Marxism and Social Science

,

Marxism and Social Science

Andrew Gamble DavidMarsh and Tony Tant Editors H " .

.

,

541."5 ,M3t{(.. ,

University of Illinois Press Urbana and Chicago

n ,

Selection and editorial maner copyright © 1999 by Andrew Gamble. David Marsh, and Tony Tam Indi vidual chapters (in order) copyright © 1999 by Andrew Gamble, Stevi lackson, Michael Kenny. GJyn Daly, Andrew Gamble. Tony Tant, Jim Johnsmn and David P. Dolowitz. Colio Hay, Chris Pierson, Charlie McMahon, Trevor Purvis, Oaryl Glaser, John Barry. Simon Bromley, Neil Robinson. David Marsh All rights reserved. First published 1999 by MACMlLLAN PRESS LTD HoundmiUs, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 X 6S and London Companies and representatives throughout the world ,

f

UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS PRESS edition, 1999

Library of Congress CataJoging-in-Puhlication Data Marxism and social science I edited by Andrew Gamble, David Marsh, and Tony Tant. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-252- Odd�: Social Class and Social Justice in Indusrrial Society (Oxford: Clarendon), Marx, K . (1 843a [1 975]). 'Critique of Hege!'s Doctine of the State', in L Collctti (cd.), Karl Mane £ar�r Writings (London: Pelican). Marx, K . ( 1 843b [1975]), On the lewish Question'. in L Colletti. (ed.), Karl Marx: Early J,Vriring.\' (London: Pelican). Marx, K. ( 1 844 [ 1 975]), 'Introduction to a Contribution to a Critique of Hegel"s Philosophy of Law', in L. Colletti (ed.), Karl Marx: Early Writings (London: Pelican). Marx, K. ( 1 848/[1973]). A1an{(eslo (�( lhe CommuniSI Party (Harmondsworth: Penguin). Marx, K. ( 1 850 [ 1 978]), 'The Class Stuggles in France: 1 845 to 1 8 50', in K . Marx and F . Engels, Collected Works, Volume 1 0 (London: Lawrence & '

Wishart).

Marx, K. (1 852 [ 1979]), 'The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte', in K. Marx and F. Engels, COllCCI(,d VVorks. Volume 1 1 (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Marx, K . ( 1 859 [1987]), 'Preface to a ContribL\tion to a Critique of Political Economy', in K . Marx and F. Engels. Collected J-f'orks, Volume 29 (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Marx , X . ( \ 867 [1 976]). Capital (VD!. I) (New York: Vintage Books). Marx. K. ( 1 8 70 [1974.]). The General Council of the Federal Council of French Switzerland', i n David Fernbach (cd.), Kar! Marx, The First lntanationul and A.fier: Political Writings vol. III (New York: Vintage). Marx, K . ( 1 8 7 1 [ 1986]), 'Tbe Civil War in France'. in K . Marx and F. Engels, Collected r·Vorks. Volume 22 (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Marx, K. ( 1 8 75/[1 974b]), 'Critique of tbe Gotha Programme', The Firsl International and A.fter (Hannondsworth: Penguin). Marx. Karl ( 1 935). 'The Critique of the Gotha Programme', in K , Marx and F. Engels, Selected Works, (Moscow: Progress Publishers). Marx, K . (1968). Korl Marx and Frederick Elfgeis: Selected Works (London: Lawrence and Wishart). Marx, K . (1973), Capital (Harmondsworth: Penguin). Marx, Karl ( 1976). Capital, Vol. 1 (Harmondsworth: Penguin). Marx, K . ( 1981), Grundrisse (Harmondsworth: Penguin). Marx, K . ( 1 983), Capital, Vo!. I (London: Lawrence & Wishar!). Marx. K. ( 1984), Capital, Vo\. 3 (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Marx, K . and F. Engels ( 1 845/6 [ 1 964]), Tlte German Ideology (Moscow: Progress Publi shers) . Marx, K . and F. Engels, ( 1 848 [1967]), The Communisl MallijeslO (London: Pelican).

362

t it

,

I

,

•

Bibliography

Marx. K. and F. Engels (1968). Selected Works in One Vc/urne (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Marx, Karl and Fr.iedrich Engels ( 1968a), The German Ideology (Moscow: Progress Publishers). Marx, Karl and Friedrich Engels (1969), Selected Works (Moscow: Progress Publishers). Marx. K . and F, Engels ( 1 975). Collected Works (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Marx. K. and F. Engels ( 1 977), Collected Works, Vo!. 3 (Moscow: FLPH). Marx, K., Enge1s, F. and V. Lenin (1975), On Proletarian internationalsm i and Bourgeois Nalionalism (Moscow: Novosti Press Agency Publishing House). Maslow, A. ( 1970), Motivation alld Personality, 2nd edn (New York: Harper & Row). Malhieu, Nicole�Claude ( 1977), Ignored by Some, Denied by Others: the Social Sex Category in Sociology (London: \Vomen's Research and Resources Centre). Mathieu, Nicole�Claude ( 1 980), 'Femininity/masculinity', Feminist Issues, 1 ( I ). _ Mayer , M . (1991), 'Politics in the Post-Fordist City', SocialiSl Review. 2 1 (I): 10;-24. Mayer, M . and R . Roth ( 1 995) , 'New Social Movements and the Tranforrnation to Post-Fordist Society', in M . Darrovsky, B. Epstein and R. Flacks (cds), Cultural Politics and Social Movements (phi ladelphia : Temple Univesi(y Press). Maynard, Mary ( 1 990) , -The re-shaping of sociology? Trends in the study of gender', Sociology, 24 (2): 269-·90. Maynard, Mary ( 1 995), 'Beyond the "big three": the development of feminist theory in the 1 9905', Women 's History Review, 4 (3): 259-81. McCarney, J. ( 1 990), Social Theory and the Crisis of Marxism (London: Verso). McCrone, D. ( 1 992). Understanding Scolland: The Sociology of a Stateless Nation (London: Routledgc). McDonough. Roisin and Rachel Harrison (1978), 'Patriarchy and relations of production'" in A. Kuhn, Annette and A. M . Wolpe (eds), feminism and Alateria/ism: Women alld Modes (�f Production (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul). Mc1ntosh, M . (1978), 'The stale and the oppression of women', in A. Kuhn and A. Wolpe (cds), Feminism and Materialism: Women and Modes of Produc rion (London: Routlcdge & Kegan Paul). McLellan, O. ( 1 983), 'Theoretical Roots of Liberal, Democratic, National Communism', i n H. Machin (ed.), National Communism in Western Europe: A Third Way Jor Socialism? (London: Melhuen). McLellan, D . ( 1 98;), Karl Marx: Selec!ed Wrilings (Oxford: Oxford 'University Press). McLellan. David (ed.) (1 977), Kart Man.:: Selected Writings (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Meadows, D. et at. (l972). The Limits to Growth: A Reporl for the Club of Romc 's Project on {he Predicament of Mankind (New York: Universe).

Bibliography

363

Mehring, F. ( 1938), The Lessing Legend (New York: Critics Group Press). Mellor, M . ( 1 992), Breaking the Boundaries: Towards a Feminist Green Socialism (London: Virago). Mellor. M. ( 1 995), 'Materialist Communal Politics: Getting from There to Here', in J. Lovenduski and J. Stanyer (eds), Contemporary Political Studies, VaL 3 (Belfast: Political Studies Association). Metzaros, I. ( 1980), The Marxist Theory of Alienation (London: Merlin). Mies, Mafia ( 1 986), Pafriarchy and Accumulation on a World Scale: Women in the International Division of Labour (London: Zed Books). Miliband, R. ( 1 965), 'Marx and the State', Socialist Register 1965, 278-96. Miliband R. ( l969), The State in Capitalist Society: An Analysis af the Western S}'stem of' Power (London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson). Miliband, R, ( 1 970), 'The Capitalist State ... Reply to Poulantzas', New Left Review, 59: 53-60. Miliband, R. ( 1 973), 'Poulantzas and the Capitalist State', New Left Review, 82: 83-92. Miliband, R. ( 1 9 77), Marxism and Politics (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Miliband, R. ( 1 983), Class POi'ver and State Power: Political essays (London: Verso). Miliband, R. ( 1 99 l ), 'Reflections on the crisis of communist regimes', in R . Blackburn (cd.), Ajier Fhe Fall (London: Verso). Miliband, R. ( 1 994), Socialism for a Sceptical Age (London: Verso). Mills, C. ( 1 986), 'Ideology in Marx and Engels', Philosophical Forum, XVI (4). Mintz, B. and M . Schwartz ( 1 985), The Power Structure of American Business (Chicago: University of Chicago Press). Mises, Ludwig von ( 1936), Socialisrn: An Economic and Sociological AnalysiS (London: Cape). Mishra, R. ( 1 984), The yVeIfare State in Crisis: social thought and social change (Brighton: Harvester Wheatsheaf) MitchelL Juiiet ( 1 975), Psychoanalysis and Feminism (Harmondsworth: Penguin). Modleski, Tania ( 1 99 1 ), Feminism I'vilhout Women (New York: Routledge). Molyneux, Maxine (l979), 'Beyond the domestic labour debate', New Left Review, 1 1 6: 3--27. Morris, P. ( 1 994), The Bakhtin Reader (London: Edward Arnold) Mouffe, C. ( 1 993), The Return of the Political (London: Verso). Mouzelis, N. ( 1991), Back to Sociological Theory: The Construction of Social Orders (Basingstoke: Macmillan). Mouzelis, N. ( 1 995), Sociological Theory: What Went Wrong? (London: Routledge). Mulberg, 1. ( 1 992), 'Who Rules the Market: Green versus Ecosocialist Economic Programmes', Political Studies, 30: 2. Mulhern, F. ( 1 9 8 1 ) , The Moment of 'S'crutiny' (London: Verso). Mulhern, F. ( 1 992), Contemporary ,\1arxist Literary Theory (London: Longmans), Murray, R. ( 1 985), 'Benetton Britain', Marxism Today, November: ( 1 66): 54 64. Nairn, T. ( 1 98 1 ), The Breakup of Britain, 2nd edn (London: Verso).

364

\

,

f t �,

f

if i.

Bibliography

Nelson, G, and L. Grossberg (eds) ( 1 989), Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture (London: Longmans). Nelson, G. and P. A. Treicher (eds) (1992), Cultural Studies (London: Routledge). Nicolaus, Martin ( 1 968), 'The Unknown Marx', New Left Review, 48. Nimni, E. ( 1 989), 'Marx, Engels and the National Question', Science & Society, 53 (3): 297-326, Nimni, E. (1991), AIarxism and Nationalism: Theoretical Origins of a Political _ Crisis (London: Pluto). Noel. A, (987), 'Accumulation, regulation and social change: an essay on French political economy', lnternalOtlal Organization, 4 1 (2): 303-33. Noel, A. (1992), 'Les fits respecteux de l'economerie', Cahiers de Recherche Soci% gique, 17: 107--23. Norris, C. (1990), What's Wrong with Postmodernism: A Critical Theory and the Ends of Philosophy (New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf). Norris. C. (1992), Uncritical Theory Pvstmodernism, Inlellecluals and fhe Gulf Wor (London: Lawrence & Wishart). Norris, C. ( 1 993), The Truth about Postmodemism (Oxford: BlackweU): Nove, A. (1986), Marxism and Really Existing Socialism (Chur: Harwood Academic Publishers). O'Brien, Mary (1981), The Politics of Reproduction (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul), O'eannor. J. ( 1 992), 'Socialism and Ecology', Society and Nature, 1 : I. O'Connor. 1. (1973). The Fiscal Crisis of fhe Slale (New York: St Martin's Press). O'Connor, 1 . ( 1991). "'External Natura'" Conditions of Production, the Stale and Political Strategy for Ecology Movements', Center for Ecological S'ocialism Working Paper }, University of California, Santa Cruz. O'Connor, J. ( 1 994), 'Is Sustainable Capitalism Possible?', in M. O'Connor (ed.) Is Capitalism Sustainable? Political Economy and the Politics of Ecology (London: Guilford Press), O'Connor, M . (ed.) ( 1 994), Is Capitalism Sustainable? Political ECOl1omy and the Polilics of Ecology (London: Guilford Press), O'NeiU, J, (1993), Ecology, Policy and Polilics (London: RoutJedge). OITe, C. (1974), 'Structural Problems of the Capitalist State: Class Rule and the Political System: On the Selectiveness of Political Inst.itutions', in K. von Beyrne (cd.) German Political Studies (Beverly Hills: Sage). Offe, C. (1975), 'The Theory of the Capitalist State and the Problem of Policy Formation', in L. Lindberg et al. (eds), Stress and Contradiction in Modern Capitalism (Lexington: D . C. Heath). Offe, C. (1 984), Contradictions of the Welfare Stale (London: Hutchinson). OIfe, C. (1991), 'Capitalism by democralic design? Democratic theory facing the- triple transition in East Central Europe', Social Research, 58, (4). OITe, C. and V. Ronge ( 1 975), 'Theses on the Theory of the State', New German Critique. 6: 1 37-47. Ohmae, K. ( 1 995), The End of the Nation State (London: HarperColIins), OIson, M and H . Landsberg (eds) ( 1 973), The No-Growth Society (London: Wohurn Press).

Bibliography

365

Pahl, Jan (1990), Money and lvlarriage (Basingstoke: MacmiIlan). Painter, J. ( 1 995), Polirics, Geography and Political Geography (London: Arnold). Pannekoek, A. ( 1 950). Workers' Councils (Melbourne: Southern Advocate for Workers' Councils). Paternan, Carole (1 988), The Sexual COlllraet (Cambridge: Polity). Pearce, D . E. Barbies and A Markandya ( 1989), Blueprilll for a Green Economy (London: Earthscan). Pearce, D . . K. Turner, T. O'Riordan, N. Adger, G. Atkinson, 1. Brisson, K. Brown, R . Dubourg, S . Frankhauser, A. Jordan, D . Maddison, D . Moran and 1 . Powell (1993), Blueprint 3 : Measuring Sustainable Development (London: Earthscan). Peck, J. and Y. Miyamachi (1994), 'Regulating Japan? Regulation theory versus the Japanese experience', Ellvironmeflt and Planning D: Society and .

Space, 12: 639-74. Peck, J . and A . Tickell ( 1 992), 'Local Modes of Social Regulation? Regulation Theory, Thatcherism and 'Uneven Development', Geoforum, 23 (3): 347-·63 . Pepper, D. ( 1 993), Eco-Socialism: From Deep Ecology to Social Jusiice

(London: Routledge). Perrons, D . ( 1986). 'Unequal integration in global fordism: the case of Ireland', in A. J . Scou and M . Storper (eds), Produclion, Work, Tedmology (London: Allen & Unwin). Petty, Celia, Deborah Roberts and Sharon Smith ( 1987), Women's Liberation and Socialism (London and Chicago: Bookmarks). Picciotto, S. ( l99l), 'The Internationalisation of Capita! and the lnternationaI State System', in S. Clarke (cd,), The State Debate (Basingstoke: Macmillan). Pierson, C. ( 1 986), MarxisT Theory and Democratic Politics (Cambridge: Polity). Piore, M . J. and C. F. Sabel (1984), The Second Industrial Divide (New York: Bask Books). Piven, F. F. and R . C]oward (J971), Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public Weifare (New York: Pantheou Books). Ple�hanov. G . (n.d.), Fundamental Problems of Marxism (Moscow: F L.P.H.). Plekhanov, G. ( 1 956), Art Qnd Social Life (London: Lawrence & Wish,rt). Plekhanov. G . (1961), Collected Philosophical Works, Vo!. 5 (Moscow: F.L.P.H.J. Podolinski, S: (1 880), 'Le Socialisme et l'unite des forces fisiques', Revue Socialiste, June. Polan, A. J. ( 1 984), Lenin and the Elld of Politics (London: Methuen). Po]lin, Robert (1 996), 'Financial Structures and Egalitarian Economic Policy',

New Left Review, 214: 26-6 1 . Popper, K . R . (1963), Conjectures and Refutations (London: Routiedge &

Kegan Paul). Popper, K. (1972), Conjeclures and Rejltlations (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul). Popper, K . R . ( 1980), The Logic of ScientifiC Discovery (London: Hutchinson).

\

\i ,,

366

�

Bibliography

Poulantzas, N, ( 1 969), The Problems of the Capitalist State', New Lefl Review, 58: 67,78, Poulantzas, N. (1973), Political Power and Social Classes (London: New Left Books), Poulantzas, N. ( 1 975), Classes in Contemporary Capitalism (London: New Left Books). Poulantzas, N . ( 1 976), 'The Capitalist State: A Reply to Miliband and Ladau', New Lefl Review, 95: 63-83, Poulantzas, N. (, l978a), 'The State and the Transition to Socialism' (interviewed by H . Weber), Socialist Review, 38: 9-36. PouJantzas, N. ( I 978b), State, Power, Socialism (London: New Left Books). Prawer, S . S . (1 976), Kar! Marx and World Literature (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Przewofski, A. ( 1 977), 'Proletariat into a Class: The Process of Class Formation from Karl Kautsky's The Class Struggle to Recent Controversies', Politics and Society. 7: 4. PrzeworskL A. ( 985) Capila/ism and Social Democracy (Cambridge: ,

Cambridge University Press).

.

.

�,

.:-

:

'.

j,

b

::

,!

, ,

,

..

,

j�

..

.. - ;, "'i

\: i ,

.­

i I, ! ,

Purvis, T, ( 1 995), 'Aboriginal Peoples and the Idea of the Nation', in L. Smith (ed.) issues in Archaeological Management.· a Reader (St Lucia: Tempus Pubikations). Putnam. H . (1981), Reasmr, Trulh and H;slOry (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Questions F6ministes Collective ( 1 981)) 'Variations on a Common Theme' (editorial to Queslions Fhninistes, 1), reprin ted in E. Marks and E. DeCourtivron (eds), New French Feminisms (Brighton: Harvester). Rakovski. M . (1978), Towards an East European MarxL'Im (London: Allison & Busby) , Ranney, A. (1975), Governing of Men, 4th edn (Hinsdale, IL: The Dryden Press). Ransome, P. ( 1992), Antonio Gramsci: A New Introduction (New York; Harvester WheatsheaQ. Renan, E, ( 1882[1990]), 'What is a Nation?', in H, Bhabha (ed.), Nation alld Narration (pp. 8-·22) (London: Routledge). Renner, K . (1978), 'Democracy and the Council System', in T. Bottomore and P. Goode (eds), Austro- .o//!lr'xism (Oxford: Clarendon Press). Renner. K . ( 1 978), 'Th� Development of the National Idea', ·in T. Bottomore and p, Goode (cds), Al/stro,Marxlsm (pp. 1 18-25) (Oxford: Clarendon): Resnick, S. and R, Wolff (1995), ' Lessons from . the USSR. Takin • . ... . Marxian theory the nex.t stcp', in B. ·Magnus arid S. CuUenberg (eds), Whither Marxism? Global crises in international per: