c~U5hshed b" h'm. FiNllr. in LN gt'IltlTffiofo:!S inlt) the GWl1tia. "'hich a", theln5eh'l"! qui'" parlicuLor 6lll(l.l ...
226 downloads
1353 Views
75MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
c~U5<S; 1M..... d lhem are suppoil'd to lu,·~ been disco,'cr«! by the anc"-'1115, and ~ fourlb" lhe pttIpt"l" one. is lhen estot>hshed b" h'm. FiNllr. in LN gt'IltlTffiofo:!S inlt) the GWl1tia. "'hich a", theln5eh'l"! qui'" parlicuLor 6lll(l.l wilhin tIw tOOtl 6\'1:1l. And lh.>1 is !he reason 6911\, ClInov, 'u,,1 oro'leiO\' a", OCI:""i"""ny id,""kal in """ning for AnslOll", but only in a fonn;sl Sl'fISO!: laket1 strictly, they a", t.lo.....J fo' parlieular reams 01 Bring, This conflttl"'lion "'ilh the ancil'11l! is, in all Ih"", wa)'5 Aristotle carries il {JUI, dilft:renl from the Platonic one, ~ince Aristotle already had a uni"OCll, ",,'rn jf nOI ,odical1y concrh'l'd, basis for lhe onlOlogkal mode of questioning. "CCluil'\'d O.00:; is,lor Cn. ·k onlological """'arch, the ,,'ar of;1otti'iS 10 lhe Sringofbt'lngs. Thisdoes not mean. oowc-'er, thai Gn.""" ontology is depmdl'nt On "logic";' "''' would first ha".. lo""k "'hal logic for th.. Greeks. and ""~ mal' no! impure to Ihmt n>O\k'm cCln6a, lSl'l1£lo6uL Ptl'l1r/i"",'IOr. r! P""a'~ pfl'Mlurr. ,*"",;"" j"/tl 1M Otl'oI:>girtll
50fdr oJ an "mphatic ~nse lor them, .nd the). expl.1iOL'd beings out of beings. This is tilt: ~ of 1I,,~ir "t..mng stonO'S"; i.l'., they mon'll ....iwly in Ike dimC1\5ion of beings and dod rool.: aU mil!. into tke dimem;ion 0/ the Bring of bein~ t.) 0 j.lb, .hoe one. says: ,pia m /I"m /242 iU>I.I frun,m",,!> .. nUl .... hully u"... ,i"",.." ~t I""", ...·1 ....'"
".riou.>
I. Tilltb&o<doo~(""r:104)
:. E.t...-l Pr· ,(ColO!;.
z........ Oir I'ldl.'''pl... "",~. ~ l.oQ E".", lIotn.,7. AWL. Lo,~!- ,m.
3. Enoln _ I>ufgL~.
f'<Jo. , ~h • .oJ U""_~_l>p.t.-Ikr G""""". EtMt llo1flr. rift· o: It.>Uor. F..O Il"''ii.1Ing Itl"I tn"",tI,'Ul.u,,,,,,,",..,...,,...,J ....._or
I!'l(\Z
1-. ~ .... (1. 1IM;,;
'iI·' ,.~>l!i~g~
"" ':";"c~ ~la. , /;
~
p ~~_:;;l
lJ~
!-;
~
0'"
......
..
cf;l. "oil"J!lii;r~5't'
-111--'-'"' ,;a
-
_,1.~ ~ .. " "",
..t~.lli.'l"r. GilS •. ~"" .:I!it_15
;~~,~§:l:-l{~'~~J i~!~i~ ;".. W'O""Il~'-'I;I""'-'~ ;f' ~;r -euch Ihe qUlSl"lln f fleing, I ....id f .... l",dili"",,1 int"'Pl'I'1alik d;,,/ogJJt, Tmay " ... ,,~t.- an "".""..hl.. ,...."m ttl met.• ""¥",;,,, anti <w'ltnlnm' R". lhe '1ue;linn !'laIn "'ises here and poM'S by me.ms of I~ woole di.>loguc has. in all hasl~. bftn forgolll'n. This for~ing of lhe ",.. in quesli(>u is"oUy for US toda)'. For we (;In "pJ'f'a" cilher e>rplicill)' Or silmll)', tel two things: 1.) The ~ of IIdng i5 obvious e>'eryon,- U5o!S 'I roostanllr and undE1'Wlnds ..hal I\e means b~' il 2.) The cr>l:epl 01 fleing Is I~ higtw.",t: therefore il cannl" al all bdefinN, As 10 Ihe first we must ",,,,,uk IMI 'f'.'f'lS ""'~' be f"l'i"d und.... lhe rules that d"'~rml"e ~ dl.'flnilion. "'hich il!;(:11 Presl.'Ots onl,. or\(' fonn of delennitU>lion.. Ilw .....' origj""~ng in a C('rf~ln propos.itonal and a ~ 1 "logX.u The "log;"" of lhe determirolion of bt>ings ""'y!>01 ~ ;n,'O;.oo ;t5 tho!- cnlerion fo< lhe ",plication of Ilcing. Tl>erd'on! Ihe us"aJ lalk ~bc>u. lhe indefinabilily (l( IlI.'mg m~...ns IlOlhing. It merely man'fests lhe common rnisund"rsllmding 01 "'hat is ~I issu" \V'tth reg;>rd tel tho primal)' t.l$l< of any possible ClOloIg)', II mUSI be said f'O'iti"dy thaI il resides f>""Ciloslo the JX-Ible """,oing in any roncn>Ie
..txn,,-,,,
l£ol..atd lrkt. Ow Plod,..,.,..
tm, PI'''''''''''' _ _•
'*' Gntsion of nothing. Or d5C\'PI of Being ,·""'u. beings. bu' lrol the whole cunsid"rahon f\I,," its routS(' in an ind,~ bet....""'" the onlkal al'ld the OIllOlogkal. And Ihis applies nol Oflly I""re bul ullimatt.-Iy 10 II\(' .....d of lho! d;"log~, SO IMI this unclarity, present In P\.JIO hirnst'lf, 'onoliNI"" III£' prnpp 01 the lat;>,d' ~~.:[e..~~ ~""'e1t' ~~·~·l·~~~_~~.:i~
_.~~
:l'.
~
:
•
~Ji":l:
':;~"'''
0-
9-~~':2"~
~
j:ii ::l"l ?
it ill
101
Q' '"
~
!!j ~~~2.s~e::
."
:;1"..0:"
I !iii!!' 5 •~ '",,,,' ;:.;Ij''''a.'I'~G;'~
~~l~-'i'·
~
=.
i! ~Jj.
"al"~~a."
;; 8~ ..~ '"
~~li~~'I!~1 ~il~~I~i ...
iii
~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ [~i if~ !·t .. ~ ...~ 1r
ig~.!
3 It>
"'!::i-:l: t'cai3 a;;::!.;:j! ,.- .....
f
~~ti'!~~~i~a~' j·~Jl~:·is.~ l q . -~_ . d -. " ".'< I -',," c ~ s i." 8 9. ;:j!" 6":T~ "'::: _ ~ . . 00"'~:T =-:. e>tion r>oW is how ,,,'can b\o und,;>n;'ood.s I\UY. Tha, is. ~ncc lhe e>.p""",ion t».o" nO"' appli.... \0 the question is: in WMI liCfISt: isQv in the thd,~ the 6).0" is a rnndc of the lv. Ti lit; 16 Ow.., tttpov toil 0"'00; h'~ l'i tcrirt... ~ toUtll'; (d. 244dUf.l. "Is the liM'IV. in which ..... is "",anl--1). Ih.t whal sort of concl'J'l of li;..o" is \)ei"S US('(! h~re? In this regard, n.'i~ is flOW "'ad~ 10 a fragmml of tt... didaclloC 1'0'-'''' of I'annffikles himself:
.av.
to""
nW.'ToWv EU,.,;..;..o1l ooalpn; tvU).l"...~ov (;yo."lf/, llEooOOtv iOOltOli~ 1'''!I' '0 y(jp 0(,,,, 111'ci~"" outt 11 1\a,6ttpov !tcl.b'Ql XP£<W Ion til f\ tfi j2.we)if.). From this It isdear thill 0.' is understood in lhe..,nscofa o6oipIrons; "'I '" inda" th.~t," l~ the meaning of 6),ov in Pannenides. A,a tOloUtO" 6;..0,· it has 3 fl1o~ and ~n>. 6" is uniform, Now if1sofar as the 6Mn' has a "'iddle ""d "",,,,,,,illes,'t is SOlI..... thing Ihal .... sl'ljl~ (en. "parts." Th..sil isa mall.,.,.of an mhrely ",.nkular ... ho~, a whok which has parts. and this wholffieS6 eM bo;> .. nderstood 35 "nity in a special sense, 'Aut. Ilfl~ T6'1t: l'lJ'CP."\'b"',' Jt6:9o.; IJh- tOU 0-0.; l'):E'" bI, toldl. 61.0",,, olw" in th ~ of thl' I'QIlPI~". can then>/"", lid,... ~dtIotene16 of the one; in suo:h" 61.ov as I'fI'£PUJI.ll''Ov the lv is ill liOnlC S
<w
3.AItnn t~h.. ~ fun"'-... .me as "f!r1islwd; a f!r1ishl..,J Ihll\& Ih~, Il complete lh'r1& I~ a~ one. Ho>~ lhe rot\cepI of tv as 0"" roinri<Jes, ,,·ith ,I", ""''''~l'' "I 1v.., ..,.....1", uni'). If, ao.:orJinsl~·. ,he 1\.\.0" ~Ia"";'; oul."-t,, oIlle:ing, is 10 lttpm' O\·e. ar>d agooll'£>refore t"\'en 'j't\"t:ings, and ""l's lhal infm.il..ly many difficulhe5 "'ill n",,' .""",.
Il\;l\"e "head) lo cnlkally ex.lmin('S tnQI';.' pteci!lel}' the ,wo o,h... posihons, he gi,",'S ~ preview of the Oppon$fXd. and can. as il "'~. be assaulted and IOtlched. genuinely is. W" could SIlyquile'briefly rn, this posi,ion wha' is is wM'.nROUnC.. ..""",,,n'~n.'is n-sis.. ~ is not. l1\,l, is how we are 10 und""''''nd this posi'ion. If we call U - f"'OPle ma ...·rialis!S thai could mean t~y.", like Vog'.' M~hott.' and Buchner.' That, ho"·,'nr. has ",o'hing 10 do wilt> it
'ha'
~
, Fq
~
'il3"'25!''C:T!'':!!::)~~·--·oQ.o:;.I:~g-
~.,:~o.$;l
:.-"1." ;j
0:
:I. _.
f