More Than Luck Ideas Australia Needs Now

– JULIAN BURNSIDE, QC

“Politics is not a horse race, but if you're anything like me and you're only just recovering from the "mule-trading" vibe of Election 2010, More than Luck is a brilliant place to restore your faith. What sweet relief to !nd a collection of words, sentences, pages, chapters, a whole book that reminds us of the possibility these current times o"er us.” – CLARE BOWDITCH, MUSICIAN

More Than Luck: Ideas Australia needs now is both a collection of ideas for citizens who want real change and a to-do list for politicians looking to base public policies on the kind of future Australians really want. In this collection of essays, CPD fellows and thinkers show what’s needed to share this country’s good luck amongst all Australians, now and in the future. #ey examine where we are now and where we need to go if we are to move beyond the stasis that has settled over government and opposition in Australia. #e result is a mix of easy wins that are ready to be implemented and some big, bold nation building ideas that may require a bit more backbone on the part of our political leaders.

Fiona Armstrong Larissa Behrendt Chris Bonnor Eva Cox Mark Davis Jennifer Doggett Ian Dunlop

Ben Eltham Kate Gauthier LEE Godden Elizabeth Hill Ray Ison Norm Kelly Phil Lynch

Centre for Policy Development 2010

Tani Shaw Ben Spies-Butcher Adam Stebbing Marcus Westbury

Edited by Mark Davis & Miriam Lyons

ISBN: 978-0-9808356-0-1

Miriam Lyons Ian McAuley Kathy MacDermott Peter Newman Barbara Pocock John Quiggin Marian Sawer

More Than Luck ideas australia needs now

“From climate change and sustainability to proper governance and strengthening our democracy, the ideas in More than Luck come at the right time. And we need politicians who are willing to take them seriously. If we cannot think bigger than tweets, we are in trouble. If our politicians won't think bigger than sound-bites, we are lost."

More Than Luck

ideas australia needs now Edited by Mark Davis & Miriam Lyons

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c: =P#N_"defA:Adf:fbghA:A; T$?4+"84*.65"B7"a4?.5"#,%&0,5 P4%".5"Y+,84"F$%&.3"i"=56-4B7"B7"M.],"j,5*&$$+C""" &%%2_``43-43%.38*65,5%*"$)+",)%&$+*/">$+@"%$"B4"3.+3)-,%48",*" >.84-7",*"2$**.B-44--A@5$>5" ,*" ," 3)-%)+,-",58"2$-.%.3,-"3$0045%,%$+C",58".*"Q.+43%$+"$'"%&4"F+,8),%4"P3&$$-"$'" Z)0,5.%.4*",58"P$3.,-"P3.4534*",%"%&4"L5.?4+*.%7"$'"j4-B$)+54C",58","'4--$>"$'" %&4"T45%+4"'$+"X$-.37"Q4?4-$2045%< .303/6&*789% ".*"%&4"R^43)%.?4"Q.+43%$+"$'"%&4"T45%+4"'$+"X$-.37"Q4?4-$2045%" j,%.-8,C" j.+.,0" &,*" ," &.*%$+7" $'" B+.56.56"2$-.37".84,*"%$"54>",)8.4534*C",*"%&4"'$)58.56"8.+43%$+"$'"%&4"=5%4+',34" G4*%.?,-"$'"=84,*".5"P78547C",58"8.+43%$+"$'"%&4"=84,*"X+$6+,0"'$+"%&4"P%+,.6&%" [)%"$'"#+.*B,54"G4*%.?,-$+@48",*","'+44-,534">+.%4+",58","048.," 84?4-$2045%"3$5*)-%,5%".5"R,*%"m0$+">.%&"%&4".5%4+5,%.$5,-"NF[C"=5%4+54>*,*" ," 84-46,%4" %$" %&4" 9:9:" P)00.%" ,58" >,*" 2+$V-48" .5" %&4" D.5@4+*" 3,%46$+7" $'" &'$% 7+C@#(?D()LC" R04+6.56" M4,84+*" *4+.4*C" ,*" ," UH$0,5" P&,2.56" ()*%+,-.,/".5"!($0,5",5")5,%%,3&48"3&,564",645%">&.-4"+4?.?.56" &4+"3$5*)-%,537C"Q.*%,k"(**$3.,%4*$+@*" >.%&" &4,-%&" 2+$?.84+C" .58)*%+7" ,58" 3$5*)04+" 6+$)2*"$5","+,564"$'"&4,-%&".**)4*+.%4+C"1$)+5,-.*%",58"3+4,%.?4"2+$8)34+"'+$0"j4-B$)+54$+@*" '$+" %&4" O4')644" T$)53.-" $'" ()*%+,-.,,*" %&4" N,%.$5,-"T$$+8.5,%$+"$'"("K)*%"()*%+,-.,C","+4')644"2$-.37"-$BB7"6+$)2">&.3&" +4345%-7" 04+648" >.%&" %&4" O4')644" T$)53.-,7,*","3$A'$)584+" $'"%&4"O4')644"(**.*%,534"X+$143%C","B$,+8"040B4+"$'"T&.-[)%"n3&.-8+45"$)%"$'" 84%45%.$5o" ,58" &,*"?.*.%48" 4?4+7" $5*&$+4" 84%45%.$5" 345%+4" .5" ()*%+,-.,,*","2,+%.3.2,5%".5"%&4"F$?4+5,534"P%+4,0"'$+"%&4"9:9:"*)00.%" P3&$$-" ,58" 2$-.37C" >.%&" *4?4+,-" 2+4*45%" 2+$143%*" ,+$)58" >,%4+" 6$?4+5,534" ,58" O46)-,%$+7"G+,04>$+@
@& J3FF" .*" ," 040B4+" $'" %&4" Q42,+%045%" $'" X$-.%.3,-" R3$5$07" ,%" %&4" L5.?4+*.%7"$'"P78547$+@48".5"%&4"V5,53.,-"*43%$+$+@",58"',0.-7"2$-.37
&4+4"&4".*"X+$'4**$+"A"P7*%40*" '$+" P)*%,.5,B.-.%7" n-$3,%48" .5" %&4" j$5,*&" P)*%,.5,B.-.%7" =5*%.%)%4o" ,58" %&4" [245" L5.?4+*.%7" nLaoC" >&4+4" &4" &,*" B445" X+$'4**$+" $'" P7*%40*" *.534" ;ddc#(,@D,$B%."J%@"%7,@%D)%(%H?DK(@$%H'()G$%U"#?.%&"%&4"()*%+,-.,5"N,%.$5,-"L5.?4+*.%7/*"T45%+4"'$+" Q40$3+,%.3"=5*%.%)%.$5*"nTQ=oC">&.3&".*",5"()*(=QA')5848"B$87"*)22$+%.56" %&4"4k$+%*"$'"54>"840$3+,3.4*".5"%&4"(*.,AX,3.V3"+46.$5"%$"*%+456%&45"%&4.+" 2$-.%.3,-"*7*%40*$+@*"'$+"%&4" Q40$3+,%.3"()8.%"$'"()*%+,-.,C",58",*",5",)%&$+"'$+"/)CD" O4*$)+34" T45%+4" *.534" 9::h,*" 2+4?.$)*-7" %&4" '$)58.56" T$$+8.5,%$+"$'"%&4"X=MTZ"Z$04-4**"X4+*$5*/"M46,-"T-.5.3">&.3&C".5"9::gC">,*" 3$5'4++48">.%&"%&4"()*%+,-.,5"Z)0,5"O.6&%*"M,>"(>,+8$+@48" ,*","3$004+3.,-"-.%.6,%$+">.%&"(--45*"(+%&)+"O$B.5*$5",58"3$A,)%&$+"$'","5)0B4+"$'"2,24+*"'$+"%&4"T45%+4" '$+"X$-.37"Q4?4-$2045%C".53-)8.56"3$,?(DKD)G%"+#%H"KK")%U$(?@'B%>"?D,D$C%="#% (%=(D#%()$(-% :D?% ()$+-8,*","P)*%,.5,B.-.%7"T$00.**.$54+".5" P78547",8?.*.56"%&4"6$?4+5045%"$5"2-,55.56".**)4*,*"," G)-B+.6&%"P45.$+"P3&$-,+",%"%&4"L5.?4+*.%7"$'"\.+6.5.,"T&,+-$%%4*?.--4C">&4+4" &4">+$%4"&.*"54>"B$$@*
,+848","S)445"R-.],B4%&"=="G4--$>*&.2"%$"*%)87"%&4".5%4+*43%.$5*" B4%>445">$+@C"',0.-7",58"3$00)5.%7"'$+"V?4"74,+*C"9::bA9::e$
".5"R3$5$0.3*",58"X$-.%.3,-"P3.4534",%"%&4" L5.?4+*.%7"$'"S)445*-,58">.%&"%&4"T45%+4"'$+"X$-.37"Q4?4-$2045%4-',+4" *%,%4C" .5" %4+0*" $'" .%*" 2$-.%.3,-" 84?4-$2045%" ,58" 8.*%+.B)%.$5,-" $)%3$04**&$)-8.?$%4< 3$08".%"$)%4+4"&4,?.-7"*3,-48"B,3@,*",*" .'" %&4" 6$?4+5045%" *%$$8" '$+" 5$)6&%" 4^342%" 64%%.56" +4A4-43%48,*" %&4" 2$.5%C"0,57">$584+48C"$'",--"%&4"6+,**+$$%*">$+@C"$'",--"%&4"*>4,%"%&,%".%"%$$@" %$"64%"+.8"$'"%&4"Z$>,+8"F$?4+5045%C">&45".%*"+42-,34045%">,*"*$")5>.--.56" %$"*%,58")2"'$+"%&4"24$2-4",58"%&4".**)4*"%&,%"2)%".%"%&4+4l X+48.3%,B-7" M,B$+" 3+.48" '$)-C" 3.%.56" -,3@" $'" *)22$+%" '$+" .%*" *3&404*" '+$0" ,5" $B*%+)3%.?4" $22$*.%.$5" ,58C" .5" %&4" 3,*4" $'" %&4" T,+B$5" X$--)%.$5" O48)3%.$5" P3&404C" %&4" F+445*2.434"*3&404C"%&4.+"+4*2$5*4"%$">&,%"O)88"&,8"3,--48"%&4"!2$-.%.3,-",58" 0$+,-"3&,--4564"$'"$)+"%.04*IC">,*">4,@".5"%&4"V+*%"2-,34,*"*$"*.0.-,+"%$"%&,%"$k4+48"B7"%&4"2+4?.$)*" 6$?4+5045%"%&,%".%"*44048"%&,%"5$"0,%%4+">&$"7$)"?$%48"'$+C"%&4"*,04"*43%.$5,-" 6+$)2*">$)-8"+4%,.5"%&4.+"&$-8"$5"2$>4+< P$04" *,7" >4" 64%" %&4" 6$?4+5045%*" >4" 84*4+?4C" ,58" %$" ,5" 4^%45%" %&.*" .*" %+)44"*%$2"2,7.56",%%45%.$5"%$"2$-.%.3*C">4"0,@4".%"4,*.4+"'$+"2$-.%.3.,5*"%$" *%$2"2,7.56",%%45%.$5"%$")*4"?$%4"'$+"%&4"2$-.%.3,-"4E).?,-45%"$'"%&4"3+,]7" >,+4&$)*4"6)7"n!(--"%&4"*4+?.34*"7$)">,5%",%"&,-'"%&4"2+.34ss"H&7"2,7"0$+4lIoC" >4"*&$)-85/%"B4"*)+2+.*48">&45">4"64%"2$-.3.4*"B).-%"%$"',--",2,+%",*"*$$5",*"%&4" 2+4**"3$5'4+4534".*"$?4+< W4%".%".*",-*$"%+)4"%&,%"6$?4+5045%*"64%"%&4"3.%.]45*"%&47"84*4+?4,*" *&.'%48"%$",?$.8"3-,*&.56">.%&"%&4"V5,-4"$'"!(C@$#,'$=,*"0)3&"4,*.4+"%$" 64%","3-4,+"2.3%)+4"$'"T,--)0",58"(8,0/*"8.k4+45%"2&.-$*$2&.4*"$5"3).*.54"%&,5" 16

Introduction

$'"F.--,+8",58"(BB$%%/*"2&.-$*$2&.4*"$5"()*%+,-.,/*"')%)+4445" %>$"*%,64A0,5,648"3$5%4*%*C">&7">$)-8"7$)"3&$$*4"%$">,%3&","B,%%-4".5">&.3&" %&4"*&+,254-"'+$0"*0,--"B)--4%*"+.3$3&4%*"$k"4?45"*0,--4+"%,+64%*l D4+4" ,+4" *.65.V3,5%" 8.k4+4534*" .5" >&,%" %&4" 0,1$+" 2,+%.4*" &,?4" 8$54" .5" %&4" 2,*%C",58".5">&,%"%&47">$)-8"?D-$"%$"8$"5$>C"B)%"%&4"*3$24"'$+"8.k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j.5.*%4+"F.--,+8/*"'$3)*"$5"3$5*45*)*AB).-8.56",5",%%402%",%"Z,>@4A *%7-4" -4,84+*&.2" %&,%" >.--" >$+@" %$" B+.56" ,*" B+$,8" ," 6+$)2" $'" ()*%+,-.,5*" ,*" 2$**.B-4"$5"B$,+8"'$+"+4'$+0*"$'")52+434845%48",0B.%.$5l"[+"1)*%",5"4^3)*4" 5$%"%$"-4,8",%",--l F.--,+8" .*" +.6&%" %$" +43$65.*4" %&,%" -4,84+*&.2" .*" 5$%" 1)*%" ,B$)%" 6.?.56" $+84+*" J" B)%".%/*"5$%",B$)%"6.?.56"24$2-4"4^,3%-7">&,%"%&47">,5%"4.%&4+&,%"%&47"8$5/%"+4,--7"5448"%$"0,@4"%&40"&,227"$+"3,+4">&,%".**)4*",+4".02$+%,5%C"4?45" 3+)3.,-C"-4%",-$54"&$>"%$"B46.5"%$",88+4**"%&405"3)-%)+4*< Z$>" ,+4" >4" %$" 0$?4" %&4" 6,04" $5" >&45" *$" 0)3&" 0,.5*%+4,0" 2$-.%.3,-" 3$0045%,+7".*"*%)3@".5"%&4"$54C"8,%48".8.$0l"D4"B-$6"&'$%>DPD)G%9'#D-$"&,8" ,5"4^34--45%"2$*%"$5"%&4"048.,"+4*2$5*4"%$"%&4"M,B$+"6$?4+5045%/*"8.%3&.56"$'" %&4"40.**.$5*"%+,8.56"*3&4047"=5*%.%)%4"2$--.56"%&,%"*&$>48"%&,%"2)B-.3"*)22$+%"'$+",3%.$5"$5"3-.0,%4" 3&,564C"4?45".'".%".5?$-?4*"*.65.V3,5%"3$*%C"&,8"',--45"'+$0"hf"24+"345%".5"9::h" %$"cf"24+"345%"$'"%&4"2$2)-,%.$5".5"9:;:,+8" 2$-.%.3,-" ,58" 2$2)-,+.%7" 3$5%4*%" ,58" ,5" 4-43%$+,%4" 8+.?45" B7" %&4" &.2A2$3@4%C" ,58" .*" )5,B-4" %$" 3,5?,*" ," 0$+4"3$02-4^"5,++,%.?4l" =%"$'%45"*440*",*".'"$)+"0,1$+"2,+%.4*"8$5/%"%+)*%"?$%4+*"%$"-$$@"B47$58"5,++$>" *4-'A.5%4+4*%"J"4?45">&45"+4*4,+3&",58"$2.5.$5"2$--*"%4--"%&40"$%&4+>.*4&,%"2$-.%.3.,5*"3,5"8$"%$".02+$?4"24$2-4/*"-.?4*C"%&4"048.," '$3)*4*"$5"24+*$5,-.%.4*.%&"$2.5.$5"2$--*">&.3&"+,+4-7"84-?4" .5%$"?$%4+*/" 84424+" $+" -$564+A%4+0" ,*2.+,%.$5*445"%>$"0.++$+*"J">&.3&4?4+"8.+43%.$5".%"-$$@*".5C".%"*44*" .5V5.%4".0,64*"$'".%*4-'"+4t43%48"B,3@">.%&"-4**",58"-4**"3-,+.%7,*"%&4">,7".5">&.3&"*$04"3$0045%,%$+*"'4--".5%$" ,"54,+A2,5.3",*"%&4"+4*)-%"$'"%&4"3$*7"%>$A2,+%7"*7*%40"B4.56"8.*+)2%48< [%&4+*"2-,7"$)%","%.+48C"8,%48">,+">.%&"U%&4"-4'%/$)-8" t$>" B,3@" %$" %&40"" .5"2+4'4+4534*< D4*4" *$+%*" $'" .5?.%,%.$5*" %$" U2$-.%.3*A,*A)*),-/" ,+4" 4?4+7>&4+4" .5" ()*%+,-.,5" 2$-.%.3*,%4+"*&$+%,64*r"$'"*3-4+$%.3C"$?4+-$,848"3.%.4*+$%4"%&,%"()*%+,-.,">,*","*43$58A+,%4" 3$)5%+7"-.?.56"$5".%*"-)3@&,%" >,*"B,*.3,--7",">4,@"43$5$07",58",">4,@"-4,84+*&.2"3-,**4"3,5"3$5%.5)4"%$"3$,*%",-$56C"$+"0,@4"%&4"3&,564*"544848"%$"5$%"$5-7"3,--" $)+*4-?4*","-)3@7"3$)5%+7C"B)%","3$)5%+7"+)5"B7"24$2-4">&$"@5$>"&$>"%$"0,@4" %&4"-)3@"-,*%< =5*%4,8C" $)+" -4,84+*" 2+4'4+" %$" 2-,7" 8.34" >.%&" 84*%.57.--" -,*%"'$+4?4+r"%&,%">4/--"8.*3$?4+","3)+4"'$+"Q)%3&"Q.*4,*4"%&,%"8$4*5/%".5?$-?4" *-$>.56"%&4"B$$0"8$>5r"%&,%"3&4,2"$.-">$5/%"+)5"$)%C"$+"%&,%",5"4E),--7"3&4,2" ,-%4+5,%.?4">.--"B4"'$)58"B4'$+4".%"8$4*r"%&,%"6-$B,-".5,3%.$5"$5"3-.0,%4"3&,564" >.--"3$5%.5)4r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

\% %&'$#$%DC%)"@'D)G%K"#$%&$">,5%"%$",?$.8" 2,7.56"%&4"')--"3$*%*"$'"%&4.+",3%.?.%.4*4+')-".5%4+4*%*",*"%&4+4">,*",B$)%" %&4"&$%-7"3$5%4*%48"F)55*"2)-2"0.--".%*4-'&.3&"2,+%7"%&47"?$%48" '$+C"UB43,)*4"%&4"0,1$+"2,+%.4*",+4"B$%&"%$$">4,@"%$"%,@4"$5"%&4".5%4+4*%*"$'"B.6" B)*.54**/&$">$)-8"5$%"$%&4+>.*4".845%.'7",*"U6+445/"%$"2)%"%&4"F+445*".5"," 2$*.%.$5"%$"843.84">&$">$)-8"&$-8"6$?4+5045%< ['%45C"?4*%48" .5%4+4*%*" &,?4" 3&,02.$5*" .5" %&4" 048.,_" .5t)45%.,-" 54>*2,24+" 3$-)05.*%*" >&$" *44" %&4.+" +$-4" ,*" *24,@.56" )2" '$+" U+4,-.*%.3/" 2$-.37" J" >&4+4" +4,-.*%.3".*"84V548",*">&,%"45%+453&48".5%4+4*%*">.--",3342%< Y$"%,3@-4"?4*%48".5%4+4*%*",58"84,-">.%&"*$04"$'"%&4"2+$B-40*"3$?4+48">.%&.5" %&.*"B$$@C">4"5448"%$"+484V54"+4,-.*0"J",5",3%.$5"%&,%".*"B$%&"5434**,+7",58" 2&7*.3,--7" ,3&.4?,B-4" *&$)-8" B4" *445" ,*" ," +4,-.*%.3" ,3%.$5.%&"*$3.,-",58"45?.+$5045%,-"+4,-.%7&$" >,5%"+4,-"3&,564"3,5/%",k$+8"%$"1)*%"3+$**"$)+"V564+*"'$+"%&4"$)%3$04*"$'"%&4" 54^%" +4?.4>C" %&4" +48.*3$?4+7" $'" +43$00458,%.$5*" '+$0" %&4" -,*%" +4?.4>C" ,5" 404+64537" *2.54" %+,5*2-,5%" ,'%4+" %&4" 4-43%.$5C" $+" %&4" 2$*.%.?4" .5t)4534" $'" ," 0$+4"2+$6+4**.?4"*45,%4< ='">4",+4"%$"8$"0$+4"%&,5"04+4-7"+4-7"$5"-)3@C">4"5448","?.,B-4C"&$24')-"5,++,%.?4" ,B$)%" %&4" ')%)+44" B4" .84,-.*%*" V+*%" ,58"2+,60,%.*%*"*43$58"J"%&4+4".*"5$"2$.5%"B4.56"2+,60,%.3")5-4**"7$)"@5$>" >&,%"7$)",+4"B4.56"2+,60,%.3",B$)%"2$-.%.3,-",58" 43$5$0.3"')%)+4< D4"*.56-4".**)4">.%&"%&4"0$*%"2$%45%.,-"'$+"%+,5*'$+0.56"%&4"2$-.%.3*">4"&,?4" .5%$"%&4"2$-.%.3*">4"5448".*",-*$"%&4".**)4"%&,%"3$04*")2"0$*%"$'%45"%&+$)6&$)%" 21

MORE THAN LUCK

%&.*" B$$@_" 6-$B,-" >,+0.564+4" 84*.6548" ,+$)58" 3,+" %+,?4-C" >&.-4" $)+" &$04*" +4-.48"$5"3$,-"%$"%)+5"$5"%&4"-.6&%*"$+"%&4"*&$>4+4">$)-8"&,?4" )*48")2",-0$*%","%&.+8"$'".%"B7"%&4"458"$'"9::g,+0.56">.--"&,?4"0,1$+"43$5$0.3",58"*$3.,-"B454V%*.--"%,@4"-.%%-4"0$+4"%&,5"2$-.%.3,-">.--< L5-.@4"%&4"6$-8V*&".5"6$?4+5045%C"0$*%"3.%.]45*"3,5"*44"B47$58"%&4"4-43%.$5" 373-4" %$" 8+4,0" $'" >&,%" -.'4" >.--" B4" -.@4" '$+" $)+" '+.458*C" $)+" ',0.-.4*C" ,58" $)+*4-?4*".5"g:"74,+*"%.044"%&.5@"$'"%&4"*%,%4"$'"$)+"2-,54%",58"$)+" 3$5%.545%C" *$04" $'" %&$*4" 8+4,0*" %,@4" $5" ," 5.6&%0,+.*&" E),-.%7" >,%4+A 6)]]-.56"3+$2*"'$+"4^2$+%&.%4">.%&"*,-%",58"$)+"*$.-"B-$>*",>,7"$5"%&4">.584"-$*4" &$)+*"4,3&"8,7"%$"*-$>C"0,8845.56"3$00)%4*"%&+$)6&"6+.%%7"*0$6C",58"*&$2",%" *)24+0,+@4%*">&4+4"%&4"%$0,%$4*"B$)534",58"%&4"3,++$%*"%,*%4"-.@4"3,+8B$,+8< X4$2-4",+4"*%,+%.56"%$"3+7"U45$)6&/,5%","')%)+4"%&,%".*"B+.6&%C"&4,-%&7",58" 6+445,5%"04,5.56')-",3%.$5"%$"3$0B,%"3-.0,%4"3&,564",58"*)*%,.5,B-7" 0,5,64" $)+" >,%4+C" '$+4*%*" ,58" 0,+.54" &,B.%,%*,5%" ()*%+,-.,5" ',+0.56" %$" +4t43%" %&4" )5.E)4" 5,%)+4" $'" $)+" '+,6.-4" 3$5%.545%,5%" $)+" @.8*" ,58" 6+,[email protected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
.--" B4" %&4" 6+$>.56" .5%4+3$5543%4854**" $'" 4?4+7%&.565" ,22+$,3&4*" %$" 2+$B-40A*$-?.56" J" ," 3$5')*.$5" *&,+48" B7" 24$2-4" .5" *45.$+" 2$*.%.$5*" $'" ,--" *%+.24*" ,58" .84$-$6.4*&.-4" j,+3)*" H4*%B)+7" ,58" #45" R-%&,0" -$$@" ,%" &$>" %$" 0,@4" 3)-%)+,-" 2$-.37" +4t43%" %&4" 5448*" $'" %$8,7/*"3)-%)+4A0,@4+*,7*"$)%"$'","*.%),%.$5" .5">&.3&"%&4"-$%%4+7"$'"B.+%&"84%4+0.54*">&$"*)33448*",58">&$"*%+)66-4*".5" ()*%+,-.,5"*3&$$-*"M,B$+"*4%".%*4-'")2"'$+"',.-)+4" $5" %&4" +4')644" 84B,%4C" ,58" 84*3+.B4*" >&,%" .%" >$)-8" %,@4" %$" %)+5" %&,%" 84B,%4" ,+$)58.%&"24,@"$.-",58"3-.0,%4"3&,564",+$)58"%&4" 23

MORE THAN LUCK

3$+54+C">&.-4"G.$5,"(+0*%+$56"*&$>*"&$>">4"3,5"*&.'%"U'+$0"'4,+"%$"&$24/"B7" 0,@.56"%&4"0$*%"$'"()*%+,-.,/*"6+445"43$5$0.3"$22$+%)5.%.4*< #)%" >&4+4" >.--" %&4" 2$-.%.3,-" >.--" 3$04" '+$0" %$" *)22$+%" %&4*4" ,58" %&4" 0,57" $%&4+".02$+%,5%".84,*".5"%&.*"B$$@l ('%4+"%&4"9::e"'484+,-"4-43%.$5"F4%L2s"3$5*)-%48".%*"040B4+*"$5"%&4.+"?.*.$5" '$+"%&4"54>"M,B$+"6$?4+5045%.%&","*4+.4*"$'"F4%" Y$64%&4+*" .5" 24$2-4/*" &$)*4*" J" %&$)*,58*" %$$@" 2,+%" .5" $?4+" b::" 044%.56*" >&4+4" %&47" 8.*3)**48" 4?4+7%&.56" '+$0" 3-.0,%4" 3&,564" %$" 3.?.3" 48)3,%.$5&.3&"3$02.-48"%&4"+4*)-%*",58"*45%"%&40"$)%"%$"040B4+*"%$"2+.$+.%.*4.*&"-.*%"'$+"%&4"M,B$+"F$?4+5045%4+"&,?4"0$?48"%$"%&4"'$+4'+$5%" $'"2$-.%.3*5"%$","B,%%-4"$?4+">&$"3,5"*2458"0$+4"0$547" $+"0,5,64"%&4"048.,"0$+4"4k43%.?4-7C">4",--"-$*4&45"%&47"&,?4"%&4" 5)0B4+*"$5"%&4.+"*.84< (*" 0)3&" $'" %&4" U$-8/" 048.," B43$04*" 4?4+" 0$+4" 2+48.3%,B-4" .5" .%*" %[email protected]" 0$+4"45%+453&48".5"&$+*4"+,34"2$-.%.3,-"+42$+%.56",58"0$+4"%&,5"4?4+"2,+%"$'" %&4"2+$34**C".5%45%"$5"2-,7.56"$)%"',)^"3)-%)+4">,+*"B4%>445",5",--A2$>4+')-" 2&,5%$0"-4'%",58"U$+8.5,+7"24$2-4/"$5"+4,-"%&+4,%*"*)3&",*"6-$B,-">,+0.56",58" .0,6.5,+7"%&+4,%*"'+$0",*7-)0"*44@4+*C"*$"54>"%[email protected]".*"3$0.56".5"5$%"$5-7" '+$0" %&4" '+.564*C" B)%" '+$0" %&4" 0,.5*%+4,0" u" %&4" *%+44%*C" %&4" *)B)+B*C" '+$0" *3&$$-*C" '+$0" )5.?4+*.%.4*C" '+$0" @.%3&45" %,B-4*" u" %&,%" %&4" 54>" 3$5*4+?,%.*0" &,*"%+.48"%$"2+4%458".*".%*"$>5< D,%" %&4+4" .*" B+$,8" *)22$+%" '$+" 54>" >,7*" $'" %[email protected]" .*" *&$>5" B7"" +4345%"2$--.56< (6,.5*%"%&4"$-8"U6+445*"?*"1$B*/"8.?.84"%&,%"3$5%.5)4*"%$"6).84"*$"0)3&"2$-.%.3,-" +&4%$+.3C".5"%&4"-4,8")2"%$"%&4"9::e"4-43%.$5"%&4"0.5.56"8.?.*.$5"$'"%&4"TGjRL" 3$5*)-%48".%*"040B4+*"$5"3-.0,%4"2$-.37",58"+434.?48")5,5.0$)*"*)22$+%"'$+" *.65.56" %&4" a7$%$" X+$%$3$-48"%&,%"eg"24+" 24

Introduction

345%"$'"24$2-4"B4-.4?4">4"5448"*%+$564+"04,*)+4*"%$"2+$%43%"%&4"&)0,5"+.6&%*"$'" 24$2-4">.%&"045%,-".--54**C"%&4"4-84+-7C"(B$+.6.5,-"()*%+,-.,5*",58"24$2-4">.%&" 8.*,B.-.%74+&7"()*%+,-.,5*"?$%4",*"%&47" 8$"*.02-7"8$4*5/%"*%,3@")24"-4,+5"%$"0,@4"')--")*4"$'"$)+"2$>4+",*"3.%.]45*4"&,?4"%&4"%$$-*"%$"3&,564",-0$*%"4?4+7%&.56",B$)%" $)+"$>5"-.?4*C"B)%"5$%&.56",B$)%"%&4">$+-8",+$)58")*