLX3RGREQLHMHGQD]GâXīV]\FKZRMHQHG\F\MQ\FKZNWyUHM Z]LĆâHPSRPQLHMV]\XG]LDâGRW\F]\âDNZHVWLLÅ(XURS\ĞURGNRZHMµLWHJRNWyUH NUDMHSRâRīRQHVĆZW\PUHMRQLHLZHGâXJMDNLFKĩUyGHâQDOHī\NZDOLILNRZDýSU]\ QDOHīQRğýSDĕVWZGRWHJRUHJLRQX

101

102


ZAPRASZAMY NA DANZIG $UW\NXâR*GDĕVNX]RVWDâVWZRU]RQ\ZSRF]ĆWNDFKLVWQLHQLD:LNLSHGLL LKLVWRULDSLHUZV]\FK]PLDQGRNRQDQ\FKZKDğOHQLH]DFKRZDâDVLċQD VHUZHUDFK:LNLSHGLL6HUZLV,QWHUQHW$UFKLYH:D\EDFN0DFKLQH SU]HFKRZXMHMHGQDNNRSLċKDVâD]OLVWRSDGD6WDUHNRSLH]D SDVRZH:LNLSHGLL]RVWDâ\WHīRGNU\WHZURNXSU]H]7LPD6WDU OLQJDLSRND]XMĆīHKDVâR]RVWDâRVWZRU]RQHMXīZPDMXEċGĆF MHGQ\P]SLHUZV]\FKW\VLċF\DUW\NXâyZ=DZLHUDâRW\ONRGZD]GDQLD *GDĕVNMHVWPLDVWHPZ3ROVFHSRâRīRQ\PQDG0RU]HP%DâW\FNLP -HJRGDZQDQD]ZDQLHPLHFNDWR'DQ]LJ

3LHUZV]DHG\FMDSU]HFKRZDQDQDVHUZHUDFK:LNLSHGLLSRFKRG]L ]OLVWRSDGD]RVWDâDGRNRQDQDSU]H]Xī\WNRZQLND-+.LSRND ]XMHKDVâRUR]EXGRZDQHZZHUVMLDQJLHOVNLHMGRVROLGQ\FKVâyZ 3LHUZV]\DNDSLWZ\GDMHVLċQLH]E\WNRQWURZHUV\MQ\ *GDĕVNMHVWPLDVWHPZ3ROVFHSRâRīRQ\PQDG0RU]HP%DâW\FNLP -HJRQLHPLHFNDQD]ZD'DQ]LJVWRVRZDQDE\âDGRF]DVXSRGELFLDUHJLRQX SU]H]=655NLHG\WRPLDVWR]RVWDâRSU]\ZUyFRQH3ROVFHSR]DNRĕF]HQLX ,,ZRMQ\ğZLDWRZHM

3RGREQLHQDMVWDUV]DHG\FMDKDVâD>>HQ'DQ]LJ@@SRFKRG]L]SDĩ G]LHUQLND3DXO'U\HZVWDZLâZQLHMW\ONRMHGQR]GDQLH 'DZQDQD]ZDPLDVWD*GDĕVN]RERGSRZLHGQLHKDVâR

1D]ZDPLDVWDV]\ENRVWDâDVLċNRQWURZHUV\MQ\PWHPDWHPJUXG QLDURNXXī\WNRZQLF]ND+-RQDWGRGDâDâDFLĕVNĆQD]ZċPLDVWD DSR]DW\PSUDZLHZV]\VWNLHZ\VWĆSLHQLDÅ*GDQVNµZDUW\NXOH]DPLHQLâD

0DWHULDâSREUDQ\]HVWURQ\KWWSZHEDUFKLYHRUJZHEKWWS ZZZZLNLSHGLDFRPZLNL*GDQVN 3REUDQROLSFD]DGUHVXKWWSPDUFLQIR"O ZLNLHQO P &DâĆHG\FMċPRīQDREHMU]HýSRGDGUHVHPKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLQGH[ SKS"WLWOH *GD&VN ROGLG

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? QDÅ'DQ]LJµSR]RVWDZLDMĆFQLH]PLHQLRQ\DNDSLWRWZLHUDMĆF\ZSLV :W\PRNUHVLHE\âDDNW\ZQĆHG\WRUNĆKDVHâ]JGDĕVNLHJRUHMRQXJHR JUDÀF]QHJRDWDNīHXF]HVWQLF]NĆJRUĆF\FKGHEDWKLVWRU\F]Q\FKNWyU\FK JâyZQ\PFHOHPE\âRREZLQLDQLHSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKRVyELRUJDQL]DFML XF]HVWQLF]ĆF\FKZPDVDNUDFKKLVWRU\F]Q\FKGHÀQLRZDQLHSRFKRG]HQLD QDURGXSROVNLHJRLZ]DMHPQHRVNDUīHQLDRE\FLHQD]LVWDPLLNRPXQL VWDPLSUDZR*RGZLQDGRW\F]ĆFHQDZLĆ]\ZDQLDGR+LWOHUDE\âRMXī ZWHG\]QDQHXF]HVWQLNRPG\VNXVMLDOHQLHPLDâR]DVWRVRZDQLD]XZDJL QDWHPDW\NċG\VNXVML -HMDGZHUVDU]HQLHSR]RVWDZDOLGâXīQLZNRPHQ WDU]DFKFRFLHNDZHMHGHQ]QLFK3RODNSRVâXJLZDâVLċSVHXGRQLPHP Å6]RSHQµ :\PLDQD]GDĕQDVWURQLHG\VNXVMLKDVâDQLHRGELHJDâD]E\WQLRRG UHWRU\NLSU]HGVWDZLRQHMSRZ\īHM8ī\WNRZQLF\Z\PLHQLDOLV]HURNLH QDZLĆ]DQLDGRNVLĆīHNVWURQ:::LLQQ\FKĩUyGHâKLVWRU\F]Q\FK NWyUHE\OLZVWDQLHSU]HGVWDZLý%\OLWHīWDF\NWyU]\VWDUDOLVLċRVWXG]Lý JRUĆFH]DSDâ\1LH]DORJRZDQ\Xī\WNRZQLNVNRPHQWRZDâJUXGQLD G\VNXVMċQDVWċSXMĆFR 'ODRVRE\DQJORMċ]\F]QHMPLDVWRQLHQD]\ZDâRVLċ*GDĕVNDīGRURNX *G\F]\WDP\DQJORMċ]\F]QHNVLĆīNLKLVWRU\F]QHRSLVXMĆFHG]LHMH PLDVWDGRURNXQDMF]ċğFLHMSRMDZLDZQLFKQD]ZD'DQ]LJ1LHPD WRīDGQHJR]ZLĆ]NX]W\PF]\MHE\âRPLDVWR²ZLċNV]RğFLDQJORMċ]\F] Q\FKRVyEDOERWRQLHREFKRG]LDOERQLHZLHG]ĆRW\PZVHQVLHīHQLH PyZLĆVDPLGRVLHELHÅ'DQ]LJRKRPXVLE\ýQLHPLHFNLHµ 0RīH RGSXğFLFLHQDMDNLğF]DVLSRVâXFKDFLHFRGRSRZLHG]HQLDPDMĆOXG]LH NWyU]\VLċ]QDMĆW]QRVRE\ORNDOQH]RGSRZLHGQLPZ\NV]WDâFHQLHP1LH FKRG]LRNZHVWLċSROVNRSUXVNĆDRWRMDNLW\WXâQDMOHSLHMSDVXMHGR HQF\NORSHGLLSLVDQHMZMċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLP

$UW\NXâHG\WRZDâRZLHOHRVyEVWDUDMĆFVLċZSURZDG]LýZHUVMċEċGĆFĆ ZLFKRGF]XFLXDNFHSWRZDOQ\PNRPSURPLVHPQSSLV]ĆFRÅPLHğFLHµ ]DPLDVWSRGDZDQLDQD]Z\JG]LHNROZLHNE\âRWRX]DVDGQLRQH3UyERZDQR

3UDZR*RGZLQDWRKXPRU\VW\F]Q\DUJXPHQWVIRUPXâRZDQ\SU]H]0LNH·D*RG ZLQDZURNXVWZLHUG]DMĆF\īHZGRZROQHMG\VNXVMLLQWHUQHWRZHMSRGZD UXQNLHPRGSRZLHGQLHMLORğFLGRVWċSQHJRF]DVXNWRğZNRĕFXGRNRQDSU]\UyZQDQLD F]HJRğGR+LWOHUDOXEQD]LVWyZ:F]ċğFLIRUyZLJUXSG\VNXV\MQ\FKLVWQLHMHWUDG\FMD PyZLĆFDīHNWRNROZLHNSU]\ZRâD+LWOHUDZUROLDQDORJLLDXWRPDW\F]QLHSU]HJU\ZD DUJXPHQWDFMċ=RE>>3UDZR*RGZLQD@@

103

104

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... UyZQLHīRG]ZLHUFLHGOLýNRQWURZHUVMHZVDP\PDUW\NXOH²QDSU]\NâDG F]HUZFDURNXXī\WNRZQLN*UHJ/LQGDKOGRGDâ 1D]ZDPLDVWDMHVWGRG]LğWHPDWHPZUDīOLZ\PQDSU]\NâDGRÀFMDOQD VWURQDKLVWRU\F]QDPLDVWD QLHSRGDMHQDZHWQD]Z\Å'DQ]LJµ

1DVWċSQHJRGQLDQLH]DUHMHVWURZDQ\Xī\WNRZQLNGRNRQDâQDVWċSX MĆFHMPRG\ÀNDFML 1DOHJDQLHSU]H]SXEOLNDFMHZMċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLPQDVWRVRZDQLHSROVNLFK QD]ZWHJRLLQQ\FKSROVNLFKPLDVWMHVWGR]DNZHVWLRQRZDQLDV]F]HJyO QLHZğZLHWOHWHJRīHRÀFMDOQ\VHUZLVKLVWRU\F]Q\PLDVWD ZQLHPLHF NLHMZHUVMLMċ]\NRZHMF]DUQRF]HUZRQRīyâW\SU]\FLVN VWRVXMHIRUPċ Å'DQ]LJµ

(G\FMDWDXWU]\PDâDVLċZ:LNLSHGLLSU]H]QLHFDâĆJRG]LQċ:KLVWR ULLKDVâDZLGDýZLHOHWHJRW\SX]PLDQ2ERNLQQ\FKG\VNXVMLNZHVWLD QD]Z\PLDVWDSRZUDFDâDZODWDFK²]DUyZQRZHG\FMDFK MDNLNRPHQWDU]DFKQDVWURQLHG\VNXVML1DZLĆ]\ZDQRGR.X.OX[.ODQX VNLQKHDGyZSURSDJDQG\WRWDOLWDUQHMLWGZUD]]SRZDīQLHMV]ĆDUJX PHQWDFMĆLĩUyGâDPLSRSLHUDMĆF\PLRE\GZDSXQNW\ZLG]HQLD :RMQ\HG\F\MQHZ:LNLSHGLLF]DVDPLZ\ND]XMĆ]ELHīQHSU]HELHJL WDNGâXJRMDNDNW\ZQLVĆQDMEDUG]LHMIDQDW\F]QLXF]HVWQLF\PQLHM UDG\NDOQLG\VNXWDQFLPDMĆSUREOHP\]QDGĆīHQLHP]DUR]ZRMHPZ\ GDU]Hĕ']LHMHVLċWDNJâyZQLH]XZDJLQDV]\ENRSRVWċSXMĆFĆHVNDODFMċ ]DDQJDīRZDQLD6WDZ 3U]HFLZQLF\]ZLċNV]DMĆSXOċDUJXPHQWyZ ZG\VNXVMLSRğZLċFDMĆFMHMF]DVSRU6KXELN LV]\ENRRGSR ZLDGDMĆQDDUJXPHQW\F]ċVWRZLHORNURWQLHVSUDZG]DMĆFF]\LQQL XF]HVWQLF\G\VNXVMLZ\UD]LOLMDNĆNROZLHNRSLQLċFKFĆFE\ýZVWDQLH V]\ENR]DUHDJRZDý'ODNRJRNROZLHNNWRQLHğOHG]LG\VNXVMLWDNGRNâDG QLHEDULHUDSLHUZV]HJROXESRQRZQHJRZHMğFLDGRQLHMRVWURZ]UDVWD JG\īSU]HELFLHVLċSU]H]WHNVWZVWDZLRQ\SU]H]QDMF]ċğFLHMNRPHQWX MĆF\FKMHVWZ\]ZDQLHP]DğZ\PLDQD]GDĕ]DZċīDVLċGRğFLVâHJRJURQD QDMEDUG]LHMRGGDQ\FKVSUDZLHL]DDQJDīRZDQ\FKXF]HVWQLNyZ*yPH] LLQ =MDZLVNRWRMHVWF]DVDPLZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHğZLDGRPLHSU]H] GRğZLDGF]RQ\FKHG\WRUyZV]\ENRSU]HGVWDZLDMĆRQLVHULċREV]HUQ\FK DUJXPHQWyZRGVWUDV]DMĆF\FKRGG\VNXVMLW\FKNWyU]\QLHVĆU]HF]\ZL ğFLH]DLQWHUHVRZDQLRPDZLDQĆNZHVWLĆ::LNLSHGLLU]DG]LHMQLīQD W\SRZ\FKIRUDFKLQWHUQHWRZ\FK]GDU]DVLċE\REV]HUQDDUJXPHQWDFMD

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? E\âDRGU]XFDQD]PHWNĆÅWOGUµWRRORQJGLGQRWUHDG]DGâXJLHQLH F]\WDâHP 1DUD\DQL&KHVKLUH.DUDW]RJLDQQLL.XQWVPDQ =DVDG\NRQVHQVXVXZ:LNLSHGLLRWZDUFLH]DFKċFDMĆXF]HVWQLNyZ G\VNXVMLGRZ\UDīDQLDVZRLFKRSLQLLRLOHVĆRQHSU]H]QLFKX]QDZDQH ]DLVWRWQH]DğEUDNRGSRZLHG]LQDDUJXPHQWX]QDMHVLċ]DZ\UDīHQLH QDĕ]JRG\.UyWNRPyZLĆFÅ]DNâDGDVLċīHNRQVHQVXVRVLĆJQLċWR MHğOLEUDNMHVWVSU]HFLZXµ>>HQ:36LOHQFHDQGFRQVHQVXV@@ FRRF]\ ZLğFLHVWDQRZL]DFKċWċGRG\VNXWRZDQLD6NXWNLHPWHJRMHğOL]DVDG\ LĩUyGâDQLHSR]ZDODMĆSRGMĆýGHF\]MLZ\JUDQLHZG\VNXVMLMHVWNZHVWLĆ SR]RVWDQLDZZ\PLDQLH]GDĕZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRGâXJR :SU]\SDGNXDUW\NXâXR*GDĕVNXDNW\ZQHE\â\FRQDMPQLHMF]WHU\ JUXS\HG\WRUyZ EQLHPLHFF\LSUXVF\QDFMRQDOLğFLQDOHJDMĆF\QDXWU]\P\ZDQLHīH 'DQ]LJQDOHīDâSU]H]W\VLĆFOHFLDGR1LHPLHF3UXVL]WHJRZ]JOċGX QDOHī\VWRVRZDýZâDğQLHWDNĆQD]Zċ ESROVF\QDFMRQDOLğFLDUJXPHQWXMĆF\īH*GDĕVNMHVWPLDVWHPSROVNLP LWRRGWDNVDPRGâXJLHJRF]DVXSU]HU\ZDQHJRMHG\QLHRNUHVDPL ]DERUyZLRNXSDFML EXī\WNRZQLF\F]ċVWRQLHPDMĆF\ZLHG]\ZRSLV\ZDQHMNZHVWLLQLHPD MĆF\WHīRNUHğORQHJR]GDQLDZGHEDFLHXZDīDMĆF\]DWRīHQDOHī\ VWRVRZDýQD]ZċF]ċğFLHMSRMDZLDMĆFĆVLċZĩUyGâDFKUyZQLHF]ċVWR Z\F]HUSDQLWUZDMĆFĆZ\PLDQĆ]GDĕLVWDUDMĆF\VLċ]DNRĕF]\ýNRQÁLNW EHG\WRU]\UyZQLHīQLHPDMĆF\RNUHğORQHJR]GDQLDZNZHVWLLQD]HZ QLFWZDOHF]UR]XPLHMĆF\īHNZHVWLDWDMHVWL]DSHZQHEċG]LHVSUDZĆ GUDīOLZĆGODZLHOXRVyEMDNWHīīHVWDELOQHUR]ZLĆ]DQLHEċG]LH PXVLDâRZ]LĆýSRGXZDJċLQWHUHV\ZV]\VWNLFKVWURQLVWDUDMĆF\VLċ Z\SUDFRZDýDNFHSWRZDOQ\GODZV]\VWNLFKNRPSURPLVMDNWHīâD JRG]ĆF\]DFKRZDQLDREXVWURQZ\FRIXMĆFLFKHG\FMH

WIECZNA WOJNA :URNXGHEDWDZHV]âDZNROHMQĆID]ċ3U]HGHZV]\VWNLPGR SRW\F]NLGRâĆF]\OLVLċNROHMQLRGGDQLHG\WRU]\:LHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZ XF]HVWQLF]ĆF\FKZVSRU]HRGVDPHJRSRF]ĆWNXXWU]\PDâRVZRMĆDN W\ZQRğýOHF]GRF]ċVWHJRHG\WRZDQLDZâĆF]\â\VLċMHV]F]HF]WHU\NRQWD 1LFRSRSLHUDMĆF\ZHUVMċÅ'DQ]LJµ:LNVLOQLHZVSLHUDMĆF\VWRVRZDQLH QD]Z\Å*GDĕVNµQLHFKċWQLHMHGQDNRGSRZLDGDMĆF\QDZLDGRPRğFL

105

106

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SR]RVWDZLRQHQDMHJRVWURQLHG\VNXVML6SDFH&DGHW]DGHNODURZDQ\ 3RODNSRSLHUDMĆF\VWRVRZDQLHQD]Z\Å*GDĕVNµ L-RKQ.DGPLQLVWUD WRUSRFKRG]ĆF\]H6WDQyZ=MHGQRF]RQ\FKZHGâXJZâDVQHMGHNODUDFML ]G\SORPHPGRNWRUDKLVWRULLSRF]ĆWNRZRVXJHUXMĆF\E\QD]ZċÅ'DQ]LJµ VWRVRZDýZNDīG\PRGQLHVLHQLXGRPLDVWDSU]HGURNLHPGRSyĩ QLHMV]\FKQDZLĆ]DĕVWRVXMĆFQD]ZċÅ*GDĕVNµ .ZHVWLDQD]Z\*GDĕVNDF]DVDPL]\VNLZDâD]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHV]HU V]HJRJURQD]ZâDV]F]DJG\GHEDW\QDWHQWHPDWSRMDZLDâ\VLċQDRJyO QHMOLğFLHG\VNXV\MQHMF]DVDPLğFLĆJDMĆFWHīXZDJċ]QDF]ĆF\FKXF]HVW QLNyZSURMHNWXMDNQS-LPER:DOHVDZZLċNV]RğFLSU]\SDGNyZ VXJHUXMĆF\FK]GURZRUR]VĆGNRZHUR]ZLĆ]DQLDQLHDQJDīXMĆF\FKVLċ]D WRZSUREOHP 0LċG]\VW\F]QLHPDOXW\PZDUW\NXOHQDWHPDW*GDĕVND GRNRQDQRSUDZLH]PLDQ]NWyU\FKSRQDGSRFKRG]LâDRGMHG QHJR]F]WHUHFKZVSRPQLDQ\FKHG\WRUyZF]DVDPLGRFKRG]LâRWHīGR ]DEH]SLHF]DQLDKDVâDSU]HGGRNRQ\ZDQLHPNROHMQ\FK]PLDQ]XZDJL QDXSRUF]\ZHNâyWQLHL]PLDQ\]PLDQR]QDF]RQRMDNRSU]\ZUyFH QLHSRSU]HGQLHMZHUVMLZZLHOXLQQ\FKSU]\SDGNDFK]PLDQ\FKRýQLH RSLV\ZDQRLFKMDNRZ\FRIDQLHZSURZDG]RQ\FKSRSU]HGQLRSRSUDZHN PLDâ\WHQVDPFKDUDNWHU :G\VNXVMLEUDOLXG]LDâUyZQLHīLQQLXī\W NRZQLF\ZW\PRVREDRZLHOHPyZLĆFHMQD]ZLHXī\WNRZQLND²*GDQVN :RMQDF]DVDPL]DKDF]DâDRLQQHZHUVMHMċ]\NRZH:LNLSHGLLJG\ī MHMXF]HVWQLF\SUyEXMĆFSRSU]HýSURSRQRZDQ\SU]H]VLHELHSXQNWZL G]HQLDGRNRQ\ZDOL]PLDQZLQQ\FKSURMHNWDFKMDNWHīPDQLSXORZDOL OLQNDPLLQWHUZLNLF]\OLSURZDG]ĆF\PLGRRGSRZLHGQLNyZGDQHJR DUW\NXâXZLQQ\FKZHUVMDFKMċ]\NRZ\FK:WHQVSRVyEDQJLHOVND:LNL SHGLDZVND]\ZDâDīHZLQQ\FKMċ]\NDFKPLDVWRQD]\ZDVLċDOER*GDĕVN DOER'DQ]LJ]DOHīQLHRGHG\WXMĆFHMIUDNFML '\VNXWDQFLSUyERZDOLUyZQLHīXVWDOLýSXQNWRGQLHVLHQLDVZRLFK GHF\]MLRVWDWHF]QĆÅRELHNW\ZQĆµPHWRGċSRGMċFLDGHF\]ML1LHNWyU]\ SU]\ZRâ\ZDOLZ\QLNLZ\V]XNLZDQLDZVHUZLVLH*RRJOHLQQLÅQDMF]ċVW V]HXī\FLHµZMċ]\NXDUJXPHQWWHQQDW\FKPLDVWRGU]XFRQR]HZ]JOċGX QDQLHPRīQRğýMHJR]ZHU\ÀNRZDQLD LQQLSU]HV]XNLZDOLDUFKLZDF]D VRSLVPQDXNRZ\FKXVWDODMĆFMDNLHQD]Z\VWRVRZDQRZRNUHğORQ\FK SU]HG]LDâDFKF]DVRZ\FKMHV]F]HLQQLSU]HV]XNLZDOLZSRGREQ\VSRVyE SRSXODUQHF]DVRSLVPDLJD]HW\FRSU]\yZF]HVQ\PVWDQLH,QWHUQHWX

1SG\VNXVMD]SDĩG]LHUQLND]DUFKLZL]RZDQDSRGDGUHVHPKWWSOLVWV ZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOZLNLSHGLDO2FWREHUKWPO

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? E\âRRZLHOHWUXGQLHMV]HQLīWHUD]:\QLNLQLHE\â\MHGQR]QDF]QH1LH MHVWQLHVSRG]LDQNĆīHZG\VNXVMLSRZUDFDâ\WHVDPHDUJXPHQW\ DXF]HVWQLF\GHEDW\E\OLğZLDGRPLLFKSRZWDU]DOQRğFL-HGQDNSRZUD FDMĆFHUDFMHSRZROL]DF]ċâ\RGQRVLýSR]\W\ZQ\VNXWHNXF]HVWQLF\ G\VNXVML]REOLJRZDQL]DVDGDPL:LNLSHGLLGRXSU]HMPRğFLZREOLF]X EORNDG\NRQWDMDNWHī]PXV]HQLGRSRSLHUDQLDVZRLFKVXJHVWLLĩUyGâDPL ]DF]ċOLSU]\QDMPQLHM]DXZDīDýīHGUXJDVWURQDG\VNXVMLF]\QLSR GREQHGRQLFKZ\VLâNL :VW\F]QLXSRGMċWRSLHUZV]ĆSUyEċXVWDOHQLDNRPSURPLVX REHMPXMĆFHJRFDâĆVSRâHF]QRğýOHF]VXJHVWLDE\PLDVWRQD]\ZDýÅ'DQ ]LJµZRNUHVLH²]DğSR]DW\PF]DVHPÅ*GDĕVNµFKRýSRSDUOL MĆPLQ-RKQ.1LFRL6]RSHQVSRWNDâDVLċ]RVWU\PVSU]HFLZHP]H VWURQ\ZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZ.LONXSU]\SDGNRZ\FKF]\WHOQLNyZQLH ğZLDGRP\FKGâXJLFKG\VNXVMLVWDUDâRVLċXZLDGRPLýPLċG]\QDURGR ZHPXNUċJRZLRGELRUFyZSRGâRīHFDâHMVSUDZ\]SXQNWXZLG]HQLD SROVNLHMVSRâHF]QRğFLLRGZRâ\ZDâRVLċGRZUDīOLZRğFLF]\WHOQLNyZ NRPHQWDU]]OXWHJRSRFKRG]ĆF\RGQLH]DORJRZDQHJRXī\W NRZQLND 1LHPLHFNDQD]ZD]RVWDâDSU]HIRUVRZDQDDSROVND]DND]DQD GRSLHUR SRHSRFH.XOWXUNDPSIXF]\OLZ\PXV]RQHMJHUPDQL]DFMLZODWDFK ;,;ZLHNX1LHPLHFNDSRF]WDGRVWDUF]DâDSU]HV\âNL]DUyZQRGRSRO VNLFKMDNLQLHPLHFNLFKRGELRUFyZDSRURNXSU]HVWDâDSU]\MPR ZDýGRZLDGRPRğFLLVWQLHQLHSROVNLFKQD]Z:ROQH0LDVWR*GDĕVN ² ZE\âR]DPLHV]NDQHSU]H]1LHPFyZDOHLVWQLDâ\ ZQLPUyZQLHīVLOQHZLċ]L]3ROVNĆVSUDZ\FHOQHSROLW\ND]DJUDQLF]QD SRF]WDLWG ZLċFXī\ZDQRGZyFKQD]Z²*GDĕVNL'DQ]LJ 3UDZG]LZ\SUREOHPSRMDZLâVLċZF]DVLH,,ZRMQ\ğZLDWRZHMNLHG\ OXG]L]DELMDQRDOERZ\V\âDQRGRRER]yZNRQFHQWUDF\MQ\FK6]WXWRZR ]DFKċýQD]\ZDQLDPLDVWDMHJRSROVNLPPLDQHP'ODWHJRZâDğQLHQLH PLHFNLHQD]Z\SROVNLFKPLHMVFRZRğFLVĆGOD3RODNyZZUċF]REUDĩOLZH 1LHZLHPGODF]HJRWDNLHUR]ZLĆ]DQLHQD]\ZDFLHNRPSURPLVHP

7DNLHDUJXPHQW\QLHRGQRVLâ\QDW\FKPLDVWRZHJRVNXWNXQLHXZD īDQRLFKWHī]DLVWRWQHOHF]]GHF\GRZDQLHSRPRJâ\SU]\QDMPQLHMF]ċğFL HG\WRUyZQLHEċGĆF\FK3RODNDPLGRVWU]HFīHGODQLHNWyU\FKF]âRQNyZ VSRâHF]QRğFLNZHVWLDQD]Z\*GDĕVNDMHVWPDWHULĆZUDīOLZĆ $UW\NXâE\â]DEH]SLHF]DQ\SU]HGGDOV]\PLHG\FMDPL]XZDJLQDZRMQ\ HG\F\MQHF]ċğý]ZLĆ]DQDE\âD]QD]ZĆPLDVWDF]ċğý²]MHJRKLVWRULĆ

107

108

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... &RFLHNDZHXī\WNRZQLF\RGGâXīV]HJRF]DVXUR]ZDīDMĆF\NZHVWLH]ZLĆ ]DQH]DUW\NXâHPQDMHJRVWURQLHG\VNXVMLVWDUDOLVLċXQLNDýFREDUG]LHM NRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKHG\FMLSRF]\QLOLQDZHWGDOHNRLGĆFHNURNLNXSRMHG QDQLXOXWHJRDGPLQLVWUDWRUMDNWHīSU]H]SHZLHQF]DVPH GLDWRULELXURNUDWD (G3RRUSRGMĆâSUyEċLQWHUZHQFMLRGEH]SLHF]DMĆF KDVâRLZJHğFLHMDNVDPRWRRSLVDâÅ]QDOH]LHQLDVSRVREXQDRVWDWHF]QH ]DīHJQDQLHNRQWURZHUVMLZRNyâQD]Z\PLDVWDµ]PLHQLâZVWċSGRDUW\ NXâXQDVWċSXMĆFR *GDĕVNOXE'DQ]LJ WR]QDQHHXURSHMVNLHPLDVWR]GâXJĆLEDUZQĆ KLVWRULĆ:Mċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLPMHVW]QDQHSRGGZRPDQLH]QDF]QLHUyī QLĆF\PLVLċQD]ZDPLZNROHMQRğFLDOIDEHW\F]QHM 'DQ]LJMċ]\NQLH PLHFNL L*GDĕVNMċ]\NSROVNL

1DVWURQLHG\VNXVMLQDW\FKPLDVWVNU\W\NRZDâWRSRVXQLċFLH-RKQ. FKRýVDPSRSLHUDâXī\ZDQLHQD]Z\Å'DQ]LJµSU]\QDMPQLHMZNRQWHN ğFLHKLVWRU\F]Q\P (FK(GQLH]E\WPLVLċSRGREDWZRMDZHUVMD3U]HGHZV]\VWNLPNDīG\ ]JRG]LVLċīHDNWXDOQLHPLDVWRQD]\ZDVLċ*GDĕVN-DVQHGDZQLHM F]ċVWRQD]\ZDQRWRPLDVWRÅ'DQ]LJµ.ZHVWLDW\ONRWHJRMDNQDMOHSLHM WHQIDNW]D]QDF]\ý2F]\ZLğFLHXZDīDPīHPRMDZHUVMDIDNW\F]QLH WâXPDF]ĆFDV\WXDFMċPLDVWR]Z\NOHQD]\ZDQR'DQ]LJGRURNX MHVWQDMOHSV]DDOHVĆG]ċīHDUW\NXâVXJHUXMĆF\MDNRE\RE\GZLHZHUVMH QD]Z\E\â\DNWXDOQLHUyZQRSUDZQHMHVWSRSURVWXEâċGQ\-HğOL]Dğ FKRG]LRZRMQċHG\F\MQĆQLHPLDâDRQDQLFZVSyOQHJR]G\VNXVMĆWR F]ĆFĆVLċQDWHMVWURQLHNWyUDQDPDUJLQHVLHZ\GDZDâDVLċMXīNU]HSQĆý )DNWHPMHVWīH>XVXQLċWDQD]ZDXī\WNRZQLNDZSURZDG]DMĆFHJR]DPċW@ ]DF]ĆâEDZLýVLċKDVâHPFHOHP]PLQLPDOL]RZDQLD]QDF]HQLDQD]Z\ 'DQ]LJZVWDZLDMĆFJG]LHVLċGDLQQHQD]Z\SUDNW\F]QLHQLHXī\ZDQH 1LHEċGċHG\WRZDýZVWċSXGRKDVâDOHF]LWDNXZDīDPīHDNWXDOQD MHJRZHUVMDMHVWQLH]E\WV]F]ċğOLZLHVIRUPXâRZDQD²MRKQOXW 87&

-DVQRZLGDýīHXī\WNRZQLNRPNWyU]\FKFLHOLXF]HVWQLF]\ýZG\V NXVMLNRĕF]\âDVLċDPXQLFMD3RQDGWR]XZDJLQDWRīHHWRV:LNLSHGLL QDU]XFDZG]LHG]LQLHĩUyGHâ]DVDG\SRVWċSRZDQLDSRGREQHGRQDXNR Z\FKXī\WNRZQLF\XWU]\PXMĆF\DNW\ZQRğýZG\VNXVMLE\OLFRQDMPQLHM VNâRQQLX]QDýUDFMċDUJXPHQWDFMLDGZHUVDU]\&RZLċFHMG\VWDQV

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? HPRFMRQDOQ\GRRSLV\ZDQ\FKWHPDWyZLXWU]\P\ZDQLHQHXWUDOQHJR SXQNWXZLG]HQLDVĆZ:LNLSHGLLMHGQ\PL]QDMZLċNV]\FKFQyWZLċF RWZDUWHXVWċSVWZDQDU]HF]DGZHUVDU]\PRJĆSU]\QLHğýV]DFXQHN VSRâHF]QRğFL'ODSU]\NâDGXZLQQHMRGSRZLHG]LQDLQWHUZHQFMċ(GD 3RRUDXī\WNRZQLN'HOLULXPGRGDâD 0RG\ÀNXMċQLHFRZHUVMċ(GDPDPQDG]LHMċīHZDNFHSWRZDOQ\VSRVyE &HOHPPRMHMHG\FMLE\âROHNNLHSU]\FK\OHQLHVLċNXDUJXPHQWRPSROVNLHM F]ċğFLG\VNXWDQWyZFRPDPQDG]LHMċMHVWZSRU]ĆGNX]XZDJLQD ZVSLHUDQLHSU]H]HPQLHMDNGRWĆGJâyZQLHVWURQ\ÅQLHPLHFNLHMµ:\MDğ QLDPīHDNWXDOQLHJâyZQLHXī\ZDVLċQD]Z\Å*GDĕVNµÅ'DQ]LJµ]Dğ MHVWQD]ZĆGDZQĆMDNWHīE\âĆQD]ZĆRERZLĆ]XMĆFĆZMċ]\NXDQJLHO VNLP²'HOLULXPOXW87&

(G\FMDZSRGREQ\PWRQLHOHF]GRNRQDQDSU]H]NRJRNROZLHN]ÅIUDN FMLJGDĕVNLHMµE\âDE\X]QDQD]DSU]HFLĆJDQLHZRMQ\HG\F\MQHMDZSHZ Q\FKV\WXDFMDFKPRJâDE\QDZHWVNXWNRZDýQDâRīHQLHPEORNDG\7D HG\FMDGRNRQDQDSU]H]RVREċ]SU]HFLZQHJRRER]XE\âD]GHF\GRZD QLHGRSU]\MċFLD3RPRJâRWRUyZQLHīZEXGRZDQLXMHMSR]\W\ZQHJR REUD]XMDNRRVRE\EċGĆFHMZVWDQLHZ\MğýSR]DZâDVQ\SXQNWZLG]HQLD LSRWUDÀĆFHMEH]VWURQQLHVSRMU]HýQDKDVâR &RPRīHZDīQLHMV]HV\WXDFMDSRND]DâDīHXī\WNRZQLF\]DDQJDīR ZDQLZZRMQċHG\F\MQĆDOHUyZQLHīXF]HVWQLF]ĆF\ZZ\PLDQLH]GDĕQD VWURQLHG\VNXVMLZVSRVyEZ\UDĩQ\VSU]HF]DMĆF\VLċZZLHOXNZHVWLDFK E\OLZVWDQLHG]LDâDýQD]DVDG]LHPLQLPDOQHJRNRQVHQVXVXZLQQ\FK 1DZHWMHğOLWH]JRGQHSXQNW\QLH]RVWDâ\Z\DUW\NXâRZDQHQDUXV]HQLH WDNLHJRQLHZ\SRZLHG]LDQHJRNRQVHQVXVX]HVWURQ\QRZRSU]\E\â\FK G\VNXWDQWyZQDZHW]GREU\PLLQWHQFMDPLQLHE\âRPLOHZLG]LDQH3R MDZLâDVLċUyZQRZDJDVWURQZNWyUHMNDīGD]QLFKSU]\QDMPQLHMX]QDâD ]DRERZLĆ]XMĆFHWHNZHVWLHNWyUHX]JRGQLRQRMXīZF]HğQLHMLE\âDğZLD GRPDLVWQLHQLDSXQNWyZ]DSDOQ\FK3RGREQLHGRERīRQDURG]HQLRZHJR UR]HMPX]F]DVX,ZRMQ\ğZLDWRZHMJG\QLHPLHFF\LEU\W\MVF\īRâQLH U]HZQLHNWyU\FKPLHMVFDFKVSRQWDQLF]QLHREFKRG]LOLğZLċWDUD]HP Z\PLHQLDMĆFQDZHWSRGDUXQNLXF]HVWQLF\ZRMQ\PLċG]\*GDĕVNLHP D'DQ]LJLHPSRMHGQDOLVLċJG\RVRE\]]HZQĆWU]QLHğZLDGRPHQLXDQ VyZWHJRFRXGDâRVLċX]JRGQLýZFKRG]Lâ\ZNRQÁLNW:\GDMHVLċīH ]DVDG\SURMHNWX]DUyZQRUR]ZLMDMĆFHMDNLWDPXMĆFHG\VRQDQVH ZVSLHUDMĆUR]ZyM:LNLSHGLL

109

110

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... =DFLċWDGHEDWDWUZDâDGDOHM=DSHZQHMHMXF]HVWQLF\SRF]XOLVLċQLH VZRMRZLG]ĆFīHG\VNXVMD]QDOD]âDVLċPDUFDQDOLğFLHÅQDM EDUG]LHMīDâRVQ\FKµZRMHQHG\F\MQ\FKZV]HFKF]DVyZ1LHRVWXG]LâRWR MHGQDNQLF]\LFK]DSDâyZQDMZ\UDĩQLHMRELHVWURQ\E\â\QLH]âRPQLH SU]HNRQDQHRVZHMVâXV]QRğFLPDUFDXī\WNRZQLN*GDQVNZUċF] VWZRU]\âFRğFRQD]ZDâÅUR]ZLĆ]DQLHPNRPSURPLVRZ\PµNWyUHJR P\ğOĆSU]HZRGQLĆFDâNRZLFLH]JRGQĆ]MHJRSXQNWHPZLG]HQLD E\âR MHGQDNE\ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLVWRVRZDýZ\âĆF]QLHQD]ZċÅ*GDĕVNµ ]DğLQQHQD]Z\SRZLQQRVLċSU]\ZRâDýMHG\QLHZRWZLHUDMĆF\PDND SLFLH5R]ZLĆ]DQLH]RVWDâRRF]\ZLğFLHSRSDUWHSU]H]ÅIUDNFMċJGDĕVNĆµ MDNWHī]\VNDâRRF]HNLZDQHZHWR]HVWURQ\MHMSU]HFLZQLNyZ:RMQD VWDZDâDVLċZVSRâHF]QRğFLFRUD]ZLGRF]QLHMV]DGRWHJRVWRSQLDīHZG\V NXVMLZ]LĆâXG]LDâyZF]HVQ\DGPLQLVWUDWRUDDNWXDOQLHF]âRQHN5DG\ 3RZLHUQLF]HM:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQNU\W\NXMĆFÅNRPSURPLVµ .LONDQDğFLHUD]\SRGHMPRZDQRSUyEċXVWDOHQLDEDUG]LHMRJyOQHJR LRVWDWHF]QHJRUR]ZLĆ]DQLDFKFĆFZSURZDG]LýJHQHUDOQH]DVDG\QD ]HZQLFWZDOHF]QLHE\â\RQHXGDQHPDUFD0HVWZLQRI *GDQVNMHGHQ]RUċGRZQLNyZQD]Z\Å*GDQVNµSRSURVLâRPHGLDFMċ PLċG]\IUDNFMĆNWyUDZMHJRRGF]XFLXSURPRZDâDXī\ZDQLHZDQJLHO VNLHM:LNLSHGLLQLHPLHFNLFKQD]ZPLDVWSROVNLFKLLQQ\FKSRâRīRQ\FK ZFHQWUDOQHM(XURSLHDW\PLNWyU]\WDNLHPX]DSLVRZLVLċVSU]HFLZLDOL -HGHQ]DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZOO\ZUFKVNRPHQWRZDâFDâRğýGRğýJRU]NR 6]F]HU]HPyZLĆFQLHZLG]ċNZHVWLLZNWyUHMGRSRPRJâDE\WXPHGLDFMD 2E\GZLHVWURQ\Z\GDMĆVLċWZDUGRVWDýQDVZRLFKVWDQRZLVNDFKLQLH X]QDZDýNRPSURPLVyZ

=XZDJLQDWRīHÅSURğEDRPHGLDFMċµPLDâDUDF]HMIRUPċOLVW\īĆGDĕ DSR]RVWDâHVWURQ\VSRUXQLHE\â\]DLQWHUHVRZDQHZ]LċFLHPZQLHM XG]LDâXWRSRVXQLċFLHSRVâXī\âRZ\âĆF]QLHMDNRSU]HVXQLċFLHG\VNXVML QDQRZHIRUXP

=REQSKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLDBWDON1DPLQJBFRQYHQWLRQVBGL VSXWHGBSODFHBQDPHV$UFKLYHB$BVXJJHVWLRQBIRUBDBFRQVLVWHQWBQDPLQJBFR QYHQWLRQBRIBGLVSXWHGBSODFHVF]\KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLDBWDON 1DPLQJBFRQYHQWLRQVBJHRJUDSKLFBQDPHV$UFKLYHBRUD]V]F]HJyOQLH KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL7DON*GDQVN1DPLQJBFRQYHQWLRQ 0DWHULDâGRVWċSQ\SRGDGUHVHPKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD5HTX HVWVBIRUBPHGLDWLRQ$UFKLYHB3ODFHQDPHVBLQB&HQWUDO(DVWHUQB(XURSH

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? -RKQ.SRZWyU]\âVZRMĆVXJHVWLċDE\ÅWU]\PDýVLċVWDQGDUGRZHJR Xī\FLDGODMċ]\NDDQJLHOVNLHJR0RīHXVWDOHQLHUDPVWDQGDUGRZHJRXī\ FLDSRZLQQRE\ýSR]RVWDZLRQHQDPNWyU]\W\PMċ]\NLHPZâDGDP\ MDNRRMF]\VW\PµNZLHWQLD 'RSURZDG]LâRE\WRGRZ\WUĆFHQLD ZV]HONLHJRRUċīD]UĆNMHJRDGZHUVDU]\OHF]QDWXUDOQLHVXJHVWLD]RVWDâD ]LJQRURZDQD%\âRMDVQHīHWUZDMĆQHJRFMDFMHQDGDNFHSWRZDOQ\PL UR]ZLĆ]DQLDPLOHF]]UHGXNRZDQLH]DZLNâDQHJRSUREOHPXKLVWRU\F] QHJRLVRFMRORJLF]QHJRZ\âĆF]QLHGRNZHVWLLOLQJZLVW\F]QHMRJUDQLF]DMĆF JRGRGDWNRZRGRURG]LP\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZMċ]\NDQLHPLDâRV]DQV QDDSUREDWċ 'RNRQDâUyZQLHī]QDF]Q\FKZ\VLâNyZDQDOL]XMĆFNVLĆīNLKLVWRU\F]QH MDNWHīZ\V\âDMĆF]DS\WDQLDGRQDXNRZHMED]\GDQ\FK-6725FKFĆF XVWDOLýMDNKLVWRU\F\QD]\ZDOLPLDVWRZUyīQ\FKRNUHVDFKMHJRKLVWRULL %DGDQLHĩUyGHâE\âR]GHF\GRZDQLHZDīQHGODG\VNXVMLOHF]QLHSRUR ]XPLHQLDSU]HNURF]\â\MXīSXQNWNU\W\F]Q\SR]DNWyU\PRVLĆJQLċFLH VSyMQHMZL]MLE\âRMXīQLHPRīOLZHUR]PLMDMĆFVLċMXīZUċF]]H]GURZ\P UR]VĆGNLHP1DZHWSR]RUQLHPDâRSUREOHPDW\F]QHGHF\]MHMDN]DSLV\ SLHUZV]\FKVâyZDUW\NXâXJHQHURZDâ\V]HURNLHGHEDW\LZ\ZRG\SHâQH QLXDQVyZ]DğZ\EyUMHGQHJR]F]WHUHFKSURSRQRZDQ\FKUR]ZLĆ]DĕE\â Z\MĆWNRZRWUXGQ\ E*GDĕVNSRSU]HGQLR'DQ]LJ E*GDĕVNQLHP'DQ]LJ E*GDĕVNSRSU]HGQLRUyZQLHī'DQ]LJ E*GDĕVNSRSU]HGQLRZMċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLP'DQ]LJ 1DMZ\UDĩQLHMVWZLHUG]HQLHīH*GDĕVNQD]\ZDQRNLHG\ğÅ'DQ]LJµ ZVND]\ZDâRMDNRE\SROVNDQD]ZDZF]HğQLHMQLHLVWQLDâDF]HPXVSU]H FLZLDâDVLċSROVNDIUDNFMD0yZLHQLHRÅ'DQ]LJµMDNRQD]ZLHZ\âĆF]QLH QLHPLHFNLHMQLHSDVRZDâRDGZHUVDU]RPJG\īQDOHJDOLRQLīHQD]ZD WDE\âDNLHG\ğUyZQLHīV]HURNRVWRVRZDQDZMċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLPVWRVR ZDQRMĆSUDZLHZ\âĆF]QLHFRE\âRDUJXPHQWHPSU]HPDZLDMĆF\P SU]HFLZNR]DSLVRZLÅ*GDĕVNSRSU]HGQLRUyZQLHī'DQ]LJµ 3RGREQLH ZĆWSOLZDE\âDRVWDWQLDSURSR]\FMDJG\īVXJHURZDâDMDNRE\Å'DQ]LJµ E\âQD]ZĆDQJLHOVNĆQLHEċGĆFĆMXīZXī\FLX:\EyUMHGQHM]RSFML Z\GDZDâVLċRJyâRZLVSRâHF]QRğFLQLHLVWRWQ\OHF]XUyVâGRUDQJLZLHO NLHJRSUREOHPXZRF]DFK]DDQJDīRZDQ\FKRVyESRQRZQLHZVND]XMĆF QDPRīOLZRğýHVNDODFMLSRğZLċFHQLDGRQLHERW\F]Q\FKUR]PLDUyZ 7DPDâR]QDF]ĆFDNZHVWLDE\âDMHG\QLHF]XENLHPJyU\ORGRZHMJG\ī QDZDUVWZLDâ\VLċNROHMQHSUREOHP\'ODSU]\NâDGXGRSXV]F]HQLHGR

111

112

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]DSLVyZ]H]QDNDPLGLDNU\W\F]Q\PLZ\HZROXR ZDâRGRRGUċEQHJRGâXJLHJRZĆWNXG\VNXVML :W\PF]DVLHXī\WNRZQLN:LNDNW\ZQ\XF]HVWQLNSRW\F]NLPLċG]\ *GDĕVNLHPD'DQ]LJLHPZSDGâZWDUDSDW\:LNGRNRQDâZDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLSRQDGW\VLċF\HG\FMLSROVNLHMZHUVMLMċ]\NRZHMQLHHG\ WRZDâZRJyOH LX]QDZDQRJR]DEDUG]RGRğZLDGF]RQHJRHG\WRUD%\â MHGQDNGRğýQLHFKċWQ\G\VNXVMRPQDGZâDVQ\PLHG\FMDPLLNRPHQWD U]RPRZ\FRI\ZDQLXSU]H]QLHJRHG\FMLLQQ\FK'ODZLHOXZLNLSHG\VWyZ GHQHUZXMĆFHE\âRWRīHZ\FRI\ZDâHG\FMH]DZLHUDMĆFHSRPQLHMV]HEâċG\ SR]RVWDZLRQHRERNZLHOXSUDZLGâRZ\FKLQIRUPDFML]DPLDVWRZHQLH ]QDF]QHSRWNQLċFLDNRU\JRZDý=XZDJLQDSRZ\īV]H]DQLHGEDQLDRUD] XSLHUDQLHVLċZNZHVWLLDUW\NXâXRSLVXMĆFHJR*GDĕVN.RPLWHW$UEL WUDīRZ\Z\GDâGHF\]MċZP\ğONWyUHMXī\WNRZQLNRZLQLHZROQRE\âR SU]\ZUDFDýSRSU]HGQLHMZHUVMLGDQHMVWURQ\ZLċFHMQLīWU]\UD]\:LN SUyERZDâÅSU]HFK\WU]\ýV\VWHPµG\VNXWXMĆFQDGQLXDQVDPLIRUP\ VâRZQHMZHUG\NWXMDNWHīSURV]ĆFRVRE\PXSU]\MD]QHRSRğUHGQLFWZR ZSU]\ZUDFDQLXSRSU]HGQLFKZHUVMLKDVHâQDOLğFLHZ\PLHQLâ ZW\P>>HQ*GDQVN@@ 1LHGâXJRSRWHPRWZDUWRNROHMQ\ZQLRVHNDU ELWUDīRZ\ZNWyU\PE\âVWURQĆLZZ\QLNXNWyUHJR]RVWDâZPDMX GRī\ZRWQLRSR]EDZLRQ\PRīOLZRğFLHG\WRZDQLD:LNLSHGLL3R W\PZ\URNX:LNSU]HGVWDZLâ-LPER:DOHVRZLXOWLPDWXPDJG\MHJR īĆGDQLDQLH]RVWDâ\VSHâQLRQHUR]SRF]ĆâDWDNRZDQLH:LNLSHGLLSU]\ Xī\FLX]âRğOLZHJRSURJUDPXQLV]F]ĆFHJRKDVâDMDNWHīHG\WRZDQLH ]ZLHOXNRQWNWyUHRVWDWHF]QLHVNXWHF]QLH]DEORNRZDQRSRF]\P RSXğFLâSURMHNW 0ċF]ĆFHLEROHVQHZRMQ\HG\F\MQHZğUyGNWyU\FKZRMQDPLċG]\ *GDĕVNLHPD'DQ]LJLHPE\âDMHGQĆ]ZLċNV]\FKMDNWHīVXNFHV]DVWR VRZDQLDÅ]DVDG\WU]HFKUHZHUWyZµZXWHPSHURZDQLX]DSċGyZ:LND ZOLVWRSDG]LHGRSURZDG]Lâ\GRX]QDQLDMHM]DRÀFMDOQĆ]DVDGċ DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLSRG]LğG]LHĕWHMUHJXâ\MDNRV]W\ZQRRERZLĆ ]XMĆFHM]DVDG\QLHZSURZDG]LâDDQLSROVND:LNLSHGLDDQLZLHOHLQQ\FK SURMHNWyZ =DVDGD]ZDQDZVNUyFLH55PyZLīH]QLHOLF]Q\PL Z\MĆWNDPLZFLĆJXNDīG\FKJRG]LQMHGQDRVREDPRīHGRNRQDýW\ONR

KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLDBWDON5HTXHVWVBIRUBDUELWUDWLRQ:LN KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD5HTXHVWVBIRUBDUELWUDWLRQ*]RUQHQSODW] ([WHQVLRQBRIBEDQ

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? WU]HFKZ\FRIDĕHG\FMLZGDQ\PDUW\NXOH]DğHG\WRU]\QDUXV]DMĆF\Wċ ]DVDGċPRJĆE\ý]DEORNRZDQL]RE>>HQ:3(GLWZDUULQJ@@>>:LNL SHGLD:RMQDHG\F\MQD@@ 5R]ZLĆ]DQLHRVRELğFLH]DWZLHUG]Lâ-LPER :DOHV 6SyUMHGQDNWUZDâGDOHMZQDMOHSV]H1DNâDGDQHF]DVDPLRJUDQLF]HQLD QDHG\WRZDQLHDUW\NXâXMDNQDSU]\NâDG]DEH]SLHF]HQLHVWURQ\ZURNX SU]H]DGPLQLVWUDWRUDLELXURNUDWċ5DXOQLHZLHOH]G]LDâDâ\ ZNZHVWLLRVWXG]HQLDNRQÁLNWX'RNRQDâ\ZUċF]F]HJRğSU]HFLZQHJR UR]MXV]DMĆFF]ċğýXF]HVWQLNyZ8ī\WNRZQLN*GDQVNSRVXQĆâVLċZUċF] GRV]DOHĕF]HJRHG\WRZDQLDKDVHâRQLHPLHFNLFKPLHMVFRZRğFLDFK GRGDMĆFLFKSROVNLHQD]Z\ZÅDNFLHRGZHWX]D]DEORNRZDQLH*GDĕVND L6]F]HFLQDµ]DFR]RVWDâW\PF]DVRZR]DEORNRZDQ\ :PLċG]\F]DVLHXī\WNRZQLN+DOLEXWW]DâRī\âVWURQċ]JâRVRZDQLHP QDGQD]HZQLFWZHP>>HQ7DON*GDĕVN1DPLQJFRQYHQWLRQ@@ 1LH SU]\QLRVâDRQDRF]HNLZDQHJRUR]ZLĆ]DQLDDMHG\QLHSRV]HU]\âDSROH GRG\VNXVML'ODSU]\NâDGXG\VNXWRZDQRRGQRZDNZHVWLHGRPQLHP\ZDĕ F]\OLFKRFLDīE\F]\VWZLHUG]HQLHīHÅ'DQ]LJµMHVWQD]ZĆQLHPLHFNĆ LPSOLNXMHīHQLHMHVWRQDXī\ZDQDZLQQ\FKMċ]\NDFK6SUDZG]DQR UR]ZLĆ]DQLDSU]\MċWHZLQQ\FKHQF\NORSHGLDFK(QFDUWD%ULWDQQLFD &ROXPELDF]\LQIRSOHDVHFRP DLWDN-RKQ.]UR]F]DURZDQLHPVWZLHU G]LâÅ%UDNZ\UDĩQHJRNRQVHQVXVXZ,QWHUQHFLHLLQQ\FKHQF\NORSHGLDFK FRGRWHJRMDNQD]\ZDVLċWHUD]WRPLDVWRµ]DğG\VNXWDQFL]GDZDOLVLċ VWRSQLRZRSRSDGDýZSDUDQRMċZNWyUHMQLFMXīQLHE\âRSHZQH=DNZH VWLRQRZDQRQDZHWIDNWīHDQJORMċ]\F]QHPHGLDVWRVRZDâ\]Z\F]DMRZR QD]ZċÅ*GDQVNµJG\īSRPLQLċFLH]QDNXGLDNU\W\F]QHJRPRJâRE\ý FHORZHLZVND]\ZDýQDSUDZLGâRZĆQD]ZċDQJLHOVNĆOHF]PRJâRWHī E\ýVNXWNLHPQLHFKOXMVWZDW\SRJUDÀF]QHJRZLċFMDNRSUDZLGâRZĆQD]Zċ ZMċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLPQDOHīDâRE\SU]\MĆýÅ*GDĕVNµ*âRVRZDQLHE\âR MHGQDNXī\WHF]QHZW\PīHSRGVXPRZDâR]DOHW\LZDG\NDīGHMSUR SR]\FMLQD]HZQLFWZDDHG\WRU]\PRJOLNRPHQWRZDýSRV]F]HJyOQH UR]ZLĆ]DQLDLZ\PLHQLDýLFKZDG\L]DOHW\

KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD7KUHHBUHYHUWBUXOHBHQIRUFHPHQW 1SWXWDMKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLQGH[SKS"WLWOH .LHO GLII RO GLG

113

114


POKÓJ Z POMINIĘCIEM KONSENSUSU '\VNXVMDQDSRZ\īV]HMVWURQLHWUZDâDUyZQROHJOH]Z\PLDQĆ]GDĕQD VWURQLHG\VNXVMLVDPHJRKDVâDGRSDĩG]LHUQLNDURNX5R]SRF]\ QDâ\VLċLNRĕF]\â\ZRMQ\HG\F\MQHGRW\F]ĆFH]DUyZQR*GDĕVNDMDN LWHPDWyZSRNUHZQ\FK3DWGHF\]\MQ\GRSURZDG]LâGRSRGGDQLDNZHVWLL SRGG\VNXVMċV]HUV]HMVSRâHF]QRğFLOXWHJRDGPLQLVWUDWRU&KULV G]LDâDMĆFZVSyOQLH]-RKQHP.L6]RSHQHPSU]\JRWRZDâEDUG]R V]F]HJyâRZĆVWURQċJâRVRZDQLDSR]ZDODMĆFĆNDīGHPXFKċWQHPXQD Z\UDīHQLHVZRMHJR]GDQLDFRGRQD]Z\PLDVWDZV]HğFLXRNUHVDFKMHJR KLVWRULLMDNWHīQD]GHF\GRZDQLHRQD]HZQLFWZLH*GDĕVNDZLQQ\FK NRQWHNVWDFKQSELRJUDÀDFKRGV\âDF]DFK ]DZLHUDâDWHī]DSLV\RHJ ]HNZRZDQLXXVWDORQHJRNRQVHQVXVXZSU]\V]âRğFL3RF]\QLRQRNURNL E\XZ]JOċGQLýRF]HNLZDQLDF]\WHOQLNyZ]UyīQ\FKNUDMyZRUyīQ\P VWRSQLXZUDīOLZRğFLMHGHQ]SU]HGVWDZLFLHOLÅRER]XSROVNLHJRµ]DSUR SRQRZDâE\ZSU]\SDGNXELRJUDÀLRVyER]GHF\GRZDQLHQLHPLHFNLP SRFKRG]HQLXQLH]DOHīQLHRGRNUHVXKLVWRU\F]QHJRVWRVRZDýQD]Zċ QLHPLHFNĆDQDORJLF]QLHGRELRJUDÀL3RODNyZ JG\īF]\WHOQLF\SU]H JOĆGDMĆF\RGQRğQHDUW\NXâ\SUDZGRSRGREQLHEċGĆWHMVDPHMQDURGR ZRğFLLORNDOQDQD]ZDEċG]LHLPEDUG]LHMRGSRZLDGDâD *âRVRZDQLH]RVWDâRRJâRV]RQHVSRâHF]QRğFLL]DDQRQVRZDQHZ:LNL SHGLD6LJQSRVWSRQRZQLHRWU]\PXMĆFWDPPLDQRÅSUDZGRSRGREQLH QDMGâXīV]HJRLQDMZLċNV]HJRVSRUXZRNyâNV]WDâWXDUW\NXâXZ:LNL SHGLLµ=DQDMSRSXODUQLHMV]ĆRSFMĆRSRZLHG]LDâRVLċZJâRVRZDQLXQLHFR SRQDGRVyEZSR]RVWDâ\FKSU]\SDGNDFKJâRVyZE\âRQLHZLHOHPQLHM 1LHMHVWWRVâDE\Z\QLNOHF]ZWDN²Z\GDZDâRE\VLċ²ZDīNLHMVSUDZLH WR]DVNDNXMĆFRQLHZLHOH'\VNXVMDQDVWURQLH>>HQ:37DON*GDQVN 9RWHGLVFXVVLRQ@@OHGZRSU]HNURF]\âDREMċWRğýSLċFLXW\VLċF\VâyZ LPLDâDSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPFKDUDNWHUWHFKQLF]Q\MDNQDOHīDâRE\SU]H SURZDG]LýJâRVRZDQLH $UJXPHQW\QDVWURQLHVDPHJRJâRVRZDQLDE\â\]GHF\GRZDQLH GâXīV]HGDMĆFZVXPLHW\VLċF\VâyZZâĆF]QLH]JâRVDPL1DGDO ZLGRF]QHE\âRīHZV]\VWNLHVWURQ\VĆğZLDGRPHSRZWDU]DOQRğFLVZR LFKDUJXPHQWyZLīHF]DVDPLQRZRSU]\E\OLG\VNXWDQFLE\OLSRGHMU]H ZDQLRE\FLHQRZ\PLZFLHOHQLDPLGRW\FKF]DVRZ\FKLQWHUORNXWRUyZ HG\WXMĆF\FKVSRGQRZHMQD]Z\Xī\WNRZQLNDOXEQDZHWQLH]DORJR ZDZV]\VLċ

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? 8XXFKF]\PRīH7\WR+HOJD":V]\VWNLHWHÅDUJXPHQW\µMXī ZLG]LDâHPLVĆG]ċīHMXī]QLPLVNRĕF]\OLğP\-HVWHPSU]HNRQDQ\īH RGSRZLHG]LLG\VNXVMDVĆJG]LHğZKLVWRULLVWURQ\ 6]RSHQ PDU87&

3UDZLHZV]\VWNLHJâRV\RGGDQRSU]HGRVWDWQLPGQLHPJâRVRZDQLD PDUFD ZLHOH]QLFKSRMDZLâRVLċQLHGâXJRSRRWZDUFLXJâRVR ZDQLD3RND]XMHWRīHZV]\VF\]DLQWHUHVRZDQLXZDīQLHğOHG]LOLNZHVWLċ DQNLHW\0RīOLZHīHQLHZV]\VF\]DJUDOLF]\VWRV]F]HJyOQLHZJâRVR ZDQLXGODRNUHVXODW²JG]LH]QDOD]âRVLċJâRVyZ]DRSFMĆ Å'DQ]LJµL]DRSFMĆÅ*GDĕVNµSU]\F]\PJâRVyZ]DSROVNRMċ ]\F]QĆRSFMĆSRFKRG]LâRRGXī\WNRZQLNyZ]QLHZLHONĆOLF]EĆHG\FML QDNRQFLHSU]H]FRSUDZGRSRGREQHMHVWīHNRQWDWH]RVWDâ\DNW\ZR ZDQHQDDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLZ\âĆF]QLHGODXF]HVWQLFWZDZJâRVRZD QLX²OLF]EDWDNLFKSRGHMU]DQ\FKJâRVyZMHVW]DVNDNXMĆFRZ\VRND -HGHQ]JâRVyZQDSHZQR]RVWDâ]âRīRQ\]NRQWDNWyUHURNSyĩQLHM RND]DâRVLċSDF\QNĆMHGQHJR]RUċGRZQLNyZSROVNLHMQD]Z\PLDVWD :LċNV]RğýSR]RVWDâ\FKSRGHMU]DQ\FKJâRVyZPRJâDMHGQDNSRFKRG]Lý RGSROVNLFKXī\WNRZQLNyZNWyU]\SRLQIRUPRZDQLRWRF]ĆF\PVLċJâR VRZDQLXUHMHVWURZDOLNRQWDZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLFKFĆFZ\UD]Lý VZRMH]GDQLHZ\NOXF]HQLHW\FKJâRVyZ]GHF\GRZDQLHQLHE\âRSRVX QLċFLHPSURFHGXUDOQLHRF]\ZLVW\POHF]QLHZ\ZRâDâRWHīEXU]\)DNW īHNZHVWLDE\âDRF]\ZLğFLHF]RâRZ\PSXQNWHP]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDSROVNLFK LQLHPLHFNLFKZLNLSHG\VWyZSU]\F]\PSRSXODFMD1LHPLHFVWDQRZL GZXNURWQRğýOXGQRğFL3ROVNLMDNWHīīHJâRVRZDQLHPRJâRE\ýZ\SD F]RQH]XZDJLQD]DVDGċZLċNV]RğFLL]QLHNV]WDâFHQLDZ\QLNDMĆFH]QD WXU\VDPHJRV\VWHPXQLHZ\ZRâDâZLċNV]HMG\VNXVML 2JyâHPXF]HVWQLF\FK\EDX]QDOLīHZV]\VWNR]RVWDâRMXīSRZLHG]LD QHDVDPRJâRVRZDQLHSU]HELHJâRUDF]HMVSRNRMQLH]U]DGNLPLRVNDU īHQLDPLRSURSDJDQG\VW\F]QH]DğOHSLHQLH3R]DPNQLċFLXJâRVRZDQLD QLHZ\VWċSRZDâ\GUDPDW\F]QHSURWHVW\ZLċFXī\WNRZQLF\Z\GDOLVLċ ]DDNFHSWRZDýMHJRUH]XOWDW 1DWXUDOQLHNZHVWLDQD]Z\PLDVWDQLH]QLNâDQDGREUHDWHPDWWHQ F]DVDPLSRZUDFDâFKRýE\]XZDJLQDRGNU\ZDQLHJRSU]H]ğZLHī\FK HG\WRUyZ1DZHWFDâNLHPQLHGDZQRERZOLSFXURNXPRīQDE\âR 3DF\QNDWRSU]\MċWHZ:LNLSHGLLRNUHğOHQLHNROHMQHJRNRQWD]DâRīRQHJRSU]H] WċVDPĆRVREċZFHOXZ\ZRâDQLDZUDīHQLDV]HUV]HJRSRSDUFLDGDQHMLGHL

115

116

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... WUDÀýQDNUyWNĆGHEDWċRW\PF]\PDORZLGâR]URNXSċG]OD KROHQGHUVNLHJRDUW\VW\,]DDNDYDQGHQ%ORFNH]DW\WXâRZDQH$OOHJRU\ RI*GDĕVNWUDGH$OHJRULDKDQGOXJGDĕVNLHJR QLHSRZLQQRVLċUDF]HM QD]\ZDý$OOHJRU\RI'DQ]LJWUDGH3RGREQLHZPDMXHG\WRUOHJL W\PXMĆF\VLċZHGâXJZâDVQHMGHNODUDFML NLONRPDG\SORPDPLLQDJUR GDPLXF]HOQLDQ\PLSUyERZDâSRQRZQLHRWZRU]\ýG\VNXVMċQDGQD]ZĆ PLDVWDOHF]]RVWDâSU]HNRQDQ\īHVSRâHF]QRğý]DGHF\GRZDâDMXīRWHM NZHVWLL-HV]F]HLQQ\SU]\NâDGSRFKRG]L]F]HUZFDNLHG\WR QLH]DORJRZDQ\Xī\WNRZQLNSUyERZDâGRGDýGRKDVâD]GDQLHQDVWċSX MĆFHMWUHğFLÅ1LHPLHFNDQD]ZDPLDVWDSU]HZDīDâDZDQJLHOVNLFKWHN VWDFKGRNRĕFD,,ZRMQ\ğZLDWRZHMµ-HJRZSLVXVXQLċWRSRPLQXWDFK :LGDý]WHJRMHGQR]QDF]QLHīHSRGMċWRGHF\]MċDGRğZLDGF]HQLHG\ WRU]\LDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\F]XZDOLQDGMHMXWU]\PDQLHP:V]HONLHSUyE\ REDOHQLDZHUVMLZ\SUDFRZDQHMZURNXPLDâ\MHG\QLHFKZLORZ\ FKDUDNWHULīDGQHM]QLFKQLHSRGMċâDRVREDUHJXODUQLHHG\WXMĆFDDUW\ NXâ\]WHMG]LHG]LQ\ $UW\NXâ\RSLVXMĆFH*GDĕVNL'DQ]LJVĆDNWXDOQLHZVWDELOQHMIRUPLH QDZHWMHğOLWRGUXJLHE\âRF]DVDPLSROHPSRPQLHMV]\FKZRMHQHG\F\M Q\FKJG\īVWDQRZLRQRSU]HNLHURZDQLHGRQD]Z\PLDVWDDQLH²MDN ZROHOLE\QLHNWyU]\²XMHGQR]QDF]QLHQLHZ\PLHQLDMĆFHRSUyF]*GDĕVND UyZQLHīDPHU\NDĕVNL]HVSyâKHDY\PHWDORZ\'DQ]LJ&KRý]DVDG\ :LNLSHGLLPyZLĆīHNRQVHQVXVPRīHXOHFQDJâ\P]PLDQRPFRF]ċVWR DQJLHOVF\ZLNLSHG\ğFLVNUDFDMĆGRÅ&&&µ.ULSOHDQLLQ 'âXJRWUZDOLXī\WNRZQLF\QLHFKFĆWUDFLýF]DVXPDNâyWQLHZNZHVWLDFK NWyUHX]QDMĆ]DMXīUR]ZLĆ]DQH:VND]\ZDQLHZF]HğQLHMZ\SUDFRZDQHJR NRQVHQVXVXSRGREQLHMDNOLQNRZDQLHGR]DVDGSURMHNWXWRPHWRGDQD ZDONċ]WUROODPL

0RīHZâDğQLHGODWHJRRVRE\NWyUHSyĩQRZFKRG]ĆGRSUDFQDG RNUHğORQ\PLDUW\NXâDPLF]ċVWRVWRMĆZG\VNXVMDFKZ:LNLSHGLLQDVWUD FRQHMSR]\FML2·1HLOE

&RFLHNDZHDPRīHQDZHWZ\QLNDMĆFH]WDNSRNRMRZHJRVWDQXKDVHâ*GDĕVN ]âRī\âVZRMĆRIHUWċ]RUJDQL]RZDQLDZURNXNRQIHUHQFML:LNLPDQLDLZ\JUDâ ]2NVIRUGHPRUD]$PVWHUGDPHPZRVWDWHF]QHMUR]JU\ZFH%\âRWRV]yVWHPLHMVFH ZNWyU\P]RUJDQL]RZDQRGRURF]QĆNRQIHUHQFMċUXFKX:LNLPHGLD

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? TRAJEKTORIE KONFLIKTÓW 6NXWNLHPZRMQ\HG\F\MQHMR*GDĕVNE\â\]PLDQ\Z]DVDGDFK:LNLSHGLL LQRZHHOHPHQW\ZLNLIRONORUXREHFQHZZ\PLDQLH]GDĕPLċG]\ZLNL SHG\VWDPLSRG]LğG]LHĕJG\SU]\ZRâXMHVLċOHJHQGDUQ\FKUR]PLDUyZ G\VNXVMċQDGSR]RUQLHPDâR]QDF]ĆFĆNZHVWLĆ 3DWU]ĆFZVWHF]]DXZDī\ýQDOHī\īHUR]ZLĆ]DQLHVSUDZ\Å*GDĕVN F]\'DQ]LJµZ\GDâRVLċRGQLHğýPRFQRORNDOQ\VNXWHN3RPRJâR ZXVWDOHQLXIXQNFMRQXMĆFHJRVWDWXVTXRZWHMNRQNUHWQHMV\WXDFMLOHF] PLDâR]GHF\GRZDQLHQLNâ\ZSâ\ZQDSRGREQHSU]\SDGNL'\VNXVMH LZRMQ\RSRGREQLHHSLFNLHMVNDOLZ\VWċSXMĆZ:LNLSHGLLFDâ\F]DV'OD SU]\NâDGXU]HND*DQJHVNWyUĆDQJORMċ]\F]QHRVRE\PLHV]NDMĆFH Z,QGLDFKQDMF]ċğFLHMQD]\ZDMĆ*DQJDZ\PLHQLDQDMHVWZ:LNLSHGLL ZâDğQLHSRGQD]ZĆ*DQJHVJG\īMHVWRQDEDUG]LHM]QDQDRVRERPXī\ ZDMĆF\PMċ]\NDDQJLHOVNLHJRZNUDMDFK=DFKRGX:UR]XPLHQLXPLHV] NDĕFyZ,QGLLWDIRUPDQD]Z\MHVWMHGQDNSR]RVWDâRğFLĆF]DVyZNROR QLDOQ\FKLMDNRWDNDPDZLHONLH]QDF]HQLHV\PEROLF]QHLHPRFMRQDOQH :ODWDFK²SURZDG]RQRV]HURNLHGHEDW\QDG]PLDQĆQD]HZQLF WZD²ZĆWNyZZWHMVSUDZLH]QDOHĩýPRīQDQDVWURQLH>>HQ7DON *DQJHV@@DLWDNVSUDZDZ\GDMHVLċGDOHNDRG]DPNQLċFLD3RGREQH G\OHPDW\Mċ]\NRZHWRNZHVWLD:\EU]HīD.RğFL6âRQLRZHM,YRU\&RDVW F]\&{WHG·,YRLUH .LMRZD.LHYF]\.\LY LZLHOXLQQ\FKPLHMVFZXMċ FLX]DUyZQRKLVWRU\F]Q\PMDNLZVSyâF]HVQ\PSU]\F]\PVSRU\RQD ]Z\JHRJUDÀF]QHVĆMHG\QLHZ\FLQNLHPFDâRğFLNRQÁLNWyZZ:LNLSHGLL 3ROVNROLWHZVNLHQDSLċFLDZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLUyZQLHīVLċ]GDU]Dâ\ LGRW\NDâ\FDâHMSOHMDG\KDVHâ²]RE>>HQ:3:LNL3URMHFWB/LWKXDQLD &RQÁLFWBUHVROXWLRQ@@ 1DZHWWHPDW\PRFQRQLHVWDQGDUGRZHVWDMĆVLċRELHNWHP]DFLċW\FK GHEDW'ODSU]\NâDGXRGNZLHWQLDGRF]HUZFDZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNL SHGLLJRUĆFRGHEDWRZDQRQDGW\PF]\0HNV\NPDMċ]\NXU]ċGRZ\ F]\QLH3RZ\PLDQLHĩUyGHâOLQNyZF\WDWyZLDUJXPHQWyZFDâRğý ]DMċâDW\VLċF\VâyZ QLHRVLĆJQLċWRNRQVHQVXVX5R]ZLĆ]DQLDQLH SU]\QLRVâRQDZHWJâRVRZDQLHPRīHGODWHJRīHZ]LċOLZQLPXG]LDâJâyZ QLHXF]HVWQLF\VSRUXLRGZURWQLHQLīE\âRWRZSU]\SDGNX*GDĕVND VSUDZDQLHZ]EXG]LâD]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDRVyE]]HZQĆWU]LZ]ZLĆ]NX

KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL7DON0H[LFR5I&'RHVBPH[LFRBKDYHBDQBRIIL FLDOBODQJXDJH

117

118

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]W\PQLHPRīQDE\âRZLċFSRZLHG]LHýE\Z\QLNJâRVRZDQLDRG]ZLHU FLHGODâV]HUV]\SXQNWZLG]HQLD:SRGREQ\PGXFKXGHF\]MDRW\P F]\DUW\NXâRMRJXUFLHSRZLQLHQVLċZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLQD]\ZDý >>HQ\RJXUW@@F]\>>HQ\RJKXUW@@VWDâDVLċSU]HGPLRWHPG]LHVLċFLX G\VNXVMLLZ\ZRâDâDQLH]OLF]RQĆOLF]EċZRMHQHG\F\MQ\FKZODWDFKRG GRSU]HGRVLĆJQLċFLHPZPLDUċVWDELOQHJRUR]ZLĆ]DQLD '\VNXVMDQDWHPDWWHJRF]\]GMċFLHPWDUDQWXOLSRZLQQRVLċ]LOXVWUR ZDýKDVâRRDUDFKQRIRELLE\âDF]WHURNURWQLHGâXīV]DQLīG\VNXVMDQDG SR]RVWDâ\PLDVSHNWDPLKDVâD)RUWHLLQ 7DNGâXJLHLRVWUHVSRU\ VĆW\SRZ\PHOHPHQWHPZV]\VWNLFKGXī\FKSURMHNWyZGODSU]\NâDGX FLHNDZDMHVWDQDOL]DNRQÁLNWXQDIUDQFXVNLHM:LNLSHGLLF]\3OXWRQ SRZLQLHQSU]HGVWDZLDQ\MDNRSODQHWD)UpDUGLLQ 0LPRīH RGVHWHNVWURQVWDQRZLĆF\FKSU]\NâDG\SRZDīQLHMV]\FKZRMHQHG\F\MQ\FK VWDQRZL6XPLLLQ WRQLHZLHOXHG\WRUyZQLJG\QLHXF]HVW QLF]\âRZZ\PLDQLH]GDĕQDMHGHQ]ÅJRUĆF\FKµWHPDWyZ0yZLVLċ WHīīHZ:LNLSHGLLNRQÁLNW\ÅZFLĆJDMĆMDNNRNDLQDµ5HDJOHD 3URFHVWHQVDPZVRELHQLHQLHVLH]HVREĆQHJDW\ZQ\FKVNXWNyZGOD VSRâHF]QRğFLDQLHQF\NORSHGLL-HGQDNZZLHOXSU]\SDGNDFKPRīHRQ GRSURZDG]DýGR]DV]F]HSLDQLDZV\VWHPLHVXELHNW\ZL]PyZZ\ZRG]ĆF MH]ZLċNV]RğFLNXOWXURZ\FKMċ]\NRZ\FKF]\SâFLRZ\FKFRZGDOV]HM NRQVHNZHQFMLMHV]F]HEDUG]LHMRGVWUDV]DOXG]LNWyU]\ZVSRâHF]QRğFL QLHVĆUHSUH]HQWRZDQLZZ\VWDUF]DMĆF\VSRVyELSRJâċELDSU]HPRF V\PEROLF]QĆ'\VNXVMDQDGQD]ZĆU]HNL*DQJHVMHVWGREU\PSU]\NâD GHPWHJR]MDZLVNDDNWXDOQLHRERZLĆ]XMĆF\NRQVHQVXVLRJyOQHSRGHM ğFLHGRSUREOHPXED]XMĆFHQD]Z\F]DMDFK=DFKRGXZSHZQ\PVWRSQLX LJQRUXMHZUDīOLZRğFLLQQ\FKNXOWXUMHVWWR]DSHZQH]ZLĆ]DQHUyZQLHī ]KLVWRULĆ:LNLSHGLLUR]ZLMDMĆFHMVLċSRF]ĆWNRZREDUG]LHMG\QDPLF]QLH Z6WDQDFK=MHGQRF]RQ\FKL(XURSLHOHF]]QLHFKċFDWRW\PVDP\P HG\WRUyZ],QGLLNWyU]\WRF]ĆQLHUyZQ\EyM.ZHVWLHQLNâHJR]QDF]HQLD V\PEROLF]QHJRGODGRPLQXMĆFHMJUXS\ZLNLPHGLDQRND]XMĆVLċFDâNLHP LVWRWQHGODW\FKNWyU\FKGRW\F]\VXELHNW\ZL]PV\VWHPRZ\:V]HUV]\P XMċFLXHG\WRU]\RRJyOQLHX]QDZDQ\FKSRJOĆGDFKF]ċğFLHM]Z\FLċīDMĆ ZG\VNXVMDFK1LHMHVWQLF]\P]DVNDNXMĆF\PīHPâRG]LGREU]HZ\NV]WDâ FHQLLZ]JOċGQLH]DPRīQLPċīF]\ĩQL]NXOWXU=DFKRGXPDMĆZLċFHMF]DVX XPLHMċWQRğFLWHFKQLF]Q\FKSRğZLċFHQLDLSU]HNRQDQLDRVHQVLHXF]HVW QLFWZDZSUDFDFK:LNLSHGLL6NâDGJUXS\HG\WRUyZPD]GHF\GRZDQLH

KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL7DON>HQ7RGGB$NLQ@@ RSLVXMĆF\PNDQG\GDWDQDVHQDWRUD86$ZZ\ERUDFKZNWyU\SRZLHG]LDâ ZWUDNFLHZ\ZLDGXīHZSU]\SDGNDFKÅOHJDOQHJRJZDâWXµDQJOHJLWLPDWHR]QD F]D]DUyZQROHJDOQ\MDNLSUDZG]LZ\IDNW\F]Q\ NRELHW\F]ċVWRQLH]DFKRG]Ć ZFLĆīċ=QDF]QDF]ċğýG\VNXWXMĆF\FKEDJDWHOL]RZDâDWċNRQWURZHUVMċQLHX]QD MĆFE\E\âDRQDZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRLVWRWQDE\XPLHğFLýMĆZDNDSLFLHZSURZDG]DMĆF\P GRDUW\NXâX6WZRU]RQRWHīDUW\NXâSRGW\WXâHP>>HQ/HJLWLPDWHBUDSH@@ÅOHJDOQ\ JZDâWµVWDQRZLĆF\SU]HNLHURZDQLHGRRSLVXSRZ\īV]HJR]GDU]HQLDFKRýF]ċğý SRVWXORZDâDE\WHUPLQOHJDOQHJRJZDâWX]DUH]HUZRZDýUDF]HMGRRSLVX]MDZLVN WDNLFKMDNSUDZQHSU]\]ZROHQLHQDJZDâWPDâīHĕVNLZQLHNWyU\FKV\VWHPDFK SUDZQ\FKF]\KLVWRULċGURLWGXVHLJQHXU²SUDZDGRSLHUZV]HMQRF\²]DPLDVWGR RSLVXMHGQRUD]RZHJRZ\GDU]HQLDZSROLW\FH6WDQyZ=MHGQRF]RQ\FK

119

120

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SURFHVUR]ZLMDQLDKDVHâ-DNMHGQDNSRND]DQRZW\PUR]G]LDOHWH RJyOQH]DVDG\FKRýIDNW\F]QLHSURPXMĆXF]HVWQLFWZRLSR]RUQLHZVND ]XMĆQDSRWU]HEċX]\VNDQLDRJyOQHJRSRUR]XPLHQLDZVSRâHF]QRğFLQLH ]DZV]HG]LDâDMĆWDNMDNFKFLHOLWHJRLFKWZyUF\ &RFLHNDZHNZHVWLDQD]Z\*GDĕVND]RVWDâDUR]ZLĆ]DQDGHIDFWR ZVSU]HF]QRğFL]RJyOQ\PL]DVDGDPL:LNLSHGLL6SUDZD]RVWDâDGHÀQL W\ZQLH]DPNQLċWDJâRVRZDQLHPQLH]DğZZ\QLNXG\VNXVMLNWyUDRND]DâD VLċNRPSOHWQLHQLHVNXWHF]QDDNRQVHQVXV]E\WWUXGQ\GRRVLĆJQLċFLD :\SUDFRZ\ZDQLHNRQVHQVXVXSRGUċF]QLNRZ\PLPHWRGDPL]DZLRGâR $NFHSWRZDOQHGODVSRâHF]QRğFLUH]XOWDW\SU]\QLRVâRZ\âĆF]QLH²V]H URNRRGUDG]DQH²]OLF]DQLHJâRVyZ1DZHWZ\QLNLJâRVRZDQLDVSRUR RGELHJDâ\MHGQDNRGW\FKNWyUHPRīQDE\âRX]QDý]D]EOLīRQHGR MHGQRP\ğOQRğFLF]ċğý]SRGMċW\FKGHF\]MLSRSDUâRUDSWHPJâRVX MĆF\FKDLWDNX]QDQRMH]DRERZLĆ]XMĆFHFKRýZGURG]HNRQVHQVXVX X]QDQRE\īHQLHPDMĆRQHZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRVLOQHJRSRSDUFLD &DâNLHPPRīOLZHīHSU]HGâXīDMĆFHVLċG\VNXVMHRGHJUDâ\]QDF]ĆFĆ UROċSR]ZROLâ\QDZ\UDīHQLHZV]\VWNLFKRSLQLLL²MDNMXīZVSRPQLDQR ²QDZHWMHğOLQLHGRSURZDG]Lâ\GRRWZDUWHJRSU]\]QDQLDVLċXF]HVWQL NyZGR]UR]XPLHQLDUDFMLDGZHUVDU]\WR]âDJRG]Lâ\LFKQDVWDZLHQLH 6DPSURFHVG\VNXVMLE\âMXīGODZV]\VWNLFKGRWHJRVWRSQLDPċF]ĆF\ īHE\OLRQLVNâRQQLQDNRPSURPLVRERMċWQLHMDNL :DUWRMHGQDNQDGPLHQLýīHFKRýG\VNXVMDQDG*GDĕVNLHPE\âD VNUDMQLHGâXJDL]DMDGâDQDZHWMDNQDVWDQGDUG\:LNLSHGLLWRVSRVyE UR]ZLĆ]DQLDWHJRNRQÁLNWXE\âRZLHOHEDUG]LHMW\SRZ\QLīPRīQDE\ SU]\SXV]F]Dý3RQDGZV]HONĆZĆWSOLZRğýQDZHWMHğOL]DVDG\:LNL SHGLLSURPXMĆRGNU\ZDQLHIDNWyZLXVWDODQLHLFKSU]H]]GHU]DQLH XĩUyGâRZLRQ\FKSRJOĆGyZMDNWHīX]QDZDQLHLRG]ZLHUFLHGODQLHLVWRW Q\FKVSRUyZQDGIDNWDPLWRZV]HONLHNZHVWLH]DZDUWHZĩUyGâDFK VWDQĆVLċQLHFK\EQLHSU]HGPLRWHPG\VNXVML3RZ\ZRâDQLXG\VNXVML ]DğHVNDODFMDSRğZLċFHQLDVWURQVSRUXZVSRVyEQDWXUDOQ\SRGQRVL SUyJZHMğFLDGODXF]HVWQLNyZVSR]DQLHJR2VRE\XF]HVWQLF]ĆFHZZ\ PLDQLH]GDĕ]NROHLUyīQLĆVLċVZRMĆGHWHUPLQDFMĆ=W\FKZ]JOċGyZ G\VNXVMHZ:LNLSHGLLNRĕF]ĆVLċQDMF]ċğFLHMQLHZWHG\JG\MHGQD]H VWURQMHVWZVWDQLHSU]HNRQDýGUXJĆL]GRE\ZDXSUDJQLRQHJRğZLċWHJR *UDDODNRQVHQVXVXī\MĆFGâXJRLV]F]ċğOLZLHOHF]ZWHG\JG\MHGQD]H VWURQMHVWG\VNXVMĆGREyOX]QXG]RQDLX]QDMHGâXīV]HXF]HVWQLFWZR ZVSRU]H]DMHV]F]HEDUG]LHMPċF]ĆFHOXEIUXVWUXMĆFH-HğOLLVWQLHMH MHGQDFHFKDNWyUDZG\VNXVMDFKZ:LNLSHGLLMHVWLVWRWQDWRMHVWQLĆ WRīHEDUG]LHMQLīUDFMDOLF]\VLċXSDUWRğý

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? 3UDZGĆMHVWīH]DVDG\:LNLSHGLLSRG]LZLDQH]DLFKSRGRELHĕVWZR GRUHJXâNZDNUyZF]\6HDUFK&RQIHUHQFHZ]DNUHVLHSU]\ZLĆ]\ZDQLD ]QDF]HQLDGRNRQVHQVXVXG]LDâDMĆVNXWHF]QLHMHğOLNRQÁLNWGDVLċ UR]ZLĆ]DýV]\ENRZVND]XMĆFQDRGSRZLHGQLHĩUyGâDLQIRUPDFML-HğOL MHGQDNVSUDZ\VLċNRPSOLNXMĆWRZFLĆJXNLONXW\JRGQLRGZ\VWĆSLHQLD NRQÁLNWXLPSDVVWDMHVLċZLGRF]Q\ 3RQLīV]DWDEHOD]HVWDZLDNODV\ÀNDFMċQDMF]ċğFLHMZ\VWċSXMĆF\FK W\SyZNRQÁLNWyZQLHGRW\F]ĆF\FKIDNWyZZ:LNLSHGLL Typologia trajektorii konfliktów

Nierówne stopnie zaangażowania

Równe stopnie zaangażowania

.RQIURQWDFMD

(/,0,1$&-$ 8F]HVWQLF\EORNRZDQL

3$7 8F]HVWQLF\RNRSXMĆVLċ

%UDNNRQIURQWDFML

'20,1$&-$ 8F]HVWQLF\SRGGDMĆVLċ

:63Ðá35$&$ 8F]HVWQLF\ZVSyâSUDFXMĆ

1DRVLSLRQRZHMUR]JUDQLF]RQRNRQÁLNW\]XZDJLQDQDVWDZLHQLH XF]HVWQLNyZ.RQÁLNW\ZNWyU\FKRE\GZLHVWURQ\X]QDMĆīHLFKSXQNW ZLG]HQLDPRīHQLHSU]HZDī\ýRSLVDQRMDNRÅEUDNNRQIURQWDFMLµ]Dğ V\WXDFMHZNWyU\FKFRQDMPQLHMMHGQD]HVWURQMHVWSU]HNRQDQDRVZHM VâXV]QRğFL²MDNRÅNRQIURQWDFMDµJG\īWHJRW\SX]DFKRZDQLD]Z\NOH DQWDJRQL]XMĆUyZQLHīSRGHMğFLHDGZHUVDU]D 3R]LRPRUR]JUDQLF]RQRNRQÁLNW\QDWHZNWyU\FKVWRSLHĕ]DDQJD īRZDQLDVWURQZVSyUMHVWUyZQ\OXERGPLHQQ\

Eliminacja -HğOLVWURQ\NRQÁLNWXGĆīĆGRNRQIURQWDFMLLVĆQLHFKċWQHSRUR]XPLH QLX]ZLQ\F]\WRMHGQHJRXSDUWHJRHG\WRUDF]\ZLċNV]HMJUXS\ OHF] VWRSLHĕLFK]DDQJDīRZDQLDZGHEDWċLFKċýSR]RVWDQLDZQLHMMDNQDM GâXīHMQLHVĆUyZQH]Z\NOHFRQDMPQLHMMHGQD]HVWURQQDUXV]D]DVDGċ ÅEH]DWDNyZRVRELVW\FKµF]\RJyOQLH]DF]\QD]DFKRZ\ZDýVLċQLH XSU]HMPLHL]RVWDMHZ\NOXF]RQD]G\VNXVML2VREDQDUXV]DMĆFD]DVDG\ QLHNRQLHF]QLHPXVLE\ýHG\WRUHPQDMEDUG]LHMNRQIURQWDF\MQ\P]QD WXU\²]Z\NOHPDSRSURVWXOXĩQLHMV]HSRGHMğFLHGR]DVDG6WRVRZDQLH

121

122

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]DVDGFKâRGQHJRQDVWDZLHQLDLSRGDZDQLDU]HWHOQ\FKĩUyGHâSRFKâDQLD ZLċFHMF]DVXLXZDJLQLīDUW\NXâRZDQLHREHOJL]âRğOLZ\FKXZDJZLċF Z\VRNLVWRSLHĕ]DDQJDīRZDQLDZG\VNXVMċâĆF]\VLċUDF]HM]SRVWċSRZD QLHP]JRGQLH]]DVDGDPLQLH]Dğ]HPRFMRQDOQ\P]DDQJDīRZDQLHP ZG\VNXWRZDQĆNZHVWLċ&]ċğýGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZSR WUDÀZWDNLFKSU]\SDGNDFKSURZRNRZDýLSRGMXG]DýGUXJĆVWURQċE\ WD]âDPDâD]DVDG\ -HğOLRE\GZLHVWURQ\]QLīĆVLċGRQLHRGSRZLHGQLHJR]DFKRZDQLDRELH PRJĆ]RVWDý]DEORNRZDQHJG\īRGSRZLHG]HQLDÅRJQLHPQDRJLHĕµ ZSRW\F]FHVâRZQHMQLHGDVLċXVSUDZLHGOLZLýZUDPDFK]DVDG:LNLSHGLL 7HJRW\SXNRQÁLNW\SUDZLHQLJG\QLHVĆNRQVWUXNW\ZQHJG\īU]DGNR GRSURZDG]DMĆGRGDOV]HJRUR]ZRMXKDVHâRSUyF]V\WXDFMLZNWyU\FK VWURQDV]DQXMĆFD]DVDG\VWDUDVLċSU]HNRQDýGUXJĆGRVZRLFKUDFML SU]H]SRSUDZLDQLHDUW\NXâX 0RīHRQQDVWĆSLýGRSLHURZWHG\JG\ GHVWUXNW\ZQLHG\WRU]\]RVWDQĆXVXQLċFL]G\VNXVML

Dominacja -HğOLXF]HVWQLF\NRQÁLNWXQLHGĆīĆGRNRQIURQWDFMLUyīQLĆFVLċMHGQR F]HğQLHSR]LRPHPGHWHUPLQDFMLE\SR]RVWDýZJU]HQDXVWDORQ\FK SU]H]SURMHNW]DVDGDFKWR]Z\NOHPQLHM]DDQJDīRZDQDVWURQDXJLQD VLċDNW\ZQLHMV]HPXHG\WRURZLLRGFKRG]L]G\VNXVML2GSRZLHG]L XG]LHODQHPQLHM]DDQJDīRZDQHMVWURQLHEċGĆQDGFKRG]LýV]\ENR L]Z\NOHEċGĆ]DZLHUDýVSRURWUHğFLZLċFVDPRSRGĆīDQLH]DWRNLHP UR]XPRZDQLDDGZHUVDU]DEċG]LHZ\PDJDýF]DVX$UJXPHQW\EċGĆ SRSDUWHĩUyGâDPL]NWyU\FKF]ċğýEċG]LHWUXGQDGRRGQDOH]LHQLDOXE NWyU\FK]ORNDOL]RZDQLHEċG]LHZ\PDJDýRGSRZLHGQLRZ\VRNLFKXPLH MċWQRğFL1DZHWPLPRWHJRīHRÀFMDOQLHEUDNMHVWNRQIURQWDFMLDWHR UHW\F]QLHRELHVWURQ\V]DQXMĆSXQNWZLG]HQLDLQWHUORNXWRUDF]HNDMĆF MHG\QLHQDRGSRZLHGQLHDUJXPHQW\ZG\VNXVMLWRZâDğQLHPQLHM]D DQJDīRZDQDVWURQDSRGGDMHVLċQLHEċGĆFZVWDQLHVSURVWDýQDU]XFR QHPXWHPSX3RGREQLHMDNZSU]\SDGNXERNVXF]\PDUDWRQXZ\WU]\ PDâRğýMHVWZG\VNXVMDFKQDGâXJLPG\VWDQVLH]GHF\GRZDQLHSRīĆGDQĆ FHFKĆ-DN]DXZDī\â2OLYHU.DPP :LNLSHGLDQLHGĆī\GRSUDZG\LNRQVHQVXVXWDNMDNZ]GHU]HQLDFK SROLW\NyZZ\PLDQċ]GDĕ]GRPLQXMĆQDMJâRğQLHMV]HLQDMEDUG]LHMXSDUWH JâRV\7RZURG]RQDZDGDV\VWHPX3UREOHPHPQLHMHVWWX]E\WQLH

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? ZLHONDOLF]EDJâRVyZFRPRīHGRSURZDG]LýGR]GRPLQRZDQLDG\VNXVML ²SUREOHPOHī\GRNâDGQLHSRSU]HFLZQHMVWURQLH8F]HVWQLFWZRZG\V NXVMLMHVWZDUWRğFLRZDQHZ\īHMQLīNRPSHWHQFMD

7RUyZQLHīVFHQDULXV]NWyU\MHVWGDOHNLRGLGHDâXJG\īRVRE\RQL VNLP]DDQJDīRZDQLXWRF]ċVWRHG\WRU]\SRF]ĆWNXMĆF\NWyU]\QLHXVWD ZLOLMHV]F]HZ\VRNRVWDZNLVZRMHJRXF]HVWQLFWZDZUR]ZLMDQLX:LNLSHGLL 2GFKRG]ĆF]NRQÁLNWX]SRF]XFLHPE\FLDQLHVSUDZLHGOLZLHSRWUDNWR ZDQ\PLOXEQLHSUDZLGâRZR]UR]XPLDQ\PLRVRE\WDNLHF]ċVWRQDGREUH RSXV]F]DMĆUyZQLHī:LNLSHGLċ0RīHWRPLHýQHJDW\ZQ\ZSâ\ZQD MDNRğýDUW\NXâyZJG\īSRWHQFMDOQLHVSHâQLRQDMHVWWXMHGQD]KLSRWH] 6DQJHUD 1DGâXīV]ĆPHWċMDNRğýGRZROQHJRDUW\NXâX:LNLSHGLLZVSRVyEORVRZ\ ]DF]QLHRVF\ORZDýZRNyâQDMZ\īV]HMJUDQLF\MDNRğFLNWyUĆ]GHÀQLXMĆ QDMEDUG]LHMXSDUFLLDJUHV\ZQLHG\WRU]\]DDQJDīRZDQLZSUDFHQDGQLP

6WUDWHJLDZ\FLHĕF]DQLDGUXJLHMVWURQ\SU]H]Z\VRNĆDNW\ZQRğýZâDV QĆRUD]GRVWDUF]DQLHREV]HUQ\FKXSU]HMP\FKLSRSDUW\FKĩUyGâDPL RGSRZLHG]LMHVWSRSXODUQDZğUyGGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZ6DP ZLHORNURWQLHVLċGRQLHMXFLHNDâHP']LHMHVLċWDNJG\ī]DVDG\GRFKR G]HQLDGRNRQVHQVXVXZ:LNLSHGLLZUċF]]DFKċFDMĆGRDUJXPHQWDFML RLOHMHVWRQDPHU\WRU\F]QDMDNWHī]XZDJLQDWRīHGRğZLDGF]HQL HG\WRU]\:LNLSHGLLGURJĆÅVHOHNFMLQDWXUDOQHMµOXELĆWHJRW\SXG\V NXVMHDSU]\QDMPQLHMRGQLFKQLHVWURQLĆ 6NXWNLHPSRZ\īV]HJR ZV]\VWNLH]QDF]QLHMV]HGHEDW\Z:LNLSHGLLVĆEDUG]RGâXJLH

Współpraca -HğOLVWURQ\G\VNXVMLQLHGĆīĆGRNRQIURQWDFMLDGRWHJRF]XMĆWHQVDP SR]LRP]DDQJDīRZDQLDZGHEDWċPRīOLZDMHVWSUDZG]LZDZVSyâSUDFD ZUR]XPLHQLXZL]ML:LNLSHGLL6FHQDULXV]WDNLQLHMHVWFDâNRZLFLH QLHSUDZGRSRGREQ\'RğýF]ċVWRMHğOLRE\GZLHVWURQ\NRQÁLNWXWU]\ PDMĆVLċQDU]XFRQ\FKRGJyUQLH]DVDGXSU]HMPHJR]DFKRZDQLDLEH] XG]LDâXHPRFMLZ\V]XNXMĆĩUyGâDQDSRSDUFLHVZRLFKUDFMLRUD]RGSR ZLHGQLFKVSRVREyZZ\UDīHQLDWUHğFLKDVâDZ\SUDFRZXMĆZVSyOQĆ ZHUVMċ3RRVLĆJQLċFLXNRQVHQVXVXMHVWRQ]Z\NOH]DGRZDODMĆF\GODZV]\VW NLFKXF]HVWQLNyZVSRUXDGRWHJRPRīOLZRğýXG]LDâXZXNV]WDâWRZDQLX

123

124

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... Z\QLNRZHMZHUVMLPDVDW\VIDNFMRQXMĆFHLXSUDZQLDMĆFH]QDF]HQLHGOD XF]HVWQLNyZ=GHF\GRZDQLHMHGQDNNRRSHUDFMDQLHMHVWGRPLQXMĆFĆ WUDMHNWRULĆNRQÁLNWyZZ:LNLSHGLL

Pat -HğOLZVSRU]HSRMDZLDVLċHOHPHQWNRQIURQWDFMLDRELHVWURQ\VĆZUyZ Q\PVWRSQLX]GHWHUPLQRZDQHSR]RVWDýZJU]HSRZWDU]DVLċVFHQD ULXV]Å%XQWRZQLNDEH]SRZRGXµJG]LHGZDMJâyZQLERKDWHURZLHVWDMĆ GRÅ:\ğFLJX&\NRUyZµNUDG]LRQ\PLVDPRFKRGDPLSċG]ĆFNXSU]HSDğFL 2GZURWQLHMHGQDNQLīZSU]\SDGNXMDNLHMNROZLHN]DEDZ\ÅZF\NRUDµ V]DORQ\UDMGQLJG\VLċZ:LNLSHGLLQLHNRĕF]\DF]DVDPLRELHVWURQ\ RNRSXMĆVLċQDGâXJĆSRW\F]NċMDNPLDâRWRPLHMVFHZSU]\SDGNXZRMQ\ R*GDĕVNOXE'DQ]LJ7DNLVFHQDULXV]MHVWGRğýF]ċVWRVSRW\NDQ\ Z:LNLSHGLLLRF]\ZLğFLHGRSURZDG]DGRZLHONLHJRPDUQRWUDZVWZD F]DVXLZ\VLâNXHG\WRUyZWRF]ĆF\FKERMHRQLHZLHONLHNZHVWLH7HJR W\SXNRQÁLNWyZ]Z\NOHQLHXGDMHVLċUR]ZLĆ]DýSU]H]NRQVHQVXVOHF] JâRVRZDQLHVSHâQLVZRMĆIXQNFMċW\ONRZWHG\JG\RSDGQLHSRF]ĆWNRZ\ HQWX]MD]P

WSPÓŁPRACA, KONFLIKT, A MOŻE I TO, I TO? 3UDZLHZV]\VWNLHG\VNXVMHVĆZ:LNLSHGLLSXEOLF]QLHGRVWċSQHZLċF LFKDUFKLZDVâXīĆ]DLVWRWQĆF]ċğýV\VWHPXNRQWUROLMDNRğFL6WYLOLD LLQ ]DğGHEDWRZDQLHPRīQDX]QDý]DXWU]\P\ZDQLHRZHM NRQWUROL&KRýMHGQDN:LNLSHGLD]DFKċFDGRFKâRGQHJRSRGHMğFLDGR HG\WRZDQLDZLċNV]RğýWUDNWXMHUHGDJRZDQLH:LNLSHGLLZPRFQRRVR ELVW\FKNDWHJRULDFK:RMQ\HG\F\MQHZV\WXDFMDFKQLHUyZQHJR]DDQJD īRZDQLDVWURQF]ċVWRVNXWNXMĆUH]\JQDFMĆMHGQHM]HVWURQ²F]DVDPL ZUċF]MHVWWRUH]\JQDFMD]GDOV]HJRUR]ZLMDQLD:LNLSHGLL²]DğNRQÁLNW\ RUyZQ\PVWRSQLX]DDQJDīRZDQLDVNXWNXMĆGâXJLPLLF]ċVWREH]RZRF Q\PLG\VNXVMDPL '\VNXWRZDQLHMHVWMHGQDNOHSV]HRGG]LDâDQLDEH]Z\MDğQLHQLD VZRLFKPRW\ZyZ-DNSRND]XMĆEDGDQLDZ\FRI\ZDQLHHG\FMLV]F]H JyOQLHEH]SRGDZDQLDSRZRGyZWDNLHJRG]LDâDQLDPDZ\MĆWNRZR QLV]F]ĆF\ZSâ\ZQDQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZNWyU\FK]PLDQ\Z\FRI\ZDQH VĆSU]H]EDUG]LHMGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKNROHJyZ+DOIDNHULLQ -HVW

DLACZEGO MUSIMY UMIERAĆ ZA GDAŃSK? MDVQHīHQRZLFMXV]HNWyU]\QLH]DLQZHVWRZDOLGXī\FKLORğFLF]DVX Z:LNLSHGLċZLċFLFKPRW\ZDFMDGRSR]RVWDQLDQLHMHVWZ\VRNDâDWZR VLċ]UDīDMĆ']LHMHVLċWDNV]F]HJyOQLHZWHG\JG\GRğZLDGF]HQLHG\WR U]\Z\FRIXMĆGRNRQ\ZDQHSU]H]QRZLFMXV]\]PLDQ\LQLH]DFKċFDMĆ GRGDOV]\FKSUyEMDNWHīQLHLQIRUPXMĆRW\PGODF]HJRGDQDHG\FMD QLHQDGDZDâDVLċGR:LNLSHGLL-HğOLMXīWRURELĆWRSRVâXJXMĆVLċWDN WDMHPQĆQRZRPRZĆīHQRZRSU]\E\OLF]ċVWRF]XMĆVLċ]QLHFKċFDQLGR G]LDâDQLDLQLHSRZUDFDMĆGR:LNLSHGLL1LHMHVWWRU]DGNRğFLĆZVSR PQLDQ\MXī(GLWRU6XUYH\5HSRUW:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ SR ND]XMHīHEDGDQ\FKSDPLċWDZ\FRI\ZDQLHLFKHG\FMLEH]īDGQHJR X]DVDGQLHQLDFKRýPyZLWHīRW\PīHLFKHG\FMHE\â\Z\FRI\ZDQH ]MDNLPğNRPHQWDU]HP :âDğQLHGODWHJRZ:LNLSHGLLLVWQLHMHWZDUGD]DVDGD]DFKRZDQLD ]DND]XMĆFDÅJU\]LHQLDQRZLFMXV]\µ>>HQ:LNLSHGLD3OHDVHGRQRWELWH WKHQHZFRPHUV@@>>:LNLSHGLD3URVLP\QLHJU\ĩýQRZLFMXV]\@@ ]Dğ XSU]HMPRğýMHVWRJyOQLHX]QDZDQD]DGREUĆFHFKċFKDUDNWHUX-HVWWR SUDZGĆGRWDNLHJRVWRSQLDīHQSQDMEDUG]LHMSURGXNW\ZQ\HG\WRU SROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLE\â\DGPLQLVWUDWRUHG\WXMĆF\ZUyīQ\FKSURMHNWDFK RGURNX]V]HğFLRF\IURZĆOLF]EĆHG\FMLSRPLPRWHJRRJURPQHJR GRURENX]RVWDâZURNXXVXQLċW\]SURMHNWX]DVSRVyEZMDNLWUDN WRZDâXī\WNRZQLNyZNWyU]\ZMDNLğVSRVyEQLHSRGRâDOLVWDQGDUGRP 2SLVDQHZ]RU\NRQÁLNWyZSRND]XMĆīHG\VNXVMHZ:LNLSHGLLPDMĆ ZSHâQLZVSyâSUDFXMĆF\FKDUDNWHUW\ONRZWHG\JG\VSHâQLRQHVĆV]F]H JyOQHZDUXQNL0RīHWRE\ýHIHNWXERF]Q\U]HF]\ZLğFLHXF]HVWQLF]Ć FHJRPRGHOXSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLZSURMHNFLH2LOHRE\GZLHVWURQ\ SRUR]XPLHZDMĆVLċXSU]HMPLHLRLOHNRQÁLNWQLHGRW\F]\IDNWyZMHğOL QSLVWQLHMĆUR]ELHīQHFRGRLQIRUPDFMLU]HWHOQHĩUyGâDDUR]ELHīQRğý QLHGDVLċZ\MDğQLýMHV]F]HLQQ\PLĩUyGâDPL Z\VWDUF]\E\VWURQ\ VSLHUDâ\VLċGDOHMWDNGâXJRMDNPDMĆQDWRRFKRWċ:VSRVyEQLHXQLN QLRQ\ÅNRQÁLNW\LZRMQ\HG\F\MQHFKRýVĆRQHRJUDQLF]RQHVZRLP ]DVLċJLHPGRQLHZLHONLHMOLF]E\DUW\NXâyZNWyUHPRīQDVNXWHF]QLH UR]SR]QDýSRFKâDQLDMĆ]QDF]QHLORğFL]DVREyZµ>HQ:LNLSHGLD,3VDUHKXPDQWRR@@

,QQ\HVHMZ\MDğQLDZSRGREQ\PWRQLHīHQLHNDīG\ÅLSHNµWRZDQGDO >>HQ:31RWHYHU\,3LVDYDQGDO@@ :LNLSHG\ğFLVĆF]ċVWRSRGHMU]OLZL ZVWRVXQNXGRQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZSU]\F]\PRZDSRGHMU]OLZRğýZPLDUċ XSâ\ZXODWVLċZ]PDFQLD-DN]DXZDī\âDQDOLW\N:LNLPHGLD)RXQGD WLRQ$DURQ+DOIDNHU -DNRğýZNâDGXQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZMHVWRGURNXSUDZLHQLH]PLHQQD &RZLċFHM]DUyZQRZSRF]ĆWNDFKLVWQLHQLD:LNLSHGLLMDNLWHUD]ZLċN V]RğýQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZQLH]DPLHU]DMHGQR]QDF]QLH]DV]NRG]Lý:LNL SHGLLRNRâRSURFHQW DZLHOX]QLFKMXīZSLHUZV]\FKHG\FMDFKSR]R VWDZLDZKDVâDFKZDUWRğFLRZHLQIRUPDFMHRNRâRSURFHQW 2GU]XFDQLH SLHUZV]\FKHG\FMLQRZ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZRGREU\FKLQWHQFMDFKMHVW

135

136

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... MHGQDN]MDZLVNLHPFRUD]VLOQLHMV]\PZVNXWHNF]HJRVSDGDZVNDĩQLN ]DWU]\PDQLDZSURMHNFLHUHGDNWRUyZ2]QDF]DWRīHZSUDZG]LHZSUR MHNFLHSRMDZLDVLċW\OHVDPRQRZ\FKOXG]LFRZURNXDOHZFKRG]Ć RQLZğURGRZLVNRFRUD]EDUG]LHMZ\PDJDMĆFHNU\W\F]QHLOXEZURJLH ZVWRVXQNXGRQLFK

3RZ\īV]H]MDZLVNRGDVLċZ\MDğQLýQDNLONDVSRVREyZ]F]HJRMHGHQ WRSRVWċSXMĆFDDOLHQDFMDVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLLRGUHV]W\ğZLDWD LXWUZDODQLHSRG]LDâXÅP\NRQWUDRQLµ%DâDJDQSDQXMĆF\ZSURFHVLH Z\ELHUDQLDIXQNFMRQDULXV]\ZMDZQ\VSRVyESRND]XMĆF\VWRVRZDQLH UR]ZLĆ]DĕVLâRZ\FKLQLHWU]\PDQLHVLċRÀFMDOQLHJâRV]RQHMUyZQRğFL HG\WRUyZ RUD]UR]GĩZLċNPLċG]\RÀFMDOQĆUHWRU\NĆHJDOLWDU\]PX DZLGRF]QĆKLHUDUFKLĆRSLVDQ\ZMHGQ\P]SRSU]HGQLFKUR]G]LDâyZ SRZRGXMHīHXī\WNRZQLF\FRUD]F]ċğFLHMVWRVXMĆUR]ZLĆ]DQLDVLâRZH 6NRUR]Z\NOLHG\WRU]\SRVWU]HJDMĆ]RVWDQLHDGPLQLVWUDWRUHPMDNR FRUD]ZLċNV]ĆVSUDZċXZDīDMĆFIXQNFMċ]DFRUD]WUXGQLHMV]ĆGRRVLĆJ QLċFLDPRJĆRGJU\ZDýVLċQDW\FKNWyU\FKSRVWU]HJDMĆMDNRÅQLīV]Ć UDQJċµHG\WRUyZF]\OLXī\WNRZQLNDFKğZLHīR]DUHMHVWURZDQ\FKRUD] DQRQLPRZ\FK 6SRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLLG]LDâDRSLHUDMĆFVLċQDQLHIRUPDOQHMLGHOL NDWQHMSDUDKLHUDUFKLLEXGRZDQHMQDSRVWU]HJDQLXGRğZLDGF]HQLD MHGQRVWNLZVSRâHF]QRğFL&]ċğýEDUG]LHMGRğZLDGF]RQ\FKXī\WNRZQL NyZSRVWU]HJDQRZLFMXV]\MDNRRVRE\VâDEV]HLSU]HV]NDG]DMĆFH1LHMHVW WR]MDZLVNRRGL]RORZDQHMDNSRGDMH(GLWRU6XUYH\5HSRUW:LNLPHGLD )RXQGDWLRQ QDZHWDQNLHWRZDQ\FKWZLHUG]LâRīHGRğZLDG F]\OLWUDNWRZDQLD]JyU\]HVWURQ\VWDUV]\FKVWDīHPZLNLSHG\VWyZ &RMHGQDNFLHNDZHNRQWURODNRQFHUW\ZQD%DUNHU VSUDZR ZDQDSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğýQLH]DWU]\PXMHVLċQDHWDSLHVSUDZG]DQLD G]LDâDĕXī\WNRZQLNyZQLH]DUHMHVWURZDQ\FKLğZLHīR]DUHMHVWURZD Q\FK:SHZQ\PVWRSQLXPRQLWRURZDQHVĆG]LDâDQLDZV]\VWNLFK ZLNLSHG\VWyZFRRF]\ZLğFLHPD]QDF]QHNRQVHNZHQFMHGODī\FLDRUJD QL]DF\MQHJR -HVWWRV]F]HJyOQLHZLGRF]QHZJâRVRZDQLDFKQDGSU]\]QDQLHPXSUDZ QLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDF]\OLÅ38$µRSLVDQ\PLZMHGQ\P]SRSU]HGQLFK UR]G]LDâyZ NWyUHF]ċVWRRG]ZLHUFLHGODMĆRUD]Z\RVWU]DMĆNâRSRW\ LWHQGHQFMHREHFQHZVSRâHF]QRğFL*âRVRZDQLD38$VĆF]ċVWRRSRZLHğ FLDPLRğFLVâHMNRQWUROLVSRâHF]QRğFL-DNQDSLVDâ'D\HZDONHUQDVZR MHMVWURQLHG\VNXVMLNRPHQWXMĆFSU]HJUDQHGODĕJâRVRZDQLH]OLVWR SDGD

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY -DNRF]HNLZDâHPNDīG\Xī\WNRZQLN]NWyU\PPLDâHPMDNLHNROZLHN QHJDW\ZQHGRğZLDGF]HQLHHG\WRUVNLHSU]\V]HGâU]XFLýNDPLHQLHP 3U]HMU]DQRPRMHHG\FMH²RGQXPHUXGRV]XNDMĆFMDNLFKNROZLHN SRWNQLċý/XG]LHNWyU\FKRNUHğOLâE\PPLDQHPÅWUXGQ\FKµSU]HV]XNL ZDOL]ZLHONĆGRNâDGQRğFLĆZV]HONLHQLHSRUR]XPLHQLDLEXGRZDOLPyM QHJDW\ZQ\ZL]HUXQHN3UDZLHF]WHUQDğFLHW\VLċF\HG\FMLZWU]\ODWD EUDNEORNDGQDNRQFLHEUDNFKRýE\RVWU]HMV]HMXZDJL:W\PF]DVLHVWD UDâHPVLċXVSRNDMDýV\WXDFMċZWHMW\NDMĆFHMERPELH]HJDURZHM1DJURGD ]DZ\F]\Q":\FLHF]NDSU]HGSOXWRQHJ]HNXF\MQ\ZNWyUHJRVNâDG ZHV]OLXī\WNRZQLF\âDPLĆF\]DVDG\E\OL]DVDGQLHEORNRZDQLDNWyU]\ VNRU]\VWDOLWHUD]]RND]MLE\VLċRGHJUDýEH]VWUDFKXRVZRMĆVNyUċ

'DOHMZMHV]F]HEDUG]LHM]âRZLHV]F]\PWRQLH :\FLĆJQĆýPRīQDFRNROZLHNVLċFKFH]WZRMHMSU]HV]âRğFL.DīG\V]F]HJyâ ]WZRMHJRī\FLDGRNWyUHJRVLċSU]\]QDâHğF]\NWyU\PRīQDZ\ZQLR VNRZDý]HVW\OXHG\WRZDQLDPRīHE\ýLEċG]LHXī\W\SU]HFLZNRWRELH 7RīHSRğZLċFLâHğF]DVQDZROXQWDUQĆSUDFċQLHMHVWWDNZDīQHMDN WRMDNSRZLQLHQHğE\âSRVWĆSLýZMDNLHMğV\WXDFMLZRSLQLLSR]RVWDâ\FK HG\WRUyZ&KURĕFLHLQIRUPDFMH]HVZRMHJRī\FLD

=GHF\GRZDQLHQLHMHVWWRU]DGNLHGRğZLDGF]HQLH:LċNV]RğýNDQ G\GXMĆF\FKGRIXQNFMLDGPLQLVWUDWRUDPRīHRF]HNLZDýīHFRNROZLHN ]DPLHğFLOLZ:LNLSHGLLZâĆF]QLH]RVWU\PLG\VNXVMDPL]ZDQGDODPL PRīH]RVWDýRGQDOH]LRQHLZ\HNVSRQRZDQH&RZDīQHSRGXZDJċZ]LċWH ]RVWDMĆQLHW\ONRHG\FMHDNWXDOQHOHF]UyZQLHīWDNLHZ\SRZLHG]LNWyUH NDQG\GXMĆFDRVREDXVXQċâDOXEVNUHğOLâD:LHOXXF]HVWQLNyZJâRVRZD QLDZUċF]DNW\ZQLHSRV]XNXMHZ\SRZLHG]LXVXQLċW\FKMDNWHīWDNLFK NWyU\FKNDQG\GXMĆFDRVREDPRJâDE\VLċZVW\G]Lý1DZHWSRMHG\QF]H RGV]F]HNQLċFLHVLċNRPXğXVXQLċWHZNLONDVHNXQGSR]DSLVDQLXPRīH ZQLHNWyU\FKZDUXQNDFK]G\VNZDOLÀNRZDýSRWHQFMDOQHJRDGPLQLVWUD WRUD7HFKQRORJLDZLNLSR]ZDODQDğOHG]HQLHZV]\VWNLFKZ\NRQDQ\FK ZSURMHNFLHHG\FMLZLċFNDīGHQDFLğQLċFLHSU]\FLVNXÅ=DSLV]µSR]RVWDZLD WUZDâ\ğODGG]LDâDOQRğFLXF]HVWQLNDĞODGWHQZSU]HZDīDMĆFHMZLċN V]RğFLSU]\SDGNyZQLHSRGOHJDXNU\FLXSU]HGRJyâHPVSRâHF]QRğFL 3RGREQLHXZDīQLHDQDOL]RZDQHVĆ]PLDQ\GRNRQDQHSU]H]NDQG\GDWD F]\NDQG\GDWNċQDMHJRMHMVWURQLHQDNUyWNRSU]HGSRGMċFLHPGHF\]ML RNDQG\GRZDQLX-HğOLRVRE\VSUDZG]DMĆFHKLVWRULċHG\FMLWHMVWURQ\ RGQDMGĆXVXQLċFLHGHNODUDFMLQDZHWSURVW\FKRğZLDGF]HĕUHOLJLMQ\FK

137

138

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SROLW\F]Q\FKF]\RSRZLDGDQLDVLċZGHEDWDFKQDWHPDWSUDZVSRâHF] Q\FKLHNRQRPLF]Q\FK F]ċVWRNDQG\GXMĆFĆRVREċX]QDMHVLċ]DU\]\ NRZQĆZNZHVWLLQHXWUDOQRğFLSRJOĆGyZOXEQHXWUDOQRğFLZNRQWDN WDFK]LQQ\PLHG\WRUDPL2SRZLHG]HQLHVLċSRNWyUHMNROZLHN]HVWURQ ZLċNV]\FKG\VNXVMLVSRâHF]Q\FKQDZHWXVXQLċWHSU]HGSRGMċFLHP F]\QQHJRXG]LDâXZJâRVRZDQLXPRīHE\ýXMDZQLRQHL]DSHZQHEċG]LH Z\SRPQLDQH -HVW]UR]XPLDâHīHNDQG\GXMĆF\GRIXQNFMLDGPLQLVWUDF\MQ\FKSRG OHJDMĆğFLğOHMV]HMNRQWUROLQLīLQQLXī\WNRZQLF\-HGQDNQD:LNLSHGLL QDG]yUGRW\F]\UyZQLHīLQQ\FKDNW\ZQ\FKHG\WRUyZQLHPDMĆF\FK DPELFMLXELHJDQLDVLċRGRGDWNRZHIXQNFMHZVSRâHF]QRğFL3RSLHUZV]H ZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZSRELHīQLHSU]HJOĆGDVWURQ\G\VNXVMLW\FKHG\WRUyZ ]NWyU\PLZ\PLHQLDXZDJL3RGUXJLHMDNMXīZVSRPQLDQRLVWQLHMH RGUċEQDNDWHJRULDZLNLSHG\VWyZUXW\QRZRSDWUROXMĆF\FKRVWDWQLH ]PLDQ\LSU]HJOĆGDMĆF\FKQDMğZLHīV]HHG\FMHZ:LNLSHGLL1DZHWMHğOL NRQFHQWUXMĆVLċRQLQD]PLDQDFKGRNRQ\ZDQ\FKZKDVâDFKF]ċğý ]QLFKORVRZRVSUDZG]DWDNīHHG\FMHVWURQG\VNXVML3RWU]HFLHZSU]\ SDGNXNRQÁLNWyZLUR]ELHīQRğFLRSLQLLDV]F]HJyOQLHMHğOLMDNLğXī\WNRZ QLNG]LDâDQDVNUDMXGHVWUXNW\ZQHJR]DFKRZDQLDQLHMHVWQLHVSRW\ NDQHMHğOLGXīDOLF]EDGRNRQDQ\FKSU]H]HĕHG\FMLXOHJDVSUDZG]HQLX ZâĆF]\ZV]\ZWRHG\FMHZG\VNXVMDFKLLQWHUDNFMH]LQQ\PLXī\WNRZ QLNDPL&RZLċFHMZSURFHVLHIRUPDOQHJRUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZ VWDQRZLĆF\P]DNUHVG]LDâDĕ.RPLWHWX$UELWUDīRZHJR G]LDâDQLDHG\WRUD VWDQRZLĆFHJRVWURQċVSRUXVĆGRNâDGQLHDQDOL]RZDQH:HZV]\VWNLFK SRZ\īV]\FKSU]\SDGNDFK]XZDJLQDWRīHWHFKQRORJLD]DVWRVRZDQD Z:LNLSHGLLSR]ZDODQDSRGHMU]HQLHNDīGHM]PLDQ\QDZHWMHğOL]RVWDâD RQDSyĩQLHMXVXQLċWDOXE]PRG\ÀNRZDQDSU]H]WHJRVDPHJRXī\WNRZ QLNDNDīGDHG\FMD]DSLV\ZDQDMHVWZ:LNLSHGLLQD]DZV]H7RNWRMHVW ZVWDQLHSU]HMU]HýVWDUV]HHG\FMHGRNRQDQHQDGDQHMVWURQLHMHVWMHG\ QLHNZHVWLĆXSUDZQLHĕZZLċNV]RğFLSU]\SDGNyZKLVWRULDHG\FMLMHVW GRVWċSQDGODZV]\VWNLFKZâĆF]QLH]DQRQLPRZ\PLLQWHUQDXWDPL :QLHNWyU\FKSU]\SDGNDFKMHğOLNWyUDNROZLHN]HVWURQ]RVWDâDXVXQLċWD GRVWċSGRKLVWRULLMHMHG\FMLPDMĆDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\]DğZU]DGNLFKSU]\ SDGNDFKJG\GRV]âRGRQSUDīĆFHJRQDUXV]HQLDSRGVWDZRZ\FK]DVDG SURMHNWXGRVWċSPRīHE\ýRJUDQLF]RQ\W\ONRGRUHZL]RUyZLVWHZDUGyZ 2]QDF]DWRīHVNRURSLVHPQHLQWHUDNFMHPLċG]\Xī\WNRZQLNDPL DOER²]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDRSURJUDPRZDQLD:LNLSHGLL²RJyOQLHHG\FMH VĆZ]DVDG]LHMHG\Q\PGRVWċSQ\PZ:LNLSHGLL]DFKRZDQLHP]DVWċ SXMĆF\P]DUyZQRNRPXQLNDFMċMDNLG]LDâDQLDZV]\VWNLH]DFKRZDQLD

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY ]DFKRG]ĆFHZ:LNLSHGLLVĆ]DSLV\ZDQHLğFLğOHNRQWURORZDQH-HīHOL SRUyZQDOLE\ğP\WRGR]Z\NâHJRī\FLDRGSRZLDGDâRE\WRFLĆJâHPX SRGJOĆGRZL]DSRğUHGQLFWZHPNDPHUÀOPXMĆF\FKNDīG\UXFKLEH] WHUPLQRZRXGRVWċSQLDMĆF\FKQDJUDQLHSR]RVWDâ\PRE\ZDWHORP:W\P VHQVLH:LNLSHGLDSU]\SRPLQD3DQRSW\NRQ)RXFDXOW F]\RWZDUWĆ SU]HVWU]HĕELXURZĆNDīG\REVHUZXMHNDīGHJRDZV]\VWNLHG]LDâDQLD VĆ]DSLV\ZDQHQDZLHF]QRğý &KRýSU]\MċW\V\VWHPVNXWHF]QLHRGJU\ZDUROċUyZQRZDīĆFĆZRO QRğýHG\WRZDQLDLRFKURQċSU]HGGHVWUXNW\ZQ\PL]DFKRZDQLDPLQD SHZQRPRFQRZSâ\ZDQD]DFKRZDQLHVLċXī\WNRZQLNyZ:LNLSHGLL QDZHWMHğOLNZHVWLDNRQWUROLQLHMHVWZHUEDOL]RZDQDDRÀFMDOQLH]DVDG\ SURPXMĆZROQRğýLHJDOLWDU\]P.DīGĆUR]PRZċZ:LNLSHGLLSURZDG]L VLċZSyâRÀFMDOQ\PVW\OXZW\PUR]XPLHQLXīHMHVWRQDGRVWċSQDGOD ZV]\VWNLFK]DLQWHUHVRZDQ\FKMDNWHīīHSU]HFKRZXMHVLċMĆFHOHPNRQ WUROLVSRâHF]QHM=DSURV]HQLHGRNRQW\QXRZDQLDUR]PRZ\SR]DRÀFMDO Q\PLNDQDâDPL:LNLSHGLLQSSU]\Xī\FLXNRPXQLNDWRUDLQWHUQHWRZHJR QLHMHVWVWRVRZDQHLSRVWU]HJDVLċMHMDNRSRWHQFMDOQĆGURJċGRQDJLQDQLD ]DVDG3RGREQLHQDZHWÅRVRELVWHµZ\PLDQ\]GDĕQDVWURQDFKG\VNXVML Xī\WNRZQLNyZSRZLQQRVLċSURZDG]LýZJâyZQ\PMċ]\NXSURMHNWX 3URZDG]LWRQDSU]\NâDGGRV\WXDFMLZNWyU\FKGZDM3RODF\SURZDG]Ć G\VNXVMċZMċ]\NXDQJLHOVNLPQDğUHGQLPSR]LRPLHMċ]\NRZ\PJG\ī G\VNXVMDRGE\ZDVLċZ:LNLPHGLD&RPPRQVFHQWUDOQ\PUHSR]\WRULXP SOLNyZPXOWLPHGLDOQ\FKGODZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLD F]XMĆF SRWU]HEċ]DFKRZDQLDSU]HMU]\VWRğFLVZRMHMLQWHUDNFMLGODLQQ\FK'ĆīH QLHGRSU]HMU]\VWRğFLSR]EDZLDLQWHUDNFMHLFKSU\ZDWQHJRFKDUDNWHUX =SXQNWXZLG]HQLDNRQWUROLVSRâHF]QHMQLHMHVW]DVNDNXMĆFHīH ZğUyGZLNLSHG\VWyZNWyU]\QDZ]DMHPVLċQLH]QDMĆQLHLVWQLHMĆSUD ZLHīDGQHSU\ZDWQHNDQDâ\UHJXODUQHMLRJyOQLHX]QDQHMLQWHUDNFML SR]DSyâRÀFMDOQ\PLNDQDâDPL,5&Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\PLW\ONRSU]H] F]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFLPRīOLZRğFLĆZ\VâDQLDZLDGRPRğFLHPDLOXī\WNRZ QLNRZLNWyU\JRG]LVLċQDWċIRUPċNRQWDNWXRUD]LQQ\PLğURGNDPL WHFKQLF]Q\PLPDMĆF\PLMHGQDNFKDUDNWHUSXEOLF]Q\MDNOLVW\G\VNX V\MQH-DNMXīZVSRPQLDQRZMHGQ\P]SRSU]HGQLFKUR]G]LDâyZOLVW\ G\VNXV\MQHDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZRUD]VWHZDUGyZU]HF]QLNyZLWG VĆ U]DGNLPLSU]\NâDGDPLNDQDâyZNRPXQLNDFMLJG]LHQLHIRUVXMHVLċ

1DOHī\]D]QDF]\ýīH]DVDG\:LNLSHGLLQLHGRW\F]ĆNRPXQLNDFMLQDNDQDâDFK ,5&LRWZDUW\FKOLVWDFKG\VNXV\MQ\FKFKRýNDQDâ\WHQLHVĆWDNSXEOLF]QHMDN LQWHUDNFMHZVDPHM:LNLSHGLL

139

140

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]DVDGSU]HMU]\VWRğFLLGRVWċSXSXEOLF]QHJR6WDQRZLĆRQHMHGQDNZ\ MĆWHNRGUHJXâ\DQDOHī\GRGDWNRZR]D]QDF]\ýīHSRUXV]DQLHQDQLFK NZHVWLLQLHVWDQRZLĆF\FKEH]SRğUHGQLRRELHNWX]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDZ\ âĆF]QLHGDQHMOLVW\G\VNXV\MQHMVâXīĆFHMGRG\VNXVMLQDGG]LDâDQLDPL DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZQLH]DğLQQ\FKNZHVWLLZV]F]HJyOQRğFL]DVDGLLFK ]PLDQJG\īWHZ\PDJDMĆ]JRG\RJyâXVSRâHF]QRğFL MHVWĩOHZLG]LDQH

KONTROLA PRZEZ STRUKTURĘ WYPOWIEDZI =DVNDNXMĆFDUyīQLFDPLċG]\SROVNĆDDQJLHOVNĆ:LNLSHGLĆOHī\ZVSR VRELHSURZDG]HQLDZ\PLDQ\]GDĕQDVWURQDFKG\VNXVMLFRSU]HNâDGD VLċQDVSRVyEVSUDZRZDQLDNRQWUROLVSRâHF]QHM2SURJUDPRZDQLH 0HGLD:LNL]DU]ĆG]DMĆFHRE\GZRPDSURMHNWDPLSR]ZDODQDLQIRUPR ZDQLHXī\WNRZQLNDRSRMDZLHQLXVLċQRZHMZLDGRPRğFLJG\MHJR VWURQDG\VNXVML]RVWDQLH]PRG\ÀNRZDQD2F]\ZLğFLHPDWRQLH]DSU]H F]DOQH]DOHW\GODRVyESRMDZLDMĆF\FKVLċZ:LNLSHGLLSRZLDGDPLDMĆF LFKīHNWRğFKFH]ZUyFLýQDVLHELHLFKXZDJċ:SROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLIXQN FMċWċZ\NRU]\VWXMHVLċQDMSUDZGRSRGREQLHM]JRGQLH]SU]H]QDF]HQLHP VWURQ\G\VNXVMLXī\WNRZQLNyZVâXīĆ]DV\VWHPSRZLDGDPLDQLDVDPH ZLDGRPRğFLVĆZLGRF]QHSXEOLF]QLHOHF]QDGDQHMVWURQLHG\VNXVML ]QDMGXMĆVLċZ\âĆF]QLHZLDGRPRğFLSU]H]QDF]RQHGODZâDğFLFLHODQLH ]DğMHJRRGSRZLHG]L -HğOLFKFċSR]RVWDZLýNRPXğZLDGRPRğýWR HG\WXMċMHJROXEMHMVWURQċG\VNXVMLLRF]HNXMċīHRGSRZLHQDPRMHM VWURQLHG\VNXVML-HğOLZ\PLDQD]GDĕMHVWGâXīV]DWRZHGZRMHZ\PLH QLDP\VLċZLDGRPRğFLDPLQDVWURQDFKG\VNXVML &RPRīHG]LZLýQDZHWSU]\Xī\FLXW\FKVDP\FKğURGNyZWHFKQLF] Q\FKV\VWHPWHQQLHIXQNFMRQXMHWDNVDPRSRZV]HFKQLHZDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLL7DPG\VNXVMċSURZDG]LVLċQDVWURQLHG\VNXVMLXī\WNRZQLND JG]LHRQDVLċUR]SRF]ċâD*G]LHNROZLHNSRGMċWRZĆWHNWRWDPPDE\ý RQNRQW\QXRZDQ\DXF]HVWQLF\G\VNXVMLVĆRGSRZLHG]LDOQL]DğOHG]HQLH F]\ZVSUDZLHSRZLHG]LDQRFRNROZLHNQRZHJR:SUDNW\FHZLGRF]Q\ HIHNWSU]\SRPLQDUDF]HMZĆWNLQDIRUXPQLīSXEOLF]QLHGRVWċSQ\ V\VWHPZ\PLDQ\ZLDGRPRğFL3RZRG\WDNLHJRSRGHMğFLDGRG\VNXVML SU]HGVWDZLDVWURQD]UDGDPLGODSRWHQFMDOQ\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ2G VW\F]QLDQDGDOZLGRF]QDZOXW\P E\âDWDPZLGRF]QDQD VWċSXMĆFDUDGDVWDQRZLĆFDMHGQĆ]G]LHVLċFLXU]HF]\SRWHQFMDOQLH ]DEyMF]\FKGODSURFHVX38$>>HQ:LNLSHGLD+RZWRSDVVDQ5I$@@

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY -HğOLMHVWHğW\SHPXī\WNRZQLNDNWyU\RGSRZLDGDQDNRPHQWDU]HQD VWURQLHG\VNXVMLLQQHJRXī\WNRZQLND35=(67$Ĕ7252%,ü7UXGQR MHVWRVRELHSU]HJOĆGDMĆFHMSUDZLGâRZRRFHQLý]DZDUWRğýWDNLHMVWURQ\ GRWHJRPRīHWRVNXWHF]QLH]QLZHF]\ý7ZRMHV]DQVHZ38$-HğOLNWRğ ZSLVXMHQD7ZRMĆVWURQċG\VNXVMLNU\W\NċDOERRVWU]HīHQLHGREU]HMHVW E\LQQLPLHOLV]DQVċ]REDF]\ý7ZRMĆRGSRZLHGĩDOERSXQNWZLG]HQLD 1LHFKFHV]īHE\PXVLHOLGRNRS\ZDýVLċGRSUDZG\

7DNLHSRGHMğFLHPDMHGQĆ]GHF\GRZDQĆZDGċLVWRWQĆV]F]HJyOQLH GODEDUG]RDNW\ZQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZQLHVĆRQLDXWRPDW\F]QLHSRZLD GDPLDQLRRGSRZLHG]LDFKQDSR]RVWDZLRQHLQQ\PZLDGRPRğFL=DPLDVW WHJRRF]HNXMHVLċRGQLFKGRGDQLDVWURQG\VNXVMLXī\WNRZQLNyZ]NWy U\PLZFKRG]ĆZLQWHUDNFMċGROLVW\VWURQREVHUZRZDQ\FKF]ċVWR]D ZLHUDMĆFHMG]LHVLĆWNLW\VLċF\GRNXPHQWyZ LUHDJRZDQLDQDSRMDZLDQLH VLċRGSRZLHG]LĞOHG]HQLHZV]\VWNLFKZĆWNyZG\VNXVMLZNWyU\FKELHU]H VLċXG]LDâMHVWZ\MĆWNRZRXFLĆīOLZHGODDNW\ZQ\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZ 'RGDWNRZRSURZDG]ĆFG\VNXVMċ]NLPğ]NLPSRUR]XPLHZDVLċZLċNV]D OLF]EDRVyEQDOHī\SU]HG]LHUDýVLċSU]H]ZV]\VWNLHZĆWNLG\VNXVML ZSRV]XNLZDQLXZâDğFLZHJR&]ċğýXī\WNRZQLNyZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL UDG]LVRELH]W\PXG]LHODMĆFRGSRZLHG]LQDZâDVQHMVWURQLHG\VNXVML LLQIRUPXMĆFLQWHUORNXWRUDRIDNFLH]DUHDJRZDQLDQDMHJRVWURQLHOHF] WDNDSUDNW\NDQLHMHVWSU]\MċW\PVWDQGDUGHPZLċFQLHPRīQDRF]HNL ZDýWHJRVWRSQLDXSU]HMPRğFLRGZV]\VWNLFK 7DUyīQLFDVWDQRZLâDGODPQLHFK\EDMHGHQ]QDMZLċNV]\FKV]RNyZ NXOWXURZ\FKZVSRâHF]QRğFLZLUWXDOQHM]NWyU\PLPLDâHPGRF]\QLHQLD SRGRâĆF]HQLXGRJURQDRVyEHG\WXMĆF\FKDQJLHOVNĆZHUVMċ:LNLSHGLL ZPDUFXURNX8]QDâHPīHZLċNV]RğýDQJLHOVNLFKZLNLSHG\VWyZ WRPDVRFKLğFLDQLHFKċýGRVNRU]\VWDQLD]IXQNFMLSRZLDGDPLDQLD RQDGHMğFLXQRZHMZLDGRPRğFL²]DLU\WXMĆFHLQLHORJLF]QH3RSU]HP\ğ OHQLXMHGQDNXZDīDPīHZLHPGODF]HJRWDNZâDğQLHURELĆ 3U]\F]\Q\WDNLHJRSRVWċSRZDQLDZ\OLF]RQHVĆZHZVSRPQLDQ\P MXīHVHMX]DZLHUDMĆF\PUDG\GODSU]\V]â\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ'\VNXVMD PDSU]HELHJDýZMHGQ\PPLHMVFXNRV]WHPQLHZ\JRG\G\VNXWXMĆF\FK OHF]GODZ\JRG\SRVWURQQ\FKREVHUZDWRUyZNWyU]\PRJĆHJ]HNZRZDý NRQWUROċVSRâHF]QĆQDGZ\PLDQDPL]GDĕ:\NRU]\VW\ZDQLHIXQNFML RSURJUDPRZDQLD0HGLD:LNLX]QDZDQHMHVW]D]PXV]DQLHVSRâHF]QRğFL GRÅGRNRS\ZDQLDVLċSUDZG\µJG\īZLNLSHG\VWRPQLH]DDQJDīRZDQ\P ZG\VNXVMċWUXGQLHMMHVWMĆğOHG]Lý0RīOLZRğýNRQWURORZDQLDZ\PLDQ\

141

142

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]GDĕZMHGQ\PPLHMVFXMHVWGODVSRâHF]QRğFLZDīQLHMV]DQLīâDWZRğý NRPXQLNDFMLGZyFKOXEZLċNV]HMOLF]E\ Xī\WNRZQLNyZ 6ĆG]ċīHMHVWWRW\SRZHGODUHODFMLPLċG]\HG\WRUDPLNRQWUROD]H VWURQ\ZVSyâUHGDNWRUyZHQF\NORSHGLLSU]HQLNDZV]\VWNLHIRUP\NRQ WDNWX]DğZV]\VWNRFRZ:LNLSHGLLSRZLHP\PRīHE\ýLEċG]LHXī\WH SU]HFLZNRQDPMHğOL]GDU]\QDPVLċSU]HNURF]\ýRNUHğORQHJUDQLFH 3U]\F]\QDGODNWyUHMNRQWURODWDQLHMHVWZ\ZLHUDQDZWDNVDPRVLOQ\P VWRSQLXZSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLOHī\SUDZGRSRGREQLHZZLHONRğFLVSR âHF]QRğFL,PEDUG]LHMUR]SURV]RQDMHVWJUXSDLLPPQLHMSROHJDRQDQD SyâRVRELVWHMVLHFLXī\WNRZQLNyZNWyU\FKUR]SR]QDMHP\SU]\QDMPQLHM ]SVHXGRQLPXW\PZLċFHMNRQWUROLZ\PDJDV\VWHPVSRâHF]Q\:V]\VW NLHHG\FMHVĆLWDNPRQLWRURZDQH]DğZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZSROVNLHM :LNLSHGLLSU]\]Z\F]DMRQ\FKMHVWGRNRQLHF]QRğFLMHGQRF]HVQHJRF]\ WDQLDZLHOXVWURQG\VNXVMLE\PLHýFDâRğFLRZ\REUD]WRF]ĆFHMVLċ UR]PRZ\ :SRGREQ\PGXFKXREVHUZDFMLXī\WNRZQLNyZZLNLSHG\ğFLVLOQLH VSU]HFLZLDMĆVLċXVXZDQLXF]HJRNROZLHN]WRNXG\VNXVMLFK\EDīHVĆ NXWHPXVLOQHSRZRG\²FKRý]DNUHVÅVLOQHJRSRZRGXµMHVWFLĆJOH G\VNXWRZDQ\2ÀFMDOQD]DVDGD:LNLSHGLL>>HQ:LNLSHGLD1RSHUVRQDO DWWDFNV@@ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLRGSRZLHGQLNSROVNLHMUHJXâ\>>:L NLSHGLDĪDGQ\FKRVRELVW\FKDWDNyZ@@Z\UDīDâDFDâRğýZSDĩG]LHUQLNX QDVWċSXMĆFR 1LHLVWQLHMHRÀFMDOQD]DVDGDPyZLĆFDRW\PNLHG\LF]\ZRJyOHQDOHī\ XVXZDýDWDNLRVRELVWHFKRýNZHVWLDE\âDV]HURNRG\VNXWRZDQD8VX QLċFLHMHGQR]QDF]Q\FKDWDNyZRVRELVW\FK]ZâDVQHMVWURQ\G\VNXVML U]DGNRZ\ZRâXMH]G]LZLHQLH1DLQQ\FKVWURQDFKG\VNXVMLV]F]HJyOQLH ZSU]\SDGNDFKJG\WHNVWREUDīDRNUHğORQHJRXī\WNRZQLNDMHJRXVX QLċFLHSRZLQQRRJUDQLF]DýVLċGRSU]\SDGNyZHZLGHQWQ\FKDWDNyZ RVRELVW\FK

'RGDWNRZREUDN]DXWRPDW\]RZDQHJRV\VWHPXSRZLDGDPLDQLDNWyU\QD PDUJLQHVLHPRīQDZSURZDG]LýQLHZLHONLPLQDNâDGDPLWHFKQLF]Q\PL ]ZLċNV]D SRğZLċFHQLHXF]HVWQLNyZG\VNXVML]PXV]RQ\FKGRğOHG]HQLDVWURQQDNWyU\FK SRGMċOLGLDORJ6WDZLDWRWHīZJRUV]HMSR]\FMLQRZRSU]\E\â\FKNWyU]\PRJĆE\ý QLHğZLDGRPLīHRGSRZLHGĩ]RVWDQLHXG]LHORQDQDVWURQLHG\VNXVMLLFKUR]PyZF\ 3U]\F]\QLDVLċWRGREXGRZDQLDHJDOLWDUQHJRV\VWHPXZâDG]\RPyZLRQHJRV]HU]HM ZUR]G]LDOHSRğZLċFRQ\PIRUPDOQ\PURORPZVSRâHF]QRğFLLKLHUDUFKLL

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY 2JyOQLHRGUDG]DVLċPRG\ÀNRZDQLHNRPHQWDU]\LQQ\FKXī\WNRZ QLNyZ:SDĩG]LHUQLNXVWURQD>>HQ:LNLSHGLD(WLTXHWWH@@>>:LNL SHGLD:LNLHW\NLHWD@@ ]DZLHUDâDQDVWċSXMĆF\]DSLV (G\WRZDQLHNRPHQWDU]\QDVWURQDFKG\VNXVMLSRGSLVDQ\FKSU]H] LQQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZQLHMHVWDSURERZDQHQDZHWMHğOLSROHJDRQR Z\âĆF]QLHQDSRSUDZNDFKRUWRJUDÀF]Q\FKLLQWHUSXQNF\MQ\FK

'RNXPHQW>>HQ:LNLSHGLD$YRLGLQJFRPPRQPLVWDNHV@@Z\PLHQLD WURFKċEâċGyZSRSHâQLDQ\FKSU]H]QRZ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZPLċG]\LQQ\PL 8VXZDQLHWHNVWX]MDNLHMNROZLHNVWURQ\G\VNXVMLEH]]DUFKLZL]RZDQLD NDVRZDQ\FKZSLVyZRSUyF]ZâDVQHMSU]HVWU]HQLXī\WNRZQLND6WURQ\ G\VNXVMLVĆF]ċğFLĆKLVWRU\F]Q\FK]DSLVyZ:LNLSHGLL3U]\NDīG\PF]\V] F]HQLX]DZDUWRğFLWDNLHMVWURQ\QDOHī\XVXZDQ\WHNVWSU]HNRSLRZDý GRDUFKLZXP²>>$UFKLZXP@@

3RGREQLHGRNXPHQW>>HQ:LNLSHGLD7DONSDJHJXLGHOLQHV@@GHÀ QLXMĆF\Z\W\F]QHSURZDG]HQLDVWURQG\VNXVMLMDVQRPyZL 1LJG\QLHHG\WXMDQLQLHSU]HVXZDMNRPHQWDU]\LQQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZ ]PLHQLDMĆFLFK]QDF]HQLD1DZHWQDZâDVQHMVWURQLHG\VNXVML3U]HNUH ğODQLHWHNVWXUyZQLHīVNXWNXMH]PLDQĆMHJR]QDF]HQLDLSRZLQQRE\ý GRNRQ\ZDQHW\ONRSU]H]RVREċNWyUDSR]RVWDZLâDSU]HNUHğODQ\NRPHQ WDU]OXELQQĆRVREċG]LDâDMĆFĆQDMHMZ\UDĩQHī\F]HQLH (G\WRZDQLH²DQDZHWXVXZDQLH²NRPHQWDU]\LQQ\FKRVyEF]DVDPL MHVWGR]ZRORQH1DOHī\MHGQDNZ\ND]\ZDýSU]\WDNLFKG]LDâDQLDFK RVWURīQRğýLQLHGRNRQ\ZDýLFKMHğOLSRMDZLDMĆVLċJâRV\VSU]HFLZX

1DZHWMHğOLRGSRZ\īV]HM]DVDG\]GDU]DMĆVLċZ\MĆWNLQSZSU]\ SDGNXRVWU\FKDWDNyZRVRELVW\FKXMDZQLDQLDZUDīOLZ\FKGDQ\FK RVRERZ\FKWUROOLQJXLZDQGDOL]PyZ EUDNXMHZQLFKQLHXSU]HMPRğFL LRND]MRQDOQ\FKLQZHNW\Z:URNXXVXQĆâHPZSROVNLHM:LNL SHGLLSRQLīDMĆF\NRPHQWDU]VNLHURZDQ\GRLQQHMXī\WNRZQLF]NL UR]SRF]\QDMĆF\VLċRGVâyZÅ6XJHUXMċQLHSU]HMPRZDýVLċRZĆªZLNL SHG\VWNĆ©-HMXOXELRQĆUR]U\ZNĆMHVWXSRPLQDQLHLQQ\FKLREUDīDQLH VLċµZNLONDPLQXWSRMHJRSXEOLNDFML0LDâHPQDG]LHMċīHZLNLSH G\VWNDZNWyUĆVNLHURZDQ\E\âyZDWDNRVRELVW\QLH]REDF]\JRLQLH SRF]XMHVLċSU]H]WRDWDNRZDQD,QQLDGPLQLVWUDWRU]\VNU\W\NRZDOL

143

144

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... MHGQDNPRMHG]LDâDQLD3RWU]\QDVWXPLHVLĆFDFKZWUDNFLHZHU\ÀNDFML PRLFKXSUDZQLHĕNZHVWLD]RVWDâDSRUXV]RQDMXīZSLHUZV]\PS\WDQLX LZ\PDJDâDV]HURNLHJRNRPHQWDU]DLXVSUDZLHGOLZLHĕ =DVDG\HG\WRZDQLDZâDVQ\FKNRPHQWDU]\VĆMHV]F]HRVWU]HMV]H >>HQ:LNLSHGLD7DONSDJHJXLGHOLQHV@@ 1DMOHSLHMMHVWXQLNDý]PLHQLDQLDZâDVQ\FKNRPHQWDU]\,QQLXī\WNRZ QLF\PRJOLMXīMH]DF\WRZDý]SRGDQLHPGLIID]REZ\īHM OXEQDQLH ]DUHDJRZDý/HSLHMMHVWZLċFVNRU]\VWDý]SU]\FLVNXÅ3RNDīSRGJOĆGµ LSU]HP\ğOHýMDN]PLHQLRQ\NRPHQWDU]PRīHZ\JOĆGDýGODLQQ\FK Xī\WNRZQLNyZSU]HGMHJR]DSLVDQLHP 8VXZDQLHOXE]QDF]QH]PLDQ\NRPHQWDU]\SRW\PMDNNWRğQDQLH RGSRZLHG]LDâPRīHSR]EDZLýRGSRZLHGĩMHMSLHUZRWQHJRNRQWHNVWX 0RīHWHīE\ýP\OĆFH3U]HG]PLDQĆNRPHQWDU]DSU]HP\ğOMHGQR]PRī OLZ\FKG]LDâDĕ 6NRQWDNWXMVLċ]RVREDPLNWyUHRGSRZLHG]LDâ\QDWZyMNRPHQWDU] QDLFKVWURQDFKG\VNXVML LVS\WDMF]\DSUREXMĆXVXQLċFLHOXE ]PLDQċ7ZRMHJRWHNVWX 6NRU]\VWDM]H]QDF]QLNyZXVXZDQLDLZVWDZLDQLDWHNVWyZSRND ]XMĆFīHFRğ]RVWDâR]PLHQLRQH y 8VXZDQLHWHNVWXNWyUHZLċNV]RğýSU]HJOĆGDUHNZ\ğZLHWODMDNR SU]HNUHğOHQLHX]\VNXMHVLċ]QDF]QLNDPLGHO!RUD]GHO! y :VWDZLDQLHWHNVWXNWyUHZLċNV]RğýSU]HJOĆGDUHNZ\ğZLHWODMDNR SRGNUHğOHQLHX]\VNXMHVLċ]QDF]QLNDPLLQV!RUD]LQV! y 7HNVW]DVWċSF]\WR]GDQLHWDNLHMDNÅ>%H]P\ğOQ\LJâXSLNR PHQWDU]XVXQLċW\SU]H]DXWRUD@µ3U]\WDNLPSRVWċSRZDQLX NRPHQWDU]HXī\WNRZQLNyZ]LU\WRZDQ\FK7ZRMĆSRVWDZĆQLH WUDFĆVHQVX0RJĆ]DWR]RVWDý]DVWĆSLRQHSU]H]VIRUPXâRZDQLH W\SXÅ>2GSRZLHGĩSRLU\WRZDQHJRXī\WNRZQLNDQDXVXQLċW\ NRPHQWDU]UyZQLHīXVXQLċWD3U]\MPXMċSU]HSURVLQ\@µ y 1LHVWRVXMSRZ\īV]\FKWHFKQLNGRNRPHQWDU]\LQQ\FKXī\W NRZQLNyZEH]LFK]JRG\ 0RG\ÀNXMĆFNRPHQWDU]PRīHV]SR]RVWDZLýQRWDWNċZVND]XMĆFĆ QD]PLDQċ0RīHV]WHīGRGDýF]DVGRNRQDQLD]PLDQ\ZVWDZLDMĆF SLċýW\OGF]\OLaaaaa

:SUDNW\FHSRGHMU]DQDMHVWNDīGD]PLDQD]DPLHV]F]RQHJRMXī NRPHQWDU]D]PRīOLZ\PZ\MĆWNLHPSRSUDZ\RUWRJUDÀLLLQWHUSXQNFML -HVWWR]DVWDQDZLDMĆFHV]F]HJyOQLHZSU]\SDGNXWHJRīHZZLHOXIRUDFK

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY LQWHUQHWRZ\FKF]\QD)DFHERRNXXVXZDQLHZâDVQ\FKNRPHQWDU]\ MDNWHīHG\WRZDQLHLFKSRVWIDFWXPMHVWVSRâHF]QLHDNFHSWRZDOQHFKRý PHFKDQL]P\HG\F\MQHQLHSR]ZDODMĆQDWDNGRNâDGQHğOHG]HQLH]PLDQ MDNPDWRPLHMVFHZ:LNLSHGLL-DNZLGDý:LNLSHGLDQLHIROJXMH]E\WQLR Xī\WNRZQLNRPFKFĆF\PFRIQĆýVZRMHXF]\QNLSR]ZDODMHG\QLHQD Z\UDīHQLHVDPRNU\W\NLSU]H]Z\NUHğOHQLHZâDVQ\FKVâyZOHF]SR]R VWDZLDMĆFMHZSU]HVWU]HQLSXEOLF]QHME\XPLHğFLýUHDNFMHLQQ\FK Xī\WNRZQLNyZQDSLHUZRWQLH]DPLHV]F]RQ\NRPHQWDU]ZRGSRZLHGQLP NRQWHNğFLH5HGDNFMDNRPHQWDU]\GR]ZRORQDMHVWMHG\QLHZRNUHğOR Q\FKSU]\SDGNDFK]RE>>HQ:35()$&725@@

KONTROLA PRZEZ PROCEDURY 1DNXOWXUċ:LNLSHGLLMDNZVSRPQLDQRHWRVğZLDWDKDNHUyZZ\ZDUâ GXī\ZSâ\ZQLHW\ONRZ]DNUHVLHDQW\HOLWDUQHJRSRGHMğFLDGRXī\W NRZQLNyZLRGU]XFDQLDKLHUDUFKLLOHF]UyZQLHīZ]QDF]HQLXSR]RU QHJROHNFHZDīHQLDIRUPDOQRğFLLELXURNUDFMLRUJDQL]DF\MQHM5D\PRQG =GURZ\UR]VĆGHNF]ċVWRXZDīDQ\MHVW]DZDīQLHMV]\RGRÀFMDOQ\FK SURFHGXU]DğRGXī\WNRZQLNyZRF]HNXMHVLċīHSRGHMPĆG]LDâDQLD NWyUHZLFKRGF]XFLXVâXīĆ:LNLSHGLLLīHZ\NDīĆVLċWU]HĩZ\PRVĆGHP V\WXDFML]DPLDVWGRVâRZQLHVWRVRZDýOLWHUċSUDZD =DPLDVWGRVâRZQHJRVWRVRZDQLDVLċGRNDīGHM]DVDG\SRGF]DVHG\WR ZDQLDZ\VWDUF]\Z\ND]\ZDýVLċ]GURZ\PUR]VĆGNLHP=E\WQLHXZL NâDQLHVLċZ]DVDG\PRīHVSRZRGRZDýXWUDWċWU]HĩZHJRSDWU]HQLDQD SURMHNWZLċFF]DVDPLOHSLHMMHVWGDQĆ]DVDGċ]LJQRURZDý1DZHWMHğOL Xī\WNRZQLNÅQDUXV]Dµ]DVDGċZMHMGRVâRZQ\P]QDF]HQLXQDGDOPRīH GRNRQDýGREUHMHG\FML3RGREQLHIDNWīHFRğQLHMHVW]DND]DQHZVSLVD Q\PGRNXPHQFLHOXEQDZHWMHğOLJG]LHğQDSLVDQRīHGDQHG]LDâDQLH MHVWGR]ZRORQHQLHR]QDF]DīHMHVWRQRVWXSURFHQWRZRRGSRZLHGQLH ZGDQHMV\WXDFML'XFK]DVDGMHVWZDīQLHMV]\RGLFKGRVâRZQHJR]QD F]HQLD>>HQ:LNLSHGLD&20021@@

-HGQD]]DVDG:LNLSHGLLVWDQRZLZUċF]Å-HğOLUHJXâ\QLHSR]ZDODMĆ FLQDSRGQLHVLHQLHMDNRğFL:LNLSHGLL]LJQRUXMMHµ>>HQ:LNLSHGLD ,JQRUHDOOUXOHV@@>>:LNLSHGLD,JQRUXMZV]\VWNLH]DVDG\@@ ]DğMHGHQ

145

146

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]SLċFLXÀODUyZ:LNLSHGLLVWDQRZLĆF\FKQDMEDUG]LHMIXQGDPHQWDOQH UHJXâ\SURMHNWXPyZL =DVDG\:LNLSHGLLQLHVĆZ\U\WHZNDPLHQLXJG\īLFKZ\PRZDLLQWHU SUHWDFMDPRJĆE\ý]PLHQQHZF]DVLH:\PRZDLGXFK]DVDG:LNLSHGLL VĆZDīQLHMV]HQLīGRVâRZQHLFK]QDF]HQLHDF]DVHPSRSUDZLHQLHMDNRğFL :LNLSHGLLZ\PDJDSRF]\QLHQLDZ\MĆWNXRGGDQHM]DVDG\1DOHī\ğPLDâR OHF]QLHEUDZXURZR DNWXDOL]RZDý]DZDUWRğýKDVHâQLHERMĆFVLċSR SHâQLDQLDEâċGyZ3RSU]HGQLHZHUVMHNDīGHMVWURQ\VĆ]DZV]HGRVWċSQH ZLċFPRīQDSRSUDZLýNDīG\SRSHâQLRQ\EâĆG>>HQ:LNLSHGLD)LYHBSLO ODUV@@>>:LNLSHGLD)@@

&R]DEDZQHLVWQLHMHQDZHWÅ]DVDGDµZIRUPLHHVHMXPyZLĆFDīH QDOHī\XQLNDýQDJURPDG]HQLDLQVWUXNFML²>>HQ:LNLSHGLD&5((3@@ ]DğMHGQD]]DVDGRSLVXMĆFDWRF]\P:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWWZDUGRRğZLDGF]D īH:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWELXURNUDFMĆ :LNLSHGLDFHFKXMHVLċZLHORPDZâDğFLZRğFLDPLELXURNUDFMLOHF]QLHMHVW ]DU]ĆG]DQDVWDWXWRZRQLHMHVWVĆGHPUHMRQRZ\P]Dğ]DVDG\QLHVWD QRZLĆZQLHMFHOXG]LDâDQLDVSRâHF]QRğFL6SLVDQH]DVDG\VDPHZVRELH QLHXVWDQDZLDMĆSU]\MċW\FKSUDNW\NDUDF]HMGRNXPHQWXMĆREHFQ\ ZVSRâHF]QRğFLNRQVHQVXVFRGRWHJRFRMHVWDNFHSWRZDOQHDFRSRZLQQR VLċRGU]XFLý-HğOL]DXZDī\VLċSU]HâDGRZDQLHV\VWHPXLQVWUXNFMDPL QDOHī\JRRF]\ğFLý 6SLVDQH]DVDG\LZ\W\F]QH:LNLSHGLLSRZLQQRVLċWUDNWRZDýSRZDī QLHOHF]QLHPRīQDLFKQDGXī\ZDý1LHZROQRVWRVRZDýVLċGR]E\WQLR GRVâRZQHMLQWHUSUHWDFMLOLWHU\]DVDGEH]RGQLHVLHQLDVLċGRMHMGXFKD -HğOL]DVDG\U]HF]\ZLğFLHSU]HV]NDG]DMĆZSRSUDZLHQLXHQF\NORSHGLL QDOHī\MH]LJQRURZDý1LH]JRGċUR]ZLĆ]XMHVLċSU]H]G\VNXVMċGĆīĆFĆ GRNRQVHQVXVX]DPLDVWğFLVâHJRWU]\PDQLDVLċ]DVDGLSURFHGXU&R ZLċFHMVDPH]DVDG\LSURFHGXU\QDOHī\]PLHQLDýE\RG]ZLHUFLHGODâ\ RQHSU]\MċW\NRQVHQVXV %âĆGSURFHGXUDOQ\SRSHâQLRQ\ZSURSR]\FMLOXEZQLRVNXQLHMHVW SRZRGHPGRRGU]XFHQLDZQRV]RQHMSURSR]\FML

3UDZGĆMHVWīHQLHGRFLĆJQLċFLDSURFHGXUDOQHQLHVWDQRZLĆSRG VWDZ\G\VNUHG\WRZDQLDSURSR]\FMLZZLċNV]RğFLSU]\SDGNyZFKRý PDMĆRQH]QDF]HQLHQDSU]\NâDGSRGF]DVZ\ERUyZIXQNFMRQDULXV]\ :LNLSHGLLNLHG\F]ċVWRNZHVWLRQXMHVLċZDīQRğýJâRVyZRGGDQ\FK

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY SU]HGRÀFMDOQ\PSRWZLHUG]HQLHPSU]H]NDQG\GDWDFKċFLXG]LDâX ZZ\ERUDFK 'RGDWNRZRSUyEDZ\NRU]\VWDQLD]DVDGZ]âHMZLHU]HOXEZ\NRU]\ VWDQLDNUXF]NyZWNZLĆF\FKZ]DVDGDFKMHVWRNUHğODQDMDNRÅSRJU\ZDQLH ]V\VWHPHPµLğFLğOH]DND]DQD'RNXPHQW>>HQ:LNLSHGLD*DPLQJWKH V\VWHP@@]DNâDGD (G\WRUSRJU\ZDMĆF\]V\VWHPHPVWDUDVLċZ\NRU]\VWDý]DVDG\SURMHNWX Z]âHMZLHU]HRGV]XNXMĆFZLFKOLWHU]HX]DVDGQLHQLHG]LDâDĕSU]HV]ND G]DMĆF\FKZSUDF\LQQ\PL]DFKRZDĕNWyU\FK]DVDG\ZFDOHQLHSRSLH UDMĆ3RGHMPXMĆFWDNLHG]LDâDQLDRGG]LHODRQ]DVDG\LZ\W\F]QHRGLFK QDOHīQHJRPLHMVFDMDNRğURGNDGRNXPHQWXMĆFHJRNRQVHQVXVVSRâHF] QRğFLLVWDUDVLċZ\NRU]\VWDýMHVHOHNW\ZQLHZVRELHW\ONR]QDQ\FK FHODFK(G\WRUSU]HV]NDG]DZSUDF\SURMHNWXMHğOLF\WXMHIUDJPHQW ]DVDG\PDMĆF\U]HNRPRZVSLHUDýSXQNWZLG]HQLDNWyU\VWRLZMDVQHM VSU]HF]QRğFL]]DVDGDPLDWDNXMHSRVWDZċPDMĆFĆVLOQHX]DVDGQLHQLH Z]DVDGDFKSURMHNWX]SUHPHG\WDFMĆEâċGQLHMHVWRVXMĆFOXE]E\WQLR XV]F]HJyâDZLDMĆF]DVDG\:LNLSHGLL

=E\WQLHREH]QDQLHZ]DVDGDFKSURMHNWXPRīHQDZHW]RVWDýX]QDQH ]DSRGHMU]DQH2GJU\ZDQLHUROLSDUDSUDZQLNDMHVWRGELHUDQH]GHF\ GRZDQLHQHJDW\ZQLHF]HPXSRğZLċFRQRQDZHWHVHM]DFKRZDZF]\ RSLVXMĆF\SRZRG\GODNWyU\FKÅZLNLSUDZQLF]HQLHµMHVWQLHZVND]DQH >>HQ:LNLSHGLD:LNLODZ\HULQJ@@ ´:LNLSUDZQLNµWRSU]HGâXīHQLHZL]HUXQNXSUDZQLNDWHUPLQWHQ PRīQDWHīVWRVRZDýZLQQ\FKNRQWHNVWDFKQSGRRVyESRZLHU]FKRZQLH RVĆG]DMĆF\FKLQQ\FKHG\WRUyZLLFKG]LDâDQLDZ\FLĆJDMĆF\FKSRFKRSQLH ZQLRVNLLÅSU]\NOHMDMĆF\FKâDWNLµZUċNXG]LHUīĆF]DVDG\:LNLSHGLL MDNRQDU]ċG]LH]Z\FLċīDQLDLQQ\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZDQLHUR]ZLĆ]\ZD QLDNRQÁLNWyZOXEZ\V]XNLZDQLDREXVWURQQLHVDW\VIDNFMRQXMĆFHJR UR]ZLĆ]DQLD =DVDG\LSURFHGXU\:LNLSHGLLSRZLQQRVLċLQWHUSUHWRZDý]H]GUR Z\PUR]VĆGNLHPE\RVLĆJQĆýFHOGODNWyUHJRRQHLVWQLHMĆSRPDJDQLH ZUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLXNRQÁLNWyZ7\SRZRÅZLNLSUDZQLF]HQLHµWRSU]\ZRâ\ ZDQLHDUJXPHQWyZSURFHGXUDOQ\FKOXEGRZRGRZ\FKZVSRVyEDQDORJLF]Q\ GRIRUPDOQ\FKSRVWċSRZDĕSUDZQ\FKF]ċVWRSU]\UR]XPRZDQLXSUDZ Q\PRSDUW\PQDEâċGQ\FKSU]HVâDQNDFK&]DVDPLÅZLNLSUDZQLF]HQLHµ PRīHGRSURZDG]LýGRSRVWDZLHQLDLVWRWQ\FKS\WDĕZâĆF]QLH]S\WDQLDPL

147

148

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... REH]VWURQQRğýOHF]F]ċğFLHMVâXī\RQRXQLNQLċFLXGDQHMNZHVWLLOXE SU]HV]NRG]HQLXZZ\SUDFRZDQLXUR]ZLĆ]DQLD

2SUyF]GRğýG]LZQHMGHNODUDFMLRQLHFKċFLGRSUDZQLNyZHVHMWHQ SRGNUHğODFRğZFRVLOQLHZLHU]\VSRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLLSURFHGXU\ PRJĆQLHE\ýLGHDOQHOHF]HG\WRU]\SRZLQQLSU]HVWU]HJDýLFKGXFKD UR]XPLHMĆFLV]DQXMĆFSRWU]HEċLVWQLHQLD]DVDG]DPLDVWZ\V]XNLZDQLD G]LXU3RGREQLHGRZVSyâSUDF\ZUDPDFKNRRSHUDW\ZyZMDN0RQ GUDJRQF]\NLEXFH ZLċNV]H]QDF]HQLHSU]\ZLĆ]XMHVLċGRVROLGDUQRğFL QLīGRUyZQRğFLSHUVH*UHHQZRRGLLQ 2F]\ZLğFLHWDNLHSR GHMğFLHQLH]DG]LDâDZV]HUV]HMVSRâHF]QRğFLOHF]Z:LNLSHGLLJG]LH PRīOLZH]DUyZQR]\VNLMDNLVWUDW\RUD]]DNUHVÅNDUµRJUDQLF]DMĆVLċ GRğZLDWDZLUWXDOQHJRLVWQLHQLHSU\PLW\ZQHMDQW\SUDZQLF]HMNXOWXU\ MHVWZ\MĆWNRZRXī\WHF]QHJG\īZWHQVSRVyEZ\PXV]DVLċQDXī\W NRZQLNDFKSRV]XNLZDQLHNRQVHQVXVXLVWRVRZDQLHDUJXPHQWyZQLH VXJHUXMĆFLP]DWRPRīOLZRğFLSRGZDīDQLDSURFHGXU =DVDGQLF]\PSUREOHPHP]NWyU\PERU\NDVLċ:LNLSHGLDMHVWWR īHFRG]LHQQDSUDNW\NDHG\F\MQDGDZQRMXīRGELHJâDRG]DGHNODURZDQHM QLHFKċFLGRSURFHGXUDOL]DFMLLIRUPDOQRğFL-XīZURNXXī\WNRZQLF\ QDU]HNDOLQDURVQĆFĆ]URNXQDURNOLF]Eċ]DVDG%XWOHULLQ DSUREOHPVWDMHVLċFRUD]VLOQLHMV]\]DUyZQRZSROVNLHMMDNLDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLL 3URFHGXU\Z:LNLSHGLLSU]\MPXMĆIRUPċ]DVDGÅSLċýÀODUyZ:LNL SHGLLµL]DVDG\UXFKX:LNLPHGLDZVSyOQHGODZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZ ]DOHFHĕZ\W\F]Q\FKLHVHMyZ3RGVWDZRZH]DVDG\VĆSUDZLHVâRZR ZVâRZRZVSyOQHGODZLċNV]RğFL:LNLSHGLLSRGF]DVJG\]DOHFHQLDVĆ F]DVDPLRGPLHQQH]DğHVHMHZ\ND]XMĆMXīEDUG]R]QDF]QĆRGPLHQQRğý :LċNV]RğýSURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLDVDPDGHF\GXMHRRERZLĆ]XMĆF\FK ZQLFKUHJXâDFK]Z\NOHMHGQDNSU]\MPXMĆF]DVDG\DQJLHOVNLHM:LNL SHGLLMDNRSXQNWZ\MğFLDQSZLċNV]Rğý]DVDGSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLWR WâXPDF]HQLD]ZHUVMLDQJLHOVNLHMOHF]F]ċğýPDMHG\QLHVWDWXVHVHMyZ JG\īQLHX]\VNDâ\RQHSRSDUFLDVSRâHF]QRğFLZGURG]HNRQVHQVXVX

&RFLHNDZHZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLG]LDâDâRZODWDFK²GREURZROQH ]U]HV]HQLHDGZRNDWyZF]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFL²>>HQ:3$VVRFLDWLRQRI0HPEHUV· $GYRFDWHV@@²SRPDJDMĆFHZUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLXNRQIOLNWyZNWyUHMHGQDN]DNRĕF]\âR VZRMĆG]LDâDOQRğý]XZDJLQDSRZROQRğýSUDFRUD]SRVWU]HJDQLHJRSU]H]VSRâHF] QRğý]D]E\WQLRELXURNUDW\F]QHLÅZLNLSUDZQLF]Hµ

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY 'RGDWNRZR]DVDG\NRPSOLNXMHIDNWīHFKRýVSRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLL UR]UyīQLDGRSHZQHJRVWRSQLD]DVDG\]DOHFHQLDLHVHMHGODSRVWURQ QHJRF]\WHOQLNDWRUR]UyīQLHQLHMHVWF]ċVWRPJOLVWH'ODSU]\NâDGX NDWHJRULDÅ=DVDG\:LNLSHGLLGRW\F]ĆFHWUHğFLµ>>HQ&DWHJRU\:LNL SHGLDFRQWHQWSROLFLHV@@ ]DZLHUDGRGDWNRZHSRGNDWHJRULH]OLF]Q\PL Z\W\F]Q\PLLHVHMDPL]ZLĆ]DQ\PL]]DVDGDPLLLFKLQWHUSUHWDFMĆ5R] UyīQLHQLHMHVWQLHMDVQHUyZQLHīQDSR]LRPLHSUDNW\F]QHJR]DVWRVRZD QLDSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK]DVDG=âDPDQLHQLHNWyU\FK]QLFKZRNUHğORQ\FK ZDUXQNDFKQLHSRFLĆJQLH]DVREĆV]F]HJyOQ\FKNRQVHNZHQFMLQS]D VDGDZHU\ÀNRZDOQRğFLMHVWQDMSUDZGRSRGREQLHMâDPDQDZLHORNURWQLH NDīGHJRGQLD OHF]]âDPDQLHUHJXâ]DPLHV]F]RQ\FKZ:LNLSHGLLÅZ\ âĆF]QLHµMDNRHVHMPRīHZQLHNWyU\FKNRQWHNVWDFKGRSURZDG]LýGR ]DEORNRZDQLDXī\WNRZQLNDQS]DWHQGHQF\MQHHG\WRZDQLH²>>HQ:LNL SHGLD7HQGHQWLRXVHGLWLQJ@@ $NWXDOQLHZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLRERZLĆ]XMHSRQDGRÀFMDOQ\FK ]DVDG]DğZSROVNLHMZHUVMLMċ]\NRZHM²SUDZLH-DNQDRUJDQL]DFMċ RFKRWQLF]ĆOLF]ED]DVDGQDZHWW\FKQDMZDīQLHMV]\FKMHVWSU]\WâDF]DMĆFD 5HJXOXMĆRQHV]HURNL]DNUHVDVSHNWyZī\FLD:LNLSHGLL²RGVSRVREyZ G\VNXWRZDQLDQDGHQF\NORSHG\F]QRğFLĆNVLĆīHNF]\OXG]LQDGDOī\MĆF\FK SU]H]]DVDG\F\ZLOL]RZDQHMZ\PLDQ\]GDĕGR]ZRORQ\FKZ:LNLSHGLL QD]ZNRQWDXī\WNRZQLNDWHJRMDNQDOHī\WUDNWRZDýXī\WNRZQLNyZ NRU]\VWDMĆF\FK]RWZDUW\FKVHUZHUyZSRğUHGQLF]ĆF\FKRSHQSUR[\ GR QSWHJRMDNREVâXJLZDýERW\SURJUDP\NWyU\FK]DGDQLHPMHVWZ\ NRQ\ZDQLHSURVW\FKDXWRPDW\F]Q\FKHG\FML &KFĆFXPLHğFLýFDâRğý ]DVDGZRGSRZLHGQLHMSHUVSHNW\ZLHQDOHī\VWZLHUG]LýīHZSDĩG]LHU QLNXURNXOLF]EDVâyZZNWyU\FK]DZDUWRRÀFMDOQH]DVDG\DQJLHO VNLHM:LNLSHGLLE\âDEOLVNDW\VLĆFRPFRMHVWOLF]EĆRZLċNV]Ć QLīREMċWRğýQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīNL 2ÀFMDOQH]DVDG\:LNLSHGLLWRMHG\QLHF]XEHNJyU\ORGRZHM0LPR ]DGHNODURZDQHMQLHFKċFLGRÅZLNLSUDZQLF]HQLDµZLNLSHG\ğFLWZRU]Ć MDVNUDZĆLURVQĆFĆNXOWXUċLQWHUSUHWDFML]DVDGZ\UDīDMĆFMĆZ]DOHFH QLDFKF]ċVWRWZRU]RQ\FKSU]\NRQVHQVXVLHVSRâHF]QRğFL LHVHMDFK ]D]Z\F]DMEċGĆF\FKZ\âĆF]QLHSU]HP\ğOHQLDPLSRMHG\QF]HJRZLNL SHG\VW\OHF]UyZQLHF]ċVWRSRZVWDMĆF\FKMDNRVNRPSOLNRZDQHWHNVW\ WZRU]RQHSU]H]V]HUV]ĆJUXSċ $NWXDOQLH]DOHFHQLDLHVHMHDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLGRW\F]ĆFHRGSRZLHGQLHJR]DFKRZDQLDVLċWRSRQDG GRNXPHQWyZ']LHZLċý]DOHFHĕGRW\F]ĆF\FKZVSyâSUDF\]LQQ\PL HG\WRUDPL]DMPXMHW\VLċF\VâyZDNROHMQ\FKGRNXPHQWyZSR ğZLċFRQ\FKRGSRZLHGQLHPX]DFKRZDQLXVLċWRNROHMQHW\VLċF\VâyZ

149

150

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ,VWQLHMĆZ\W\F]QHRSLVXMĆFHV]F]HJyâRZRHQF\NORSHG\F]QRğýZRNUHğOR Q\FKG]LHG]LQDFK]DVDG\UR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLHNRQÁLNWyZPHGLDFMċSURğE\ RNRPHQWDU]EORNRZDQLHF]\DUELWUDī²DVWDQRZLWRMHG\QLHZ\FLQHN RJyâXUHJXODFMLī\FLDZSURMHNFLH/LF]EDHVHMyZ]DZLHUDMĆF\FKNRPHQ WDU]HQDWHPDW]DVDGL]DOHFHĕGREUHUDG\RUD]DQDOL]\VSRâHF]QH SU]HNUDF]D7UXGQRMHVWFKRýE\ZSU]\EOLīHQLXRV]DFRZDýREMċWRğý WHNVWXZV]\VWNLFKHVHMyZLZ\W\F]Q\FKDOHQDSHZQRMHVWRQDZ\UDīDQD ZPLOLRQDFKVâyZ 3U]HF]\WDQLHZV]\VWNLFKZ\W\F]Q\FKQDZHWJG\E\QRZ\Xī\WNRZ QLNFKFLDâVLċ]DSR]QDýZ\âĆF]QLH]NOXF]RZ\PLGRNXPHQWDPLLWRQLH ZF]\WXMĆFVLċZV]F]HJyâ\D]DSR]QDMĆFVLċ]QLPLGODRJyOQHJR]UR]X PLHQLDMHVWNRPSOHWQLHQLHZ\NRQDOQH

PRZYCZYNY BIUROKRATYZACJI -HGQD]SU]\F]\QURVQĆFHMOLF]E\UHJXODFMLLLFKLQWHUSUHWDFMLMHVWRF]\ ZLVWDZPLDUċUR]ZLMDQLDVLċHQF\NORSHGLLLZ]URVWXMHMMDNRğFLSR WU]HEQ\FKMHVWZLċFHM]DVDGNRRUG\QXMĆF\FKSU]HSâ\ZG]LDâDĕLNRQ WUROXMĆF\FKLFKUH]XOWDW\6WYLOLDLLQ LSRWU]HEDRUJDQL]DF\MQHM UXW\Q\.U]\ZRU]HND &RZLċFHMZHZ]URğFLHNDīGHMRUJDQL]DFMLZUD]]HZ]URVWHPOLF]E\ XF]HVWQLNyZLGRâĆF]DQLHPGR]DâRī\FLHOLHQWX]MDVWyZRVyEğFLğOHM SU]\]Z\F]DMRQ\FKGR]DVDGLVW\OyZ]DU]ĆG]DQLDZâDğFLZ\FKGODF]ċ ğFLHMVSRW\NDQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMLSRMDZLDVLċWHQGHQFMDGRELXURNUDW\]DFML RWRF]HQLD*UHLQHU 1LH]Z\NOHWUXGQRMHVWMĆVWâXPLýQDZHW ZRUJDQL]DFMDFKğZLDGRPLHGĆīĆF\FKGRRJUDQLF]HQLDREFLĆīHQLDSUR FHGXUDPLLXWU]\P\ZDýLQQRZDF\MQ\GXFKZVSRâHF]QRğFLFRZLGDý QSZ0LFURVRIFLH$UWKXU 1DZHWÀUP\Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQHMDNR PRGHORZHSU]\NâDG\ÀOR]RÀLDQW\ELXURNUDW\F]QHMSRSDGDMĆZSLH NLHâNRSDSLHURORJLL*LUDUG 2SXV]F]HQLHSU]H]:LNLSHGLċID]\ SRF]ĆWNRZHMMHVWZW\PXMċFLXR]QDNĆMHMGRMU]DâRğFLLZ]URVWXQDZHW MHğOLQRUPDOL]DFMDSR]EDZLDMĆHOHPHQWXRU\JLQDOQRğFL,VWQLHMĆMHGQDN LQQHSU]\F]\Q\GODNWyU\FKGRğZLDGF]HQLD:LNLSHGLLSRGOHJDNRQWUROL ELXURNUDW\F]QHM :W\SRZ\PNRQWHNğFLHRUJDQL]DF\MQ\PNRQWURODELXURNUDW\F]QD RGJU\ZDVZRMĆUROċZXVWDQDZLDQLXKLHUDUFKLLLSRGVWDZQDG]RUX PHQHGīHUVNLHJR%UDYHUPDQ LQLHMHVWSR]EDZLRQDSR]\W\ZyZ

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY 'X*D\-HPLHOQLDN :ğZLHFLHZVSyâF]HVQ\PV]F]HJyOQLH ZğURGRZLVNDFKRSDUW\FKQDZLHG]\WHJRW\SXNRQWURODSR]ZDODQDWZR U]HQLHSâ\QQ\FKUDPG]LDâDQLD/HZLQL6WHSKHQV DMHMDVSHNW VWUXNWXUDOQ\]DQLNDFKRýNRQWURODQDGDOMHVWHJ]HNZRZDQD&REELLQ 1RJDOVNLL'DGHM 7DNZâDğQLHMHVWZ:LNLSHGLL]XZDJL QDMHMDQW\KLHUDUFKLF]Q\]GHNODURZDQLHHJDOLWDUQ\LGRSHZQHJRVWRS QLDÅDQW\RUJDQL]DF\MQ\µFKDUDNWHUMDNWHī]HZ]JOċGXQDSU]HMğFLRZĆ LFKDRW\F]QĆQDWXUċLQWHUDNFMLLUyOZ,QWHUQHFLHVSRâHF]QRğýMHV]F]H VLOQLHMSROHJDQDNRQWUROLRUJDQL]DF\MQHMZUR]XPLHQLXZ]DMHPQHM NRQWUROLHG\WRUyZ]DFKRZ\ZDQLDNDīGHJRG]LDâDQLDLVâRZDF]\ELX URNUDW\F]Q\FKSU]HSLVyZL]DVDG =DPLDVWRGZRâ\ZDýVLċGR]GDQLDRVyE XZâDG]\ZLNLSHG\ğFLSU]\ZRâXMĆ]DVDG\]MDZLVNRWREċG]LHSU]HG PLRWHPRSLVXNROHMQHJRUR]G]LDâXSRğZLċFRQHJR]DXIDQLXLNRQWUROL UHIHUHQFML-HGQDU]HF]MHVWMHGQDNMDVQDSR]RUQDVZRERGDLSR]EDZLH QLH:LNLSHGLL]DVDGMHVWPU]RQNĆ%XWOHULLQ :LNLSHGLDMHVW 1LHGHUHULYDQ'LMFN VWRSQLRZRHZROXXMĆF\PV\VWHPHPVRFMRWHFKQLF]Q\PNWyU\GR NâDGQLHXVWDZLDZV]\VWNLFKHG\WRUyZOXG]LRUD]DXWRPDW\ ZSURZD G]DMĆFKLHUDUFKLċ]DU]ĆG]DMĆFĆSURWRNRâ\L]DXWRPDW\]RZDQHV\VWHP\ HG\WRZDQLD

3URFHGXU\SRGREQLHMDNG]LDâDQLDOXG]LLERWyZHG\WXMĆF\FK:LNL SHGLċGHWHUPLQXMĆMHMUR]ZyMZFRQDMPQLHMWDNLPVDP\PVWRSQLX MDNWZRU]ĆSRWċīQHPHFKDQL]P\REURQQHSRZVWU]\PXMĆFHMHGQDNīH UHWHQFMċQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZ*HLJHULLQ -HVWMDVQHīHELXURNUDW\F]QHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHğURGNyZWHFKQLF]Q\FK VNXWNXMHZGXī\PVWRSQLXNRQWURORZDQLHP]DFKRZDĕXī\WNRZQLNyZ LZ\FKZ\W\ZDQLHPQLHSUDZLGâRZRğFL'ODSU]\NâDGXZSURZDG]HQLH SyâDXWRPDW\F]Q\FKQDU]ċG]LSU]HFLZG]LDâDMĆF\FKZDQGDOL]PRPF]ċVWR VNXWNXMHRGU]XFHQLHPHG\FMLGRNRQDQ\FKZGREUHMZLHU]HJG\īHG\WR URZLâDWZLHMMHVWRGU]XFLýEâċGQĆHG\FMċQLīSRSUDZLýMĆLV]F]HJyâRZR Z\MDğQLýSRWU]HEċSUDZLGâRZHJRHG\WRZDQLD1RZLHG\WRU]\WUDÀDMĆ PLċG]\PâRWDNRZDGâRPLċG]\UHJXODF\MQH]DFKRZDQLDLQQ\FKDSR VWU]HJDQLHQRZRSU]\E\â\FKMDNRZDQGDOLQDZHWMHğOLSRSURVWXQLH SRMPXMĆ]DVDGLVWDQGDUGyZRERZLĆ]XMĆF\FKZ:LNLSHGLL-HGQ\P ]UR]ZLĆ]DĕMDNVXJHUXMĆDNWXDOQLHSURZDG]RQHEDGDQLDPRJâRE\ E\ýZSURZDG]HQLHUR]ZLĆ]DĕWHFKQLF]Q\FKLDOJRU\WPyZSU]\JRWRZD Q\FKQDW\OHGRNâDGQLHE\E\â\ZVWDQLHUR]SR]QDýHG\FMHGRNRQ\ZDQH

151

152

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ZGREUHMZLHU]HFRSR]ZROLâRE\RGZUyFLýQLH]GURZHWHQGHQFMHWUDFHQLD HG\WRUyZ+DOIDNHULLQ 2VâDELâRE\WRMHGQDNZDUVWZ\ZHZQċWU] QHJRSRU]ĆGNXLHJ]HNZRZDQLDVWDWXVXMDNWHīSR]EDZLâRE\VSRâHF] QRğý:LNLSHGLLZLHOXÅâDWZ\FK]GRE\F]\µGODOLF]QLNDHG\FMLMDNQD SU]\NâDGPRīOLZRğFLFRIDQLDMHGQ\PNOLNQLċFLHPHG\FMLQLHZSHâQL WU]\PDMĆF\FKVLċVWDQGDUGyZSURMHNWX %H]ZĆWSLHQLDSRVWċSXMĆFDELXURNUDW\]DFMDVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLL F]ċğFLRZRVâXī\QDZHWEH]ZLHGQLHFHORZLSRGZ\īV]HQLDEDULHU\ZHMğFLD GODQRZ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZDOERUDF]HMXâDWZLHQLXUR]SR]QDQLDVWDWXVX LSR]\FMLVSRâHF]QHM3U]\EUDNXWUDG\F\MQHMKLHUDUFKLLMDNWHīZREOLF]X VSURZDG]HQLDGRQLH]EċGQHJRPLQLPXPLVWRWQRğFLTXDVLKLHUDUFKLF] Q\FKRÀFMDOQ\FKUyORSLVDQ\FKZSRSU]HGQLPUR]G]LDOHOLF]ED]DVDG SR]ZDODZVSRVyEâDWZ\QDVWUDW\ÀNDFMċZLNLSHG\VWyZĪHOD]QHSUDZR ROLJDUFKLLPyZLīHZZLċNV]RğFLRUJDQL]DFMLGRFKRG]LGRZ\NV]WDâFHQLD VLċROLJDUFKLLNWyUHZNRĕFXSU]HMPXMĆNRQWUROċQDGRUJDQL]DFMĆ:LNL SHGLDQLHMHVWWXZ\MĆWNLHP.RQLHF]Q\D 3RND]\XPLHMċWQRğFLWHFKQLF]Q\FKL]QDMRPRğFL]DVDGZLNLVNâDGQL DWDNīHSU]\MPRZDQLHZ\UD]yZZG]LċF]QRğFLRGLQQ\FKQDSU]\NâDG RSLVDQ\FKZSLHUZV]\PUR]G]LDOHRG]QDF]Hĕ:LNLSHGLL RGJU\ZDMĆ ]QDF]ĆFĆUROċZHJ]HNZRZDQLXSR]\FMLVSRâHF]QHMQDUyZQL]H]UR]X PLHQLHP]DVDG:LNLSHGLLLSU]\ZRâ\ZDQLHPLFKZG\VNXVMDFKÅ6WURQ\ G\VNXVMLVSHâQLDMĆUyZQLHīIXQNFMċG\VF\SOLQRZDQLDQRZ\FKXī\WNRZ QLNyZOXEZLNLSHG\VWyZRUHZROXF\MQ\FK]DSċGDFK:âDğQLHZW\FK]D NDPDUNDFK:LNLSHGLLRGVLHZDVLċ]LDUQRRGSOHZµ7NDF] 2SLVKDNHUyZDXWRUVWZD(*DEULHOOL&ROHPDQPRīQDUyZQLHGR EU]HRGQLHğýGRZLNLSHG\VWyZ&ROHPDQ 3RGREQLHMDNF]HODGQLF\ZJLOGLLXF]\OLVLċLNRSLRZDOLWHFKQLNLVWRVRZDQH ZLFKIDFKXWDNVDPRKDNHU]\ZFKRG]ĆZğZLDWXVWDQGDU\]RZDQ\FK NRQZHQFMLLSUHIHUHQFMLRUD]QLHSRZWDU]DOQHMRUJDQL]DFMLVSRâHF]QHM SU]\VWċSXMĆFGRSURMHNWXRWZDUWHJRRSURJUDPRZDQLD

1RZRSU]\E\OLPXV]ĆXGRZRGQLýVZRMĆSU]\GDWQRğýGODSURMHNWX DOHUyZQLHīZWRNXSHZQHJRF]HODGQLFWZDSRND]DýīHSR]QDOL]Z\F]DMH U\WXDâ\L]DVDG\RERZLĆ]XMĆFHZVSRâHF]QRğFL1LHSRVLDGDMĆF\NRQW Xī\WNRZQLF\DQRQLPRZLRGSRZLDGDMĆQDZHW]DMHGQĆF]ZDUWĆWUHğFL DOHZVSyâWZRU]ĆW\ONRGZXG]LHVWĆF]ċğý]DVDGFRVDPRZVRELHPRīH E\ýMXīýZLF]HQLHPÅSROLW\F]Q\Pµ$DOWRQHQL/DQ]DUD :LċN V]Rğý]DVDGSRZVWDâDMXīSU]HGURNLHPFRFLHNDZHMDNMXī

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY ZVSRPQLDQRZF]HğQLHMMHVWWRURNZNWyU\PRGQRWRZDQRVSDGHN ZVSyâF]\QQLND]DWU]\P\ZDQLDZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLHG\WRUyZRUD] PQLHMV]H]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHSU]\VWĆSLHQLHPGRSURFHGXU\QDGDQLD XSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUD ZLċFGODQRZ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZVĆRQH ZLHONĆPDVĆREMDZLRQ\FKQRUP3URFHVWZRU]HQLDLPRG\ÀNRZDQLD Z\W\F]Q\FKGRW\F]ĆF\FK]DFKRZDQLD]QDF]QLHVSRZROQLâRGWHJRF]DVX )RUWHLLQ 6WDWXVTXRZVSRVyERF]\ZLVW\QDUXV]DWU]HFLĆ]DVDGċ 2VWURPPyZLĆFĆRVWDELOQ\P]DU]ĆG]DQLXZVSyOQ\PLGREUDPL2VWURP FRZ\PDJDÅZVSyOQ\FKXVWDOHĕSR]ZDODMĆF\FKW\PNWyU]\ SU]\]QDMĆ]DVRE\XF]HVWQLF]\ýZSURFHVLHSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLµ6\ WXDFMDWDMHVWV]F]HJyOQLHQLHNRU]\VWQDGODQRZRSU]\E\â\FKJG\īVĆ RQLQDMEDUG]LHMSRGDWQLQDUHJXODFMċXZDīDMĆMĆ]DRZLHOHVWDELOQLHM V]ĆQLīF]\QLĆWRZHWHUDQLSURMHNWXVĆWHīSR]EDZLHQLPRīOLZRğFL ZSâ\QLċFLD]QDF]ĆFRQD]DVWDQH]DVDG\+DOIDNHULLQ DGRWHJR SRVWU]HJDMĆELXURNUDW\F]QĆQDWXUċUHJXORZDQLDG]LDâDĕZ:LNLSHGLL MDNRSUREOHPÅQLZHF]ĆF\DQDUFKLF]QHLGHHµVSRâHF]QRğFL0XOOHU 6HLW]L5HJHU $QGUHZ/LK]DXZDī\âFRQDVWċSXMH :UD]]ZROQĆPHWDPRUIR]Ć]DVDGZIRUPċEDUG]LHMUHVWU\NF\MQĆRUD] SRMDZLDQLHPVLċZ\]ZDĕSRGSRVWDFLĆNRQLHF]QRğFLHG\WRZDQLDFRUD] EDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQ\FKVWURQRUD]SURVWĆHVNDODFMĆOLF]E\XF]HVWQLNyZ RGVHWHNGRPLOLRQyZVSRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLLPRīHSU]\SRPLQDýīDEċ SRZROLXV\FKDMĆFĆQDSROHFHQLHGRNWRUD²QLHğZLDGRPĆQDGFKRG]ĆFHJR NU\]\VXJG\īQLHSRVWU]HJDRQDMDNEDUG]R]PLHQLâRVLċMHMRWRF]HQLH

'RğZLDGF]HQLXī\WNRZQLF\F]ċVWRZG\VNXVMDFKSRVâXJXMĆVLċWD MHPQ\PLVNUyWRZFDPLLīDUJRQHP6IRUPXâRZDQLDWDNLHMDNÅâDPLH ]DVDGċ:(5µÅZLHV]DN²XVXQĆýµÅQLHHQF\µF]\ÅHN²13$µVĆ V]\ENRUR]SR]QDZDQHSU]H]GRğZLDGF]RQ\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZOHF]PDMĆ ]GHF\GRZDQLHRQLHğPLHODMĆF\ZSâ\ZQDQRZRSU]\E\â\FKZSURZDG]D MĆFSDUDKLHUDUFKLF]Q\SRU]ĆGHN]DSRGVWDZċSU]\MPXMĆF\]QDMRPRğý ]DVDG:LNLSHGLL-DNZVND]XMH0DWKLHX2·1HLOÅPHWRG\GRPLQDFML QLHVĆRJUDQLF]RQHGRSURVWHJRZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQLDQDU]ċG]LGREORNR ZDQLD7DNLHPHWRG\VĆZUċF]PQLHMHIHNW\ZQHRGPHWRGVXEWHOQ\FK

1DOHī\WXMHGQDN]D]QDF]\ýīH]DVDG\2VWURPRGQRVLâ\VLċGRRZLHOHPQLHM V]\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLZLċFPRīQD]DâRī\ýīH:LNLSHGLDMHVWSLRQLHUHPZRGQLHVLH QLXVLċGRZLHOXSUREOHPyZVNDOLRUJDQL]DFMLVSRâHF]QHMMDNWHīīHQLHZV]\VWNLH ]DVDG\ZâDğFLZHGODVSRâHF]QRğFLRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\GDG]ĆVLċGRQLHM]DVWRVRZDý

153

154

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SROHJDMĆF\FKQDHNVSHUFNLHM]QDMRPRğFLSURMHNWXµ2·1HLOE 1DZHWMHğOLVSHF\ÀF]Q\īDUJRQF]ċVWRZFKRG]LZQDZ\NHG\WRUyZ NWyU]\QLHRSXV]F]DMĆSURMHNWX%HVFKDVWQLNKLLQ PRīHWR VWDQRZLýRW\PīHUR]SR]QDMĆRQLQRUP\VSRâHF]QHLLVWRWQRğýVWRVR ZDQLDVSHF\ÀF]QHJRMċ]\NDSURMHNWXOHF]QLHNRQLHF]QLHSR]ZDOD VWZLHUG]LýMDNVLOQLHSURFHGXUDOL]DFMDRGVWUDV]DW\FKNWyU]\SRNUyWNLHM SU]\JRG]LH]HG\WRZDQLHPRSXV]F]DMĆV]HUHJLZLNLSHG\VWyZ6NXWNLHP SRZ\īV]HJRSU]\QDMPQLHMGRSHZQHJRVWRSQLD+DOIDNHULLQ :LNLSHGLDGRNRQDâD]PLDQ\RGE\FLDÅHQF\NORSHGLĆNWyUĆNDīG\PRīH HG\WRZDýµGRÅHQF\NORSHGLLNWyUĆHG\WRZDýPRīHNDīG\NWRUR]XPLH MHMQRUP\ZQLNDZMHMVSRâHF]QRğýVNXWHF]QLHXQLNDEH]RVRERZHM ğFLDQ\SyâDXWRPDW\F]QHJRRGU]XFDQLDZNâDGXDPLPRWHJRQDGDOFKFH GREURZROQLHSRğZLċFDýMHMF]DVLHQHUJLċµ

&RZLċFHMSRNU\ZDQLHVLċ]DVDGLLFKQDGPLDUSR]ZDODMĆQDHOD VW\F]QLHMV]HRVLĆJDQLH]DPLHU]RQ\FKHIHNWyZ,VWQLHMHZLHOH]DVDG L]DOHFHĕZLċFâDWZRğýSRUXV]DQLDVLċZLFKJĆV]F]XGDMHZLNLSHG\MQ\P ZHWHUDQRPGRGDWNRZHPRīOLZRğFL7DUR]PDLWRğýZVSLHUDMHGQDN UyZQLHīSURFHVXVWDODQLDNRQVHQVXVXJG\īSRGREQLHGRWDOPXG\F] Q\FKLQWHUSUHWDFML Z]DOHZLH]DVDGSURFHVG\VNXWRZDQLDQDGLFK ]DVWRVRZDQLHPVWDMHVLċLVWRWQLHMV]\QLīLFKGRVâRZQH]QDF]HQLH-DN ]DXZDī\OL.ULSOHDQLLQ 8ī\WNRZQLF\PRJĆUyīQLHLQWHUSUHWRZDýGDQĆV\WXDFMċLSU]\ZRâ\ZDý UyīQH]DVDG\E\SRSU]HýVZyMSXQNWZLG]HQLD'RNâDGQD]DVDGDPRīH QDZHWQLHLVWQLHý:WDNLHMZLHOR]QDF]QRğFLGDVLċRGQDOHĩýZLHOHSU]\ NâDGyZRIHQV\ZNWyUHSRGHMPXMĆHG\WRU]\FKFĆFNRQWURORZDý]DZDUWRğý KDVHâLZSâ\ZDýQDLQQ\FKZSURFHVLHXVWDODQLDNRQVHQVXVX5yZQROHJOH ZLHOR]QDF]QRğýVDPHJRSURFHVXXVWDODQLDNRQVHQVXVXLMHJRZVSyOQ\ Mċ]\NRUD]ğURGRZLVNR]DVDGVĆF]\QQLNDPLVSDMDMĆF\PLVSRâHF]QRğý

1DJURPDG]HQLH]DVDGLUHJXâZ\Z\īV]DSR]\FMċRUJDQL]DF\MQĆ DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSURMHNWXJG\īGHIDFWRVWDMĆVLċRQLLFKLQWHUSUHWD WRUDPLLMDN]DXZDīDZVZRMHMQRZDWRUVNLHMDQDOL]LHDQWURSRORJLF]QHM SOHPLRQZLUWXDOQ\FK0DWKLHX2·1HLOÅVċG]LDPLâDZQLNDPLLNDWDPLµ 2·1HLO :W\PğZLHWOHWRīH]DVDG\VĆZ]JOċGQLHU]DGNRSU]\ ZRâ\ZDQHZG\VNXVMDFKQDG]DZDUWRğFLĆKDVHâPRīHQLHZ\GDZDýVLċ ]DVNDNXMĆFH*ROGVSLQN LFKFHOHPQLHMHVWQRUPDOL]RZDQLH

WIELKI BRAT PATRZY WUHğFLJG\īPDMĆRQHUyZQLHīIXQNFMċV\PEROLF]QĆSR]ZDODMĆFQD VWUDW\ÀNDFMċZLNLSHG\VWyZZ]DOHīQRğFLRGLFKELHJâRğFLZ]DVDGDFK :LNLSHGLL6DPRLVWQLHQLH]DVDG]ZLċNV]DWHīQLHUyZQRğýPLċG]\ ZHWHUDQDPLDQRZLFMXV]DPL 6SRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLLFKDUDNWHU\]XMHVLċF]\PğFR2VWURPQD]ZDâD UDG\NDOQĆDXWRQRPLĆ JG\īG]LDâDRQDSU]\PLQLPXP]DVDG ]HZQċWU]Q\FK]DğZHZQċWU]QDNRQWUROD]DFKRZDĕXī\WNRZQLNyZ MHVWZ\MĆWNRZRğFLVâD']LDâDRQDWHīQD]DVDG]LHNWyUĆ%RVVHZLWFKL6LQ QUHLFK RNUHğODMĆÅ]PLHQQ\PVWDQHPLQIRUPDFMLµMHVWWRQLH XVWDQQ\3DQRSW\NRQZNWyU\PNDīG\REVHUZXMHNDīGHJRSRâĆF]RQ\ ]ÅNRĕFHP]DSRPLQDQLDµF]\OLHSRNĆ]DSLV\ZDQLDLSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLD ZV]\VWNLHJRFRVLċGD:V]\VWNLHLQWHUDNFMHSURZDG]LVLċ]]DâRīHQLHP īHPRJĆE\ýLEċGĆ NRQWURORZDQHSU]H]RJyâZVSyâHG\WRUyZF]\OL ZVSRVyERGPLHQQ\RG]Z\F]DMQ\FKUR]PyZ/DQLDGRLLQ ,Q WHUIHMV:LNLSHGLLUyZQLHīVWDQRZL]DFKċWċGRREVHUZDFMċ]DFKRZDĕ SR]RVWDâ\FKXF]HVWQLNyZSURMHNWX%U\DQWLLQ -DNZ\UD]Lâ VLċ]QDQ\NU\W\N:LNLSHGLL)LQNHOVWHLQ :DīQHMHVWE\SDPLċWDýīH]DPLDVWRSLHZDQHJRTXDVLPLVW\F]QHJR ZVSyOQHJRSU]HGVLċZ]LċFLDNWyUH]HVâRP\SU]ċG]LH]âRWRWDNQDSUDZGċ MHVWWRPDUQLH]RUJDQL]RZDQDELXURNUDFMD]G\QDPLNĆJUXSRZĆZâDğ FLZĆGODVHNW\

)DNWīH:LNLSHGLDPLPRHJDOLWDUQHJR]RULHQWRZDQHJRQDZROQRğý LDKLHUDUFKLF]QHJRSRGHMğFLDZ\NRU]\VWXMHğFLVâHPHFKDQL]P\NRQWUROL ELXURNUDW\F]QHMSU]H]ğOHG]HQLHNDīGHJR]DSLVXLG]LDâDQLDXī\WNRZ QLNyZRUD]V]DOHĕF]HLORğFLQLHXVWDQQLHUR]V]HU]DMĆF\FKVLċ]DVDG QLH SRZLQLHQE\ý]DVNRF]HQLHP.ROHNW\ZL]PPRīQDF]DVDPLSRVWU]HJDý MDNRDOWHUQDW\ZċELXURNUDW\]DFML5RWKVFKLOG:KLWW DVSRâHF] QRğFLRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXXF]HVWQLFWZDF]ċVWRV]F]\FĆVLċXQLNDQLHP SRSDGDQLDZâDğQLHZWDNLWU\EG]LDâDQLD)XJJHWWD OHF]ZSUDN W\FHQDGDOPRJĆNRU]\VWDý]MHGQHM]ZâDğFLZ\FKGODĕIRUP'H/DDW +ROFNL-¡UJHQVHQ ,VWQLHMHMHGQDNREV]DUZNWyU\PNRQWURODZ:LNLSHGLLMHVWQD]DVND NXMĆFRQLVNLPSR]LRPLH²MHVWQLPNRQWURODIDNW\F]Q\FKWRīVDPRğFL LUHIHUHQFML=MDZLVNRWRMHVW]ZLĆ]DQH]HVSRVREHP]DPLDQ\]DXIDQLD LQWHUSHUVRQDOQHJRLRUJDQL]DF\MQHJRZ:LNLSHGLLDWDNīHNRQWUROL IDNW\F]Q\FKUHIHUHQFMLQDU]HF]]DXIDQLDZSURFHGXU\ELXURNUDW\F]QH 6WDQRZLWRSU]HGPLRWUR]ZDīDĕNROHMQHJRUR]G]LDâXNVLĆīNL

155

NIE UFAJ NIKOMU: PRAWDA JEST... GDZIEŚ TAM

3RSU]HGQLUR]G]LDâSRğZLċFRQ\E\âV]HURNLHPX]DNUHVRZLNRQWUROLRU JDQL]DF\MQHMNWyUHMGRğZLDGF]DMĆZLNLSHG\ğFLMDNWHī3DQRSW\NRQRZL Z]DMHPQHJRQDG]RUXREHFQHPXQDNDīG\PHWDSLHSUDFZ:LNLSHGLL %DGDQLDNRQWUROLRUJDQL]DF\MQHMQDOHī\VNRQWUDVWRZDý]MHV]F]H LQQ\PQLHW\SRZ\P]MDZLVNLHPWHMVSRâHF]QRğFLRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\ EXGRZDQLHP]DXIDQLDLQWHUSHUVRQDOQHJRLUHIHUHQFML-HVWWRZ\MĆW NRZRLVWRWQHJG\īPLPRLīZLNLSHG\ğFLWZRU]ĆVSRâHF]QRğýRğFLVâHM NRQWUROLZV]HONLFK]DFKRZDĕRVWURRGU]XFDMĆLGHċVSUDZG]DQLDUHIH UHQFMLMDNZ\NDīċZQLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDOH7DNLHSR]RUQLHVSU]HF]QH SRGHMğFLHMHVWVNXWNLHPVSRVREyZQDRJyOQHZ\UDīDQLH]DXIDQLDZVSR âHF]QRğFLMDNWHī]ZLĆ]NXRVRERZRğFLZLUWXDOQHMÅSHUVRQ\µ ]ÅSUDZ G]LZĆµWRīVDPRğFLĆSRUQSáXF]HZVNL =DXIDQLHMHVWWHPDWHPZVSyOQ\PGODEDGDĕRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FKQD V]F]HEOX]DUyZQRPLċG]\RUJDQL]DF\MQ\P1HZHOOL6ZDQ+RII PDQQLLQ MDNLZHZQĆWU]RUJDQL]DF\MQ\P*DPEHWWD 7KDXLLQ0F(YLO\ 5HZROXF\MQ\ZSâ\ZQRZ\FKWHFKQR ORJLLQD]DXIDQLHVWDâVLċMXīSU]HGPLRWHPZLHOXEDGDĕLGRP\VâyZQD XNRZ\FK(QJOLVK/XHFNLLQ/DWXVHNL-HPLHOQLDN/DWX VHNL*HUEDVL*UXG]HZVNLLLQ UyZQLHīZğURGRZLVNDFK

:RU\JLQDOHFUHGHQWLDOVF]\OLSRWZLHUG]RQHNRPSHWHQFMHNZDOLILNDFMHIRU PDOQH UHIHUHQFMH

158

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... RSHQVRXUFH&LHVLHOVNDL,VNRXMLQD RUD]ZQLHZLUWXDOQHMSUDF\ UR]SURV]RQHM2·/HDU\LLQ .ZHVWLD]DXIDQLDMHVWV]F]HJyOQLHLVWRWQDGODQRZ\FKVSRâHF]QRğFL RSDUW\FKQDZLHG]\RUD]ZâDğFLZ\FKGODQLFKğURGRZLVNZLUWXDOQ\FK NWyUHVWDZLDMĆRGPLHQQHRGGRW\FKF]DVRZ\FKZ\]ZDQLD]DUyZQRGOD ]DXIDQLDMDNLNRQWUROL.QLJKWVLLQ.RĩPLĕVNL.Rĩ PLĕVNL =RF]\ZLVW\FKZ]JOċGyZWHFKQLF]Q\FKL]SRZRGXEUDNX LQWHUDNFMLRVRELVW\FKHJ]HNZRZDQLHNRQWUROLWRīVDPRğFLNUHDFMD ]DXIDQLDLVSRVyEZHU\ÀNDFMLUHIHUHQFMLVĆ]QDF]QLHRGPLHQQHRG WUDG\F\MQ\FKğURGRZLVNRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FK2[OH\LLQ*UHHQL&DU SHQWHU 7HNZHVWLHVĆREV]DUHPV]F]HJyOQHJR]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDZğURGRZL VNDFKRSHQVRXUFHJG]LHXF]HVWQLFWZRZUXFKXMHVWGREURZROQH]DFKċW\ LNDU\VĆQLHZLHONLHF]âRQNRVWZRUR]SURV]RQHDWRīVDPRğFLMHG\QLH ZLUWXDOQHMDNRSLVDQRZSRSU]HGQLFKUR]G]LDâDFK =DVWDQDZLDMĆFH MHVWWHīWRīHEXGRZDQLH]DXIDQLDZ:LNLSHGLLZV]F]HJyOQRğFLZNRQ WHNğFLHVSUDZG]DQLDUHIHUHQFMLQLHE\âRWHPDWHPSRZDīQHMDQDOL]\ QDXNRZHM:QLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDOHRGQLRVċVLċGRWHMNZHVWLLJG\īMHVW RQDQLH]Z\NOHLVWRWQDGOD]UR]XPLHQLDMDNZLQWHUQHWRZHMVSRâHF]QRğFL ZLNLSHG\VWyZIXQNFMRQXMĆXSU]HGQLRSRUXV]RQHNZHVWLH]ZLĆ]NyZ ZâDG]\KLHUDUFKLLNRQWUROLL]DU]ĆG]DQLD$QDOL]D]DXIDQLDUyZQLHī SRVâXī\]DSXQNWZ\MğFLDGRNROHMQ\FKUR]ZDīDĕQDGSU]\ZyG]WZHP L]DU]ĆG]DQLHP:LNLSHGLĆ

ZAUFANIE A SPOŁECZNOŚCI OPEN SOURCE 5R]ZyMLVSRâHF]QDSURGXNFMDZLHG]\Z\PDJDMĆ]ZLĆ]NyZRSDUW\FKQD ZVSyâSUDF\ZHZQĆWU]RUJDQL]DFML=ZLĆ]NLWHMHGQDNWDPRZDQHVĆSU]H] GRPLQXMĆFH]DâRīHQLHīHOXG]LHQDMVLOQLHMPRW\ZRZDQLVĆSRWHQFMDO Q\PL]\VNDPLGODVDP\FKVLHELH1DKDSLHWLLQ LPRJĆQLH DQJDīRZDýVLċZG]LDâDQLDQLHSU]\QRV]ĆFHLPPDWHULDOQ\FK]\VNyZ QDGâXīV]ĆPHWċ=LGHQW\ÀNRZDQHMXīWU\E\ZVSyâSUDF\W\SRZHGOD VSRâHF]QRğFLRSHQVRXUFHMHGQDNXGRZDGQLDMĆQLHSUDZG]LZRğýWHJR ]DâRīHQLDJG\īZLHOXOXG]LZ\ND]XMHFKċýZVSyâSUDF\LSLVDQLDEH]]\ VNyZPDWHULDOQ\FKVĆQDZHWZVWDQLHZVSRVyEXGDQ\UR]ZLMDýSURGXNW\ LSRP\Vâ\NRQNXUXMĆFHQDUyZQHMVWRSLH]NRPHUF\MQ\PLRGSRZLHG QLNDPL%HQNOHUE 3U]\NâDG\WHJRW\SXXGDQ\FKSURMHNWyZ

NIE UFAJ NIKOMU: PRAWDA JEST... GDZIEŚ TAM SRMDZLâ\VLċZSRSU]HGQLFKUR]G]LDâDFK-DNMXī]D]QDF]RQR:LNLSHGLD ]QDF]QLHUyīQLVLċRGLQQ\FKGXī\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\ JG\īQDMHMVSRâHF]QRğýVNâDGDMĆVLċJâyZQLHQLHSURIHVMRQDOLğFLF]\OL MHVW]XSHâQLHRGPLHQQDRGSURMHNWyZ)/266WZRU]RQ\FKSU]H]]DZR GRZ\FKLQī\QLHUyZRSURJUDPRZDQLD2UJDQL]DFMHRSDUWHQDRWZDUWHM ZVSyâSUDF\Z\GDMĆVLċSRGĆīDý]DQDG]LHMĆRVLĆJQLċFLDZVSyOQHJRGREUD QDG]LHMĆNWyUĆZ\NRU]\VWXMHVLċMDNRPHWRGċDQLHW\ONRMDNRZLDUċ 0L\D]DNL 3U]HSURZDG]RQRMXīZLHOHEDGDĕZLDU\JRGQRğFLDUW\NXâyZ:LNL SHGLL'RQGLRLLQ.ZDQL5DPDFKDQGUDQ6XQGLQ OHF]PHFKDQL]PEXGRZDQLD]DXIDQLDLUHIHUHQFMLZVSRâHF]QRğFLHG\WR UyZ:LNLSHGLLU]DGNRJRğFLâZSRZDīQ\FKEDGDQLDFKQDXNRZ\FK.UXSD LLQ ,QQHEDGDQLDZVND]XMĆMHGQDNīHVSRâHF]QRğFLRQOLQHSR ]EDZLRQHLQWHUDNFMLPLċG]\LFKF]âRQNDPLSR]D,QWHUQHWHPFRZZLċN V]RğFLRGQRVLVLċGRZLNLSHG\VWyZ SRGFKRG]ĆGRNZHVWLL]DXIDQLD LQDF]HMQLīJUXS\F]âRQNyZNRQWDNWXMĆF\FKVLċÅQDī\ZRµ0DW]DW :]LĆZV]\SRGXZDJċEUDNWUDG\F\MQHMZHU\ÀNDFMLUHIHUHQFML :LNLSHGLDVWDMHVLċZ\MĆWNRZRFLHNDZ\PSU]HGPLRWHPEDGDĕQDG Z\UDīDQLHP]DXIDQLD&RZLċFHMMDNMXī]RVWDâRVWZLHUG]RQH:LNL SHGLDMHVWPRGHORZ\PSU]\NâDGHPRUJDQL]DFMLSROHJDMĆFHMQDHJDOLWD U\]PLH]SâDVNĆVWUXNWXUĆR]GHFHQWUDOL]RZDQHMZâDG]\ZWDNLPğUR GRZLVNX]DXIDQLHRGJU\ZD]NRQLHF]QRğFLLVWRWQĆUROċ-RQHVL*HRUJH 'H-RQJL(OIULQJ 3RSU]HGQLHUR]G]LDâ\RGQRVLâ\VLċGR NZHVWLLZ\UDīDQLDZâDG]\LVWDWXVXZVSRâHF]QRğFLMDNWHīNRQWUROLRUJD QL]DF\MQHM]UR]XPLHQLHMDNXWU]\PDQLHWDNLFKPHFKDQL]PyZMHVW PRīOLZHZWDNUR]SURV]RQHMRUJDQL]DFMLZLUWXDOQHMZ\PDJDEDUG]LHM V]F]HJyâRZHJRVSRMU]HQLDQDNZHVWLHUHIHUHQFMLL]DXIDQLD -RKQVRQDUJXPHQWXMHīHZHZVSyâF]HVQ\PVSRâHF]HĕVWZLHUHIHUHQ FMHVWDâ\VLċLVWRWQLHMV]HZEXGRZDQLX]DXIDQLDQLīWRīVDPRğýRUD]]D OHīQRğFL3RVWU]HJDEUDNXZLHU]\WHOQLRQ\FKGDQ\FKZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFK LQWHUQHWRZ\FKMDNRJâyZQ\F]\QQLNKDPXMĆF\VNXWHF]QHLUHJXODUQH G]LDâDQLDVSRâHF]QH-RKQVRQ 3RGREQLHMDN]DXZDīDMĆLQQL DXWRU]\EUDNSU]HMU]\VWRğFLZNZHVWLLXMDZQLDQLDWRīVDPRğFLHG\WRUyZ :LNLSHGLLUyZQLHīSR]ZDOD]DNZHVWLRQRZDýHIHNW\SUDF\HG\WRUyZF]\OL WUHğýKDVHâ:DWHUV 6DQWDQDL:RRGNU\W\NXMĆF:LNLSHGLċ F]\QLĆZUċF]PHORGUDPDW\F]Q\]DU]XW īHÅDQRQLPRZDSUR GXNFMDLZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQLHLQIRUPDFMLQLHSR]ZDODMĆOXG]LRPRVLĆJQĆý QDMJâċEV]\FK]QDF]Hĕī\FLDâDPLĆFGRWHJRHW\F]QH]DVDG\LQWHJUDO QRğFLLQIRUPDFML&RZLċFHMDQRQLPRZLWZyUF\QLHPXV]ĆZ\ND]\ZDý

159

160

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... PRUDOQHMRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğFLJG\īQLHPDPLHMVFDRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğý ]DF]\Q\µ6ĆG]ċīHWRVWZLHUG]HQLHQLHW\ONRMHVWEâċGQHELRUĆFSRG XZDJċSRSXODUQRğýLXGRZRGQLRQĆMDNRğý:LNLSHGLL OHF]UyZQLHī ğZLDGF]\RQLHZLHG]\DXWRUyZFRGR]DVDGIXQNFMRQRZDQLDSURMHNWX RUD]FRGRUHODFMLPLċG]\OXG]NLFK]ZLĆ]DQ\FK]SU]HND]\ZDQLHP ZLHG]\$XWRU]\MHGQDNSRGQRV]ĆLVWRWQĆNZHVWLċDPLDQRZLFLHīH TXDVLDQRQLPRZHVSRâHF]QRğFLLQWHUQHWRZHPXV]ĆZRGSRZLHGQLGOD VLHELHVSRVyERGQLHğýVLċGRNZHVWLLRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğFL]DG]LDâDQLD VZRLFKF]âRQNyZ-HVWZLċFQLH]Z\NOHLVWRWQHE\EDGDF]HRUJDQL]DFML SR]QDOLL]UR]XPLHOLDPRīHQDZHW]GHÀQLRZDOLPHFKDQL]P\]DXIDQLD LNRQWUROLUHIHUHQFMLZğURGRZLVNXQRZHMU]HF]\ZLVWRğFLF]ċVWRSR]ED ZLRQ\PW\SRZ\FKPRW\ZDWRUyZNDULKLHUDUFKLLOHF]SR]ZDODMĆF\P QDWZRU]HQLHQLH]Z\NOHSâ\QQ\FKFKRýQLHMDVQ\FKWRīVDPRğFL.ZHVWLD WDMHVWZDīQDJG\īSRSXODUQRğýSURMHNWyZRRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\ URğQLHVWDMĆFVLċVWRSQLRZR]QDF]Q\PVHJPHQWHPRJyOQHMRUJDQL]DFML ZVSyâSUDF\QDğZLHFLH1HXVL6FKHUI 6LOQHV\VWHP\NRQWUROLF]ċVWRSRVWU]HJDVLċV]F]HJyOQLHZğURGR ZLVNDFKLQWHUQHWRZ\FKMDNRUR]ZLĆ]DQLHSDOĆFHJRSUREOHPX]DXIDQLD &KHVKLUH ZHU\ÀNDFMDWRīVDPRğFLLUHIHUHQFMLVWDQRZLQLHMDNR NRQWUROċSURJRZĆSRPDJDMĆFĆZ\SHâQLýSyĩQLHMV]\EUDN]DXIDQLDLQ WHUSHUVRQDOQHJR-DNZ\NDīċZQLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDOHWDNLVFHQDULXV] QLHMHVWZâDğFLZ\GOD:LNLSHGLL1DZHWZREOLF]XWHJRīHMHMVSRâHF]QRğý SU]HV]âDSHZQHNU\]\V\]DXIDQLDQLH]GHF\GRZDâDRQDRZSURZDG]H QLXMDNLFKNROZLHNV\VWHPyZZHU\ÀNDFMLUHIHUHQFMLXF]HVWQLNyZSU]\ LFKSU]\VWĆSLHQLXGRSURMHNWX=DPLDVWWHJRMDNVLċZ\GDMHNRQWUROċ WRīVDPRğFLHG\WRUyZLLFK]GROQRğFLPHU\WRU\F]Q\FK]DPLHQLâDQD SU]HSLV\ELXURNUDW\F]QH,QQ\PLVâRZ\VSRâHF]QRğýRGU]XFLâDSRP\Vâ ]ZLċNV]DQLDNRQWUROLQDGHG\WRUDPLOXEVSUDZG]DQLDLFKUHIHUHQFML EĆGĩWHī]DXIDQLDXī\WNRZQLNRPQDU]HF]]DXIDQLDSU]HSLVRPLSUR FHVRPRUJDQL]DF\MQ\PZV]F]HJyOQRğFL²ZSU]\SDGNX:LNLSHGLL² PDMĆF\PSRVWDýZ\W\F]Q\FKFRGR]DFKRZDQLDHVHMyZ]DVDGLWHFKQLN RUD]QRUPUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZ .U\]\V]DXIDQLDLQWHUSHUVR QDOQHJR]RVWDâMDNZLGDýUR]ZLĆ]DQ\ğURGNDPLVLOQHJR]DXIDQLD ZVDPĆLQVW\WXFMċRUD]RUJDQL]DF\MQHğURGNLSDUDSUDZQHQDZHWMHğOL ZWUDG\F\MQ\FKQLHZLUWXDOQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMDFKNU\]\V\WDNLH]Z\NOH SRJâċELDMĆEUDN]DXIDQLDGRLQQ\FK6LWNLQL5RWK &HOHPQLQLHMV]HJRUR]G]LDâXMHVWZLċFDQDOL]DVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLL ZMHMSRGHMğFLXGR]DXIDQLDLUHIHUHQFMLSU]H]DQDOL]ċÅNURNSRNURNXµ

NIE UFAJ NIKOMU: PRAWDA JEST... GDZIEŚ TAM MHGQHJR]QDMZLċNV]\FKNU\]\VyZZG]LHG]LQLH]DXIDQLDLWRīVDPRğFL ZLUWXDOQHMZG]LHMDFK:LNLSHGLL²W]ZLQF\GHQWX(VVMD\D²RUD]GHEDW ZHZQċWU]Q\FKNWyUHWRF]\â\VLċSRVDP\PNU\]\VLH5R]G]LDâRSDUW\ MHVWQDDQDOL]LHSU]\SDGNXGRNWyUHMZâĆF]RQRZLHOHVWURQG\VNXVML LNRPHQWDU]\âĆF]QLHREHMPXMĆF\FKW\VLċF\VâyZWHNVWX 6NDQGDO]URNXZVWU]ĆVQĆâVSRâHF]QRğFLĆ:LNLSHGLLLE\âV]HURNR NRPHQWRZDQ\ZPHGLDFK²QDGPLHQLýZ\VWDUF]\īHZSLVDQLHZZ\ V]XNLZDUFH*RRJOHIUD]\Å(VVMD\FRQWURYHUV\µ]ZUDFDSUDZLHW\ VLċF\Z\QLNyZ6NDQGDOVNXWNRZDâFLĆJLHPGâXJLFKG\VNXVMLLGHEDW ZHZQċWU]Q\FKSRğZLċFRQ\FK]DXIDQLXGRHG\WRUyZLLFKZLDU\JRGQRğFL :\GDU]HQLHPLDâRPLHMVFHMXīGâXīV]\F]DVWHPXDVNDQGDO]RVWDâ ]DīHJQDQ\ZDUWRMHGQDNGRNRQDýLQWHUSUHWDFMLUHDNFMLLGHF\]MLVSRâHF] QRğFLJG\īXMDZQLDMĆRQHNLONDPHFKDQL]PyZVSRâHF]Q\FKLSRND]XMĆ NLONDSRGVWDZRZ\FK]DâRīHĕFRGRG]LDâDQLD:LNLSHGLL&DâDVSUDZD ]RVWDâDQDZHWZVSRPQLDQDZNLONXSXEOLNDFMDFKQDXNRZ\FK%UXQV /LK OHF]MDNGRWĆGQLHSRGGDQRMHMV]F]HJyâRZHMDQDOL]LH V]F]HJyOQLH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDWHRULLRUJDQL]DFMLL]DU]ĆG]DQLDFKRý PRJâRE\WRU]XFLýQRZHğZLDWâRQDHJ]HNZRZDQLH]DXIDQLDGRLQQ\FK RUD]]QDF]HQLDUHIHUHQFMLZNRQWHNğFLHVSRâHF]QRğFLLQWHUQHWRZ\FK

SPRAWA ESSJAYA 8ī\WNRZQLN(VVMD\]DF]ĆâHG\WRZDý:LNLSHGLċZURNX2GVDPHJR SRF]ĆWNXQDMHJRVWURQLHXī\WNRZQLNDZLGQLDâDLQIRUPDFMDīHMHVWRQ SURIHVRUHPUHOLJLR]QDZVWZD]GRNWRUDWHPZG]LHG]LQLHWHRORJLLRUD] SUDZDNDQRQLF]QHJRMDNWHīJDUğFLĆLQQ\FKW\WXâyZZSRNUHZQ\FK QDXNDFK-DNWZLHUG]LâZ\NâDGDâUHJXODUQLHWHRORJLċQDVWXGLDFKPD JLVWHUVNLFKRUD]SRG\SORPRZ\FKQDSU\ZDWQHMDPHU\NDĕVNLHMXF]HOQL :\ND]\ZDâGXīĆDNW\ZQRğýZKDVâDFKGRW\F]ĆF\FKUHOLJLLDZ]DOHGZLH SLċýPLHVLċF\]\VNDâVRELHSU]\FK\OQRğýVSRâHF]QRğFLZ\VWDUF]DMĆFĆ GR]GRE\FLDVWDWXVXDGPLQLVWUDWRUD]LPSRQXMĆF\PSRSDUFLHP JâRVXMĆF\FK 3RX]\VNDQLXIXQNFMLDGPLQLVWUDWRUD]ZLċNV]\âMHV]F]H VZRMĆDNW\ZQRğýZVSRâHF]QRğFL²E\âPHGLDWRUHPZVSRUDFK]ZDOF]Dâ ZDQGDOL]P\LSUDZLGâRZRZ\ZLĆ]\ZDâVLċ]SRZLQQRğFLDGPLQLVWUDWRUD -HJRVXNFHVGRSURZDG]LâGRSU]\]QDQLDPXIXQNFMLELXURNUDW\LFKHF NXVHUDF]âRQNDVSRâHF]QRğFLNWyU\]GRE\âZ\VWDUF]DMĆFH]DXIDQLHE\

161

162

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... PLHýGRVWċSGRZUDīOLZ\FKLQIRUPDFMLQDWHPDWDGUHVyZ,3Z\NRU]\ VW\ZDQ\FKSU]H]LQQ\FKHG\WRUyZ RUD]SU]HZRGQLF]ĆFHJR.RPLWHWX 0HGLDF\MQHJR %\âQDW\OHZ\GDMQ\PLRGGDQ\P:LNLSHGLLHG\WRUHPīHMDNRPR GHORZ\SU]\NâDGZVSyâSUDF\:LNLSHGLL]HğZLDWHPDNDGHPLFNLP]RVWDâ G]LċNLUHNRPHQGDFML:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQSRSURV]RQ\ZOLSFX SU]H]W\JRGQLNÅ7KH1HZ>:3%LRJUDILHRVyEī\MĆF\FK@@SR]ZDODMĆXQLNQĆýWDNGâXJLFKG\VNXVML

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? URG]DMXREXVLHF]QHRVWU]HLQIRUPDFMLEH]U]HWHOQ\FKĩUyGHâQLHZROQR SXEOLNRZDýDOHQLHZROQRWHīXVXZDýLQIRUPDFMLRSDWU]RQ\FKRGSR ZLHGQLPLSU]\SLVDPL 2E\GZDSU]\SDGNLXND]XMĆWHīEUDNEH]SRğUHGQLHMZâDG]\Z:LNL SHGLLQDZHWMHğOLPRZDRQDMEDUG]LHMSURPLQHQWQ\FKLXSU]\ZLOHMR ZDQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNDFK=LWWUDLQ -HVWWRĩUyGâRDWUDNF\MQRğFL :LNLSHGLLLMHMPRGHOXRUJDQL]DF\MQHJR²DOHUyZQLHīMHMVâDE\SXQNW FR]RVWDQLHSRND]DQHSyĩQLHM-HVWUyZQLHīZ\UDĩQLHZLGRF]QHīHQD ZHWQDMEDUG]LHMV]DQRZDQ\FKOXG]LQLHRERZLĆ]XMHZ:LNLSHGLLWDU\ID XOJRZD-HVWWRV]F]HJyOQLHLVWRWQHGOD]UR]XPLHQLD]PLDQUROL-LPER :DOHVDZUXFKX:LNLPHGLD

ZMIENIAJĄCA SIĘ ROLA WALESA 1DSRF]ĆWNXLVWQLHQLD:LNLSHGLLSR]\FMD-LPER:DOHVDE\âDQLHGR ]DNZHVWLRQRZDQLD1LH]DOHīQLHF]\E\âMHG\QLHÅZVSyâ]DâRī\FLHOHPµ :LNLSHGLLF]\QLHE\âRVWDWHF]Q\PDXWRU\WHWHPZHZV]\VWNLFKGHF\ ]MDFKZU]HğQLDRSXEOLNRZDâRğZLDGF]HQLHGRW\F]ĆFH]DVDG >>HQ8VHU-LPER:DOHV6WDWHPHQWRISULQFLSOHV@@GHNODUXMĆFPLċG]\ LQQ\PL 3RZLQLHQHPSRGNUHğOLýīHWRVĆPRMH]DVDG\LīHWRMDMHVWHPLFKRVWD WHF]Q\PVċG]LĆ1LHR]QDF]DWRīHQLHSRVâXFKDPJâRVXLQQ\FKOHF] R]QDF]DWRīHQDSHZQ\PSRGVWDZRZ\PSR]LRPLHWRZâDğQLHWDNEċG]LH G]LDâDý:LNLSHGLD.URSND1LHEyMFLHVLċMHGQDNSU]HF]\WDMFLHGDOHM 1RZLFMXV]\QDOHī\]DZV]HSRZLWDý::LNLSHGLLPDQLHE\ýVLWZHOLW KLHUDUFKLLLVWUXNWXUSU]HV]NDG]DMĆF\FKZRWZDUWRğFLQDQRZ\FKXī\W NRZQLNyZ:V]HONLHğURGNLEH]SLHF]HĕVWZDQDOHī\ZSURZDG]DýFHOHP RFKURQ\VSRâHF]QRğFLSU]HGSUDZG]LZ\PLZDQGDODPL²DIDNW\F]QLH LVWQLHMĆSUDZG]LZLZDQGDOHNWyU]\MXī]DF]\QDMĆZ\ZLHUDýQDQDVVZyM ZSâ\Z²QDSRGVWDZLHÅğFLVâHMREVHUZDFMLµ

:RZ\FKF]DVDFKJG\LVWQLDâW\ONRMHGHQZLRGĆF\SURMHNWW\SXZLNL FRNROZLHNSRZLHG]LDâ-LPERVWDZDâRVLċSUDZHP5]DGNRZ\NRU]\VW\ ZDâVZRMHSU]\ZLOHMH]Z\NOHSR]RVWDZLDMĆFZV]HONLHNZHVWLHNRQVHQ VXVRZLVSRâHF]QHPXOHF]NLHG\Z\UDīDâVZRMHGHF\]MHWRE\â\RQH RVWDWHF]QH2GSRF]ĆWNXG]LDâDOQRğFLSURMHNWXZ\UDīDâVZRMĆQLHFKċý

191

192

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... GRHOLWDUQRğFLKLHUDUFKLLLVWUXNWXUREDURNRZ\FKUR]PLDUDFKMDNR V]F]HJyOQLH]QLHFKċFDMĆF\FKQRZRSU]\E\â\FK=ZDOF]DâUyZQLHī]MD ZLVNRVLWZ²ZLċFHMQDWHPDWNOLNPRīQD]QDOHĩýZMHGQ\P]SRSU]HG QLFKUR]G]LDâyZSRğZLċFRQ\PIRUPDOQ\PURORPLKLHUDUFKLL :JUXGQLXSRZVWDâDUW\NXâQDWHPDWUXFKX:LNLPHGLDZNWy U\PQDSLVDQRīH-LPER:DOHVMHVWÅGREURWOLZ\PG\NWDWRUHPDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLµ&RFLHNDZH:DOHVVDPHG\WRZDâRZRKDVâRZHZU]HğQLX OHF]ZWHG\QLHXVXQĆâJRDQLQLH]PLHQLâGRGDMĆFMHG\QLHNUyWNL GRSLVHNÅ1DOHī\MHGQDNGRGDýīHVDP-LPERSROHPL]XMH]W\PRNUHğ OHQLHPµ.RPHQWDU]GRSURZDG]LâGR]DGDQLDS\WDQLDQDVWURQLHG\V NXVMLDUW\NXâXRWRGODF]HJR-LPERVSU]HFLZLDVLċWHPXRNUHğOHQLX :DOHVRGSRZLHG]LDâFLHNDZ\PDXWRUHÁHNV\MQ\PRSLVHPZâDVQHMUROL ZVSRâHF]QRğFL /HSLHMF]XMċVLċEċGĆFSRUyZQ\ZDQ\PGRPRQDUFK\EU\W\MVNLHJR²WR ]QDF]\PRMDZâDG]DSRZLQQDE\ýLIDNW\F]QLHMHVW RJUDQLF]RQDSR ZLQQDWHīZPLDUċXSâ\ZXF]DVXVâDEQĆý:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWDQDUFKLĆ FKRýPDSHZQHFHFK\DQDUFKLL1LHMHVWWHīGHPRNUDFMĆPLPRīHZ\ VWċSXMĆZQLHMFHFK\GHPRNUDFML1LHMHVWDU\VWRNUDFMĆFKRýWHīPDMHM SHZQHFHFK\:NRĕFXQLHMHVWPRQDUFKLĆPLPRSRVLDGDQLDSHZQ\FK FHFKPRQDUFKLL 'REU\PSU]\NâDGHPWHJRMDNPyJâE\PRGJU\ZDýSURGXNW\ZQĆ UROċSRSU]H]HJ]HNZRZDQLHZâDG]\MHVWKROHQGHUVND:LNLSHGLD0RMD URODZW\PSURMHNFLHRJUDQLF]DVLċJâyZQLHGRE\FLDGRUDGFĆSRPDJD MĆF\POXG]LRPVSRMU]HýQDV]HUV]\REUD]LFKG]LDâDĕLRGQDMG\ZDýQDMOHS V]HPHWRG\LQWHUDNFMLRUD]ZVSyâSUDFRZDQLDZGRNRQ\ZDQLXQDV]\FK MDNīHZDīQ\FKG]LDâDĕ -HVWWRMHGQDNUyZQLHīURODRÅNRQVW\WXF\MQHMµLVWRWQRğFLZ]QDF]H QLXZNWyU\PNDīG\XF]HVWQLNG\VNXVMLPRīHF]XýVLċNRPIRUWRZR ZLHG]ĆFīHSRGMċWHGHF\]MHEċGĆZLĆīĆFHīHMHVWZ\īV]\PHFKDQL]P LFKHJ]HNZRZDQLD0RMĆUROĆQLHMHVWQDU]XFHQLHUR]ZLĆ]DQLDDQLSU]H IRUVRZDQLHPRMHMGHF\]MLZVSRâHF]QRğFLOHF]F]ċğFLRZRMHVWQLĆJZD UDQFMDSU]H]RVRELVWĆRELHWQLFċīHZ\SUDFRZDQHZWRNXVHQVRZQHM G\VNXVMLUR]ZLĆ]DQLDEċGĆSU]H]NRJRğHJ]HNZRZDQH :\MĆWNRZRQLHZLHOHZW\FKG]LDâDQLDFKZ\PDJDIDNW\F]QHMZâDG]\ :\PDJDUDF]HMV]DFXQNXGRPQLHVDPHJRLGRRGJU\ZDQHMSU]H]HPQLH

KWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL%HQHYROHQWBGLFWDWRU

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? UROL6]DFXQHNWHQMHVWPRīOLZ\W\ONRZSU]\SDGNXSRGHMPRZDQLDSU]H]H PQLHUR]ZDīQ\FKG]LDâDĕ]JRGQ\FK]]DVDGDPLLXF]FLZ\FKZVWRVXQNX GRLQQ\FKMDNWHī]JRGQLH]V]HURNLPNRQVHQVXVHPVSRâHF]QRğFL =DXZDīFLHWHīLīVĆG]ċīHZâDG]ċSRZLQQRVLċ]PLHQLDýZPLDUċ XSâ\ZXF]DVXSRZRâXMĆFLQVW\WXFMHVSRâHF]QHWDNLHMDNQDSU]\NâDG .RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLGHF\]MHFDâHMVSRâHF]QRğFL ZZHUVMLQLHPLHFNLHM 0DP\QLHZLHOHSUREOHPyZSR]DRGL]RORZDQ\PLSU]\SDGNDPL ]ZLĆ]DQ\PL]QDGXī\FLDPLXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUVNLFKF]\VLWZDPL ²QDZHWZPQLHMV]\FKZHUVMDFKMċ]\NRZ\FKSRF]ċğFLGODWHJRīHZV]\VF\ VĆGRğýPRFQRğZLDGRPLīHSRGHMPċZV]HONLHG]LDâDQLDQLH]EċGQHGR ]DSHZQLHQLDSUDZLGâRZHJRIXQNFMRQRZDQLDZV]\VWNLFKREV]DUyZ:LNL SHGLLQDMOHSLHMMDNSRWUDÀċ 1LF]WHJRFRURELċQLHMHVWZâDğFLZHGODG]LDâDĕG\NWDWRUDRERMċWQLH F]\GREURWOLZHJRF]\QLH²-LPER:DOHVSDĩG]LHUQLND87&

:DOHVUR]SR]QDâNRQLHF]QRğýVWRSQLRZHJR]PQLHMV]DQLD]DNUHVX VZRMHMZâDG]\SU]HZLG]LDâSU]HMċFLHMHMSU]H]LQVW\WXFMHZ\âRQLRQH]JURQD Xī\WNRZQLNyZWDNLHMDN.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\DWDNīHVNRPHQWRZDâ ZâDVQĆUROċRVRE\QLHNRU]\VWDMĆFHM]ZâDG]\=DPLDVWE\ýXRVRELHQLHP ZâDG]\UR]ZLĆ]XMĆF\PVSRU\LSRGHMPXMĆF\PRVWDWHF]QHG]LDâDQLDZRODâ E\ýJZDUDQWHPNRQVHQVXVX :DOHVFRMHVWGRğýZLGRF]QHQLHXZDīDâE\XNXW\SU]H](ULFD65D\ PRQGD DSU]\QDMPQLHMSU]H]HĕVSRSXODU\]RZDQ\WHUPLQNWyU\ SRMDZLâVLċZGREU]HSU]\MċW\PHVHMXQDWHPDW]DU]ĆG]DQLDSURMHNWDPL RSURJUDPRZDQLDRSHQVRXUFHGDâVLċQDW\FKPLDVWRZRUR]SR]QDýMDNR F\WDW5D\PRQGWZLHUG]LâīHÅGREURWOLZDG\NWDWXUDµMHVWHIHNW\ZQ\P PRGHOHPRUJDQL]DFMLG]LDâDĕVSUDZG]RQ\PQSQDSU]\NâDG]LH/LQXNVD 5D\PRQG² 2UJDQL]DFMDRGREURWOLZHMG\NWDWXU]HW\SRZRHZROXXMH]SRVWDFLRUJD QL]DFMLÅZâDğFLFLHOD]DU]ĆGF\µZPLDUċMDNMHM]DâRī\FLHOVNXSLDJURQR ZVSyâSUDFRZQLNyZ GREURWOLZ\G\NWDWRUQLHMHVWIDNW\F]QLHDEVR OXWQ\PZâDğFLFLHOHPSURMHNWX0DSUDZDGRSRGHMPRZDQLDZLĆīĆF\FK GHF\]MLOHF]WDNQDSUDZGċZ\SU]HGDMHXG]LDâ\VZRMHMUHSXWDFML]DSUDFċ LQQ\FK :WUDG\F\MQ\PXMċFLXÅG\NWDWRUµDOERRVREDSU]HZRG]ĆFDSURMHNWRZL GHZHORSHUyZNRGXSRZLQLHQNRQVXOWRZDýVLċ]XF]HVWQLNDPLSURMHNWX ZNZHVWLDFKNOXF]RZ\FK 0ĆGU\SU]\ZyGFDUR]SR]QDMĆF\IXQNFMH

193

194

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ZHZQċWU]Q\FKJUDQLFZâDVQRğFLZSURMHNFLHQLHEċG]LHZWUĆFDýVLċGR GHF\]MLSRGHMPRZDQ\FKSU]H]ZâDğFLFLHOLSRGV\VWHPXDQLLFKQHJRZDý &]ċğýGXī\FKSURMHNWyZRGU]XFDFDâNRZLFLHPRGHOG]LDâDQLDGREUR WOLZHJRG\NWDWRUD-HGQ\PVSRVREHPQDGRNRQDQLHWHJRMHVWSU]HLVWR F]HQLHZVSyâWZyUFyZSURMHNWXZF]âRQNyZJâRVXMĆFHJRNRPLWHWXMDN PLDâRWRPLHMVFHZSU]\SDGNXSURMHNWX$SDFKH,QQ\PMHVWURWDFMDQD SR]\FMLSU]\ZyGF\ZNWyUHMNRQWURODMHVWF]DVDPLSU]HND]\ZDQDPLċG]\ XF]HVWQLNDPLSURMHNWXZNUċJXVWDUV]\FKGHYHORSHUyZ²WDN]NROHL ]RUJDQL]RZDQDMHVWVSRâHF]QRğýUR]ZLMDMĆFDMċ]\N3HUO

5D\PRQGQDMSUDZGRSRGREQLHM]DF]HUSQĆâXī\WHSU]H]VLHELHVIRUPX âRZDQLH]SVHXGRQLPXÅGRī\ZRWQLHJRGREURWOLZHJRG\NWDWRUDµZ\P\ ğORQHJR]NROHLGOD*XLGRYDQ5RVVXPDWZyUF\Mċ]\ND3\WKRQ9DQ 5RVVXP .RQFHSFMD5D\PRQGDMHVWMHGQDNEOLīV]DWHPXFR :DOHVZRODâE\QD]ZDýÅPRQDUFKLĆNRQVW\WXF\MQĆµ-LPERSUDZGRSR GREQLHPLDâMHGQDNUDFMċWZLHUG]ĆFīHSR]DğURGRZLVNDPLKDNHUVNLPL LSURMHNWDPLRSHQVRXUFHRNUHğOHQLHWRPRīHE\ýQLHMDVQHDQDZHWEX G]LýVNRMDU]HQLD]RVREDPLWDNLPLMDN+R&KL0LQJ-RVLS%UR]7LWR F]\)LGHO&DVWURNWyU]\SU]\QDMPQLHMWDNWZLHUG]L:LNLSHGLDZDUW\ NXOHQDWHPDWGREURWOLZHMG\NWDWXU\ RNUHğODOLVLċZâDğQLHWDNLP PLDQHP:DUWRMHGQDNQDGPLHQLýīHMDNZ\UD]LOLWRQLHNWyU]\ZLNL SHG\ğFLÅPRQDUFKLDNRQVW\WXF\MQDµSUHIHURZDQDSU]H]:DOHVDQLH MHVWRNUHğOHQLHPRZLHOHWUDIQLHMV]\P]XZDJLQDMHJRUyīQHUR]XPLHQLH Z6WDQDFK=MHGQRF]RQ\FKL(XURSLHVNRMDU]HQLDKLVWRU\F]QHF]\ ]DZDUWĆZQLPLGHċVXNFHVML 6\WXDFMDQLHXOHJDâD]PLDQLHSU]H]QDVWċSQHNLONDPLHVLċF\=DVDG QLF]HUHJXâ\:LNLSHGLL]RVWDâ\VIRUPXâRZDQHMXīZPDMXURNX 8ī\WNRZQLN8QLQYLWHG&RPSDQ\]HEUDâMHZGRNXPHQFLH>>HQ:3)RXQ GLQJ3ULQFLSOHV@@ :LNLSHGLDMDNRVSRâHF]QRğýHG\WRUyZFHFKXMHVLċNLONRPDSRGVWDZR Z\PLFKDUDNWHU\VW\NDPLQLHSRGOHJDMĆF\PLG\VNXVML-DNLHNROZLHN NRQWHVWRZDQLHW\FKīH]DVDG]Z\NOHVNXWNXMH]LJQRURZDQLHPG\VNXVML DRVRE\QLH]JDG]DMĆFHVLċ]QLPL]Z\NOHRSXV]F]DMĆSURMHNW Å3URFHVZLNLµMDNRRVWDWHF]QDZâDG]DZG]LHG]LQLH]DZDUWRğFL KDVHâ 0RīOLZRğýRWZDUWHJRHG\WRZDQLDDUW\NXâyZEH]NRQLHF]QRğFL ORJRZDQLDVLċ 1DF]HOQD]DVDGDHG\WRUVND²QHXWUDOQ\SXQNWZLG]HQLD

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? =DZDUWRğýGRVWċSQDQDOLFHQFML*)'/ -LPER:DOHVMDNRRVWDWHF]Q\DXWRU\WHWZGRZROQHMNZHVWLL 2EHFQRğýLQLH]PLHQQDQDWXUDSRZ\īV]\FKSRGVWDZRZ\FK]DVDGSUR MHNWXMHGQ\P]SRZRGyZZ\VQXZDQLDRVNDUīHĕRG]LDâDOQRğýVLWZ Z:LNLSHGLL

3R]\FMD-LPER:DOHVD²MDNRVWRMĆFHJRSRQDGZV]\VWNLPLHG\WRUD PL²]RVWDâDXVWDORQDZSXQNFLH²FRNROZLHN-LPERSRZLHG]LDâPX VLDâRE\ýZ\NRQDQHZGRNâDGQLHSU]HSLVDQ\SU]H]HĕVSRVyE:W\P PRPHQFLHSRMDZLâ\VLċMXīMHGQDNZLGRF]QH]DF]ĆWNL]PLDQ$XWRU\WHW -LPER]RVWDâ]ZHUEDOL]RZDQ\VSLVDQ\MDNRSUDZR1DZHWMHğOLZWHQ VSRVyESRSURVWXSRWZLHUG]RQRVWDWXVTXRQLHGDâRVLċQLH]DXZDī\ý OHNNLHJRSU]HVXQLċFLD]HVWDQXPRQDUFKLLDEVROXWQHMZNLHUXQNX PRQDUFKLLRJUDQLF]RQHM :DOHVRZLZLGRF]QLHWRQLHSU]HV]NDG]DâR3RND]\ZDâZUċF]VLOQH SRSDUFLHSRP\VâXE\F]ċğýRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğFLSU]HND]Dý.RPLWHWRZL $UELWUDīRZHPXSRPDJDMĆFPXSRZVWDýZURNX:\NOXF]\ZV]\ ZV]\VWNRLQQHE\FLHMHG\QĆRVREĆPDMĆFĆIDNW\F]QĆZâDG]ċUR]ZLĆ]\ ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZPLċG]\GRğZLDGF]RQ\PLHG\WRUDPL:LNLSHGLLPXVLDâR E\ýGODQLHJRPċF]ĆFH=Z\Nâ\FKZDQGDOLEORNRZDâRVLċâDWZROHF]NDīG\ SRZDīQLHMV]\NRQÁLNWV]F]HJyOQLHDQJDīXMĆF\VLâ\GZyFKLZLċFHMDGPL QLVWUDWRUyZPLDâZLHONLHV]DQVH]QDOHĩýVLċQDVWURQLHG\VNXVML:DOHVD JUXGQLD:DOHVPLDQRZDâSLHUZV]HJURQRDUELWUyZRGSR ZLHG]LDOQ\FK]DIRUPDOQHUR]ZLĆ]\ZDQLHNRQÁLNWyZRUD]PHGLDWRUyZ RGSRZLHG]LDOQ\FK]DSUyE\SRMHGQDQLD]ZDğQLRQ\FKVWURQSU]HGSRG MċFLHPLQQ\FKğURGNyZ²ZGRğýQLHIRUPDOQ\VSRVyEQRPLQXMĆFZV]\VW NLFKW\FKNWyU]\]JRG]LOLVLċSRGMĆýWHGRGDWNRZHRERZLĆ]NL :W\PF]DVLH.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\E\âSRSURVWXJUXSNĆRFKRWQL NyZ1LFG]LZQHJRīHMHJRDXWRU\WHWE\âQLHZLHONLLGRğýSâ\QQ\ :ZLDGRPRğFLZ\VâDQHMQDOLVWċG\VNXV\MQĆ:LNLSHGLLVW\F]QLD :DOHVVWZLHUG]Lâ

:LDGRPRğý]OLVW\G\VNXV\MQHM:LNL(1/Z\VâDQDSU]H]-LPP\·HJR:DOHVD GRVWċSQDSRGDGUHVHPKWWSPDUNPDLORUJPHVVDJHNRPFOG\DSDWV[MTXHU\ SDJHPLGNRPFOG\DSDWV[MVWDWHUHVXOWVGRVWċSVW\F]QLD :LDGRPRğý]OLVW\G\VNXV\MQHM:LNL(1/Z\VâDQDSU]H]-LPP\·HJR:DOHVD GRVWċSQD SRG DGUHVHP KWWSOLVWVZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOZLNLHQO -DQXDU\KWPOGRVWċSVW\F]QLD

195

196

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... =GUXJLHMVWURQ\.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\PRīHQDU]XFLýUR]ZLĆ]DQLH NWyUHX]QDP]DZLĆīĆFH]]DVWU]HīHQLHPīHUH]HUZXMċVRELHSUDZR âDVNLDQDZHWUR]ZLĆ]DQLDFDâHJRWHJRFLDâDMHğOL.$RNDīHVLċNOċVNĆ 6ĆG]ċMHGQDNīHWDNLVFHQDULXV]MHVWPDâRSUDZGRSRGREQ\SRUyZQ\ ZDOQ\GRSRWHQFMDâXUR]ZLĆ]DQLDSDUODPHQWXEU\W\MVNLHJRZEUHZMHJR ī\F]HQLXSU]H]NUyORZĆ$QJOLL²F]\OLSUDNW\F]QLHR]HURZHMV]DQVLH ]DLVWQLHQLDDOHVWDQRZLĆF\RVWDWQL]DZyUEH]SLHF]HĕVWZDGODQDV]\FK ZDUWRğFL

:DOHVUD]MHV]F]HSRZUyFLâGRVZRLFKXOXELRQ\FKPHWDIRUSU]\ZR âXMĆFPRQDUFKLċ3U]HGVWDZLâ.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\MDNRLQVW\WXFMċ RZDUXQNRZHMOHJLW\PL]DFMLPLDâDE\RQDSU]HWUZDýW\ONRLZ\âĆF]QLH ZWHG\MHğOLQLHRND]DâDE\VLċNODSĆZUR]XPLHQLXVDPHJR-LPER 7RZ\GDU]HQLHPRJâRE\ýSXQNWHP]ZURWQ\PZSURFHVLHZ\FRI\ZD QLDVLċ:DOHVD]NLHURZQLFWZDZ\NRQDZF]HJRZVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLL FKFLDâ]DFKRZDýGODVLHELHSUDZRREDOHQLDGHF\]MLNRPLWHWXJG\E\FRğ SRV]âRQLHWDN]DSHZQHZLHU]\âWHīīH]DFKRZDGODVLHELHRGURELQċ ÅSDSLHVNLHJRPDMHVWDWXµMHğOLQDGHV]âDE\NRQLHF]QRğýGHF\]\MQHM LQWHUSUHWDFMLNWyUHMğ]SRGVWDZRZ\FK]DVDGQLHGĆī\âMHGQDNGRQL F]HJRZLċFHM :VLHUSQLXSRGF]DVNRQIHUHQFML:LNLPDQLDMHJRDXWRU\WHW ZVSRâHF]QRğFLE\âMHGQDNQDGDOQDW\OHZ\VRNLE\PyJâQDGREUH]DP NQĆý:LNLSHGLċZMċ]\NXNOLQJRĕVNLPQLHZ\MDğQLDMĆFSXEOLF]QLHWHM GHF\]MLLQLHZ\ZRâXMĆFZLċNV]\FKSURWHVWyZ :OLSFXRVWDWQLD]IXQGDPHQWDOQ\FK]DVDGDQJLHOVNLHM:LNL SHGLL]PLHQLâDVZRMHEU]PLHQLHQDVWċSXMĆFRÅ-LPER:DOHVMDNRRVWD WHF]Q\DXWRU\WHWZGRZROQHMNZHVWLLFKRýF]ċğýZâDG]\]RVWDâDSU]HND ]DQDLQQ\PRUJDQRP]RE.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\5DGD3RZLHUQLF]D µ :W\PVDP\PURNX-LPER]RVWDâUyZQLHīVWHZDUGHPDOHFRFLHNDZH QLHXF]HVWQLF]\âZZ\ERUDFKFKRýEH]FLHQLDZĆWSOLZRğFLMHJRNDQ G\GDWXUDFLHV]\âDE\VLċZLHONLPSRSDUFLHP ]RVWDâ]DWRQRPLQRZDQ\ QDVWHZDUGDSU]H]:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ:SDĩG]LHUQLNX]UH ]\JQRZDâ]IXQNFMLSU]HZRGQLF]ĆFHJR5DG\3RZLHUQLF]HMIXQGDFMLFKRý XWU]\PDâZQLHMGRī\ZRWQLHPLHMVFH3U]HGZ\ERUDPLZHZU]HğQLX

.OLQJRĕVNLMHVWV]WXF]Q\PMċ]\NLHPVWZRU]RQ\PQDSRWU]HE\VHULDOX6WDU 7UHNLUR]ZLMDQ\PSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğýIDQyZ:LċFHMQDWHQWHPDWPRīQDSU]HF]\WDý SRGDGUHVHPKWWSSOZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL-ċ]\NBNOLQJRĕVNL

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? SXEOLF]QLHZ\UD]LâSRSDUFLHGODGZyFKNDQG\GDWyZFRMHGQDN QLH]RVWDâR]E\WFLHSâRSU]\MċWHSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý]XZDJLQDWRīH PLDâMHGQRF]HğQLHWHFKQLF]QĆPRīOLZRğýREVHUZRZDQLDUR]NâDGX JâRVyZZWUDNFLHZ\ERUyZ:V]\VWNLHSyĩQLHMV]HZ\ERU\GR5DG\3R ZLHUQLF]HM]RVWDâ\RGGDQHGRUHDOL]DFMLGR]HZQċWU]QHMRUJDQL]DFML 1DGDOMHGQDNXWU]\P\ZDâZLHONĆZâDG]ċV]F]HJyOQLHZVSRâHF] QRğFLDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL:OLVWRSDG]LHXī\WNRZQLN5DGLDQW VWZRU]\âHVHM]RSLVHPHG\FMLÅFK\EDWHJRQDPSRWU]HED µ ZNWyU\P QDSLVDâPLċG]\LQQ\PL Å$UJXPHQWXPDG-LPERQHPµMHVWF]DVDPLVSRW\NDQ\PZ:LNLSHGLL VRÀ]PDWHPZ\VWċSXMĆF\PJG\]DNâDGDVLċīHSXQNWZLG]HQLDMHGQRVWNL MHVWSUDZLGâRZ\JG\ī-LPERXZDīDâE\WDNVDPR:WDNLPUR]XPRZD QLXVĆGZDEâċG\SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPLVWQLHMHDUJXPHQWXPDGYHUHFXQ GLDP²-LPERQLH]DZV]HDXWRPDW\F]QLHPDUDFMċZHZV]\VWNLPFR SRZLH'UXJĆNZHVWLĆMHVWWRīHZV]\VWNLHVSRU\PRJĆE\ýRSLHUDQH QDQLHSUDZG]LZ\FKLQWHUSUHWDFMDFKLZQLRVNDFK]WHJRFRSRZLHG]LDâ NLHG\ğ-LPERMDNWHīF\WDWDFKQLHDNWXDOQ\FKRGNLONXODW:DULDFMĆQD WHPDWSRZ\īV]HJRMHVWÅ$UJXPHQWXPDG%ULRQHPµ 2F]\ZLğFLHQLHZROQRQDPLJQRURZDýWHJRFRQDGDQ\WHPDWPDMĆ GRSRZLHG]HQLD-LPERL%ULRQL]DLVWHREDMFLOXG]LHPDMĆZâDG]ċGR XVWDODQLD]DVDGRGSRGVWDZMHğOLX]QDMĆWDNLHG]LDâDQLH]DVWRVRZQH 1LHSRZLQQLğP\MHGQDNRSLHUDýQDV]\FKGHF\]MLQDFKDRW\F]Q\FKLQ WHUSUHWDFMDFKF]HJRNROZLHNFRNWyUDNROZLHN]W\FKRVyESRZLHG]LDâD ZğUHGQLR]ZLĆ]DQHM]DNWXDOQĆV\WXDFMĆNZHVWLLNLONDODWWHPX

3U]\ZRâDQ\ZSRZ\īV]\PF\WDFLH%ULRQ9LEEHUE\âJâyZQ\PDUFKL WHNWHPRSURJUDPRZDQLDZ:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ=SRZ\īV]HJRF\WDWX MDVQRZLGDýīHSU]\ZRâ\ZDQLHDXWRU\WHWX-LPERGRGDZDâRZDJLNDī GHMG\VNXVML 3U]H]ODWDIXQNFMRQRZDQLD.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\PLPRQLHNWyU\FK NRQWURZHUVMLWDNLFKMDNRSLVDQDZSRSU]HGQLPUR]G]LDOHVSUDZD (VVMD\D ]DVNDUELâVRELH]DXIDQLHVSRâHF]QRğFL-DNSRGDMĆQLH]DOHīQH EDGDQLD.RPLWHWFRGR]DVDG\E\âZVWDQLHVNRQFHQWURZDýVLċQD ]DFKRZDQLXXī\WNRZQLNyZLRGNâDGDýQDERNNZHVWLHPHU\WRU\F]QH +RIIPDQL0HKUD 3RUR]SDWU]HQLXVHWHNVSUDZZ\GDQLXZLHOX

KWWSPDUFLQIR"O ZLNLSHGLDO P Z GRVWċSZU]HğQLD

197

198

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... RVWU]HīHĕEORNDGLEDQyZGRī\ZRWQLFKSR]EDZLHĕPRīOLZRğFLHG\ WRZDQLDSU]H]GDQĆRVREċQLH]DOHīQLHRGOLF]E\SRVLDGDQ\FKNRQWVWDâ VLċRQLQVW\WXFMĆSXEOLF]QHJR]DXIDQLDLRVWDWHF]Q\PRUJDQHPUR]ZLĆ ]\ZDQLDNRQÁLNWyZ5ROD-LPER:DOHVD]PLHQLâDVLċZUD]]HZROXFMĆ .RPLWHWX 3RP\VâSRVLDGDQLDNRPLWHWXDUELWUDīRZHJRVWDâVLċSRSXODUQ\ZLQ Q\FKZHUVMDFKMċ]\NRZ\FK:LNLSHGLL:URNXSROVNDLQLHPLHFND :LNLSHGLDSRZRâDâ\ZâDVQH.RPLWHW\$UELWUDīRZHED]XMĆFQD]DVDGDFK ]DF]HUSQLċW\FK]ZHUVMLDQJLHOVNLHM :PDUFXRVWDWQLD]DVDGD:LNLSHGLLEU]PLDâDMXīÅ5DGD 3RZLHUQLF]DPDRVWDWHF]QĆZâDG]ċZNZHVWLDFK]ZLĆ]DQ\FK]:LNLPH GLD)RXQGDWLRQ:SUDNW\FH-LPER:DOHVSR]RVWDMHRVWDWHF]Q\PVċG]LĆ ZQLHNWyU\FKSURMHNWDFKFKRýF]ċğýWHMZâDG]\]RVWDâDRGGHOHJRZDQD GRLQQ\FKRUJDQyZWDNLFKMDN.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\µ 3R]\FMD-LPERQDGDOE\âDZ\MĆWNRZRVLOQDZPDUFXPLPRSU]H SURZDG]RQHMG\VNXVMLLXVWDORQHJRSRPLHVLĆFDFKUR]ZDīDĕNRQVHQVXVX ]DZHWRZDâSRâĆF]HQLH]DVDGZHU\ÀNRZDOQRğFL]DND]X]DPLHV]F]DQLD WZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHMLU]HWHOQ\FKĩUyGHâZMHGQĆ]DVDGċÅNRPSHWHQFMLµ WZLHUG]ĆFīHLQWHJURZDQLH]DVDGMHVWZLHONLPEâċGHPLQLHSU]\MPXMĆF NU\W\NLSRVZRMHMGHF\]ML 1LHFRSyĩQLHMZURNXSU]H]OLVWċG\VNXV\MQĆ:LNLPHGLD )RXQGDWLRQSU]HWRF]\âDVLċGâXJDG\VNXVMDQDGW\PF]\SU]HZRGQL F]ĆF\P5DG\3RZLHUQLF]HM:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQRUD]5DG\'RUDG F]HMQDOHīDâRE\SU]\]QDýIXQNFMHVWHZDUGD]XZDJLQDSLDVWRZDQH VWDQRZLVND'\VNXVMDGRW\F]\âDWHīWHJRF]\-LPERSRZLQLHQGRNRQDý SRWZLHUG]HQLDVZRMHMUROLMDNRVWHZDUGDMDNURELOLWRSR]RVWDOLVWH ZDUG]LF]\PRīHQDOHīDâRE\JRWUDNWRZDýMDNRIXQNFMRQDULXV]DQD GRī\ZRWQLHMSR]\FML6SRVWU]HīHQLDGXīHMF]ċğFLVSRâHF]QRğFLSRGVX PRZXMHGLDORJGZyFKSURPLQHQWQ\FKZLNLSHG\VWyZPDMĆF\FKV]HUHJ XSUDZQLHĕZZLHOXSURMHNWDFK:LNLPHGLD 3\WDQLHF]\ī-LPERQLHMHVWSRQDGF]DVRZ\"²$QRQ\PRXV'LVVLGHQW7DON OLVWRSDGD87&

KWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLQGH[SKS"WLWOH )RXQGDWLRQBLVVXHV GLII ROGLG KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD:LNLSHGLDB6LJQSRVW1HZVB DQGBQRWHV KWWSVPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL7DON6WHZDUGVHOHFWLRQVB

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? 3UDZLHQDSHZQRQLHPDGODQLHJRPLHMVFDQDOLğFLHSRWZLHUG]Hĕ /DUWFOLVWRSDGD87&

&]ċğýF]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFL]FKċFLĆXWU]\PDâDE\VWDWXV-LPERMDNR VWHZDUGDMDNWHīQDGDâDE\IXQNFMRQDULXV]RP:LNLPHGLDVWDWXVVWH ZDUGDRUD]GRVWċSGRRGSRZLHGQLHMOLVW\G\VNXV\MQHMOHF]SRMDZLâ\VLċ WHīVFHSW\F]QHJâRV\ZWHMNZHVWLL'DâDVLċWHī]DXZDī\ýUyīQLFD]GDĕ PLċG]\IXQGDFMĆDVSRâHF]QRğFLĆHG\WRUyZ1DSRGVWDZLHSU]HSURZD G]RQ\FKSU]H]HPQLHZ\ZLDGyZPRJċVWZLHUG]LýīHFRQDMPQLHMF]ċğý VWHZDUGyZXZDīDVZRMĆSR]\FMċ]DIXQNFMċ]DXIDQLDSXEOLF]QHJR ZLHU]ĆFīHUHSUH]HQWXMĆVSRâHF]QRğýSU]HGIXQGDFMĆQLHFKFĆFGR SXV]F]DýRVyEQLHZ\EUDQ\FKSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğýGRZHZQċWU]QHMOLVW\ G\VNXV\MQHM :HZU]HğQLXSRZVWDâDMHGQDNKXPRU\VW\F]QDVWURQDVWDZLD MĆFDS\WDQLHRWRFR]URELâE\-LPER²>>HQ:3:KDW:RXOG-LPER'R@@ -HMJâyZQĆSU]HVâDQNĆE\âRWRīHHG\WRUQDSHZQR]URELZâDğFLZĆU]HF] MHğOL]DGDVRELHS\WDQLHRWRMDNSRVWĆSLâE\-LPER :URNXRGE\âDVLċQDVWċSXMĆFDG\VNXVMDRG]ZLHUFLHGODMĆFD F]ċğýZĆWSOLZRğFLHG\WRUyZ>>HQ:3BWDON5ROHBRIB-LPP\B:DOHV@@ 6ĆG]ċīHMXīRGGâXīV]HJRF]DVXQLHXZDīDVLċE\-LPERPLDâIDNW\F]QĆ ZâDG]ċ1DHULLF]HUZFD87& =DS\WDPNLHG\ZRJyOH]DGHF\GRZDOLğP\īHVWUDFLâRZĆZâDG]ċ" 7LSWRHW\WDON 1LHZLHP:ĆWSLċMHGQDNE\NWRNROZLHNWUDNWRZDâSRZDīQLHMHJR KLSLVRZVNLHE]GHW\ZVW\OXÅNRFKDMEOLĩQLHJRVZHJRµZFKZLODFK JG\FKFHPXVLċVNRPHQWRZDýMDNĆNROZLHNNZHVWLċVSRâHF]QRğ FLRZĆ²1DHULLF]HUZFD87& 'RğZLDGF]HQLHL]DXIDQLHF]ċVWRQDGDMĆZLNLSHG\ğFLHQLHIRU PDOQĆZâDG]ċ0RīHLMHVWWRKLSLVRZVNLHJOċG]HQLHDOHWRSU]HGH ZV]\VWNLPGREUHUDG\NWyUHVWDUDPVLċEUDýVRELHGRVHUFD²1HG 6FRWWF]HUZFD87& :RGSRZLHG]LGOD7LSWRHW\]WHJRFRVâ\V]DâHPZZ\ZLDGDFK WRZâDğQLHVDP-LPERGĆī\âGR]PQLHMV]HQLDZDJLIRUPDOQHM ZâDG]\GRSRPRF\ZSU]HMğFLXNX]DU]ĆG]DQLXV\VWHPHPSU]H] VDPĆVSRâHF]QRğý²1HG6FRWWF]HUZFD87&

&RZLċFHMG\VNXVMHQDWHPDW-LPERMDNRVWHZDUGDSRZUDFDâ\ :OXW\PJG\SU]\V]HGâF]DVNROHMQ\FKSRWZLHUG]HĕVWHZDUGyZ

199

200

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]DâRīRQRUyZQLHīVWURQċQDNWyUHMPRīQDE\âR]JâDV]DýXZDJLQDWHPDW SR]RVWDZDQLD-LPERZWHMUROL:LHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZWZLHUG]LâRīH ]XZDJLQDMHJRQLVNĆDNW\ZQRğýMDNRVWHZDUGDQDOHīDâRE\JRSR]ED ZLýW\FKXSUDZQLHĕLSU]HQLHğýGRJUXS\ÅSUDFRZQLNyZREVâXJLµ VWDII 7R]NROHLZ\GDZDâRVLċQLHZSRU]ĆGNXLQQHMJUXSLHQDOHJD MĆFHMīH-LPERQLHSU]\QDOHī\UyZQLHīGRWHMNDWHJRULL3RMDZLâ\VLċ UyZQLHīRSLQLHīHVNRURZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLPDRQVWDWXVÅ]DâR ī\FLHODµWRSRZLQQRPXVLċQDGDýWHVDPHXSUDZQLHQLDZSR]RVWDâ\FK SURMHNWDFK*âRV\E\â\SRG]LHORQHOHF]-LPER]GHF\GRZDâīHSRMDZLâD VLċZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRVLOQDDUJXPHQWDFMDE\VWZRU]\ýZVSyOQĆUROċÅ]D âRī\FLHODµGODZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZREHMPXMĆFĆSRGREQHXSUDZQLHQLD GRVWHZDUGD5R]ZLĆ]DQLHZ\GDâRVLċZWHG\ZV]\VWNLFK]DGRZROLý LSR]ZROLâR-LPERXWU]\PDýSHâHQZDFKODU]SU]\ZLOHMyZLQDU]ċG]LEH] NRQLHF]QRğFLSRWZLHUG]DQLDVZRLFKFKċFLGRGDOV]HJRVSUDZRZDQLD IXQNFMLVWHZDUGD :OLSFX:DOHV]DEORNRZDâMHGQĆ]DGPLQLVWUDWRUHNDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLL]XZDJLQDSRF]\QLRQHSU]H]QLĆNRPHQWDU]HSRGDGUHVHP HG\WRUDNWyU\GRNRQ\ZDâQLHSUDZLGâRZ\FKHG\FMLFKRýG]LDâDâZGREUHM ZLHU]H6SUDZDWUDÀâDSU]HG.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\NWyU\ZVND]DâQD SHZQHQLHGRFLĆJQLċFLDZG]LDâDQLDFK-LPERZRGQLHVLHQLXGR]DVDG EORNRZDQLD6NXWNLHPWHJR-LPERGREURZROQLH]U]HNâVLċNRU]\VWD QLD]QDU]ċG]LEORNRZDQLDZSU]\V]âRğFL&DâHZ\GDU]HQLHQLHE\âRPRīH QLF]\PZLHONLPDOHMHVWLVWRWQHJG\īV\PEROLF]QLHRGPLHU]DF]DV ZNWyU\P.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\X]\VNDâZZLGRF]Q\VSRVyEZâDG]ċQDG -LPER &RZLċFHMZOLSFXSRZVWDâDSURSR]\FMDVWZRU]HQLDFLDâDGR UDGF]HJRGRVSUDZUR]ZRMXSURMHNWXDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLNWyUHM SRP\VâRGDZFĆE\â.RPLWHW$UELWUDīRZ\SRSDUW\SU]H]-LPER>>HQ:LNL SHGLD$GYLVRU\&RXQFLORQ3URMHFW'HYHORSPHQW@@ OHF]NWyU\QLH ]RVWDâSU]\MċW\]E\WGREU]HSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý2JyOQLHZ\UDīDQRVLċ RW\PSRP\ğOHMDNRRSUyELHSRV]HU]HQLD]DNUHVXZâDG]\EċGĆFHM ZUċNDFK.RPLWHWX$UELWUDīRZHJRSR]DPDQGDWVSRâHF]QRğFL6]F]H JyOQLHNU\W\NRZDQRQLHSU]HMU]\VW\FKDUDNWHUSURSRQRZDQHMNRPLVML ]DSURV]HQLDGRXF]HVWQLFWZDZMHMSUDFDFKUR]V\âDQHE\â\SU]H]DUELWUyZ Z\EUDQ\PHG\WRURP 3UyEDSRZRâDQLDQRZHJRRUJDQXEH]GHF\]ML

KWWSVPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL6WHZDUGVFRQILUP-LPERB:DOHV >>HQ:3$UELWUDWLRQB&RPPLWWHH1RWLFHERDUG$UFKLYHB$UELWUDWLRQBPR WLRQBUHJDUGLQJB-LPERB:DOHVBDQGB%LVKRQHQ@@

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? VSRâHF]QRğFLZ\ZRâDâDZğFLHNâRğýLVFHSW\F\]PZLHOXOXG]L²ZâDğQLH WDNLHG]LDâDQLDSU]\SRPLQDâ\]QLHQDZLG]RQHVLWZ\ :HZU]HğQLXWHJRVDPHJRURNX-LPERRğZLDGF]\âīHRGWHJRPR PHQWXQRPLQDFMHQRZ\FKF]âRQNyZ.RPLWHWX$UELWUDīRZHJREċGĆPLDâ\ F]\VWRFHUHPRQLDOQ\FKDUDNWHUF]\OLīHRQVDPZ\âĆF]QLHGRNRQDSX EOLF]QHJRRJâRV]HQLDZ\QLNXGHPRNUDW\F]Q\FKZ\ERUyZ²QLHEċG]LH PRīOLZRğFLRGU]XFHQLDSU]H]QLHJRZ\EUDQ\FKNDQG\GDWyZ1LHGâXJR SyĩQLHMPLDâ\PLHMVFDGZDZ\GDU]HQLDNWyUHQD]DZV]H]PLHQLâ\UROċ SU]\ZyGF\:LNLSHGLL

PRZEŁOMOWE EKSPERYMENTY :VW\F]QLXXī\WNRZQLN3ULYDWHPXVLQJVVWZRU]\âZ:LNLYHUVLW\ VWURQċSRğZLċFRQĆHNVSHU\PHQWRPHW\F]Q\PVSUDZG]DMĆF\PQDUX V]DQLHQRUPZ:LNLSHGLLSU]H]WZRU]HQLHÀNF\MQ\FKELRJUDÀLGRGD ZDQLHSU]HNRQXMĆF\FKOHF]QLHSUDZG]LZ\FKSU]\SLVyZLWG:OXW\P GRGDâGRVZRLFKQRWDWHNVWURQċRSLVXMĆFĆMDNVNXWHF]QLHNRU]\VWDý ]SDF\QHNRV]XNXMĆFDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ:LNLSHGLL7HJRVDPHJRGQLD SRLQIRUPRZDQRJRRQLHRGSRZLHGQLPFKDUDNWHU]HGRGDZDQ\FKSU]H]Hĕ WUHğFLLRW\PīHZSU]HV]âRğFLGRFKRG]LâRMXīGRXVXZDQLDSRGREQ\FK SU]HZRGQLNyZZLQQ\FKVHUZLVDFK:LNLPHGLD8ī\WNRZQLNSRGV]HGâ GRW\FKSRUDGZVSRVyEGRğýVSRNRMQ\ZPDUFX]DâRī\âWHīVWURQċG\V NXVMLQDGVZRLPSRUDGQLNLHP-HGHQ]XF]HVWQLNyZG\VNXVMLSRLQIRU PRZDâ-LPERRFDâHMVSUDZLHQDMHJRVWURQLHG\VNXVMLLSRSURVLâRUHDNFMċ -LPERQLHGRâĆF]\âGRG\VNXVMLZGXFKXPLâRğFLL]UR]XPLHQLD8VX QĆâFDâĆVWURQċSRUDGQLNDZUD]]MHMSRGVWURQDPLL]DEORNRZDâXī\W NRZQLND3ULYDWHPXVLQJV*G\MHGHQ]DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSRGMĆâG\V NXVMċQDGV\WXDFMĆ-LPERZ\GDâRğZLDGF]HQLHGRVWċSQHSRGDGUHVHP >>:LNLYHUVLW\HQ&RPPXQLW\5HYLHZ:LNLPHGLD(WKLFV(WKLFDO%UHD FKLQJ([SHULPHQWV@@

1DOHī\WXFK\EDQDGPLHQLýīHDNWXDOQLHIXQNFMRQXMH]DPNQLċWDOLVWDG\VNX V\MQDLQWHUQDOO SU]H]QDF]RQDGODF]ċğFLSUDFRZQLNyZ:0)SU]HGVWDZLFLHOL ORNDOQ\FKSDUWQHUyZIXQGDFMLRUD]Z\EUDQ\FK]DXIDQ\FKHG\WRUyZ $GPLQLVWUDWRU]\VHUZLVX:LNLYHUVLW\QRV]ĆZSUDZG]LHQD]ZċÅNXVWRV]\µ FXVWRGLDQ OHF]EċGċNRU]\VWDý]SRZV]HFKQLHMV]HMQD]Z\IXQNFMLE\QLHGRSUR ZDG]LýGRQLHSRUR]XPLHĕ

201

202

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... $NWXDOQLHG\VNXWXMċ]5DGĆQDGPRīOLZRğFLĆ]DPNQLċFLD:LNLYHUVLW\ 1LHMHVWWRUR]ZLĆ]DQLHSUDZGRSRGREQHOHF]ZVSRPLQDPRQLPWXWDM JG\īFKFċ]D]QDF]\ý]DNUHVWHPDW\F]Q\SURMHNWX]DZċīRQ\ğFLğOHGR RWZDUW\FK]DVREyZHGXNDF\MQ\FK6ĆG]ċīHPRMHG]LDâDQLDZW\P SURMHNFLHVĆVLOQ\PZ\UD]HPSRSDUFLDGODU]HWHOQHMVSRâHF]QRğFLNWyUD ZâDğQLHWDNLHPDWHULDâ\FKFHWZRU]\ý3RND]XMċMDVQRīHPDMĆZHPQLH VLOQHZVSDUFLH0RīHVĆOXG]LHNWyU]\XZDīDMĆīH:LNLYHUVLW\MHVW ZâDğFLZ\PPLHMVFHPGODQLHPĆGU\FKLQLHGRMU]Dâ\FKHNVSHU\PHQWyZ -HğOLVĆWDF\NWyU]\FKFĆRQLFKG\VNXWRZDýWRPDMĆGODVLHELHFDâ\ ,QWHUQHW²QLHZROQRLP]DZâDV]F]Dý:LNLYHUVLW\W\ONRGODZâDVQ\FK FHOyZ²-LPER:DOHVPDUFD87&

3RZ\īV]\NRPHQWDU]SRZV]HFKQLHRGHEUDQRMDNRJURĩEċ:LHOXHG\ WRUyZNRPHQWRZDâRFDâRğýQDVWċSXMĆFRZSUDZG]LHQLHSRZLQQRVLċ SRSLHUDýSRZVWDZDQLDPDWHULDâyZLQVWUXNWDīRZ\FKQDWHPDWRV]X NLZDQLDLSURZDG]HQLDHNVSHU\PHQWyZQD:LNLSHGLLOHF]GRNXPHQ WRZDQLHWDNLFKSU]\SDGNyZMDNWHīLFKEDGDQLHSRZLQQRE\ýWDNVDPR FHQLRQHMDNQSNZHVWLHEH]SLHF]HĕVWZDLQIUDVWUXNWXU\LQIRUPDW\F]QHM :W\PF]DVLHDGPLQLVWUDWRULELXURNUDWD:LNLYHUVLW\6%-RKQQ\ RGWZRU]\âVWURQ\XVXQLċWHSU]H]-LPERLRGEORNRZDâXī\WNRZQLND 3ULYDWHPXVLQJV2GSRZLHGĩ-LPERE\âDQDW\FKPLDVWRZDSRQRZQLH XVXQĆâVWURQ\SRUDGQLND]DEORNRZDâ3ULYDWHPXVLQJVLXī\ZDMĆF QDU]ċG]LVWHZDUGDNWyUHPLDâG]LċNLÁDG]HÅ]DâRī\FLHODµSR]EDZLâ 6%-RKQQ\·HJRXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDLELXURNUDW\2ğZLDGF]\â WHīīHSU]\ZUyFLMHMHğOL6%-RKQQ\SU]HVWDQLHSRSLHUDýG]LDâDQLD 3ULYDWHPXVLQJV8ī\WNRZQLN7KHNRVKHU]DEORNRZDQ\ZDQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLOHF]QDGDODNW\ZQ\ZVHUZLVLH:LNLYHUVLW\VNRPHQWRZDâ QDZ\īHMSU]\ZRâDQHMVWURQLHīHG]LDâDQLD-LPERÅZVSRVyENRPLF]Q\ SU]\SRPLQDMĆV]NROQHJREUXWDODµDGRWHJRSRUyZQDâ:DOHVDGRLQWHU QHWRZHJRWUROOD5HDNFMĆ-LPERE\âRXVXQLċFLHNRPHQWDU]DL]DEORNR ZDQLHXī\WNRZQLND :\ZRâDâRWRIDOċNU\W\NLJâyZQLHGODWHJRīHZLHOXXī\WNRZQLNyZ XZDīDâRīH-LPERSU]HNURF]\âVZRMHXSUDZQLHQLD:VND]\ZDQRQDIDNW īHQLHE\âRQQDZHWDGPLQLVWUDWRUHP:LNLYHUVLW\QLHE\âWHīZ\EUDQ\P VWHZDUGHP:LNLPHGLDDMHJRVWDWXVÅ]DâRī\FLHODµFKRýWHFKQLF]QLH UyZQR]QDF]Q\]]DNUHVHPZâDG]\VWHZDUGyZQLHSRZLQLHQE\ýZ\NR U]\VW\ZDQ\ZHGâXJMDNLHJRNROZLHNZLG]LPLVLċPLPREUDNXNRQVHQ VXVXVSRâHF]QHJR:LDGRPRğFLQDVWURQLHG\VNXVML-LPERSR]RVWDZLâR V]HğFLXXī\WNRZQLNyZīĆGDMĆFZ\MDğQLHĕZSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKNZHVWLDFK

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? -HJRRGSRZLHG]LE\â\PDâRWUHğFLZH²-LPERWZLHUG]LâVWDQRZF]RīH G]LDâDâ]SHâQ\PSRSDUFLHPIXQGDFMLFRMHV]F]HSRGV\FDâRG\VNXVMH QDWHPDWWHJRMDNLNLHG\WRRÀFMDOQHSRSDUFLH]RVWDâRZ\UDīRQH :REOLF]XHVNDODFMLDZDQWXU\6XH*DUGQHUG\UHNWRUNDZ\NRQDZF]D :LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQRSXEOLNRZDâDVZRMHRğZLDGF]HQLH 1DWHMVWURQLHMHVWVSRURNRPHQWDU]\ZWHPDFLHWHJRF]\-LPP\ PDMDNĆNROZLHNZâDG]ċZVHUZLVLH:LNLYHUVLW\SR]ZDODMĆFĆPXQD ]URELHQLHWHJRFRIDNW\F]QLH]URELâ²XVXZDQLHVWURQLSR]EDZLDQLH DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZLFKXSUDZQLHĕ=FDâ\PV]DFXQNLHPXZDīDPīHWR FHORZHRGFLĆJDQLHXF]HVWQLNyZG\VNXVMLRGPHULWXP:VSLHUDPG]LD âDQLD-LPP\·HJRJG\īX]QDMċMHJRSU]HVâDQLH]DSUDZG]LZH²DGRWHJR ]DF]\QDPQLHPDUWZLýīHSU]HVâDQLHWRWRQLHZUR]PRZLHQDWHPDW DXWRU\WHWX -LPP\PyZLīHXZDīDLīZ:LNLYHUVLW\SDQRV]\VLċGHVWUXNW\ZQ\ WUROOLQJLīHVSRâHF]QRğýPXVLRSUDFRZDýOHSV]HVSRVRE\QDFKURQLHQLH VLHELHLVZRMHMSUDF\0yZLīHZDīQHMHVWE\VSRâHF]QRğýMDVQRGHÀQLR ZDâDVZRMĆPLVMċDQLHSUH]HQWRZDâDSRVWDZ\OHVHIHU\]PX&DâNRZLFLH VLċ]W\P]JDG]DP²MHğOLQLHGDVLċ]GHÀQLRZDýSRGHMPRZDQ\FKG]LDâDĕ ZVSRVyEZ\NOXF]DMĆF\GHVWUXNW\ZQHQRQVHQV\WRSRMDZLDVLċZLHONL SUREOHP ²6XH*DUGQHUPDUFD87&

:W\PF]DVLHVSRâHF]QRğýSUDFRZDâDMXīZ\WUZDOHQDGXVWDQDZLD QLHP]DVDGNWyUH]DND]\ZDâ\E\GRNRQ\ZDQLDHNVSHU\PHQWyZWHVWX MĆF\FKUHDNFMHVSRâHF]QRğFLSU]\QDMPQLHMSRGSRVWDFLĆV]F]HJyâRZHJR LQVWUXNWDīX 3RQLīV]\NRPHQWDU]-LPERZ\GDâVLċXVSRNRLýV\WXDFMċ 0RMDZâDG]DZW\PSURMHNFLHQLHZ\QLND]HVSRâHF]QRğFLLQLHMHVWF]\Pğ FR]DPLHU]DPZ\NRU]\VW\ZDýZSU]\V]âRğFL=DOHFLâHPSRSURVWXXVX QLċFLHSUREOHPDW\F]QHMWUHğFL²MHVWWRDUJXPHQWDFMDLG\VNXVMDNWyUHM QLHSRWU]HEXMHP\NWyUDZ\ZRâDâDE\NRPSOLNDFMHJG\E\]DLVWQLDâD ZGDOV]HMSU]\V]âRğFL1LHWZyU]FLH]DVDGNWyUHVĆ]EċGQH-HğOLZHMGċ ZDPZSDUDGċ]DSRZLHG]P\PLHVLĆFHWRRF]\ZLğFLHZWHG\ZDUWR EċG]LHFRğ]W\P]URELý²-LPER:DOHVPDUFD87&

-LPER]JRG]LâVLċ]W\PīH3ULYDWHPXVLQJVZ\GDZDâVLċUR]VĆGQ\P HG\WRUHPLīHMHVWPDâRSUDZGRSRGREQHE\SU]\ZUyFLâNRQWURZHUV\MQH WUHğFLSRF]\PRGEORNRZDâJRPDUFDURNX6%-RKQQ\]GHF\GRZDâ

203

204

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... MHGQDNīHQLHF]XMHVLċMXīNRPIRUWRZRMDNRDGPLQLVWUDWRULELXURNUDWD SURMHNWXL]UH]\JQRZDâ]]DMPRZDQ\FKIXQNFML:Z\QLNXG\VNXVML XSUDZQLHĕ]U]HNâVLċMHV]F]HMHGHQDGPLQLVWUDWRU:LNLYHUVLW\ &LHNDZHMHVWīHXF]HVWQLF\G\VNXVMLE\OLğZLDGRPLWHJRLī3ULYD WHPXVLQJVE\âDNW\ZQ\PXī\WNRZQLNLHPJUXS\:LNLSHGLDUHYLHZFRP EDUG]RNU\W\F]QLHSRGFKRG]ĆFHMGRG]LDâDĕ:LNLSHGLLLF]ċVWR]OHNFHZD īHQLHPZ\SRZLDGDMĆFHMVLċRSURMHNWDFK:LNLPHGLD:VHUZLVLHSRGMĆâ WHPDWPRīOLZHJRXPLHV]F]HQLDZ:LNLSHGLLIDâV]\Z\FKWUHğFLFRPLDâR E\ýSHZQHJRURG]DMXHNVSHU\PHQWHPVSUDZG]DMĆF\PRGSRUQRğýVSR âHF]QRğFLQDSU]HNâDPDQLDGHNODUXMĆFīHHNVSHU\PHQWSU]HSURZDG]L '\VNXVMDE\âDPLPRWHJR]DFLċWD]DğVSRâHF]QRğýEDUG]LHM]DDEVRU ERZDâ\G]LDâDQLD-LPERSU]HNUDF]DMĆFHMHJRXSUDZQLHQLDQLHG]LDâDâ DQLZFKDUDNWHU]HDGPLQLVWUDWRUDDQLVWHZDUGDDQLZ\NRQDZF\RÀ FMDOQHMGHF\]MLIXQGDFML :\W\NDQRWHīEUDNNRQVXOWDFML]HVSRâHF]QRğFLĆ ]MHJRVWURQ\MDNWHīQLHSRGDQLHSU]H]QLHJRZ\MDğQLHĕ&RQDMZDī QLHMV]HVNRU]\VWDâRQ]XSUDZQLHĕVWHZDUGDEċGĆF\FKZMHJRSRVLDGD QLX]XZDJLQDVWDWXVÅ]DâRī\FLHODµ ZFHOXSR]EDZLHQLDXī\WNRZQLND XSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSR]DSU]\MċW\PLSURFHGXUDPL '\VNXVMDZVHUZLVLH:LNLYHUVLW\Z0HWD:LNLDWDNīHQDOLVWDFK G\VNXV\MQ\FKREMċâDW\VLċF\VâyZLZ\ZRâDâDNROHMQĆUR]SRF]ċWĆ Z0HWD:LNLPDUFDURNX'RW\F]\âDRQDWHJRF]\-LPERQDOHī\ SR]EDZLýÁDJLÅ]DâRī\FLHODµ]HZ]JOċGXQDSU]HNUDF]DQLHSU]H]QLHJR XSUDZQLHĕ3RGNRQLHFPDUFDJâRV\UR]âRī\â\VLċMHGQDNQDNRU]\ğý -LPERXī\WNRZQLNyZSRSDUâRRGHEUDQLHPXGRGDWNRZ\FKSU]\ ZLOHMyZE\âRSU]HFLZZVWU]\PDâRVLċRGJâRVX,ZWHG\QDVWĆSLâR NROHMQHQLHIRUWXQQH]GDU]HQLH

KWWSZLNLSHGLDUHYLHZFRPLQGH[SKS"VKRZWRSLF VW S HQWU\GRVWċSF]HUZFD 0HWD:LNLEĆGĩNUyFHMÅ0HWDµWRRGUċEQ\SURMHNWRSDUW\QDPHFKDQL]PDFK ZLNLGRVWċSQ\SRGDGUHVHPKWWSVPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJLVâXīĆF\]DFHQWUXP NRRUG\QDFMLZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZ2GE\ZDMĆVLċZQLPG\VNXVMHQDGJOREDOQ\PL ]DVDGDPL]ZDOF]DQLHPZDQGDOL]PyZREHMPXMĆF\FKZLHOHSURMHNWyZLG]LDâDQLDPL VWHZDUGyZ:LNLPHGLD KWWSVPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL5HTXHVWVBIRUBFRPPHQW5HPRYHB)RXQGHUB IODJ

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT?

DZIECIĘCA PORNOGRAFIA? :NZLHWQLX/DUU\6DQJHUSRVXQĆâVLċGRZ\VâDQLDOLVWXGR)%, ZNWyU\PRVNDUīDâVHUZLV:LNLPHGLD&RPPRQVRSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLH SRUQRJUDÀLG]LHFLċFHM0HW] SRPLMDMĆFMXīNZHVWLċLQQ\FK PDWHULDâyZ]]DNUHVXWZDUGHMSRUQRJUDÀL*âyZQ\SU]HND]OLVWXSU]H ]QDF]RQ\GODPHGLyZE\âMDVQ\:LNLSHGLDFKRýSUH]HQWXMHVLHELHMDNR VHUZLVHGXNDF\MQ\LVâXīĆF\V]HU]HQLXZLHG]\]DZLHUDQLHGZX]QDF]QH LSRWHQFMDOQLHREUDĩOLZHDQDZHWSU]HVWċSF]HWUHğFLJUDÀF]QH7HPDW RFKRF]RSRGMĆâVHUZLV)R[1HZVFRP:LQWHUF &DâRğýPRJâD E\ýNOċVNĆGODZL]HUXQNXUXFKX:LNLPHGLD-LPER:DOHV]GHF\GRZDâ īHQLH]EċGQHVĆV]\ENLHG]LDâDQLD3RVSLHV]QLH]DOHFLâE\VSRâHF]QRğý RSUDFRZDâDZ\W\F]QHGRW\F]ĆFHJUDÀNRMHGQR]QDF]QLHVHNVXDOQ\P FKDUDNWHU]H :\âDQLDMĆF\VLċNRQVHQVXVQLHE\âMHGQDNMHGQR]QDF]Q\3RF]ĆWNRZR :DOHVDUJXPHQWRZDâīHQDOHī\XVXQĆýSOLNLSRGOHJDMĆFHV]F]HJyâRZ\P XVWDOHQLRPDPHU\NDĕVNLHMXVWDZ\RRFKURQLHG]LHFLLQLHSU]\]ZRLWRğFL &KLOG3URWHFWLRQDQG2EVFHQLW\(QIRUFHPHQW$FW 3yĩQLHMMHGQDN SRV]HU]\âNRQLHF]QRğýRFKURQ\SU]HGQLHPRUDOQRğFLĆRJUDÀNLLGLD JUDP\3U]HZLGXMĆFNOċVNċ35RZĆGRGDWNRZRVDPXVXQĆâSOLNyZ JUDÀF]Q\FKZW\PLOXVWUDFMHZ\NRQDQHSU]H]VDP\FKZLNLPHGLDQ LZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHZDUW\NXâDFKRWHPDW\FHVHNVXMDNWHīKLVWRU\F]QH SUDFHX]QDQ\FKDUW\VWyZ3UDZGĆMHVWīHF]ċğýXVXQLċW\FKSOLNyZ SU]HGVWDZLDâDPRFQRMHGQR]QDF]QHWUHğFL]GHF\GRZDQLHQLHSU]\]ZRLWH GODSHZQ\FKNUċJyZRGELRUFyZ'ODSU]\NâDGXEDUG]RNRQWURZHUV\MQD E\âDJUDÀND)HOLFLHQD5RSVDEHOJLMVNLHJRPDODU]DG]LHZLċWQDVWRZLHF] QHJR]DW\WXâRZDQDĞZLċWD7HUHVDSU]HGVWDZLDâDVLRVWUċ]DNRQQĆ XEUDQĆMHG\QLHZF]HSLHFLEXW\Xī\ZDMĆFĆGLOGD]HNVWDW\F]Q\PZ\ UD]HPWZDU]\LNUZLĆFLHNQĆFĆ]SRFKZ\6]F]HJyOQLHZRF]HNLZDQLX QDNU]\īRZ\RJLHĕDUJXPHQWDFMLPHGLyZ:DOHVSUDZGRSRGREQLH FKFLDâGRSURZDG]LýGRXVXQLċFLDQDMEDUG]LHMNRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKWUHğFL FKRýE\SRWRE\SU]\ZUyFLýMHSyĩQLHMSRGRJâċEQ\PSU]HP\ğOHQLX VSUDZ\LXVWDOHQLXVHQVRZQ\FK]DVDGSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý

3OLN GRVWċSQ\ SRG DGUHVHP KWWSFRPPRQVZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL)LOH )&$OLFLHQB5RSVBB6DLQWH7KpUqVHSQJ

205

206

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 8VXZDQLHUHSURGXNFMLG]LHâV]WXNLZ\ZRâDâRMHGQDNSURWHVW\3R GREQĆUHDNFMċZ\ZRâDâRXVXZDQLHJUDÀNHGXNDF\MQ\FKZ\NRU]\VW\ZD Q\FKZKDVâDFKRSLVXMĆF\FK]DFKRZDQLDVHNVXDOQHQDSU]\NâDGÀVWLQJ Z\NRU]\VWDQ\REUD]HN-LPERNLONXNURWQLHRNUHğOLâMDNRÅF]\VWĆ ī\ZĆSURVWĆSRUQRJUDÀċµ :LNLSHG\ğFLVĆV]F]HJyOQLHZ\F]XOHQLQD MDNLNROZLHNZ\UD]FHQ]XU\DGRWHJRQLHFKċWQLQDU]XFDQLXRJUDQLF]Hĕ QDSU]HGVWDZLDQLHNRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKFKRýOHJDOQ\FKWUHğFL&]ċğý DGPLQLVWUDWRUyZSRGĆī\âDğODGDPL-LPEROHF]MHV]F]HZLċNV]DOLF]ED Xī\WNRZQLNyZZ\UD]LâDVZyMVSU]HFLZWDNLPG]LDâDQLRP-LPER]DF]Ćâ PDVRZRXVXZDýJUDÀNLEH]G\VNXVMLF]\FKRýE\RğZLDGF]HQLDRZ\MĆW NRZRSLOQHMSRWU]HELHSRGMċFLDNURNyZ]DUDGF]\FK3RNRQIURQWDFML ]NLONRPDDGPLQLVWUDWRUDPL&RPPRQV]DF]ċâDVLċZRMQDHG\F\MQD ZWUDNFLHNWyUHM-LPERQDOHJDâīHG\VNXVMDMHVWPRīOLZDDOHGRSLHUR SRW\PMDNVNRĕF]\VSU]ĆWDQLHQLHRGSRZLHGQLFKSOLNyZ:SRğSLHFKX QLHSRSURVLâQLNRJRRSRPRFOHF]VDPSRGMĆâG]LDâDQLDQLHRGSRZLDGDMĆF WHīQDS\WDQLDVSRâHF]QRğFL]RF]HNLZDQĆV]F]HJyâRZRğFLĆ&RJRUV]D ]LJQRURZDâSRZDīQHNRQVHNZHQFMHWHFKQLF]QHXVXZDQLDSOLNyZNWyUH E\â\Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQHZDUW\NXâDFKZZLHOXZHUVMDFKMċ]\NRZ\FK:LNL SHGLLJUR]LâWHīOXG]LRPSU]\ZUDFDMĆF\PVNDVRZDQHSOLNLīHMHğOL QLHXVWĆSLĆ]RVWDQĆ]DEORNRZDQL

3OLNGRVWċSQ\SRGDGUHVHPKWWSFRPPRQVZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL)LOH:LNLIL VWLQJSQJ :DUWRFK\ED]D]QDF]\ýīHZPDUFXQLHPLHFND:LNLSHGLD]GHF\GRZDâD R]QLHVLHQLXRJUDQLF]HĕQDURG]DMHPDWHULDâXHNVSRQRZDQHJRQDJâyZQHMVWURQLH SURMHNWXLPLPRZLHOXJâRVyZVSU]HFLZXSRFKRG]ĆF\FKRGF]\WHOQLNyZXWU]\PDâD QDJâyZQHMVWURQLHDUW\NXâ]LOXVWURZDQ\]EOLīHQLHPOXG]NLHMSRFKZ\'\VNXVMD ZHZQĆWU]SURMHNWXSRGV\FDQDNRPHQWDU]DPLUR]]âRV]F]RQ\FKF]\WHOQLNyZ]DP NQċâDVLċZW\VLĆFDFKVâyZKWWSGHZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLDB'LVNXVVLRQ +DXSWVHLWH9XOYD OHF]EH]Z\UDĩQHJR]DZHWRZDQLDZ\HNVSRQRZDQHJRZVHUZL VLHKDVâD3RGREQLHPLPRZLHOXSURWHVWyZLGâXJLHMG\VNXVMLZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNL SHGLLZKDğOH>>-\OODQGV3RVWHQB0XKDPPDGBFDUWRRQV@@]DFKRZDQRNDU\NDWXUċ SURURND0DKRPHWDRSXEOLNRZDQĆSU]H]GXĕVNLG]LHQQLNÅ-\OODQGV3RVWHQµ ZURNX²PLPRīHU\VXQHNX]QDQ\]RVWDâSU]H]ZLHOXPX]XâPDQ]DZ\MĆW NRZRREUDĩOLZ\]DğMHJRSXEOLNDFMDZJD]HFLHVNRĕF]\âDVLċJZDâWRZQ\PLSURWH VWDPLDQDZHWG]LDâDQLDPLWHUURU\VW\F]Q\PL6SRâHF]QRğFLUXFKX:LNLPHGLDQLH VĆMHGQDNZVWDQLHRVLĆJQĆýNRQVHQVXVXZNZHVWLLWHJRMDN]RUJDQL]RZDýILOWUR ZDQLHJUDILN²GREU\PSRGVXPRZDQLHPZLHOXG\VNXVMLZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKMHVW VWURQDKWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL&RQWURYHUVLDOBFRQWHQW7LPHOLQH *UDILNLXVXQLċWH]VHUZLVX:LNLPHGLD&RPPRQV]QLNDMĆ]HVWURQZV]\VWNLFK SURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLDJG]LHMH]DPLHV]F]RQR-HVWWRVNXWNLHPG]LDâDQLDVSHFMDO QHJRVNU\SWXNWyU\SLOQXMHE\DUW\NXâ\SRND]\ZDâ\JUDILNLDQLHOLQNLZLRGĆFH GRQLNĆG-HGQ\P]HIHNWyZXERF]Q\FKG]LDâDQLDWHJRPHFKDQL]PXMHVWMHGQDN

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? +HUE\WK\PHDGPLQLVWUDWRURUD]FKHFNXVHUZVHUZLVLH&RPPRQV ]DS\WDâ-LPERQDMHJRVWURQLHG\VNXVML =QRZX SRZVWU]\PXMċVLċSU]HGJUXELDĕVWZHPDOH]DFKRZDQLHNWyUH ZLG]ċMHVWSRSURVWXQLHGR]DDNFHSWRZDQLD-HğOLMHVWHğG\NWDWRUHP WR2.&L]QDVNWyU\PQDVHUFXOHī\GREUR&RPPRQV²NDīGHJR]D NĆWNDWHJRSURMHNWX²SRSURVWXSU\VQĆVWĆG]RVWDZLDMĆFW\ONRNDUWNċ E\RVWDWQLSU]\Z\MğFLX]JDVLâğZLDWâRRLOHQLHVNRĕF]\V]]WDNLPVW\OHP ÅSU]\ZyG]WZDµ7DNWDNWRVDUND]P 2ZV]HPGRZ\NRQDQLDMHVWURERWDGRZ\U]XFHQLDMHVWVSRURğPLHFL DOHMHVWWHīVSRâHF]QRğýNWyUDRGGâXīV]HJRF]DVXVWDUDVLċSRSUDZLDý WHQSURMHNWÅLQZHVWXMĆFµZQLHJRFDâNLHPVSRURRG7ZRMHMRVWDWQLHM ZL]\W\3U]HP\ğOWRPRīH²WRQLHMHVWSU]\SDGHNDQJLHOVNLHJR:LNL YHUVLW\WRNOXF]RZ\SURMHNWNWyU\PDVZRMĆZ\VRNĆ ZDUWRğýV]F]H JyOQLHGODW\FKNWyU]\PXVLċSRğZLċFLOLLNWyU\FKWHQSURMHNWREFKRG]L ²+HUE\WDONWK\PHPDMD87&

-DNRSLVDâV\WXDFMċMHGHQ]HVWHZDUGyZZXG]LHORQ\PPLZ\ZLDG]LH :JURQLHVWHZDUGyZ]DF]ċâDVLċG\VNXVMD²FKROHUDFRPDP\URELý IDFHWPDQLHUyZQRSRGGHNOHP&]\PDP\PXRGHEUDýXSUDZQLHQLD F]\FR"6WHZDUG]LEċGĆF\ZNRQWDNFLH]IXQGDFMĆPyZLOLīHOXG]LH ]:0)WHīE\OL]V]RNRZDQLQLHFKFLHOLSRGHMPRZDýG]LDâDĕMDNRSUDFRZ QLF\IXQGDFML:NRĕFXVWHZDUG]LXVWDOLOLīHPRīH]DMğýNRQLHF]QRğý ]DEORNRZDQLD-LPERLSR]EDZLHQLDJRXSUDZQLHĕDOHZWHG\RGSXğFLâ

:GâXJLHMLJRUĆFHMGHEDFLHNWyUDSU]HWRF]\âDVLċQLHW\ONRQDVWUR QDFKG\VNXVMLZVHUZLVLH&RPPRQVOHF]UyZQLHīQDOLğFLHG\VNXV\MQHM IXQGDFML:DOHV]RVWDâRVWURVNU\W\NRZDQ\LRND]MRQDOQLHREUDīRQ\ :\WNQLċWRPXWHīīHMHJR]DFKRZDQLHZ&RPPRQVZ\ZRâDâRZUDīHQLH MDNE\VHUZLVIDNW\F]QLHE\âUHSR]\WRULXPPDWHULDâyZSRUQRJUDÀF]Q\FK

NRQLHF]QRğýSRQRZQHJRUċF]QHJRXPLHV]F]DQLDZKDVâDFKNDīGHM]SU]\ZUDFDQ\FK JUDILN :V]\VWNLHF\WDW\]G\VNXVMLSRFKRG]Ć]OLVW\G\VNXV\MQHMIXQGDFMLRLOHQLH ]D]QDF]RQRLQDF]HM$UFKLZXPZLDGRPRğFLGRVWċSQHMHVWSRGDGUHVHPKWWSOLVWV ZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOIRXQGDWLRQO0D\WKUHDGKWPO

207

208

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SRGF]DVJG\ZSU]HZDīDMĆFHMZLċNV]RğFL]DZLHUDâMHG\QLHPDWHULDâ\ HGXNDF\MQH-LPERWDNEURQLâVZRMHJR]GDQLDPDMD :V]\VWNLHPHGLD]DFKZLOċREU]XFLâ\E\QDVEâRWHP]DSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLH WZDUGHMSRUQRJUDÀLLELHUQRğýZW\PWHPDFLH7HUD]RERZLĆ]XMHZHUVMD ZNWyUHMRF]\V]F]DP\QDV]H]DVRE\-HVWHPGXPQ\]WHJRīHWDNZâDğQLH DNWXDOQLHSLV]ĆPHGLDLSU]\NURPLīHE\GRWHJRGRSURZDG]LýPXVLDâHP ZHMğýQDRGFLVNVSRUHMJUXSLHOXG]L

1DIXQGDF\MQHMOLğFLHG\VNXV\MQHMSRSDUFLHGODG]LDâDĕ-LPERZ\ UD]LâRNLONXF]âRQNyZ5DG\3RZLHUQLF]HM7U]HED]DXZDī\ýīH]JUDÀN XVXQLċW\FKSU]H]-LPERSU]\ZUyFRQRMHG\QLHRNRâRSRâRZċFRR]QDF]D īHZSRQDGSRâRZLHSU]\SDGNyZPLDâUDFMċLG]LDâDâ]JRGQLH]]DVDGDPL VSRâHF]QRğFL6SUDZDE\âDMHGQDNRZLHOHZLċNV]DQLīUDFMDOXEMHMEUDN ZXVXZDQLXJUDÀN-DN]DXZDī\â.DPHUDDG3MRWUMHGHQ]GRğZLDGF]R Q\FKDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ&RPPRQVPDMD 1LNWRSUyF]VSRâHF]QRğFL&RPPRQVRUD]5DG\3RZLHUQLF]HMQLHPD SUDZDXVWDODý]DVDGSURMHNWX7\WHīQLHPDV]WHJRSUDZD=DFKRZDâHğ VLċMDNZDQGDO²NDīG\LQQ\Xī\WNRZQLNZ7ZRMHMV\WXDFML]RVWDâE\EH] WHUPLQRZR]DEORNRZDQ\1LHFKRG]LZFDOHRSRUQRJUDÀċW\ONRRWRīH QDGXī\âHğVZRMHJRVWDWXVXZQDMJRUV]\VSRVyEMDNLNWRNROZLHNMHVW VRELHZVWDQLHZ\REUD]Lý*G\E\ğ]DVWRVRZDâVLċGRSU]\MċW\FKSURFHGXU ]DPLDVWNDVRZDýSOLNLQDSUDZRLOHZRZV]\VWNRGDâRE\VLċZ\MDğQLý &]ċğýJUDÀNLWDN]RVWDâDE\XVXQLċWD 7DNLH]DFKRZDQLHMHVWQLHGRSXV]F]DOQHLQLHZ\EDF]DOQHÅ1DMSLHUZ NDVXMSRWHPS\WDMµQLHMHVWVNUyFRQĆZHUVMĆWU\EXG]LDâDQLDVSRâHF]QRğFL &RPPRQV1LJG\WDNQLHE\âR-HVWHğGXPQ\SRZLDGDV]"0DV]GRWHJR SUDZR=QLV]F]\âHğZV]HONĆXIQRğýNWyUĆPLDâDGR&LHELHVSRâHF]QRğý LV]F]HU]HPyZLĆFFDâNRZLFLHVRELHQDWR]DVâXī\âHğ -HğOLQDMOHSV]\PVSRVREHPMHVWZHGâXJ&LHELHZâDīHQLHOXG]LRPQD RGFLVNLWRPRīH]DPLDVWÅHQF\NORSHGLLNWyUĆNDīG\PRīHHG\WRZDýµ SRZLQLHQHğ]DGHNODURZDýīH:LNLSHGLDWRÅSURMHNWNWyU\G]LDâD]JRGQLH ]ZLG]LPLVLċLIDQWD]MDPLE\âHJRZâDğFLFLHODµ" =QLHVPDF]RQ\E\â\DGPLQLVWUDWRU&RPPRQV

.DPHUDDG3MRWUQDGDOMHVWDGPLQLVWUDWRUHP&RPPRQVOHF]VSRUH JURQRXī\WNRZQLNyZZâĆF]\ZV]\ZWROXG]LZ\VRFHGRğZLDGF]RQ\FK

CZY LECI Z NAMI PILOT? MDNWHīQLHFRDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZ]GHF\GRZDâRVLċRSXğFLý&RPPRQVRUD] RJyOQLHUXFK:LNLPHGLD]XZDJLQD]DFKRZDQLH-LPER 5yZQROHJOHGRG\VNXVMLQDOLğFLHVWZRU]RQD]RVWDâDSHW\FMDGR-LPER NWyUDZFLĆJXSLċFLXGQL]\VNDâDSRSDUFLHSRQDGXī\WNRZQLNyZ VSU]HFLZZREHFQLHM]JâRVLâRPQLHMQLīRVyE Z]\ZDMĆFDJRGRV]D QRZDQLDSURFHVyZL]DVDGXVWDORQ\FKSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý]DğZU]DGNLFK SU]\SDGNDFKZ\PDJDMĆF\FKQDW\FKPLDVWRZHMLQWHUZHQFML²MDVQHJR SRVWDZLHQLDVSUDZ\ZâĆF]QLH]HV]F]HJyâRZ\PREMDğQLHQLHPVZRLFK G]LDâDĕ -LPERZNRĕFXSU]HSURVLâ²LWRNLONDNURWQLH²Z\MDğQLDMĆFīHPLDâ SRF]XFLHSUHVMLV\WXDFML1LHZLHOHWRMHGQDNSRPRJâR6SUDZDGRSURZD G]LâDGRSRZURWXGRNZHVWLLZQLRVNXRRGHEUDQLH-LPERMHJRPLċG]\ SURMHNWRZ\FKSU]\ZLOHMyZLVSRZRGRZDâD]PLDQċUR]NâDGXJâRVyZQD VWURQLHJâRVRZDQLDQDGXVXQLċFLHPÁDJLÅ]DâRī\FLHODµ]NRQWD:DOHVD '\VNXVMDQDGVWDWXVHP-LPERE\âDJRUĆFD]DP\NDMĆFVLċZW\ VLĆFDFKVâyZDXG]LDâZQLHMZ]LċâREDUG]RZLHOXXF]HVWQLNyZUXFKX :LNLPHGLD'RPDMD]DSR]EDZLHQLHP-LPERXSUDZQLHĕ]DJâR VRZDâRRVyEGRGDWNRZHRVyE]DJâRVRZDâR]DWĆGHF\]MĆZFLĆJX NROHMQ\FKPLHVLċF\ 7\ONRRVyEZ\UD]LâRVZyMVSU]HFLZZNROHMQ\FK PLHVLĆFDFKMHV]F]H RVyEZW\PMDZ\UD]LâRVZRMĆQHXWUDOQRğý =DUyZQRRJyOQLHZ\VRNDOLF]EDJâRVyZMDNLLFKVNUDMQDSRODU\]DFMD RUD]Xī\W\HPRFMRQDOQ\WRQZ\SRZLHG]LMDVQRZVND]XMĆīHVSRâHF] QRğýX]QDâDNZHVWLċSR]EDZLHQLD:DOHVDXSUDZQLHĕ]DLVWRWQĆ :LHOXXF]HVWQLNyZG\VNXVMLZ\UDīDâRVZRMĆ]âRğýF]ċğý]QLFKZVSR VyEVHQVRZQ\F]ċğýQLHGRNRĕFD²SRMDZLâ\VLċQSSURSR]\FMH]EDQR ZDQLD-LPERZHZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWDFKF]\SRNU]\NLZDQLDRG\NWD WXU]HLRW\PīHPLQĆâMXīF]DVERVNLFKU]ĆGyZ6SRURNRPHQWDWRUyZ Z\UDīDMĆF\FKVLċZEDUG]LHMF\ZLOL]RZDQ\VSRVyEZVND]\ZDâRīH SURMHNW\:LNLPHGLDPRJĆFLHUSLHýQDÅV\QGURP]DâRī\FLHODµLīHGREU]H E\âRE\JG\E\-LPERSU]HV]HGâJG]LHLQG]LHM3RZVWDZDâ\WHīVSRNRMQH DQDOL]\ZVW\OX]DF\WRZDQHMQLīHMZ\SRZLHG]LXī\WNRZQLND'FRHW]HH GRğZLDGF]RQHJRDGPLQLVWUDWRUDDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLL&RPPRQV NWyU\QDSLVDâSRSLHUDMĆFRGHEUDQLH:DOHVRZLÁDJL]DâRī\FLHOD -LPER:DOHVMHVWGOD:LNLSHGLLGREURG]LHMVWZHPMDNRMHMSU]HGVWDZLFLHO LU]HF]QLNMHGQDNJG\SUyEXMHHJ]HNZRZDýDXWRNUDW\F]QLHVZRMH

KWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL3HWLWLRQBWRB-LPER

209

210

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... XSUDZQLHQLDSRMDZLDMĆVLċSUREOHP\FRREVHUZRZDOLğP\MXīNLOND NURWQLH 7DNLH]DZV]HEċGĆNRQVHNZHQFMHQLH]DOHīQLHRGWHJRNWR G]LHUī\GRGDWNRZHXSUDZQLHQLD-HJRQLHGDZQHG]LDâDQLDE\â\V]F]H JyOQ\PQLHZ\SDâHPSRND]XMĆF\PEUDNSRGVWDZRZHJRNRQWDNWX]SUR FHVDPLLWU\EHPSRVWċSRZDQLDVSRâHF]QRğFL&RPPRQV:VSLHUDP PRīOLZRğýSRGHMPRZDQLDSU]H]5DGċ3RZLHUQLF]ĆQLHSRSXODUQ\FK G]LDâDĕZWU\ELHDZDU\MQ\POHF]QLHSRZLQQRVLċWHJRURELýSU]H] QLHQD]ZDQHEH]RVRERZHNRQWDUHSUH]HQWXMĆFH]ELRURZĆZROċF]âRQNyZ 5DG\=DFKċFDPE\-LPER]U]HNâVLċRJyOQ\FKXSUDZQLHĕLG]LDâDâWDN MDNNDīG\LQQ\DGPLQLVWUDWRUSRGOHJDMĆFW\PVDP\PZ\PRJRPLRJUD QLF]HQLRP-HğOLMHVWWRQLHPRīOLZHSURV]ċ5DGċRSRQRZQHUR]ZDīHQLH V]F]HJyOQ\FKXSUDZQLHĕ-LPERE\QLHGRSXğFLýGRNRQÁLNWyZZSU]\ V]âRğFL²'FRHW]HHPDMD87&

PDMD-LPERSU]\FK\OLâVLċGRīĆGDĕVZRLFKSU]HFLZQLNyZ :ZLDGRPRğFLZ\VâDQHMQDOLVWċG\VNXV\MQĆIXQGDFMLRğZLDGF]\â :LQWHUHVLHWHJRE\GDOV]DG\VNXVMDSRğZLċFRQDE\âDÀOR]RÀLG]LDâDQLD SURMHNWyZLLFK]DZDUWRğFLQLH]DğWHPXMDNQD]E\WSRFKRSQLHSRVWĆ SLâHPXVXQĆâHPSUDNW\F]QLHZV]\VWNLHQDU]ċG]LD]DZDUWHZ]HVWDZLH XSUDZQLHĕ]DâRī\FLHOD8VXQĆâHPQDZHWPRīOLZRğýHG\WRZDQLDSRâR ZLF]QLH]DEH]SLHF]RQ\FKVWURQFKRýQDGDOPDPPRīOLZRğýSRGJOĆGDQLD UR]PDLWHM]DZDUWRğFL 1LHFKFċE\ýDQLW\UDQHPDQLG\NWDWRUHP1LHFKFċE\ğP\WRF]\OL RWRERMHJG\īRGFLĆJDWRQDVRGIDNW\F]QHMSUDF\

:\GDâRVLċWRQLHFRXVSRNRLýV\WXDFMċ&RFLHNDZHMDNRND]DâRVLċ QLHZLHOHSyĩQLHMQLH]DOHīQLHRGG\VNXVMLQDGW\PF]\]DVDGQHMHVW ZRJyOHXWU]\PDQLHZ:LNLPHGLD&RPPRQVF]ċğFLJUDÀNV]\ENLHXVX ZDQLHSOLNyZSU]H]-LPERE\âRSU]\QDMPQLHMGREU]HVNRRUG\QRZDQ\P UXFKHPSUHZHQF\MQ\P6HUZLV)R[1HZVFRPQLHW\ONRQDGDOSXEOL NRZDâPDWHULDâ\VXJHUXMĆFHīHZSURMHNWDFK:LNLPHGLDPRīQD]QD OHĩýG]LHFLċFĆSRUQRJUDÀċDOHSRGMĆâWHīNRQWDNW]GDUF]\ĕFDPLNRU SRUDF\MQ\PLSU]HND]XMĆF\PLğURGNL:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQQS 0LFURVRIW*RRJOH%HVW%X\)RUG)RXQGDWLRQ2SHQ6RFLHW\,QVWLWXWH 86$1HWZRUNVL>&RPPRQVBWDON6H[XDOBFRQWHQW@@ :\GDMHPLVLċīHE\âDWRDNFMDZ\MĆWNRZRL]DVNDNXMĆFRQLHGRU]HF]QD OHF]EH]ZĆWSLHQLDSRGMċWDZGREUHMZLHU]H*âyZQHSUREOHP\NWyUH VLċZQLHMXMDZQLâ\WR SDQLNDLV]\ENLHG]LDâDQLH-LPEREH]SUyE\ XVWDOHQLDNRQVHQVXVXL SU]\ZRâDQLHDXWRU\WHWX]DâRī\FLHODLF]âRQND 5DG\ZWUDNFLHG]LDâDQLD7RFK\EDZâDğQLHWDGUXJDNZHVWLDGRSUR ZDG]LâDGRZ\DOLHQRZDQLDF]ċğFLDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZNWyU]\RSXğFLOL SURMHNW²-PDEHOWDONF]HUZFD87&

:F]HUZFX]DVDG\VSLVDQHZGRNXPHQFLH>>HQ:3&KLOGSUR WHFWLRQ@@]RVWDâ\X]QDQH]DRÀFMDOQLHRERZLĆ]XMĆFHZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNL SHGLLL]DWZLHUG]RQHSU]H]-LPER:DOHVD7RSRVXQLċFLHQLHZ\ZRâDâR QLHSRNRMyZSU]\MċWRMHMDNRZ\QLNDMĆFH]]DVDG\>>HQ:3&21(; &(37@@VWDQRZLĆFHMīHÅRNUHğORQH]DVDG\LGHF\]MHSRGMċWHSU]H] :LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQMHMSUDFRZQLNyZLF]âRQNyZ.RPLWHWX$UELWUD īRZHJROHīĆSR]D]DVLċJLHPNRQVHQVXVXHG\WRUyZµ6SRâHF]QRğý V]F]HJyOQLHHG\WRU]\DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLZ\ND]DâD]UR]XPLHQLHGOD SRWU]HE\Z\HOLPLQRZDQLDQLHOHJDOQ\FKLV]NRGOLZ\FKJUDÀN:ğFLHNâRğý VSRâHF]QRğFLXMDZQLDâDVLċW\ONRZSU]\SDGNDFKSRVWU]HJDQHJRâDPD QLDSURFHGXUSU]\HJ]HNZRZDQLXLQDGXī\ZDQLXQLHIRUPDOQ\FK PHFKDQL]PyZZâDG]\ 1DMFLHNDZV]HZ\GDMHVLċMHGQDNWRFR]SU]\ZyG]WZHP:DOHVDG]LDâR VLċSyĩQLHM%H]SRğUHGQLH]DDQJDīRZDQLH-LPERZHJ]HNZRZDQLH ]DVDGHG\WRZDQLHLÅPDâĆDGPLQLVWUDFMċµZğUyGHG\WRUyZ:LNLSHGLL

211

212

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... VSDGâROHF]MHJRZSâ\ZQDV]HU]HMSRMPRZDQĆVSRâHF]QRğýUXFKX :LNLPHGLD]QDF]QLHZ]UyVâ'ODSU]\NâDGXSU]\ZyG]WZR-LPERE\âR NOXF]RZHGODDNFMLSURWHVWDF\MQHMSU]HFLZNRZSURZDG]HQLXZ6WDQDFK =MHGQRF]RQ\FKXVWDZ623$L3,3$:URNX:DOHV]DSRF]ĆWNR ZDâG\VNXVMċXUXFKRPLâJâRVRZDQLHL]RUJDQL]RZDâG]LDâDQLDVSRâHF] QRğFLZVSRVyENWyU\SRV]HURNLHMGHEDFLHGRSURZDG]LâGRVWUDMNX VW\F]QLDZV]\VWNLHVWURQ\DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]RVWDâ\]D F]HUQLRQH]DğVSRâHF]QRğFLLQQ\FKSURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLDZ\UD]Lâ\ VZRMĆVROLGDUQRğý]SURWHVWHPÅ7KH1HZğPLHFK@F]\OLJG\RGGDODVLċVWHUHRW\SWHJRīHSUDFXMċ DNWXDOQLHGOD:LHONLHJR6]DWDQD

3RVWU]HJDQLH:0)QLHMHVWRJyOQLHWDNQHJDW\ZQHMDNPyJâE\WR ZVND]\ZDýSRZ\īV]\F\WDWOHF]ZVSRâHF]QRğFLLVWQLHMHGRğýVLOQLH SU]HNRQDQLHīHWRZâDğQLHVSRâHF]QRğýLZRORQWDULXV]HVĆVLâĆQDSċGRZĆ UXFKX:LNLPHGLD]DğIXQGDFMDVSHâQLDIXQNFMċSRPRFQLF]ĆLPDVâX ī\ýRJyOQLHZROLHG\WRUyZ7DNLSXQNWZLG]HQLDMHVW]UHV]WĆSRF]ċğFL VSyMQ\]ZL]MĆVDPHMIXQGDFML 2GVHSDURZDQLHVLċIXQGDFMLRGVSRâHF]QRğFLLZ\ND]\ZDQHSU]H]QLĆ SUREOHP\NRPXQLNDF\MQHG]LDâDMĆUyZQLHīZGUXJĆVWURQċ6SRâHF]QRğFL SURMHNWyZZVSRVyEEDUG]RQLHRGSRZLHG]LDOQ\QLHDQRQVXMĆVZRLFK G]LDâDĕQDZHWWDNLFKNWyUHZ\ZLHUDMĆEH]SRğUHGQLLQDW\FKPLDVWRZ\ ZSâ\ZQDIXQGDFMċ-HGQ\P]QLHGDZQ\FKSU]\NâDGyZNWyU\Z\ZRâDâ V]RNLQLHGRZLHU]DQLHZIXQGDFMLE\âVWUDMNZâRVNLFKZLNLSHG\VWyZ 6SRâHF]QRğýZâRVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]DGHF\GRZDâDRZ]LċFLXXG]LDâXZSUR WHğFLHSU]HFLZNRXVWDZLHRSRGVâXFKDFK²''/²LQWHUFHWWD]LRQLQDG NWyUĆGHEDWRZDâZâRVNLSDUODPHQW3URWHVWRZDQRSU]HGHZV]\VWNLP SU]HFLZNRDUW\NXâRZLXVWDZ\NWyU\QDNâDGDâQDZV]\VWNLHVHUZLV\ LQWHUQHWRZHG]LDâDMĆFHZH:âRV]HFKRERZLĆ]HNRSXEOLNRZDQLDQD īĆGDQLHZQLRVNRGDZF\NRUHNW\LQIRUPDFMLNWyUHWHQX]QD]DV]NRG]ĆFH MHJRZL]HUXQNRZLZFLĆJXJRG]LQRGZH]ZDQLDEH]SUDZDGRNRPHQ WDU]D.DUĆ]DQLHGRSHâQLHQLHWHMSRZLQQRğFLPLDâRE\ýGRW\VLċF\ HXUR%\PRFQR]D]QDF]\ýVZyMSXQNWZLG]HQLDRGGRSDĩG]LHU QLNDZâRVND:LNLSHGLDSU]HUZDâDXGRVWċSQLDQLHWUHğFL%\âWR SLHUZV]\SU]\SDGHNRGFLċFLDGRVWċSXGRWUHğFLZJHğFLHSURWHVWX ZSURMHNWDFK:LNLPHGLD '\VNXVMDSURZDG]RQDZHZQĆWU]VSRâHF]QRğFLZâRVNLFKHG\WRUyZ Z\GRVWDâDVLċGRRJyâXZLNLPHGLDQGRSLHURSRIDNFLH1DOLğFLHG\V NXV\MQHMIXQGDFMLZĆWHNVWUDMNXSRMDZLâVLċZGQLXMHJRUR]SRF]ċFLD

3HâQDWUHğýPDQLIHVWX]QDMGXMHVLċSRGDGUHVHPKWWSLWZLNLSHGLDRUJZLQGH[ SKS"WLWOH :LNLSHGLD&RPXQLFDWRBBRWWREUHBHQ ROGLG =REKWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLPHGLDB)RUXP,WDOLDQB:LNLSHGLD& ORVHBWKHB,WDOLDQBFKDSWHURUD]G\VNXVMċSRGDGUHVHPKWWSOLVWVZLNLPHGLDRUJ SLSHUPDLOIRXQGDWLRQO2FWREHUWKUHDGKWPO =REKWWSOLVWVZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOIRXQGDWLRQO2FWREHUKWPO

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII ]DğIXQGDFMDRFDâHMVSUDZLHGRZLHG]LDâDVLċNLONDJRG]LQSU]HGUR]SR F]ċFLHPDNFML-DNSRZLHG]LDâPLMHGHQ]SUDFRZQLNyZIXQGDFML =GHF\GRZDQLHPLHOLğP\SRF]XFLH]V]RNRZDQLDP\ğOHOLğP\Å&KROHUD FRWHUD]]URELP\"&RğWDNLHJRQLJG\VLċQLHZ\GDU]\âRµ=GUXJLHMVWURQ\ XGHU]\âRPQLHQLHWRīHGRZLHG]LHOLğP\VLċRIDNFLHQDJRG]LQ\SU]HG MHJR]DLVWQLHQLHPQLHWRīHQLH]DXZDī\OLğP\īHVSRâHF]QRğýSURMHNWX GRFKRG]LGRMDNLHMğGHF\]MLDOHIDNWīHVSRâHF]QRğýQLHF]XâDSRWU]HE\ SRZLDGRPLHQLDIXQGDFMLRSURWHğFLHQDGâXīHMQLīJRG]LQ\SU]HGMHJR SRGMċFLHP%\âRWDNMDNE\QLNW]HG\WXMĆF\FKZâRVNĆ:LNLSHGLċQLH SRP\ğODâÅNXUF]ċSRZLQQLğP\SRZLHG]LHýRW\POXG]LRPNWyU]\ ]DU]ĆG]DMĆQDV]\PLVHUZHUDPLµ²QLNWQDPQLHGDâ]QDý%\âRWDN GODWHJRīHFK\EDVSRâHF]QRğýMHVWU]HF]\ZLğFLHPHQWDOQLHEDUG]LHM VDPRG]LHOQDRGIXQGDFML&]\WDNDMHVWSU]\F]\QDWHJRīH]QDPLQLH UR]PDZLDMĆF]\PRīHNLONDQLH]UR]XPLDâ\FKVâyZ ²WHJRQLHMHVWHP SHZLHQ6SRMU]HQLHQD]XSHâQLHRGPLHQQHSRGHMğFLHGRIXQGDFML]H VWURQ\HG\WRUyZE\âRMHGQDNZ\MĆWNRZRLQWHUHVXMĆFH

&DâDV\WXDFMDE\âD]XSHâQLHQLH]ZLĆ]DQD]W\PīHIXQGDFMDF]\5DGD 3RZLHUQLF]DPLDâ\MDNLHNROZLHNZĆWSOLZRğFLFRGRG]LDâDĕVSRâHF]QRğFL :0)QDW\FKPLDVWRZRZWHQVDPG]LHĕZNWyU\PZâRVF\ZLNLSHG\ğFL SRGMċOLDNFMċSURWHVWDF\MQĆ Z\GDâDRğZLDGF]HQLHSRSLHUDMĆFHZâRVNLFK HG\WRUyZ3UREOHPSROHJDâSRSURVWXQDW\PīHZREOLF]XWDNGXīHJR SRVXQLċFLDR]QDF]HQLXSROLW\F]Q\PIXQGDFMD]RVWDâD]DODQDSURğEDPL PHGLyZRNRPHQWDU]LSU]H]MDNLğF]DVPRJâDE\ýSR]RVWDZLRQDVDPD VRELHVWDUDMĆFVLċGRMğýRFRZFDâ\PW\P]DPLHV]DQLXFKRG]L :âRVNLSURWHVWE\âMHGQDNSUHFHGHQVHPNWyU\QLHGâXJRSRWHPER VW\F]QLDGRSURZDG]LâGR]DPNQLċFLDQDJRG]LQ\DQJLHOVNLHM :LNLSHGLLSURWHVWXMĆFHMSU]HFLZNRXVWDZRP6WRS2QOLQH3LUDF\$FW 623$ L3URWHFW,QWHOOHFWXDO3URSHUW\$FW3,3$ QDGNWyU\PLWRF]\âD VLċGHEDWDZDPHU\NDĕVNLP.RQJUHVLHOLSFDURV\MVND:LNL SHGLD]DSURWHVWRZDâDSU]HFLZNRSURSRQRZDQ\PSU]H]'XPċSRSUDZNRP

=REKWWSOLVWVZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOIRXQGDWLRQO2FWREHUKWPO =REKWWSEORJZLNLPHGLDRUJUHJDUGLQJUHFHQWHYHQWVRQLWDOLDQ ZLNLSHGLD =REKWWSVHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL3URWHVWVBDJDLQVWB623$BDQGB3,3$:LNL PHGLDBFRPPXQLW\

245

246

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... GRSUDZDLQIRUPDF\MQHJRSR]ZDODMĆF\PQDZFLĆJDQLHSRV]F]HJyO Q\FKVHUZLVyZLQWHUQHWRZ\FKQDF]DUQHOLVW\L]DND]\ZDQLHNRU]\ VWDQLD]QLFK .ZHVWLDWHJRF]\ORNDOQHVSRâHF]QRğFLHG\WRUyZSURMHNWyZ:LNL PHGLDSRZLQQ\DQJDīRZDýVLċZPLHMVFRZRWRF]RQHG\VNXVMHSROL W\F]QHQLH]RVWDâDMDNGRWĆGMHGQR]QDF]QLHXVWDORQDDGRWHJRQLH MHVWGRNRĕFDMDVQHF]\]DWU]\PDQLHGRVWDUF]DQLDWUHğFLHQF\NORSHGLL LQWHUQHWRZHMZFHOX]DGHPRQVWURZDQLDRNUHğORQHMSRVWDZ\SROLW\F] QHMQLHMHVWVSU]HF]QH]JâyZQĆPLVMĆUXFKX)XQGDFMDRUD]MHM5DGD 3RZLHUQLF]DX]QDâ\īHORNDOQHVSRâHF]QRğFLZ\ND]XMĆVLOQHSRF]XFLH ZâDVQRğFLSURMHNWyZ7RSRF]XFLHMHVWZUċF]ZSLVDQHZRUJDQL]DFMċ UXFKX7ZyUF\:LNLSHGLLÅFKFĆE\ZV]\VF\HG\WRU]\PLHOLVLOQLHMV]H SRF]XFLHZâDG]\LZâDVQRğFLZSURMHNFLHSU]H]FREċGĆVLOQLHMPRW\ZR ZDQLGRSU]\F]\QLDQLDVLċGRMHJRVXNFHVyZµ0DORQHLLQ 'RGDWNRZRZHZV]\VWNLFKWU]HFKSU]\WRF]RQ\FKSU]\SDGNDFK]DDQ JDīRZDQLHSROLW\F]QHE\âR]DZV]H]ZLĆ]DQH]NZHVWLĆZROQRğFL,QWHU QHWXLSU]HFLZVWDZLDQLDVLċFHQ]XU]HLQIRUPDFMLF]\OL]UG]HQQ\PL ZDUWRğFLDPLUXFKX)/266%ULQFNHUL*XQGHODFK&ROHPDQ ]QDMGXMĆF\PLVLċUyZQLHīZFHQWUXPZDUWRğFLUXFKX:LNLPHGLD *DUGQHU0RUHOOD 6]HUV]DVSRâHF]QRğýZLNLPHGLDQ]D F]ċâDMXīSUDFHQDGSURFHGXUDPL]DU]ĆG]DQLDSURWHVWDPLQDVNDOċ FDâ\FKSURMHNWyZOHF]SURSR]\FMHQLHVĆMHV]F]HVNU\VWDOL]RZDQH 2GU]XFHQLHSU]H]:0)GHF\]MLVSRâHF]QRğFLZ\SUDFRZDQHMZWRNX G\VNXVMLZHZQĆWU]SURMHNWXMHVWU]DGNLHDOHWHJRW\SXV\WXDFMHMXī VLċ]GDU]Dâ\3U]\NâDGHPMHVWV\WXDFMD]PDMDNLHG\WRVSR âHF]QRğýDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]GHF\GRZDâDSU]\WâDF]DMĆFĆZLċNV]RğFLĆ JâRVyZSRQDGGZLHWU]HFLHRGGDQ\FKJâRVyZSRSDUâRSURSR]\FMċSU]\ SRQDGJâRVXMĆF\FK E\WZRU]HQLHQRZ\FKDUW\NXâyZE\âRPRīOLZH GRSLHURGODXī\WNRZQLNyZ]DWZLHUG]RQ\FKFRR]QDF]DâRīHXī\WNRZ QLF\QLH]DORJRZDQLOXEFLNWyU]\QLHPDMĆQDVZRLPNRQFLHHG\FML LNLONXGQLRZHJRVWDīXQLHPRJOLE\WZRU]\ýQRZ\FKKDVHâ 3URSR]\FMD PLDâDQDFHOX]PLQLPDOL]RZDQLH]MDZLVNDZDQGDOL]PXLSR]ZROHQLH

=REKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL5XVVLDQB:LNLSHGLD%ODFNRXW =REKWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL3URMHFWZLGHBSURWHVWV KWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL,JQRULQJBFRPPXQLW\BFRQVHQVXV KWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD9LOODJHBSXPSBSURSRVDOV3UR SRVDOBWRBUHTXLUHBDXWRFRQILUPHGBVWDWXVBLQBRUGHUBWRBFUHDWHBDUWLFOHV

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII QRZ\PXī\WNRZQLNRPQDVWRSQLRZHSR]QDZDQLH]DVDGHG\WRZDQLD :LNLSHGLL '\VNXVMDE\âDGâXJDLWUXGQDOHF]MHMXF]HVWQLF\ZNRĕFX]GHF\GR ZDOLīHZDNWXDOQ\PVWDGLXPUR]ZRMXDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLWDNLH UR]ZLĆ]DQLHEċG]LHQDMOHSV]H3RZLHOXPLHVLĆFDFKMHGQDNJG\ZNRĕFX RVLĆJQLċWRNRQVHQVXVXVWDQRZLRQRGâXJRğýRNUHVXSUyEQHJRLSU]HG VWDZLRQRZQLRVHNGRZ\NRQDQLDSURJUDPLVWRP0HGLD:LNLSRMDZLâVLċ ]LFKVWURQ\RVWU\VSU]HFLZ3RF]ĆWNRZRDUJXPHQWRZDOLīHNRQVHQVXV QLHE\âMHGQR]QDF]Q\OHF]XVâ\V]HOLZRGSRZLHG]LīHWRQLHGRQLFKQDOHī\ LQWHUSUHWDFMDG\VNXVMLJG\īWD]RVWDâD]DPNQLċWD]JRGQLH]SU]\MċW\PL ]Z\F]DMDPLLQLNWQLH]JâRVLâMXīVSU]HFLZX6SRâHF]QRğýE\âDWHī]D VNRF]RQDīHGHZHORSHU]\ZRJyOHSRGMċOLG\VNXVMċ-DNVNRPHQWRZDâ Z]JâRV]HQLXZV\VWHPLH%XJ]LOODHG\WRU6QRWW\ZRQJNZLHWQLD &]\NWRğPyJâE\PLZ\WâXPDF]\ýMDNHG\WRU]\PDMĆUR]PDZLDý]GH ZHORSHUDPLFKFĆFZSURZDG]Lý]PLDQċ"0LHOLğP\QDG]LHMċīHSR SURVWXZ\MDğQLP\RFRQDPFKRG]LLZVNDīHP\QDSUDZLGâRZRSU]H SURZDG]RQĆG\VNXVMċZNWyUHMX]\VNDQRNRQVHQVXVFRGRRNUHVX SUyEQHJRGOD]PLDQ\DZWHG\NWyU\ğ]GHZHORSHUyZSU]HâĆF]\SDUċ SVWU\F]NyZ 1LHE\OLğP\ğZLDGRPLWHJRīHQDV]DNRQFHSFMDPLDâDSU]HMğýSU]H] NROHMQĆUXQGċÅDSHODFMLµ]HVWURQ\GHZHORSHUyZQDSLċýPLQXWSU]HG UR]SRF]ċFLHPSR]âRīHQLXZQLRVNXQD%XJ]LOOL:V]F]HJyOQRğFLPDUWZL PQLHWRīHG\VNXVMDZV\VWHPLH%XJ]LOODQLHMHVWZLGRF]QDGODQLNRJR ]VHWHNHG\WRUyZNWyU]\XF]HVWQLF]\OLZG\VNXVMLVSRâHF]QRğFLRZHM ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL -HğOLVĆMDNLHğNZHVWLHQDWXU\WHFKQLF]QHMXQLHPRīOLZLDMĆFHZ\HJ ]HNZRZDQLHZROLVSRâHF]QRğFLSRZLHG]FLHQDPRQLFKDP\SRVWDUDP\ VLċ]QDOHĩýZVSyOQLH]:DPLMDNLHğUR]ZLĆ]DQLH-HğOLPDFLHZĆWSOLZRğFL QDWXU\HG\F\MQHMWRPRLP]GDQLHPSRZLQQRVLċMHZ\UD]LýZWUDNFLH G\VNXVMLZ:LNLSHGLLNWyUDWUZDâDSU]H]SUDZLHGZDPLHVLĆFHLE\âD RJâRV]RQDZ.DZLDUHQFHLLQQ\FKFHQWUDFKG\VNXVML 1LHFKFċWZRU]\ýZURJLHMDWPRVIHU\LQLHFKFċOHNFHZDī\ýLVWRWQ\FK ZĆWSOLZRğFLDOHF]XMċīHNRPHQWDU]HNWyUHWXVLċSRMDZLDMĆPDMĆ FKDUDNWHUUHGDNF\MQ\LQLH]RVWDâ\ZQLHVLRQHSU]H]XF]HVWQLNyZG\VNXVML :W\PVHUZLVLHVĆRQH]XSHâQLHQLHQDPLHMVFX

KWWSEXJ]LOODZLNLPHGLDRUJVKRZBEXJFJL"LG

247

248

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 3URV]ċGDMFLHPL]QDýF]\PRMHREDZ\VĆEH]SRGVWDZQHF]\PRīH WDNLMHVWWXWHMV]\VWDWXVTXR6]F]HJyâ\RNUHVXSUyEQHJRE\â\Z\SUD FRZ\ZDQHSU]H]ZLHOXHG\WRUyZSU]H]SUDZLHSyâURNX²FKFLHOLE\ğP\ MXīXMU]HýHIHNW\QDV]HMG\VNXVML

'\VNXVMDWUZDâDGDQHMZREUċELHZQLRVNXZV\VWHPLH%XJ]LOOD ZSHZQ\PPRPHQFLH]DDQJDīRZDOLVLċZQLĆSU]HGVWDZLFLHOHIXQGDFML NWyU]\DUJXPHQWRZDOLīHSURSRQRZDQD]PLDQDJRG]LZDNWXDOQHFHOH VWUDWHJLF]QH:0)LīHZLHOH]GRVWċSQ\FKEDGDĕVXJHUXMHīHZSUR ZDG]HQLHSURSR]\FMLHG\WRUyZE\âRE\Z\VRFHV]NRGOLZHGODSURMHNWX PRJĆFQDZHWGRSURZDG]LýGRMHJRXSDGNX :QLRVHN]RVWDâZNRĕFXRGU]XFRQ\JâyZQLH]WHJRSRZRGXīHSU]H F]\âPLVMLUXFKX:LNLPHGLDLVWUDWHJLF]Q\PFHORPNWyUHPyZLâ\RZLċN V]\PRWZDUFLXQDHG\WRUyZ]DPLDVWRSRGQRV]HQLXEDULHUZHMğFLD 3U]HGVWDZLFLHOHIXQGDFMLZâĆF]QLH]MHMZLFHG\UHNWRUHP(ULNLHP 0|OOHUHPSRGHMPRZDOLSUyE\SRMHGQDZF]HGDMĆFMDVQRGR]UR]XPLH QLDīHGXFKSURSR]\FML]RVWDQLHSRGGDQ\V]HUV]HMG\VNXVMLLE\ýPRīH RSUDFRZDQD]RVWDQLHRQDZLQQ\VSRVyEOHF]QLHGDVLċ]DSU]HF]\ý īHLFKDUJXPHQW\SU]HFLZNRSURSR]\FMLSRMDZLâ\VLċ]E\WSyĩQRLSR ZLQQ\E\â\E\ýZ\DUW\NXâRZDQHSRGF]DVG\VNXVMLQDGSURSR]\FMĆ ZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL)XQGDFMD]JâRVLâDLVWRWQH]DU]XW\FRGRLGHL OHF]VNXWNLHPWHJRīHQLH]URELâDWHJRZF]HğQLHMJG\VSRâHF]QRğýDQ JLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLG\VNXWRZDâDGRSLHURSLHUZV]HV]F]HJyâ\E\âRWR īH]DSU]HSDV]F]RQRGXīRZ\VLâNXHG\WRUyZ-DNZVZRLPNRPHQWDU]X ]DP\NDMĆF\PFDâĆNZHVWLċ]D]QDF]\â(ULN0|OOHUZU]HğQLD :VSyâF]XMċW\PNWyU]\Z\UDīDMĆVZyMJQLHZLIUXVWUDFMċMHVWPLSU]\NUR īHQLHE\OLğP\ZVWDQLHSRVWĆSLý]FDâĆVSUDZĆWDNE\WHGZDRGF]XFLD ]PLQLPDOL]RZDý 0DMĆFQDXZDG]HSRZ\īV]H²MHğOLX]QDMHFLHīHMHG\Q\PSUDZLGâR Z\PSRVXQLċFLHPNWyUHJRPRīQDZ]ZLĆ]NX]WDNĆSURSR]\FMĆGR NRQDýMHVWZ\HJ]HNZRZDQLHZROLVSRâHF]QRğFLWRGDOV]DG\VNXVMDQLH PD]E\WQLHJRVHQVX1LHWDNXZDīDP\QLHWDNSUDNW\NXMHP\QDV]H G]LDâDQLD 0RMHRVRELVWHSRGHMğFLHMHVWGRğýSURVWHVSRâHF]QRğýG]LDâDF]DVDPL VXELHNW\ZQLHDLQQ\FKU]HF]\QLHGRVWU]HJD:0)G]LDâDF]DVDPLVX ELHNW\ZQLHDLQQ\FKU]HF]\QLHGRVWU]HJD6SċG]LZV]\ZRE\GZX RER]DFKGRğýGXīRF]DVXPRJċ]SHâQ\PSU]HNRQDQLHPVWZLHUG]LýīH :0)LVSRâHF]QRğFLWRGZDUyīQHJDWXQNL

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII :NRQWHNğFLHSRZ\īV]HJR]GDU]HQLDZDUWRQDGPLHQLýīHUROD]DVDG QHJRXF]HVWQLFWZDSHU\IHU\MQHJRZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKRRWZDUW\PPRGHOX ZVSyâSUDF\MHVWGRğýLVWRWQDLQDZHWF]\WHOQLFWZRWUDNWXMHVLċF]DVDPL MDNRSLHUZV]\NURNSURZDG]ĆF\GRZHMğFLDZVSRâHF]QRğýQLH]DğMDNR QLH]DOHīQHG]LDâDQLH$QWLQL&KHVKLUH :W\P]QDF]HQLXZNâDG QLH]DUHMHVWURZDQ\FKXī\WNRZQLNyZPRīHE\ýQLH]EċGQ\MDNRZSUR ZDG]HQLHGRHG\WRZDQLD:LNLSHGLLQDZHWZ\VRNDOLF]EDZDQGDOL]PyZ PRīHE\ýX]QDQD]DQLHXQLNQLRQ\NRV]WSU]\FLĆJDQLDQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZ 6HGQRSUREOHPXMHVWMHGQDNQLHLVWRWQHVNRURNRPXQLNDFMLRUyīQ\FK LQWHUSUHWDFMDFK]DVDG]RGSRZLHGQLPZ\SU]HG]HQLHPSRSURVWX]DEUD NâR]HVWURQ\IXQGDFML-DNSU]\]QDâSRGF]DVZ\ZLDGXMHGHQ]SUDFRZ QLNyZ:0) 6ĆG]ċīHGRV]OLğP\GRZâDğFLZHMGHF\]ML6ĆG]ċīHZâDğFLZ\PG]LDâD QLHPE\âRE\WXMHGQDNZHMğFLHLSRZLHG]HQLHÅ1LH]URELP\WHJRµSU]HG W\PMDNVSRâHF]QRğýSU]H]WU]\PLHVLĆFHGRFKRG]LâDGRLPSOHPHQWDFML SRGHMPRZDâDGHF\]MċLWGLWS

7HQV]F]HJyOQ\SU]\SDGHNSRND]XMHīHSRVWU]HJDQLHZâDVQRğFL SURMHNWyZMHVWZUDīOLZĆNZHVWLĆ6SRâHF]QRğFLMDVQRZLHU]ĆīHWRRQH QDSċG]DMĆSURMHNW\]DğIXQGDFMDMHVWRGSRZLHG]LDOQD]DDGPLQLVWURZD QLHQLPLLZ\NRQ\ZDQLHGHF\]MLVSRâHF]QRğFLZPLDUċGRVWċSQ\FK]DVR EyZ)XQGDFMD]NROHLZ\FKRG]L]]DâRīHQLDīHVSRâHF]QRğFLPRJĆVDPH GHF\GRZDýRVZRMHMRUJDQL]DFMLRUD]]DVDGDFKZ\âĆF]QLHZJUDQLFDFK RNUHğORQ\FKZL]MĆVWUDWHJLF]QĆ5DG\3RZLHUQLF]HMDWRZâDğQLH)XQ GDFMDPDSUDZRUR]VWU]\JDýZNZHVWLDFKJG\SRGHMğFLHVSRâHF]QRğFL QLHMHVW]JRGQH]ZL]MĆ5DG\3RGREQ\FKREVHUZDFMLGRNRQDâ(GZDUG &DVWURQRYD SRND]XMĆFQDSU]\NâDG]LHVSRâHF]QRğFLJUDF]\ RQOLQHīHMHğOLXF]HVWQLF\QLHPDMĆZâDG]\WHFKQLF]QHMQLH]EċGQHMGR Z\HJ]HNZRZDQLDZâDG]\]DU]ĆG]DQLHZ\ZRG]ĆFHVLċ]ZQċWU]DVSR âHF]QRğFL]DF]\QDE\ýNZHVWLRQRZDQH3U]\SRPLQDQLHMHGQDNRW\P VSRâHF]QRğFLLSRGNUHğODQLHEUDNXğURGNyZWHFKQLF]Q\FKGRSRGHMPRZD QLDG]LDâDĕMHVWU\]\NRZQHV]F]HJyOQLHMHğOLFDâRğýVSRâHF]QHMRUJDQL]D FMLSURGXNFMLWUHğFLVSRF]\ZDQDNRRUG\QRZDQLXZ\VLâNyZQDMEDUG]LHM RGGDQ\FKVSUDZLHRFKRWQLNyZ/HYLQH MDNWHīQD]DV]\W\PZVWUXN WXU]HRUJDQL]DF\MQHMXSUDZRPRFQLHQLXXF]HVWQLNyZGRVDPRGHF\GR ZDQLD%XWOHULLQ)RUWHLLQ -DNZLGDýVWUXNWXUDV\V WHPX]DU]ĆG]DQLDRUD]MHMHJ]HNZRZDQLHPRJĆPLHýRJURPQ\ZSâ\Z

249

250

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... QDPRW\ZDFMċLRJyOQĆFKċýZVSyâSUDF\ZSURMHNWDFKRRWZDUW\PXF]HVW QLFWZLH6KDK %\ýPRīHZâDğQLHGODWHJRUyīQLFH]GDĕWDNLHMDNRSLVDQHSRZ\īHM VĆQLH]Z\NOHU]DGNLHDQLHGRVWDWNLZNRPXQLNDFMLPLċG]\:LNLPHGLD )RXQGDWLRQDVSRâHF]QRğFLDPLSURMHNWyZOXESU]HGVWDZLFLHODPLORNDO Q\PLIXQGDFMLMDNGRWHMSRU\QLHZ\ZRâDâ\ZLċNV]\FKUR]âDPyZ ZğZLHFLH)/266]QDQ\FKMDNRW]ZIRUNLQJ

FORKING )RUNLQJWR]Z\F]DMRZHG]LDâDQLHGRP\ğOQLHSRGHMPRZDQHZFHOXUR] G]LHOHQLDSURMHNWyZRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXXF]HVWQLFWZD:HEHU :Z\QLNX]DFKFLDQNLQLH]JRG\ZSRGVWDZRZ\FKNZHVWLDFKWHFKQLF] Q\FKOXENRQÁLNWXRVRELVWHJRNDīG\PRīHSU]HQLHğýSRGVWDZRZ\NRG /LQXNVDF]\$SDFKHLVWZRU]\ýQDMHJRSRGVWDZLHZâDVQ\SURMHNW RSDWUXMĆFJRLQQ\PL]DVDGDPLGHF\]\MQRğFLLVWUXNWXUDPL2WZDUW\ NRGĩUyGâRZ\RUD]]DVWRVRZDQHOLFHQFMHZ]PDFQLDMĆXSUDZQLHQLH Xī\WNRZQLNyZZWHMG]LHG]LQLH

-DNSRND]Dâ\EDGDQLDSU]HSURZDG]RQHQDUyīQ\FKSURMHNWDFK RRWZDUW\PNRG]LHNWyUHGRğZLDGF]\â\ZVZRLPLVWQLHQLX]MDZLVND IRUNLQJXQLH]DGRZROHQLH]]DU]ĆG]DQLDSURMHNWHPMHVWLVWRWQĆPRW\ ZDFMĆGRRGâĆF]HQLDVLċ NWyUHMXVWċSXMHMHG\QLHPRW\ZDFMDQD WXU\WHFKQLF]QHM9LVHXU RGJU\ZDMĆFD]DLVWH]QDF]QĆUROċF]âRQ NRZLHVSRâHF]QRğFLGHF\GXMĆVLċZ\SURZDG]LýZâDVQĆRGQRJċSURMHNWX QDLQQHZRG\MHğOLXZDīDMĆīHSURMHNWQLHMHVWZVWDQLHZGRW\FKF]D VRZHMVZRMHMIRUPLHUR]ZLMDýVLċWDNMDNE\VRELHWHJRī\F]\OL/L 1\PDQL0LNNRQHQ 1DZHWMHğOLSURMHNW\RRWZDUW\PPRGHOX XF]HVWQLFWZDZ\UDīDMĆGXīH]DVWU]HīHQLDFRGRIRUNLQJX6WHZDUWL*R VDLQ MDVQHMHVWīHQLH]DGRZROHQLH]]DU]ĆG]DQLDSURMHNWHPPRīH E\ý]QDF]ĆF\PSRZRGHPRGâĆF]DQLDVLċJUXSXF]HVWQLNyZ 0QLHMV]HRGâĆF]DQLDVLċRGSURMHNWyZ:LNLPHGLDPLDâ\MXīPLHMVFH² MHGQ\P]RVWDWQLFKSU]\NâDGyZMHVWWKHRSHQJOREHRUJNWyU\SRZVWDâ ZURNXQDED]LHSURMHNWX:LNL1HZVOHF]XSDGâSRQLHFDâ\P

=REKWWSOLVWVZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOIRXQGDWLRQO6HSWHPEHU KWPO

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII URNX6SRâHF]QRğýUXFKX:LNLPHGLDUyZQLHīF]DVDPLGHEDWRZDâD QDGVFKL]PĆSU]\F]\PG\VNXVMH]Z\NOHPLDâ\SRGâRīHLGHRORJLF]QH 1LHGDZQ\PSU]\SDGNLHPZNWyU\P]DLVWQLDâWHPDWRGâĆF]HQLDVLċ F]ċğFLVSRâHF]QRğFLE\âRÀOWURZDQLHNRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKJUDÀNğFLğOH SRZLĆ]DQH]NZHVWLDPLSRUQRJUDÀLSU]\ZRâDQ\PLZF]HğQLHM3RND]XMH WRīHSRV]F]HJyOQHVSRâHF]QRğFLUXFKX:LNLPHGLDFHFKXMĆVLċUyīQ\PL SR]LRPDPLZUDīOLZRğFLOHF]PLPRUyīQLFF]ċVWRâĆF]\MHRVWUHEURQLH QLHVZRLFKUDFML0LPRīHZLċNV]RğýZLNLPHGLDQSRSDUâDSRP\VâÀOWUR ZDQLDNRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKWUHğFLZ\UDīDMĆFVZRMĆDSUREDWċZQDMZLċNV]\P UHIHUHQGXPUXFKX:LNLPHGLDZURNX]Dğ5DGD3RZLHUQLF]D Z\GDâDGHF\]MċZNWyUHM]DFKċFDâDGRRSUDFRZDQLDğURGNyZWHFKQLF] Q\FKSR]ZDODMĆF\FKXī\WNRZQLNRPZ\EUDýF]\WHJRW\SXWUHğFLPDMĆ E\ýSU]HGQLPLXNU\ZDQHRSyU]GHWHUPLQRZDQHMPQLHMV]RğFLVNXW NRZDâSRU]XFHQLHPÀOWURZDQLDWUHğFLQDVNDOċJOREDOQĆ-DNSRZLH G]LDâDPLZWUDNFLHZ\ZLDGX6XH*DUGQHUG\UHNWRU]DU]ĆG]DMĆF\ :LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ 0RJOLğP\SRZLHG]LHýÅ,WDNWR]URELP\ERGZLHWU]HFLHOXG]LZ\UD]LâR VZRMHSRSDUFLHµOHF]FKFLHOLğP\X]QDýZĆWSOLZRğFLSR]RVWDâHMMHGQHM WU]HFLHMHG\WRUyZNWyUDZ\UD]LâDVZyM]GHF\GRZDQ\VSU]HFLZÀOWURZDQLX NRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKJUDÀNFKFLHOLğP\WHīSRGHMğýGRVSUDZ\RGVWURQ\ WHFKQLF]QHMJG\E\ğP\VWZRU]\OLUR]ZLĆ]DQLHÀOWUXMĆFHSHZQHWUHğFL PLPRVSU]HFLZXMHGQHMWU]HFLHMVSRâHF]QRğFLWREDUG]RWUXGQRE\âRE\ QDWHMSURSR]\FML]EXGRZDýNRQVHQVXVDP\U\]\NRZDOLğP\SRZVWD ZDQLHQLHPLHFNLHJRRGâDPX:LNLSHGLLIUDQFXVNLHJRLWG%\âDWRZLċF NZHVWLDSRWHQFMDOQLHG]LHOĆFDVSRâHF]QRğýPDMĆFDPRīQRğýUR]ELFLD UXFKX:LNLPHGLDZ\ZRâDQLDQHJDW\ZQ\FKXF]XýLZURJRğFLSRWHQ FMDOQLHSDUDOLīXMĆFPRīOLZRğýSRGHMPRZDQLDLQQ\FKG]LDâDĕSU]H] IXQGDFMċ:UXFKXWDNLPMDNQDV]UHSHUNXVMHRGâDPXVĆUHDOQHSRGRE QLHMDNVNXWNLQLHPRīQDLFKSRPLQĆýJG\īPRīOLZRğýG]LDâDQLD IXQGDFMLMHVW]DOHīQDRGZVSyOQHJRG]LDâDQLD

=REKWWSHQZLNLQHZVRUJZLNL:LNLQHZV:DWHUBFRROHUPLVFHOODQHRXVDUFKL YHV$XJXVW:1BIRUNBRSHQBJOREHBLVBQRBPRUH :UHIHUHQGXPRGGDQRSRQDGW\VLĆFHJâRVyZ]DğMHJRZ\QLNSRND]XMHRJyOQH SRSDUFLHVSRâHF]QRğFLGODMHGQHM]IRUPILOWURZDQLDNRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKJUDILN=RE KWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL,PDJHBILOWHUBUHIHUHQGXP5HVXOWVHQ '\VNXVMHQDGNRQWURZHUV\MQ\PLWUHğFLDPLRGE\ZDâ\VLċQSQDVWURQLHKWWS PHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL&RQWURYHUVLDOBFRQWHQW

251

252

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 'HF\]MLQLHSRGMċWRSUDZGRSRGREQLH]HZ]JOċGXQDWRīHGĆīRQRGR X]\VNDQLDNRQVHQVXVXQDSR]LRPLHMHGQRP\ğOQRğFL,GHDÀOWURZDQLD JUDÀNQDVWRSQLXJOREDOQ\P]\VNDâD]QDF]QHSRSDUFLHOHF]QLHE\âR WRMHGQDNSRSDUFLHRGGDQ\FKHG\WRUyZPDMĆF\FKQDMZLċNV]\ZSâ\Z ZORNDOQ\FKSURMHNWDFK5HIHUHQGXPGRWDUâRGRZLNLPHGLDQHG\WXMĆ F\FK]UyīQĆF]ċVWRWOLZRğFLĆF]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFLMHGQDN]RUJDQL]RZDâD ZâDVQHJâRVRZDQLDğFLĆJDMĆFQDMF]ċğFLHMQDMDNW\ZQLHMV]\FKDQLH SU]HORWQ\FKHG\WRUyZF]HJRZ\QLNLHPE\âRVWZLHUG]HQLHīHZNLONX GXī\FKSURMHNWDFKLGHDÀOWURZDQLDWUHğFLVSRWNDâDVLċ]VLOQ\PVSU]H FLZHPZKLV]SDĕVNLHM:LNLSHGLLZZHUVMLIUDQFXVNLHM ]DğZQLHPLHFNLHM F]DVDPLQDSRGâRīXLGHRORJLF]Q\PF]DVDPL ]DğZZ\QLNXSRVWU]HJDQLDSRVXQLċFLDJOREDOQHJR]D]E\WQLRNROLGXMĆFH ]ORNDOQ\PLFHODPLSURMHNWyZ5DGD3RZLHUQLF]DLIXQGDFMDPXVLDâ\ RVWURīQLHSRGFKRG]LýGRZ\GDZDQLDGHF\]MLNWyUH²FKRýE\SRWHQFMDO QLH²SRGZDīDâ\E\SU]HNRQDQLDNWyUHMNROZLHN]OLF]QLHMV]\FKVSRâHF] QRğFLJG\īQDSU]\NâDGZQLHPLHFNLHM:LNLSHGLLSRMDZLâ\VLċMXīSR P\Vâ\QDIRUNLQJ -DNMXīZVSRPQLDQRQLHPLHFND:LNLSHGLDLORNDOQHVWRZDU]\V]HQLH :LNLPHGLD'HXWVFKODQGFHFKXMĆVLċVLOQ\PVW\OHPDGPLQLVWURZDQLD D]HZ]JOċGyZWHFKQLF]Q\FKLÀQDQVRZ\FKRGâĆF]HQLHVLċLFKRGUHV]W\ UXFKX:LNLPHGLDPRJâRE\VLċQDZHWSRZLHğý=DJURīHQLHRUD]VLOQ\ VSU]HFLZ]HVWURQ\ZLHOXDNW\ZLVWyZUXFKX:LNLPHGLDXQLHPRīOLZLâR ZLċFSU]HIRUVRZDQLHUR]ZLĆ]DQLDNWyUHQRPLQDOQLHSRSDUâDZLċNV]Rğý HG\WRUyZRUD]SUDZGRSRGREQLH]QDF]QDZLċNV]RğýF]\WHOQLNyZSUR MHNWyZ:LNLPHGLD 1DOHī\QDGPLHQLýīHIRUNLQJF]ċVWRQLHOXELDQ\LNU\W\NRZDQ\ ZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXXF]HVWQLFWZDRNUHğODQ\MDNR V]NRGOLZ\GODZVSyOQ\FKFHOyZXF]HVWQLNyZMHVWUR]ZLĆ]DQLHPNWyUH GHIDFWRVSUDZLDīHZVSyâSUDFDZSURMHNFLHMHVWU]HF]\ZLğFLHZROQD 5HDJOH&KHOLRWLV 1DZHWWHRUHW\F]QDPRīOLZRğýUR]âDPX

KWWSHVZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD(QFXHVWDV6REUHBHOBILOWURBGHB LP&$JHQHV KWWSIUZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLS&$GLD6RQGDJH,QVWDOODWLRQBGXQB )LOWUHBGLPDJH KWWSGHZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD0HLQXQJVELOGHU(LQI&%&KUXQJB SHUV&%QOLFKHUB%LOGILOWHU KWWSGHZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL:LNLSHGLD:LNLSHGLD)RUN

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII VâXī\]DÅ]DZyUEH]SLHF]HĕVWZDµRLVWQLHQLXNWyUHJRSDPLċWDMĆ XF]HVWQLF\V]DQXMĆFZROċPQLHMV]RğFL-HVWWRÅQLHZLG]LDOQDUċND ]UyZQRZDīHQLDµSURMHNWyZSR]ZDODMĆFDLPQDUR]ZLMDQLHVLċ1\PDQ LLQ 3UDNW\F]Q\SRWHQFMDâGRRGâĆF]HQLDVLċ]DOHī\MHGQDNRG PRGHOX]DU]ĆG]DQLDIXQNFMRQXMĆFHJRZVSRâHF]QRğFL.RJXWL0HWLX ::LNLSHGLLFKRýNLONDNURWQLHG\VNXWRZDQRQDGWHRUHW\F]QĆ VWURQĆIRUNLQJXDGRWHJRSRMDZLâRVLċNLONDSURMHNWyZSUDNW\F]QLH UHDOL]XMĆF\FKWċZL]MċQS&LWL]HQGXP:LNLQIR(QF\FORSHGLD/LEUH GODGRNâDGQLHMV]HMDQDOL]\RGâDPyZ:LNLSHGLD]REQS7NDF] XGDQHRGâĆF]HQLHVLċRG:LNLSHGLLVNXWNXMĆFHSRZVWDQLHPSURMHNWX RSRGREQHMGR:LNLSHGLLVNDOLVXNFHVXMHVWUDF]HMPDâRSUDZGRSRGREQH ]NLONXSRZRGyZ 3RSLHUZV]HPLPRīHLVWQLHMHZLHOHVHUZLVyZLQWHUQHWRZ\FKZVSRVyE RWZDUW\LOHJDOQ\NRSLXMĆF\FK]DZDUWRğý:LNLSHGLLLFDâNRZLFLHX]D OHīQLRQ\FKRGMHM]DZDUWRğFLGRGDMĆFMHG\QLHQLHZLHOHRGVLHELHMDN PDWRPLHMVFHZSU]\SDGNXSRUWDOX$ERXWFRP:LNLSHGLDMHVWZ\VRFH XPLHMVFRZLRQDZZ\QLNDFKZ\V]XNLZDQLD&RZLċFHMZ\MĆWNRZRGXīR VWURQOLQNXMHGRMHMWUHğFL1DZHWJG\E\G]LğZLċNV]DF]ċğýMHGQHM ]:LNLSHGLL]GHF\GRZDâDR]PLDQLHEDUZNOXERZ\FKLVWQLHMHZ\VRNLH SUDZGRSRGRELHĕVWZRīH:LNLSHGLDEċG]LHG]LDâDýGDOHMZ\FKRZXMĆF NROHMQHSRNROHQLHHG\WRUyZSRGF]DVJG\QRZ\SURMHNWPLDâE\]QDF]QH WUXGQRğFL]SR]\VNDQLHPF]\WHOQLNyZLQRZ\FKHG\WRUyZ=WHJR Z]JOċGXRGPLHQQLHQLīZSU]\SDGNXQSUyīQ\FKG\VWU\EXFML/LQXNVD :LNLSHGLDFLHV]\VLċXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQĆSR]\FMĆMHğOLFKRG]LRGRVWċSQRğý GODXī\WNRZQLNyZ 3RGUXJLHFR]ZLĆ]DQHMHVW]SRZ\īV]\PFKRýZDUWRğý:LNLSHGLL SRFKRG]LJâyZQLH]MHM]DZDUWRğFLDNWXDOQLHGXīDMHMF]ċğýZ\ZRG]LVLċ ]PDUNLSURMHNWX:âDğFLFLHOHP]DZDUWRğFLQLHMHVW:0)OHF]QLH PRīQDMHMWHīSRVLĆğý]XZDJLQDRWZDUW\PRGHOOLFHQF\MQ\=DWHPWR ZDUWRğý]QDNXWRZDURZHJR:LNLSHGLLVWDMHVLċ]QDF]ĆFĆZDUWRğFLĆ GRGDQĆSURMHNWXJG\SRUyZQDVLċJR]LQQ\PLVHUZLVDPL]DZLHUDMĆ F\PLWHVDPHWUHğFL3U]HFLċWQ\Xī\WNRZQLNQLHW\ONRQLHZLHRLVWQLHQLX VSRâHF]QRğFLVWRMĆFHM]DSUH]HQWRZDQ\PLPXWUHğFLDPLOHF]LVWQLHQLH WDNLHMVSRâHF]QRğFLMHVWPXRERMċWQH2GPLHQQLHQLīZSU]\SDGNX 2SHQ%6'-DY\F]\8QLNVD.XPDU ZSU]\SDGNX:LNLSHGLL ]QDF]QDF]ċğýMHMSR]\FMLU\QNRZHMLF]\WHOQLFWZDMHVW]DOHīQDRGF]\Q QLNyZ]HZQċWU]Q\FKQSSR]\FMRQRZDQLDZZ\V]XNLZDUNDFKF]\RG LVWQLHQLDVWDELOQHMLX]QDQHMPDUNL3URGXNWMHVWZVSRVyERF]\ZLVW\

253

254

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ZDīQ\FRSRWZLHUG]DMĆW\VLĆFHQLH]QDQ\FKVHUZLVyZNRSLXMĆF\FK ZFDâRğFL]DZDUWRğý:LNLSHGLL/RJRW\S\:LNLSHGLLLUXFKX:LNLPHGLD RGUyīQLDMĆRU\JLQDOQHSURMHNW\RGFDâHMUHV]W\DZLċFWRPDUNDQLH SURGXNWSU]\FLĆJDUXFKVLHFLRZ\.OHLQ 3DUDGRNVDOQLHZ\VRND OLF]EDIXQNFMRQXMĆF\FKPLUURUyZ:LNLSHGLL]ZLċNV]DUR]SR]QDZDOQRğý RU\JLQDOQHJRSURMHNWX)DPLJOLHWWL :LHOH]HZQċWU]Q\FKVHU ZHUyZNRSLXMĆF\FKDUW\NXâ\:LNLSHGLLVâXī\MDNRURVQĆFHÅIDUP\ OLQNyZµZSURFHVLHSR]\FMRQRZDQLDVWURQ:::EĆGĩWHīMDNRĩUyGâD QLHZLHONLFKSU]\FKRGyZ]W\WXâXJHQHURZDQHJRUXFKX]VHUZLVyZ Z\V]XNLZDZF]\FKDOHWR:LNLSHGLDG]LċNLZVSDUFLXVSRâHF]QRğFLRUD] V]\ENRJHQHURZDQHMLSRSUDZLDQHMWUHğFLPDSRSURVWXOHSV]HPHFKD QL]P\NRQWUROQH=\VNXMHUyZQLHīG]LċNLWUHğFLOLFHQFMLNWyUHMZDUXQNL PXV]ĆVSHâQLDýVHUZHU\OLQNXMĆFHGRMHM]DZDUWRğFL 3RWU]HFLHSUDZGRSRGRELHĕVWZRIRUNLQJXMHVWZ\īV]HZSU]\SDGNX EUDNXNRRUG\QDFMLG]LDâDĕOXE]E\WğFLVâHMNRQWUROLVSUDZRZDQHMQDG VSRâHF]QRğFLĆSU]H]FHQWUXPNRRUG\QDFML.XPDU -DNGRWĆG IXQGDFMD]GHF\GRZDQLHELHU]HWRSRGXZDJċLQLHGRSURZDG]DGRWDNLFK NRQIURQWDFML]HVSRâHF]QRğFLDPLSURMHNWyZNWyUHPRJâ\E\VNXWNRZDý RGâĆF]HQLHPVLċJUXS\HG\WRUyZVWDUDMĆFVLċQLHLQWHUZHQLRZDýZV\WXD FMDFKNWyUHVSRâHF]QRğFLORNDOQHX]QDMĆ]DLVWRWQHMDNWHīUHī\VHUXMĆF RJyâG]LDâDĕUXFKX:LNLPHGLD1DZHWVDPR]DâRīHQLHIXQGDFMLSR U]XFHQLHSRGHMğFLDZâDğFLZHJRGODVWDUWXSyZRUD]UDG\NDOQDRWZDU WRğýSUH]HQWRZDQ\FKWUHğFLPRJâ\E\ýSRVXQLċFLDPLQDNWyUHZSâ\Z PLDâDSRWU]HED]DSRELHīHQLDUR]âDPRPVSRâHF]QRğFLLXWU]\PDQLH DNW\ZQRğFLZRORQWDULXV]\&KHQ(Q\HG\L7NDF] ]Dğ 5DGD3RZLHUQLF]DLIXQGDFMDğZLDGRPLHXQLNDMĆRGF]DVXLFKSRZRâDQLD WHJRW\SX]DJURīHĕ 3RF]ZDUWHUyZQLHīLVWRWQHMHVWīHV\VWHP\ZVSyâSUDF\RQOLQH Z\PDJDMĆGRWHJRE\ZVSyâSUDFD]DF]ċâDIXQNFMRQRZDýSHZQHMQLHPD âHMPDV\NU\W\F]QHMNWyUDSR]ZDODGRGDWNRZRSR]\W\ZQ\PDVSHNWRP V\VWHPX]\VNDýSU]HZDJċQDGMHJRQLHGRVNRQDâRğFLDPL%RQDFFRUVL L5RVVL3UDVDUQSKDQLFKL:DJQHU %UDNVXNFHVXSRSU]HG QLFKIRUNyZMHVWLVWRWQ\PV\JQDâHPRVWU]HJDZF]\PīHSR]DUXFKHP :LNLPHGLDXWU]\PDQLHRGSRZLHGQLHMRUJDQL]DFMLPRīHE\ýQLHZ\NR QDOQH%\ýPRīHZâDğQLHGODWHJRQDSLċFLDZG]LHG]LQLH]DU]ĆG]DQLD UXFKHP:LNLPHGLDVNXSLDMĆVLċQDG\VNXWRZDQLXQDG]DVDGDPLLLFK ]PLHQLDQLXRUD]QDZ]DMHPQ\FKUHODFMDFKXG]LDâRZFyZ]DPLDVWQD PRīOLZRğFLRGâĆF]HQLDVLċ

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII 3RWHQFMDâIRUNLQJXMHVWMHGQDNLVWRWQ\PF]\QQLNLHPNWyU\QDOHī\ Z]LĆýSRGXZDJċZ]DU]ĆG]DQLXUXFKHP:LNLPHGLD3U]\NâDGHPMHVW KLV]SDĕVNLIRUN:LNLSHGLL(QF\FORSHGLD/LEUHNWyU\ZSUDZG]LHQLH VWDâVLċXGDQ\PQLH]DOHīQ\PSURMHNWHPHQF\NORSHGLLLQWHUQHWRZHM DOHSUDZGRSRGREQLH]DFKZLDâUyZQRZDJĆSRZVWDMĆFHJRUXFKX:LNL PHGLDLZSâ\QĆâQDGHF\]MċGRW\F]ĆFĆQLHXPLHV]F]DQLDZ:LNLSHGLL UHNODPFRZURNXE\âRMHV]F]HUR]ZDīDQH7NDF] 3RSRZRâDQLX:&$MDNWHīSRG\VNXVMDFKGRW\F]ĆF\FKSRGVWDZZL]ML UXFKX:LNLPHGLDRUD]MHJRGDOV]HJRUR]ZRMXGODSU]\NâDGX:0) SRVWXOXMH]DZċīHQLH]DNUHVXG]LDâDĕLNRQFHQWUDFMċQDQDMZDīQLHMV]\FK FHODFKUXFKXSRGF]DVJG\F]ċğýF]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFLX]QDMHWDNLH SRGHMğFLH]DRVâDELHQLHNLONXNOXF]RZ\FKLQLFMDW\Z SRWHQFMDâZ\âR QLHQLDVLċJUXS\RGâDPRZHM]DF]ĆâURVQĆýMDN]DXZDī\âDQS9LFWRULD QDOLğFLHG\VNXV\MQHM:LNLPHGLDSDĩG]LHUQLND :0)EċG]LHZLċF]ELHUDýğURGNLLSU]HND]\ZDýMHZVRELHW\ONR]QDQ\ VSRVyE-DNRE\âDF]âRQNLQLNRPLVMLSU]\]QDMĆFHMJUDQW\PRJċVWZLHU G]LýīHDNWXDOQLHSURFHVWHQQLHMHVWZ\GDMQ\LīHQLH]DSURSRQRZDQR īDGQ\FKGODQLHJRDOWHUQDW\Z-HğOL:0)VNRQFHQWUXMHVLċQDSU]HND ]\ZDQLXJUDQWyZ]DPLDVWXG]LHODýEH]SRğUHGQLHMSRPRF\OXG]LRPEH] GRğZLDGF]HQLDZVSHFMDOL]RZDQ\P]DGDQLXXELHJDQLDVLċRJUDQW\ F]âRQNRPVSRâHF]QRğFL EċG]LHZ\MĆWNRZRWUXGQRSRGMĆýZ\P\ğORQH LQLFMDW\Z\]DğğURGNLSU]HND]DQH]RVWDQĆVWURQRPWU]HFLP3RGF]DV ÅRNUHVXUHVWUXNWXU\]DFMLµ:0)SU]HVWDQLHÀQDQVRZDýGREU]HG]LDâD MĆFHU]HF]\WDNLHMDN:LNLPDQLDSR]RVWDZLDMĆFMHVDP\PVRELHMDN URELWRZVWRVXQNXGRORNDOQ\FKSDUWQHUyZ =DVWDQDZLDPVLċW\ONRNLHG\HXURSHMVF\SDUWQHU]\:0)SRGSU]\ ZyG]WZHPVNXWHF]Q\FK1LHPFyZ]GHF\GXMĆīHQLHSRWU]HEXMĆMXī :0)NXSLĆZâDVQHVHUZHU\LGRNRQDMĆIRUNLQJX

6]F]HJyOQLHZREOLF]XNU\]\VXSR]\FMLSU]\ZyGF\RSLVDQHJRZSR SU]HGQLPUR]G]LDOHVWDELOQRğý]DU]ĆG]DQLDUXFKHP:LNLPHGLDZ\GDMH VLċQLHFR]DFKZLDQD

3RP\Vâ\E\â\G\VNXWRZDQHQDVWURQLHKWWSPHWDZLNLPHGLDRUJZLNL8VHUB WDON6XHB*DUGQHU1DUURZLQJBIRFXVGRVWċSSDĩG]LHUQLND 'RNXPHQWGRVWċSQ\SRGDGUHVHPKWWSOLVWVZLNLPHGLDRUJSLSHUPDLOZLNLPH GLDO2FWREHUKWPOZâĆF]QLH]FDâĆG\VNXVMĆZZĆWNX

255

256


NIEKOMPLETNA Z DEFINICJI? ,QWHUSUHWXMĆFQDSLċFLDPLċG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLXF]HVWQLNDPLUXFKX :LNLPHGLDMDNWHīRJyOQLHNRQÁLNW\Z:LNLSHGLLQDOHī\SDPLċWDý RMHGQHMZDīQHMNZHVWLLVWDQGDUGyZRGF]\W\ZDQLDVNDOLQLHSRVâXV]Hĕ VWZDZREHFSU]\MċW\FKSUDNW\NQLHPRīQDSRMPRZDýZUR]XPLHQLX WUDG\F\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFML'ODSRVWURQQHJRREVHUZDWRUDSU]\]Z\F]D MRQHJRGRZ\UDīDQLDMHG\QLH]QDF]QHJRQLH]DGRZROHQLDZV\WXDFMDFK ZNWyU\FKHNVSUHVMDIUXVWUDFMLLJQLHZXMHVWWâXPLRQDSU]H]VWUDFKSU]HG UR]ZLĆ]DQLDPLVLâRZ\PLVSRâHF]QRğýUXFKX:LNLPHGLDZ\GDMHVLċ JâyZQLHVNâDGDý]SLHQLDF]\ 6SRâHF]QRğýZLNLPHGLDQMHVWMHGQDNSU]\]Z\F]DMRQDGRZ\UDīDQLD VZRMHJRQLH]DGRZROHQLD-DNMXī]UHV]WĆZVSRPQLDQRQLHZ\UDīDQLH QLH]DGRZROHQLDMHVWWUDNWRZDQHMDNR]JRGDQDSURSRQRZDQHUR]ZLĆ ]DQLD&RMHVWUyZQLHīW\SRZHGODSDUW\F\SDF\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFML*UHHQ ZRRGLLQ:K\WHL:K\WH Z\UDīDQLHRGPLHQQ\FKRSLQLL L]GHU]DQLH]HVREĆVNUDMQLHUyīQLĆF\FKVLċSRJOĆGyZVWDQRZLVWDQ GDUGRZĆSUDNW\NċZSUDZLHNDīGHMNZHVWLL:UXFKX:LNLPHGLDMHGQR MHVWSHZQHNDīGDGHF\]MDEċG]LHSURZDG]LýGRG\VNXVML:DUWRMHGQDN SDPLċWDýīHWDNLH]DFKRZDQLHMHVWV\JQDâHPSRGVWDZRZ\FKSRG]LDâyZ OXE]DJQLHīGīRQ\FKZV\VWHPLHQLHUyZQRğFLLQLHVSUDZLHGOLZRğFL Z]QDF]QLHPQLHMV]\PVWRSQLXQLīZWUDG\F\MQ\FKKLHUDUFKLF]Q\FKRU JDQL]DFMDFK&RğFRZWHJRW\SXNRQWHNVWDFKVWDQRZLâRE\RSRZDīQ\P NRQÁLNFLHQDZHWRVFKL]PLHZLQWHUQHWRZ\PğURGRZLVNXRWZDUWHM ZVSyâSUDF\MHVWFKOHEHPSRZV]HGQLP-DN]DXZDī\â&OD\6KLUN\ 2WZDUWHV\VWHP\VĆRWZDUWH'ODRVRE\SU]\]Z\F]DMRQHMGRNRQWDNWX ]LQVW\WXFMDPLNWyUH]URELĆZV]\VWNRE\]DPDVNRZDýVZRMHQLHGRVNR QDâRğFLMHVWWR]SRF]ĆWNXZLGRNZUċF]RK\GQ\-HGQDNNDīG\NWRXMU]Dâ MDNSRSUDZLDQ\MHVWSURJUDPRRWZDUW\PNRG]LHF]\SDPLċWDQDSDG\ KLVWHULLHG\WRUyZ%ULWDQQLNLJG\FLPyZLOLR:LNLSHGLLZLG]LDâWHīMDN EXOJRF]ĆFDNU\W\NDSXEOLF]QDXVSUDZQLDRWZDUWHV\VWHP\

-DNMHVWWRRSLVDQHZQLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDOHV]HUV]\ZL]HUXQHN ]DU]ĆG]DQLDUXFKHP:LNLPHGLDSRND]XMHīHOLF]\VLċZQLPQLHW\ONR VSRâHF]QRğý3RMHG\QF]HSURMHNW\PRJĆGHF\GRZDýRZLċNV]RğFLRER ZLĆ]XMĆF\FKZQLFK]DVDGLGRNRQXMĆWHJRZWRNXG\VNXVMLZHZQĆWU] VSRâHF]QRğFL%ODFNLLQ ]DğÅ:LNLSHGLċUR]ZLQLċWRSUDZLHEH]

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII FHQWUDOQ\FKPHFKDQL]PyZNRQWUROLµ0DORQHLLQ LVWQLHMH V]NLHOHW]DU]ĆG]DQLDRUJDQL]DF\MQHJRQDNWyU\VNâDGDVLċ:LNLPHGLD )RXQGDWLRQRUD]ZUyīQ\PVWRSQLXUR]ZLQLċWHORNDOQHRUJDQL]DFMH SDUWQHUVNLHSOXVQRZH]U]HV]HQLHRZ\FKSDUWQHUyZ ]DğQDJUDQLFDFK QLHMDVQR]GHÀQLRZDQ\FKÅWHU\WRULyZµSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKXF]HVWQLNyZ UXFKX:LNLPHGLDSRMDZLDMĆVLċ]JU]\W\&RZLċFHMZNZHVWLLÀOR]RÀL ]DU]ĆG]DQLDRUD]]DVREyZZ\VWċSXMHU\ZDOL]DFMDRUD]SRğUHGQLD QLHRÀFMDOQDNRQNXUHQFMD 3RMDZLHQLHVLċSU]\ZyGFyZZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKRUD]]JU]\WyZ]ZLĆ ]DQ\FK]]DU]ĆG]DQLHPZğURGRZLVNXZ\VRFHDKLHUDUFKLF]Q\PRUD] HJDOLWDUQ\PQLHMHVWQLF]\P]DVNDNXMĆF\P:NRĕFX&ROOLHUL.UDXW =ELRURZRLQWHOLJHQWQHRUJDQL]DFMH]ELRURZHWDNLHMDNSURMHNW\RSUR JUDPRZDQLDRRWZDUW\PNRG]LHL:LNLSHGLċPRīQDSRVWU]HJDýMDNR VWUXNWXU\SâDVNLHHJDOLWDUQHLVDPRRUJDQL]XMĆFH3RGMċWRMHGQDNEDGD QLDQDGğFLVâĆJUXSĆSU]\ZyGFyZZ\âDQLDQ\FKZIRUPDOQ\FKZ\ERUDFK VSRğUyGÅWâXPXµ3U]\ZyGF\HOHNFLRUJDQL]DFML]ELRURZ\FKF]ċVWRVWDQR ZLĆFHQWUXPNRRUG\QDFMLFHOyZGâXJRIDORZ\FKPHGLXMĆNRQÁLNW\ZH ZQĆWU]RUJDQL]DF\MQHLUR]ZLMDMĆIRUPDOQH]DVDG\G]LDâDQLDRUJDQL]DFML

3URFHVWHQMHVWğFLğOHUHJXORZDQ\LZHZQĆWU]NDīGHM]HVSRâHF]QRğFL ]Z\NOHSU]HELHJDMĆF\EH]]JU]\WyZOHF]QDSR]LRPLHNRRUG\QDFMLJOR EDOQHMQDGDOSRV]XNXMHUyZQRZDJLZW\PSURFHVLHPRīOLZHMHVWNLOND SRGHMğý1DMHGQ\PVNUDMXMHVW:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQNWyUĆPRīQD SRVWU]HJDýMDNRNRQWUDKHQWDRNRQWUDNFLHRGQDZLDQ\PFRURNGDMĆ FHJRVSRâHF]QRğFLHG\WRUyZVHUZHU\SRPRFSUDZQĆRUD]SURIHVMRQDOQH SR]\VNLZDQLHğURGNyZSU]\F]\PVSRâHF]QRğFLRUJDQL]XMĆVLċWDN GREU]HīH]ZLĆ]HN]IXQGDFMĆPRJĆ]DNRĕF]\ýZGRZROQ\PPRPHQFLH OXE]GHF\GRZDýīHLFKFHOHRZLHOHVNXWHF]QLHMRVLĆJQLHLQQDRUJDQL ]DFMD'UXJLHVNUDMQHSRGHMğFLHWRWDNLHZNWyU\P:LNLPHGLD)RXQ GDWLRQMHVWIDNW\F]Q\PZâDğFLFLHOHPUXFKX:LNLPHGLDDVSRâHF]QRğFL

3RGREQLHGRNDīGHMLQQHMRUJDQL]DFMLUyZQLHīLWDP]GDU]DMĆVLċF]DVDPLQD SLċFLDZVIHU]H]DU]ĆG]DQLD']LHMHVLċWDNQDMF]ċğFLHMJG\QDOHī\]GHILQLRZDý ]DNUHVZâDG]\RUD]MHMHJ]HNZRZDQLDZSUDNW\FHGODNDīGHMIXQNFMLZVSRâHF]QRğFL QSZSU]\SDGNXXSUDZQLHĕF]âRQNyZ.RPLWHWX$UELWUDīRZHJRPRīOLZRğFLSR GHMPRZDQLDSU]H]VWHZDUGyZG]LDâDĕZORNDOQ\FKSURMHNWDFKSRG]LDâXRERZLĆ]NyZ PLċG]\JOREDOQĆ.RPLVMċ5]HF]QLNyZDORNDOQHNRPLWHW\NRQWUROQH

257

258

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... GDVLċZ]JOċGQLHâDWZRZ\PLHQLýMHğOLQLH]JRG]ĆVLċ]Z\W\F]Q\PL :0)1DV]F]ċğFLHGODUXFKX:LNLPHGLDMDNGRWHMSRU\īDGHQ]MHJR XF]HVWQLNyZQLH]EOLī\âVLċZGĆīHQLDFKGRNWyUHMNROZLHN]W\FKVNUDM Q\FKRSFML²ZV]\VF\VĆğZLDGRPLīHQLH]DOHīQLHRGWHJRNWyUH]SR Z\īV]\FKSRGHMğýPDWHRUHW\F]QĆSU]HZDJċQDGGUXJLPSUyEDSU]H IRUVRZDQLDJRVNRĕF]\VLċSRZDīQ\PNU\]\VHP3HZQHHOHPHQW\ZDONL RZâDG]ċMDNMXīRSLVDQRVĆZğUyGLQWHUHVDULXV]\HZLGHQWQHLQDMSUDZ GRSRGREQLHMZ\QLNDMĆFH]QLHVWRVRZDQLDVLċGRMHGQHM]]DVDGU]ĆG]ĆF\FK VSRâHF]QRğFLDPLVDPRRUJDQL]XMĆF\PLVLċ2VWURP Z\PDJDMĆFHM E\JUDQLFHPLċG]\F]ċğFLDPLVSRâHF]QRğFLE\â\MDVQRRNUHğORQH:âDğ QLHWDNVLċG]LHMHZUXFKX:LNLPHGLDQDV]F]HEOXJOREDOQ\PJG]LH NDīGD]HVSRâHF]QRğFLPDQDVZRMHSRWU]HE\VWDELOQHL]GHÀQLRZDQH UDP\RUJDQL]DF\MQHOHF]UyZQRZDJDPLċG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLHOHPHQ WDPLVNâDGRZ\PLUXFKXMHVWZFLĆīSâ\QQD&RRF]\ZLVWHZV\WXDFMDFK JG\UDP\RUJDQL]DF\MQHQLHVĆMDVQR]GHÀQLRZDQHWRZFHOXZ\SHâQLH QLDSXVW\FKSU]HVWU]HQLLQWHUHVDULXV]HSRVXZDMĆVLċGRUyīQ\FKUR] JU\ZHNLZFLHODMĆZī\FLHUR]PDLWHVWUDWHJLH:âDG]DRUJDQL]DF\MQD :0)]DNRU]HQLRQDZSRVLDGDQLXGRPHQLQWHUQHWRZ\FKG]LċNLNWy U\P IXQNFMRQXMĆ SURMHNW\ ]GROQRğFLDFK SR]\VNLZDQLD IXQGXV]\ LV]NLHOHFLHDGPLQLVWUDF\MQ\P]RğURGNDPLSUDZQ\PLWHFKQLF]Q\PL LNRRUG\QDF\MQ\PL RVâDELDQDMHVWSU]H]URVQĆFHRF]HNLZDQLDSURIH VMRQDOL]XMĆF\FKVZRMHG]LDâDQLDSDUWQHUyZORNDOQ\FKRUD]LFK]U]HV]H QLD MDNWHīVLOQLHLGHRORJLF]QHMVSRâHF]QRğFLRFKRWQLNyZSU]\F]\P SU]\MċWĆSUDNW\NĆMHVWZ\UDīDQLHLG\VNXWRZDQLHREDZ&RZLċFHMLVW QLHMHZLHOHZL]MLUyORGJU\ZDQ\FKSU]H]XF]HVWQLNyZUXFKXRUD]GURJL NWyUĆPLDâE\SRGĆī\ýUXFK:LNLPHGLDMDNRFDâRğýFRMHV]F]HVLOQLHM GHVWDELOL]XMHFDâ\V\VWHP.DUWĆSU]HWDUJRZĆEċG]LHZWHMV\WXDFML XZLHU]\WHOQLHQLHZRF]DFKVSRâHF]QRğFLDWXIXQGDFMċFKRý]DU]ĆG]D QLĆ5DGD3RZLHUQLF]DWU]HEDMHGQDNX]QDý]DEDUG]LHMRGGDORQĆRG UXFKXQLīORNDOQHRUJDQL]DFMH:LNLPHGLD3DUDGRNVDOQLHEUDNEH]SR ğUHGQLHMRGSRZLHG]LDOQRğFLSU]HGVSRâHF]QRğFLĆVSUDZLDīHIXQGDFMD MHVWVâDEV]D.HDUQV*XRL0XVVR V]F]HJyOQLHGODWHJR īHG]LDâDSU]HFLHīRSLHUDMĆFVLċQDHJRYHUQDQFHLRELHFXMĆF]GHFHQ WUDOL]RZDQHXSUDZQLHQLHRUD]EH]SRğUHGQLĆUROċVSRâHF]QRğFL0D] ]DUHOOD 0RīQDMHGQDNDUJXPHQWRZDýīH]DU]ĆG]DQLHUXFKHP:LNLPHGLD SRGREQLHGRZLHOXLQQ\FKIDNW\F]QLHXF]HVWQLF]ĆF\FKLVDPRU]ĆGQ\FK RUJDQL]DFMLMHVW]VDPHMVZRMHMGHÀQLFMLQLHNRPSOHWQH*DUXGLLQ JG\ī]DDQJDīRZDQLHXF]HVWQLNyZUXFKXZMHJRFLĆJâHWZRU]HQLH

MIĘDZY ANARCHIĄ A BIUROKRACJĄ: ZARZĄDZANIE W WIKIPEDII VWDQRZLSRF]ċğFLRMHJRDWUDNF\MQRğFL:DīQĆF]ċğFLĆ]DU]ĆG]DQLD UXFKHP:LNLPHGLDMHVW]ZURWQDVDPRRUJDQL]DFMDXMċWDMDNRSURFHV -HVVRS 6WUXNWXUD]DU]ĆG]DQLDUXFKXMHVWZFLĆī]PLHQQD]Dğ QLHSRNRUQDNUHDW\ZQRğýXF]HVWQLNyZZSRâĆF]HQLX]HVNUDMQĆSU]HM U]\VWRğFLĆG]LDâDĕVNXWNXMHF]\PğFRSRZLHU]FKRZQLHZ\JOĆGDQD ]DFLHNâ\EyMIUDNFMLOHF]ZU]HF]\ZLVWRğFLVWDQRZLPHWRGċFDâNLHP SRNRMRZHMVWDâHMUHJHQHUDFMLVWUXNWXU\RUJDQL]DF\MQHM(IHNWSU]\SR PLQDVZRMĆIRUPĆRUJDQL]DFMċVLHFLRZĆ3RZHOO JG\īRGVWċSXMH RQDRGZ]RUFyZKLHUDUFKLF]Q\FKLU\QNRZ\FKW\SRZ\FKGODWUDG\F\M Q\FKIRUPRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FKFKRýMHVWMHGQRF]HğQLHVNUDMQLHDQW\JRVSR GDUF]D']LDâDQD]DVDGDFKDGKRNUDFML.RQLHF]Q\D.RQLHF]Q\ DOERUDF]HMKHWHUDUFKLLF]\OLDGKRNUDW\F]QHMPHU\WRNUDFML ]UR]SURV]RQĆVLHFLĆVWUXNWXUZâDG]\áĆF]\ELXURNUDW\F]QĆNRQWUROċ SURFHGXUDOQĆ]HODVW\F]Q\PGRVWRVRZDQLHPRUJDQL]DF\MQ\PRUD] VSRQWDQLF]QRğFLĆZ\PDJDMĆFGRSHZQHJRVWRSQLDQLHSUHF\]\MQ\FK LSâ\QQ\FKSURFHGXURUD]]DVDG]DU]ĆG]DQLD7RQRZHSRâĆF]HQLHPRīH VWDQRZLý]MDZLVNRNWyUH2·1HLOQD]ZDâÅVLHFLRZĆELXURNUDFMĆSOH PLHQQĆµ EċGĆFĆRGSRZLHGQLNLHPZVSyâF]HVQ\FKQLHZLUWXDOQ\FK ÅPLċNNLFKELXURNUDFMLµ&RXUSDVVRQ UyZQRZDīĆF\FKIRUPD OL]DFMċLī\ZLRâSU]HGVLċELRUF]RğFL-HVWWRV\VWHPVDPRG]LHOQLHUHSUR GXNXMĆF\VLċDXWRPDW\F]QLHGRVWRVRZXMĆF\VLċGRV\WXDFMLVWZRU]RQ\ VDP]VLHELHLDXWRSRLHW\F]Q\3DĕNRZVND 1LHVWHW\VDPR RUJDQL]DFMDF]ċVWRSURZDG]LGRGRVNRQDOHQLDUDFMRQDOQRğFLSURFHGXU DQLHNRQFHQWUDFMLQDFHODFKRUJDQL]DFML0H\HUL5RZDQ+HUPDQ L5HQ] :SU]\SDGNXUXFKX:LNLPHGLDPRīQDWR]DXZDī\ý ZQSNRQFHQWUDFMLG\VNXVMLQDWHPDFLHHJDOLWDU\]PXZâĆF]DQLXQRZ\FK Xī\WNRZQLNyZGRZVSyâSUDF\ZROQRğFLLQIRUPDFMLV]DFXQNXGOD ]QDF]ĆF\FKPQLHMV]RğFLZV]\VWNLHWHNZHVWLH]ZLĆ]DQHVĆ]HVW\OHP ZVSyâSUDF\ZSURMHNFLH QLH]DğQDGĆīHQLXGRFKZLOLZNWyUHMNDīGD RVREDQDğZLHFLHEċG]LHPLDâDGRVWċSGRVXP\OXG]NLHMZLHG]\FRMHVW FHOHPUXFKXOHF]SU]\]QDF]QLHPQLHMV]\PXG]LDOHF]DVXSRğZLċFRQHJR QDG\VNXVMHQDGQLP %H]Z]JOċGXQD]PLDQ\ZSâ\ZyZZJURQLHXF]HVWQLNyZUXFKX:LNL PHGLDMHVWGRğýRF]\ZLVWHīH]DUyZQR:0)MDNLMHM5DGD3RZLHUQLF]D VĆSUDZQLHLRUJDQL]DF\MQLHZ\MĆWNRZRVLOQHLXPRFRZDQHZGHF\]MDFK GRW\F]ĆF\FK]DVDGL]DU]ĆG]DQLD3RVWU]HJDMĆVZRMĆUROċMDNRFRğ RZLHOHLVWRWQLHMV]HJRQLīVâXīHQLHVSRâHF]QRğFLZIRUPLHFLFKHJRZVSLH UDQLDMHMG]LDâDĕLZ\NRQ\ZDQLDMHMGHF\]MLFKFĆSU]HZRG]LýUXFKRZL :LNLPHGLDLXVWDODýMHJRFHOH=XZDJLMHGQDNQDVLOQĆLGHRORJLċXF]HVW

259

260

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... QLFWZDZ\UDīDQĆSU]H]F]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFLMHM]DSDWU\ZDQLDQD ZâDVQRğýSURMHNWyZRUD]VLOQĆSR]\FMċSDUWQHUyZORNDOQ\FKLLFK DVSLUDFMHSUDNW\F]QDZâDG]DIXQGDFMLSRMPRZDQDMDNRPRīOLZRğý NV]WDâWRZDQLDNLHUXQNXZMDNLPSRGĆī\UXFK:LNLPHGLDLMHJRGDO V]HJRUR]ZRMXMHVWGRğýRJUDQLF]RQD =MHGQHMVWURQ\RJyOQLHXMPXMĆFÅVSRâHF]QRğýE\âDMDNGRWĆGZVWDQLH XWU]\PDý:0)ZSU]\SLVDQHMMHMUROL²MDNRâĆF]QLNDLQVW\WXFMRQDOQHJR PLċG]\VSRâHF]QRğFLDPLSURMHNWyZDRJyâHPVSRâHF]HĕVWZDRUD]MDNR ]LQVW\WXFMRQDOL]RZDQHJREXIRUX]ZLċNV]DQLDXF]HVWQLFWZDZSURMHN WDFKµ&KHQ SU]\MPXMĆF]DVDG\LGHF\]MHSUDZLHZ\âĆF]QLH ZZ\QLNXNRQVHQVXVXZVSRâHF]QRğFL&KHQ =GUXJLHMVWURQ\VSRâHF]QRğýUXFKX:LNLPHGLDZVSRVyEW\SRZ\ GODJUXSDNW\ZLVWyZSRGĆīDMĆF\FKğODGDPLRNUHğORQHMLGHRORJLLFR F]\QL]PLDQċRUJDQL]DF\MQĆEDUG]LHMSUDZGRSRGREQĆ'RERV]%RXUQH L.RVWHUD MHVWVNUDMQLHZUDīOLZDQDSXQNFLHZV]\VWNLHJRFR ZMHMPQLHPDQLXQLHMHVW]JRGQH]ÀOR]RÀĆUXFKXMDNNZHVWLHÀOWUD REUD]yZSRVWU]HJDQHMDNRNURNZNLHUXQNXFHQ]XU\LRJUDQLF]DQLD ZROQRğFL,QWHUQHWXMHGQHM]IXQGDPHQWDOQ\FKZDUWRğFL:LNLPHGLD SRU.HOW\ JG\īZVZRLPUR]XPLHQLXNLHUXMHVLċHWRVHP3HQW ]ROG $NW\ZLğFLSDUWQHUVNLFKRUJDQL]DFMLUXFKX:LNLPHGLD SURIHVMRQDOL]XMĆVZRMHG]LDâDQLDLWZRU]ĆVWUXNWXU\RUJDQL]DF\MQH VWDQRZLĆFHDOWHUQDW\ZċGOD:0)2E\GZLHWHQGHQFMH]QDF]QLH]PQLHM V]DMĆ]DNUHVUHDOQHMZâDG]\:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQOHF]FDâ\SURFHV PLPRVZRMHMSRZLHU]FKRZQRğFL]DOHī\EDUG]LHMRGQHJRFMDFMLQLīRG NRQÁLNWX

UWAGI KOŃCOWE

:QLQLHMV]HMSXEOLNDFMLRSLVDâHPZ\QLNLV]HğFLROHWQLHJRXF]HVWQLF]Ć FHJRSURMHNWXHWQRJUDÀF]QHJRZ:LNLSHGLL6WDUDâHPVLċSU]HGVWDZLý SRGVWDZRZH]DVDG\ZHGâXJNWyU\FKī\MHVSRâHF]QRğýSURMHNWXDWDNīH SRND]DýīHG\VNXUVUyZQRğFLZ:LNLSHGLLMHGQRF]HğQLHQDVLODZ\F]XOH QLHQDZV]HONLHSU]HMDZ\ZâDG]\:\MDğQLâHPMDNWHRUHW\F]QLHDKLH UDUFKLF]Q\V\VWHPPRīHZ]PRFQLýSRVWU]HJDQLHQLHUyZQRğFLZXMċFLX SUDNW\F]Q\PMDNWHīVSRVyEZMDNLKLHUDUFKLDMHVWNRQVWUXRZDQDSU]H] JâRVRZDQLDLZ\ERU\VSRâHF]QRğFLRZH²MHG\QĆF]ċVWĆRND]MċQDWRE\ RJyâVSRâHF]QRğFL]UHDOL]RZDâVZRMĆZâDG]ċ3RND]DâHPīHZSUDZG]LH :LNLSHGLċF]ċVWRSU]HGVWDZLDVLċMDNRVSRNRMQĆLQDVWDZLRQĆQDZVSyâ SUDFċPyZLVLċZUċF]īHWRPRGHORZ\SU]\NâDGVNXWHF]QHMRUJDQL ]DFMLRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\ OHF]ZWDNLPVDP\PVWRSQLXSROHJDRQD WDNīHQDNRQÁLNWDFKLVSRUDFK2SLVDâHPMDNVWRSQLRZH]ZLċNV]DQLH XG]LDâXMHGQRVWNLZHG\WRZDQLXLHVNDODFMD]DDQJDīRZDQLDVWDQRZLĆ RDWUDNF\MQRğFLWHJR]DMċFLDLRMHJRX]DOHīQLDMĆF\PFKDUDNWHU]HDZNRQ VHNZHQFMLUyZQLHīRNRQÁLNWRJHQQRğFL:\MDğQLâHPMDNSRZLHU]FKRZ QLHFKDRW\F]QDDQDUFKLVW\F]QDLOHVHIHU\F]QDRUJDQL]DFMDZVSyâSUDF\ ZUDPDFK:LNLSHGLLMHVWWDNQDSUDZGċSRGDWQDQDğFLVâĆNRQWUROċSU]H] REVHUZDFMċL]DSLV\ZDQLH]DFKRZDĕVWUXNWXUDOL]RZDQLHG\VNXVMLXF]HVW QLNyZRUD]SURFHGXU\3U]HDQDOL]RZDâHPQDJURPDG]HQLHELXURNUDFML ZUR]XPLHQLXīHOD]QHJRSUDZDROLJDUFKLLSRWU]HEċSU]\ZUDFDQLD LXVWDQDZLDQLDKLHUDUFKLLLWHFKQLF]QHZVSDUFLHGODUR]G]LHOHQLDGRVWċSX

262

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... GRZâDG]\PLċG]\QRZRSU]\E\â\PLDZHWHUDQDPL3RND]DâHPMDNNRQ WURODRUJDQL]DF\MQDWDNVLOQDZSR]RVWDâ\FKDVSHNWDFKUR]OXĩQLDVLċ ZNZHVWLLVSUDZG]DQLDUHIHUHQFMLFRMHVWVNXWNLHPSU]HMğFLDRG]DXID QLDLQWHUSHUVRQDOQHJRLSRWU]HE\NRQWURORZDQLDLQQ\FKGR]DXIDQLD SURFHGXURP3RND]DâHPMDNEUDNUR]SR]QDZDQLDU]HF]\ZLVWHJRGR ğZLDGF]HQLDHG\WRUyZLIRUPDOQHMZLHG]\SRPDJDZXWU]\PDQLXVSR âHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLL]DUyZQRSU]H]GDZDQLHMHMPRīOLZRğFLEXGRZDQLD DOWHUQDW\ZQ\FKZ]RUFyZZâDG]\MDNWHīSU]H]QHJRZDQLHVNRVWQLDâ\FK VWUXNWXUWZRU]HQLDZLHG]\ZğZLHFLHU]HF]\ZLVW\P3U]HğOHG]LâHPHZR OXFMċUROL-LPP\·HJR:DOHVDZ:LNLSHGLLLREMDğQLâHPMDNVSRâHF]QRğFL RWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\Z\PDJDMĆ]JRGQRğFLZNZHVWLLV\QFKURQL]DFML PRGHOXSU]\ZyG]WZDRUJDQL]DF\MQHJRZâDGF]HJROXEHJDOLWDUQHJR ]IRUPDPLHJ]HNZRZDQLDZâDG]\EH]SRğUHGQLRLLQWHUZHQFMRQLVW\F]QLH OXERJyOQLHLZL]MRQHUVNR 1DNRQLHFGRNRQDâHPDQDOL]\VNâDGXZH ZQċWU]Q\FKLQWHUHVDULXV]\UXFKX:LNLPHGLDLRSLVDâHPMDNQDWHQ VNâDGZSâ\ZDSRVWċSXMĆFDSURIHVMRQDOL]DFMDORNDOQ\FKSDUWQHUyZ :0)5R]ZDī\âHPPRīOLZRğýRGâĆF]HQLDVLċF]ċğFLXF]HVWQLNyZUXFKX IRUNLQJ SU]HDQDOL]RZDâHPQDSLċFLDLNRQÁLNW\Z\VWċSXMĆFHPLċG]\ NOXF]RZ\PLJUDF]DPLGODRVRE\SRVWURQQHMPRJĆFHPLHý]âRZURJL FKDUDNWHUOHF]ZU]HF]\ZLVWRğFLEċGĆFHQLHJURĩQ\PLMHğOLZ]LĆýSRG XZDJċīHVĆRQHSRSURVWXEDUG]LHMGRVâRZQHLZ\HNVSRQRZDQHZVNUDM QLHRWZDUWHMNXOWXU]HQLīZWUDG\F\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMDFK LGRNRQDâHP UHÁHNVMLQDGSRZVWDMĆF\PSâ\QQ\PPRGHOHP]DU]ĆG]DQLDUXFKHP :LNLPHGLDRJUDQLF]DMĆF\PZSâ\Z:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQPLPRVSUD ZRZDQLDSU]H]QLĆQDMZDīQLHMV]HMUROL :QLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDOHSRGHMPċMHV]F]HGZLHNZHVWLHğFLğOH]ZLĆ ]DQH]SRSU]HGQLPLUR]G]LDâDPLOHF]QLHRSLVDQHMHV]F]HEH]SRğUHGQLR .ZHVWLHWHGRW\F]ĆWHJRF]\VSRâHF]QRğFLRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXZVSyâSUDF\ VĆDZDQJDUGĆUXFKXNWyU\XZDOQLDVSRâHF]HĕVWZRRGQHROLEHUDOQHJR UHīLPXF]\UDF]HMVĆRQHSUHOXGLXPGRQRZHMHU\WRWDOLWDUQHMLLGHROR JLF]QHMNRQWUROLRUD]F]\:LNLSHGLDMHVWSU]\NâDGHPUHZROXFMLZâDG]\ LZLHG]\GHÀQLXMĆF\PQDQRZRJUDQLFHZLHG]\VSRâHF]QHMLKLHUDUFKLL RZHMZLHG]\

UWAGI KOŃCOWE

NOWE WOLNOŚCI I ALTRUIZM, CZY WYZYSK NA NOWO? 8F]HVWQLFWZRZVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKZLUWXDOQ\FKRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\MDN QSSURMHNWDFKUXFKX)/266LLQQ\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLDFKRRWZDUW\P PRGHOXG]LDâDQLDPD]QDF]Q\ZSâ\ZQDHQNXOWXUDFMċLNV]WDâWRZDQLH ZVSyOQ\FKZDUWRğFLXF]HVWQLNyZ'ODSU]\NâDGXHW\NDKDNHUyZUXFKX 'HELDQDMHVWZZLHONLPVWRSQLX]EXGRZDQDVSRâHF]QLHLZ]PRFQLRQD ZLQWHUDNFMDFKPLċG]\Xī\WNRZQLNDPLRGPLHQQLHQLīPDWRPLHM VFHZWUDG\F\MQHMU\QNRZHMNRQFHSFMLZâDVQRğFLLQWHOHNWXDOQHM&ROH PDQL+LOO SU]\MPXMĆF]DSXQNWFHQWUDOQ\VLOQĆZLDUċZZROQRğFL RVRELVWH&ROHPDQL*ROXE 3HNND+LPDQHQ RSLVXMHQDGHMğFLHQRZHMIDOLÅKDNHUVNLHMHW\NLµ FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHMGODSRMDZLDMĆFHJRVLċVSRâHF]HĕVWZDVLHFLRZHJR 1RZ\SDUDG\JPDWSROHJDUyZQLHīQDQRZHMUROLZVSyâSUDF\LZVSyâ SURGXNFMLSU]H]GRNRQDQLHWUDQVIRUPDFMLJRVSRGDUNLLVSRâHF]HĕVWZD %HQNOHUE :]HVWDZLHMHJR]DVDG]QDF]QĆUROċRGJU\ZDMĆDOWUX LVW\F]QHZ\VLâNLZVSyâSUDFRZQLNyZRUD]UyZQRğýXF]HVWQLNyZ'RGDW NRZRÅSRGVWDZRZ\PF]\QQLNLHPRUJDQL]DF\MQ\Pī\FLDQLHMHVWSUDFD DQLSLHQLĆG]HOHF]SDVMDLGĆīHQLHGRVWZRU]HQLDUD]HPF]HJRğZDUWRğ FLRZHJRVSRâHF]QLHµ+LPDQHQ 7UXGQRMHVWQLH]DXZDī\ýīH SRZ\īV]HFHFK\GREU]HZVSyâJUDMĆ]FHQWUDOQ\PLZDUWRğFLDPLVSR âHF]QRğFLUXFKX:LNLPHGLD$QWLQ :LNLSHG\ğFLSRGREQLHGR ÅJHHNyZµRSLVDQ\FKSU]H]&KULVWRSKHUD.HOO\·HJR ZâĆF]\ZV]\ ZWRKDNHUyZSURJUDPLVWyZDGPLQLVWUDWRUyZLWGRSUyF]PHU\WRU\F] QHMSUDF\QDGWUHğFLĆDUW\NXâyZSRğZLċFDMĆWHīGXīRF]DVXQDG\VNXVMH QDGZDUWRğFLDPLLGHDPLLZROQRğFLDPLLQWHUQHWRZ\PLDZLHOH]W\FK G\VNXVMLQDSċG]DQ\FKMHVWSU]H]LGHRORJLċ:âDğQLHPLċG]\LQQ\PL GODWHJRSURWHVW\SU]HFLZNRXVWDZRP623$L3,3$Z\UHī\VHURZDQH SU]H]-LPP\·HJR:DOHVDLRSLVDQHZUR]G]LDOHSRğZLċFRQ\PSU]\ZyG] WZX]\VNDâ\WDNLUR]PDFK:W\P]QDF]HQLXUXFK:LNLPHGLDZSLVXMH VLċZDOWHUQDW\ZQĆOHZLFRZĆNU\W\NċV\VWHPXNDSLWDOLVW\F]QHJR SRNURMXLQLFMDW\Z\Å2FFXS\:DOO6WUHHWµVSU]HFLZLDMĆFHMVLċQHROLEH UDOQHMZHUVMLğZLDWD+DUGWL1HJUL.OHLQ -DN]DXZDī\â 0DUWLQ+LOEHUW DSOLNDFMH:HEZW\PVLHFLVSRâHF]QRğ FLRZHL:LNLSHGLD PDMĆSRWHQFMDâGRZ\SHâQLHQLDRELHWQLF\]HUZDQLD]GâXJRWUZDâ\P GHPRNUDW\F]Q\PNRPSURPLVHPSRPLċG]\ZLHONRğFLĆJUXS\EH]SR

263

264

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ğUHGQLHJâRVRZDQLDSRZV]HFKQHZ]DâRīRQHM]JyU\WHPDW\FH DJâċER NRğFLĆDUJXPHQWDFMLG\VNXVMHLQHJRFMDFMHZPDâHMJUXSLH

:W\PGXFKXPRīQDWHīSRVWU]HJDý:LNLSHGLċMDNRDZDQJDUGċ QRZ\FKWU\EyZZVSyâSUDF\NZHVWLRQXMĆFĆDNWXDOQLHRERZLĆ]XMĆF\ V\VWHPJRVSRGDUF]\LÅGRNRQXMĆFĆWUDQVIRUPDFMLU\QNyZLZROQRğFLµ SU]H]SURGXNFMċVSRâHF]QĆLRWZDUWĆZVSyâSUDFċ%HQNOHUE :LNLSHGLDMHVWMHGQDNUyZQLHīRG]ZLHUFLHGOHQLHPMHV]F]HLQQHJR ]MDZLVNDDPLDQRZLFLHNDSLWDOL]PXSURVXPHQFNLHJR-DNVWZLHUG]LOL *HRUJH5LW]HUL1DWKDQ-XUJHQVRQ V\VWHPWDNLFKDUDNWHU\]XMH VLċZLHONLPLLORğFLDPLQLHRSâDFDQHMSUDF\LSURGXNWyZSRZVWDMĆF\FK EH]NRV]WyZFRVNXWNXMHREÀWRğFLĆGyEUSRSU]HGQLREċGĆF\FKU]DG NRğFLĆ3RVWU]HJDMĆRQL]MDZLVNR:HEZW\P:LNLSHGLċMDNRIHQR PHQSRMDZLDMĆF\VLċQDIDOLQRZHMRIHQV\Z\NDSLWDOL]PXFHFKXMĆFHJR VLċPRīHMHV]F]HZ\īV]\PZ\]\VNLHPQLīSRSU]HGQLR=DPLDVWF\IUR ZHMXWRSLLUyZQRğFLZROQRğFLLÅNXOWXU\V]F]RGURğFLµ7DSVFRWWL:LO OLDPV PRīHRQVâXī\ýMDNMXī]DXZDīRQRZ\īHMZ]PRīRQHPX QDG]RURZLNRQWUROLNRUSRUDF\MQHMLQDGXī\FLRPSU]H]HNVSORDWDFMċQLH RSâDFDQHMSUDF\7XUQHU%DXPDQ0RUR]RY 5HZR OXFMDWHFKQLF]QDQRZHMIDOLNDSLWDOL]PXZWDNLPVDP\PVWRSQLXGDMH VZRERGċZMDNLPMĆRGELHUD6HQQHWW :W\PXMċFLXV\VWHP\PRW\ZDF\MQHRUD]SDUDKLHUDUFKLHLVWUXNWXUD X]QDQLDVSRâHF]QHJRV\VWHPyZRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\RSLVDQHZSRF]ĆW NRZ\FKGZyFKUR]G]LDâDFKWHMNVLĆīNLPRīQDSRVWU]HJDýMDNRSRWHQ FMDOQHHOHPHQW\NRQWUROLQRUPDW\ZQHM.XQGD QDGXF]HVWQLNDPL ]SRF]ĆWNXSU]H]QDNâDQLDQLHXF]HVWQLNyZGRZVSyâSUDF\RIHURZDQLH LPPRīOLZRğFLSRGHMPRZDQLDG]LDâDĕRQLVNLPNRV]FLHXF]HVWQLFWZD ZMHGQRUD]RZ\FKQLHPDOEH]Z\VLâNRZ\FKSRUFMDFK]DğSyĩQLHMZSâ\ ZDQLHQDV\VWHP\ZDUWRğFLXF]HVWQLNyZLVW\PXORZDQLHGDOV]HJR UR]ZLMDQLDSURMHNWXSU]H]SHUVZD]MċLGHRORJLF]QĆ(G\WRZDQLH:LNL SHGLLF]ċVWRSU]HGVWDZLDQHMHVWMDNR]DEDZDQDOHī\MHGQDN]D]QDF]\ý īHLQWHUQHWRZHVSRâHF]QRğFLJUDF]\QLHU]DGNRIRUVXMĆLGHRORJLċ]DEDZ\ .FNOLFK DRUJDQL]DFMHNRPHUF\MQHUyZQLHīZFRUD]ZLċNV]\P VWRSQLXGRNRQXMĆSRQRZQHMGHÀQLFMLSUDF\XND]XMĆFMĆMDNRGREUĆ ]DEDZċ)OHPLQJL6SLFHU)OHPLQJL6SLFHU6¡UHQVHQ L6SRHOVWUD ²ZV]\VWNRSRWRDE\ZSâ\QĆýQDPRW\ZDFMċXF]HVW QLNyZ)DNWīHSUDFDZUDPDFKSODWIRUPRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\SRVWU]H JDQDMHVWMDNRKREE\QLHSRZLQLHQR]QDF]DýīHEUDNXMHZQLHMHOHPHQWX Z\]\VNX.U\W\NDRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\MDNRQRZHMIRUP\JHQHURZDQLD

UWAGI KOŃCOWE NDSLWDâXG]LċNLXī\WNRZQLNRP]DSU]ċJQLċW\PGRWZRU]HQLDZDUWRğFL GODÅSURGXFHQWyZµQLHRGQRVLVLċEH]SRğUHGQLRGR:LNLSHGLL:LNLSHGLD UR]ZLMDQDMHVWZWU\ELHQRQSURÀWDZ\]\VNXF]HVWQLNyZRLOHZRJyOH Z\VWċSXMHVâXī\RJyâRZLVSRâHF]HĕVWZD7U]HEDMHGQDNSDPLċWDýīH LVWQLHMĆLQQHRUJDQL]DFMHG]LDâDMĆFHQDED]LHFURZGVRXUFLQJXG]LċNL VSRâHF]QHPXJHQHURZDQLXWUHğFLQS7ULS$GYLVRUF]\,0'% RSDUWH QDHOHPHQWDFKRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\SU]HWHVWRZDQ\FKWDNGREU]HQD SU]\NâDG]LH:LNLSHGLL]RULHQWRZDQHMXīFDâNRZLFLHE\]PDNV\PDOL]R ZDýSU]\FKRG\1DOHī\ZLċF]D]QDF]\ýīHWH]DMDNRE\]MDZLVNRRWZDUWHM ZVSyâSUDF\MHGQR]QDF]QLHL]GHF\GRZDQLHSURZDG]LâRGRXZROQLHQLD NRQVXPHQWyZRGWUDG\F\MQ\FKLQVW\WXFMLQHROLEHUDOQ\FKLJRVSRGDU F]\FKZ\GDMHVLċ]E\WU\]\NRZQD &RZLċFHMWHRUHW\F]QDGHPRNUDW\]DFMDSURFHVXJHQHURZDQLDZLHG]\ PRīHE\ýWDNQDSUDZGċRGQRZLHQLHPLXPRFQLHQLHPMXīG]LDâDMĆFHJR V\VWHPX.|QLJ FR]RVWDâRSU]\ZRâDQHZUR]G]LDOHSRğZLċFR Q\PVWUXNWXU]HLKLHUDUFKLL-DNSRND]XMHGRELWQLH3DULVHU ZVZRLPQLHGDZQ\PRSUDFRZDQLXZROQ\GRVWċSGRLQIRUPDFMLPRīH E\ý]DJURīRQ\SU]H]ÅSċFKHU]\NLÀOWUXMĆFHµLNRUSRUDF\MQĆPRQRSR OL]DFMċZLHG]\QLHW\ONRZVSLHUDMĆFĆVWDUHVWUXNWXU\OHF]UyZQLHī GRGDMĆFĆGRQLFKQRZHZDUVWZ\:LNLSHGLDZ\GDMHVLċğZLDGRPLHOXE QLHE\ýZFHQWUXP]QDF]QHJRNRQÁLNWXLGHRORJLF]QHJR-DNVLċRND ]XMH5LW]HUL-XUJHQVRQ $NWXDOQLHSRWċīQHLZ\VRFHGRFKRGRZHNRUSRUDFMHWDNLHMDN0LFURVRIW L*RRJOHZDOF]ĆRZ\īV]ĆZLGRF]QRğýLZâDG]ċZ,QWHUQHFLH.LHUXQHN L FHOH NDSLWDOL]PX ² V]F]HJyOQLH VWDâH ]ZLċNV]DQLH ]\VNX ² VWRMĆ ZVSU]HF]QRğFL]F\EHUOLEHUWDULDQL]PHPNWyU\MHVWHNVSRQRZDQ\ ZVHUZLVDFKWDNLFKMDN:LNLSHGLDF]\VSRâHF]QRğFLDFK/LQXNVDLUXFKX &UHDWLYH&RPPRQV=W\FKZ]JOċGyZNRUSRUDFMHOLF]ĆFHQD]\VNLQLH PRJĆ]DSRPLQDýR,QWHUQHFLHPXV]Ć]QDOHĩýVSRVRE\QDGRVWRVRZDQLH VLċGRWHMQRZHMHW\NLVLHFLSU]\QDMPQLHMSU]HMğFLRZR

)LOWHUEXEOHWRIHQRPHQSROHJDMĆF\QDW\PīHFRSUDZGD,QWHUQHWXPRīOLZLD GRVWċSGRZV]HONLHMLQIRUPDFMLDOHMHGQRF]HğQLHDOJRU\WP\Z\V]XNLZDQLDVĆGR VWRVRZ\ZDQHGRMHGQRVWNLLVĆGHWHUPLQRZDQHSU]H]SUHIHUHQFMHSRFKRG]HQLH VSRâHF]QHGRFKyGLWS=DWHPWRFRSR]RUQLHZ\GDMHVLċ]DV\S\ZDQLHPF\IURZHJR SRG]LDâXZLVWRFLHPRīHJRSRJâċELDýLGRGDWNRZRXPDFQLDý

265

266

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 0RīHWRE\ýSRZRGHPGODNWyUHJRVSRâHF]QRğýUXFKX:LNLPHGLD ī\ZLRâRZRUHDJXMHQDMDNLHNROZLHNSU]HMDZ\FHQ]XU\QDZHWMHğOLFKRG]L RPDWHULDâ\SyâSRUQRJUDÀF]QHOXEGUDVW\F]QHOHF]PDMĆFHPLHMVFH ZWUHğFLDFKHQF\NORSHG\F]Q\FK RUJDQL]XMĆFZLHONLHSURWHVW\FHOHP RFKURQ\ZROQRğFL,QWHUQHWXLWZDUGREURQLĆFSU\ZDWQRğFLXī\WNRZ QLNyZ&KRýNRQFHSFMDÅLQWHUQHWRZ\FKWXE\OFyZµF]\WHīÅG]LHFLVLHFLµ &]HUVNL ZSU]\SDGNXQRZHJRSRNROHQLDMHVWSU]HVDG]RQDLSR ZLHODQDEH]JâċEV]HMUHÁHNVML6HOZ\Q FRğZQLHMMHGQDNMHVW -HğOLVWRVXMHVLċMĆGRZV]\VWNLFKWRSRNROHQLH:LNLSHGLLOXG]LNWyU]\ GRURğOLF]\WXMĆFLF]DVDPLHG\WXMĆF:LNLSHGLċEċGĆFğZLDGNDPLQRZHM NXOWXU\PHGLyZZ]QDF]Q\PVWRSQLX]DOHīQHMRGSURGXNFMLNRQVXPHQ FNLHM'HX]H EDUG]RGREU]HZSDVRZXMHVLċZWċGHÀQLFMċ 2SLVDQHZ\īHMVSU]HF]QHÀOR]RÀHOLEHUWDULDQL]PNRQWUDQRZDOHZLFD ]ZLċNV]DQLHZROQRğFLRVRELVW\FKNRQWUDV\VWHPQRZ\FKSU]HğODGRZDĕ ZVSyâSURGXNFMDMDNRDOWUXLVW\F]QHZVSyOQHSU]HGVLċZ]LċFLHNRQWUD SUDQLHPy]JXFHOHPSR]\VNDQLDGDUPRZHMVLâ\URERF]HM QLHPXV]Ć VLċFDâNRZLFLHZ\NOXF]Dý:LNLSHGLDPRīHSRF]ċğFL]DOHīHýRGNRQWUROL QRUPDW\ZQHMLLGHRORJLF]QHMMHGQDNMHMQDMFLHPQLHMV]HHIHNW\XERF]QH PRīOLZHGR]DXZDīHQLDZRUJDQL]DFMDFKNRPHUF\MQ\FK%DUOH\L.XQGD )OHPLQJL6SLFHU QLHSRMDZLDMĆVLċ]XZDJLQDFDâNRZLFLH RFKRWQLF]\LQLHSLHQLċīQ\FKDUDNWHUXF]HVWQLFWZDZSURMHNFLHRUD]SUR ÀOQRQSURÀWRUJDQL]DFMLQDGU]ċGQHMZVWRVXQNXGRUXFKX&RZLċFHM :LNLSHGLDPRīHE\ýGREU\PSU]\NâDGHPÅZVSyâSURJUHV\ZL]PXµ -RKQVRQ FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHMFHFK\F\IURZ\FKWXE\OFyZâĆF]Ć FHMFHFK\NRMDU]RQHQDMF]ċğFLHM]SUDZLFĆOLEHUWDULDQL]PUR]SURV]RQD LQWHOLJHQFMDSU]HZDīDMĆFDQDGVFHQWUDOL]RZDQ\PSODQRZDQLHP ]WUD G\F\MQLHSU]\SLV\ZDQ\PLOHZLF\ZVSyâSUDFDUR]ZLMDQLHLRFKURQD GyEUZVSyOQ\FK

WIKIPEDIA JAKO ZAGROŻENIE 3DXOGX*D\RSLVXMĆFUyīQHSRGHMğFLDGRWRīVDPRğFLRUJDQL]DF\MQHM VWZLHUG]Lâ Å0XVLP\]REDF]\ýMDNSRV]F]HJyOQHNDWHJRULH RVyE]RVWDâ\VWZRU]RQHOXEXNV]WDâWRZDQHZRNUHğORQ\FKNRQWHNVWDFK ZRNUHğORQ\PF]DVLHLSU]\Xī\FLXRNUHğORQ\FKQDU]ċG]Lµ$WUDNF\M QRğýE\FLDZLNLSHG\VWĆMHVW]ZLĆ]DQD]LVWRWQ\P]QDF]HQLHPWHJRīH Xī\WNRZQLF\PRJĆSU]\MĆýPDVNċWZyUFyZZLHG]\UROċWUDG\F\MQLH

UWAGI KOŃCOWE ]DUH]HUZRZDQĆGODZ\VRFHXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQHMNDVW\QDXNRZFyZ%\ý PRīHUyZQLHīGODWHJR:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWV]HURNRFHQLRQDZPXUDFK XF]HOQL-DNVWZLHUG]Lâ/DZUHQFH6DQJHU -HğOL:LNLSHGLDXU]HF]\ZLVWQLVZyMQDMZLċNV]\SRWHQFMDâSRGSRVWDFLĆ PLHU]DOQHMMDNRğFLHNVSHUFLQLHEċGĆPXVLHOLE\ýXPLHMVFDZLDQLQD SR]\FMDFKRV]F]HJyOQHMZâDG]\E\OXG]NRğýPLDâD]DVRE\GRNâDGQLH RG]ZLHUFLHGODMĆFHRSLQLHHNVSHUWyZ

ĞZLDGRPLHOXEQLHZLHOXQDXNRZFyZPRīHX]QDZDý:LNLSHGLċ]D V\PEROLF]QH]DJURīHQLHLFKDXWRU\WHWX6SUDZ\SU]\ELHUDMĆMHV]F]H JRUV]\REUyWJG\SRGHMPXMĆRQLSUyEċHG\WRZDQLD:LNLSHGLLLQDJOH VWDMĆRNRZRNR]IDNWHPīHLFKRNXSLRQHFLċīNĆSUDFĆVWRSQLHQDXNRZH QLHSRPDJDMĆDQLQDMRWċZG\VNXVMDFK]SR]RVWDâ\PLHG\WRUDPL,FK DXWRU\WHWZG\VNXUVLHRUD]ZLHG]DSRZLQQ\RF]\ZLğFLHGRSRPDJDý ZXPRFQLHQLXSUH]HQWRZDQHMDUJXPHQWDFMLOHF]Z:LNLSHGLLDXUDHNV SHUWDMHVWSU]\JDV]RQD:LNLSHGLDSRQRZQLHGHÀQLXMHWU\E\ZSURZD G]DQLDZRELHJZLHG]\LMHMUR]ZLMDQLDSU]HLVWDF]DMĆFMĆZNRQFHSFMċ UHODFMLÅZLHOXGRZLHOXµLÅXF]HVWQLF]ĆFHMHNVSHUFNRğFLµ3ÀVWHU ,QQRZDF\MQDNRQVWUXNFMD]DXIDQLDLWRīVDPRğFLZ:LNLSHGLLSU]HGVWD ZLRQDZMHGQ\P]SRSU]HGQLFKUR]G]LDâyZWHMNVLĆīNLZ\QLND]SRWU]HE\ RGU]XFHQLDWUDG\F\MQHMKLHUDUFKLLSURGXNFMLZLHG]\:W\P]QDF]HQLX SHZQDGR]DOHNFHZDīHQLDW\WXâyZQDXNRZ\FKZ\âĆF]QLHSRGSRVWDFLĆ IRUPDOQHJRX]QDQLDDXWRU\WHWyZEH]RGQRV]HQLDVLċGRNZHVWLLIDN W\F]QHMZLHG]\ MHVW]DNRU]HQLRQDZÀOR]RÀLUXFKX =DU]ĆG]DQLHZLHG]ĆPRīHE\ýMHG\QLHSU]HORWQĆPRGĆZOLWHUDWXU]H EL]QHVRZHM-HPLHOQLDNL.RFLDWNLHZLF] OHF]IDNW\F]QH]DU]Ć G]DQLHZLHG]ĆSU]H]FURZGVRXUFLQJJHQHURZDQLDRZHMZLHG]\VNXWNXMH XGDQ\PSU]HGHÀQLRZDQLHPJUDQLFZLHG]\VSRâHF]HĕVWZDNWyUHJR F]ċğFLĆMHVWUXFK:LNLPHGLD1LHXQLNQLRQDZW\PSURFHVLHUHG\VWU\ EXFMDZâDG]\VSRâHF]QHM)RXFDXOW MHVWSUDZGRSRGREQLHMMHV]F]H EDUG]LHMLVWRWQDQDGâXīV]ĆPHWċQLīUyZQROHJâDWUDQVIRUPDFMDNRQ VXPHQWyZNXOWXU\ZMHMSURGXFHQWyZ%UXQV 1RZ\WU\EJHQH URZDQLDZLHG]\SU]HğFLJDWUDG\F\MQ\KLHUDUFKLF]Q\SRG]LHORQ\QD VWUHI\ZSâ\ZyZNDVWRZ\V\VWHPQDNWyU\PVZHG]LDâDQLHRSLHUDMĆ XQLZHUV\WHW\*LEERQV*RGLQL*LQJUDV%DUWXQHN VWDMĆFVLċSUDZGRSRGREQLHMHV]F]HEDUG]LHMZ\GDMQ\RGLQVW\WXWyZ QDXNRZ\FKMHğOLFKRG]LR]DDQJDīRZDQLHXF]HVWQLNyZRUD]V]HUV]HM VSRâHF]QRğFL

267

268

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... 7DUHZROXFMDZG]LHG]LQLHG\VWU\EXFMLZLHG]\LZâDG]\PRīH]DVNR F]\ýZLHOXDLQQ\FKQDZHWSU]HUD]Lý0RīHE\ýMHGQ\P]SRZRGyZGOD NWyU\FKF]ċğýWHFKQRORJLF]Q\FKJXUXLQDXNRZFyZFKċWQLHSU]HZLGXMH QDGFKRG]ĆF\NRQLHF:LNLSHGLL'ODSU]\NâDGX(ULF*ROGPDQSURIHVRU QDXNSUDZQ\FKQD6DQWD&ODUD8QLYHUVLW\MXīZURNXRVWU]HJDâ īHÅ:LNLSHGLDXSDGQLH]DSLċýODWµ*ROGPDQ MDNRSRZyGSRGD MĆFMHM]E\WQLRRWZDUWĆQDWXUċMDNWHīVSDGDMĆF\HQWX]MD]PF]âRQNyZ VSRâHF]QRğFLRUD]RJUDQLF]DQLHVLċPRīOLZRğFLZDONL]HVSDPHPLZDQ GDOL]PDPL:PLDUċXSâ\ZXODWSRZWDU]DVZRMHSURURFWZDJâyZQLH XDNWXDOQLDMĆFSU]HZLG\ZDQĆGDWċRGHMğFLD:LNLSHGLLGRODPXVD$Q GHUVRQ &]ċğýQDXNRZFyZPLPRīHQLHSU]HZLGXMHWDNU\FKâHJRXSDGNX :LNLSHGLLSRVWU]HJDMĆMDNRVHNWċ$UWKXU3HWHUV0HW] E &\WXMĆF6DPD9DNQLQD :V]\VWNLHVHNW\VĆWDNLHVDPHSRMDZLDVLċZQLFKKLHUDUFKLD]DZLâH ]DVDG\SDUDQRLGDOQD]DğFLDQNRZRğýEUDNWROHUDQFMLGODÅP\ğOĆF\FK LQDF]HMµNU\W\NDQWyZLQLH]JRG\DFRZLċFHMSU]\SLVXMĆRQHVRELH NRVPLF]Q\FKUR]PLDUyZPDMHVWDW\F]QĆPLVMċGRVSHâQLHQLD1LHPD QLHJURĩQ\FKVHNW:V]\VWNLHNLHURZDQHVĆSU]H]MHGQRVWNLRFHFKDFK QDUF\VW\F]Q\FKD:LNLSHGLDQLHMHVWWXZ\MĆWNLHP

,QQLGRFHQLDMĆFGRNRQDQLD:LNLSHGLLQDGDOXZDīDMĆīHMHVWRQD RSDUWDQDV\VWHPLHQLHVSUDZLHGOLZRğFLUR]ZLĆ]DĕVLâRZ\FKLGRPLQDFML 2·1HLOD EċGĆFÅVNDīRQĆVSRâHF]QRğFLĆZLHG]\µ5REHUWVL3H WHUV 1DOHī\MHGQDN]DXZDī\ýīHPLPRSRZ\īV]\FK]DVWU]HīHĕSRVWU]H JDQLH:LNLSHGLLSU]H]ğURGRZLVNDDNDGHPLFNLH]F]DVHPMHVWFRUD] OHSV]HSRGREQLHMDNZ]UDVWD]DXZDīDQLHMDNRğFLMHMWUHğFL6KDFKDI DNUċJLQDXNRZHQLHW\ONRFRUD]F]ċğFLHM]QLHMNRU]\VWDMĆDOH QDZHWDNW\ZQLHZVSLHUDMĆ%DWHPDQL/RJDQ+HLOPDQLLQ NRU]\VWDMĆF]QLHMQDZHWMDNR]QDU]ċG]LDG\GDNW\F]QHJR.R QLHF]Q\ FKRýZLHOXSU]\]QDMHRWZDUFLHīH:LNLSHGLDVDPD ZVRELHMHVWZ\]ZDQLHPGODWUDG\F\MQLHSRMPRZDQHJRDXWRU\WHWX DNDGHPLFNLHJR(LMNPDQ -DN]DXZDī\â0DWWKHZ%DWWOHV $XWRU\WHWNRQLHFNRĕFyZZ\ZRG]LVLċ]Z\QLNyZQLH]Dğ]EL]DQW\MVNLFK NRQVWUXNFMLWDNLFKMDNVWRSQLHQDXNRZHQDJâyZNLHG\WRUVNLHF]\QHR NODV\F\VW\F]QHNROXPQ\-HğOLQLHGRSU]\ZLOHMRZDQLOXEQLHGRW\WXâRZDQL

UWAGI KOŃCOWE F]âRQNRZLHQDV]HMVSRâHF]QRğFLPDMĆVLHG]LHýFLFKRWRNWRZ\HJ]HNZXMH RGQLFKWċFLV]ċ"5]ĆG"8QLZHUV\WHW\LIXQGDFMH"'RVWDZF\,QWHUQHWX LPHGLDOQLJLJDQFL"&]\WRVĆDXWRU\WHW\²EĆGĩLFKDZDWDU\ZIRUPLH ]ZHU\ÀNRZDQ\FKLRÀFMDOQLHXGRNXPHQWRZDQ\FKWUHğFL²NWyU\PSRZLQ QLğP\VLċNâDQLDý" 'RğZLDGF]HQLHZLHG]DLDXWRU\WHW\QLHWUDFĆVZRMHMPRF\SRSU]H NURF]HQLXJUDQLF,QWHUQHWX$NWXDOQLHHZROXXMĆMHG\QLHQDU]ċG]LD RGNU\ZDQLDLZ]PDFQLDQLDDXWRU\WHWXHNVSHUFNLHJRMHGQRVWHNWDP JG]LHVLċRQSRMDZLD

-HVWWR]JRGQH]REVHUZDFMĆ&OD\D6KLUN\·HJRSU]\ZRâDQ\]D*DXQW OHWW :LNLSHGLDGHIDFWR]DSRZLDGD]PLDQċZQDWXU]HDXWRU\WHWyZ3U]HG HUĆ%ULWDQQLNLZLċNV]RğýHQF\NORSHGLLZ\ZRG]LâDVZyMDXWRU\WHWRG DXWRUD1DVFHQLHSRMDZLâDVLċ%ULWDQQLFDLGRNRQDâDFDâNLHPUDG\NDO QHJR]DSHZQLHQLDīHDXWRU\WHWPRīHWHīVSRF]\ZDýZUċNDFKLQVW\WX FML=DXIDMFLH%ULWDQQLFHNWyUD]NROHL]QDMG]LHOXG]LNWyU]\QDSLV]Ć GODQLHMKDVâD:LNLSHGLD]DWRVXJHUXMHīHDXWRU\WHWPRīQDXWRīVDPLý ]ZLGRF]Q\PSURFHVHP-HğOLZLG]LVLċMDNG]LDâD:LNLSHGLDL]DXZDīD VLċDNFHSWRZDOQHUH]XOWDW\MHMG]LDâDQLDPRīQDMHMZGâXīV]HMSHUVSHN W\ZLH]DXIDý-HVWWRQDSUDZGċSRWċīQHZ\]ZDQLHGODQDV]HJRSRMPR ZDQLDWHJRF]\PMHVWLQVW\WXFMDFRR]QDF]D]DXIDýF]HPXğF]\FR R]QDF]DDXWRU\WHWZWDNLHMVSRâHF]QRğFL

:V]HUV]\PXMċFLX:LNLSHGLDPLPRMHMQLHGRVNRQDâRğFLSUREOHPyZ LQDSLċýMHVWQDGDOGRVNRQDâ\PXFLHOHğQLHQLHPKDEHUPDVRZVNLHM SODWIRUP\ÅUDFMRQDOQHJRG\VNXUVXµHPDQF\SXMĆFHJRNRPXQLNDFMċ LSR]ZDODMĆFHJRQDWZRU]HQLHLG]LHOHQLHVLċZLHG]ĆZGXFKXHJDOLWD U\]PXSU]HF]ĆFWH]LHMDNRE\WHFKQRORJLDLQIRUPDF\MQDE\âDJâyZQLH QDU]ċG]LHPNRQWUROLVSRâHF]QHMLGRPLQDFML&DPPDHUWV+DQVHQ LLQ 5]XFDRQDZ\]ZDQLHÅPRQRORJLF]QHPXµDXWRU\WHWRZLHNV SHUFNLHPXGRPLQXMĆF\FKHOLWLQWHOHNWXDOQ\FK+DUWHOLXV NR PXQLNDF\MQDDXWRUHÁHNV\MQRğýSUDZGDZ\SUDFRZ\ZDQDSU]H]GLDORJ LXVLHFLRZLRQHNRPSHWHQFMHZ:LNLSHGLLVWDQRZLĆRRVWU\PNRQWUDğFLH ]PRGHOHPWUDG\F\MQ\PXFLHOHğQLDQ\PSU]H]%ULWDQQLNċ-DN]DXZD ī\â-RVHSK05HDJOHE LQVW\WXFMHVSRâHF]HĕVWZZNWyU\FK IXQNFMRQRZDâ\XQLZHUV\WHW\XF]HQLLPċGUF\]DZV]HZ\âDQLDâ\VLċ ZRGSRZLHG]LQDQLHGRVNRQDâRğFLVZRLFKSRSU]HGQLNyZLQLHPRīQRğý

269

270

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ]DVSRNRMHQLDSU]H]HĕSRWU]HEZG]LHG]LQLHJHQHURZDQLDLUR]SR ZV]HFKQLDQLDZLHG]\FRPRīQDWHīRGQLHğýGR:LNLSHGLL 3URMHNW\UXFKX:LNLPHGLDZSHZQ\PXMċFLXEDODQVXMĆQDNUDZċG]L VSRâHF]QHMSU]HGVLċELRUF]RğFL&ODPSL$OKDPLV QDZHWMHğOLQLH VĆZīDGQHMPLHU]H]RULHQWRZDQHQDJHQHURZDQLH]\VNyZJG\īVĆ ğPLHUWHOQ\PLNRQNXUHQWDPLZLHOXSRGREQ\FKSURGXNWyZUR]ZLMDQ\FK MDNRUR]ZLĆ]DQLDNRPHUF\MQH%ULWDQQLFDDRGQLHGDZQD:LNLWUDYHO MXīEROHğQLHRGF]Xâ\īHQDSċG]DQHVLâDPLRFKRWQLNyZVSRâHF]QRğFL SRğZLċFRQHUR]SRZV]HFKQLDQLXZLHG]\]DGDUPRLEH]UHNODPPRJĆ WZRU]\ýSURGXNW\NWyUHEDUG]LHMSU]HPDZLDMĆGRF]\WHOQLNyZLZVSyâ WZyUFyZQLīLFKZâDVQHUR]ZLĆ]DQLD-HVWWRPRīOLZHSRF]ċğFLG]LċNL ]DVWRVRZDQHPXPRGHORZL]DU]ĆG]DQLDZNWyU\PZ\VWċSXMH]DOHīQRğý RGUR]SURV]RQHMVSRâHF]QRğFLLHG\WRUyZF]DVDPLRUJDQL]XMĆF\FKVLċ ZLQVW\WXFMHSDUWQHUVNLHOHF]SU]\XG]LDOHSURIHVMRQDOQHMIXQGDFML RGSRZLHG]LDOQHM]DV]NLHOHWG]LDâDĕFRREMDğQLDâRVWDWQLUR]G]LDâQLQLHM V]HMNVLĆīNL

ZAKOŃCZENIE 1LQLHMV]DNVLĆīNDMHVWVNXWNLHPJâċERNRXF]HVWQLF]ĆFHJRLZUċF]LQ W\PQHJRZQLNQLċFLDZEDGDQĆRUJDQL]DFMċRRWZDUW\PXF]HVWQLFWZLH -DNRPHWRGċEDGDZF]ĆZ\EUDQRSDUW\F\SDFMċFRMHVWSU]HGPLRWHP V]HUV]HJRREMDğQLHQLDZSLHUZV]\PGRGDWNXGRNVLĆīNLSRğZLċFRQ\P PHWRG\FHEDGDĕ6WDUDâHPVLċRSLVDýXQLNDOQĆRUJDQL]DFMċVSRâHF]QĆ :LNLSHGLL]ZV]HONLPLMHMRVREOLZRğFLDPLG\VIXQNFMDPLLSUREOHPDPL

:LNLWUDYHONRPHUF\MQHSU]HGVLċZ]LċFLH,QWHUQHW%UDQGVZ\NRU]\VW\ZDâR ZâDVQĆVSRâHF]QRğýRFKRWQLNyZGRUR]ZLMDQLDZLNLSU]HZRGQLNDWXU\VW\F]QHJR :URNX]QDF]QDF]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFLSURMHNWX]GHF\GRZDâDVLċSRGMĆýZVSyâ SUDFċ]:LNLYR\DJHQLHPLHFNLPIRUNLHPSURMHNWX:LNLWUDYHOVWZRU]RQ\PZURNX ZVNXWHNQLH]DGRZROHQLD]SHUVSHNW\Z\]DPLHV]F]DQLDZVHUZLVLHUHNODP ZVSyOQLHZQLRVNXMĆFRZâĆF]HQLHLFKSU]HGVLċZ]LċFLDGRJURQDSURMHNWyZ:LNL PHGLDSRDSUREDFLH:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ7UHğFL:LNLWUDYHOPRīQDE\âRX]\VNDý ]H]U]XWXED]\GDQ\FKQDPRF\OLFHQFML&UHDWLYH&RPPRQVFKRý,QWHUQHW%UDQGV QLHGâXJRZ\âĆF]\âDWċPRīOLZRğý ZLċFQRZ\VHUZLVLQWHUQHWRZ\MXīSRGQD]ZĆ :LNLYR\DJHVNXWHF]QLHSU]HMĆâWUHğFLLNOXF]RZĆF]ċğýVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLWUDYHO SR]RVWDZLDMĆF,QWHUQHW%UDQGVZQLHZ\JRGQHMSR]\FMLVWUDWHJLF]QHM&RKHQ ]REUyZQLHī>>HQ:3:LNLYR\DJH@@

UWAGI KOŃCOWE DOHUyZQLHīSRND]XMĆFMHMQLHE\ZDâĆZ\GDMQRğýRWZDUWRğýLNXOWXUċ HJDOLWDU\]PX :LNLSHGLDMHVWRJyOQLHXMPXMĆFV]DOHĕF]RDPELWQ\PSURMHNWHP GĆīĆF\PGR]HEUDQLDVXP\OXG]NLHMZLHG]\ZSRMHG\QF]\P]RUJDQL ]RZDQ\PLXVWUXNWXUDOL]RZDQ\PRSUDFRZDQLXRUD]GRXGRVWċSQLHQLD RZHMVXP\ZLHG]\ZV]\VWNLPFKċWQ\P]DGDUPR&KRýVĆWDF\NWyU]\ XZDīDMĆīHG]LHâR:LNLSHGLLMHVWEOLVNLHVSHâQLHQLX5RVHQ WR LQQLWZDUGR]DSU]HF]DMĆWDNLPSRJOĆGRP*G]LHNROZLHNQLHZ\SDGQLH IDNW\F]Q\SXQNWQDV\FHQLDWUHğFLĆSURZDG]LGRQLHJRGâXJDGURJD MHğOLSRGXZDJċZ]LĆýZV]\VWNLHSURMHNW\:LNLPHGLDZNDīGHMZHUVML Mċ]\NRZHM2ERMċWQLHF]\:LNLSHGLDMHVWIDNW\F]QLHRWZDUWDLHJDOLWDUQD F]\QLHF]\Z\VWDUF]DMĆFRF]ċVWRSRGDMHSUDZLGâRZHLQIRUPDFMHF]\ QDGDO]E\WâDWZRSR]ZDODSU]HNâDPDQLRPQDZ]LċFLHJyU\F]\MHM]D U]ĆG]DQLHLVWUXNWXUDVĆZ\VWDUF]DMĆFRVWDELOQHE\]DSHZQLýMHMGâXJR IDORZĆVWDELOQRğýPLPR]PLDQVSRâHF]Q\FKF]\QLH²MHGQRMHVWSHZQH VSRâHF]QDRUJDQL]DFMDQLHHNVSHUFNLHMSUDF\ZWHMZLUWXDOQHMVSRâHF] QRğFLRWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\MHVW]MDZLVNLHPIDVF\QXMĆF\PZ\MĆWNRZ\P LLQVSLUXMĆF\PGODEDGDĕQDG]DU]ĆG]DQLHPRUD]RUJDQL]DFMĆL² PLHMP\QDG]LHMċ²QLHUD]VWDQLHVLċWHPDWHPEDUG]LHMV]F]HJyâRZHM DQDOL]\ 8ī\WNRZQLN5DXOVWZRU]\â]ELyUÅ3UDZ:LNLSHGLLµJG]LH ]JURPDG]LâZâDVQH]âRWHP\ğOLMDNWHīUyīQRUDNLHPĆGURğFLSRFKR G]ĆFHRGLQQ\FKPDUFDGRNROHNFMLGRâĆF]\âÅ]HURZHSUDZR :LNLSHGLLµQLH]QDQHJRSRFKRG]HQLD-HVWWRZVSDQLDâHSRGVXPRZDQLH ZLHF]QLHHZROXXMĆFHMQLHE\ZDOH]UyīQLFRZDQHML]DVNDNXMĆFRVNX WHF]QHMVSRâHF]QRğFLPRJĆFHVâXī\ý]DRVWDWHF]QĆNRQNOX]MċQLQLHMV]HM NVLĆīNLÅ3UREOHP:LNLSHGLLOHī\ZW\PīHG]LDâDRQDZ\âĆF]QLH ZSUDNW\FH7HRUHW\F]QLHWHQSURMHNWQLHMHVWZVWDQLHIXQNFMRQRZDýµ

8ī\WNRZQLN(PLMUSRNUHğOLâīHQDNRQLHF:LNLSHGLDPRīH]DZLHUDýRNRâR VXP\OXG]NLHMZLHG]\RSLHUDMĆFVLċQDSU]\EOLīHQLDFKZUyīQ\FKG]LHG]LQDFK ZLHG]\OLF]ELHÅF]HUZRQ\FKOLQNyZµF]\OLOLQNyZGRQLHLVWQLHMĆF\FKMHV]F]HZSLVyZ LWG=RE>>HQ8VHU(PLMUS$OOBKXPDQBNQRZOHGJH@@ 'RNXPHQWGRVWċSQ\SRGDGUHVHPKWWSHQZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL8VHU5DXO 5DXOVBODZV

271

Dodatek 1

METODYKA BADAŃ

3XEOLNDFMDPDFKDUDNWHUQDXNRZ\LMDNRWDNDPXVLREMDğQLý]DVWRVR ZDQĆPHWRG\NċL]DâRīHQLDPHWRGRORJLF]QH:SUDZG]LHQLQLHMV]\ GRGDWHNPRīHE\ýPQLHMSU]\VWċSQ\GODF]\WHOQLNyZQLHEċGĆF\FK QDXNRZFDPLOHF]XPLHMVFDZLDSU]HSURZDG]RQHEDGDQLDZNRQWHNğFLH OLWHUDWXU\SU]HGPLRWXLZV]HUV]\PSRGHMğFLXQDXNRZ\P0RīHWHī VâXī\ýMDNRZSURZDG]HQLHGRLQWHUQHWRZ\FKEDGDĕHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FK

ETNOGRAFIA A PRZENIKNIĘCIE DO BADANEJ SPOŁECZNOŚCI Ī\FLHZLUWXDOQ\FKG]LNLFKMHVWSURMHNWHPHWQRJUDÀF]Q\P:LHOHRSUD FRZDĕQDXNRZ\FKSU]HGVWDZLDVLċMDNRHWQRJUDÀHRUJDQL]DF\MQHZLċF NRQLHF]QHMHVWWXNLONDVâyZNRPHQWDU]D=GDU]DVLċīHVHULċMDNRğFLR Z\FKZ\ZLDGyZLSRMHG\QF]\FKREVHUZDFMLSU]HGVWDZLDVLċMDNRED GDQLHHWQRJUDÀF]QHÅ3RGUyīGRZQċWU]DRUJDQL]DF\MQHMGīXQJOLMHVW F]ċVWRQLHZLHOHZLċFHMQLīEH]SLHF]QĆIRUPĆDQWURSRORJLF]QHMWXU\VW\NL ZWRZDU]\VWZLHSU]HZRGQLNDµ%DWH :U]DGNLFKSU]\ SDGNDFKMDNRÅEDGDQLDHWQRJUDÀF]QHµSU]HGVWDZLDVLċZUċF]DQDOL]\ SU]HELHJDMĆFHEH]GâXīV]HJRSRE\WXZEDGDQHMVSRâHF]QRğFLE\ýPRīH FKFĆFMHXZLDU\JRGQLýFKRýNRĕF]\VLċWRF]\PğFR%DWHQD]ZDâÅSD VWLV]HPHWQRJUDÀLµ7HJRW\SXEDGDQLDPRJĆZSUDZG]LHE\ýFLHNDZH

274

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... LZDUWRğFLRZHOHF]SRELHīQLHQDGDQHLPHW\NLHWNLVNXWHF]QLHUR]ZDG QLDMĆU]HF]\ZLVWHEDGDQLDHWQRJUDÀF]QH:ROFRWW 1LQLHMV]DNVLĆīNDMHVWVNXWNLHPGâXJRWHUPLQRZHJRUHÁHNV\MQHJR XF]HVWQLFWZDZVSRâHF]QRğFLSRâĆF]RQHJR]EDGDQLDPLHWQRJUDÀF]Q\PL :âDğFLZĆGODWHMSR]\FMLWUDG\FMĆEDGDZF]ĆMHVWDQWURSRORJLDRUJDQL]D FMLNWyUD]\VNXMHFRUD]ī\ZV]ĆXZDJċVSRâHF]QRğFLQDXNRZHM6FKZDUW ]PDQ:ULJKW.RVWHUD+XPSKUH\VL:DWVRQ =DNâDGDRQDīHEDGDQLDHWQRJUDÀF]QHZ\PDJDMĆV]HURNLFKG]LDâDĕOR NDOQ\FKSRâĆF]RQ\FK]UyīQ\PLPHWRGDPLDQDOL]NWyU\FKFHOHPMHVW ÅXFKZ\FHQLHSXQNWXZLG]HQLDWXE\OFDMHJRVWRVXQNXGRī\FLDSRMċFLH MHJRZL]MLğZLDWDµ0DOLQRZVNL .VLĆīNDWDMHVWQDSLVDQDSU]H]ÅDQWURSRORJDWXE\OFDµ1DUD\DQ MHVWHIHNWHPGâXJRWUZDâHMREHFQRğFLZEDGDQHMVSRâHF]QRğFL SRGF]DVNWyUHMDXWRU]RVWDâX]QDQ\]DMHMF]âRQND7UDG\F\MQDDQWUR SRORJLDF]DVDPLSU]HVWU]HJDSU]HGEDGDQLHPZâDVQHMNXOWXU\/HDFK Å%DGDQLDWHUHQRZHZNRQWHNğFLHNXOWXURZ\PZNWyU\P PDVLċMXīGRğZLDGF]HQLD]SLHUZV]HMUċNLZ\GDMĆVLċRZLHOHWUXGQLHMV]H RGEDGDĕWHUHQRZ\FK]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDQDLZQHMRVRE\]]HZQĆWU]µ $QWURSRORJRPPyZLVLċE\SR]RVWDOLÅSURIHVMRQDOQ\PLREF\PLµ $JDU OXEÅWXE\OFDPLZPDUJLQDOQ\PVWRSQLXµ/RER :DOVK QLH]DğE\ÅZQLNDOLZVSRâHF]QRğýµ1DGWHJRW\SX REDZDPLG\VNXWRZDQRMXīRGMDNLHJRğF]DVX-DUYLH OHF]VWDQLH VLċWXE\OFHPQLHVLH]HVREĆSHZQH]DOHW\]QDXNRZHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD +D\DQR7UHVFK :SHZQ\FKSU]\SDGNDFKWDNLHG]LDâD QLHPRīHQDZHWE\ýSRīĆGDQH6SHUVFKQHLGHUL%DJJHU -RKQ 9DQ0DDQHQRNUHğOLâWRQDVWċSXMĆFR %DGDQLDWHUHQRZHW\SXHWQRJUDÀF]QHJRVĆDXWHQW\F]QHGRVWRSQLD ZNWyU\PSU]\SRPLQDMĆG]LDâDQLDREFHMRVRE\ZFKRG]ĆFHMZNXOWXURZR QLH]QDQĆMHMVSRâHF]QRğýE\VWDýVLċF]DVRZRZVSRVyEQLHSU]HZLG\ ZDOQ\DNW\ZQ\PXF]HVWQLNLHP]ZLĆ]NyZSRPLċG]\MHMF]âRQNDPL

6]F]HJyOQLHZSU]\SDGNXVSRâHF]QRğFLZLUWXDOQ\FKJG]LHSXQNWHP Z\MğFLDZV]\VWNLFKLFKXF]HVWQLNyZMHVWE\FLHREF\PLZNRĕFXQLNW QLHURG]LVLċLQWHUQHWRZ\PWXE\OFHP SHâQLDGRğZLDGF]Hĕ]HVWDQLDVLċ F]âRQNLHPVSRâHF]QRğFLMHVWQLHRG]RZQD*DWVRQL=ZHHULQN ]Dğ PDQNDPHQW\VWDQLDVLċWXE\OFHP²QDMF]ċğFLHM]QHXWUDOL]RZDQH'R ğZLDGF]HQLHWRGRW\F]\F]HJRğZLċFHMQLīSUDNW\F]QHMNZHVWLLÀ]\F]QHM

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ GRVWċSQRğFLGRVSRâHF]QRğFLVWDQLHVLċZLNLSHG\VWĆDXWRFKWRQHPMHVW QLHW\ONRVSRVREHPQD]DVNDUELHQLHVRELH]DXIDQLDLSU]\MDĩQLLQQ\FK F]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFLE\E\OLRQLJRWRZLG]LHOLýVLċVZRLPLGRğZLDGF]H QLDPLLV]F]HU]HZ\UDīDýSRJOĆG\OHF]UyZQLHīğURGNLHPGR]UR]XPLH QLDWHPDWyZG\VNXVMLLZ\GDU]HĕNWyUHVĆGODWHMVSRâHF]QRğFLLVWRWQH 1DZLUWXDOQHī\FLHVSRâHF]QRğFLFKDUDNWHU\]XMĆFHMVLċÅJâċERNLP ]UyīQLFRZDQLHPµNXOWXUL]DSOHF]D(QJOLVK/XHFN VNâDGDVLċ QLHE\ZDâDZUċF]LORğýLQIRUPDFML&RZLċFHMFKRýPRīOLZHMHVWUHWUR VSHNW\ZQHSU]HğOHG]HQLHZLHOXG\VNXVMLMHVWWRMHGQRF]HğQLHQLHE\ ZDOHWUXGQH'ODRVRE\NWyUDQLHZVLĆNâDZNXOWXUċ:LNLSHGLLQDNLOND ODW]UR]XPLHQLHNRQWHNVWXZLHOXG\VNXVMLLLGHQW\ÀNDFMDWHPDWyZ SRZUDFDMĆF\FKRUD]QRZ\FKMHVWIDNW\F]QLHZ\]ZDQLHP'\QDPLND G\VNXVML]Z\NOHMHVWXWUDFRQDSRMHM]DNRĕF]HQLXÅ%\FLHSRZHZQċWU]QHM VWURQLH>PRīQDX]QDý@]DNOXF]GR]DJâċELHQLDVLċZXNU\WH]DNDPDUNL RUJDQL]DFMLµ/DEDUHH 3RF]ĆWNXMĆF\HG\WRU]\ZDOF]ĆQDZHW ]RSDQRZDQLHPMċ]\NDZâDğFLZHJRWXE\OFRPOHF]WċEDULHUċâDWZLHM MHVWSU]H]Z\FLċī\ýZNRQWHNğFLH:LNLSHGLLQLīZWUDG\F\MQ\FKEDGD QLDFKDQWURSRORJLF]Q\FK%DGDQLDZVWHF]QHSURZDG]RQHSU]H]QLH ZLNLSHG\VWyZF]ċVWRNRĕF]ĆMDNRSâ\WNLHRSUDFRZDQLD]XZDJLQD KHUPHW\F]QĆQDWXUċZLHOX]DFKRZDĕF\IURZ\FKSOHPLRQRUD]SRWU]HEċ ']LċNLX]\VNDQLXXSUDZQLHĕDGPLQLVWUDWRUDRUD]VWHZDUGDPLDâHPGRVWċSGR ]DZDUWRğFLDUW\NXâyZLVWURQG\VNXVMLNWyUH]RVWDâ\XVXQLċWH]:LNLSHGLLSU]H] FRPRJâHP]UR]XPLHýMDNZSUDNW\FHDQLHW\ONRZOLWHU]H]DVDGG]LDâDMĆ]DVDG\ XVXZDQLDL]DFKRZ\ZDQLDWUHğFL :F]HUZFXZDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]QDMGRZDâRVLċPLOLRQDKDVHâOHF] ī\FLHVSRâHF]QRğFL]DFKRG]LâRZLQQ\PMHMREV]DU]H:FDâHM:LNLSHGLL]QDMGXMHVLċ RSUyF]KDVHâSRQDGPLOLRQyZVWURQ²]RE>>HQ:LNLSHGLD6L]HBRIB:LNLSHGLD@@ 1DZHWSRRGMċFLXRGWHMOLF]E\ZV]\VWNLFKVWURQG\VNXVMLNDWHJRULLSU]HNLHURZDĕ LWGVWDMHVLċRNRZRNR]PLOLRQDPLGRNXPHQWyZ]NWyU\FKZLHOH]DZLHUDVHWNL W\VLċF\VâyZGRNXPHQWXMĆFG\VNXVMHPLċG]\Xī\WNRZQLNDPLVWURQ\JâRVRZDĕ RSLQLH]DVDG\L]DOHFHQLDHVHMHDQNLHW\F]\DQHJGRW\]UR]XPLDâHJâyZQLHGODZLNL SHG\VWyZ:DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLZ\GDMHVLċUyZQLHīFRG]LHQQĆÅJD]HWċµUHGD JRZDQĆSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý²>>HQ:LNLSHGLD:LNLSHGLDB6LJQSRVW@@6DPUR]PLDU SLVDQHMNXOWXU\ZLNLSHG\VWyZZDQJLHOVNLHMRUD]LQQ\FKZHUVMDFKMċ]\NRZ\FK ZRGHUZDQLXRGKDVHâQLHF]ċVWRF]\W\ZDQ\SU]H]QLHZLNLSHG\VWyZMHVWQLHER W\F]Q\3UDZGRSRGREQLHQLHPRīOLZHMHVWSU]HF]\WDQLHZV]\VWNLFKW\FKGRNXPHQ WyZZFLĆJXī\FLDOHF]GRğZLDGF]HQLZLNLSHG\ğFLğOHG]ĆRJyOQHG\VNXVMHLGHEDW\ 'RGDWNRZRLPLVWRWQLHMV]DMHVWG\VNXVMDOXERSLQLDW\PEDUG]LHMSUDZGRSRGREQLH ğFLĆJQLHQDVLHELHXZDJċVSRâHF]QRğFLEċG]LHSRGOLQNRZDQDQDRJyOQ\FKVWURQDFK G\VNXVML]NWyU\FKZLHOHUR]SRF]\QDVLċOXESU]\QDMPQLHMQDZLĆ]XMHGRW]ZND ZLDUHQNLDOEREDUX²>>:LNLSHGLD.DZLDUHQND@@>>HQ:LNLSHGLD9LOODJHBSXPS@@ IXQNFMRQXMĆFHMMDNRWDEOLFDRJâRV]HĕOXERJyOQHIRUXPG\VNXV\MQH

275

276

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SR]QDQLDNRQWHNVWXSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKNZHVWLLMDNWHīG\VNXVMLSR]D:LNL SHGLĆ RVRE\]]HZQĆWU]PDMĆRJUDQLF]RQ\GRVWċSGRZLHG]\VSRâHF] QRğFL0HUWRQ NWyUDMHVWGRWHJRVWRSQLDNRQWHNVWRZDīH]D KDF]DRKHUPHW\F]QRğý1LHZLNLSHG\ğFLF]ċVWRWHīLQWHUSUHWXMĆ REVHUZRZDQHV\WXDFMHSU]H]SU\]PDWGRğZLDGF]HQLD]WUDG\F\MQ\FK RUJDQL]DFMLF]HJRVNXWNLHPPRīHE\ýEâĆGNRJQLW\ZQ\²MDNVWDUDâHP VLċZ\ND]DýMHVWWRQDSU]\NâDGW\SRZHGODRGELHUDQLDQDSLċýRUJD QL]DF\MQ\FKZVSRâHF]QRğFLZLNLSHG\VWyZSRVWU]HJDQ\FKQDMF]ċğFLHM MDNRR]QDNLJâċERNLFKNRQÁLNWyZQLH]DğMDNRZ\UD]VNUDMQHMRWZDUWRğFL LRJyOQHJRSU]\]ZROHQLDQDZROQHZ\UDīDQLHRSLQLLEH]REDZRQDUX V]HQLHKLHUDUFKLL1LQLHMV]HEDGDQLH]\VNXMHZLċFG]LċNL]DVWRVRZDQ\P PHFKDQL]PRPDXWRHWQRJUDÀF]Q\P+D\DQR.DQXKD 6WRVXMHVLċWHīGRUDG\%DUEDU\&]DUQLDZVNLHM-RUJHV E\FHOHP NZHVWLRQRZDQLDRF]\ZLVW\FKZ\MDğQLHĕREVHUZRZDQ\FK]MDZLVNL]DFKR ZDQLDWRīVDPRğFLEDGDF]DXWU]\P\ZDýÅDQWURSRORJLF]QHVSRMU]HQLHµ

NARRACJA W PIERWSZEJ OSOBIE 3UH]HQWDFMDUROLHWQRJUDIDF]\HWQRJUDINLZWHUHQLHMHVWQLH]Z\NOHLVWRWQD GOD]DSLVDQHJRHIHNWXMHJROXEMHM SUDF\EDGDZF]HM9DQ0DDQHQ ,VWQLHMHZLHOHVWUDWHJLLSU]HGVWDZLDQLDDXWRUVWZDZG]LHOH HWQRJUDÀF]Q\P*HHUW] (WQRJUDIRZLHF]ċVWRFLHUSLĆ]SRZRGX]MDZLVNDRSLVDQHJRSU]H] &OLIIRUGD*HHUW]D VĆUR]GDUFLPLċG]\QDSLVDQLHPWHNVWXÅQD V\FRQHJRDXWRUHPµDÅRGHUZDQHJRRGDXWRUDµ7UHğFLSLVDQHZSLHUZV]HM RVRELHSU]HQRV]ĆF]\WHOQLNDZPLHMVFH]GDU]Hĕ'DMĆSRF]XFLHÅE\FLD ZFHQWUXPZ\GDU]HĕµGUDPDW\]XMĆRSLV\ZDQHSU]\SDGNLLXZLHU]\ WHOQLDMĆSUDFċDQWURSRORJLF]QĆZEDGDQ\PPLHMVFX7DNLZ\EyUVW\OL VW\F]Q\]DJUDīDMHGQDNQDXNRZHPXSRVWU]HJDQLXSUDF\JG\īRSUDFR ZDQLDQDXNRZH]Z\NOHSLV]HVLċZWU]HFLHMRVRELH:HGâXJWUDG\F\MQHJR SRGHMğFLDQDXNRZF\RGīHJQXMĆVLċFDâNRZLFLHRGVZRLFKVXELHNW\ZQ\FK RVĆGyZ8QLNDQLHQDUUDFMLZSLHUZV]HMRVRELHEXGXMHQDXNRZ\FKD UDNWHURSUDFRZDQLDNWyUHMHVWÅUHDOLVW\F]QHµZW\PVHQVLHīHWUDNWXMH EDGDQLHNXOWXU\MDNRF]\QQRğýQDWXUDOQĆLQLHVSRâHF]QĆWDNMDNE\ QDXNRZLHFRSLV\ZDâMHG\QLHREVHUZRZDQH]GDU]HQLD9DQ0DDQHQ 3RGHMğFLHWDNLH]DNâDGDīHÅHOLPLQDFMDSRVWDFLQDXNRZFD F]âRZLHND]WHNVWXMHVW]JRGQD]]DâRīHQLHPīHXVXQLċFLHVXELHNW\ZL]PX

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ SRFKRG]ĆFHJRRGDXWRUDMHVW]DUyZQRSRīĆGDQHMDNLPRīOLZHµ*ROGHQ %LGGOHL/RFNH 1DUUDFMDEDGDĕHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FKZWU]HFLHMRVRELHE\âDMXīNU\W\ NRZDQD+DVWUXS%DO'HQ]LQL/LQFROQ/LQFROQ L'HQ]LQ DGRWHJRQLHVLH]HVREĆU\]\NRīHÅZLHOH]]DSLVDQ\FK WUHğFLQLHVWDQRZLSRSURVWXFLHNDZHMOHNWXU\JG\īWU]\PDQLHVLċ SU]\MċWHJRPRGHOXZ\PDJDE\SLV]ĆF\XFLV]DOLZâDVQ\JâRVE\X]QD ZDOLVDP\FKVLHELH]DF]\QQLN]DQLHF]\V]F]DMĆF\WHNVWµ5LFKDUGVRQ OHF]GHF\]MDLWDNQLHMHVWâDWZD(WQRJUDÀDF]ċVWRE\âD NZHVWLRQRZDQDLX]QDZDQD]DPDMĆFĆSR]\FMċQLīV]ĆRGSR]RVWDâ\FK QDXNF]DVHPZUċF]EDODQVXMĆFĆQDNUDZċG]LÀNFML6LOYHUPDQ :HEVWHU ZLċFG\OHPDWMHVW]DLVWHQLHPDâ\ &RFLHNDZHDQWURSRORG]\VĆZVWDQLH]DXZDī\ýSROLW\F]QĆQDWXUċ WHJRSUREOHPX&OLIIRUGL0DUFXV HWQRJUDÀDMHVW]DZV]HVXELHN W\ZQDFKRýE\ZGRERU]HSUH]HQWRZDQ\FKF\WDWyZLRSLV\ZDQ\FK ]GDU]Hĕ3RGREQLHGRSR]RVWDâ\FKWHNVWyZQDXNRZ\FKHWQRJUDÀDQLH MHVWUDSRUWRZDQLHPRELHNW\ZQHMU]HF]\ZLVWRğFLDXVXQLċFLHDXWRUD ]SLVDQHJRSU]H]HĕWHNVWXQLHVSUDZLDE\Z\QLNLEDGDĕE\â\EDUG]LHM OXEPQLHMXJUXQWRZDQHMHVWWRSRSURVWXSU]HNRQXMĆFDVWUDWHJLD SROHJDMĆFDQDVFKRZDQLXDXWRUD]DSR]RUQLHEH]VWURQQĆQDUUDFMĆ:DW VRQ 0DWRPLHMVFHQDZHWZWDN²Z\GDZDâRE\VLċ²EH]RVRER Z\FKG]LHG]LQDFKZLHG]\MDNHNRQRPLD0F&ORVNH\ F]\QDXNL ğFLVâH/DWRXUL:RROJDU.QRUU&HWLQD )DNW\F]QLHÅQLH GDVLċXQLNQĆýFLċīDUXDXWRUVWZDRERMċWQLHMDNZLHONLHJRQLHPD PRīOLZRğFLSU]HQLHVLHQLDJRZREV]DU\PHWRG\µ*HHUW] :SU]\SDGNXZ\GDU]HĕNWyU\FKQDXNRZLHFQLHW\ONRE\âğZLDGNLHP OHF]UyZQLHīZNWyU\FKDNW\ZQLHXF]HVWQLF]\âZ\PD]DQLHSLHUZV]HM RVRE\]QDUUDFMLGODXF]F]HQLDWUDG\FMLOLWHUDWXU\QDXNRZHMZ\GDMHVLċ GRğýNRV]WRZQ\PSRVXQLċFLHP%RFKQHU %\ýPRīHZâDğQLHGODWHJRF]ċğýEDGDĕHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FKSURZDG]RQD MHVWZSLHUZV]HMRVRELH3RZGHUPDNHU 3RGREQLHF]ċVWRX]DVDG QLRQHMHVWSLVDQH]SHUVSHNW\Z\ÅMDµZHWQRJUDÀDFKRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FK &]DUQLDZVND -HVWWRLVWRWQHGODQDUUDFMLNWyUHVĆHIHNWHP EDGDĕDXWRHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FK$QGHUVRQ'HQ]LQ$IRQVR L7D\ORU DZNWyU\FKHWQRJUDISRGHMPXMHUHÁHNVMċQDGZâDVQ\PL GRğZLDGF]HQLDPL 3URPXMĆFWDNĆZâDğQLHORJLNċQLHSRGMĆâHPSUyE\Z\HOLPLQRZDQLD ZV]\VWNLFKSU]\SDGNyZQDUUDFMLZSLHUZV]HMRVRELHZQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīFH 2SLVXMĆFVSRâHF]QRğý:LNLSHGLLDWDNīHZZLċNV]RğFLLQQ\FKSU]\SDGNyZ

277

278

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... QDUUDFMċSURZDG]ċZWU]HFLHMRVRELHMHGQDNSU]\ZRâXMĆF]GDU]HQLD ZNWyU\FKVDPE\âHPVWURQĆVWRVXMċHOHPHQW\ÅNRQIHV\MQHµ9DQ0DDQHQ ]DğF\WXMĆFZâDVQHGRğZLDGF]HQLDEĆGĩSRGMċWHGHF\]MH ZâĆF]QLH]QLQLHMV]\PUR]G]LDâHPLNZHVWLĆZ\ERUXPHWRG\EDGDZ F]HM ]GDU]DPLVLċFHOHPSRGNUHğOHQLDXF]HVWQLFWZDSU]HFKRG]LýGR QDUUDFMLSLHUZV]RRVRERZHM

METODY BADAWCZE %DGDQLHNWyUHJRHIHNWHPMHVWQLQLHMV]DNVLĆīNDSRZVWDâRQDED]LHSD UDG\JPDWXLQWHUSUHWDW\ZQHJR%XUUHOOL0RUJDQ.U]\ZRU]HND L.U]\ZRU]HND =JRGQLH]HVâ\QQ\PF\WDWHP&OLIIRUGD*HHUW]D Z\FKRG]ĆFRGSRUyZQDQLD:HEHUD ]DNâDGDRQRīHÅF]âRZLHN MHVW]ZLHU]ċFLHP]DZLHV]RQ\PZSDMċF]\QDFK]QDF]HĕNWyUHVDPXWNDâµ ]DğEDGDQLHJRÅQLHMHVWHNVSHU\PHQWHPZSRV]XNLZDQLXSUDZLGâR ZRğFLOHF]LQWHUSUHWDFMĆSRV]XNXMĆFĆ]QDF]HQLDµ%DGDQLHNRU]\VWD ]PHWDIRU\WHDWUX*RIIPDQ ]DNâDGDVLċīHUROHDNWRUyZRUJD QL]DF\MQ\FKRGJU\ZDQHVĆG\QDPLF]QLHLG\VNXUV\ZQLH%RZHUVL,ZL ]XF]HVWQLFWZHPLFKRGWZyUFyZLQHJRFMRZDQLHPV\PEROLF]Q\FK ]QDF]HĕLFKSRJOĆGyZ%OXPHU&ROOLQV-HPLHOQLDNE 7\SRZRGODRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FKEDGDĕHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FKQLQLHMV]D NVLĆīNDSRVWU]HJDNXOWXUċMDNRUG]HQQĆPHWDIRUċ6PLUFLFK .U]\ZRU]HNDDE FRR]QDF]DīHEDGDQĆVSRâHF]QRğýZLG]L MDNRNXOWXUċ]DNâDGDVLċīHSURFHV\NXOWXURZHVĆZDīQ\PNOXF]HPGR ]UR]XPLHQLDLQWHUDNFMLZHZQĆWU]VSRâHF]QRğFL DQDMRGSRZLHGQLHMV]\P UHSHUWXDUHPPHWRGMHVWSRGHMğFLHDQWURSRORJLF]QH&]DUQLDZVND-RHU JHV$OYHVVRQ 6NXWNLHPWHJREDGDQDNXOWXUDMHVWSRVWU]HJDQDSHUIRUPDW\ZQLH QLH]DğRVWHQV\ZQLH/DWRXU-HPLHOQLDN FRR]QDF]DīH DQDOL]XMHVLċMĆEH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLD]JyU\SU]\MċWHJRWHRUHW\F]QHJR PRGHOXNXOWXU\OHF]GĆī\VLċGR]UR]XPLHQLDPDS\NRJQLW\ZQHMLWHJR MDNNXOWXUD]RUJDQL]RZDQDMHVWZRF]DFKMHMXF]HVWQLNyZDQDOL]DVNXSLD VLċQDIDNW\F]Q\FKSUDNW\NDFKQLH]DğQDW\PFRPRGHOXMĆ]DVDG\ )HOGPDQ6SLFHULLQ 6SRâHF]QLHNRQVWUXRZDQ\FKDUDNWHUFRG]LHQQHMU]HF]\ZLVWRğFL %HUJHUL/XFNPDQ ]DNâDGDīHNDīGDREVHUZDFMDMHVWJâċERNR ]DNRU]HQLRQDZLQWHUSUHWDFMLLīHQDV]HSRVWU]HJDQLHğZLDWD]DZV]HMHVW

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ V\PEROLF]QH&]DUQLDZVND U]HF]\ZLVWRğýVSRâHF]QD]\VNXMH ]QDF]HQLHZ\âĆF]QLHSU]H]LQWHUVXELHNW\ZQHQHJRFMDFMH6FKW] $XWHQW\F]QRğýUH]XOWDWyZRGQDMG\ZDQDMHVWZLċFZRGGDQLX VSUDZLHGOLZRğFLLRGZ]RURZDQLXSRMPRZDQLDğZLDWDSU]H]VSRâHF]QRğý ZU]HWHOQHMUHÁHNV\MQHMLQWHUSUHWDFML]HEUDQHJRPDWHULDâXĩUyGâRZHJR &XQOLIIH ]DPLDVWSU]HGVWDZLDQLDÅMDNWRMHVWQDSUDZGċµ&DVH ZRELHNW\ZQ\PLRğZLHFRQ\PUDSRUFLH :\EUDQHGRQLQLHMV]HJRSURMHNWXPHWRG\EDGDZF]HVĆW\SRZHGOD HWQRJUDÀL1DFKPLDVL)UDQNIRUW1DFKPLDV.U]\ZRU]HND L.U]\ZRU]HND LRSDUWHQDWULDQJXODFMLPHWRG'HQ]LQ -HPLHOQLDNF :EDGDQLXZ\NRU]\VWDQRREVHUZDFMċXF]HVWQL F]ĆFĆZ\ZLDG\RWZDUWHLVWXGLDSU]\SDGNX 7\SRZRGODEDGDĕDQWURSRORJLF]Q\FK$WNLQVRQL+DPPHUVOH\ REVHUZDFMDXF]HVWQLF]ĆFDMHVWZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQDZQDMZLċNV]\P VWRSQLX(PHUVRQLLQ'HODPRQW 3U]\MĆâHPUROċXF]HVW QLNDEDGDF]DVWDUDMĆFHJRVLċ]UR]XPLHýVSRâHF]QRğýMDNRMHMSHâQR SUDZQ\F]âRQHN]\VNXMĆFJâċEV]ĆZLHG]ċQDWHPDWMHMEXGRZ\VSR âHF]QHMQLīE\âRE\WRRVLĆJDOQHZEDGDQLDFKQLHXF]HVWQLF]ĆF\FK $GOHUL$GOHU %DGDQLHUR]SRF]ĆâHPOLVWRSDGDURNX 2GWHJRGQLDFRG]LHQQLHORJRZDâHPVLċZ:LNLSHGLLE\WZRU]\ýQRZH KDVâDSRSUDZLDýLVWQLHMĆFHZSLV\F]\SRSURVWXVSUDZG]LýMDNLFK ]PLDQGRNRQDOLLQQLMDNWHīZFKRG]LýZLQWHUDNFMH]LQQ\PLZLNLSH G\VWDPLQDWHPDW]DVDGQDVWURQDFKG\VNXVMLKDVHâZG\VNXVMDFK QDGHQF\NORSHG\F]QRğFLĆDUW\NXâyZLWHPDWyZ :PLDUċXSâ\ZXF]DVXSLĆâHPVLċSRV]F]HEODFKSDUDKLHUDUFKLL:LNL SHGLL:NZLHWQLX]RVWDâHPZ\EUDQ\QDDGPLQLVWUDWRUDSROVNLHJR SURMHNWX=DF]ĆâHPUyZQLHīHG\WRZDýDQJLHOVNĆ:LNLSHGLċLZPQLHM V]\PVWRSQLXLQQHSURMHNW\:LNLPHGLD:URNX]RVWDâHPMHGQ\P ]NLONXQDVWXELXURNUDWyZSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]REUR]G]LDâQDWHPDW IRUPDOQ\FKUyOLKLHUDUFKLL :URNX]RVWDâHPMHGQ\P]V]HğFLX F]âRQNyZ.RPLVML5]HF]QLNyZZVSyOQHMGODZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZ:LNL PHGLDQDğZLHFLH=IXQNFMLU]HF]QLND]UH]\JQRZDâHPZOXW\P NLHG\WR]RVWDâHPZ\EUDQ\MHGQ\P]HVWHZDUGyZ:LNLPHGLDXī\W NRZQLNyZRQDMZ\īV]\FKXSUDZQLHQLDFKWHFKQLF]Q\FKZHZV]\VWNLFK SURMHNWDFK:LNLPHGLD :SDĩG]LHUQLNX]RVWDâHPGRGDWNRZR Z\EUDQ\GR.RPLVML)LQDQVRZHM)XQGV'LVVHPLQDWLRQ&RPPLWHH JOREDOQHJRFLDâDGRUDGF]HJRSU]\:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQZVNâDG NWyUHJRZFKRG]LVLHGPLXZLNLPHGLDQ]FDâHJRğZLDWDRUD]GZyFKSU]HG VWDZLFLHOL5DG\3RZLHUQLF]HMEH]SUDZDJâRVXZNWyU\P]RVWDâHPWDNīH

279

280

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... SLHUZV]\PSU]HZRGQLF]ĆF\P3RGF]DVPRMHMDNW\ZQRğFLZ:LNLSHGLL ]JURPDG]LâHPSLċFLRF\IURZĆOLF]EċHG\FML3U]H]V]HğýODWVSċG]DâHP Z:LNLSHGLLğUHGQLRJRG]LQċG]LHQQLHXF]HVWQLF]ĆFZMHMSUDFDFK VSRU]ĆG]DMĆFQRWDWNL(PHUVRQLLQ LREVHUZXMĆFVSRâHF] QRğý²RZHVHWNLJRG]LQREVHUZDFMLHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FKVĆPRLPJâyZQ\P ĩUyGâHPNRQNOX]ML&KRýWHFKQLF]QLHE\âHPDNW\ZQ\ZSRQDGSUR MHNWDFK:LNLPHGLDZLċNV]RğýPRLFKHG\FMLSU]\SDGDQDSROVNĆLDQ JLHOVNĆ:LNLSHGLċ0HWDVSHFMDOQ\SURMHNWZLNLNRRUG\QXMĆF\UXFK :LNLPHGLD RUD]ZPQLHMV]\PVWRSQLX&RPPRQVZVSyOQHUHSR]\WR ULXPPHGLyZGODZV]\VWNLFKSR]RVWDâ\FKSURMHNWyZ 'RGDWNRZRNVLĆīNDRSDUWDMHVWQDUHÁHNV\MQ\FKZ\ZLDGDFKMDNRğ FLRZ\FK$OYHVVRQ PHWRG]LHF]ċVWRWRZDU]\V]ĆFHMREVHUZDFMRP 'DUOLQJWRQL6FRWW 3U]HSURZDG]LâHPZ\ZLDGyZ]DGPLQL VWUDWRUDPLSROVNLHMLDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLZW\P]SLċFLRPDVWHZDUGDPL LSU]HGVWDZLFLHODPLSDUWQHUyZ:0)MDNWHī]SLċFLRPDSUDFRZQLNDPL :LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ:V]\VWNLHZ\ZLDG\]RVWDâ\VSLVDQH]QDJUDQLD RSUyF]GZyFKNWyUHSU]HSURZDG]LâHPZVLHFL,5&.DīG\]QLFKWUZDâ RNRâRJRG]LQ\LE\âQLHXVWUXNWXUDOL]RZDQ\:K\WHL:K\WH 7UDQVNU\SFMHSU]\JRWRZDQR]JRGQLH]SRGHMğFLHPHWQRPHWRGRORJLF] Q\P6LOYHUPDQ VSLVDQRMH]DFKRZXMĆFMDNQDMZ\īV]ĆZLHUQRğý RU\JLQDOQHMUR]PRZLHZâĆF]QLH]SDX]DPLLEâċGDPL2GPLHQQLHQLī ZWHRULLXJUXQWRZDQHM*ODVHUL6WUDXVV OHF]W\SRZRGODZ\ZLDGyZ HWQRJUDÀF]Q\FK$WNLQVRQL+DPPHUVOH\ ]HEUDQHGDQHZ\NRU]\ VWDQRZVSRVyEOXĩQRXVWUXNWXUDOL]RZDQ\ZFHOX]UR]XPLHQLDLQIRU PDFML]HEUDQ\FKZZ\QLNXREVHUZDFMLXF]HVWQLF]ĆF\FK 0RQRJUDÀDSRZVWDâDUyZQLHīQDED]LHZ\EUDQ\FKVWXGLyZSU]\SDGNX 'HQ]LQL/LQFROQ6WDNH NWyUHE\â\V]F]HJyOQLHSU]\GDWQH ZRGQLHVLHQLXVLċGRW\FKZ\GDU]HĕZNWyU\FKQLHXF]HVWQLF]\âHP (LVHQKDUGW OHF]NWyUHE\â\LVWRWQHGODNV]WDâWRZDQLDVLċVSR âHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLL%\âHPZVWDQLHSU]HğOHG]LýZV]\VWNLHG\VNXVMH SRVWIDFWXPHG\FMDSRHG\FMLLğOHG]LýSU]HELHJZ\PLDQ]GDĕZF]DVLH MDNWHī]DMU]HýGRW\FKF]ċğFLG\VNXVMLNWyUH]RVWDâ\SyĩQLHMXVXQLċWH DGRWHJRSRQLHZDīMHVWHPGRğZLDGF]RQ\PZLNLSHG\VWĆIDNWQLH XF]HVWQLF]HQLDZRSLVDQ\FKZ\GDU]HQLDFKZF]DVLHZNWyU\PPLDâ\ RQHPLHMVFHQLHE\âGXīĆSU]HV]NRGĆZGRNâDGQHMLFKDQDOL]LH3U]\ SDGNLSRGGDQHEDGDQLRPZ\EUDQH]RVWDâ\]DUDGĆZHWHUDQyZ:LNL SHGLLDLFKRSLVVWDQRZL]QDF]QĆF]ċğýPDWHULDâXZQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīFH JG\ī]RVWDâ\RQHX]QDQH]DQDMEDUG]LHMUHSUH]HQWDW\ZQHLLVWRWQH ZRF]DFKVSRâHF]QRğFL:SRâĆF]HQLX]ZâDVQ\PLREVHUZDFMDPLLZ\ZLD

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ GDPLVWXGLDSU]\SDGNyZSR]ZROLâ\QDV]HURNĆWULDQJXODFMċ]HEUDQHJR PDWHULDâX%D[WHUL-DFN 3U]\SDGNLZ\EUDQHGRV]HUV]HMDQDOL]\ REHMPXMĆâĆF]QLHSyâWRUDPLOLRQDVâyZ&]\VWRWHNVWRZDQDWXUDRZ\FK SU]\SDGNyZRUD]G\QDPLNDQDUUDFMLVSUDZLDMĆīHLFKDQDOL]D]EOLīD VLċGRQDUUDF\MQ\FKVWXGLyZRUJDQL]DFML&]DUQLDZVND%RMH .RVWHUDL*OLQND.RVWHUD$GDPF]\N.RFLDW NLHZLF]L.RVWHUDáXF]HZVNLLáXF]HZVND =DUyZQRDQDOL]\SU]\SDGNyZMDNLREVHUZDFMHXF]HVWQLF]ĆFH]RF]\ ZLVW\FKSRZRGyZRSLHUDâ\VLċQDPHWRGRORJLLDQDOL]\]DZDUWRğFL .ULSSHQGRUII+VLHKL6KDQQRQ FRMHVWW\SRZHGODEDGDĕ SURZDG]RQ\FKZ,QWHUQHFLH+HUULQJ

PYTANIA BADAWCZE 3RGREQLHGRZLċNV]RğFLMDNRğFLRZ\FKEDGDĕLQWHUSUHWDF\MQ\FK0DU VKDOOL5RVVPDQ QLQLHMV]\SURMHNWQLHZ\V]HGâRGOLVW\KLSRWH]GR VSUDZG]HQLDOHF]UDF]HMRGSRF]ĆWNRZ\FKS\WDĕ6LOYHUPDQ E-DNOXG]LHSRVWU]HJDMĆKLHUDUFKLċLEXGXMĆÅNDULHU\µZDKLHUDUFKLF] Q\PğURGRZLVNX"-DNHJ]HNZXMHVLċZâDG]ċLVWDWXVZSURMHNWDFK RRWZDUW\PXF]HVWQLFWZLH":MDNLVSRVyEVSUDZXMHVLċNRQWUROċ RUJDQL]DF\MQĆZğURGRZLVNDFKZLUWXDOQ\FKJG]LHQLHGRVWċSQHVĆ WUDG\F\MQHQDU]ċG]LDPRW\ZDFMLDWRīVDPRğFLVĆSâ\QQH" E-DNF]âRQNRZLHRWZDUW\FKSURMHNWyZRSDUW\FKQDZVSyâSUDF\UyZ QRZDīĆSRWU]HEċVSUDZG]DQLDUHIHUHQFML]DZRGRZ\FKL]DXIDQLD LQQ\PHG\WRURP]SURFHGXUDPLLRUJDQL]DFMĆ" E'ODF]HJRWZRU]\VLċLHJ]HNZXMHELXURNUDW\F]QHSU]HSLV\ZSyâ DQDUFKLF]QHMVSRâHF]QRğFLZLUWXDOQHMNWyUDGHNODUXMHVSU]HFLZ ZREHFWDNLFKSURFHGXU" E:MDNLVSRVyEVSRâHF]QRğýUR]SURV]RQ\FKZRORQWDULXV]\PRīH RGHEUDýXSUDZQLHQLDRUJDQL]DFML:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQ GHIDFWR SRVLDGDMĆFHM]DVRE\ZâĆF]QLH]SODWIRUPĆG]LċNLNWyUHMZRORQWD ULXV]HPRJĆVLċZ]DMHPQLHNRQWDNWRZDý" E-DNLHVĆ]DVDG\LSDUDG\JPDW\]DU]ĆG]DQLDQDNWyU\FKPRīQD RSU]HýIXQNFMRQRZDQLHZLUWXDOQHMVSRâHF]QRğFLED]XMĆFHMQDRWZDUWHM ZVSyâSUDF\" E-DNZRUJDQL]DFMLSRGNUHğODMĆFHMHJDOLWDUQRğýLVSU]HFLZLDMĆFHMVLċ SU]\ZyG]WZXIXQNFMRQXMĆDXWRU\WHW\LSU]\ZyGF\"

281

282

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... E-DNLHIHNWZ\ZRâDâZVWUXNWXU]HRUJDQL]DF\MQHM:LNLSHGLLNU\]\V

SU]\ZyG]WZD"-DNLHURG]DMHNRQÁLNWyZ]ZLċNV]DMĆVZRMHUR]PLDU\ LMDNUR]ZLĆ]XMHVLċNRQÁLNW\" E:MDNLPVWRSQLXSURMHNW\RWZDUWHMZVSyâSUDF\QDSċG]DMĆVLċG]LċNL QLH]JRG]LHLQLH]DGRZROHQLX]DPLDVWGĆīHQLDGRZVSyâSUDF\LNRPX QLNDFML"-DNXVWDODVLċG]LDâDMĆFH]DVDG\ZVSyâSUDF\ZVSRâHF]QRğFL Xī\WNRZQLNyZQLHPDMĆF\FKWDNQDSUDZGċZVSyOQ\FKSXQNWyZD]D WRFHFKXMĆF\FKVLċ]QDF]Q\P]UyīQLFRZDQLHPHGXNDF\MQ\PSRFKR G]HQLRPZLHNRZ\PVSRâHF]Q\PNXOWXURZ\PLWGPDMĆFSU]\W\P RJUDQLF]RQHPRīOLZRğFLSRUR]XPLHZDQLDVLċ" :V]\VWNLHWHS\WDQLD]RVWDâ\SRGMċWHZEDGDQLXRSDUW\PQDVSRâHF] QRğFL:LNLSHGLL

ETNOGRAFIA WIRTUALNA &]ċğýQDXNRZFyZX]QDMHīHSURZDG]HQLHEDGDĕHWQRJUDÀF]Q\FKZ,Q WHUQHFLHMHVWNRPSOHWQLHRGPLHQQHQLīZSU]\SDGNX]Z\Nâ\FKEDGDĕ JG]LHQDVWċSXMHÀ]\F]Q\NRQWDNW%XFKDQDQ 3RGZLHORPDZ]JOċGDPLSURZDG]HQLHEDGDĕWHUHQRZ\FKRQOLQH MHVWRGPLHQQHRGVWHUHRW\SRZHJREDGDQLDHJ]RW\F]Q\FKSOHPLRQ *DUFLDLLQ 'ODSU]\NâDGX EÀ]\F]QDREHFQRğýZW\PVDP\PPLHMVFXZNWyU\PSU]HE\ZDMĆED GDQLMHVWZZLċNV]RğFLV\WXDFMLQLHPRīOLZD]Dğ]GROQRğFLLQWHUDNF\MQH ]NRQLHF]QRğFLRSDUWHVĆQDG\VNXVMLWHNVWRZHMF]ċVWRDV\QFKURQLF] QHM]U]DGNDVWRVXMHVLċUR]PRZ\ZLGHR EEDGDQHRVRE\PDMĆRZLHOHZLċNV]HPRīOLZRğFLWZRU]HQLDVZRLFK WRīVDPRğFLZLċFSUH]HQWDFMDVDPHJRVLHELHMHVWRGPLHQQDQLīZī\ FLXUHDOQ\P*RIIPDQ âDWZRMHVWXNU\ýSHZQHVW\JP\VSR âHF]QH*RIIPDQ QDSU]\NâDGZ\QLNDMĆFH]SâFLSRFKRG]HQLD HWQLF]QHJRF]\XSRğOHG]HĕÀ]\F]Q\FKSRGF]DVJG\LQQHVĆEDUG]LHM Z\HNVSRQRZDQHMDNWH]ZLĆ]DQH]SLğPLHQQRğFLĆ]DNUHVHPVâRZ QLFWZDLWG E]QDF]QLHRGPLHQQHVĆNZHVWLH]\VNDQLDGRVWċSXGRVSRâHF]QRğFL )HOGPDQLLQ MDNWHīVWDZDQLDVLċÅWXE\OFHPµSU]\F]\P RE\GZLHVĆQLH]Z\NOHLVWRWQHGODEDGDĕDQWURSRORJLF]Q\FK

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ EVIHUDSXEOLF]QDLSU\ZDWQDVĆUR]P\WHZLHOHGLDORJyZSURZDG]LVLċ

ZSyâSU\ZDWQ\VSRVyE]]DâRīHQLHPīHFKRýVĆGRVWċSQHSXEOLF]QLH OXEGRVWċSQHZ\âĆF]QLHGODF]âRQNyZVSRâHF]QRğFL ZSUDNW\FH GRVWċSGRQLFK]HVWURQ\RJyâXVSRâHF]QRğFLQLHLVWQLHMH

'RGDWNRZR]PRG\ÀNRZDýQDOHī\F]ċğýZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\FKPHWRG EDGDZF]\FKREVHUZDFMDXF]HVWQLNyZVSRâHF]QRğFLQLH]DFKRG]LSU]H] SRGJOĆGDQLHVDP\FKOXG]LDOHSU]H]SRGĆīDQLH]D]DFKRZDQLDPLLFK DZDWDUyZLLQWHUQHWRZ\FKRVRERZRğFL6FKURHGHUL$[HOVVRQ FRMHVWW\SRZHGODğURGRZLVNZ\âĆF]QLHWHNVWRZ\FK:LOOLDPV 6SRâHF]QRğFLLQWHUQHWRZHQLHVĆMHGQDNXERīV]HZLQWHUDNFMHRG UHV]W\ğZLDWD3DFFDJQHOOD :LHOHV]F]HJyâyZSURZDG]RQHJR EDGDQLDPRīHE\ýRGPLHQQ\FKDEDGDF]PXVLGRVZRMHMSUDF\SRGHMğý ZRGPLHQQ\VSRVyEOHF]MHGQDNSRGRELHĕVWZDLWDNSU]HZDīDMĆÅ%D GDF]HMDNRğFLRZLNWyU]\SU]HP\ğOHOLXZDīQLHNZHVWLċHWQRJUDÀLLQWHU QHWRZHMSU]\MPXMĆīHQDOHī\MĆVWRVRZDýLUR]XPLHýMDNRF]ċğýHWQRJUD ÀF]QHMWUDG\FMLµ7UDYHUV Z]DVDG]LHÅHWQRJUDÀHZLUWXDOQH WRSRSURVWXHWQRJUDÀHµDÅDUJXPHQWīHZWHMG]LHG]LQLHPHU\WRU\F] QLHLPHWRGRORJLF]QLHG]LHMHVLċFRNROZLHNQRZHJRµZ\QLND]XSU]\ ZLOHMRZDQLDVSRâHF]QHJRWUDG\F\MQ\FKPHWRGEDGDZF]\FK5DQGDOO LLQ :âDğQLHGODWHJRGREDGDQLDVSRâHF]QRğFLLQWHUQHWRZ\FKZ\NRU]\ VWDQRHWQRJUDÀċLZâDğFLZHGODQLHMQDU]ċG]LD1RFHUD 2GODW ;;ZLHNXQDXNDWDSU]\FLĆJDFRUD]ZLċFHMDQWURSRORJyZ&ROHPDQ D =RVWDâDUR]ZLQLċWDLSU]\MċWDGRJURQDQDXNVSRâHF]Q\FKJG]LH QD]ZDQRMĆÅZLUWXDOQĆHWQRJUDÀĆµ+LQH+DQFRFNLLQ ÅHWQRJUDÀĆVLHFLRZĆµFRQQHFWLYHHWKQRJUDSK\ 'LUNVHQLLQ ÅHWQRJUDÀĆF\IURZĆµ0XUWK\ ÅHWQRJUDÀĆLQWHUQHWRZĆµ6DGH %HFN F]\MDNFHOQLH]DSURSRQRZDâ5REHUW9.R]LQHWVÅQHWQR JUDÀĆµ.R]LQHWV.R]LQHWV-HPLHOQLDN &]ċğý DQWURSRORJyZZVSRVyEDNW\ZQ\XF]HVWQLF]\âDWHīZUR]ZLMDQLXUXFKX ZROQHMNXOWXU\LZROQHMLQIRUPDFML.HOW\ 7HQREV]DUEDGDĕDQWURSRORJLF]Q\FKMHVWQRZ\OHF]PDMXīXJUXQ WRZDQĆSR]\FMċWDNīHZG]LHG]LQLHDQWURSRORJLLRUJDQL]DF\MQHM%R HOOVWRUII3UDJQHOOL*DW]LGLV6WHLQPHW] &]HUSLĆF ]W\FKSU]\NâDGyZZQLQLHMV]HMSR]\FML]DNâDGDPīHHWQRJUDÀDZLUWXDOQD MHVWRGPLDQĆWUDG\F\MQHMHWQRJUDÀLNWyUDMXīVDPDZVRELHMHVW]UyīQL FRZDQDÅ5]HF]\ZLVWRğýZLUWXDOQDµQLHMHVWRGVHSDURZDQDRGFDâRğFL

283

284

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ğZLDWDOXG]NLFKLQWHUDNFML6WDQRZLRQDUDF]HMV]F]HJyOQĆIRUPċLQ WHUDNFMLOXG]L%HQHLWR0RQWDJXW WZRU]ĆFG]LHG]LQċG]LDâDĕ OXG]NLFKNWyUHMQLHSRZLQQRVLċDUELWUDOQLHRGG]LHODýRGLQQ\FK]DFKR ZDĕ5XKOHGHU -DN]DREVHUZRZDâD&KULVWLQH+LQH =DVDGQH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDHWQRJUDÀLVĆZV]HONLHIRUP\LQWHUDNFMLQLH W\ONRWH]DFKRG]ĆFHÅWZDU]ĆZWZDU]µ.V]WDâWRZDQLHRELHNWXEDGDĕ HWQRJUDÀF]Q\FKZIRUPLHZNWyUHMXPRīOLZLDMĆWRğURGNLWHFKQLF]QH WRWHīHWQRJUDÀD-HVWWRHWQRJUDÀDZğZLHFLHZLUWXDOQ\PGRW\F]ĆFD ğZLDWDZLUWXDOQHJRLSU]H]HĕEDGDQD

$XWRUQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīNLPDMXīGRğZLDGF]HQLDZHWQRJUDÀLWUDG\ F\MQ\FKRUJDQL]DFML]DUyZQRZG]LHG]LQLHEDGDQWHUHQRZ\FK-HPLHO QLDN-HPLHOQLDNE+XQWHULLQ MDNLPHWRGRORJLL -HPLHOQLDNL.RVWHUD-HPLHOQLDNG-HPLHOQLDNH ZLċFEDGDQLHQHWQRJUDÀF]QHSU]HSURZDG]RQRVWRVXMĆFGRZLUWXDOQHM VSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLL]Z\F]DMRZH]DVDG\HWQRJUDÀF]QH'DQLHO :3ROVFHEDGDQLDQHWQRJUDÀF]QHGRSLHURUDF]NXMĆDOHVĆMXīSU]HG PLRWHP]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDEDGDF]\]UyīQ\FKG\VF\SOLQ]ZâDV]F]D ]PâRGV]HJRSRNROHQLD%DWRUVNL%DWRUVNLL2OFRĕ.XELFND +DODZDLLQ7NDF]\N)LOLFLDN7NDF]\N &LFKRFNLLLQ0D]XUHND0D]XUHNE ]DUyZQR ZEDGDQLDFKVSRâHF]QRğFLRSDUW\FKQDWHNğFLHMDNLREUD]NRZ\FK 7HPSVNDL=\GHO0DJDOD

NAZEWNICTWO I POWODY, DLA KTÓRYCH BADANIE OPARTO NA DWÓCH WIKIPEDIACH 3LV]ĆFRVSRâHF]QRğFL:LNLSHGLLQDOHīDâRZVSRVyESU]HP\ğODQ\SRGHMğý GRNZHVWLLF\WDWyZ:HGâXJ5R\D/DQJHUDL6X]DQQH&%HFNPDQ SVHXGRQLP\LQWHUQHWRZHQDOHī\WUDNWRZDýZNZHVWLLRFKURQ\RVRELVWHM WDNVDPRMDNSUDZG]LZHLPLRQDLQD]ZLVND:SHZQ\PVHQVLHSVHX GRQLP\ZLNLSHG\VWyZZVSRâHF]QRğFLIXQNFMRQXMĆSUDZLHQD]DVDG]LH LPLRQLQD]ZLVN']LHMHVLċWDNGRWDNLHJRVWRSQLDīHSRGF]DVVSRWNDĕ ZğZLHFLHU]HF]\ZLVW\PQD)DFHERRNXNDQDâDFK,5&RUD]ZLQQ\FK SU]\SDGNDFKZLNLSHG\ğFLRGQRV]ĆVLċGRVLHELHF]ċVWRSRQD]ZLH Xī\WNRZQLNDQDZHWMHğOL]QDMĆVZRMHLPLRQDLQD]ZLVND3RP\VâQD

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ SRVWċSRZDQLH]SVHXGRQLPDPLWDNMDNE\E\â\SUDZG]LZ\PLQD]ZL VNDPLPDZLċFUDFMRQDOQHSU]HVâDQNL *G\E\MHGQDNWUDNWRZDýWDNLHSRGHMğFLHNRQVHNZHQWQLHQDOHīDâRE\ Z]QDF]Q\PVWRSQLXSR]PLHQLDýQLHNWyUHF\WDW\2U\JLQDâ\ZV]\VWNLFK EH]SRğUHGQLR]DPLHV]F]RQ\FKZ\SRZLHG]LMHğOLFKRG]LRDQJLHOVNĆ :LNLSHGLċ²QLQLHMV]DNVLĆīNDSU]HGVWDZLDWâXPDF]HQLDF\WDWyZ âDWZR RGQDOHĩýZ\NRU]\VWXMĆFZ\V]XNLZDUNL1DZHWSRGDQLHIUDJPHQWX F\WDWXF]ċVWRZ\VWDUF]\GRQDPLHU]HQLDRGQRğQHMG\VNXVML7DNLH Z\V]XNLZDQLHMHVWGRğýSRZV]HFKQĆUR]U\ZNĆZLHOXF]\WHOQLNyZ EDGDĕLQWHUQHWRZ\FK.R]LQHWV 6NXWNLHPSRZ\īV]HJRVWDQ GDUGRZDSURFHGXUDSRGFKRG]HQLDGRSVHXGRQLPyZQLHVSUDZG]LâDE\ VLċZSU]\SDGNXWHMNVLĆīNL :DUWRMHGQDNSDPLċWDýīHZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQLHPHWDIRUSU]HVWU]HQQ\FK QSRGQRV]HQLHVLċGRÅSU]HVWU]HQLµZLUWXDOQ\FK QLHPXVLE\ýMHG\Q\P VSRVREHPUR]XPLHQLDVSRâHF]QRğFLLQWHUQHWRZ\FK3U]\MPRZDQLH WUDG\F\MQ\FK]DVDGEDGDĕQDOXG]LDFKKXPDQVXEMHFWUHVHDUFK GR EDGDQLD]ELRURZRğFLZLUWXDOQ\FK%DVVHWWL2·5LRUGDQ F]ċVWRQLH PDZUċF]VHQVXDGRVWċSQHDOWHUQDW\Z\WRPLQWUDNWRZDQLH,QWHU QHWXMDNRSXEOLF]QLHGRVWċSQHJRWHNVWX'\VNXVMHRQOLQHSURZDG]LVLċ SU]HFLHī]]DâRīHQLHPīHEċGĆMHF]\WDýRJyOQLHSRMPRZDQLLQWHUQDXFL LQLH]LGHQW\ÀNRZDQLRGELRUF\WR]DâRīHQLH]Dğ]QDF]QLHZSâ\ZDQD VSRVRE\]DFKRZ\ZDQLDVLċXī\WNRZQLNyZ:LNLSHGLL²ZLċFHMQDWHQ WHPDWZUR]G]LDOH:LHONL%UDWSDWU]\ :NRQVHNZHQFMLSRZ\īV]HJR QLHMHVWNRQLHF]QHVWRVRZDQLHHW\NLEDGDĕQDOXG]LDFKF]\OLEDGDF] QLH]DZV]HPXVLVLċSU]HMPRZDýEH]SRğUHGQLPLF\WDWDPL1DZHW ZWUDG\F\MQHMHWQRJUDÀLF]ċVWRPRīOLZHMHVW]LGHQW\ÀNRZDQLHF\WRZD Q\FKRUJDQL]DFMLLRVyEZLċFQHWQRJUDÀDQLHSRZLQQDZGRGDWNRZ\P VWRSQLXSU]HMPRZDýVLċVWDQGDUGRZĆRFKURQĆQD]ZLVNLGDQ\FKRVR ELVW\FKEDGDQ\FKRVyE*DWVRQL=ZHHULQN 6]F]HJyOQLHMHGQDNZSU]\SDGNXV\WXDFMLZNWyU\FKRVRELğFLHXF]HVW QLF]\âHPD]ZâDV]F]DNRQÁLNWyZRSLVDQLHLFKZVSRVyESR]ZDODMĆF\ GRMğýGRPRLFKE\â\FKDGZHUVDU]\Z\GDMHVLċQLHXF]FLZHLEDODQVXMĆFH QDNUDZċG]LRVRELVWHM]HPVW\'ODWHJRSRPLPRGXīHMLORğFLPDWHULDâX EDGDZF]HJR]XZDJLQDQLHPRīOLZRğý]DSUH]HQWRZDQLDJRZVSRVyE NWyU\JZDUDQWRZDâE\DQRQLPRZRğýEDGDQ\FKRSLHUDPVLċJâyZQLHQD RSLVDFKSU]\SDGNyZZNWyUHQLHE\âHP]QDF]ĆFR]DDQJDīRZDQ\RVRELğFLH :NVLĆīFHVWDUDPVLċXPLHV]F]DýMDNQDMZLċFHMPDWHULDâXSRFKRG]Ć FHJR]DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]XZDJLQDMHMUR]PLDU]QDF]QLHZLċNV]\ ZSRUyZQDQLX]HG\FMĆSROVNĆMDNWHīZLċNV]H]UyīQLFRZDQLHHG\WRUyZ

285

286

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... =DâRīHQLHGODWHMNVLĆīNLMHVWWDNLHīHSXEOLF]QHG\VNXVMHRQOLQHVĆ SU]H]QDF]RQHGODRJyâXRGELRUFyZLQLHZ\PDJDMĆNRGRZDQLDMHğOLFKR G]LRRVRE\ZQLFKXF]HVWQLF]ĆFHLLFKWRīVDPRğFL.LHG\NROZLHNSU]\ ZRâ\ZDQDMHVWMHGQDNVDPD:LNLSHGLDEH]GRRNUHğODQLDMHMZHUVML Mċ]\NRZHMSRF]\QLRQHREVHUZDFMHVĆQDWXU\RJyOQHMLRGQRV]ĆVLċGR ZV]\VWNLFKSURMHNWyZ]NWyU\PLDXWRUMHVW]D]QDMRPLRQ\ 2F]\ZLğFLHLVWQLHMHZLċFHMGREU\FKSRZRGyZGODNWyU\FKZDUWR RSU]HýEDGDQLHQDZLċFHMQLīMHGQHMZHUVMLMċ]\NRZHM:LNLSHGLL:V]F]H JyOQRğFLSRUyZQDQLHGZyFKSURMHNWyZZGZyFKUyīQ\FKMċ]\NDFK LRGZyFKUyīQ\FKNXOWXUDFKGDMHLVWRWQH]\VNL-DNGRWĆGZLċNV]Rğý EDGDĕQDXNRZ\FKVNXSLDâDVLċQDDQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL+DUDLLQ NWyUHMSU]\SLVXMHVLċF]DVDPLPLDQR²SRSURVWXÅ:LNLSHGLLµ WDNMDNE\E\âDWRMHG\QD:LNLSHGLDQDğZLHFLHFKRýVSRâHF]QRğFL ZLUWXDOQHLQQ\FKSURMHNWyZSRWUDÀĆE\ýNRPSOHWQLHRGPLHQQHDZLHOH SUDZLGâRZRğFLNWyUHEDGDF]HX]QDOL]DÅXQLZHUVDOQHµGODZV]\VWNLFK VSRâHF]QRğFLZVSyâSUDFXMĆF\FKPRīHPLHýZ\MĆWNRZRORNDOQ\]DVLċJ &]ċğýEDGDĕ]DNâDGDZUċF]īHQLHLVWQLHMĆ]QDF]ĆFHUyīQLFHNXOWXURZH PLċG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLSURMHNWDPL3IHLOLLQ ]DUyZQRMHğOLFKRG]L RZ]RUFHLQWHUDNFML+DUDLLQ MDNLRRJyâ]DFKRZDĕW\SRZ\ GODG]LDâDĕZLNLSHG\VWyZ6WYLOLDLLQ1HPRWRL*ORRU 3URMHNW\GRğýSRZDīQLHSRGFKRG]ĆGRNZHVWLLVZRMHMQLH]DOHīQRğFL GRWDNLHJRVWRSQLDīHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHVZRMHMSR]\FMLZMHGQ\P]QLFKGR ]ZLċNV]HQLDVZRMHMUDQJLZLQQ\PX]QDZDQHMHVW]DIDX[SDVXVWDOH QLDLQQ\FKSURMHNWyZEUDQHVĆ]SHZQĆGR]ĆRVWURīQRğFLQDSU]\NâDG SUyE\SU]HV]F]HSLHQLDGRSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLF]ċğFL]DVDG]ZHUVMLDQ JLHOVNLHMRNUHğODVLċSHMRUDW\ZQLHMDNRHQZLNL]P LWG6NXWNLHPWHJRVĆ ]QDF]QHUyīQLFHPLċG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PL:LNLSHGLDPLLLQQ\PLSURMHN WDPL:LNLPHGLD :QLHZLHONLHMF]ċğFLGRVWċSQ\FKEDGDĕELHU]HVLċSRGXZDJċF]ċğý VSHF\ÀNLVSRâHF]QRğFLSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKZHUVMLMċ]\NRZ\FKDOHEDUG]R QLHZLHOXEDGDF]\]GHF\GRZDâRVLċZ]LĆýSRGXZDJċMHGQRF]HğQLHGZLH :LNLSHGLH]DğZEDGDQLDFKRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FKLZLUWXDOQHMHWQRJUDÀL QLHGRNRQDâWHJRMHV]F]HQLNW&KFĆFZ\VQXýMDNLHNROZLHNLVWRWQH ZQLRVNLGRW\F]ĆFHWDNLFKSURMHNWyZRRWZDUW\PPRGHOXZVSyâSUDF\ MDNWHīRJyOQLHMV]HJRFKDUDNWHUX]DFKRG]ĆF\FKZHZQĆWU]QLFKUHODFML FRMHVWNRQLHF]QHMHğOLV]XNDVLċLQVSLUDFMLGODLQQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMLOXE FKFHVLċGRNRQDýRJyOQLHMV]\FKZQLRVNyZGODğURGRZLVNRWZDUWHM ZVSyâSUDF\ ZDīQHMHVWE\Z]LĆýSRGXZDJċīHQDF]ċğý]DREVHUZR ZDQ\FK]MDZLVNPRīHPLHýGXī\ZSâ\ZNXOWXUDQDURGRZDOXEMHMMċ]\N

Dodatek 1: METODYKA BADAŃ F]\WHīSU]HMğFLRZ\HSL]RGZKLVWRULLGDQHMVSRâHF]QRğFL:LHOHRVREOL ZRğFLNWyUHPRīQDE\SU]\SLV\ZDýVDPHMIRUPLHRUJDQL]DFMLZLUWXDO Q\FKVSRâHF]QRğFLZVSyâSUDFRZQLNyZQLHNRQLHF]QLHZ\JOĆGDWDNVDPR ZUyīQ\FKSURMHNWDFK:QLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīFHSRâRīRQRZLċFQDFLVNQD WHREVHUZDFMHNWyUHVĆZVSyOQHGODSROVNLHMLDQJLHOVNLHMVSRâHF]QRğFL ZLNLSHG\VWyZDMHğOLSRPLċG]\W\PLVSRâHF]QRğFLDPLLVWQLHMĆUyīQLFH R]QDF]HQLXGODG\VNXWRZDQ\FKNZHVWLLVĆRQHHNVSRQRZDQH &RFLHNDZHMDNSRGDMHGRNXPHQW:LNLSHGLD(GLWRU6XUYH\]URNX ]ELHUDMĆF\Z\QLNLDQNLHWDXWRUVWZD:LNLPHGLD)RXQGDWLRQSRO VND:LNLSHGLDFLHV]\VLċQDMZ\īV]\PZVNDĩQLNLHP]DGRZROHQLDXī\W NRZQLNyZ&ROOHFWLYH G]LċNLF]HPXMHVWGREU\PPRGHOHPGR UR]ZDīDĕ =DVDG\L]DOHFHQLDSRFKRG]Ć]DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLL]]D]QDF]HQLHP UyīQLFPLċG]\ZHUVMĆDQJLHOVNĆDSROVNĆMHğOLMHVWWRLVWRWQH Z\MĆWNLHP MHVWWX'RGDWHNNWyU\]DZLHUD]HVWDZUHJXâRERZLĆ]XMĆF\ZSROVNLHM :LNLSHGLL:V]\VWNLHG\VNXVMHRJyOQHLQLHRVRELVWHRUD]SU]\SDGNL LZ\GDU]HQLDSRFKRG]Ć]DQJLHOVNLHM:LNLSHGLLSU]\F]\PZ\SRZLHG]L QLHNRGRZDQRSRVâXJXMĆFVLċSVHXGRQLPDPLLQD]ZLVNDPLDXWRUyZ ²SRQLHZDīZ\SRZLDGDOLVLċğZLDGRPLHZSXEOLF]Q\FKSRZV]HFKQLH GRVWċSQ\FKG\VNXVMDFK

287

Dodatek 2

PIĘĆ FILARÓW WIKIPEDII

WPROWADZENIE 1LQLHMV]\GRGDWHNSRğZLċFRQ\MHVWSRGVWDZRZ\P]DVDGRP]JRGQLH ]NWyU\PLG]LDâD:LNLSHGLD6ĆRQHZVSyOQHDQDZHWF]ċVWRLGHQW\F]QH GODSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKZHUVMLMċ]\NRZ\FKWX]DF]HUSQLċWHVĆ]ZHUVML SROVNLHM 5HJXODUQLHG\WRU]\:LNLSHGLL]GHF\GRZDQLHEċGĆ]QLPL]D ]QDMRPLHQLOHF]F]ċğýF]\WHOQLNyZNWyUDQLHPLDâDPRīQRğFLUHGDJRZDý KDVHâZ:LNLSHGLLPRīHFKFLHý]DSR]QDýVLċ]QLPLE\]UR]XPLHýSRG VWDZRZH]DVDG\U]ĆG]ĆFHSURMHNWHPZVSyâSUDFRZQLNyZ&]ċğý]W\FK IXQGDPHQWDOQ\FK]DVDGMHVWWHīSU]\ZRâ\ZDQDZQLQLHMV]HMNVLĆīFH *G\]DF]ĆâHPSLVDýWċF]ċğýNVLĆīNLGRWDUâRGRPQLHīHGREU]HE\âRE\ ZSXEOLNDFMLSRğZLċFRQHM:LNLSHGLL]DF\WRZDýWUHğFLSURMHNWXRSDWUX MĆFMHNRPHQWDU]HP=GHF\GRZDâHPZLċFīHGRGDWHNWHQEċG]LHPLHý HNVSHU\PHQWDOQ\FKDUDNWHUīHEċG]LHG]LHâHPRGG]LHOQ\PRGSR]R VWDâ\FKUR]G]LDâyZ3R]DQLQLHMV]\PNUyWNLPZVWċSHPFDâD]DZDUWRğý GRGDWNX]DF]HUSQLċWDMHVW]:LNLSHGLLQDPRF\OLFHQFML&UHDWLYH&RP PRQV8]QDQLHDXWRUVWZD1DW\FKVDP\FKZDUXQNDFKZHUVMD 8QSRUWHGDFDâRğýGRGDWNXXGRVWċSQLDPQLQLHMV]\PQDWHMVDPHM OLFHQFML

KWWSFUHDWLYHFRPPRQVRUJOLFHQVHVE\VDGHHGSO

290

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... -HGQ\P]FHOyZWHMVHNFMLEċGĆFHMGRVâRZQĆNRSLĆF]ċğFL:LNLSHGLL MHVWZ\URELHQLHZF]\WHOQLNXQLH]D]QDMRPLRQ\P]]DVDGDPLU]ĆG]ĆF\PL VSRâHF]QRğFLĆZLNLSHG\VWyZSRF]XFLDWHJRMDNLPMċ]\NLHP]DSLVDQH VĆLMDNSUH]HQWXMĆVLċ]DVDG\:LNLSHGLL6WDUDâHPZMDNQDMPQLHMV]\P VWRSQLXUHGDJRZDý]DZDUWRğýQLQLHMV]HJRUR]G]LDâX 3RF]\QLRQHSU]H]HPQLH]PLDQ\WRXVXQLċFLHLQIRUPDFML]DZDUW\FK ZUDPNDFKJUDÀNVSLVyZWUHğFLQRWDWHNNDWHJRULLLQIRUPDFML]ZLĆ ]DQ\FK]GDQĆVWURQĆLLQQ\FKGRGDWNRZ\FK]DVREyZXVXQLċFLHVHNFML Å=REDF]WHīµLZV]\VWNLFKKLSHUâĆF]RUD]NRORUyZF]FLRQHN3RF]\QLâHP WHīSRPQLHMV]HSRSUDZNLUHGDNF\MQHSRGNRQLHFF]ċğFLVWURQXVXZDQLH DNDSLWyZZ\NRU]\VWXMĆF\FKZLHOHOLQNyZ XVXQĆâHPGRGDWNRZH RELHNFMHLREMDğQLHQLD 1DSRF]ĆWNXGRGDWNXSU]\ZRâXMċSLċýÀODUyZ:LNLSHGLL>>:3)@@ .DīG\]ÀODUyZSRâĆF]RQ\MHVW]RSLVHPMHGQHM]]DVDG:LNLSHGLLNWyUH UyZQLHīVĆ]DF\WRZDQHZGRGDWNX E:LNLSHGLDWRHQF\NORSHGLD²OLQNGR>>:LNLSHGLD&]\P:LNLSHGLD QLHMHVW@@ E::LNLSHGLLVWRVXMHVLċ]DVDG\QHXWUDOQHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD²OLQN GR>>:LNLSHGLD1HXWUDOQ\SXQNWZLG]HQLD@@ E:LNLSHGLDMHVWZROQ\P]ELRUHPZLHG]\²OLQNGR>>:LNLSHGLD3UDZD DXWRUVNLH@@ E::LNLSHGLLQDOHī\SU]HVWU]HJDý]DVDGHW\NLHW\²OLQNGR>>:LNL SHGLD:LNLHW\NLHWD@@ E1D:LNLSHGLLQLHPDV]W\ZQ\FK]DVDG²OLQNGR>>:LNLSHGLD,JQRUXM ZV]\VWNLH]DVDG\@@ 1DMNUyWV]D]]DVDG:LNLSHGLL]DZLHUDVLċUDSWHPZVâRZDFK ]DVDGDÅ,JQRUXMZV]\VWNLH]DVDG\µ 1DMGâXīV]\GRNXPHQWWRRSLV QHXWUDOQHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD]DMPXMĆF\RNRâRVâyZ.ZHVWLD ELXURNUDFMLZ:LNLSHGLLRUD]LORğFLRERZLĆ]XMĆFHMZQLHM]DVDGL]DOHFHĕ ]DZDUWDMHVWZUR]G]LDOH:LHONL%UDWSDWU]\ :'RGDWNXQLHSU]\ZRâXMċZLHOXZDīQ\FK]DVDG1DOHīĆGRQLFK QSÅ.RQVHQVXVµÅĪDGQ\FKRVRELVW\FKDWDNyZµÅ:RMQDHG\F\MQDµF]\ Å1LHSU]HGVWDZLDP\WZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHMµ']LHMHVLċWDN]RF]\ZLVWHJR SRZRGXīHZSHZQ\PPLHMVFXQDOHī\SRZLHG]LHýÅVWRSµ]DâRīHQLH 'RGDWNXMHVWWDNLHīH]DZLHUDýRQEċG]LHW\ONRSLċýÀODUyZ:LNLSHGLL LEH]SRğUHGQLRLPRGSRZLDGDMĆFH]DVDG\MDNRQDMEDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZH

Dodatek 2: PIĘĆ FILARÓW WIKIPEDII LSU]\MċWHSU]H]RJyâVSRâHF]QRğFL:V]\VWNLHV]Hğý]DF\WRZDQ\FKVWURQ VNRSLRZDQRZLFKZHUVML]VW\F]QLDURNXFKRýQDOHī\WX]D]QD F]\ýīHSRGVWDZRZH]DVDG\:LNLSHGLL]PLHQLDMĆVLċQLH]Z\NOHU]DGNR

PIĘĆ FILARÓW 3RGVWDZRZH]DVDG\:LNLSHGLLVĆSRGVXPRZDQHZIRUPLHMHMSLċFLX ÅÀODUyZµ

Wikipedia to encyklopedia ]DZLHUDMĆFDZVRELHDUW\NXâ\PRJĆFH]QDOHĩýVLċZHQF\NORSHGLDFKSR ZV]HFKQ\FKVSHFMDOLVW\F]Q\FKLUyīQHJRURG]DMXDOPDQDFKDFK:LNL SHGLDQLHMHVWVâRZQLNLHPPLHMVFHPGR]DPLHV]F]DQLDWHNVWyZĩUy GâRZ\FKSURSDJRZDQLDVZRMHJRğZLDWRSRJOĆGXJD]HWĆPLHMVFHP JG]LHPRīQDEH]SâDWQLHXPLHV]F]DýVWURQ\:::PLHMVFHPGRSLVDQLD DUW\NXâyZSURPRF\MQ\FK]ELRUyZZVSRPLQHNHNVSHU\PHQWHPZ]D SURZDG]DQLXDQDUFKLLOXEGHPRNUDFMLNROHNFMĆRGQRğQLNyZ]DUyZQR ZHZQċWU]Q\FKL]HZQċWU]Q\FK 1LHMHVWWDNīHPLHMVFHPGR]DPLHV] F]DQLDZâDVQ\FKRSLQLLDUJXPHQWyZLGRğZLDGF]HĕRVRELVW\FK²ZV]\VF\ DXWRU]\PXV]ĆSU]HVWU]HJDý]DVDG\QLHSU]HGVWDZLDQLDWZyUF]RğFL GRFLHNDĕEDGDĕLWS ZâDVQHMQLHSU]HGVWDZLDP\WZyUF]RğFLZâDVQHM :V]\VF\DXWRU]\SRZLQQLGĆī\ýGRPDNV\PDOQHMSUHF\]MLL]JRGQRğFL ]IDNWDPL

W Wikipedii stosuje się zasady neutralnego punktu widzenia FR]QDF]\īHGĆī\P\GRSLVDQLDDUW\NXâyZNWyUHQLHZVSLHUDMĆīDGQHJR SRMHG\QF]HJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD&]DVDPLZ\PDJDWRSU]HGVWDZLHQLDZLHOX SXQNWyZZLG]HQLDZWDNLVSRVyEDE\NDīG\]QLFKE\âRSLVDQ\U]HWHO QLHLDE\F]\WHOQLNQLHPLDâZĆWSOLZRğFLNRPXQDOHī\SU]\SLVDýRNUHğ ORQ\SXQNWZLG]HQLDRUD]DE\īDGQHPX]W\FKSXQNWyZZLG]HQLDQLH E\âDSU]\]QDQDRVWDWHF]QDUDFMD:\PDJDWRDE\F\WRZDýZLDU\JRGQH

&]\WHOQLF\]DLQWHUHVRZDQL]DSR]QDQLHPVLċ]SR]RVWDâ\PL]DVDGDPLL]DOHFH QLDPLSROVNLHM:LNLSHGLLSRZLQQLRGZLHG]LýVWURQċKWWSSOZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL .DWHJRULD=DVDG\B:LNLSHGLLRUD]MHMSRGNDWHJRULH

291

292

ŻYCIE WIRTUALNYCH DZIKICH. NETNOGRAFIA WIKIPEDII... ZHU\ÀNRZDOQHĩUyGâDNLHG\WRW\ONRPRīOLZHLXQLNDýPQLHMZLDU\ JRGQ\FK]ZâDV]F]DZDUW\NXâDFKQDWHPDW\NRQWURZHUV\MQH.LHG\ SRMDZLVLċNRQÁLNWNWyUD]ZHUVMLDUW\NXâXMHVWEDUG]LHMQHXWUDOQD QDOHī\RJâRVLýRNUHVÅZ\FLV]HQLDµLF]DVRZR]UH]\JQRZDý]MHJRHG\ FMLSRWRDE\ZW\PF]DVLHVSRNRMQLHRPyZLýVSUDZċQDVWURQLHG\V NXV\MQHMWHJRKDVâD]DFKRZXMĆFSU]\W\P]DVDG\:LNLHW\NLHW\

Wikipedia jest wolnym zbiorem wiedzy RSDUW\PQDOLFHQFMDFK&&%

Życie wirtualnych dzikich

Gringo Wśród Dzikich Plemion

Recommend Documents