The Politics Of Aesthetics: The Distribution of the Sensible

R s

\ {\

N

r\ \J

x

r

i

= 'i z

+ i,

= ? i

= /

.5 - :. = =----=-^-

g3 i=

=,

l'.

=

ut'

:e ..=.:

7 - f

)

1';3 j=

. .!

t:.= E jr -. 3 " :t r

Y

qE'

zi

=-E

,-r' ? v

=.-_

-:-.: i-

--+ g -!9 E =,i 5, r-f

{

=

:.-

:==1zi--a

{\ - - '

c;': ;.e ! {. - =' - Ed

r.!s;

;?--:

: =

i?EIa4 E4

I -= - E *t '=7

t =

.5

.;

u€.:

zt'c't 7;=,.= ; r.: =

=

; td

u.:

i; 3- E >. €

a ..=

z= -c

a-

', ;v. , _

F:€>=

a

€ : x:

ql

t

+! L:-2t 9 a.-

a\=c :,l Y N

-

7,5-i: .42i .==! :i ! : E i . :

T:u':14

/"72

t*_ .e:= s'j,*r; =aJ

a'J: = - .;_: € .

L

i.= a !.=_ .I ir =:

2 :! /

s=t 7 - -:

l :*, =

:r

a u

"--r' .
': ar; L'1---c:

a . -9t - _ -: ! =.r

3

^. Y

i l =- ; 0 ^ a ^E. E 4

"'>FEsp-;?; E i ! ZYj+ a'j+ -'

=io--,-eo >...

i , ?9 = . !

T:-;g ;

I Y b= :=

f u i-+-Ly =:zi =='F.v,+ 3 iEE - x; '" i.X- .9: 1'-; ?, "a c dU : ' E w;9 c.E o c X =

3o-.-'=i2=nJP-

a

i;-r

at-.c, -

P E o-r r 9€

sF.szZY=vEi. s, dE

= i,I

P - e P =g oi 1 z € 3 y tr z"':

:X

:

a :'

a

}.Y

A

*".,.=.c.gi

^e l]N

y ''-

9

= b

C

G^g g€ 4il t'€'b

Ir=

U

:dE;ii];Es "5G=7dEc-=i.

F

-J :t F

{S$€rZEiE5

'ilsslavF, E c ' .! a L6 y Uu ." t T> . .-

'>

f NT H.6iT T PE - "X- i5. sf i, =-= a i ' to = ' r E- E c :u

; FX'b:i* 3= r ? ! EE"Ei .sS:€= = :Ji t 3& g.Es'r

i' i

f= F..:'l r# it.. t,..,

a..l i.''

\

N N

v

:*"€!tt.s

,:5:'': i

i,,

-^

!

'':tt1*;z

= . - = . 2 - : . i 2 = . Ea . z | 1 - - ' 7 - =

-

-

-

-

u

-

l;_a

c_1,+

-

t

:!-:::

-

!

i :i

_

a

=

t

7 ; ; t 7 i 1 z = r = i = i =i -=t=. - - f , i a: i. 7 : E ?,. = = J 7 = f " a- . 9 L F . i _ : 1 i 2 2 . ' =

" :"i I ? :+' t: = . t ; i r , f:= , ; € *7-: i ' = = i+ ,-?

t,iz::=tzi=Et=:!"12= 1: ii a =.i 1:4. *3 i,i=

._7::= iZ=, ZiE=| 1 =€

a=7=:1i!.--=2li"=i',

--:

t+-;:: r:,=]r;; -:1:

t+

ia-.,=G-a==l=i.:=t2.

= ?i?+;?if

= .

z =

i I t

:=',Zi;v=7=27+=,::

= )= a'z t i r t, =.":rz

i=S-,*E;_yE4Zi:i=z=

r

al'.ii77?;ei:zz=:iz ;:a=:".afr,II,a:?i

, =__=

a==_EiliiS:-lijE=i;

i

?i

=Z

= 2 i z :

,_;:i: t.pEiZ".:7 2_+:; 7?'= 3'.c ==

::F"_?+14+E+,i;€:t=

fi,iiiffi ;iE{:i; #*fff#ff =iiii€€;iis=:ii i;iE€ iii$iiftijifii;sE

ca,

Z L

L

E F

z c F

c t:

E L

:zii,ii*:+ii: j1;t17:;t:ii!:

i+iii *l=1*r;f*fi#g*;'f f'gff

a? 'F.\ .r{

sisiiff;iiiiig i;i;#*isfi $ ffffiffffjffi*iir{

!:,F!:i? isijjijii{tE:t:irj

iti;i?ii \\

' s( :{ \

*\ *S (.-, (\ -\ q

s' hJ \

t'l

\\ \) V \ \

\ *s *s \\

\

a

sr

s ".r{ s-\ FJ

*S S.

\\ '\i

\) f\


rC

d

-!

.:

>-g

o

U

E .E

ft

- = -,

F

6(

'-q

p3

!U

UL

L

qU

c

U

:

=' =i +:7+ i=,,i;i'+ ; il-=:i;=riiS ! :izi/z' :=*zi,Eii;=tiij"i s;!i':iti+; ;t,E}E==E js{ j igI€ Eit'z;++E ;E EX; R;.i; ri*irsi,

f\ -i

I

E

Z

-: z. = F

Q F l' h

a

(, -

F *..t

F

N

i-Z;t i=i+7: Z:?!ti: : ! ii ;i z;r'ia:12;:Z:i

ii+!::!i:1;+jE17..!,t;i E i;1i:1=zi ; :ii= i :,+1'z ! =:==-i== l?= :, 2 t=t7i 7 : i : ;i:;j :j :j,!i;1,1;1r:: ;i :ii:;;i=Ei,

Ei€iii tgl f;iiiilii?is:Ef liiii* zizi li'izrilE=#113t*? rizr+|ziiEi+z;i??1",iiiE jt*i

illLltiii; ?:n E zli:;lll\t*iii EE|| ;r i+:r :*i;fsEEliii ii *liei ir I i;g li ii:Biil iil t?l lii i li;E i$s itjf:i;i:t:ijii;iliIi?ili iiiiE:

a. -..1

!

z T E

r

il x

q

:r L

U F rt E F tu

o (, F

E F

oo N

iil?1f i:*:,t1*t1j;*i{zt

i=::;Eii1";=z-it::i:=i,;=;::;

1==i=:=i:,*ii;i=1:4zli+/1

z i:,1;',?z= :jz :l; :1::z:i::21 z€i::!:=*i :i E:i i E:, : = i =

::=::.; i:: :i:ii:; r?i: ::=. r Lil;tilll:i:*tE+: :i ; Eg;i E;i : ::i zi,*,i

O F l. F

F.

O F Fl

F

cO

si

\-_

a

' l-\ +,.J U

s

t\

\ \,\\ t\ N

L

\J

\Ti

\) bn ,\ ' n!. . r tr ti

\ b '\

> =

i: i14 !; f +: t tE++r

7e:iz_-=jE::2.::Ef l= E.l -.=.=:.= ?= a 3':

zar+;E=,:+i;4 Ei+i

ji€ ffi lt+ilizr;i 6 P

l=; r ! 3==E

E'F 6 U c - 6 F.g Fq'q,

EilE I* il*; i;'=!g!

-

=:12izt

:,=i4iiiiii:iiEi rFit€:€?!; ij!r:; *"jif :f iE+ieTrE+

i:€Ijiif r*i i;j; I

€ l+i; *::.E€r rEgE€sS

a

; Z f

r

r 7 F

:

F

t

F

U F F

E

o (.) F J

l. F

N cO

? 7'zZi'A, ? t

;fii{;ziEjii?ij iif?ji iiiitsltl iiiigi lii*{:i*i+illllii*lii;i=

ltltftiE

r;,!i?irisiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii* iiiiii gEg?* izii u lr€ i i, *ii fii ; iiegiiit ie i;t i

I F s.l f

F u< U -J

l-t F

cO

'ql

.$

F.\

6.. sr '

b

N

:N

\ +-_

a

sr S.

lL{ N!

s

L\

: t-i

l}r \

ii:ii::iitit"t**!1+z

=:Z i:=i=;iz i;+-z i7:€ ; : ii'*?: 122=:2 Y i-z i ?ii zi+EY2;; t"+=,,;r.1

rE€f :

;i 7ZZ ii 1:e:i =;:=: ?' :;i ?i ==;ai;+ i:i;t-,*,:t; t ; z:+ziiii z:l !ei,;ii+=i? t i-,, ;i'ri iiZva-,Ez;i ZZ i;! gEE : i* ; =2;"s*:{?Y=

:s;zie+ !FFT* *:,:i;t€j,:

i ii i g:ijirs i*v1li;a+;i; Ef-'+tei ;?"ilig;

*ril: E;;j*t[ ;:E-:"i:gisr?;+:;i?E?

j jt iitA:i;ji,i:;;+:giig*j:j; ii,iE;

iliiti'irE filltfiiiii€g;gBsti{E+ iia;riii?r;ai aiEE" i€; , it; iEi ! s:-;+ e+b:r r -:t:+:i.ii;s*i!;E:fi€i+*gt=a

i* f;3€ 3v= i s.*q"fj=ue;> i:t g E: zEz"ri e€-

ii,=js+g+i+{FE-;€ ;:€+=i ;Fi{* E€Hi€;E

zi 7 t;

r I

lz z-'iz v ""2 v g: e: ti'Z:

C

t=

t=

u,.

ft

a

c r)

d

'o -iiU

c C

'1 -v

U

ft

a)

>-

.E

a

=

; - c--o tr

)\c

U

(!

C)

^n!

dX d

-at

'-

.: )-

do

^

.= (_)

i+iij?zliiliti*t'iiiitJ! 7 a-t 7;z =iV

G

:

li r EEi=

-

1O U

?j E;EE igfgtiiiiStii+: ii!i.'i;bi;? t]*Elca

7 i i+iilXEiZi ziEIEZT]bi z4i !'11z i:lig ys:7= i t Pi1,?i: e

itE:, jj PF ei +EE

jr

=3t :'i= ?=r= =e-

r ; :?ib;:-i+:= gt:*:ii;:g+;,E i i : ti g€ : jrEi;+tfF; i=ii

6

.U

!

4bl

(6 ! r !(

2 GN

!>

-

; I !1rVliiEZtZ*I E'=i=E i;::= s rit r*1;?iFt*E;ii i rr==;

j;if iif i€i;*'ti;f ! g?"rYiiiEj ; ; t :;=x ; -t$i;j;;:i: ;;;

-o

*I i ; i;t iZi 1;E i?:t =ii€ = ;5i;*ir=,r:i€ tfjj#rrfF;j;it5:

'p

fi

LU

c -, =o0>

a (J,

,9

!

qil

- G l { .u^

I:iiifr;3€ljil;:{jj;, ; F;iriEtegEf d

t r=;j€i: l; :st*;s*jr?+=:+ iz vr::s

3 si*t:; r;*{:;€r-;6igIf l;:r i secr:

t

c\

z q

T F q

Z

c --

r

-7

til1lit4ltiir:ilttiXitlg

j;?ii;Etl?li4i lllet:i:tl,tti i+;4'{11fi$iZi?ai'i: iisiiii;*+;i=u{fiiiifiiz j;fi;ji iiiiE iiijEtiFiEsf iffE f ij ff i if i FF

- (L-E 7

v rt

u \. u,c i

"

!-.

'> P - . - l - ! - I ' 7

l:= 3 \ !

-

-

r

-

U i,^

C

tsn+

*\+

Ettt

u

= ; 7 7- c F -

c =-E r=t

> )..^'i.-

u - =p,: : ' e

=;.C-.'.J=

t: -/'U:'!+

i-

9

.:,.-l:X

" - -= t : - . Q

y -: e

- \ - ' ai - ! u v

_a

^

!a-UL': - >. \". 7 i==y-

,; G

Y

Zit+"{'Eiti11:?!iii*:ii1!i,}

E:itziii ii1,*i*i+;lrl *\t*ti 3gi ii; i ilj iiitilii?ggi9j iiriit:E ij i,*iiii* iilij :tiIgiiiiii i;i+E iig3ij *isiii ?ii I3ili€

-

-

: 1 = - - i z - 1 + = -i 1 ? ? . = z = : = I i1i=-

= = 24,=+,i t.1==

:7::i' = : i:i i ?t;i:i1;1ii1+i17';i:'i11:i

iii,:lali *12:.i:1=+t+ii1,i#

{t+ifi jiii#ii=t1;iii+ii:, ilz zizci?ii:;i7i11:itz i;i iil*ti{;v*iliij ili;ilil+r'i1liii{ !;iiiv N

x

>+ sr

t\

bJ \ +*\ \ \

r*'r* =-: !:?;'z 1:

i a a !,= ;

*:.

'..r :. \s t. -\

N\

\: \. ' \ \i Y

\CJ

.S S i:^r':

(\

.d s=

'N

\q

\st \ rlY

\,e I G(

FTN

.\ < \:. \:

tt

ssl\i

\

r i i !::"Si i =;::z : ;=:='t=ti; =i i ;i*:\:: =:==;:i: -= :r?'=i;:

1i=?ii=: ii :: :i i s 1-li-=_t|i

( ii::iif : 72.;;r=1i;=+ i

== i iisit:: ;}1!Z:1=,Zi!;? H: i*-t ;t: :.= =, t;== e'z i iv ;_=,; = ;;";izZa+?" ;a i:ri;ili i=---

== i :: -] i i: 11+ -z .:=+2 =?11:it

::i==-ii

eiZirii?'=Ea;: iil= : i : ; i i I: i*: s:: Zvi;+==i= y : I =*;= +

i

F ? r

= ss =i si\r .:::;itzEIT:12=7 i v!::2ri!=;::/: :iT ili:tS ji=:;i -,j.iP, -,ti

r s:iYt!..:,=i;*€E=t:?ii:=

t

7

--

n Z

= ; -

? a I

7

-

F

q

F

T

F

(,

:l

i : i+z :'7*iil:= =::::i: a:i::;{?;,:=i

tiiiiii:3:iiiiilliltttjsl* it;futi atl; :ltI:tiilii?ii gl;lgiis l+ giii r+t;iiF,! ii iiiijitii: t;iIiiit*: I!1=,;i9= ;iti;$j:;$t;i; iyi ef;ii1rjli€ iz;#ii:=!i1!111*1 ligiii is'lj ;j ritiiiii:iiii*9€ Iiri?l :€

7.

: e :: v, = z !

-

3 lj

-: 7.

'l

U F F

o F a l. F

N

lil1;i1+ii:,1; ii 1i4 iiiEl+{lilliti il gj lltiii;g?tgi ti:*iist t*; ?jg;as ifi =

,iziiEz/i:i=*1*:!:iiii

;:1rl;12:=;:;i1';1::71;:

t:i!!':i;+1+:11I::7'2

= :itiui7,

1!i :=1::ii zt::i;t ;1;iiz:; ;'eitiiitt; E.E

I

L

F

r

ci

-

-

Z

r:.

!

-

Fl

U F

r-) i. F

' Siiss iffij;i*g;stsrgsi;;iiii a I

; E-":

r^:.-i

.-r-e-,-L!.--5

q'

Z--."

F

-

-

FU?: *

-

* 9 . :

-'\*r'

, > .-. -.-e,. --a-

-

l'=--u

_-: -i';-

/

Y

='=

tr'-

r'-.-

t'-

^

a-.

u'=

E a

7cr

r t

g i r -

- L

.=

a

-a

a'

a t a

I'

= .:

c

a a

o

il

-

c

U

C

-

a v c-

-t

c u 2

a)

x)

a

C)

O

a

c

c

U

U c- c-

o-

( ?

i

c

-a

a

U

(

-

a

-

N

=

u

> ( ot. a

-=i

r>

,F

q

1,.1

: ?

t

! ;

,'l

a

:;_a

-.;

lE i=i'i : i : i=:-i; ; : i =:=+a= t-:: 21,

lli='il,1i4;li1::{ : i,=ii=E==2:77=r,-i=j : : i,;.+ =

?i:=;' i;zi: i;:;:i ;;

u

llliltz?gj :is:ii i*:*1*9ji; lii .

U-

,\)

-

OU

--t

>Y

.r=

€5

€-

3

!

,'I d!

>!

!

c':

ts

:

o-

c-y

F

tf*1+j1#|;1i;ut+tl ! hrc i-

\-

c\€ .{t:

i

7. !

; U Z

cr

=

F

(i F F q

qi

(-) -

F-.1

F

F

:11= Z;i;ii{zzi3i 1izi;1:i +riii:;1:i:il :t j::=::1 I

:,: :: ,2il,7!=Z;+7:;ri ::i+= i j:it,it1li:zilF;l*=i{!i;;=izi

,!1{}-lzlfz:;t+it=;::i;t

jij jli!ig t11l41zl1ri11i41

Iit il*tt*iit ii; i iSsi =iisit li;1r ii :tEffliiiii illliil?l; ii:iiiiliigtisiiislsrsi;ii F

\.

Z

I

q a

r

L

Z

U F tF Ei !l

F ': 5

F

N

\o

t=i{tt'l.ia::i:11?'= tlia]=ii 1:iiiz+i*:17 r:'+z; :,,t::i j:z*i#tt+;s1 {i*ixii;iiiiiSis =i;j:1=s7==: i i i : i: tTi:ii:=iit':t;:!iZ=:

{tit**isiitfifittziiit;i j; iiiiiiiiiiiiiiigr iliiii';:iii?*iis F

\9

-t

z trl

A-

F r

/ r L

z

U F. F

a

U

-

r

F

-$

' - r - - -

-

't

-

-

'!-a

.-E

t

-

'

' J

:

L

9 y

,,. J e l r n t , t -

u

-

t

e

!

\

>, d

;

?'\)

U-: ./ r \

:5fi

ye

r

c-a

-:;il:l v .: r'

:

J

L - - L l w

: : ,

:1?;ii,11,i z+{:\i1ti';; i ri+ S;: ti ?i: :t : i: {* z=1 zlZZi :*i i :1. : i l_=

-

:l e

,---

-:l

C -

-:

=-..+.i .we:C7/ eJ

-

, f

r

a

'-D., ts(, a -

,

u,*.rc+

.t =:= = U r--a r ;lu-tr"J

-

v

- u - , - - J - / t t '

J

;- - ,

e

,.

D

-'

!.

j;i i3ilzttz{Si+i??iilii#{,illtil#{.1ilti#1 t{iil,gi i1ilit eigi ;i:i1*1{fiff \Ei3s s:iig;E ffiiii;iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiri fii *

U F q T F

t!

O F !

o F

: ! ^

c-)

- = 't:

-E

L i -

U

-cU

c-c

u

*v >N

ta hJ

\

\TT'

a=

N

\ \

s

$

*S'

-\

q

*

: r.r ,t.\

d.:

v.

5D9

oa -E

s

Eo

=qQ)

9i

FB9 6'-

6

:iJ

,, u .^

U

.:-o

l)

-ru c,a

a

\ S. /\

'Ft (J S N

\-_

a

ii

d

\) \] \ t\

:=i=j:;=:; i t: ;:z:ii=?:7=:ii=z=,

t;;E!iE =1i; |::=t;z1+i i::;itz; Zi

!,*t:tltri++:*u11r

lzz:;: j;ji:izi1;:izz:iz ;t.tlii;sExLi,il;iiilii

a

i

-Z2L;:-Ej =i ?'z==i+:i

':Vi'Z:

':'?22-,"t'j.'=

i',i +!;= ==rl i.1-:+t ::,-1== i:,i:,==,

il;i€ i i1i11l:zt?:?=t774 i:?i;:i:: :i|?ilu:,rlzZ1{+?**zin

i ;E=r:: :?: I;i;: :igj* :,?,ile*;t?Iir5;

iji;ij;!i::ii:!+11=zt;tz

T

e

r

=rj7:i, =i:;=t j Ei+, z73r::t; LititT:,t ,i :

t :a1i'tl:: ; riri!1===+ i;+=;:=i:1';=z7=li

: ;= +i:: r+=2 II; !7'=n !=" ii ':! c74::= zi l;i::t1:: :;tt:} :: i

i :i :;=:t+i::;::7:1i :,: :i i

;li:,2**i=+i*ii;17zii3i

#ll iil it;i,ttir ,jilfliifi#f?tita

itl}Zli3 i3iI'i\?EEs': E;?i-jEE;*s?i fiil

iijiiiiiili;i:ii{E\i\\ iiiiiiif l;#i:;illlli!;lrljt+er11 @

'ii1;:iz?ii*t'iiii+*ili1:r

j i*,=i1='li*t=.t"t4ttt j1t47l1i{1i4i111 jsll:t ij

Nlliiff *;ljiri: *

t. f-

'N >\.

x

lfl

!:

(/ F F

q

o F

F

N

t,::i;:=1;: !=ia,:il:tEi1::?i: :!i:*=

z:iil*j{+:;t1:11=}::it:i

t=zz;+i:i+#:i1;zt;i

-U .

-

-q.Y

>:

. i

9X 4{")

-c.-

)

U

\ -E :, ' ; c-

.d U

O

>. u

\

*{i

-q tr

-E

"!

'7

-

o-

u

t- . G R

^\ I

=' tr

CJ

E U

o tr

t:ti;ii*I;iitztilillil

t:I+iii3:g p: {ilii# :zi:i iiti,*ir *ii I ula)

o-, e a ! !

iql. !

!

: !

3 L ' " , t

x>

^+

C.Y

!-

M

>ilI O:Y: -.u;1 u-:

ccc^ t

a

+. q,

E*a

-o -=d -.-

tr.

9,

Y

d

F " . ' -F r

!.'Je

'6t

v,

OJ O

v.. L V ?' .-: v q &.rv. -4.1 I-!.+ \!s o

YUVC Lr.O *ar.u :!

*n

.' :p /.-i.

=

$

3\

r.

'\ '\

T.

-

(, F F r U F Fl

c L

t'-

t,: =2 i. i7

E

=: =7_

:t_=_4 1!=

.

j t Zi32i+ ?=:=77"i, =o :, E = : i====i= 7

::==i :: : != a =4=-= _a :=3= ta 7'-='-: ? = =' zt 1,..-):-az 4:,; : L: = 1:: := t= = = ; ;

u=ii:z =t i: i =,=.,1+ z L?ii i7 : =74 2 i =z

?i=

:Z

: -7 -

=-;i

t ? t: aa=i

? - 1 . == : i Z = -==: r': ', -=

2 Q'=E-?2,ii tE i:; :=a?t,t; ; i 7 zQ-. i = 7 :z i : :==i_az: -=l . : ;:t:1 I i;:==Z=-ztr.'i r'?.;:: '

:72','*= 2 Z::i;3 i+a . ?; zi z -*i:.-=.;;ZTi, =_i;=t_!,=. a*+ 7 t1 ::=Z tili i -=: j7; i z ;

z3+;i, =.=?;,o74 i i =,;;t a ?i: :

+i2;I: :;===;f =3' Ft=a=::l:s =,; j ; ; ; i !-i-?==r i it"E 2 *i4, 1 : :', ' . 1 ? V | = = t I : ; : = r t . 7 p . . 7 ' i- = = -;i: 7 v zd '- = .':E i,**E1i tii= *4.t7'-=

I { E= i = j Z j,t i g =4 }i;_2=:, ?; :; . Z ;4.= = = i r -J ===_ i - 1..'v_ 7 | *E c.i: -,

i+; i =: i : ?:'-i=,:: ==+i=i=, i i s7 ?e.4

+3 a*-E+ 3 €€ ;p :t ! :ElZ3;

j::i:ii;:1,iii4:it\ !:=t*i*=,=;;Ztlu: 1::t{; TriiZZ;:i alljr;!-*;EiE;,i}2:i1;;S

*i*ltllliill**tl{ilili:itl

G

'ta

'4,

--

q q

I

_,i

,_

:-

-

-

!

J

-

a

_

ii =Z=, 1 ',!==:. ,: J, ts

=

ii

=

r

-

i

I

>.=

/

t

_,.