Dupont Analysis
Page 1 of 24
Dupont Analysis
DUPONT Analysis of Some Selected Indian Companies DUPONT Analysis of RON...
16 downloads
839 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Dupont Analysis
Page 1 of 24
Dupont Analysis
DUPONT Analysis of Some Selected Indian Companies DUPONT Analysis of RONW Ashok Leyland RONW PAT/NW
Profit Margin PAT/ SALES
Asset Turnover SALES/ TOTAL ASSETS
DUPONT
Asset Leverage TOTAL ASSETS/ NET WORTH
2004-05
2003-04
2002-03
20.02%
16.30%
12.40%
5.6%
4.9%
3.91%
Asset Turnover
142.9%
155.1%
250.3%
Asset Leverage
249.9%
213.48%
252.08%
RONW Profit Margin
DUPONT Analysis of ROCE
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 2 of 24
ROCE PBIT/CE
Profit Margin PBIT/ SALES
Asset Turnover SALES/ TOTAL ASSETS
Asset Leverage TOTAL ASSETS/ CE
DUPONT ROCE Profit Margin Asset Turnover
2004-05
2003-04
2002-03
15.9%
17%
10.1%
7.37%
7.29%
5.53%
142.9%
155.1%
126%
Asset Leverage
151.1%
150.2%
144.6%
Implications: The ROCE shows a declining trend except for the last year. This was largely due to decline in Profit Margins. The company has however tamed the buck by increasing the asset turnover to arrive at a better overall ROCE. The ROCE is not as good as NALCO (28%) but equivalent to that of STERLITE
DUPONT Analysis of ROTA
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 3 of 24
ROTA PBIT/TA
Turnover Revenues/Total Asset
DUPONT ROTA Turnover Operating Profit Current Asset Leverage
Operating Profit PBIT/ Revenues
Current Asset Leverage Sales / CA
2004-05
2003-04
2002-03
15.9%
17%
10.1%
125.8%
134.7%
143.5%
8.38%
8.39%
8.38%
223%
268.3%
229.3%
Bajaj Auto
DUPOT AALYSIS DuPont Analysis : Dupont Analysis is an approach to analyse the firm by evaluating inter relationships among many of the performance measures. In the Dupont Analysis we try to find out what are the factors/drivers that are causing the profits to move up. By identifying these factors/drivers we can concentrate on them and improve our efficiency. ROTA 2004 - 05
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 4 of 24
ROTA = PBIT / Total Asset 0.1311
PBIT / Sales
Sales / Total Asset
0.1895
0.7638
COGS / Sales
Expenses / Sales
Dep.n / Sales
Sales / FA
Sales / CA
0.7151
0.1624
0.0323
5.0284
2.2151
Salary / Sales
Sales / Debtors
Sales / Cash
Sales / Inventory
0.0434
32.5377
52.8214
25.5861
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 5 of 24
2003 - 04 ROTA = PBIT / Total Asset 0.1345
PBIT / Sales
Sales / Total Asset
0.2022 0.6652
COGS / Sales
Expenses / Sales
0.6728
0.1869
Dep/ Sales
Sales / FA
Sales / CA
0.0378
3.8592
2.3162
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 6 of 24
ROTA = PBIT / Total Asset 0.1275
2002 - 03
PBIT / Sales
Sales / Total Asset
0.1899
0.6715
COGS / Sales
Expenses / Sales
Dep / Sales
Sales / FA
Sales / CA
0.6475
0.1939
0.0411
3.2037
1.9299
Salary / Sales
Sales / Debtors
Sales / Cash
0.0572
24.9048
138.6367
Sales / Inventory 19.9957
ROCE 2004 - 05
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 7 of 24
ROCE 2002 - 2003 TA Chart 80000 75100 71482
70000
61939
60000 50000 40000 30000 20000 10000 0 2004-05
2003-04 TA ( mn)
2002-03
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 8 of 24
ROW 2004 - 05
ROW = PAT / W 0.1794
PAT / Sales
Sales / Total Asset
Total Asset / W
0.1337
0.7638
1.7571
Sales / FA
Sales / CA
Total Asset / Capital
Total Asset / R & S
5.0284
2.2151
74.2094
1.8621
Sales / Debtor
Sales / Cash
Sales / Inventory
32.5377
52.7728
25.5861
ROW 2003 - 2004
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 9 of 24
ROW = PAT / W 0.1917
PAT / Sales
Sales / Total Asset
Total Asset / W
0.1538
0.6652
1.8730
Sales / FA
Sales / CA
Total Asset / Capital
Total Asset / R & S
3.8594
2.3162
70.6344
1.9898
Sales / Debtor
Sales / Cash
Sales / Inventory
35.5131
59.8892
23.4709
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 10 of 24
ROW = PAT / W 0.1578
PAT / Sales
Sales / Total Asset
Total Asset / W
O.1295
0.6715
1.8148
Sales / FA
Sales / CA
Total Asset / Capital
Total Asset / R & S
3.2037
1.9299
61.2046
1.973
Sales / Debtor
Sales / Cash
Sales / Inventory
24.9048
138.6367
19.9957
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 11 of 24
DRL DuPont Analysis The three components of DuPont measure the profitability, efficiency and the degree of leverage of the firm. The DuPont chart makes an intra firm comparison among these three parameters for three years. The profitability of the firm as shown by the first component has decreased from 0.26 to 0.05 which is not good for the company. This can be further explained as a consequence of the increase in the cost of goods sold which is in turn due to the increase in raw material and labor costs. There is also a marginal increase in the marketing expenses which may not significantly affect profitability. Therefore the major causes for poor profitability are rising material and labor costs. The second component is indicative of the asset use efficiency of the firm. The asset turnover has decreased from 0.73 to 0.59. This shows a declining trend in the usage efficiency of the assets. When the DuPont chart is used to track down the area of concern, we can find that fixed asset turnover has remained fairly constant and in some cases even improved over the three years. However, current asset turnover is not so satisfactory. Even among the current assets, we can find that the ratio of sales to cash has been fairly consistent. Stock turnover has on the other hand declined and this is the reason for inefficient asset usage. Stock here implies both raw materials and finished goods. We can see that the stock turnover ratio has declined from 7.1 to 5.69 thereby causing resource inefficiency. The third component shows the degree of leverage of the firm. Though the ratio between total assets and capital employed has remained fairly consistent, on closer examination, one can find that there is a huge anomaly with respect to long term loans. There is a steep decline from 62 times to 11 times. This shows how the leverage of the firm has changed as a result of long term loans. The company has taken huge long term loans to finance its activities and this has rightly been reflected in the DuPont chart.
DU-POT CHARTS Tata Motors
ROCE-2005
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
Page 12 of 24
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 13 of 24
In case of Tata Motors Ltd. we can see that the RoCE was at 0.28 i.e. for every Rs.100 of CE the profit(PBIT) is Rs.23, in 2002-2003. this went up to 0.43 i.e. for every Rs.100 of CE the profit(PBIT) is Rs.43, in 2003-2004 and took a plunge in 2004-2005 when it went down to 0.33 i.e. for every Rs.100 of CE the profit(PBIT) is Rs.33. What seems strange is that the other ratios have been indicating a bull run for the company and this is the first ratio that the picture isn’t all that rosy as it seems to be. To analyze what is going wrong, we will have to scrutinize the balance sheet a little more closely. Immediately we’ll find that two components of CE have drastically gone up. The share capital has gone up, and complementing that increase, the long term debts have increased drastically. Though the secured loans have gone down, a big chunk of unsecured loans has come in. this rate of increase in CE is higher than the rate at which the PBIT has been increasing. This points at possibility of better corporate governance to boost up ROI on CE i.e. RoCE, and hence benefiting the Profit Generating Ability(PGA) of the company.
RONW – 2005
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 14 of 24
Tata Motors has been enjoying a steady increase in the RoNW last three financial years. However, there has been a slight slowdown in this increase in rate between the FY ended 2004 and the FY ended 2005. As can be seen in the balance sheet, the PAT as well as the PBIT has been increasing.
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 15 of 24
Therefore the only other reason why this could be happening is because of the increase in the share capital. This fact can be corroborated from the increase in the share capital as can be seen in the balance sheet.
ROTA - 2005
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 16 of 24
Tata Motors Ltd. has faced a situation similar to the previous ratio here. The RoTA has gone up in the FYs ended 2002-2003 and 2003-2004. Here
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 17 of 24
after seeing the balance sheet, we can find out the reason. The assets have been increasing at faster rate as compared to the PBIT. This is also proves another thing, the investment decisions of the company are not garnering enough profits.
8.0 DuPont Analysis: Hero Honda
8.0.1 Return on et Worth
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
Page 18 of 24
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 19 of 24
8.0.2 Return on Capital Employed
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 20 of 24
8.0.3 Return on Total Asset
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
Page 21 of 24
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 22 of 24
The return on Net Worth of Hero Honda is a staggering 63.95%, which is way above those of Bajaj & TVS. The major rise behind the huge RONW is the fact that the Net worth of Hero Honda is way lower as compared that of its competitors. The Net Worth of Hero Honda stands at Rs 1139 crore, out of which capital comprises of Rs 40 crore, whereas that of Bajaj stands at Rs 3694 crore. One of the strengths of Hero Honda is the efficient working capital management as a result its able to reduce its cost to the minimum extent possible. It has a policy of financing even its fixed assets by current liability. As a result it is using a source which either does not has any cost or if it has any cost its very minimum. The following important facts stand out from the Dupont analysis: Its cogs/sales ratio has fallen from 85% in 01-02 to 82% in 03-04. This reflects the large scale cost reduction measures initiated by Hero Honda. In this tough competition where selling price cannot be increased, cost reduction is the only option available for increasing the profits. Its sales/FA ratio increased from 925% in 01-02 to 1019% in 03-04. This shows that Hero Honda is able to generate more sales from same amount of Fixed assets. It shows that they are also undertaking measures to increase productivity, which is of utmost importance for survival in modern competitive world. Its sales/cash ratio has increased from 4166% to 16157%, which reflects the after effect of a sound cash management policy. The company is maintaining cash which is optimum, considering its future plans. The sales/debtors ratio has increased from 4522%in 01-02 to 13693% in 03-04, which shows the efficient credit and follow up procedure. Thus the company is ale to play with its creditors because o its position as a market leader and for other reasons as well, which in turn reduces the financing needs of the company. Sales/inventories ratio rose to 3186% in 03-04 from 2545% in 01-02, This is also the effect of working capital management policies. Similarly ROCE of Hero Honda is around 82% for last few years, whereas that of its competitors is hovering around the 20% level. This not only reflects the above proved sound working capital management, but also reflects the low debt policy of Hero Honda. The Long term Debt of Hero Honda for 03-04 is Rs 175crore whereas that of Bajaj has touched the sky high limit of Rs 1006 crore. It shows that Hero Honda is also not using its 2nd source of finance,i.e. Long term Debt. Thus it clearly shows that Hero Honda’s major source of finance is its current liabilities, which stood at Rs 1260.05crore which not only exceeds its current liability, but is also very close to crossing its figure of capital employed. This is a breathtaking fact, which shows the company is financing its fixed assets from its current liabilities. This can be risky as the company might face short term liquidity crisis in future. But the company is following with this because of its control over sundry debtors, whereby its able to realize funds from debtors at a very short notice. The above analysis gives us a light as to why Hero Honda is able to maintain its dominance in 2 wheeler segment for such a long period.
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 23 of 24
red to that from sale of goods.
The data used to calculate all the ratios used in DU PONT chart are shown below. DATA SALES PBIT TA FA CA CE OF LTL COGS EXP DEP INVENTORY DEBTORS CASH OTHER CA LOANS & ADV
2002-03 2704.53 203.97 1069.35 532.67 448.76 539.79 422.95 121.89 1858.68 583 79.91 214.07 52.21 82.46 0 100.02
TVS 2003-04 2820.21 215.74 1281.13 704.18 436.03 676.09 574.95 119.01 1855.17 705 79.89 216.66 51.9 18 0.19 149.28
2004-05 2875.91 201.24 1521.98 770.48 506.65 769.33 678.83 186.84 1981.42 683 89.63 233.23 34.56 73.87 0.29 164.7
2002-03 4159.08 789.71 6193.93 1298.22 2155.13 1523.34 3240.6 840.22 2692.75 806.52 171.15 207.98 167.03 30.02 59.44 1690.63
BAJAJ 2003-04 4755.17 961.33 7148.23 1232.07 2053.04 966.72 3693.62 1005.72 3199.22 888.58 179.89 202.56 133.94 79.37 45.48 1591.68
2004-05 5736.35 1087.07 8295.19 1140.83 2589.74 940.65 4134.34 1226.99 4102.08 931.43 185.36 224.17 176.34 108.68 68.53 2012.01
ANALYSIS TVS has a lower ROCE mainly because of low operating profit (PBIT) and comparatively higher capital employed. This has been the
recent trend in past 3 years when TVS is trying to expand and hence incurring more cost on it, as a result its non-trade investment is quite low as compared to other competitors who have been operating in market for a quit long time. PBIT/SALES is less for TVS mainly because of higher EXP/SALES as compared to the industry average. SALES/TA of TVS is more than the industry average mainly because of lower Total-Assets, which in turn is due to lower CurrentAssets.
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
Dupont Analysis
Page 24 of 24
SALES/CA is also quite high for TVS as compared that of Bajaj mainly because of lower amounts of ‘OTHER CA’ and ‘LOANS &
ADV’, or in other words, huge SALES/OTHER CA and SALES/LOANS & ADV. As explained earlier, Capital Employed of TVS is low mainly because it has low Net Worth and it has raised lower amount of Long Term Loans when compared with Bajaj.
http://home.ximb.ac.in/~ramana/AFDMCourseWeb/Dupont%20Analysis.htm
20-10-2010
