Neurobiology of Human Values

:-;-):+0)6,8-:;8-+-;16 6-=:7;+1-6+-; .WVLI\QWV1X[MV -LQ\WZ A^M[+PZQ[\MV.WVLI\QWV1X[MV8IZQ[.ZIVKM -LQ\WZQIT*WIZL )TJMZ\)O]IaW5K/QTT=VQ^MZ[Q\a5WV\ZMIT+IVILI 8PQTQXXM)[KPMZ-KWTM6WZUITM;]XÈZQM]ZM8IZQ[.ZIVKM )TIQV*MZ\PWb+WTTÇOMLM.ZIVKM+6:;=8:8IZQ[.ZIVKM 2MIV5IZQM*M[[WV16;-:5=8IZQ[.ZIVKM -UQTQW*QbbQ5I[[IKP][M\\[1V[\Q\]\MWN<MKPVWTWOa*W[\WV=;) )VLMZ[*RÕZST]VL=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN4]VL;_MLMV 1ZI*TIKS=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN5MLQKQVM,MV\Q[\ZaWN6M_2MZ[Ma8Q[KI\I_Ia=;) .TWaL*TWWU;KZQXX[+TQVQKIVL:M[MIZKP.W]VLI\QWV4I2WTTI=;) 2WÊT*WKSIMZ\+MV\ZM+6:;16;-:5LM8PIZUIKWTWOQM-VLWKZQVWTWOQM  5WV\XMTTQMZ.ZIVKM 8QMZZM*][MZ1V[\Q\]\LM[6M]ZW[KQMVKM[8IZQ[.ZIVKM 2MIV8QMZZM+PIVOM]`+WTTÇOMLM.ZIVKM1V[\Q\]\8I[\M]Z8IZQ[.ZIVKM +IZT+W\UIV=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN+ITQNWZVQI1Z^QVM=;) ;\M^MV,]VVM\\=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN+IUJZQLOM+IUJZQLOM=3 /MWZOM.QVS5MLQKIT:M[MIZKP+W]VKQT-LQVOJ]ZOP=3 .ZML/IOM;ITS1V[\Q\]\M4I2WTTI=;) 2IKY]M[/TW_QV[SQ+WTTÇOMLM.ZIVKM8IZQ[.ZIVKM +TI]LM3WZLWV16;-:5=!8IZQ[.ZIVKM 5QKPMT4IKW]Z+6:;=:)5IZ[MQTTM.ZIVKM 5QKPMT4M5WIT16;-:5=!*WZLMI]`.ZIVKM /IZa4aVKP=VQ^MZ[Q\aWN+ITQNWZVQI1Z^QVM=;) *ZMVLI5QTVMZ5K/QTT=VQ^MZ[Q\a5WV\ZMIT+IVILI 2WPV7TVMa?I[PQVO\WV=VQ^MZ[Q\a5MLQKIT;KPWWT;IQV\4W]Q[=;) )TIQV8ZQ^I\16;-:5=5WV\XMTTQMZ.ZIVKM )TTMV:W[M[,]SM=VQ^MZ[Q\a5MLQKIT+MV\MZ,]ZPIU=;) +WV[\IV\QVW;W\MTW16;-:5=8IZQ[.ZIVKM 2MIV,QLQMZ>QVKMV\1V[\Q\]\)TNZML.M[[IZL+6:;/QN[]ZA^M\\M.ZIVKM *Z]VW?QTT+MV\ZMLM6M]ZWKPQUQML]+6:;16;-:5=  ;\ZI[JW]ZO.ZIVKM

28+PIVOM]` ):,IUI[QW ?;QVOMZ A+PZQ[\MV -L[

6M]ZWJQWTWOa WN0]UIV>IT]M[   ?Q\P.QO]ZM[IVLMZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO6M_AWZS 1;*6 ! ;XZQVOMZ>MZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO6M_AWZS 4QJZIZaWN+WVOZM[[+WV\ZWT6]UJMZ"! MZTIO>QWTI\QWV[IZMTQIJTM NWZXZW[MK]\QWV]VLMZ\PM/MZUIV+WXaZQOP\4I_ ;XZQVOMZ>MZTIOQ[IXIZ\WN;XZQVOMZ;KQMVKM*][QVM[[5MLQI [XZQVOMZWVTQVMKWU ˆ;XZQVOMZ>MZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO 8ZQV\MLQV/MZUIVa



MZTIOXX -LMTUIV/5!!*ZQOP\IQZJZQTTQIV\âZM"WV\PMUI\\MZWNUQVL6M_AWZS"*I[QK*WWS[ /PQ[MTQV5! 0]`TMaMZTIOXX ;QVOMZQ[Q\WZ[\W\PM1UXMZQIT+WTTMK\QWV[I\\PM6I\QWVIT5][M]UWNIT]M[ ˆ;XZQVOMZ>MZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO

   .ZIV[*5LM?IIT TMaZMITQbML\PI\\PMTI_[WN\PMXPa[QKIT_WZTLIZM]VIT\MZIJTM0MNMT\PW_M^MZ \PI\\PMQZQUXIK\WVP]UIVM`Q[\MVKMKW]TLJM[WN\MVMLIVLUWLQâMLXZW^QLML XMWXTM SMX\ VI\]ZM ]VLMZ KWV\ZWT 0M KWUXIZML ][ _Q\P I OIZLMVMZ _PW PI[ I PIZL\QUMSMMXQVO_MML[W]\WNPQ[OIZLMVMZJMMSIVLLM?IIT)VM`\MV[Q^MZM^QM_WNZMKMV\KPQTL [\]LQM[Ja>MZJMMSM\ITKWVâZU[\PI\\PMLI\ITWWSM[[MV\QITTa\PM[IUM NWZ KPQTLZMV KPQUXIVbMM[ UWVSMa[ IVL OWI\[  )N\MZ âOP\[ QVLQ^QL]IT[ KWUM \WOM\PMZ UWZM \PIV VWZUITTa WN\MV _Q\P QV\MV[M KWV\IK\ XI\\MZV[ LWQVO [W M[ XMKQITTa_Q\PXIZ\VMZ[_PWU\PMaVMMLNWZWVMZMI[WVWZIVW\PMZIT]IJTM:MTI\QWV[PQX0aXW\PM[Q[_PQKPKIVJMNWZU]TI\ML\P][" t:MKWVKQTQI\QWV_QTTWKK]ZM[XMKQITTaJM\_MMVQVLQ^QL]IT[_PW[\IVLU]KP\WTW[M QN \PMQZ ZMTI\QWV[PQX LM\MZQWZI\M[u MZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO

   0IVVI,IUI[QW

.QO58.+QV\PQ[LQ[WZLMZ')VL_PaQ[IVMUW\QWVIT QUXIQZUMV\IVWJTQOI\WZaIKKWUXIVQUMV\'58.+ZMOQWVQ[VMKM[[IZa NWZ\ZQOOMZQVOUW[\WN\PM[ITQMV\[WKQITMUW\QWV[Q\[N]VK\QWVITZWTMQV\PQ[ZMOIZL JMQVOISQV\W\PI\WN\PMIUaOLITIZMOIZLQVONMIZ1V\PMIJ[MVKMWN[XWV\IVMW][ [WKQITMUW\QWV[MIZTaWV[M\>58.+XI\QMV\[_W]TLJMLMXZQ^MLWNVWZUITQV\MZ IK\QWV[_Q\PW\PMZ[IVL_W]TLJM\PMZMKQXQMV\[WNXW\MV\QITTaIJVWZUITZMIK\QWV[ NZWU W\PMZ[ 1\ _W]TL JM LQNâK]T\ NWZ \PM[M aW]VO XI\QMV\[ \W IKY]QZM I VWZUIT ^QM_WN[WKQITQV\MZIK\QWV[OQ^MV\PM[ML]ITTaXMZ\]ZJMLZMTI\QWV[PQX[ *]\\PM>58.+Q[TQSMTa\WXTIaIVW\PMZZWTM\PI\WNITMIZVMLZMXW[Q\WZaWN \PMTQVSJM\_MMV[Q\]I\QWV[KITTQVONWZILMKQ[QWVIVL\PMW]\KWUM[WNLMKQ[QWV[ WV\PMWVMPIVLIVLWV\PMW\PMZ\PMMUW\QWVIT[\I\MI[[WKQI\ML_Q\P\PM[Q\] I\QWV[ WZ _Q\P \PM ZM[]T\ WN \PM LMKQ[QWV[ 58.+ _W]TL PW][M \PM ZMKWZL WN\PMTQVSIOMJM\_MMVt[Q\]I\QWVIVLI[[WKQI\MLMUW\QWVuWZtW]\KWUMIVLZM []T\QVOMUW\QWVu?PMVI[Q\]I\QWVWN\PM[IUMKI\MOWZaI[WVMXZM^QW][TaM`XM ZQMVKML_W]TLXZM[MV\Q\[MTN\PM>58.+_W]TLOMVMZI\M\PMMUW\QWVXZM^QW][Ta I[[WKQI\ML_Q\P\PI\KI\MOWZaWN[Q\]I\QWVIVL_Q\P\PMW]\KWUMWN\PMLMKQ[QWV Q\ XZWUX\ML 1V \PQ[ ZWTM \PM >58.+ Q[ WVKM IOIQV I \ZQOOMZ ZMOQWV NWZ MUW \QWV[M`KMX\\PI\PMZM\PM\ZQOOMZQ[VW\IVM^WT]\QWVIZQTaM[\IJTQ[PMLMUW\QWVITTa KWUXM\MV\[\QU]T][[]KPI[\PM[]NNMZQVOWNIVW\PMZ_PQKP\ZQOOMZ[KWUXI[[QWV :I\PMZ\PM\ZQOOMZQ[I[\QU]T][TMIZVMLJa\PM[]JRMK\QVPQ[WZPMZXI[\M`XMZQ MVKMIVL\PM\ZQOOMZMLMUW\QWVUIaWZUIaVW\JMI[WKQITMUW\QWV  *W\PQVMIZTaWV[M\IVLIL]T\WV[M\>58.+TM[QWV[\PQ[WXMZI\QWV_W]TL JMXZMKT]LML58.+_W]TLWXMZI\MJaIK\QVOWVW\PMZ JZIQV [\Z]K\]ZM[ VIUMTa \PM ,48.+ _PMZM _M [][XMK\ [QOVITQVO NZWU >58.+ XTIa[IZWTMQVZMI[WVQVOIVLLMKQ[QWVUISQVOLQZMK\TaWZ^QI\PMQV\MZUMLQIZa IK\QWVWN[]JKWZ\QKITZMOQWV[MOIUaOLITI1VW\PMZ_WZL[\PMt[WUI\QKUIZS MZu [QOVIT M^WSML QV >58.+ _W]TL LMXMVL WV KWV\ZQJ]\QWV[ NZWU []JKWZ\QKIT [\Z]K\]ZM[IVLM`MZ\Q\[ZWTMQV\PMO]QLIVKMWNJMPI^QWZ^QI\PMZMOQWV[WV_PQKP ZMI[WVQVOQ[TQSMTa\WLMXMVL\PMUW[\OQ^MV\PMQZZWTMQVPQOPMZKWOVQ\QWV"\PM ,48.+ IT]M[ ˆ;XZQVOMZ>MZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO

   )V\WVQW,IUI[QW _I[KWV[\ZIQVMLIVLWZQMV\MLQVKMZ\IQVLQZMK\QWV[JaXZMM`Q[\QVOJQWTWOQKITKWV LQ\QWV[ 1\ LQL VW\ MVRWa QVâVQ\M NZMMLWU 1V VW _Ia LWM[ \PQ[ ^QM_ ZML]KM \PM UMZQ\WN\PMQV\MTTQOMV\KWV[\Z]K\QWV#VMQ\PMZLWM[Q\WJTQOMK]T\]ZM\WNWTTW_JQWT WOaJTQVLTa

4HEBIOLOGICALBLUEPRINTFORHUMANVALUESCANBEFOUNDINTHEMACHINERY OFHOMEOSTASIS 1VITTTQNMNWZU[\PMZMQ[IKWTTMK\QWVWN[a[\MU[\PI\XMZUQ\[WZOIVQ[U[\WUIQV \IQVJQWTWOQKITXZWKM[[M[_Q\PQV\PMZIVOMKWUXI\QJTM_Q\PTQNM1VKWUXTM`[XM KQM[\PMZMO]TI\QWVWNTQNMLMXMVL[WVIKTW[MQV\MZIK\QWVJM\_MMVJZIQV[a[\MU[ IVLJWLaXZWXMZ[a[\MU[IVLQ\Q[QVMNNMK\KWV\ZWTTMLJaI[XMKQâKKWTTMK\QWVWN _MTTKWWZLQVI\MLJZIQVZMOQWV[[MM,IUI[QW!!!IVLNWZIZM^QM_ 4QNMZMO]TI\QWVQ[IVa\PQVOJ]\IVM]\ZITXZWKM[[1\Q[\PZW]OPIVL\PZW]OPIV IK\Q^MKWUUQ\\ML[\Z]OOTQVOXZWKM[[\PI\[MMS[WX\QUITXIZIUM\MZ[NWZ\PMKWV \QV]I\QWVWNTQNM1\QV^WT^M[KPWQKM[IVLXZMNMZMVKM[IT\PW]OPI\\PMJI[QKTM^MT[ \PW[MKPWQKM[IVLXZMNMZMVKM[IZMI]\WUI\QKMZTIOXXw  ;QVOMZIT]M[ ˆ;XZQVOMZ>MZTIO*MZTQV0MQLMTJMZO

   2W[P]I/ZMMVM ZM[MIZKP []OOM[\[ I [aV\PM[Q[ WN \PM \_W ZM[MIZKP \ZILQ\QWV[ UMV\QWVML IJW^M 5WZM[XMKQâKITTaW]Z_WZS[]OOM[\[\PI\UWZITR]LOUMV\[IZMXZWL]KML\PZW]OP IKWUXTM`QV\MZXTIaJM\_MMVQV\]Q\Q^MMUW\QWVITXZWKM[[M[IVLKWV\ZWTTMLtKWOVQ \Q^MuXZWKM[[M[

%MOTIONALÈ%NGAGEMENTÈINÈ-ORALÈ*UDGMENT +WV[QLMZ\PMNWTTW_QVOUWZITLQTMUUISVW_VI[\PM\ZWTTMaLQTMUUI.WW\! #