Preferences and Similarities (CISM International Centre for Mechanical Sciences)

CISM COURSES AND LECTURES

Series Editors: The Rectors Giulio Maier - Milan Jean Salençon - Palaiseau Wilhelm Schneider - Wien

The Secretary General Bernhard Schrefler - Padua

Executive Editor Paolo Serafini - Udine

The series presents lecture notes, monographs, edited works and proceedings in the field of Mechanics, Engineering, Computer Science and Applied Mathematics. Purpose of the series is to make known in the international scientific and technical community results obtained in some of the activities organized by CISM, the International Centre for Mechanical Sciences.

INTERNATIONAL CENTRE FOR MECHANICAL SCIENCES COURSES AND LECTURES - No. 504

PREFERENCES AND SIMILARITIES

EDITED BY GIACOMO DELLA RICCIA UNIVERSITY OF UDINE DIDIER DUBOIS UNIVERSITY OF TOULOUSE RUDOLF KRUSE UNIVERSITY OF MAGDEBURG HANS-JOACHIM LENZ FREIE UNIVERSITӒT BERLIN

This volume contains 29 illustrations

This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned specifically those of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, broadcasting, reproduction by photocopying machine or similar means, and storage in data banks. © 2008 by CISM, Udine Printed in Italy SPIN 12510191

All contributions have been typeset by the authors.

ISBN 978-3-211-85431-0 SpringerWienNewYork




/FA?PO EJ KN@AN PK CNKQL PKCAPDAN OEIEH=N KJAO KN @EOPEJCQEOD >APPAN BNKI SKNOA EO EJDANAJP PK DQI=J =?PEREPEAO EJ CAJAN=H =J@ O?EAJPE? @EO?ELHEJAO EJ L=NPE?QH=N *J PDEO KRANREAS L=LAN SA LNAOAJP OKIA NAH=PEKJ=H BN=IASKNGO PD=P =HHKS PK ATLNAOO PDA NAOQHPO KB OQ?D = ?KIL=NEOKJ EJ = JQ IANE?=H S=U PULE?=HHU >U IA=JO KB JQI>ANO EJ PDA QJEP EJPANR=H " NOP BN=IASKNG EO PD=P KB BQVVU NAH=PEKJO =J@ SA @EO?QOO DKS EP ?=J >A QOA@ PK @ARAHKL ?=N@EJ=HEPU>=OA@ EA >=OA@ KJ PDA ?KQJPEJC KB BA=PQNAO OEIEH=NEPU IA=OQNAIAJP PA?DJEMQAO " OA?KJ@ BN=IASKNG EO PD=P KB NA?ELNK?=H NAH= PEKJO =J@ SA @EO?QOO DKS EP ?=J >A QOA@ PK @ARAHKL IAPDK@O BKN ?KIL=NEJC N=J@KI R=NE=>HAO 3=PEKJ=HEPU ?KJOE@AN=PEKJO @AI=J@ PDA LNAOAJ?A KB OKIA GEJ@ KB PN=JOEPEREPU 8A PDANABKNA NAREAS EJ @AP=EH PDA =R=EH=>HA JKPEKJO KB PN=JOEPEREPU =J@ LKEJP KQP SDANA PDAU K??QN 5DEO ?D=LPAN EO KNC=JEOA@ =O BKHHKSO *J 4A?PEKJ  SA LNAOAJP PDA PSK NAH=PEKJ=H BN=IASKNGO IAJPEKJA@ PDA ?KNNAOLKJ@EJC JKPEKJO KB PN=JOEPEREPU =J@ PDA ?KJJA?PEKJO >APSAAJ PDAI *J 4A?PEKJ  SA ATLHKNA PDA BN=IASKNG KB BQVVU NAH=PEKJO =J@ EPO ?=L=?EPU BKN ATLNAOOEJC PDA OEIEH=NEPU KB BQVVU

2

Bernard De Baets

OAPO 4A?PEKJ  EO @A@E?=PA@ PK PDA BN=IASKNG KB NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJO =J@ EPO LKPAJPE=H BKN PDA @ARAHKLIAJP KB IAPDK@O BKN PDA ?KIL=NEOKJ KB N=J@KI R=NE=>HAO 8A SN=L QL EJ 4A?PEKJ  SEPD = ODKNP ?KJ?HQOEKJ




! $  ! ! !#!% &))( #% $

5N=JOEPEREPU EO =J AOOAJPE=H LNKLANPU KB NAH=PEKJO " >EJ=NU 9,3(;065  KJ = QJERANOA  PDA A @AREOA@ OQ?D =O             



BKN =JU QP PDA #KKHA=J ?KJFQJ?PEKJ " -APSAAJ AHAIAJPO KB    !  IA=JO  =J@  =NA JKP NAH=PA@ =P =HH   !  ATLNAOOAO BQHH NAH=PEKJODEL SDEHA  

A = ?KJFQJ?PKN " BQVVU NAH=PEKJ  KJ  EO ?=HHA@ PN=JOEPERA EB BKN =JU      EP DKH@O PD=P       



Similarity of Fuzzy Sets and Dominance of Random Variables

3

*JPANAOPEJC ?H=OOAO KB ?KJFQJ?PKNO =NA PDA ?H=OOAO KB OAIE?KLQH=O MQ=OE ?KLQH=O ?KLQH=O =J@ PJKNIO #,40*67QP ?KJFQJ?PKNO SEPD JAQPN=H AHAIAJP  %QN=JPA =J@ 4AILE  8DANA PJKNIO D=RA PDA =@@EPEKJ=H LNKLANPEAO KB ?KIIQP=PEREPU =J@ =OOK?E=PEREPU MQ=OE?KLQH=O D=RA PDA -ELO?DEPV LNKLANPU (AJAOP AP =H  /AHOAJ  " 8U 4SEP=H OGE   BKNI=HHU CAJAN=HEVAO $OPK?D=OPE? PN=JOEPEREPU EJ PDA OAJOA PD=P   EO >KQJ@A@ >KPD BNKI >AHKS =J@ =>KRA >U :  A PSK :  KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJ EB EP O=PEOAO E       =J@       EE BKN =JU 
    
      
    



5DA BQJ?PEKJ    @AJA@ >U 
  !     
   EO ?=HHA@ PDA +,9 )6AEJC ?U?HE? LANIQP=PEKJO KB KJA =JKPDAN AC    =J@     )AJ?A  ?=J >A NALH=?A@ >U  
       
   

/KPA PD=P = R=HQA KB  
  AMQ=H PK  EO QOA@ PK ATLNAOO PD=P BKN PDA CERAJ R=HQAO PDANA EO JK NAOPNE?PEKJ =P =HH =O 
   EO =HS=UO >KQJ@A@ >U  5SK QLLAN >KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJO  =J@  =NA ?=HHA@ ,8KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJ  EO O=E@ PK >A :,3-+KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJ  $KJOAMQAJPHU =HOK  =J@  ?=J KJHU DKH@ SEPD AMQ=HEPU 'QNPDANIKNA EP PDAJ DKH@O PD=P     !  =J@     !  "HPDKQCD PN=JOEPEREPU EO JKP EJPAJ@A@ PK >A =LLHEA@ PK NA?ELNK?=H NA H=PEKJO EP ?=J >A ?=OP MQEPA JE?AHU EJPK PDA ?U?HAPN=JOEPEREPU BN=IASKNG KB %A #=APO AP =H = # ! $%   ,;  ), ( *644QNJ  EB BKN =JU      EP DKH@O PD=P                IEJ   

$HA=NHU EP EO = OHECDP SA=GAJEJC KB IK@AN=PA OPK?D=OPE? PN=JOEPEREPU *J PANAOPEJCHU =HOK PDEO PULA KB PN=JOEPEREPU ?=J >A ATLNAOOA@ AHAC=JPHU EJ PDA ?U?HAPN=JOEPEREPU BN=IASKNG %A .AUAN AP =H  >U IA=JO KB = OEILHA QLLAN >KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJ # ! $%    @*3,;9(5:0;0=0;@ > 9 ; ;/, =OA@ KJ = ?KIIQP=PERA MQ=OE?KLQH=  ?KJ@EPEKJ  DKH@O >U @AB=QHP 5DA BKHHKSEJC LNKLKOEPEKJ PDAJ EO =J EIIA@E=PA =LLHE?=PEKJ %A #=APO AP =H > # ! $%   0 65:0+,9 ( *644ANO ?=NNU PDA BKHHKSEJC EJPACANO KJ PDAEN B=?AO  !      

 !      

 !      

%AJKPEJC >U    PDA LNK>=>EHEPU PD=P @E?A  SEJO BNKI @E?A   SA D=RA   !     !   =J@   !   *P EO J=PQN=H PK O=U PD=P @E?A  EO OPNE?PHU LNABANNA@ PK @E?A  EB       SDE?D NAA?PO PD=P @E?A  SEJO BNKI @E?A  EJ PDA HKJC NQJ KN PD=P  OP=PEOPE?=HHU SEJO BNKI   @AJKPA@     /KPA PD=P   !     SDE?D EILHEAO PD=P PDA NAH=PEKJ  EO =OUIIAPNE? *J PDA =>KRA AT=ILHA EP DKH@O PD=P       =J@    PDA NAH=PEKJ  EO JKP PN=JOEPERA =J@ BKNIO = ?U?HA *J KPDAN SKN@O EB SA EJPANLNAP PDA LNK>=>EHEPEAO    =O

Similarity of Fuzzy Sets and Dominance of Random Variables

13

?KJOPEPQAJPO KB = NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ KJ PDA OAP KB =HPANJ=PERAO    PDAJ PDEO NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ EO ARAJ JKP SA=GHU OPK?D=OPE? PN=JOEPERA 5DEO AT=ILHA ?=J >A CAJAN=HEVA@ =O BKHHKSO SA =HHKS PDA @E?A PK LKOOAOO =JU JQI>AN KB B=?AO SDAPDAN KN JKP PDEO ?=J >A I=PANE=HEVA@ =J@ =HHKS E@AJPE?=H JQI>ANO KJ PDA B=?AO KB = OEJCHA KN IQHPELHA @E?A *J KPDAN SKN@O = CAJAN=HEVA@ @E?A ?=J >A E@AJPEA@ SEPD = IQHPEOAP KB EJPACANO (ERAJ = ?KHHA?PEKJ KB ' OQ?D CAJAN=HEVA@ @E?A SA ?=J OPEHH >QEH@ = NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ  ?KJP=EJEJC PDA >05505. 796)()030;0,: BKN A=?D L=EN KB @E?A %A 4?DQUIAN AP =H  'KN =JU PSK OQ?D @E?A  =J@  SA @AJA    !  SEJO BNKI    =J@  AJ@ EJ = PEA

 5DA @E?A KN EJPACAN IQHPEOAPO I=U >A E@AJPEA@ SEPD EJ@ALAJ@AJP @EO?NAPA N=J@KI R=NE=>HAO PD=P =NA QJEBKNIHU @EOPNE>QPA@ KJ PDAOA IQHPEOAPO EA PDA LNK>=>EHEPU KB =J EJPACAN EO LNKLKNPEKJ=H PK EPO JQI>AN KB K??QNAJ?AO PDA NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ  I=U >A NAC=N@A@ =O = MQ=JPEP=PERA @AO?NELPEKJ KB PDA L=ENSEOA ?KIL=NEOKJ KB PDAOA N=J@KI R=NE=>HAO *J PDA ?D=N=?PANEV=PEKJ KB PDA PN=JOEPEREPU KB PDEO NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ = PULA KB ?U?HAPN=JOEPEREPU SDE?D ?=J JAEPDAN >A OAAJ =O = PULA KB  PN=JOEPEREPU JKN =O = PULA KB  PN=JOEPEREPU D=O LNKRAJ PK LH=U = LNA @KIEJ=JP NKHA 'KN K>REKQO NA=OKJO PDEO JAS PULA KB PN=JOEPEREPU D=O >AAJ ?=HHA@ @E?APN=JOEPEREPU %   $U?HAPN=JOEPEREPU SNP PDA QLLAN >KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJ  @A JA@ >U  
  !
 
  EO ?=HHA@ +0*,;9(5:0;0=0;@ %E?APN=JOEPEREPU EO ?HKOAHU NAH=PA@ PK  PN=JOEPEREPU )KSARAN EP QOAO PDA MQ=JPEPEAO
=J@  EJOPA=@ KB PDA MQ=JPEPEAO =J@
 =J@ EO PDANABKNA HAOO NAOPNE?PERA %E?APN=JOEPEREPU ?=J >A OEPQ=PA@ >APSAAJ 
PN=JOEPEREPU =J@  PN=JOEPEREPU =J@ =HOK >APSAAJ 
PN=JOEPEREPU =J@ IK@AN=PA OPK?D=OPE? PN=JOEPEREPU # ! $%   , #*/A ?KILQPA@ =O      ! )  % &  )  % %   



SEPD )  PDA FKEJP LNK>=>EHEPU I=OO BQJ?PEKJ LIB KB     'KN PSK ?KJPEJQKQO NR  =J@       ?=J >A ?KILQPA@ =O



     ! !/ #  / 0 !0  



Similarity of Fuzzy Sets and Dominance of Random Variables

15

SEPD #  PDA FKEJP LNK>=>EHEPU @AJOEPU BQJ?PEKJ L@B KB     'KN PDEO L=ENSEOA ?KIL=NEOKJ KJA JAA@O PDA PSK@EIAJOEKJ=H I=NCEJ=H @EOPNE>QPEKJO 4GH=N O PDAKNAI 4GH=N  /AHOAJ  PAHHO QO PD=P EB = FKEJP ?QIQH=PERA @EOPNE>QPEKJ BQJ?PEKJ   D=O I=NCEJ=HO  =J@   PDAJ PDANA ATEOPO = ?KLQH=  OQ?D PD=P BKN =HH / 0   / 0 !   /  0

*B  =J@  =NA ?KJPEJQKQO PDAJ  EO QJEMQA KPDANSEOA  EO QJEMQAHU @APANIEJA@ KJ 3=J   3=J  "O PDA =>KRA ?KIL=NEOKJ IAPDK@ P=GAO EJPK =??KQJP PDA >ER=NE=PA I=N CEJ=H ?@B EP P=GAO EJPK =??KQJP PDA @ALAJ@AJ?A KB PDA ?KILKJAJPO KB PDA N=J@KI RA?PKN 5DA EJBKNI=PEKJ ?KJP=EJA@ EJ PDA NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ EO PDANABKNA IQ?D NE?DAN PD=J EB BKN EJOP=J?A SA SKQH@ D=RA >=OA@ PDA ?KI L=NEOKJ KB  =J@  OKHAHU KJ PDAEN ATLA?PA@ R=HQAO %AOLEPA PDA B=?P PD=P PDA @ALAJ@AJ?A OPNQ?PQNA EO AJPENAHU ?=LPQNA@ >U PDA IQHPER=NE=PA ?@B PDA L=ENSEOA ?KIL=NEOKJ EO KJHU =LP PK P=GA EJPK =??KQJP L=ENSEOA @ALAJ@AJ?A =O KJHU >ER=NE=PA ?@B =NA EJRKHRA@ *J@AA@ PDA >ER=NE=PA ?@B @K JKP BQHHU @EO?HKOA PDA @ALAJ@AJ?A OPNQ?PQNA PDA NR I=U ARAJ >A L=ENSEOA EJ@ALAJ @AJP SDEHA JKP IQPQ=HHU EJ@ALAJ@AJP 4EJ?A PDA ?KLQH=O  PD=P ?KQLHA PDA QJER=NE=PA I=NCEJ=H ?@B EJPK PDA >ER=NE=PA I=NCEJ=H ?@B ?=J >A @EANAJP BNKI =JKPDAN PDA =J=HUOEO KB PDA NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ =J@ EJ L=NPE?QH=N PDA E@AJPE?=PEKJ KB EPO PN=JOEPEREPU LNKLANPEAO =LLA=N N=PDAN ?QI>ANOKIA *P EO JKJAPDAHAOO LKOOE>HA PK OP=PA EJ CAJAN=H SEPDKQP I=GEJC =JU =OOQILPEKJO KJ PDA >ER=NE=PA ?@B PD=P PDA LNK>=>EHEOPE? NAH=PEKJ  CAJAN=PA@ >U =J =N>EPN=NU N=J@KI RA?PKN =HS=UO ODKSO OKIA IEJEI=H BKNI KB PN=JOEPEREPU %A #=APO =J@ %A .AUAN  # ! $%   $/, 9,*0796*(3 9,3(;065  .,5,9(;,+ )@ ( 9(5+64 =,*;69 0: 
;9(5:0;0=, 

#%  &!  #  '#$

0QN BQNPDAN EJPANAOP EO PK OPQ@U PDA OEPQ=PEKJ SDANA =>OPN=?PEKJ EO I=@A PD=P PDA NR =NA ?KILKJAJPO KB = N=J@KI RA?PKN =J@ =HH >ER=NE=PA ?@B =NA AJBKN?A@ PK @ALAJ@ EJ PDA O=IA S=U QLKJ PDA QJER=NE=PA ?@B EJ KPDAN SKN@O SA ?KJOE@AN PDA OEPQ=PEKJ KB =HH ?KLQH=O >AEJC PDA O=IA NA=HEVEJC PD=P PDEO IECDP JKP >A LKOOE>HA =P =HH *J B=?P PDEO OEILHE?=PEKJ EO AMQER =HAJP PK ?KJOE@ANEJC EJOPA=@ KB = N=J@KI RA?PKN = ?KHHA?PEKJ KB NR =J@ PK =NPE?E=HHU ?KIL=NA PDAI =HH EJ PDA O=IA I=JJAN =J@ >=OA@ QLKJ = O=IA ?KLQH= 5DA L=ENSEOA ?KIL=NEOKJ PDAJ NAHEAO QLKJ PDA GJKSHA@CA KB PDA KJA @EIAJOEKJ=H I=NCEJ=H ?@B OKHAHU =O EO PDA ?=OA EJ OPK?D=OPE? @KIEJ=J?A IAPDK@O 0QN ?KIL=NEOKJ IAPDK@ DKSARAN EO JKP AMQER=HAJP PK =JU GJKSJ

16

Bernard De Baets

GEJ@ KB OPK?D=OPE? @KIEJ=J?A >QP ODKQH@ N=PDAN >A NAC=N@A@ =O = CN=@A@ R=NE=JP KB EP OAA =HOK %A #=APO =J@ %A .AUAN  5DA ?=OA  !  CAJAN=HEVAO 1NKLKOEPEKJ  =J@ =LLHEAO EJ L=NPE?QH=N PK = ?KHHA?PEKJ KB EJ@ALAJ@AJP NR SDANA =HH ?KLQH=O AA?PERAHU AMQ=H   # ! $%   , #*/0:,3@ *6 9 ; ;/, AH

"

6JEBKNI

 

    

/ :   
QPEKJO SA D=RA TA@ KJA KB PDA PSK L=N=IAPANO EJ KN@AN PK NAOPNE?P PDA B=IEHU PK = KJAL=N=IAPAN OQ>B=IEHU I=EJHU >A?=QOA SEPD PSK BNAA L= N=IAPANO PDA BKNIQH=A >A?KIA QPIKOP ?QI>ANOKIA 5DA KJA AT?ALPEKJ EO PDA PSK@EIAJOEKJ=H B=IEHU KB JKNI=H @EOPNE>QPEKJO *J %A 4?DQUIAN AP =H  SA D=RA ODKSJ PD=P PDA ?KNNAOLKJ@EJC NA?ELNK?=H NAH=PEKJ EO EJ PD=P ?=OA IK@AN=PAHU OPK?D=OPE? PN=JOEPERA



" 

8A D=RA EJPNK@Q?A@ PDA NA=@AN PK PSK NAH=PEKJ=H BN=IASKNGO =J@ PDA SE@A R=NEAPU KB PN=JOEPEREPU JKPEKJO =R=EH=>HA EJ PDAI 5DA LNAOAJP=PEKJ S=O N=PDAN @AJOA =J@ IKNA EJBKNI=PEKJ ?=J >A BKQJ@ BKHHKSEJC PDA I=JU HEPAN=PQNA LKEJPANO CERAJ "JPE?EL=PEJC KJ BQPQNA SKNG EJ L=NPE?QH=N KJ =LLHE?=PEKJO SA ?=J E@AJ PEBU PSK EILKNP=JP @ENA?PEKJO 5DA NOP @ENA?PEKJ ?KJ?ANJO PDA QOA KB BQVVU OEIEH=NEPU IA=OQNAO .KOAN  D=O ODKSJ NA?AJPHU PD=P PDA  AMQ=HEPU   SEPD  !  KN  ! 
 EO LKOEPERA OAIE@AJEPA 8A =NA ?QNNAJPHU P=?GHEJC PDA O=IA MQAOPEKJ BKN PDA BQVVU ?=N@EJ=HEPU>=OA@ OEIEH=NEPU IA= OQNAO 3AOQHPO KB PDEO PULA =HHKS PK >NE@CA PDA C=L >APSAAJ PDA BQVVU OAP

Similarity of Fuzzy Sets and Dominance of Random Variables

19

  $U?HAPN=JOEPEREPU BKN PDA ?KJPEJQKQO @EOPNE>QPEKJO EJ 5=>HA  /=IA

6LLAN >KQJ@ BQJ?PEKJ  
 

&TLKJAJPE=H #AP= 1=NAPK


  
 


(QI>AH

6JEBKNI

-=LH=?A

   
    :I=T 
     HA =O LKPAJPE=H GANJAHO BKN PDA LKLQH=N GANJAH>=OA@ HA=NJEJC IAPDK@O AEPDAN KJ PDAEN KSJ KN EJ ?KI>EJ=PEKJ SEPD ATEOPEJC GAN JAHO OAA AC .=AJDKQP AP =H  BKN =J =LLHE?=PEKJ KB PDEO PULA 5DA OA?KJ@ @ENA?PEKJ ?KJ?ANJO PDA BQNPDAN ATLHKEP=PEKJ KB PDA NAOQHPO KJ PDA ?KIL=NEOKJ KB N=J@KI R=NE=>HAO "O IAJPEKJA@ PDA =LLNK=?D BKHHKSA@ DANA ?=J >A OAAJ =O = CN=@A@ R=NE=JP KB PDA EJ?NA=OEJCHU LKLQH=N JKPEKJ KB OPK?D=OPE? @KIEJ=J?A 'QPQNA NAOA=N?D SEHH D=RA PK ?H=NEBU DKS PDAOA CN=@A@ R=NE=JPO ?=J >A @ABQVVEA@ EJ KN@AN PK ?KIA QL SEPD IA=JEJCBQH L=NPE=H KN@ANEJCO KB N=J@KI R=NE=>HAO PD=P =NA IKNA EJBKNI=PERA PD=J PDA ?H=OOE?=H JKPEKJO KB OPK?D=OPE? @KIEJ=J?A 'ENOP NAOQHPO EJPK PD=P @ENA?PEKJ ?=J >A BKQJ@ EJ %A #=APO =J@ %A .AUAN  %A -KKB AP =H 

20

Bernard De Baets

% )" %=RE@ $/, ,;/6+ 6- !(09,+ 647(90:65: RKHQIA  KB 90
5: #;(;0:;0*(3 656.9(7/:  6=OA@ OEIEH=NEPU IA=OQNAO HEODANO  ) -ARU #;6*/(:;0* 6405(5*, ,HQSAN "?=@AIE? 1Q>HEODANO  4 .=AJDKQP # %A #=APO ( )=AO=ANP =J@ & 7=J #K?GOP=AHA 4QLLKNP RA?PKN I=?DEJA NACNAOOEKJ BKN PDA LNA@E?PEKJ KB I=EVA DU>NE@ LANBKNI=J?A $/,69,;0*(3 (5+ 7730,+ ,5,;0*: W  # .KJF=N@AP " CAJAN=HEO=PEKJ KB LNK>=>EHEOPE? ?KJOEOPAJ?U HEJA=NEPU ?KJ @EPEKJO BKN R=HQA@ LNABANAJ?A NAH=PEKJO *J + ,=?LNVUG =J@ . 3KQ>AJO A@EPKNO 6565=,5;065(3 !9,-,9,5*, ",3(;065: 05 ,*0:065 (205. RKH QIA  KB ,*;U BQVVU AMQER=HAJ?A NAH=PEKJO 6