Nihilism Now!: Monsters of Energy

Nihilism Now! Monsters of Energy Edited by Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan Copyright material from www.palgrave...

Author: Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan (editors)

205 downloads 940 Views 4MB Size Report

This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form

DOWNLOAD PDF

Nihilism Now! Monsters of Energy

Edited by Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

Nihilism Now!

10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan

Also by Keith Ansell Pearson GERMINAL LIFE: The Difference and Repetition of Deleuze

KANT TROUBLE: The Obscurities of the Enlightened



Also by Diane Morgan

Nihilism Now! Edited by

Keith Ansell Pearson and

Diane Morgan



Monsters of Energy

First published in Great Britain 2000 by

MACMILLAN PRESS LTD

Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and London Companies and representatives throughout the world A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.

First published in the United States of America 2000 by ST. MARTIN’S PRESS, INC., Scholarly and Reference Division, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 ISBN 0–312–23209–8 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Nihilism Now! : monsters of energy / edited by Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–312–23209–8 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Nihilism. I. Ansell-Pearson, Keith, 1960– II. Morgan, Diane, 1963– B828.3 .N447 149'.8—dc21

2000 99–088249

Selection and editorial matter © Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan 2000 Text © Macmillan Press Ltd 2000 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. 10 09

9 08

8 07

7 06

6 05

5 04

4 03

3 02

2 01

1 00

Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire



ISBN 0–333–73292–8

!"#$%#$&

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`)XXNa -#9 !*$#@%/'$ `)XXCaB -#9 (& /%#%.-2 %9($". "0 $+% R"F.#-2 D$;'&$590 9 8",)&94 "2 E'*4"%"I'C 9&. D$/'&"4"?C> 5/6#2 3$$%+)$72 (& ,%#(". K%7$F.%. (# !F2$F.-2 ,$F9(%& -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 *%%&&(9% -#9 7"S0"F#9(#/ %9($". "0 $+% %2%7$."#(7 R"F.#-2 (,4#,)$ 39/'*&$ `+$$34]]!F2$F.%6-7+(#%>$%%&>-7>FTa> M(& 8".T +-& H%%# 3FH2(&+%9 (# &%'%.-2 R"F.#-2& -#9 7"22%7$("#& -#9 +% (& 7F..%#$21 8".T(#/ "# - 6"#"/.-3+B (,4#,)$ "& B),?%0 !9)/"J/,4#,)94 A#,.*$% "2 >*?' 3".$)&*#C> 8$4/)2 9/7:#"" (& P."0%&&". (# M(&$".(7-2 -#9 !F2$F.-2 ,$F9(%& -$ ^"29S &6($+;& !"22%/%B \#('%.&($1 "0 K"#9"#> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 7)# "2 8,.?$5$&# `)X?XaB 7 G9&# B*/#*"&9)C `Z2-7T8%22 )XXJaB (#? +-'% 8".T%9 $"/%$+%. -#9 -3-.$ "# 2($%.-S $F.%B #-$("#-2(&6B -#9 G"6-#$(7 -%&$+%$(7&> *+%1 98%22 (# E%2H"F.#% -#9 +-'% H"$+ $-F/+$ -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 E%2H"F.#%> 5/,#(" 9$,4/7 (& P."0%&&". "0 P+(2"&"3+1 -#9 [(.%7$". "0 ^.-9F-$% ,$F9(%& -$ P%## ,$-$% \#('%.&($1> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 !*$#@%/'$ 9&. #'$ E"4*#*/94 `)XXCa -#9 !*$#@%/'$N% B9&?$)",% O95$0 E'*4"%"I'C "2 #'$ D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4% `)XXCa>

'(



="$%& "# $+% !"#$.(HF$".&

!"#$% "& #'$ ("&#)*+,#")% '((

;$/,,/ 8$2:( (& G%-9%. (# P+(2"&"3+1 -#9 [(.%7$". "0 G%&%-.7+ -$ E-#7+%&S $%. E%$."3"2($-# \#('%.&($1> ,+% (& "# $+% %9($".(-2 H"-.9& "0 P"5$&N% E'*4"J %"I'C 1$F*$= -#9 7&?$49;*> ,+% 8."$% +%. 9"7$".-2 $+%&(& (# LV0".9 "# $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 $.F$+ (# $*.$??$) 9&. 6#'*/% `)XXJa> ,+% (& 7F..%#$21 8".T(#/ "# $+% _F%&$("# "0 $(6% (# 7"#$%63".-.1 $+"F/+$ -#9 "# - H""T %#$($2%9 B$))*.$9& D$5I")94*#*$%> 5/,#(" */%@ (& 7F..%#$21 5E-cd$.% 9% !"#0%e.%#7%&; (# $+% U#/2(&+ [%3-.$6%#$ "0 $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 P(7-.9(% (# Q6(%#&B W.-#7%> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 &%'%.-2 -.$(72%& "# Z%7T%$$ -#9 "$+%. 6-R". 6"9%.#(&$&B -2"#/ 8($+ $+% .%7%#$ H""TB A9C*&? - !" 3")$0 A,+K$/#*F*#C 9&. ("&%/*",%&$%% *& #'$ E)"%$ "2 A95,$4 A [F.(#/ )XXJhN +% 8-& - K%'%.+F26% G%&%-.7+ W%22"8 -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 O-.8(7T> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 D*5$ 9&. 6H#$)*")*#C0 7)*%#"#4$R >$*.$??$)R B$))*.9 `)XXDaB -#9 "0 - #F6H%. "0 -.$(72%& "# -#7(%#$ ^.%%T 3+(2"&"3+1B 72-&&(7-2 ^%.6-# 3+(2"&"3+1B -#9 7"#$%63".-.1 W.%#7+ 3+(2"&"3+1> M(& #%V$ H""T 8(22 H% "# [%2%FA% -#9 [%..(9->



9/%+()#,( 5/"( .%7%#$21 7"632%$%9 +%. P+[ $+%&(& 5Q#$"#(# Q.$-F9 -#9 P+(2"&"3+14 *+% P."H2%6 8($+ *+"F/+$; -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 O%&$%.# ,19S #%1>

Y#$."9F7$("#4 $+% G%$F.# "0 E"#&$."F& =(+(2(&6

O% 2-7T 7.%-$("#> O% 2-7T .%&(&$-#7% $" $+% 3.%&%#$> [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(B P'9# *% E'*4"%"I'CS `)XX)a M-'% 8% +-9 %#"F/+i ZF$ %#"F/+ "0 8+-$ %V-7$21i L0 "F. 6"F.#(#/ -#9 6%2-#7+"2(-i L0 3"&$6"9%.# #-.7(&&(&6i L0 "F. 9%3.%&&('% (22#%&& -#9 -#V(S %$(%& "0 #"$ 5H%(#/ $+%.%; -#1 2"#/%.i U#"F/+ "0 %#"F/+j O% #"8 -&T4 8+-$ "0 $+% 0F$F.% "0 $+% +F6-# -#9 "0 $+% 0F$F.% "0 $+% 0F$F.%i Y& ($ #"8 3"&&(H2% $" 3."9F7% .%'($-2(&%9 8-1& "0 $+(#T(#/ -#9 6"9%& "0 %V(&$(#/ $+-$ +-'% 9(/%&$%9 $+% 9%6-#9 0". $.-#&+F6-# "'%.7"6(#/& -#9 &" -.% -H2% $" #-'(S /-$% #%8 +".(A"#& "0 '(.$F-2 H%7"6(#/i Y& ($ 3"&&(H2% $" &-'% $+"F/+$ 0."6 ($& 7F..%#$ 9%/%#%.-$('% -#9 '%/%$-$('% &$-$% -$ $+% +-#9& "0 - &6F/ -#9 7"&1 3"&$6"9%.# -7-9%6(7(&6i !-# 8% &$(22 (#'%#$ #%8 7"#7%3$&i Y0 "#% 0"22"8& 7%.$-(# (#02F%#$(-2 7"#$%63".-.1 -77"F#$&B ($ 8"F29 -33%-. -& (0 $+% %V3%.(%#7% -#9 _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 +-'% H%7"6% I9%%$M> Y& #"$ $+% F./%#71 (#0".6(#/ $+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% 5#"8; "0 #(+(2(&6 .%9F#9-#$ -#9 "$("&%i W". k%-# Z-F9.(22-.9B 0". %V-632%B $+%.% (& #"8 "#21 $+% &(6F2-$("# "0 - .%-2(&%9 #(+(2(&6 -#9 2($$2% .%6-(#& "0 - 3"&&(H2% #(+(2(&6 `- #(+(2(&6 "0 $+% 3"&&(H2%a (# $+%".1> Y# .%2-$("# $" 3.%'("F& 0".6& "0 #(+(2(&6 h ."6-#$(S 7(&6B &F..%-2(&6 -#9 9-9-(&6 h 8% 0(#9 "F.&%2'%& (# -# 5(#&"2FH2% 3"&($("#;> LF. #(+(2(&6 $"9-1 (& #%($+%. -%&$+%$(7 #". 3"2($(7-2> *+% -3"7-213&% (& "'%.B ($& $(6% +-& /"#% -#9 2(%& H%+(#9 F&4 *+% -3"7-213&% (& 0(#(&+%9B $"9-1 ($ (& $+% 3.%7%&&("# "0 $+% #%F$.-2B "0 $+% 0".6& "0 $+% #%F$.-2 -#9 "0 (#9(00%.%#7%> `Z-F9.(22-.9 )XXDB )NIa Z-F9.(22-.9 /"%& "# $" 6-T% $+% 72-(6B $%..(01(#/ (# ($& 0F22 (63".$B $+-$ -22 $+-$ .%6-(#& (& - 50-&7(#-$("#; 0". $+%&% (#9(00%.%#$ 0".6& -#9 0". $+% "3%.-S $("# "0 $+% &1&$%6 $+-$ -##(+(2-$%& F&> ,F.%21B Z-F9.(22-.9 (& H%(#/ (."#(7 8+%# +% 72-(6& $+-$ $+(& 6"9% "0 #(+(2(&6 (& "F. 7F..%#$ 53-&&("#;i M"8 7-# "#% H% 3-&&("#-$% -H"F$ (#9(00%.%#7% -#9 "#%;& "8# -##(+(2-$("#i Q& Z-F9.(22-.9 -7T#"82%9/%&B $+(& '(((



G$*#' 7&%$44 E$9)%"& 9&. B*9&$ 3")?9&

-&#)".,/#*"& (V

*+% 9(-2%7$(7 &$-/%B $+% 7.($(7-2 &$-/% (& %63$1> *+%.% (& #" 6".% &$-/% > > > *+% 6-&&%& $+%6&%2'%& -.% 7-F/+$ F3 (# - /(/-#$(7 3."7%&& "0 (#%.$($+."F/+ -77%2%.-$("#> *+%1 -.% $+(& %V7.%&7%#$B 9%'"F.(#/B 3."7%&& $+-$ -##(+(2-$%& -22 /."8$+ -#9 -22 &F.32F& 6%-#(#/> *+%1 -.% $+(& 7(.7F($ &+".$S 7(.7F($%9 H1 - 6"#&$."F& 0(#-2($1> `Z-F9.(22-.9 )XXDB )N)a< P%.'%.&%21 3%.+-3&B "F. 9%&(.% (# $+(& '"2F6% (& $" (#&3(.% - .%$F.# $" $+% %#%./%$(7& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 3."&% -#9 $+% 7.($(7-2 (#$%#&($1 "0 +(& -33."-7+ $" #(+(2(&6B $" .%&$".% - &%#&% "0 +(& +"3%0F2 6"#&$%.& -#9 $" /('% H-7T $" $+% 0F$F.% ($& .(/+$0F2 0F$F.($1> M"8 7-# $+%.% H% - &%#&% "0 56"#&$."F& 0(#-2($1; 8($+"F$ -# -6H(/F($1 "0 6%-#(#/i Y$ (& 3.%7(&%21 $+% 9"FH2%S#-$F.% "0 #(+(2S (&6 $+-$ (& 9%&$."1%9 H1 $+% 3"&$6"9%.# &(#/2%S6(#9%9 (66%.&("# (# $+% 6%2-#7+"2(- "0 $+% &1&$%6> L0 7"F.&%B $+%.% (& #" 0(#-2 7-$-&$."3+%> ZF$ $+%.% -.% /.%-$ %V3%7$-$("#&B -# %V3%.(%#7% "0 $+% /.%-$ #""#$(9%B $+% 3.%6"#($("# $+-$ 5+% 6F&$ 7"6% "#% 9-1;B $+(& '(7$". "'%. ^"9 -#9 $+% 7F2$ "0 #"$+(#/S #%&& `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB YY l Y# 6-.T(#/ &" 7-.%0F221 -#9 9%6-#9(#/21 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# 9/#*F$ #(+(2(&6 -#9 I9%%*F$ &*'*4*%5B =(%$A&7+% 8-& 3.%S &%#$(#/ -#9 &$-/(#/ -# (63".$-#$ 9(-2%7$(7 "0 #(+(2(&6 9&. 7F2$('-$(#/ /)*#*/94 #(+(2(&6 $""4 =(+(2(&6> Y$ (& 95+*?,",% `@=$*.$,#*?a4 Q> =(+(2(&6 -& - &(/# "0 (#7.%-&%9 3"8%. "0 $+% &3(.($4 -& 9/#*F$ &*'*4*%5> Z> =(+(2(&6 -& 9%72(#% -#9 .%7%&&("# "0 $+% 3"8%. "0 $+% &3(.($4 -& I9%%*F$ #(+(2(&6> Y$ 7-# H% - &(/# "0 &$.%#/$+4 $+% &3(.($ 6-1 +-'% /."8# &" &$."#/ $+-$ 3.%'("F& /"-2& `57"#'(7$("#&;B -.$(72%& "0 0-($+a +-'% H%7"6% (#7"66%#S &F.-$% `0". - 0-($+ /%#%.-221 %V3.%&&%& $+% 7"#&$.-(#$ "0 7"#9($("#& "0 %V(&$%#7%B &FH6(&&("# $" $+% -F$+".($1 "0 7(.7F6&$-#7%& F#9%. 8+(7+ "#% 02"F.(&+%&B /."8&B /-(#& 3"8%.a> L. - &(/# "0 $+% 2-7T "0 &$.%#/$+ $" 3"&($ 0". "#%&%20B 3."9F7$('%21B - /"-2B 8+1B - 0-($+> `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l Y$ (& $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 $+% 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$ 8+" #" 2"#/%. -&3(.%& $"8-.9& - $.-#&7%#9%#7% ". "'%.7"6(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# `7"#9($("#aB HF$ 8+" &(6321 -##"F#7%& -#9 %#R"1& ($& 9(&-33%-.S -#7%B $+% &3%7$-$". 8-$7+(#/ $+% &3%7$-72% "0 +(& "8# 9%6(&%>) M(&$".1B 3"2($(7&B 6%$-3+1&(7&B +-'% -22 .%-7+%9 $+%(. $%.6(#-2 3"(#$B -#9 8(22(#/ #"$+(#/#%&& -33%-.& $" H% $+% "#21 9%&(.% "0 $+% 8(22 -'-(2-H2% $" $+% 3"&$S 6"9%.# 6(#94

-&#)".,/#*"&

32%-&F.% 8($+ %V(&$%#7% +-& #"$ H%7"6% -#1 /.%-$%. $+-# 3.%'("F& $(6%&B ($ (& &(6321 $+-$ 8% 6"9%.#& +-'% 7"6% $" 6(&$.F&$ -#1 56%-#(#/; (# &F00%.(#/ -#9 (# %V(&$%#7% ($&%20> L#% %V$.%6% 3"&($("# (& #"8 &F77%%9%9 H1 -#"$+%.B %_F-221 %V$.%6% 3"&($("#B "#% $+-$ 7"#&$.F%& %'%.1$+(#/ -& (0 ($ 8%.% *& F9*&> Y$ (& $+(& 5(# '-(#;B -#9 (# 3-.$(7F2-. ($& $(% 8($+ .,)9#*"&B 8+(7+ 7"#&$($F$%& $+% 7+-.-7$%. "0 53.%&%#$S9-1 #(+(2(&6; h ". $+(&B &-1& =(%$A&7+%B (& 8+-$ .%_F(.%& 9%6"#&$.-$("#> *+% 3."H2%6 (& $8"0"29B $+%.%0".%4 ($ (#'"2'%& - 6(&$.F&$ "0 -22 3.%'("F& '-2F-$("#& $+-$ H".9%.& "# $+% 3-$+"2"/(7-2 `-22 '-2F%& -.% #"8 &%%# -& 2F.%& $+-$ 59.-8 "F$ "0 $+% 7"6%91 HF$ 8($+"F$ H.(#/(#/ ($ 72"&%. $" &"2F$("#;aB -#9B &%7"#921B 59F.-$("# 55(# '-(#;;B 8($+"F$ /"-2 `T*$4a ". 3F.3"&% `T=$/;aB (& $+% 6"&$ 3-.-21A(#/ (9%-; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lJJa> Y# &+".$B 8% F#9%.&$-#9 8% -.% H%(#/ 0""2%9 -#9 1%$ 2-7T $+% 3"8%. &"# $" H% 0""2%9> O% +-'% H%7"6% $+% '(7$(6& "0 -# %V7%&& "0 T#"82%9/% $+-$ 9"%& #"$ %#-H2% F& $" ".(%#$ -#9 7"63".$ "F.&%2'%& (# #%80"F#9 7"#9($("#& -#9 8% 7F..%#$21 2-7T $+% .%&"F.7%& $" 7.%-$% #%8 6"9%& "0 T#"8(#/ -#9 -7$(#/> M%#7% 8% 0(#9 "F.&%2'%& $.-33%9 (# 3-.-21&(#/ 0".6& "0 #(+(2(&6> Y63".$-#$21B =(%$A&7+% 9.-8& "F. -$$%#$("# $" $+% 0-7$ $+-$ 5-7$('% #(+(2(&6; 3.%&F33"&%& - 9%/.%% "0 5&3(.($F-2 7F2$F.%;B 8+(2% "F. 0%%2(#/ "0 &3(.($F-2 8%-.(#%&& $+-$ +-& 7F26(S #-$%9 (# 5$+% 6"&$ +"3%2%&& &T%3$(7(&6 .%/-.9(#/ -22 3+(2"&"3+1; (& -2&" - &(/# "0 "F. H1 #" 6%-#& 2"8 3"&($("# -& #(+(2(&$&4 $" H% - #(+(2(&$ (& $" H% (# 5.%2-$('%21 8%22 "00; 3"&($("#B &3(.($F-221 -#9 7F2$F.-221 &3%-T(#/ `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lJJa> Y$ (& $+% -$$%63$ $" 7F2$('-$% -# -7$('% #(+(2(&6 h $+% -7$('% 50".7% "0 9%&$.F7$("#; -& =(%$A&7+% 7-22& ($ `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l Y$ (& - #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 9%&%.'%& $" 9(%> Z1 7"#$.-&$B $+% %&&-1& /-$+%.%9 (# $+(& '"2F6% -.% -# -$$%63$ $" .%&3"#9 $" =(%$A&7+%;& 2-6%#$& (# D'$ P*44 #" E"=$) -H"F$ -# %$+(7"S3"2($(7-2 -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 52"&& "0 &$(6F2F&;B - 7%.$-(# 2-7T "0 '(/"F. -#9 .(/"F.B - 7.%%3S (#/ -3-$+1 -#9 2-A(#%&& (# 5"F.; $+(#T(#/ -#9 -33."-7+ $" 2(0%> Y# &"6% &%#&%B



V

5#(+(2(&6; (& -28-1& 5#"8;B -28-1& 3.%&&(#/ -#9 F./%#$21 7-22(#/ 0". "F. -$$%#$("#> =(%$A&7+% 7"#$%#9%9 $+-$ #(+(2(&6 (& - 5#".6-2 7"#9($("#; -28-1& 2F.T(#/ "# $+% +".(A"#B #"$ &(6321 -# %V7%3$("#-2 &$-$% "0 %6%./%#71> M"8S %'%.B +% -2&" 9%&7.(H%9 ($ -& - 3-$+"2"/(7-2 $.-#&($("#-2 &$-/% "#% #%7%&&-.(21 %V3%.(%#7%& "#7% $.-9($("#-2 '-2F%& 9(&(#$%/.-$% F#9%. $+% 3.%&&F.% "0 9(&S (22F&("#6%#$ -#9 9(&$.%&& `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)@a> =(+(2(&6 (& 6-.T%9 H1 $.-F6-$(7 &32($ 0."6 7"#'%#$("#-2 -&&F.-#7%& 8+(7+ 0".7%& $+% _F%&$("# P"@,S 8+-$ (& -22 $+(& -H"F$ -#9 8+%.% -.% 8% +%-9(#/ `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l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m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`$" /('% 56%-#(#/; $" -# %V3%.(%#7%B (# $+(& 7-&%B $+-$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -& $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&a> *+% %'%#$ (& 9"FH2%B -$ 2%-&$4 %V$.-7$%9 0."6 $+% &$-$% "0 -00-(.& ($ (& 2(#T%9 8($+ ($ 9(&72"&%& $+% 3"&&(H2% "0 $+% 3"&&(H2% -#9 -& 5"&%#)",% h 5$+% 0F$F.% %V(&$& (# - +F#9.%9 &(/#&; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B P.%0-7% l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`=(%$A&7+% )X?NB &%7$("# YYB l *+% 2-$$%. "#21 &%.'% $" %V-7%.H-$% $+% 3."H2%6> L0 7"F.&%B "# "#% 2%'%2 h $+-$ "0 $+% +F6-# ($&%20B "0 +F6-# 7"63.%+%#&("# -#9 (#7"63.%+%#&("# h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b-#$;& !"3%.#(7-# .%'"2F$("# (# $+"F/+$> *+%&% 7"#72F&("#&B +"8%'%.B "#21 $-T% F& &" 0-. -#9 $+% 9(&$-#7% $.-'%22%9 6-1 #"$ H% '%.1 0-. -$ -22> Y9%-2(&6 `(#72F9(#/ 3"&$6"9%.# .%2-$('S (&6 -#9 &"S7-22%9 53%.&3%7$('(&6;aB 7"#&(9%.%9 -& - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &$-#7%B 6-1 &(6321 H% 3-.$ "0 "F. $.-#&+F6-# -9"2%&7%#7% -#9B -& &F7+B 7"6% $" H% &%%# -& H%2"#/(#/ $" $+% (66-$F.% 3-.$ "0 "F. %#2(/+$%#%9B HF$ "'%.+F6-#B H%7"6(#/> *+% %&&-1& 7"22-$%9 +%.% $%&$(01 $" $+% '(.$F-2($1 -#9 /%.6(#-2($1 "0 $+% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6B %&3%7(-221 (# $+% 9(6%#&("# "0 ($& 6"#&$."F& -6H(/F($1> Y# $+% "3%#(#/ %&&-1 "0 $+% '"2F6% U2("$ Q2H%.$ 7"#$%&$& $+% -77F.-71 "0 "F. .%-9(#/ "0 - =(%$A&7+%-# 6"9%.#($1 (# $%.6& "0 !"3%.#(7-# -#9 b-#$(-# .%'"2F$("#&> Y0 $+%.% (& -# %V-7%.H-$("# -#9 (#$%#&(0(7-$("# "0 $+%&% 6"9%.# %2%6%#$& -#9 $%#9%#7(%& (# =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$ ($ (& #"$ (# $+% 9(.%7$("# "0 &"6% &%20S&%.'(#/ -#$+."3"2"/(&6> Q2H%.$ 7"#$%#9& $+-$ !"3%.#(7F&; .%'"2FS $("# 8-& #"$ - .-9(7-2 "#% &(#7% ($& %&&%#$(-2 -6H($ 8-& $" 32-7% $+% ,F# (# .%2-$("# $" $+% 7"&6"& (# %V-7$21 $+% &-6% $%.6& $+-$ +-9 H%%# -&&(/#%9 $"



V(( -&#)".,/#*"&

$+% 3.('(2%/%9 U-.$+> *+% %00%7$ (& &$(22 $" $+(#T "0 - 7%#$.%9 -#9 +(%.-.7+(7-2 7"&6"& 8%22S.%/F2-$%9 H1 #%/-$('% 0%%9H-7T -#9 +-.6"#("F& %_F(2(H.(F6&> *+% 7"#&%.'-$('% #-$F.% "0 !"3%.#(7F&; $+%".1 %&3%7(-221 7"6%& $" 2(/+$ 8+%# $+% 7"#$.-&$ (& 6-9% 8($+ $+% +%.%$(7-2 (9%-& "0 ^(".9-#" Z.F#" `)JD?h)NIIa> b-#$;& &%3-.-$("# "0 0-($+ -#9 T#"82%9/%B "0 6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 &7(%#7%B 8-& - +-20S+%-.$%9 -$$%63$ $" 3.%&%.'% - $.-#&7%#9%#$ .%-26 0."6 /%#F(#% -$$-7T -#9 (##"'-$("#> Y#%'($-H21 (# $+% +-#9& "0 =(%$A&7+% ($& 7"#7%($& -.% .%2%#$2%&&21 -#9 .%6".&%2%&&21 %V3"&%9B -#9 $+(& 0".6& -# %&&%#S $(-2 3-.$ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7+%%.0F2 -$+%(&6> M%.% -$+%(&6 9%#"$%& #"$ &" 6F7+ $.-/(7 -002(7$("# -& $+% 3+(2"&"3+%.;& &%.%#($1 -#9 -7+(%'%6%#$> 5="$+(#/ (& $.F%B %'%.1$+(#/ (& 3%.6($$%9; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB l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`&%% =(%$A&7+% )X?XB YY l) G(7+-.9 Z%-.9&8".$+ "00%.& - 7-.%0F2 -#9 +(/+21 (#'%#$('% .%-9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$ Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C> M% -(6& $" 9%6"#&$.-$% $+% (632(7-$("# "0 $+% _F%&$("# "0 5&3(.($; (# =(%$A&7+%;& -$$%63$ $" $+(#T H%1"#9 ". "F$&(9% 6%$-3+1&(7&> M(& "'%..(9(#/ 7"#7%.# (& $" /F-.9 -#9 8-.# -/-(#&$ -#1 %-&1 -33."3.(-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%B &F7+ -& 7+-63("#(#/ $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9



-&#)".,/#*"& V(((

(# $+% #-6% "0 - 6"#&$."F& 0F$F.% $+-$ ($ 8"F29 /-(21B HF$ H2(#921 -00(.6> L0 7"F.&%B $+% 0F$F.% 8(22 H% 6"#&$."F&B ($ 7-##"$ H% -#1$+(#/ "$+%.B HF$ 8+-$ 7-##"$ H% #-('%21 ". H2(#921 -00(.6%9 0". Z%-.9&8".$+ (& &"6% 7"632%$%21 -+(&$".(7-2 -#9 F#6%9(-$%9 5[("#1&(-#; &%#&% -#9 &%#&(H(2($1 `$+% 8".29 -& 6"#&$%. "0 %$%.#-2 &%20S7.%-$("# -#9 &%20S9%&$.F7$("# H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2B 0". %V-632%a> O+-$ 7"F29 H% 6".% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+-# $+(&i Y# "33"&($("# $" -# -00(.6-$("# "0 &F33"&%921 $(6%2%&& 7"#9($("# ". $.F$+ h $+% $.F$+ 8+(7+ 3."72-(6& $+% 8".29 $" H% 8(22 $" 3"8%. -#9 #"$+(#/ H%&(9%& h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k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i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`-6H(/F"F&B 9"FH2%B $8"S +%-9%9B -7$('% -#9 3-&&('%B %$7>aB -#9 9%&$."1& -22 3"&($("#(#/ -#9 32-7%> [" 8% &$(22 +-'% %-.& 0". =(%$A&7+% -#9 +(& 6F&(7i [" 8% &$(22 +-'% $+% .%&"F.7%& $" $+(#Ti M-'% 8% H%7"6% $"" &%20S&-$(&0(%9 8($+ -#9 (# "F. #(+(2S (&6i *+%&% -.% $+% T(#9 "0 F./%#$ _F%&$("#& M"9/%;& %&&-1 %#$(7%& F& $" 7"#0."#$ #"8> ,F+-(2 E-2(T 0"7F&%& +(& -$$%#$("# "# M%(9%//%.;& _F%&$("#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6B (# 3-.$(7F2-. "# $+% 7"#0(/F.-$("# "0 +*"% -#9 $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%#



V(' -&#)".,/#*"&

#(+(2(&6 -#9 4*2$ (# +(& $+"F/+$ -#9 ($& 2%/-71> M"8 -.% 8% $" $+(#T H("/%#S %&(&i M"8 -.% 8% $" .%2-$% "#$"/%#%&(& -#9 "#$"3"(%&(&i *+% -(6 "0 $+(& %V-7$(#/ 7"#$.(HF$("# (& $" -..('% -$ $+% H%/(##(#/& "0 - 72%-.%. -#9 6".% 3.%7(&% F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 (# M%(9%//%. -#9B (# $+(& 8-1B $" 6"'% H%1"#9 8+-$ (& (#7.%-&(#/21 H%7"6(#/ - 6%.%21 7"#'%#$("#-2 .%-9(#/ "0 "F. 6"9%.#($1 -#9 +(&$".(7($1> Y#($(-221 $+(& .%_F(.%& - .%7T"#(#/ 8($+ M%(9%/S /%.;& 6"&$ (63".$-#$ 7"#$%#$("#& -H"F$ =(%$A&7+%4 $+-$ +% (& $+% 3+(2"&"S 3+%. "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 "0 2(0% H%7-F&% +% 9%$%.6(#%& H"$+ (# -77".9-#7% 8($+ 2"/(7 "0 '-2F%& `9%'-2F-$("#B $.-#&'-2F-$("#B %$7>am -#9 $+-$ +% -33."-7+%& $+% _F%&$("# "0 52(0%; #"$ H("2"/(7-221 HF$ 6%$-3+1&(7-221> K(0% +-& #" &$-H2% ".9%. ". '-2F% 0". =(%$A&7+%B +%#7% ($& 2"/(7 (& -28-1& "#% "0 7"632(7-$("# -#9 %V7%&& `"0 7"F.&%B -& E-2(T 7"#7%9%& (# - #"$%B - 9(00%.%#$ H("2"/1 $" $+% "#% M%(9%//%. (& 8".T(#/ 8($+ 6(/+$ 6%-# $+-$ $+(& 7"#7%3$("# +-& $" H% 9.-6-$(7-221 .%'(&%9a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i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h -#9 H1 %V$%#&("#B #(+(2(&6> O% &%20S'('(&%7$("#(&$& 6F&$ &$(22 -$$%#9 $" 6-$$%.& "0 H"91 -#9 &"F2>



-&#)".,/#*"& V'

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`9%0(#%9 (# $+% %&&-1 -& 5$+% 0(#-2 3.%&%#$;a -8-1 0."6 $+% 6-33%9S"F$#%&& "0 $%2%"2"/(7-2 $+"F/+$> Y0B $" -9-3$ &"6%8+-$ M%(9%//%.;& 6%2"9.-6-$(7 -#9 +1&$%.(7-2 72-(6B 5"#21 - 7(2(F6 7-# &-'% F&;BJ $+%# $+(& (& "#21 &" 0-. -& $+% 8".29 "0 H%7"6(#/ (& .%/-.9%9B #"$ -& 0-7(#/ "#% 7-$-&$."3+(7 %#9B HF$ (#&$%-9 -& 5- 3%.3%$F-2 3.%&%#$ 6-9% F3 "0 "#% 7"#$(#F-221 7+-#/(#/ -3"7-213&%; `MFV2%1 )XXDB )Ia> *+(& 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $8" $13%& "0 -3"7-213$(7 $+"F/+$ (& (63".$-#$ -& ($ 6-.T& $+% 9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# "#% 8+(7+ 7"F29 2%-9B -#9 9(9 2%-9 8($+ =-A(&6B $" 6F.9%."F&21S(#72(#%9 H("3"2($(7& (#$%#$ "# - /%#%.-2(&%9 7"#02-/.-$("#B %#$-(2(#/ $+% &F(7(9% "0 $+% &$-$%B -#9 -#"$+%.B 1%$ $" H% %V32".%9B 2(#% "0 6"#&$."F& H%7"6(#/> *+% &%7"#9 "3%#& ($&%20 $" $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0 $+% 5H("S #%/-$('%; $" 53."'"T%; 2(0% (#$" +(/+21 H.%9 `?$@,U/'#$#$a 0".6& 8+(7+ %7&$-$(7S -221 7.-&+ -/-(#&$ $+% H-..(%. "0 (66-$%.(-2($1> *+(& 8".T 3."'(9%& 0""9 0". .%S$+(#T(#/ "0 %F/%#(7& -& $+% %F2"/1 "0 .$J2")59#*"&B #"$ $+% &%-.7+ 0". $%2%"2"/(7-221 6"$('-$%9 &%-.7+ 0". 53F.($1;> Y$ (& #"$ %#"F/+ $" 9(&6(&& %F/%#(7& "F$S"0S+-#9 -& $+% 9(&3%#&-H2% H1S3."9F7$ "0 .%3F/#-#$ $+(.$(%&; 3"2($(7&> Y#9%%9B (# -# -/% "0 /%#%$(7 %#/(#%%.(#/B F2$.-&"F#9 &7-#& -#9 -6#("7%#$%&(&]0%$".7"3(%&B %F/%#(7& #" 2"#/%. 6%.%21 &$-#9& -$ $+% 9"".B 8-($(#/ $" H% 2%$ (# ". 9%#(%9 %#$.1> M%#7% Z%##;& 8".T (& 6"&$ $(6%21 (# ($& -$$%63$& $" H.(#/ $+% 9(&7(32(#%& "0 3"%$.1 -#9 6%9(7(#% $" H%-. "# 3.%&%#$ $%7+#"2"/(&%9 6-$$%.`&a> k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h -#9 %-&(21 6(&F#9%.&$""9 h 6"'% "0 7"#&$.F(#/ 0-&7(&6 -& - 3."H2%6 "0 53F.% 6-$$%.; `-& "33"&%9B &-1B $" - 3."H2%6 "0 7F2$F.-2 -#9 3"2($(7-2 +(&$".1 ". 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1a> *+% 56-R".; 7"#$%#$("# 6-9% (& $+-$ $+% -#-21&(& +-& $" H% "# $+% 2%'%2 "0 - 3+1&(7& "0 $+% 6-$%.(-2($1 -#9 -00%7$('($1



V'( -&#)".,/#*"&

"0 H"9(%&> Y# ".9%. $" 9%6"#&$.-$% $+(&B ". -$ 2%-&$ $" H%/(# $+% $-&TB P."$%'( +-& .%7"F.&% $" 7"632%V($1 $+(#T(#/B F$(2(&(#/ $+% #"$("# "0 &%20S"./-#(&(#/ 3."7%&&%&B (# ".9%. $" &F332%6%#$ $+% #%8 7"#7%3$& "0 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( `$+% 5H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&; -#9 ($& $13"2"/(%&B &$.-$(0(7-$("# -#9 9%&$.-$(0(7-S $("#B $+% 5.+(A"6%;B $+% 5'(.$F-2; -#9 &" "#a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`$+% T(#9 9(-/#"&%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%B +% 72-(6&a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h -#1 -$$%63$ $" .%'-2F% '-2F%& 8(22 6%.%21 .%&F2$ (# #(+(2(&6;& .%$F.# (& +(& 7"#$%#$("# h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`P2-S $"#(&6 -#9 !+.(&$(-#($1a #%7%&&-.(21 .%&F2$& (# - 6%.% (#'%.&("#> Q# -$$%63$ $" -00(.6 2(0% 0."6 $+% 3"(#$ "0 '(%8 "0 ($& (66-#%#$ 3."9F7$("# (& RF&$ -& #(+(2(&$(7 -& $+% +%/%6"#(7 -$$%63$ $" &-'% ($ 0". $.-#&7%#9%#7% `-& (# $+% &-#7$($1 "0 2(0% 9"7$.(#% 3."6F2/-$%9 (# $+% .%7%#$ f-$(7-# &$-$%6%#$& 9(&S 7F&&%9 (# $+% %&&-1a> !-1/(22 8(&+%&B $+%.%0".%B $" &+"8 $+% %..".& 7"66($$%9 (# -#1 -$$%63$ $" "'%.7"6% #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 9"%& &" (# (/#".-#7% "0 ($& 3"8%.& "0 .%$F.# -#9 .%3%$($("#> M% 2"7-$%& - 5&"2F$("#; (# =(%$A&7+%;& 3F.&F($ "0 57+%%.0F2#%&&;B - 7+%%.0F2#%&& 0.%% "0 $+% &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/% -#9 ($& .%&&%#$(S 6%#$ $"8-.9& 2(0% `8+%$+%. ($& #%/-$("# ". -00(.6-$("#a> Q $+%"2"/1 h



-&#)".,/#*"& V'((

8+%$+%. 6%$-3+1&(7-2 ". 3"&$S6%$-3+1&(7-2 h "0 2(0% /('%& 8-1 $" - 3.-V(& "0 2(0% -& (# $+% %V-632% "0 !+.(&$ `$.%-$%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 (# $+% 6(&2%-9S (#/21 $($2%9 D'$ 7&#*J(')*%#a> M"8%'%.B =(%$A&7+% -2&" &3%-T&B -#9 -& (& 7($%9 H1 !-1/(22 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 +(& #%80"F#9 7+%%.0F2#%&& (# $+% 8-T% "0 $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9 `-#9 8+-$ 7"F29 H% 6".% 9%-9ia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e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bY= Y, =L KL=^UG *MU ,ELL*M ,U=,\L\, ,\GWQ!U LW Q ,Y*U LG Q ,!GUU=> ,T(# #" 2"#/%. &(/#(0(%& 72"&F.%>*+% .F3$F.% "0 &F.0-7% -#9 "0 &T(# 6%-#& $+% $)9%,)$ "0 (##%. -#9 "F$%.> Q& (#$%.0-7%B $+% &T(# (& (#-9%_F-$% `,$%2-.7 )XXJB X)a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



V'((( -&#)".,/#*"&

(#/B (632(7-$(#/ F& 8($+(# ($> *+% %$+(7-2 6"6%#$ (& 3"&($%9 -& $+-$ 8+(7+ (#$%..F3$& -##(+(2-$("#> !-$+%.(#% [-2% -2&" 0"7F&%& "# -# (#$%..F3$("# "0 &".$&B "#% $+-$ (& 5.F9%; -#9 8+(7+ &+"F$& 9"8# 3-$ -#9 0".6F2-(7 9(&7"F.&%& 0". 7"#$."22(#/ 8+-$ (& 3%.7%('%9 -& 6-9#%&&> Q.$-F9 (& 3.%&%#$%9 -& - 0(/F.% 8+"&% 7"#$."22%9 `&%20aS 8"F#9(#/& 3."'(9% F& 8($+ -# -%&$+%$(7 7"."22-.1 $" Z""$+."19;& %$+(7-221S 0"7F&%9 (#$%.'%#$("# "# 5&T(#(+(2-$("#;> Y# - 7"#&(9%.-$("# "0 $+% 0%-&(H(2($1 "0 -# .%S%#%./%$(&%9 -#9 .%S%#%./(&(#/ #(+(2(&6B "#% 7-3-H2% "0 "'%.7"6(#/ $+% (#%.$(- "0 3%&&(6(&6B &+% 0".6F2-$%& $+% 3+.-&% 5- 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2%; $" 9%#"$% $+% 3."7%&&& "0 7"#'%.&("# -$ 32-1 8($+(# Q.$-F9;& 8".T> Y# - 7"#S 0."#$-$("# 8($+ -# -3".%$(7 -H1&&B $+-$ (& 8($+ &"6%$+(#/ h &F7+ -& $+-$ "0 $+% 502(7T%.(#/ 0".6 "0 - 6-# HF.#(#/ -$ $+% &$-T%; h 8+(7+ 7-##"$ H% /.-&3%9 -#9 3F$ (#$" - 0F221 7"#7%3$F-2(&%9 0".6B $+% -H&"2F$%#%&& "0 2(0% (& &%%# -& .%S %6%./(#/> *+(& -H&"2F$% 2(0% (& #"$ "#% $+-$ /%$& H-7T (# .%$F.# 0". +-'(#/ $.-9%9 (# "#%;& &%#$(%#$ H"91 $" $+% 3"2(7%6%# "0 6".-2($1m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b-$A -2&" 7"#7%#$.-$%& "# - 6"9%.#(&$ 8.($%. 8+" (& &%%# -& .%&(&$(#/ 7.($(7-2 -33."3.(-$("#> M% .%R%7$& - .%-9(#/ "0 ,-6F%2 Z%7T%$$ 8+(7+ 8"F29 -$$%63$ $" .%7F3%.-$% +(& 9(00(7F2$ -#9 %2F&('% "$,F)$ H1 3F$$(#/ $" 8".T $+% #%/-$('($1 0"F#9 $+%.%(#> b-$A .%0F&%&B -#9 2"7-$%& - .%0F&-2 8($+(# Z%7T%$$ +(6&%20B - .%7F3%.-$('% 2"/(7 8+(7+ .%9F7%& 7"632%V $+(#T(#/ H1 3.%&%#$(#/ ($ -& - &(/#(0(7-#$ h -#9 $+%.%H1 3"&($('%21 (#0F&%9 8($+ 6%-#(#/0F2#%&& h &$-/(#/ "0 $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 6%-#(#/> b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` O% .%$F.# $" "F. H%/(##(#/4 $+% _F%&$("# "0 +-'(#/ +-9 %#"F/+ "0 6%2S -#7+"2(- -#9 ($& 9"/6-$(7 -#9 F#7.($(7-2 &2F6H%.&> Y0 $+(& '"2F6% (#&3(.%& .%#%8%9 -$$%63$& $" $+(#T -#9 /" H%1"#9 $+% +F6-# 7"#9($("#B $+%# ($ 8(22 +-'% &%.'%9 ($& /%.6(#-2 3F.3"&%> U#/2(&+ ". W.%#7+ &3%22(#/ "0 K%'(#-& +-& H%%# 2%0$ $" (#9('(9F-2 -F$+".&> *+% %9($".& 8"F29 2(T% $" $+-#T "F. 7"31S%9($".B ,-221 !.-80".9B -$ E-76(22-#B 0". +%. %00(7(%#$ +%23 8($+ $+(& '"2F6%>

C$%() Z-F9.(22-.9;& 3"&($("# -$ $+(& 3"(#$ 6(/+$ 8%22 .%6(#9 "#% "0 Z%#R-6(#;& 9%0(#($("# "0 0-&7(&6 `)X? ,%% Q#&%22 P%-.&"# )XXC 0". 7.($(7-2 .%'-2F-$("# "0 &F7+ -33."-7+%& $" $+% 53"&$S+F6-#;> C *+(& (& - .%0%.%#7% $" Z%#(/#(;& 0(26 5K- '($- %n H%22-; `)XX?aB - 57"6%91; -H"F$ 2(0% (# $+% =-A( !"#7%#$.-$("# !-63&B 8+(7+ -$ $+% 6"6%#$ "0 8.($(#/ $+(& (#$."9F7$("# +-& RF&$ .%7%('%9 -# L&7-.>

0(D()(,1(Q9".#"B *+> `)X?Ia !$?9#*F$ B*94$;#*; W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 ,F+.T-63 `)XC@a !$?9#*F$ B*94$/#*/%B $.-#&> U>Z> Q&+$"#B =o4 !"#$(#FF6> `)XXCa 5f%.&F7+B 9-& U#9&3(%2 AF '%.&$%+%#; (# 5Q+ &9/' 7,%/'=*#@ &"/' %*/' 4$+$& 49%%$N0 6*& I'*4"%"I'*%/'$% L$%$+,/' %9> G> *(%9%6-##B W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 ,F+.T-63> Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)XXCa 5K(0% Z%7"6(#/ Z"914 L# $+% 5E%-#(#/; "0 P"&$ MF6-# U'"2F$("#; (# (,4#,)94 X94,$% '"2> )B #"> ,7"$$ O(2&"#B LV0".94 Z2-7T8%22 PFH2(&+%.& K$9> pp ` Z-F9.(22-.9B k> 5L# =(+(2(&6; (# A*5,4/)9 9&. A*5,49#*"& $.-#&> ,>W> ^2-&%.B E(7+(/-#4 E(7+(/-# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&> Z%#R-6(#B O> `)X? M> q"+#B ZF#/-1B ,F00"2T4 W"#$-#-] !"22(#&> [-8T(#&B G> `)XX)a D'$ SW> `)XXCa 5Q P"&$6"9%.# W-H2%; (# E"%#5".$)& :9+4$%B $.-#&> ^> '-# 9%# QHH%%2%B E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&> =(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN?a D'$ P*44 #" E"=$) $.-#&> O> b-F06-##B =o4 f(#$-/%> pp `)X?Na >,59&R 744 D"" >,59&B $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&> pp `)X?Xa Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% 9&. 6//$ >"5" $.-#&> O> b-F06-##B =o4 f(#$-/%> ,$%2-.7 `)XXJa 5*"8-.9& $+% P"&$S+F6-#; (# 7)/'*#$/#,)94 B$%*?&0 7)/'*#$/#% *& (C+$)%I9/$ #"> ))?B !-6H.(9/%4 Q7-9%61 ^."F3 K$9> O"2(#B G> %9> `)XX@a D'$ >$*.$??$) ("&#)"F$)%C !-6H.(9/% E-&&-7+F&%$$&4 EY* P.%&&>



-&#)".,/#*"& VV(

) 64*"# 74+$)#

,(#7% !"3%.#(7F& 6-# +-& H%%# ."22(#/ 0."6 $+% 7%#$.% $"8-.9 :> =(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)>J ,(#7% !"3%.#(7F&B 6-# &%%6& $" +-'% /"$ +(6&%20 "# -# (#72(#%9 32-#% h #"8 +% (& &2(33(#/ 0-&$%. -#9 0-&$%. -8-1 0."6 $+% 7%#$.% (#$" 8+-$i (#$" #"$+(#/#%&&i (#$" - 5I$&$#)9#*&? &%#&% "0 +(& #"$+S (#/#%&&;i =(%$A&7+% )XNX YYY l<J *+%.%(# 8% +-'% $+% .%-&"# 8+1 %'%.1 6-#B 8+%$+%. +% H% "# %-.$+B (# $+% &F#B". "# -#"$+%. 32-#%$B -28-1& +-& $+% (63.%&&("# $+-$ -22 "$+%. $+(#/& -.% (# 6"'%6%#$ 8+(2&$ +% +(6&%20 (& (# - &".$ "0 (66"'-H2% 7%#$.%m +% 8(22 7%.$-(#21 -28-1& 7+""&% 3"2%& 8+(7+ 8(22 '-.1 -77".9(#/ -& +(& 32-7% "0 %V(&$%#7% (& $+% &F#B $+% %-.$+B $+% 6""#B E-.& %$7> Y# 7"#&%_F%#7%B $+%.% 8(22 -28-1& H% - 59/'*&9 5,&.* 8+"&% 7%#$.% &" $" &3%-TB (& %'%.18+%.%B 8+"&% 7(.7F60%.S %#7% (& #"8+%.%B 0". ^"9 (& ($& 7(.7F60%.%#7% -#9 7%#$.% -#9 +% (& %'%.18+%.% -#9 #"8+%.%> !F&-B B$ B"/#9 -?&")9&#*9 ZT> YYB !+> )
Y$ $+%# H%7"6%& -33-.%#$ $+-$ b-#$;& 72-(6 (& #"$ .%-221 -& -3"7-213$(7B -& 7-$-721&6(7B ". -& .%'"2F$("#-.1B 0". $+% $%.6&B 7"#'%#$("#&B 2(6($& -#9 3"&&(H(2($(%& "0 $+"F/+$ -& +% 8"F29 8(&+ F& $" $+(#T> Y$ (& F2$(6-$%21 (# )



*+% ,+-$$%.(#/ "0 $+% !.1&$-2 ,3+%.%&4 5."22(#/ 0."6 $+% 7%#$.% $"8-.9 :;

!*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C

Z-$-(22%;& &%#&%B 7"6(7-2> 5=" "#% 7-# &-1 8($+"F$ H%(#/ 7"6(7-2 $+-$ +% (& /%$$(#/ .%-91 $" "'%.$F.# $+(#/&4 M% 6F&$ "'%.$F.#B -#9 $+-$;& -22; `Z-$-(22% )XX) PF$ "$+%.8(&%B (# $+% 2(#% "0 $+"F/+$ H%(#/ 0"22"8%9 +%.%B b-#$;& $+"F/+$ (& 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& H%(#/ - 5.%#"'-$%9 $+%"2"/1; `[%2%FA% )X?@B X@a> Y# 7"#&%_F%#7%B 0-. 0."6 7"#&$($F$(#/ $+% (#'%#$("# "0 - $+"F/+$ $+-$ 8"F29 %&7-3% ,$-$%S0".6 -#9 5H2-&$ "3%# $+% 7"#$(#FF6 "0 +(&$".1; `Z%#R-6(# )XC@B < *+% 2(#T H%$8%%# $+% ,$-$%S0".6 -#9 $.-#&7%#9S %#7% (& $+% 7"632(6%#$ $" $+% (#$(6-71 $+-$ 7-# H% %V32".%9 (# -# -H&$.-7$ 9(-/.-6 "0 (66-#%#$ 7.($(_F% -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7"S3"2($(7-2 +%.%&1m $+(& (#$(S 6-71 (& #"$ -77(9%#$-2 HF$ 7"#&$($F$('%m $+% ,$-$%S0".6 (# ($& 9(00%.%#$ 6-#S (0%&$-$("#& $+."F/+ +(&$".1 (& &F&$-(#%9 H1 $.-#&7%#9%#7%>@ [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( 7-3$F.% $+% (&&F% $+F&4 O+%#%'%. $+%.% (& $.-#&7%#9%#7%B '%.$(7-2 Z%(#/B (63%.(-2 &$-$% (# $+% &T1 ". "# %-.$+B $+%.% (& .%2(/("#m -#9 $+%.% (& 3+(2"&"3+1 8+%.%'%. $+%.% (& (66-#%#7%> `[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX)B DNm )XXDB D@a Q# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+(& -H&$.-7$ 9(-/.-6 "0 3"8%. -#9 $.-#&7%#9%#7% (& $+% #%7%&&-.1 3.%7"#9($("# "0 -77%3$(#/ b-#$;& 72-(6 $" H% !"3%.#(7-#m ($ 9"%& "0 7"F.&% /('% $+-$ 72-(6 -# %#$(.%21 9(00%.%#$B #%/-$('% ". &$.(7$21 9%2(6($%9 '-2F%> O% 7-# -77%3$ b-#$;& 72-(6 $" H% !"3%.#(7-# (#&"0-. -& !"3%.#(7F&; .%'"2F$("# (& F#9%.&$""9 -& 6%.%21 +-'(#/ 7-..(%9 "F$ - 7"&6(7 &8-33(#/ "0 32-7%&4 $+-$ (& $" &-1B +% 32-7%& $+% ,F# (# $+% 7%#$.% "0 $+% 7"&6"&B 8+%.% $+% U-.$+ +-9 H%%#> !"3%.#(7F&B (# "$+%. 8".9&B .%32-7%& /%"S 8($+ $+% &$(22 6".% -#7(%#$ +%2("7%#$.(&6BD -#9 $.-9%& "#% '-.(-#$ "0 +(%.-.7+(7-2 $+(#T(#/ 0". -#"$+%.m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`Z.F#" )XX?B <Ja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`,3(#"A- )X?XB U YY Ca> KF22 $"" 3"&$F2-$%& - #%8 8".29B 0.%% 0."6 5$+% .%&$.-(#$& "0 $+% +(%.-.7+(7-2 &$.F7$F.%& "0 6%9(%'-2 7"#7%3$&;> *+% 7"#7%3$& 8%.% #"8 F#9%.&$""9 .%2-$('% $" "#% -#"$+%.B 5(# .%2-$("#&+(3& $+-$ 8%.% "3%# H%7-F&% $+%1 7"F29 H% .%'%.&%9; `G""H )XXCB

Nihilism Now!: Monsters of Energy

She Says My Monsters Now

She Says My Monsters Now

She Says My Monsters Now

Nihilism

Nihilism

Genealogy of Nihilism

Genealogy of Nihilism

MONSTERS

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Nihilism a Philosophical Essay

Modernism and Nihilism

Nihilism a Philosophical Essay

Literature, Philosophy, Nihilism: The Uncanniest of Guests

Movement of Nihilism: Heidegger's Thinking After Nietzsche

The Carnival of Monsters

A Multitude of Monsters

Of Myths and Monsters

Warcraft. Manual of Monsters

The Monsters of Templeton

Monsters of the Midway

The Sea of Monsters

The Sea of Monsters

The Sea of Monsters

Nihilism Now!: Monsters of Energy

She Says My Monsters Now

She Says My Monsters Now

She Says My Monsters Now

Nihilism

Nihilism

Genealogy of Nihilism

Genealogy of Nihilism

MONSTERS

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Nihilism a Philosophical Essay

Modernism and Nihilism

Nihilism a Philosophical Essay

Literature, Philosophy, Nihilism: The Uncanniest of Guests

Movement of Nihilism: Heidegger's Thinking After Nietzsche

The Carnival of Monsters

A Multitude of Monsters

Of Myths and Monsters

Warcraft. Manual of Monsters

The Monsters of Templeton

Monsters of the Midway

The Sea of Monsters

The Sea of Monsters

The Sea of Monsters

Recommend Documents